Evaluation of no-wash calcium assay kits: enabling tools for calcium mobilization

The no-wash calcium assay kits developed by Molecular Devices Corporation have greatly enhanced the throughput of cell-based calcium mobilization high-throughput screening (HTS) assays and enabled screening using nonadherent cells. The fluorescent imaging plate reader (FLIPR) Calcium 3 Assay Kit, optimal for targets that have proteins or peptides as agonists, has 2 potential drawbacks: 1) a significant downward spike in fluorescence signal upon liquid transfer that can be the same magnitude as the agonist response, making data analysis difficult; and 2) medium removal is required for some targets, which essentially reintroduces a wash step. Several no-wash products were introduced in 2005. The authors compare the Fluo-4 NW Calcium Assay Kit and the BD Calcium Assay Kit with the FLIPR Calcium 3 Assay Kit using human native rhabdomyosarcoma cells expressing the urotensin-II receptor (UT). The BDtrade mark Calcium Assay Kit gives the best performance in the true no-wash mode, in which both agonist and antagonist activity are easily quantified. Although these new products provide additional options for measuring calcium mobilization, the different results observed with each kit, using the UT receptor as an example, suggest that one should characterize all dyes against each target in a systematic way prior to choosing one for HTS.     

A simple, no-wash cell adhesion-based high-throughput assay for the discovery of small-molecule regulators of the integrin CD11b/CD18

The leukocyte-specific integrin CD11b/CD18 plays a key role in the biological function of these cells and represents a validated therapeutic target for inflammatory diseases. Currently, the low affinity interaction between CD11b/CD18 integrin and its respective ligand poses a challenge in the development of cell-based adhesion assays for the high-throughput screening (HTS) environment. Here the authors describe a simple cell-based adhesion assay that can be readily used for HTS for the discovery of functional regulators of CD11b/CD18. The assay consistently produces acceptable Z' values (> 0.5) for HTS. After testing the assay using 2 established blocking antibodies as reference biologicals, the authors performed a proof-of-concept primary screen using a library of 6612 compounds and identified both agonist and antagonist hits.     

Evaluation of division-arrested cells for cell-based high-throughput screening and profiling

Just-in-time cell supply for cell-based high-throughput screening (HTS) is frequently problematic. In addition to scheduling and logistical issues, quality issues and variability due to passage effect, cell cycle, or confluency contribute to day-to-day signal variability in the course of cell-based HTS campaigns. Cell division-arrest and cryopreservation technologies permit the use of cells as assay-ready reagents for HTS and other cell-based profiling and structure-activity studies. In this report, the authors compare division-arrested and dividing cells in 2 assay types that are dependent on movement of proteins within or through cell membranes: a receptor tyrosine kinase assay involving A431 cells responsive to epidermal growth factor, and a secretion reporter assay, which measures secretion of a reporter gene, secreted alkaline phosphatase. In both assays, dividing and division-arrested cells yielded similar basal and maximal signals at a given cell density. Similar IC50s were obtained for reference inhibitors in each assay, type in both dividing and division-arrested cells. In addition, for the secretion reporter assay, when comparing IC50s obtained from 44 compounds randomly chosen from a primary screening hit list, the rank order of potency obtained from dividing cells and division-arrested cells was essentially identical. Furthermore, the results show that, under certain assay conditions, data generated using division-arrested cells are less variable than those generated using dividing cells. In summary, the results suggest that, in many cases, division-arrested cells can substitute for dividing cells and offer certain advantages for cell-based assays.     

Identification of small molecule antagonists of the human mas-related gene-X1 receptor

The recently identified mas-related-gene (MRG) family of receptors, located primarily in sensory neurons of the dorsal root ganglion, has been implicated in the perception of pain. Thus, antagonists of this class of receptors have been postulated to be useful analgesics. Toward this end, we developed a cell-based beta-lactamase (BLA) reporter gene assay to identify small molecule antagonists of the human MRG-X1 receptor from a library of compounds. Single-cell clones expressing functional receptors were selected using the BLA reporter gene technology. The EC50 for the MRG agonist peptide, BAM15, appeared to be comparable between the BLA assay and the intracellular Ca2+ transient assays in these cells. Ultra high-throughput screening of approximately 1 million compounds in a 1.8-microl cell-based BLA reporter gene assay was conducted in a 3456-well plate format. Compounds exhibiting potential antagonist profile in the BLA assay were confirmed in the second messenger Ca2+ transient assay. A cell-based receptor trafficking assay was used to further validate the mechanism of action of these compounds. Several classes of compounds, particularly the 2,3-disubstituted azabicyclo-octanes, appear to be relatively potent antagonists at the human MRG-X1 receptors, as confirmed by the receptor trafficking assay and radioligand binding studies. Furthermore, the structure-activity relationship reveals that within this class of compounds, the diphenylmethyl moiety is constant at the 2-substituent, whereas the 3-substituent is directly correlated with the antagonist activity of the compound.     

Oncology drug discovery applications using the FMAT 8100 HTS system

High-throughput screening (HTS) for potential anticancer agents requires a broad portfolio of assay platforms that may include kinase enzyme assays, protein-protein binding assays, and functional cell-based apoptosis assays. The authors have explored the use of fluorometric microvolume assay technology (the FMAT 8100 HTS System) in three distinct homogeneous HTS assays: (1). a Src tyrosine kinase enzyme assay, (2). a Grb2-SH2 protein-peptide interaction assay, and (3). an annexin V binding apoptosis assay. Data obtained from all three assays suggest that the FMAT system should facilitate the implementation of homogeneous assays for a wide variety of molecular targeted and cell-based screens.     

A homogeneous high throughput nonradioactive method for measurement of functional activity of Gs-coupled receptors in membranes

A method is described for measuring the activity of G(s)-coupled receptors in a nonradioactive homogeneous membrane-based assay. This method has several major advantages over currently used methods for measuring functional activity of G(s)-coupled receptors. The assay is high throughput (>150,000 data points/day using a single reader). Dimethyl sulfoxide tolerance is high ( approximately 10%). Compared to complex cell-based assays, there is limited potential for nonspecific compound action. This resulted in low compound hit rates in robustness screening, where hit rates from a simulated screen were 1.0% (antagonist screen) and 0.1% (agonist screen). No continuous cell culture is required for the assay, reducing cell culture overheads and allowing the screen to run every day. Automation is simple and requires no temperature- or humidity-controlled incubation. No radioactivity is required. The method relies on measurement of cyclic AMP (cAMP) generation by fluorescence polarization assay using commercially available reagents. Membranes (1-2 microg protein per well, containing anti-cAMP antibody) are transferred to 384-well plates containing 1 microl test compound. For antagonist screens, agonist is added 15 min later. After 30 min incubation at room temperature, one further assay reagent (fluorescein-cAMP in a buffer containing detergent) is added. The signal may be read after 1 h and is stable for greater than 12 h. Typical Z' for the assay is approximately 0.5.     

Miniaturization of intracellular calcium functional assays to 1536-well plate format using a fluorometric imaging plate reader

The measurement of intracellular calcium response transients in living mammalian cells is a popular functional assay for identification of agonists and antagonists to receptors or channels of pharmacological interest. In recent years, advances in fluorescence-based detection techniques and automation technologies have facilitated the adaptation of this assay to 384-well microplate format high-throughput screening (HTS) assays. However, the cost and time required performing the intracellular calcium HTS assays in the 384-well format can be prohibitive for HTS campaigns of greater than 1 x 10(6) wells. For these reasons, it is attractive to miniaturize intracellular calcium functional assays to the 1536-well microplate format, where assay volumes and plate throughput can be decreased by several fold. The focus of the research described in this article is the miniaturization of an intracellular calcium assay to 1536-well plate format. This was accomplished by modifying the hardware and software of a fluorometric imaging plate reader (FLIPR) to enable transfer of nanoliters of test compound directly to a 1536-well assay plate, and measure the resulting calcium response from all 1536 wells simultaneously. An intracellular calcium functional assay against the rat muscarinic acetylcholine receptor subtype 1 (rmAchR1) G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR) was miniaturized and executed on this modified instrument. In experiments measuring the activity of known muscarinic receptor agonists and antagonists, the miniaturized FLIPR assay gave EC(50) and IC(50) values and rank order potency comparable to the 384-well format assays. Calculated Z' factors for the miniaturized agonist and antagonist assays were, respectively, 0.56 +/- 0.21 and 0.53 +/- 0.22, which were slightly higher (Z'(agonist) = 0.55 +/- 0.33) and lower (Z'(antagonist) = 0.70 +/- 0.18) than the corresponding values in the 384-well assays. A mock agonist HTS campaign against the muscarinic receptor in miniaturized format was able to identify all wells spiked with the rmAchR1 agonist carbachol.     

Comparison of high throughput screening technologies for luminescence cell-based reporter screens

As higher density formats become more and more common in HTS labs, the expectations for maintaining faster, lower cost screens puts great pressure on traditional 96-well screens. In some cases higher density formats are not compatible with the assay. This seems especially true in cell-based assays. In our case, the nature of the cells' response forced us to remain in 96-well plates. In this paper, we describe the development of a luminescence reporter assay and its performance in two detection modes, flash and glow. The advantages in cost and throughput for each technique are explored, along with automation considerations. An additional new technology, the use of pins for low-volume transfers, is also briefly described because of its dramatic effect on our screen's throughput. However, it will be more thoroughly presented in a future publication. Comparing the technologies available for HTS aids in designing automated systems that meet the unique needs of each assay.     

An improved beta-lactamase reporter assay: multiplexing with a cytotoxicity readout for enhanced accuracy of hit identification

A problem inherent to the use of cellular assays for drug discovery is their sensitivity to cytotoxic compounds, which can result in false hits from certain compound screens. To alleviate the need to follow-up hits from a reporter assay with a separate cytotoxicity assay, the authors have developed a multiplexed assay that combines the readout of a beta-lactamase reporter with that of a homogeneous cytotoxicity indicator. Important aspects to the development of the multiplexed format are addressed, including results that demonstrate that the IC(50) values of 40 select compounds in a beta-lactamase reporter assay for nuclear factor kappa B and SIE pathway antagonists are not affected by the addition of the cytotoxicity indicator. To demonstrate the improvement in hit confirmation, the multiplexed assay was used to perform a small-library screen (7728 compounds) for serotonin 5HT1A receptor antagonists. Hits identified from analysis of the beta-lactamase reporter data alone were compared to those hits determined when the reporter and cytotoxicity data generated from the multiplexed assay were combined. Confirmation rates were determined from compound follow-up using dose-response analysis of the potential antagonist hits identified by the initial screen. In this representative screen, the multiplexed assay approach yielded a 19% reduction in the number of compounds flagged for follow-up, with a 37% decrease in the number of false hits, demonstrating that multiplexing a beta-lactamase reporter assay with a cytotoxicity readout is a highly effective strategy for reducing false hit rates in cell-based compound screening assays.     

The high throughput screening of neuropeptide FF2 receptor ligands from Korean herbal plant extracts

We have screened 356 libraries of Korean herbal plant extracts to find potential anti-obesity drugs. We employed the recently developed fluorescence polarization high throughput screening (FP HTS) assays of human neuropeptide FF (NPFF) receptors in 384-well microtiter plates. The primary hits were cherry-picked from the libraries and further analyzed by secondary displacement curve assays, in vitro GTPgammaS binding assays and cell-based CRE luciferase reporter assays. Agonists of NPFF receptors showed biphasic affinity curves while the antagonist, BIBP 3226, gave a monophasic affinity curve in competitive binding assays. We isolated and characterized two agonists of human NPFF2 receptor, PC 314 with K(i) of 1.42 microM, and PC 315 with K(i) of 2.17 microM from Schizandra chinensis. PC 314 and PC 315 have been characterized as benzoylgomisin Q (M.W. 552) and gomisin G (M.W. 536). We report that PC 314 and PC 315 are the first non-peptide, natural compounds, which bind to human NPFF2 receptors with good affinity. PC 314 and PC 315 inhibit forskolin-stimulated luciferase expression when CHO cells are co-transfected with NPFF2 receptor and CRE reporter vector. They possess the pharmacological and functional profiles of full agonists. The FP HTS system provides a specific, sensitive and reproducible methodology for studying and screening NPFF receptor ligands.     

Development of a functional reporter gene HTS assay for the identification of mGluR7 modulators

For the identification of modulators of the metabotropic glutamate receptor mGluR7, a functional cell-based high throughput screening (HTS) assay was developed. This assay utilizes the signal transduction pathway of mGluR7, which is negatively coupled to adenylyl cyclase. A cAMP-responsive luciferase reporter gene and rat mGluR7 cDNA were cotransfected into CHO-K1 cells by electroporation. Stable recombinant cells were selected by resistance to the antibiotic G418. Functional selection was carried out by analyzing the effect of the agonist glutamate to reduce elevated cAMP levels after forskolin stimulation. Out of 83 G418-resistant cell clones, the clone with the best functional characteristics was selected. This clone displayed the strongest reduction of forskolin-stimulated cAMP levels. Glutamate (10 mM) decreased cAMP levels, as monitored by luciferase expression, by about 50%, and the more potent agonist L-2-amino-4-phosphonobutyrate resulted in nearly complete reduction, exhibiting an EC(50) of 0.9 mM. The functional response of the clone did not change during cell passages, indicating the stability of this novel recombinant cell line. The luciferase reporter gene assay, which allows easy nonradioactive luminescence detection of mGluR7 activity, was optimized for its application in automated HTS.     

Cell-Based Assays for High-Throughput Screening

Cell-based assays represent approximately half of all high-throughput screens currently performed. Here, we review in brief the history and status of high-throughput screening (HTS), and summarize some of the challenges and benefits associated with the use of cell-based assays in HTS. Approaches for successful experimental design and execution of cell-based screens are introduced, including strategies for assay development, implementation of primary and secondary screens, and target identification. In doing so, we hope to provide a comprehensive review of the cell-based HTS process and an introduction to the methodologies and techniques used.     

Novel patient cell-based HTS assay for identification of small molecules for a lysosomal storage disease

Small molecules have been identified as potential therapeutic agents for lysosomal storage diseases (LSDs), inherited metabolic disorders caused by defects in proteins that result in lysosome dysfunctional. Some small molecules function assisting the folding of mutant misfolded lysosomal enzymes that are otherwise degraded in ER-associated degradation. The ultimate result is the enhancement of the residual enzymatic activity of the deficient enzyme. Most of the high throughput screening (HTS) assays developed to identify these molecules are single-target biochemical assays. Here we describe a cell-based assay using patient cell lines to identify small molecules that enhance the residual arylsulfatase A (ASA) activity found in patients with metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD), a progressive neurodegenerative LSD. In order to generate sufficient cell lines for a large scale HTS, primary cultured fibroblasts from MLD patients were transformed using SV40 large T antigen. These SV40 transformed (SV40t) cells showed to conserve biochemical characteristics of the primary cells. Using a specific colorimetric substrate para-nitrocatechol sulfate (pNCS), detectable ASA residual activity were observed in primary and SV40t fibroblasts from a MLD patient (ASA-I179S) cultured in multi-well plates. A robust fluorescence ASA assay was developed in high-density 1,536-well plates using the traditional colorimetric pNCS substrate, whose product (pNC) acts as "plate fluorescence quencher" in white solid-bottom plates. The quantitative cell-based HTS assay for ASA generated strong statistical parameters when tested against a diverse small molecule collection. This cell-based assay approach can be used for several other LSDs and genetic disorders, especially those that rely on colorimetric substrates which traditionally present low sensitivity for assay-miniaturization. In addition, the quantitative cell-based HTS assay here developed using patient cells creates an opportunity to identify therapeutic small molecules in a disease-cellular environment where potentially disrupted pathways are exposed and available as targets.     

Detection of bioavailable peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma modulators by a cell-based luciferase reporter system

In vitro cell-based reporter assays are a useful tool for the discovery and characterization of nuclear receptor modulators. However, the properties of a given molecule can differ when tested in vitro and in vivo as a result of the molecule's bioavailability. In this work, we describe a methodology that allows the detection of the PPARγ (peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma) agonist bezafibrate in rat serum by an in vitro cell-based reporter assay. This methodology could be adapted to the detection and characterization of bioavailable PPARγ or other nuclear receptor modulators in serum, extending the possibilities of the classical in vitro assays.     

High throughput screening for small molecule therapy for Gaucher disease using patient tissue as the source of mutant glucocerebrosidase

Gaucher disease (GD), the most common lysosomal storage disorder, results from the inherited deficiency of the lysosomal enzyme glucocerebrosidase (GCase). Previously, wildtype GCase was used for high throughput screening (HTS) of large collections of compounds to identify small molecule chaperones that could be developed as new therapies for GD. However, the compounds identified from HTS usually showed reduced potency later in confirmatory cell-based assays. An alternate strategy is to perform HTS on mutant enzyme to identify different lead compounds, including those enhancing mutant enzyme activities. We developed a new screening assay using enzyme extract prepared from the spleen of a patient with Gaucher disease with genotype N370S/N370S. In tissue extracts, GCase is in a more native physiological environment, and is present with the native activator saposin C and other potential cofactors. Using this assay, we screened a library of 250,000 compounds and identified novel modulators of mutant GCase including 14 new lead inhibitors and 30 lead activators. The activities of some of the primary hits were confirmed in subsequent cell-based assays using patient-derived fibroblasts. These results suggest that primary screening assays using enzyme extracted from tissues is an alternative approach to identify high quality, physiologically relevant lead compounds for drug development.     

A solid-phase immunosorbent assay for the detection of protein kinase-specific monoclonal antibodies

We describe two solid-phase immunosorbent assays that detect monoclonal antibodies against a cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase from Paramecium tetraurelia without the need for pure kinase preparations. A radiometric immunosorbent assay (RISA) previously described by E.A. Pierce, M. C. Dame, and H. F. De Luca (1986, Anal. Biochem. 153, 67-74) was adapted to detect monoclonal antibodies against cyclic AMP-binding proteins. The RISA identified antibodies against the regulatory subunit of the enzyme, but failed to detect antibodies against the catalytic subunit. We therefore developed a solid-phase assay for immunoadsorbed protein kinase activity (IPKA) in 96-well plates. Antibodies were adsorbed from hybridoma supernatants to wells coated with anti-immunoglobulin antibodies. The wells were then incubated with protein kinase, and bound protein kinase activity was assayed with histone as a substrate. Monoclonal antibody concentrations of 1 micrograms/ml were reliably detected in hybridoma supernatants. As little as 10 histone-phosphorylating units (picomoles of phosphate incorporated per minute) were required per assay. The IPKA detected not only catalytic subunit-specific antibodies, but also antibodies directed against the regulatory subunit of the cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase. Since crude preparations of protein kinase can be used in the IPKA, monoclonal antibodies raised against impure protein kinase can be identified.     

A disease-relevant high-content screening assay to identify anti-inflammatory compounds for use in cystic fibrosis

Chronic lung inflammation caused by bacterial pathogenesis through activation of nuclear factor kappa B (NFκB)-responsive proinflammatory genes is a major hurdle in the management of lung disease in cystic fibrosis (CF) patients. The authors generated a disease-relevant cell-based high-content screen to identify novel anti-inflammatory compounds for treating lung inflammation in CF. The human bronchial epithelial cell line KKLEB, harboring the most common form of mutation that causes CF, was modified to express an NFκB-responsive green fluorescent protein (GFP) reporter. After creation, the cell line was tested for its ability to respond to disease-relevant inflammatory stimuli elicited by treatment of cells with filtrates of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolated from the airways of a CF patient. P. aeruginosa filtrates potently activated NFκB-responsive GFP reporter expression in cells. Subsequently, the assay was optimized for high-throughput screening (HTS) through generation of a Z factor (~0.5) and by testing its tolerance to the commonly used solvents ethanol and DMSO. A pilot library of clinically approved compounds was screened for assay validation. Several compounds with known NFκB inhibitory activity were identified, including several steroidal compounds that have been clinically tested in CF. Thus, the assay can be used in a broader HTS campaign to find anti-inflammatory agents for use in CF.     

A fluorescent reporter assay for the detection of ligands acting through Gi protein-coupled receptors

Accompanying the advances in basic biology of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) is the practical need among biopharmaceutical companies for sensitive assays to assess GPCR function, particularly formats that are compatible with high-throughput drug screening. Here we describe a novel cell-based assay format for the high-throughput detection of ligands for Gi protein-coupled receptors. Two Gi-GPCRs, mu-opioid receptor (mu-OPR) and 5-hydroxytryptamine receptor la (5HT1aR) are employed as model receptor targets. The key feature of this assay system is the isolation of stable, clonal Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines that carry three separate expression plasmids: (1) a chimeric Gq/i5 protein (which re-directs a negative Gi-type signal to a positive Gq-type response), (2) a given Gi-GPCR, and (3) a beta-lactamase (beta1a) reporter gene responsive to Gi-GPCR signaling. Cell-based assays built using this format show appropriate rank order of potency among a reference set of receptor agonist and antagonist compounds. Such assays are also robust, reliable, and can be used for industrial-scale applications such as high-throughput screening for drug leads.