Designation of Pathotypes of Plant Pathogens

For evaluation and communication of data on populations of plant pathogens a sensible code to name pathotypes can be extremely helpful. Starting from a coding system proposed by Habgood in 1970, a system, called “coded triplets” is developed which has the same advantages but is easier to understand and to use. This is especially useful as, in the meantime, pathotypes did become increasingly complex due to the increased number of genes conferring race specific resistance in the host. An important advantage of the coded triplets is that codes change only at one digit if, for example, a new differentia) is added or if the pathotype changes from avirulence to virulence or vice versa on a single differential. In this way evoluationary patterns and changes in the pathogen population can be visualized easily. The system is used to describe complex data on haplotypes of the barley mildew pathogen, but it is suited equally well for designation of pathotypes of other pathogens. Some basic principles of coded triplets are similar to octal notation, described by Gilmour in 1973, which has, however, not become widely known. Reasons for this are discussed. – There is a fourth system belonging to the same group of mathematical, condensing codes. As there is reason to believe that the evolution of condensing codes is drawing to an end, the systems are compared extensively, and the benefits of a generally accepted designation are outlined.     

Cloned DNA probes distinguish endemic and exotic Entomophaga grylli fungal pathotype infections in grasshopper life stages

Entomophaga grylli is a fungal pathogen of grasshoppers and at least three pathotypes are recognized world-wide. Pathotypes 1 and 2 are endemic to North America while the Australian pathotype 3 had been released into two field sites in North Dakota between 1989 and 1991. Grasshoppers were collected over the summer at the field sites in 1992 and assessed for pathotype infection by cloned DNA probe analysis. The three most predominant grasshopper species that were infected ( Melanoplus sanguinipes, M. bivittatus and Camnula pellucida ) were assessed for pathotype infection with respect to their life stages (nymphal instars and adult males and females). Pathotype 1 predominantly infected grasshoppers in the subfamilies Oedipodinae and Gomphocerinae and pathotype 2 predominantly infected grasshoppers in the subfamily Melanoplinae. Early-instar M. sanguinipes and M. bivittatus had higher pathotype 2 infection frequencies, while late-instar and adult C. pellucida had higher pathotype 1 infection frequencies. Cross-infection by the pathotypes did occur in up to 3% of the individuals, on a per species basis, and primarily in later instar and adult grasshoppers. Pathotype 3 infections occurred in later instar and adults of the three grasshopper species. Infection of grasshoppers by E. grylli pathotypes is discussed with reference to the fungal life cycles.     

Strains of Zucchini Yellow Mosaic Virus in Muskmelon (Cucumis melo L.)

According to the reaction of muskmelon line PI 414723, 22 natural isolates of Zucchini Yellow Mosaic Virus (ZYMV) were grouped into two pathotypes. When inoculated by isolates belonging to pathotype 0, most of the PI 414723 plants (over 70%) remained symptomless while few plants developed systemic chloronecrotic spotting and more rarely yellowing, stunting, mosaic and leaf deformations. When contaminated by pathotype 1 all PI 414723 plants developed systemic chloronecrotic spotting. Two variants were obtained from representative strains of these two pathotypes, able to induce yellowing, stunting, mosaic and leaf deformation on all inoculated PI 414723 plants. These variants could not be differentiated from their originating strains either by host range, serology or aphid transmission properties. Therefore they are regarded as belonging to a third group called pathotype 2. No relation was observed between the type of symptom developed on PI 414723 and the ability to induce a rapid wilting reaction of melon cv. Doublon (pathotype F).     

Observations on the relationship between morphological variation and host range in populations of cereal cyst-nematode

British pathotype 3 of cereal cyst-nematode differs morphologically from Heterodera avenae. Mature cysts have a distinct underbridge which is absent from pathotypes 1 and 2. A population of pathotype 3 produced cysts on cereal genotypes resistant to pathotypes 1 and 2. The relationship of this pathotype to other graminaceous cyst-nematodes is discussed.     

Pathotypes in the Entomophaga grylli species complex of grasshopper pathogens differentiated with random amplification of polymorphic DNA and cloned-DNA probes.

The zygomycetous fungus Entomophaga grylli is a pathogen that shows host-specific variance to grasshopper subfamilies. Three pathotypes of the E. grylli species complex were differentiated by three molecular techniques. In the first method, the three pathotypes showed different fragment patterns generated by random amplification of polymorphic DNA (RAPD). There was little or no interisolate variability in RAPD fragment patterns within each pathotype. Passage of an isolate of pathotype 3, originally from an Australian grasshopper (Praxibulus sp.), through a North America grasshopper resulted in no differences in the resultant RAPD fragment patterns. In the second method, polymorphic RAPD fragments were used to probe the genomic DNA from the three pathotypes, and pathotype-specific fragments were found. In the third method, restriction fragments from genomic DNA of the three pathotypes were cloned and screened for pathotype specificity. A genomic probe specific for each pathotype was isolated. These probes did not hybridize to DNA from Entomophaga aulicae or from grasshoppers. To facilitate the use of RAPD analysis and other molecular tools to identify pathotypes, a method for extracting DNA from resting spores from infected grasshoppers was developed. The DNA from the fractured resting spores was of sufficient integrity to be blotted and probed with the pathotype-specific DNA probes, thus validating the use of these probes for pathotype identification in field-collected grasshoppers.     

Molecular Assessment of Diversity among Pathotypes of Colletotrichum falcatum Prevalent in Sub-Tropical Indian Sugarcane

Summary Six pathotypes of Colletotrichum falcatum, responsible for Red-rot in sugarcane, prevalent in subtropical India were examined for genetic relationships using RAPD markers. A high degree of polymorphism (78.6%) was observed using 40 RAPD markers. More than 50% genetic divergence was found among the pathotypes and UPGMA cluster analysis of genetic similarity indices grouped the six pathotypes into two clusters. Cluster I comprised pathotypes Cf01 and Cf09, while cluster II comprised the remaining four pathotypes. Cf02 and Cf08 were the most closely related among all the pathotypes. Pathotype-specific unique bands generated in RAPD profiling are being used for developing markers for pathotype identification in diseased cane samples.     

On cyst colour changes, bionomics and distribution of potato cyst-eelworm (Heterodera rostochiensis Woll.) pathotypes in the East Midlands

Pot tests and field trials in 1966 confirmed earlier observations that pathotype A potato cyst-eelworm (Heterodera rostochiensis Woll.) showed marked colour differences from pathotypes B and C during development on the roots of susceptible potatoes. In hatching tests started in July, newly formed brown cysts of pathotype A released four times as many larvae as those of pathotypes B and C, without entering an immediate diapause; the latter produced larvae after a rest period of 18–21 days. Subsequent second-generation cyst production in glass-tube culture was greater from pathotype A. Field observations suggested that all pathotypes mature at about the same time and give rise to only one flush of cysts on both early and maincrop potatoes in the growing season. Cyst colour surveys in commercial crops, and pot and field trials using resistant potato selections, confirmed that pathotypes B and C are both dominant and widespread in the East Midlands.     

Gaps and perspectives of pathotype and race determination in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Golovinomyces cichoracearum</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Podosphaera xanthii</Emphasis>

Golovinomyces cichoracearum and Podosphaera xanthii (family Erysiphaceae) are the most important species causing cucurbit powdery mildew (CPM), a serious disease of field and greenhouse cucurbits. Both species are highly variable in their pathogenicity and virulence, as indicated by the existence of large number of different pathotypes and races. Various independent systems of CPM pathotype and race determinations and denominations are used worldwide. CPM pathotype identification is based on intergeneric and interspecific differences in host-CPM interactions. The most commonly used set of CPM pathotype differentials includes one genotype from four species representing three agriculturally important cucurbit genera plus two genotypes from a fifth species, melon Cucumis melo L. CPM races are characterized by specialization on different cultivars or lines of one host species and have, to date, been differentiated only on melon (C. melo L.). The most frequently used set of melon differentials includes 11 genotypes that can differentiate CPM races originating from melon and other cucurbits, e.g., cucumber, Cucurbita spp., and watermelon. In this paper, we critically review the current state, gaps, and perspectives in our understanding of pathogenicity variation in these two CPM pathogens at the pathotype and race levels.     

The broad-spectrum potato cyst nematode resistance gene (Hero) from tomato is the only member of a large gene family of NBS-LRR genes with an unusual amino acid repeat in the LRR region

The Hero gene of tomato is a broad spectrum resistance gene that confers a high level of resistance to all pathotypes of the potato cyst nematodes Globodera rostochiensis and partial resistance to G. pallida. The gene was identified by map-based cloning, sequencing and complementation analysis of two susceptible tomato lines with an array of 13 overlapping cosmids spanning a total distance of 135 kb. Hero encodes a protein with a nucleotide-binding site (NBS) and a leucine-rich-repeat (LRR) domain and is a member of a gene family of 14 highly homologous genes, which are clustered within a continuous 118-kb region. The isolated Hero gene displayed resistance to various G. rostochiensis pathotypes and partial resistance to G. pallida pathotype Pa2/3 in transgenic tomato lines. None of the Hero homologues conferred resistance to G. rostochiensis pathotypes. Hero can be distinguished from its homologues by the length of a compound hexanucleotide microsatellite, which codes for a charged and repetitive amino acid domain within the LRR. We propose that the expansion of this microsatellite may be involved in the evolution of the Hero resistance gene.     

Multiple alleles for resistance and susceptibility modulate the defense response in the interaction of tetraploid potato (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Solanum tuberosum</Emphasis>) with <Emphasis Type="Italic">Synchytrium endobioticum</Emphasis> pathotypes 1, 2, 6 and 18

The obligate biotrophic, soil-borne fungus Synchytrium endobioticum causes wart disease of potato (Solanum tuberosum), which is a serious problem for crop production in countries with moderate climates. S. endobioticum induces hypertrophic cell divisions in plant host tissues leading to the formation of tumor-like structures. Potato wart is a quarantine disease and chemical control is not possible. From 38 S. endobioticum pathotypes occurring in Europe, pathotypes 1, 2, 6 and 18 are the most relevant. Genetic resistance to wart is available but only few current potato varieties are resistant to all four pathotypes. The phenotypic evaluation of wart resistance is laborious, time-consuming and sometimes ambiguous, which makes breeding for resistance difficult. Molecular markers diagnostic for genes for resistance to S. endobioticum pathotypes 1, 2, 6 and 18 would greatly facilitate the selection of new, resistant cultivars. Two tetraploid half-sib families (266 individuals) segregating for resistance to S. endobioticum pathotypes 1, 2, 6 and 18 were produced by crossing a resistant genotype with two different susceptible ones. The families were scored for five different wart resistance phenotypes. The distribution of mean resistance scores was quantitative in both families. Resistance to pathotypes 2, 6 and 18 was correlated and independent from resistance to pathotype 1. DNA pools were constructed from the most resistant and most susceptible individuals and screened with genome wide simple sequence repeat (SSR), inverted simple sequence region (ISSR) and randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers. Bulked segregant analysis identified three SSR markers that were linked to wart resistance loci (Sen). Sen1-XI on chromosome XI conferred partial resistance to pathotype 1, Sen18-IX on chromosome IX to pathotype 18 and Sen2/6/18-I on chromosome I to pathotypes 2,6 and 18. Additional genotyping with 191 single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers confirmed the localization of the Sen loci. Thirty-three SNP markers linked to the Sen loci permitted the dissection of Sen alleles that increased or decreased resistance to wart. The alleles were inherited from both the resistant and susceptible parents.     

Genotyping with RAPD and microsatellite markers resolves pathotype diversity in the ascochyta blight pathogen of chickpea

 The poor definition of variation in the ascochyta blight fungus (Ascochyta rabiei) has historically hindered breeding for resistance to the chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) blight disease in West Asia and North Africa. We have employed 14 RAPD markers and an oligonucleotide probe complementary to the microsatellite sequence (GATA)₄ to construct a genotype-specific DNA fragment profile from periodically sampled Syrian field isolates of this fungus. By using conventional pathogenicity tests and genome analysis with RAPD and microsatellite markers, we demonstrated that the DNA markers distinguish variability within and among the major pathotypes of A. rabiei and resolved each pathotypes into several genotypes. The genetic diversity estimate based on DNA marker analysis within pathotypes was highest for the least-aggressive pathotype (pathotype I), followed by the aggressive (pathotype II) and the most-aggressive pathotype (pathotype III). The pair-wise genetic distance estimated for all the isolates varied from 0.00 to 0.39, indicating a range from a clonal to a diverse relationship. On the basis of genome analysis, and information on the spatial and temporal distribution of the pathogen, a general picture of A. rabiei evolution in Syria is proposed. Received: 10 January 1998 / Accepted: 23 January 1998     

Analysis of Pathotypic and Genotypic Diversity of Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae in China

Virulence analysis and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) were used to evaluated the population structure of Xanthomonas oryzae pv . oryzae ( Xoo ) from the main rice-growing region in China. The pathotype of Xoo was determined for 103 strains by inoculating 13 near-isogenic rice lines using IR24 as the recurrent parent. Sixty-one pathotypes was shared by these strains, on the basis of the consensus of three clustering statistics, and four clusters for pathotype were formed. Cluster 2 consists of strains with high molecular polymorphorism and many pathotypes that are either virulent to a majority of the 13 major resistance ( R ) genes or avirulent only to Xa21 , and is geographically dispersed. The resistance gene Xa21 has broader resistance than others to the strains tested. A probe from a member of the avrBs3/pthA type III effector family, 1376 bp Sph I-digested fragment, was used to screen the genomes of 52 strains tested. Four common bands were found in the DNA fingerprint pattern of Xoo , suggesting basic patterns of evolutionary relationship for members of avrBs3/pthA family and/or the pathogen. Each distinct RFLP banding pattern of each strain was considered as a haplotype; 42 haplotypes were revealed by the probe and divided into four lineages by the same statistics method. It was observed that some isolates with different pathotypes shared the same haplotype and others with different haplotypes harboured identical pathotype. There was a weak correlation between virulent pathotypes and molecular haplotypes.     

Ⅰ型马立克氏病病毒不同致病型参考株与中国分离株pp24基因的克隆与序列分析

为了比较Ⅰ型马立克氏病病毒(MDV)的致病型与pp24基因的关系,将Ⅰ型MDV弱毒(mMDV)、强毒(vMDV)、超强毒(vvMDV)、特超强毒(vv MDV)等不同致病型的CVI988、GA、648A、RB1B、Md5和Md11等6个国际参考株,从中国河北、北京、广东和广西等地分离的7个中国分离株和1个中国疫苗毒814株的pp24基因分别做PCR扩增,并将其克隆到pMD-18载体中测序,与国外已发表的BC-1株进行序列比较.结果表明:Ⅰ型MDV的pp24基因非常保守,15个毒株中只出现5个碱基的随机变化,并引起相应的4个氨基酸改变,但与致病型无明显相关;pp24基因ORF的第81碱基出现差异,所有中国株为G,所有不同致病型国外参考株为C,但并未引起氨基酸改变,显示这一碱基差异只是作为MDV地域性分布的遗传标志,而与病毒分离的年代及致病型等因素无关.     

DNA Fingerprinting with a Dispersed Repeated Sequence Resolves Pathotype Diversity in the Rice Blast Fungus

The poor definition of pathotype variation in the rice blast fungus has historically handicapped strategies for reducing blast disease damage to the world's rice crop. We have employed a probe for a dispersed repeated DNA sequence called MGR [Hamer et al. (1989). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86, 9981-9985] to construct genotype-specific, EcoRl restriction fragment length profiles (MGR-DNA fingerprints) from United States field isolates of this fungus. By using a blind-test design, we demonstrated that MGR-DNA fingerprints distinguished the major pathotypes in the United States, accurately identified the pathotypes of isolates collected over a 30-year period, and defined the organization of clonal lineages within and among pathotype groups. These results resolved a lingering controversy regarding rice blast pathotype stability and illustrated new opportunities for tracking the population dynamics and evolution of this important crop pathogen.     

Evaluation of MALDI-TOF mass spectroscopy methods for determination of Escherichia coli pathotypes

It is rapidly becoming apparent that many E. coli pathotypes cause a considerable burden of human disease. Surveillance of these organisms is difficult because there are few or no simple, rapid methods for detecting and differentiating the different pathotypes. MALDI-TOF mass spectroscopy has recently been rapidly and enthusiastically adopted by many clinical laboratories as a diagnostic method because of its high throughput, relatively low cost, and adaptability to the laboratory workflow. To determine whether the method could be adapted for E. coli pathotype differentiation the Bruker Biotyper methodology and a second methodology adapted from the scientific literature were tested on isolates representing eight distinct pathotypes and two other groups of E. coli. A total of 136 isolates was used for this study. Results confirmed that the Bruker Biotyper methodology that included extraction of proteins from bacterial cells was capable of identifying E. coli isolates from all pathotypes to the species level and, furthermore, that the Bruker extraction and MALDI-TOF MS with the evaluation criteria developed in this work was effective for differentiating most pathotypes.     

Size and complexity of the nuclear genome of Colletotrichum graminicola.

DNA reassociation was used to estimate GC content, size, and complexity of the nuclear genomes of Colletotrichum from maize and sorghum. Melting-temperature analysis indicated that the GC content of the maize pathotype DNA was 51% and that the GC content of the sorghum pathotype was 52%. DNA reassociation kinetics employing S1 nuclease digestion and an appropriately modified second-order equation indicated that the genome sizes of the maize and sorghum pathotypes were 4.8 x 10(7) bp, and 5.0 x 10(7) bp, respectively. Genomic reconstruction experiments based on Southern blot hybridization between a cloned single-copy gene, PYR1 (orotate phosphoribosyl transferase), and maize-pathotype DNA confirmed the size of the nuclear genome. The single-copy component of the genomes of both pathotypes was estimated at about 90%. For both pathotypes, ca. 7% of the genome represented repetitive DNA, and 2 to 3% was foldback DNA.     

Resistance of roses to pathotypes of Diplocarpon rosae

Colonies of Diplocarpon rosae derived from single conidia were isolated on malt extract agar, multiplied (at 23°C) and stored (at ?20°C) on surface‐sterilised leaf discs of a universally susceptible rose, ‘Frensham’. The resistance of 16 species and cultivars of Rosa to different isolates of D. rosae was assessed using surface‐sterilised leaf discs. Four pathotypes of D. rosae were distinguished on the basis of host range. One species and one hybrid were resistant to all pathotypes. Two species and two cultivars were susceptible to all pathotypes. Four species and six cultivars were interpreted as having vertical resistance because they were strongly resistant to some but not all pathotypes. Only species and hybrids of the section Cinnamomeae were resistant to the pathotype identified as CW1 whereas only roses of other origins were resistant to the pathotype DA2.     

Rapid identification of genetic variation and pathotype of Leptosphaeria maculans by random amplified polymorphic DNA assay.

Canadian isolates of Leptosphaeria maculans, the causal agent of blackleg of crucifers, were examined for genetic relatedness by the random amplified polymorphic DNA assay. DNA polymorphisms amplified with random decamer primers were used to distinguish three groups of isolates. Group 1 contained all isolates of the virulent pathotype, group 2 contained isolates of the avirulent pathotype from western Canada, and group 3 contained avirulent pathotype isolates from Ontario. These results agreed with other reports which showed many genetic differences between pathotypes and were consistent with the hypothesis that the virulent pathotype was recently introduced into Canada and has diverged relatively little. In contrast, the avirulent pathotype has probably been present in Canada for a longer time and has diverged with geographic isolation. In addition to establishing genetic relationships, DNA fingerprints generated by the random amplified polymorphic DNA assay have potential applications in pathotype identification and blackleg disease management.     

Rapid identification of genetic variation and pathotype of Leptosphaeria maculans by random amplified polymorphic DNA assay.

Canadian isolates of Leptosphaeria maculans, the causal agent of blackleg of crucifers, were examined for genetic relatedness by the random amplified polymorphic DNA assay. DNA polymorphisms amplified with random decamer primers were used to distinguish three groups of isolates. Group 1 contained all isolates of the virulent pathotype, group 2 contained isolates of the avirulent pathotype from western Canada, and group 3 contained avirulent pathotype isolates from Ontario. These results agreed with other reports which showed many genetic differences between pathotypes and were consistent with the hypothesis that the virulent pathotype was recently introduced into Canada and has diverged relatively little. In contrast, the avirulent pathotype has probably been present in Canada for a longer time and has diverged with geographic isolation. In addition to establishing genetic relationships, DNA fingerprints generated by the random amplified polymorphic DNA assay have potential applications in pathotype identification and blackleg disease management.