Incorporation of eel electroplax acetylcholinesterase into black lipid membranes. A possible model for the cholinergic receptor

Addition of low concentrations of acetylcholine or carbamylcholine to solutions bathing a black lipid membrane into which electroplax acetylcholinesterase has been incorporated elicits a dramatic increase in the membrane conductance. This change is prevented or reversed by addition of neostigmine or atropine to the system. The magnitude of the conductance increase of the acetylcholinesterase-treated membrane is proportional to the fourth power of the carbamylcholine concentration and, at constant carbamylcholine concentration, to the fourth power of the enzyme concentration in the medium.     

Ion-gated channel induced in planar bilayers by incorporation of (Na+,K+)-ATPase

An ion-gated channel was conferred on a planar lipid bilayer membrane upon incorporation of (Na+,K+)-ATPase. The channel exhibited two conductance states. The high conductance state was only observed when an ion gradient was present across the planar membrane. This state corresponded to an enzyme conformation which was ouabain and vanadate sensitive (i.e. conductance was inhibited by these compounds), while the low conductance state showed no sensitivity to either inhibitor. Single channel conductance behavior was observed when minimal amounts of enzyme were incorporated into the planar bilayer. The observed single channel conductance was 270 +/- 14 picosiemens. Similar transport behavior was observed for enzyme purified from ovine kidney using sodium dodecyl sulfate (anionic), eel electroplax using Lubrol-WX (nonionic), and kidney microsomes. In addition, the data strongly suggest that enzyme from the kidney microsomes was asymmetrically incorporated into the planar bilayer.     

On Some Structural Analogies between Acetylcholinesterase and the Macromolecular Receptor of Acetylcholine

Several properties of the enzyme acetylcholinesterase (AChE) isolated in vitro are compared with those of the membrane receptor(s) of acetylcholine expressed by the in vivo electrical response of the electroplax membrane. AChE strongly binds in vitro effectors of the electroplax: agonists e.g., decamethonium or antagonists, e.g., d-tubocurarine and flaxedil. It also reacts covalently with an affinity labeling reagent of the acetylcholine receptor site(s) in vivo (TDF). Two classes of sites on AChE molecule account for the binding of these quaternary nitrogen containing compounds: (1) the anionic site of the active center and (2) noncatalytic "peripheral anionic centers" located outside the active center. A disulfide bond breaking agent, dithiothreitol (DTT) alters in a parallel manner the reaction of AChE and the excitable membrane of the electroplax to TDF. The irreversibility of TDF action is lost in both cases, after exposure to DTT. Both AChE and the acetylcholine receptor thus contain disulfide bonds—they are closely related but not necessarily identical proteins.     

The Nature of the Negative Resistance in Bimolecular Lipid Membranes Containing Excitability-Inducing Material

When sufficiently small amounts of excitability-inducing material (EIM) are added to a bimolecular lipid membrane, the conductance is limited to a few discrete levels and changes abruptly from one level to another. From our study of these fluctuations, we have concluded that the EIM-doped bilayer contains ion-conducting channels capable of undergoing transitions between two states of different conductance. The difference in current between the "open" and "closed" states is directly proportional to the applied membrane potential, and corresponds to a conductance of about 3 x 10^-10 ohm^-1. The fraction of the total number of channels that is open varies from unity to zero as a function of potential. The voltage-dependent opening and closing of channels explains the negative resistance observed for bimolecular lipid membranes treated with greater amounts of EIM.     

Modification of electroplax excitability by veratridine

Veratridine influences membrane-potential changes arising both from the action potential and from the application of external cholinergic agonists in the isolated monocellular electroplax preparation. The action potential shows a long depolarizing after-potential in the presence of veratridine. The effects of various pharmacological agents and of external ion changes on this after-potential are similar to those reported for other nerve and muscle fibers and are consistent with the view that veratridine acts chiefly to increase the Na⁺ conductance.Membrane depolarizations by cholinergic agonists are inhibited by veratridine at pH 7 but strikingly amplified at pH 9. The former effect appears to involve interaction with the cholinergic receptor at the surface of the membrane, while the latter potentiation parallels the increase in the spike after-potential at pH 9 and presumably arises from a Na⁺ conductance increase.Veratridine appears to interact with the component involved in the Na⁺ conductance in the interior membrane phase. The possible localization of this component in both the conducting and synaptic membrane is discussed.     

Isologous Oxygen,Sulfur, and Selenium Compounds as Probes of Acetylcholine Receptors

Evidence is presented that while the conformations of acetylcholine and acetylthiolcholine are different, acetylthiolcholine and acetylselenolcholine are structurally and conformationally very similar. Experiments with sulfur and selenium isologs of acetylcholine, choline, and local anesthetics suggest that the active sites of receptors of the electroplax and of electric eel acetylcholinesterase are different, but are compatible with the postulate that acetylcholine receptors of axonal and synaptic excitable membranes are similar.     

Characterization of the channel properties of a neuronal acetylcholine receptor reconstituted into planar lipid bilayers

An alpha-toxin-binding membrane protein, isolated from the head and thoracic ganglia of the locus (Locusta migratoria), was reconstituted into planar lipid bilayers. Cholinergic agonists such as acetylcholine, carbamylcholine, and suberyldicholine induced fluctuations of single channels, which suggests that the protein represents a functional cholinergic receptor channel. The antagonist d-tubocurarine blocked the activation of the channels, whereas hexamethonium had only a weak effect; similar properties have been described for nicotinic insect receptors in situ. The channel was selectively permeable to monovalent cations but was impermeable to anions. The conductance of the channel (75 pS in 100 mM NaCl) was independent of the type of agonist used to activate the receptor. Kinetic analysis of the channel gating revealed that, at high agonist concentrations (50 microM carbamylcholine), more than one closed state exists and that multiple gating events, bursting as well as fast flickering, appeared. At very high agonist concentrations (500 microM carbamylcholine), desensitization was observed. Channel kinetics were dependent on the transmembrane potential. Comparing the conductance, the kinetics, and the pharmacology of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor from insect ganglia and fish electroplax reconstituted into bilayers revealed obvious similarities but also significant differences.     

Spontaneous opening at zero membrane potential of sodium channels from eel electroplax reconstituted into lipid vesicles

Summary The voltage-dependent sodium channel from the eel electroplax was purified and reconstituted into vesicles of varying lipid composition. Isotopic sodium uptake experiments were conducted with vesicles at zero membrane potential, using veratridine to activate channels and tetrodotoxin to block them. Under these conditions, channel-dependent uptake of isotopic sodium by the vesicles was observed, demonstrating that a certain fraction of the reconstituted protein was capable of mediating ion fluxes. In addition, vesicles untreated with veratridine showed significant background uptake of sodium; a considerable proportion of this flux was blocked by tetrodotoxin. Thus these measurements showed that a significant subpopulation of channels was present that could mediate ionic fluxes in the absence of activating toxins. The proportion of channels exhibiting this behavior was dependent on the lipid composition of the vesicles and the temperature at which the uptake was measured; furthermore, the effect of temperature was reversible. However, the phenomenon was not affected by the degree of purification of the protein used for reconstitution, and channels in resealed electroplax membrane fragments or reconstituted, solely into native eel lipids did not show this behavior. The kinetics of vesicular uptake through these spontaneously-opening channels was slow, and we attribute this behavior to a modification of sodium channel inactivation.     

Blocking of the beta-latrotoxin channels in bimolecular lipid membranes by antibodies

Asymmetric ion channels are formed in a bimolecular lipid membrane by beta-latrotoxin (LT) introduced to one (cis) side of the membrane. LT-specific antibodies added to the opposite (trans) side of the membrane block the current through the LT channels when a negative potential is applied to the cis side, no blockade is observed at positive potentials. LT-specific antibodies do not block the channel current when added to the cis compartment after removal of LT. LT-unspecific immunoglobulins have no influence on LT channel conductance.     

A differential scanning calorimetry study of acetylcholine receptor-rich membranes from Torpedo californica

Various acetylcholine receptor-rich membrane preparations from Torpedo californica electroplax tissue were examined using the techniques of differential scanning calorimetry coupled with gel electrophoretic analysis of heat-denaturing material and functional assays following passage through discrete transitions. In unfractionated membranes, four irreversible calorimetric transitions were observed, one of which (Td = 59 degrees C) could be assigned to a complete loss of acetylcholine receptor function. A second lower temperature transition apparently corresponds to loss of certain peripheral membrane proteins including the Mr = 43,000 polypeptide and the acetylcholinesterase activity. Membrane preparations highly enriched in acetylcholine receptor polypeptides contained a major transition at 59 degrees C which could be shown to be sensitive to the presence of added ligands of the acetylcholine receptor, supporting its assignment to structural alterations of the receptor protein or its arrangement in the membrane.     

A comparison of eel electroplax and snake venom acetylcholinesterase

The effects of some cholinergic ligands, harmala alkaloids and local anesthetics on the activity of eel electroplax and Naja naja siamensis venom acetylcholinesterase have been studied. In most cases, eel electroplax was found to be more susceptible towards inhibition than the venom acetylcholinesterase. No major difference was observed with respect to the type of inhibition in both enzymes. The activation of the two enzyme preparations by inorganic cations (Ca2+, Mg2+ and Na+) showed a similar pattern. In both preparations, the onset of activation was detectable at much lower concentration with the divalent metal ions than with the monovalent Na+. Antagonism between Ca2+ and decamethonium, tubocurarine and tetracaine in both enzymes approached competitive kinetics. The onset of substrate inhibition is delayed by Ca2+ (30 mM) in both enzymes. It is suggested that the Ca2+ binding site overlaps with the substrate inhibitory site. It is concluded that cobra venom acetylcholinesterase has similar allosteric binding sites to those of eel electroplax.     

Single-channel current recordings of acetylcholine receptors in electroplax isolated from theElectrophorus electricus main and Sachs' electric organs

Summary Extensive chemical kinetic measurements of acetylcholine receptor-controlled ion translocation in membrane vesicles isolated from the electroplax ofElectrophorus electricus have led to the proposal of a minimum model which accounts for the activation, desensitization, and voltage-dependent inhibition of the receptor by acetylcholine, suberyldicholine, and carbamoylcholine. Comparison of chemical kinetic measurements of the dynamic properties of the acetylcholine receptor in vesicles with the properties of the receptor in cells obtained from the same organ and animal have been hampered by an inability to make the appropriate measurements withElectrophorus electricus electroplax cells. Here we report a method for exposing and cleaning the surface of electroplax cells obtained from both the Main electric organ and the organ of Sachs and the results of single-channel current recordings which have now become possible. The single-channel current recordings were made in the presence of either carbamoylcholine or suberyldicholine, as a function of temperature and transmembrane voltage. Both the channel open times and the single-channel conductance were measured. The data were found to be consistent with the model based on chemical kinetic measurements using receptor-rich membrane vesicles prepared from the Main electric organ ofE. electricus.     

Reactivity to acetylcholine developed by artificial membranes containing a protein from Electrophorus electricus: the effect of uranyl ions

A special hydrophobic protein fraction from the electroplax of $\text{Electrophorus}\text{electricus}$, when incorporated into artifical lipid membranes, induces a reactivity to acetylcholine. Uranyl ions increase 10–20 times the conductivity of such membranes, produce discrete current jumps, and strongly potentiate the effect of acetylcholine. The response to acetylcholine was studied in media containing KCl,NaCl, Choline-Cl and Na-Propionate in the presence or absence of uranyl ions. control membranes made of lipids or containing a non-cholinergic protein from the same tissue showed no reactivity to acetylcholine and had only a slight increase in conductance at very high concentrations of uranyl ions.     

Fusion of native or reconstituted membranes to liposomes, optimized for single channel recording.

We here describe a protocol for fusing vesicles into large structures suitable for patch clamp recording. The method may be used with native membrane vesicles or with liposomes containing reconstituted/purified ion channels. The resulting unilamellar membranes exhibit high channel surface abundance, yielding multiple channels in the average excised patch. The procedure has been used to record voltage-sensitive Na channels from three native membrane preparations (eel electroplax, rat skeletal muscle, squid optic nerve), and from reconstituted protein purified from eel electroplax. Channels treated with batrachotoxin (BTX) displayed characteristic activation voltage dependence, conductances, selectivity, and sensitivity to saxitoxin (STX).     

Acetylcholine receptor-mediated membrane current in oocytes injected with Electrophorus electricus mRNA: analyses of nicotine, succinylcholine, and decamethonium responses on the basis of the minimal model

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor was synthesized in Xenopus oocytes after injection of the mRNA purified from Electrophorus electricus electroplax. Nicotine, succinylcholine, and decamethonium (agonist)-elicited membrane currents in the injected oocytes were measured electrophysiologically by the voltage-clamping method. The following four different measurements were made to establish the relationship between the agonist concentration and the membrane current: 1) the agonist-induced membrane current before desensitization, 2) the agonist-induced membrane current after desensitization equilibrium, 3) the fraction of the active form of the receptors after desensitization equilibrium, 4) the rate of recovery of desensitized receptors upon removal of the agonist. These results were analyzed on the basis of the minimal model proposed from receptor-mediated ion translocation measurements. The equilibrium and rate constants of the model were evaluated for nicotine, succinylcholine, and decamethonium, and could explain the observed electrical responses in the injected oocyte, i.e. the characteristics of the receptor response caused by these agonists.     

Neurotoxin-modulated uptake of sodium by highly purified preparations of the electroplax tetrodotoxin-binding glycopeptide reconstituted into lipid vesicles

Summary Using the dialysable detergent CHAPS (3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)-dimethylammonio]-1-propane sulfonate), the tetrodotoxin-binding protein from the electroplax of the electric eel has been purified to a high degree of both chemical homogeneity and toxin-binding activity. On sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, the best preparations showed only a single microheterogeneous band atM _r approximately 260,000, despite attempts to visualize smaller bands by sample overloading. Upon dialysis, this material became incorporated into the membranes of small unilamellar vesicles, and in this form the purified protein exhibited tetrodotoxin-binding properties similar to the component in the original electroplax membrane. Furthermore, in the presence of activator neurotoxins the vesicles were able to accumulate isotopic sodium in a manner similar to that previously described for less active or less pure preparations of vesicles containing either mammalian or eel electroplax toxinbinding proteins. Quantitative consideration of the isotopic transport activity of this pure material, along with the high degree of purity of the protein, strongly suggests that the 260-kDa glycopeptide from electroplax is necessary and sufficient to account for the sodium channel function seen in these studies, and eliminates the possible involvement of smaller peptides in the channel phenomena observed.     

Monoclonal Antibody Tor 23 Recognizes a Determinant of a Presynaptic Acetylcholinesterase

A significant proportion of the acetylcholinesterase that is present in the electric organ of Torpedo californica exists as a presynaptic membrane molecule. The monoclonal antibody Tor 23 binds the Torpedo presynaptic nerve membrane where it recognizes a polypeptide of 68,000 daltons. Our present studies indicate that Tor 23 identifies acetylcholinesterase. From the homogenates of Torpedo nerve terminals, Tor 23 immunoprecipitates measurable esterase activity. Esterase precipitation was not observed with no Tor 23 added; nor was it observed with any other test antibodies, including other Tor antibodies, in particular, Tor 70, which binds, as does Tor 23, to the presynaptic nerve membrane. The esterase activity was specific for acetylcholinesterase. Our studies indicate the molecule defined by Tor 23 has the solubility properties described for that of presynaptic acetylcholinesterase: it is soluble in detergent-treated electroplax homogenates and insoluble in high-salt extractions. In sections of Torpedo back muscle, both nerve and endplate acetylcholinesterase can be detected histochemically. Tor 23 localizes to the nerve and is not clustered at the endplate. The utility of the antibody Tor 23 thus includes biochemical and histological analyses of the multiple forms of acetylcholinesterase.     

Veratridine modification of the purified sodium channel alpha- polypeptide from eel electroplax

In the interest of continuing structure-function studies, highly purified sodium channel preparations from the eel electroplax were incorporated into planar lipid bilayers in the presence of veratridine. This lipoglycoprotein originates from muscle-derived tissue and consists of a single polypeptide. In this study it is shown to have properties analogous to sodium channels from another muscle tissue (Garber, S. S., and C. Miller. 1987. Journal of General Physiology. 89:459-480), which have an additional protein subunit. However, significant qualitative and quantitative differences were noted. Comparison of veratridine-modified with batrachotoxin-modified eel sodium channels revealed common properties. Tetrodotoxin blocked the channels in a voltage-dependent manner indistinguishable from that found for batrachotoxin-modified channels. Veratridine-modified channels exhibited a range of single-channel conductance and subconductance states. The selectivity of the veratridine-modified sodium channels for sodium vs. potassium ranged from 6-8 in reversal potential measurements, while conductance ratios ranged from 12-15. This is similar to BTX-modified eel channels, though the latter show a predominant single-channel conductance twice as large. In contrast to batrachotoxin-modified channels, the fractional open times of these channels had a shallow voltage dependence which, however, was similar to that of the slow interaction between veratridine and sodium channels in voltage-clamped biological membranes. Implications for sodium channel structure are discussed.     

Fluorinated aldehydes and ketones acting as quasi-substrate inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase.

1. The inhibition of acetylcholinesterase (acetylcholine hydrolase, EC 3.1.1.7) by compounds containing trifluoromethyl-carbonyl groups was investigated and related to the effects observed with structurally similar, non-fluorinated chemicals. 2. Compounds that in aqueous solution readily form hydrates inhibit acetylcholinesterase in a time-dependent process. On the other hand non-hydrated, carbonyl-containing compounds showed rapid and reversible, time-independent enzyme inactivation when assayed under steady state conditions. 3. m-N,N,N-Trimethylammonium-acetophenone acts as a rapid and reversible, time-independent, linear competitive inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase (Ki = 5.0 . 10(-7) M). 4. The most potent enzyme inhibitor tested in this series was N,N,N,-trimethylammonium-m-trifluoroacetophenone. It gives time-dependent inhibition and the concentration which inactivates eel acetylcholinesterase to 50% of the original activity after 30 min exposure is 1.3 . 10(-8) M. The bimolecular rate constant for this reaction is 1.8 . 10(6) 1 . mol-1 . min-1. The enzyme-inhibitor complex is very stable as the inhibited enzyme after 8 days of dialysis is reactivated to 20% only. This compound represents a quasi-substrate inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase.     

Characterization of acetylcholine receptor-rich and acetylcholinesterase-rich membrane particles from Torpedo californica electroplax

Large-scale purification of acetylcholinesterase-rich and acetylcholine receptor-rich membrane fragments from Torpedo californica electroplax is described. Electron microscopy studies reveal structural differences in the two types of particles and the results are discussed in terms of structural aspects of the postsynaptic cleft. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of receptor-rich fragments reveals that the fragments contain the same polypeptide components observed in receptor preparations purified from the same electroplax membranes, indicating that purified Torpedo receptor is not composed of species degraded by proteolysis. Results obtained from fluorescence studies of a cholinergic analog allow conclusions to be reached regarding species differences in electroplax acetylcholine receptor preparations.