Fluorescence quenching in lipid micelles and bilayers: Evaluation of bimolecular rate constants

Dynamic quenching of fluorophores and quenchers in lipid micelles and bilayers can yield information about the bimolecular rate constant for the quenching reaction, and hence information about the microviscosity of the fluorophore-quencher environment. When the fluorophore and quencher have relatively fixed transverse positions in the bilayer, the analysis of Sikaris et al. (Chem. Phys. Lipids. 29 (1981) 23) can be used to separate the microviscosity and proximity contributions to quenching. We now extend this method to show explicitly the effect of static quenching on the analysis. We show by simulation and experiment that a correction factor must be included when static quenching contributes to the observed quenching efficiency.     

Multi-path quenchers: efficient quenching of common fluorophores

Fluorescence quenching groups are widely employed in biological detection, sensing, and imaging. To date, a relatively small number of such groups are in common use. Perhaps the most commonly used quencher, dabcyl, has limited efficiency with a broad range of fluorophores. Here, we describe a molecular approach to improve the efficiency of quenchers by increasing their electronic complexity. Multi-Path Quenchers (MPQ) are designed to have multiple donor or acceptor groups in their structure, allowing for a multiplicity of conjugation pathways of varied length. This has the effect of broadening the absorption spectrum, which in turn can increase quenching efficiency and versatility. Six such MPQ derivatives are synthesized and tested for quenching efficiency in a DNA hybridization context. Duplexes placing quenchers and fluorophores within contact distance or beyond this distance are used to measure quenching via contact or FRET mechanisms. Results show that several of the quenchers are considerably more efficient than dabcyl at quenching a wider range of common fluorophores, and two quench fluorescein and TAMRA as well as or better than a Black Hole Quencher.     

Characterization of dark quencher chromophores as nonfluorescent acceptors for single-molecule FRET

Dark quenchers are chromophores that primarily relax from the excited state to the ground state nonradiatively (i.e., are dark). As a result, they can serve as acceptors for Förster resonance energy transfer experiments without contributing significantly to background in the donor-emission channel, even at high concentrations. Although the advantages of dark quenchers have been exploited for ensemble bioassays, no systematic single-molecule study of dark quenchers has been performed, and little is known about their photophysical properties. Here, we present the first systematic single-molecule study of dark quenchers in conjunction with fluorophores and demonstrate the use of dark quenchers for monitoring multiple interactions and distances in multichromophore systems. Specifically, using double-stranded DNA standards labeled with two fluorophores and a dark quencher (either QSY7 or QSY21), we show that the proximity of a fluorophore and dark quencher can be monitored using the stoichiometry ratio available from alternating laser excitation spectroscopy experiments, either for single molecules diffusing in solution (using a confocal fluorescence) or immobilized on surfaces (using total-internal-reflection fluorescence). The latter experiments allowed characterization of the dark-quencher photophysical properties at the single-molecule level. We also use dark-quenchers to study the affinity and kinetics of binding of DNA Polymerase I (Klenow fragment) to DNA. The measured properties are in excellent agreement with the results of ensemble assays, validating the use of dark quenchers. Because dark-quencher-labeled biomolecules can be used in total-internal-reflection fluorescence experiments at concentrations of 1 μM or more without introducing a significant background, the use of dark quenchers should permit single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer measurements for the large number of biomolecules that participate in interactions of moderate-to-low affinity.     

Wavelength-shifting molecular beacons

We describe wavelength-shifting molecular beacons, which are nucleic acid hybridization probes that fluoresce in a variety of different colors, yet are excited by a common monochromatic light source. The twin functions of absorption of energy from the excitation light and emission of that energy in the form of fluorescent light are assigned to two separate fluorophores in the same probe. These probes contain a harvester fluorophore that absorbs strongly in the wavelength range of the monochromatic light source, an emitter fluorophore of the desired emission color, and a nonfluorescent quencher. In the absence of complementary nucleic acid targets, the probes are dark, whereas in the presence of targets, they fluoresce-not in the emission range of the harvester fluorophore that absorbs the light, but rather in the emission range of the emitter fluorophore. This shift in emission spectrum is due to the transfer of the absorbed energy from the harvester fluorophore to the emitter fluorophore by fluorescence resonance energy transfer, and it only takes place in probes that are bound to targets. Wavelength-shifting molecular beacons are substantially brighter than conventional molecular beacons that contain a fluorophore that cannot efficiently absorb energy from the available monochromatic light source. We describe the spectral characteristics of wavelength-shifting molecular beacons, and we demonstrate how their use improves and simplifies multiplex genetic analyses.     

Joint determination by Brownian dynamics and fluorescence quenching of the in-depth location profile of biomolecules in membranes

The in-depth molar distribution function of fluorophores is revealed by a new methodology for fluorescence quenching data analysis in membranes. Brownian dynamics simulation was used to study the in-depth location profile of quenchers. A Lorentzian profile was reached. Since the Stern-Volmer equation is valid at every depth in the membrane for low quencher concentrations, the molar distribution of the fluorophore (also regarded as a Lorentzian) can be achieved. The average location and the broadness of the fluorophore distribution can be calculated. The importance of the knowledge of the location width is demonstrated and discussed, since this parameter reveals important conclusions on structural features of the interaction of membranes with probes and biomolecules (e.g., conformational freedom in proteins), as well as photophysical properties (e.g., differential fluorophore quantum yields). Subsequent use of this methodology by the reader does not, necessarily, involve the performance of simulations and is not limited to the use of Lorentzian function distributions.     

Interaction of antioxidants with depth-dependent fluorescence quenchers and energy transfer probes in lipid bilayers.

Three fluorescent, lipophilic, heterocyclic antioxidants were incorporated into lipid bilayers and exposed to depth-dependent nitroxyl fatty acid quenchers. The Stern-Volmer plots curved upward at low quencher concentrations. Quantitative analysis of the results showed that this behavior is consistent with complex formation between quencher and fluorescent antioxidant, where the complex is 2-3 times more fluorescent than the parent fluorophore. At higher quencher concentrations, both free antioxidant and 'bright complex' are quenched dynamically, albeit quenching of the latter is less efficient. The complex probably results from ionic, hydrogen bond and pi-pi interactions. Formation of such a 'bright complex' is also observable in a homogeneous solution of the reactants in cyclohexane. Additional evidence for the complexation of these antioxidants with fatty acids in lipid bilayers is provided by the fact that energy transfer from the antioxidants to anthroyloxy fatty acids occurs at surface concentrations where radiative energy transfer between free molecules should be not be efficient. For directly probing the relative depths of these fluorophores in lipid bilayers we used the aqueous quenchers acrylamide and iodide. They showed that in terms of increasing depth in the bilayer, the order was U-78, 517f < U-78,518e < U-75,412e. Our results, in toto, demonstrate that the Lazaroid antioxidants are incorporated into the lipid bilayer where they occupy strictly defined positions and orientations. Complexation with fatty acyl chains should be mechanistically relevant, since it may enhance antioxidant activity by hindering free radical chain propagation.     

Basic Principles of Fluorescence and Energy Transfer Applied to Real-Time PCR

Fluorescence is highly sensitive to environment, and the distance separating fluorophores and quencher molecules can provide the basis for effective homogeneous nucleic acid hybridization assays. Molecular interactions leading to fluorescence quenching include collisions, ground state and excited state complex formation, and long-range dipole-coupled energy transfer. These processes are well understood and equations are provided for estimating the effects of each process on fluorescence intensity. Estimates for the fluorescein-tetramethylrhodamine donor–acceptor pair reveal the relative contributions of dipole-coupled energy transfer, collisional quenching, and static quenching in several common assay formats, and illustrate that the degree of quenching is dependent upon the hybridization complex formed and the manner of label attachment.     

Novel DNA probes with low background and high hybridization-triggered fluorescence

Novel fluorogenic DNA probes are described. The probes (called Pleiades) have a minor groove binder (MGB) and a fluorophore at the 5′-end and a non-fluorescent quencher at the 3′-end of the DNA sequence. This configuration provides surprisingly low background and high hybridization-triggered fluorescence. Here, we comparatively study the performance of such probes, MGB-Eclipse probes, and molecular beacons. Unlike the other two probe formats, the Pleiades probes have low, temperature-independent background fluorescence and excellent signal-to-background ratios. The probes possess good mismatch discrimination ability and high rates of hybridization. Based on the analysis of fluorescence and absorption spectra we propose a mechanism of action for the Pleiades probes. First, hydrophobic interactions between the quencher and the MGB bring the ends of the probe and, therefore, the fluorophore and the quencher in close proximity. Second, the MGB interacts with the fluorophore and independent of the quencher is able to provide a modest (2–4-fold) quenching effect. Joint action of the MGB and the quencher is the basis for the unique quenching mechanism. The fluorescence is efficiently restored upon binding of the probe to target sequence due to a disruption in the MGB–quencher interaction and concealment of the MGB moiety inside the minor groove.     

Fluorescent labeling of Taqman oligonucleotide probes via Cu(I)-catalyzed alkyne-azide cycloaddition (CuAAC) click chemistry

We describe an approach to the synthesis of TaqMan oligonucleotide probes that is based on Cu(I)-catalyzed alkyne-azide cycloaddition (CuAAC) click chemistry when oligonucleotides containing an internal alkynyl group at the pyrimidine position are labeled post-synthetically with a f luorescent azide. TaqMan probes were constructed with f luorescein in different internal positions and a BHQ1 quencher on the 3′-end. Our previously designed alkynylated deoxyuridine or deoxycytidine phosphoramidites have been employed for the synthesis of alkynyl oligonucleotides. It was demonstrated that the synthesized TaqMan probes can detect accumulation of PCR product in real-time. The closer to the label the 3′-terminal quencher, the higher the quenching efficiency, but the efficiency of probe hybridization to DNA template is reduced in this case.     

Detection of PCR products using self-probing amplicons and fluorescence.

Molecular diagnostics is progressing from low-throughput, heterogeneous, mostly manual technologies to higher throughput, closed-tube, and automated methods. Fluorescence is the favored signaling technology for such assays, and a number of techniques rely on energy transfer between a fluorophore and a proximal quencher molecule. In these methods, dual-labeled probes hybridize to an amplicon and changes in the quenching of the fluorophore are detected. We describe a new technology that is simple to use, gives highly specific information, and avoids the major difficulties of the alternative methods. It uses a primer with an integral tail that is used to probe an extension product of the primer. The probing of a target sequence is thereby converted into a unimolecular event, which has substantial benefits in terms of kinetics, thermodynamics, assay design, and probe reliability.     

Fluorescence-quenching study of percolation and compartmentalization in two-phase lipid bilayers.

Fluorescence quenching of a lipid-labeled fluorophore by a lipid spin-labeled quencher has been studied experimentally in two-component, two-phase phosphatidylcholine bilayers to examine the effect of phase connection and disconnection on quenching. Both fluorophore and quencher prefer the fluid phase. At the percolation threshold, the point at which the fluid phase becomes subdivided into may small disconnected domains, the quenching drops abruptly. This decrease in quenching is a function of the fluid-phase fraction and is due to the heterogeneous distribution of fluorophores and quenchers over the fluid-phase domains. Computer simulations of the system were carried out with a triangular lattice divided into closed compartments of variable size and reactant occupancy. The simulations demonstrate that the degree of quenching is reduced in the disconnected systems and that the reduction is correlated with the size of the disconnected domains. The combination of experimental data with simulations leads to the conclusion that at constant temperature the size of fluid-phase domains, nfluid, in the region of the coexistence of the fluid and gel phases is proportional to the fluid fraction, Xfluid. This is in a qualitative agreement with a previous electron spin resonance study of interlipid spin-spin interactions in the same two-component, two-phase bilayer system.     

Interactive Fluorophore and Quencher Pairs for Labeling Fluorescent Nucleic Acid Hybridization Probes

The use of fluorescent nucleic acid hybridization probes that generate a fluorescence signal only when they bind to their target enables real-time monitoring of nucleic acid amplification assays. Real-time nucleic acid amplification assays markedly improves the ability to obtain qualitative and quantitative results. Furthermore, these assays can be carried out in sealed tubes, eliminating carryover contamination. Fluorescent nucleic acid hybridization probes are available in a wide range of different fluorophore and quencher pairs. Multiple hybridization probes, each designed for the detection of a different nucleic acid sequence and each labeled with a differently colored fluorophore, can be added to the same nucleic acid amplification reaction, enabling the development of high-throughput multiplex assays. In order to develop robust, highly sensitive and specific real-time nucleic acid amplification assays it is important to carefully select the fluorophore and quencher labels of hybridization probes. Selection criteria are based on the type of hybridization probe used in the assay, the number of targets to be detected, and the type of apparatus available to perform the assay. This article provides an overview of different aspects of choosing appropriate labels for the different types of fluorescent hybridization probes used with different types of spectrofluorometric thermal cyclers currently available.     

Viscosity dependence of acrylamide quenching of ribonuclease T1 fluorescence. The gating mechanism.

The structural regulation of the access of acrylamide molecules, as quenchers, to the buried tryptophans of a protein can be modelled by a simple gate concept. Such a gate, when open, allows transient exposure of the fluorophore to the quencher molecule in solution. We have previously shown that the observed viscosity dependence of acrylamide quenching process in ribonuclease T1 (RNAse T1) is not reconcilable with the gating mechanism. However, on that occasion, we neglected the effect of changes in the activity of the quencher molecule and the possible presence of static quenching. The experimental observation of a considerable contribution by static quenching and the realization that static quenching might produce dramatic effects in steady state measurements led us to reexamine the question. It is shown that in a gating model the static component can also influence the apparent dynamic quenching. In this paper, we present derived equations for the gated quenching mechanism including possible contributions from the static component. We also carefully remeasured the acrylamide quenching of RNAase T1 as a function of increasing glycerol concentration. Computer simulations were carried out to compare the experimental data set to the generalized model. We reach the conclusion that even the new, quite complex equations fail to predict the qualitative and quantitative features of the observed quenching experiments. We arrived at the conclusion that the fluorophore is never the target of the quencher molecules in solution.     

Unexpected transformation of black hole quenchers in electrophoretic purification of the fluorescein-containing TaqMan probes

The fluorescence quenchers BHQ1 and BHQ2 can be modified by trace amounts of ammonium persulfate, used for initiating gel polymerization, in electrophoretic purification of TaqMan probes using a denaturing polyacrylamide gel. The case study of BHQ1 quencher has demonstrated that a Boyland–Sims reaction proceeds in the presence of ammonium persulfate to give the corresponding sulfate. The absorption maximum of the resulting quencher shifts to the short-wavelength region relative to the absorption maximum of the initial BHQ1. The TaqMan probe containing such a quencher is less efficient as compared with the probe carrying an unmodified BHQ1. The presence of fluorescein in TaqMan probe plays decisive role in this transformation: the quencher modification proceeds at a considerably lower rate when the fluorescein is absent or replaced with a rhodamine dye (for example, R6G). It is assumed that the observed reaction can take place in two ways—both in darkness and in the reaction of the quencher in an excited state due to energy transfer from the fluorophore irradiated by light.     

Organization and dynamics of pyrene and pyrene lipids in intact lipid bilayers. Photo-induced charge transfer processes.

The dynamics of fluorescence quenching and the organization of a series of pyrene derivatives anchored in various depths in bilayers of phosphatidylcholine small unilamellar vesicles was studied and compared with their behavior in homogeneous solvent systems. The studies include characterization of the environmental polarity of the pyrene fluorophore based on its vibronic peaks, as well as the interaction with three collisional quenchers: the two membrane-soluble quenchers, diethylaniline and bromobenzene, and the water soluble quencher potassium iodide. The system of diethylaniline-pyrene derivatives in the membrane of phosphatidylcholine vesicles was characterized in detail. The diethylaniline partition coefficient between the lipid bilayers and the buffer is approximately 5,800. Up to a diethylaniline/phospholipid mole ratio of 1:3 the perturbation to membrane structure is minimal so that all photophysical studies were performed below this mole ratio. The quenching reaction, in all cases, was shown to take place in the lipid bilayer interior and the relative quenching efficiencies of the various probe molecules was used to provide information on the distribution of both fluorescent probes and quencher molecules in the lipid bilayer. The quenching efficiency by diethylaniline in the lipid bilayer was found to be essentially independent on the length of the methylene chain of the pyrene moiety. These findings suggest that the quenching process, being a diffusion controlled reaction, is determined by the mobility of the diethylaniline quencher (with an effective diffusion coefficient D approximately 10(-7) cm2 s-1) which appears to be homogeneously distributed throughout the lipid bilayer. The pulsed laser photolysis products of the charge-transfer quenching reaction were examined. No exciplex (excited-complex) formation was observed and the yield of the separated radical ions was shown to be tenfold smaller than in homogenous polar solutions. The decay of the radical ions is considerably faster than the corresponding process in homogenous solutions. Relatively high intersystem crossing yields are observed. The results are explained on the basis of the intrinsic properties of a lipid bilayer, primarily, its rigid spatial organization. It is suggested that such properties favor ion-pair formation over exciplex generation. They also enhance primary geminate recombination of initially formed (solvent-shared) ion pairs. Triplet states are generated via secondary geminate recombination of ion pairs in the membrane interior. The results bear on the general mechanism of electron transfer processes in biomembranes.     

Position of the fluorescent label is a crucial factor determining signal intensity in microarray hybridizations

A key issue in applications of short oligonucleotide-based microarrays is how to design specific probes with high sensitivity. Some details of the factors affecting microarray hybridization remain unclear, hampering a reliable quantification of target nucleic acids. We have evaluated the effect of the position of the fluorescent label [position of label (POL)] relative to the probe-target duplex on the signal output of oligonucleotide microarrays. End-labelled single-stranded DNA targets of different lengths were used for hybridization with perfect-match oligonucleotide probe sets targeting different positions of the same molecule. Hybridization results illustrated that probes targeting the labelled terminus of the target showed significantly higher signals than probes targeting other regions. This effect was independent of the target gene, the fluorophore and the slide surface chemistry. Comparison of microarray signal patterns of fluorescently end-labelled, fluorescently internally random-labelled and radioactively end-labelled target-DNAs with the same set of oligonucleotide probes identified POL as a critical factor affecting signal intensity rather than binding efficiency. Our observations define a novel determinant for large differences of signal intensities. Application of the POL effect may contribute to better probe design and data interpretation in microarray applications.     

Fluorescence quenching in model membranes: phospholipid acyl chain distributions around small fluorophores

Fluorescence quenching in lipid bilayers is treated by a new approach based on calculation of the probability distribution of quenching and nonquenching acyl chains around a fluorophore. The effect of acyl lattice site dependence (i.e., correlations of phospholipid sister chain occupancy of neighbor sites) was modeled by use of Monte Carlo simulations of acyl chain occupancy. This explicit accounting of site occupancy correlation was found to fit observed quenching behavior better than did a model wherein phospholipid quenchers are considered to be independent. A key aspect of this approach is to evaluate the rate for quenching in a bilayer composed of pure quenching lipid. In order to evaluate this quenching rate, and also to provide a strong test of the calculated probability distributions, we synthesized lipids with both acyl chains labeled with a quenching moiety (Br or nitroxide), as well as the more usual single-chain quenchers. The fluorescence of tryptophan octyl ester (TOE), and of the 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH) derivatives trimethylammonium-DPH (TMA-DPH) and 1-lauroyl-2-(DPH-propionyl)phosphatidylcholine (DPH-PC), was examined. We obtained consistent results with all the fluorophores and quenchers indicating that up to 18 neighboring acyl sites can contribute to quenching, corresponding to two shells of acyl sites on a hexagonal lattice. Calculated discrete distributions of fluorescence intensities were converted into fluorescence lifetimes and compared with Gaussian and Lorentzian continuous lifetime distributions. The fluorescence quenching theory presented here may be used to explain quantitatively the heterogeneity of fluorophore environments in multicomponent membranes.     

DFT study of the interaction between the conjugated fluorescein and dabcyl system, using fluorescene quenching method

Molecular beacon is a DNA probe containing a sequence complementary to the target that is flanked by self-complementary termini, and carries a fluorophore and a quencher at the ends. We used the fluorescein and dabcyl as fluorophore and quencher respectively, and studied with DFT calculations at the GGA/DNP level, and taking into account DFT dispersion corrections by the Grimme and Tkatchenko-Scheffler (TS) schemes, the distance, where the most favorable energetic interaction between the fluorophore and quencher in conjugated form occurs. This distance occurs at a separation distance of 29.451?? between the centers of Dabcyl and fluorescein employing the TS DFT dispersion correction scheme, indicating FRET efficiency around 94.28?%. The calculated emission spectra of the conjugated pair in water indicated that the emission and absorption spectrum overlap completely and thus no fluorescence can be observed due to the fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) effect. The DFT results confirmed the experimentally observing fluorescence quenching of the fluorescein-dabcyl conjugated system by FRET.     

Effect of primary and secondary structure of oligodeoxyribonucleotides on the fluorescent properties of conjugated dyes

We studied fluorescence intensity, polarization and lifetime of some commonly used fluorophores conjugated to oligodeoxyribonucleotides with different primary and secondary structures. We found that fluorescence intensity can increase or decrease upon hybridization of the labeled strand to its complement depending on the sequence and position of the fluorophore. Up to 10-fold quenching of the fluorescence upon hybridization was observed when the dye moiety was attached close to the 3′ end and the 3′-terminal base was either dG or dC. No quenching upon hybridization was observed when the dye was positioned within the same sequence context but close to the 5′ end. The presence of a dG overhang quenches the fluorescence less efficiently than a blunt end dG-dC or dC-dG base pair. When located internally in the double strand, the dG-dC base pair does not affect the fluorescence of the nearby dye. Guanosine in a single-stranded oligonucleotide quenches the fluorescence of nearby dye by <2-fold. Upon duplex formation, this quenching is eliminated and the fluorescence increases. This increase can only be detected when the fluorophore is located at least 6 nt from the terminal dG-dC base pair. The change of fluorescence polarization upon duplex formation inversely correlates with the change of intensity. Fluorescein conjugated to a single-stranded oligonucleotide or a duplex undergoes a bi-exponential decay with ~4 and ~1 ns lifetimes.     

Stem-loop probe with universal reporter for sensing unlabeled nucleic acids

In this article, we present the design principles and application of a motif composed of a stem-loop probe (SP) hybridized to a fluorescently labeled universal reporter (UR) for sensing unlabeled nucleic acids. At room temperature, SP-UR is in the hairpin-closed form in which the fluorophore of UR is in proximity to the G bases of the hairpin, where consequently the fluorescent emission is quenched significantly. On hybridization with target, SP-UR is trapped in the hairpin-opened configuration in which the fluorophore and the G quenchers are apart. This turns off quenching, increases emission intensity, and signals the presence of target. Compared with the common approach that employs an oligonucleotide probe with a covalently linked fluorophore, the use of a fluorescently labeled universal reporter strand hybridized to an unlabeled stem-loop probe provides a more efficient approach to the fabrication of nucleic acid sensors and microarrays potentially useful for real-time analysis.