Complexation of integral membrane proteins by phosphorylcholine-based amphipols

Amphiphilic macromolecules, known as amphipols, have emerged as promising candidates to replace conventional detergents for handling integral membrane proteins in water due to the enhanced stability of protein/amphipol complexes as compared to protein/detergent complexes. The limited portfolio of amphipols currently available prompted us to develop amphipols bearing phosphorylcholine-based units (PC). Unlike carboxylated polymers, PC-amphipols remain soluble in aqueous media under conditions of low pH, high salt concentration, or in the presence of divalent ions. The solubilizing properties of four PC-amphipols were assessed in the case of two membrane proteins, cytochrome b₆f and bacteriorhodopsin. The protein/PC-amphipol complexes had a low dispersity in size, as determined by rate zonal ultracentrifugation. Short PC-amphipols (<M>≈ 22 kDa) of low dispersity in length, containing ∼ 30 mol% octyl side groups, ∼ 35 mol% PC-groups, and ∼ 35 mol% isopropyl side groups, appeared best suited to form stable complexes, preserving the native state of BR over periods of several days. BR/PC-amphipol complexes remained soluble in aqueous media at pH ≥ 5, as well as in the presence of 1 M NaCl or 12 mM calcium ions. Results from isothermal titration calorimetry indicated that the energetics of the conversion of BR/detergent complexes into BR/amphipol complexes are similar for PC-amphipols and carboxylated amphiphols.     

Interaction of amphipols with sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase

Amphipols are short-chain amphipathic polymers designed to keep membrane proteins soluble in aqueous solutions. We have evaluated the effects of the interaction of amphipols with sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca(2+)-ATPase either in a membrane-bound or a soluble form. If the addition of amphipols to detergent-solubilized ATPase was followed by removal of detergent, soluble complexes formed, but these complexes retained poor ATPase activity, were not very stable upon long incubation periods, and at high concentrations they experienced aggregation. Nevertheless, adding excess detergent to diluted detergent-free ATPase-amphipol complexes incubated for short periods immediately restored full activity to these complexes, showing that amphipols had protected solubilized ATPase from the rapid and irreversible inactivation that otherwise follows detergent removal. Amphipols also protected solubilized ATPase from the rapid and irreversible inactivation observed in detergent solutions if the ATPase Ca(2+) binding sites remain vacant. Moreover, in the presence of Ca(2+), amphipol/detergent mixtures stabilized concentrated ATPase against inactivation and aggregation, whether in the presence or absence of lipids, for much longer periods of time (days) than detergent alone. Our observations suggest that mixtures of amphipols and detergents are promising media for handling solubilized Ca(2+)-ATPase under conditions that would otherwise lead to its irreversible denaturation and/or aggregation.     

How Amphipols Embed Membrane Proteins: Global Solvent Accessibility and Interaction with a Flexible Protein Terminus

Amphipathic polymers called amphipols provide a valuable alternative to detergents for keeping integral membrane proteins soluble in aqueous buffers. Here, we characterize spatial contacts of amphipol A8-35 with membrane proteins from two architectural classes: The 8-stranded β-barrel outer membrane protein OmpX and the α-helical protein bacteriorhodopsin. OmpX is well structured in A8-35, with its barrel adopting a fold closely similar to that in dihexanoylphosphocholine micelles. The accessibility of A8-35-trapped OmpX by a water-soluble paramagnetic molecule is highly similar to that in detergent micelles and resembles the accessibility in the natural membrane. For the α-helical protein bacteriorhodopsin, previously shown to keep its fold and function in amphipols, NMR data show that the imidazole protons of a polyhistidine tag at the N-terminus of the protein are exchange protected in the presence of detergent and lipid bilayer nanodiscs, but not in amphipols, indicating the absence of an interaction in the latter case. Overall, A8-35 exhibits protein interaction properties somewhat different from detergents and lipid bilayer nanodiscs, while maintaining the structure of solubilized integral membrane proteins.     

Use of amphipathic polymers to deliver a membrane protein to lipid bilayers

Data are presented which suggest that a class of amphiphilic polymers known as 'amphipols' may serve as a vehicle for delivering complex integral membrane proteins into membranes. The integral membrane protein diacylglycerol kinase (DAGK) was maintained in soluble form by either of two different amphipols. Small aliquots of these solutions were added to pre-formed lipid vesicles and the appearance of DAGK catalytic activity was monitored as an indicator of the progress of productive protein insertion into the bilayers. For one of the two amphipols tested, DAGK was observed to productively transfer from its amphipol complex into vesicles with moderate efficiency. Results were not completely clear for the other amphipol.     

Amphipol-Trapped ExbB–ExbD Membrane Protein Complex from Escherichia coli: A Biochemical and Structural Case Study

Nutrient import across Gram-negative bacteria’s outer membrane is powered by the proton-motive force, delivered by the cytoplasmic membrane protein complex ExbB–ExbD–TonB. Having purified the ExbB₄–ExbD₂ complex in the detergent dodecyl maltoside, we substituted amphipol A8-35 for detergent, forming a water-soluble membrane protein/amphipol complex. Properties of the ExbB₄–ExbD₂ complex in detergent or in amphipols were compared by gel electrophoresis, size exclusion chromatography, asymmetric flow field-flow fractionation, thermal stability assays, and electron microscopy. Bound detergent and fluorescently labeled amphipol were assayed quantitatively by 1D NMR and analytical ultracentrifugation, respectively. The structural arrangement of ExbB₄–ExbD₂ was examined by EM, small-angle X-ray scattering, and small-angle neutron scattering using a deuterated amphipol. The amphipol-trapped ExbB₄–ExbD₂ complex is slightly larger than its detergent-solubilized counterpart. We also investigated a different oligomeric form of the two proteins, ExbB₆–ExbD₄, and propose a structural arrangement of its transmembrane α-helical domains.     

Bacteriorhodopsin/amphipol complexes: structural and functional properties

The membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin (BR) can be kept soluble in its native state for months in the absence of detergent by amphipol (APol) A8-35, an amphiphilic polymer. After an actinic flash, A8-35-complexed BR undergoes a complete photocycle, with kinetics intermediate between that in detergent solution and that in its native membrane. BR/APol complexes form well defined, globular particles comprising a monomer of BR, a complete set of purple membrane lipids, and, in a peripheral distribution, ∼2 g APol/g BR, arranged in a compact layer. In the absence of free APol, BR/APol particles can autoassociate into small or large ordered fibrils.     

Nonionic homopolymeric amphipols: application to membrane protein folding, cell-free synthesis, and solution nuclear magnetic resonance

Nonionic amphipols (NAPols) synthesized by homotelomerization of an amphiphatic monomer are able to keep membrane proteins (MPs) stable and functional in the absence of detergent. Some of their biochemical and biophysical properties and applications have been examined, with particular attention being paid to their complementarity with the classical polyacrylate-based amphipol A8-35. Bacteriorhodopsin (BR) from Halobacterium salinarum and the cytochrome b(6)f complex from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii were found to be in their native state and highly stable following complexation with NAPols. NAPol-trapped BR was shown to undergo its complete photocycle. Because of the pH insensitivity of NAPols, solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) two-dimensional (1)H-(15)N heteronuclear single-quantum coherence spectra of NAPol-trapped outer MP X from Escherichia coli (OmpX) could be recorded at pH 6.8. They present a resolution similar to that of the spectra of OmpX/A8-35 complexes recorded at pH 8.0 and give access to signals from solvent-exposed rapidy exchanging amide protons. Like A8-35, NAPols can be used to fold MPs to their native state as demonstrated here with BR and with the ghrelin G protein-coupled receptor GHS-R1a, thus extending the range of accessible folding conditions. Following NAPol-assisted folding, GHS-R1a bound four of its specific ligands, recruited arrestin-2, and activated binding of GTPγS by the G(αq) protein. Finally, cell-free synthesis of MPs, which is inhibited by A8-35 and sulfonated amphipols, was found to be very efficient in the presence of NAPols. These results open broad new perspectives on the use of amphipols for MP studies.     

Molecular Dynamics Simulations of a Membrane Protein/Amphipol Complex

Amphipathic polymers known as “amphipols” provide a highly stabilizing environment for handling membrane proteins in aqueous solutions. A8-35, an amphipol with a polyacrylate backbone and hydrophobic grafts, has been extensively characterized and widely employed for structural and functional studies of membrane proteins using biochemical and biophysical approaches. Given the sensitivity of membrane proteins to their environment, it is important to examine what effects amphipols may have on the structure and dynamics of the proteins they complex. Here we present the first molecular dynamics study of an amphipol-stabilized membrane protein, using Escherichia coli OmpX as a model. We begin by describing the structure of the complexes formed by supplementing OmpX with increasing amounts of A8-35, in order to determine how the amphipol interacts with the transmembrane and extramembrane surfaces of the protein. We then compare the dynamics of the protein in either A8-35, a detergent, or a lipid bilayer. We find that protein dynamics on all accessible length scales is restrained by A8-35, which provides a basis to understanding some of the stabilizing and functional effects of amphipols that have been experimentally observed.     

Protective and inhibitory effects of various types of amphipols on the Ca2+-ATPase from sarcoplasmic reticulum: a comparative study

Amphipols are amphipathic polymers designed to replace or supplement detergents in membrane protein solution studies. Previous work has suggested both advantages and disadvantages to the use of a polyacrylate-based amphipol, A8-35, for studying the sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase (SERCA1a). We investigated this issue further using a set of four amphipols with different chemical structures. Previous size exclusion chromatography experiments had shown that A8-35 and SERCA1a/A8-35 complexes aggregate under certain conditions. We show here that aggregation can be prevented by omitting calcium from buffers or by using a sulfonated version of A8-35. A8-35 had previously been shown to protect Ca2+-ATPase from irreversible denaturation, while inhibiting its activity in a reversible manner. We show here that the other three amphipols tested also display these properties and that all four amphipols slow down backward calcium dissociation from the nonphosphorylated solubilized enzyme, a priori an unrelated step. As this calcium dissociation involves the opening up of the bundle of transmembrane ATPase segments, the slowing of this process may indicate that multipoint attachment of the polymers to the hydrophobic transmembrane surface damps protein dynamics ("Gulliver" effect). Damping might be the reason why amphipols also simultaneously protect membrane proteins against irreversible denaturation and may inhibit the activity of those of them that display large rearrangements of their transmembrane surface during their catalytic cycle.     

Amphipols and Photosynthetic Light-Harvesting Pigment-Protein Complexes

The trimeric light-harvesting complexes II (LHCII) of plants and green algae are pigment-protein complexes involved in light harvesting and photoprotection. Different conformational states have been proposed to be responsible for their different functions. At present, detergent-solubilized LHCII is used as a model for the “light-harvesting conformation”, whereas the “quenched conformation” is mimicked by LHCII aggregates. However, none of these conditions seem to perfectly reproduce the properties of LHCII in vivo. In addition, several monomeric LHC complexes are not fully stable in detergent. There is thus a need to find conditions that allow analyzing LHCs in vitro in stable and, hopefully, more native-like conformations. Here, we report a study of LHCII, the major antenna complex of plants, in complex with amphipols. We have trapped trimeric LHCII and monomeric Lhcb1 with either polyanionic or non-ionic amphipols and studied the effect of these polymers on the properties of the complexes. We show that, as compared to detergent solutions, amphipols have a stabilizing effect on LHCII. We also show that the average fluorescence lifetime of LHCII trapped in an anionic amphipol is ~30 % shorter than in α-dodecylmaltoside, due to the presence of a conformation with 230-ps lifetime that is not present in detergent solutions.     

Dynamics of membrane protein/amphipol association studied by Förster resonance energy transfer: implications for in vitro studies of amphipol-stabilized membrane proteins

Amphipols (APols) are short amphipathic polymers that can substitute for detergents to keep membrane proteins (MPs) water-soluble while stabilizing them biochemically. We have examined the factors that determine the size and dispersity of MP/APol complexes and studied the dynamics of the association, taking as a model system the transmembrane domain of Escherichia coli outer membrane protein A (tOmpA) trapped by A8-35, a polyacrylate-based APol. Molecular sieving indicates that the solution properties of the APol largely determine those of tOmpA/APol complexes. Achieving monodispersity depends on using amphipols that themselves form monodisperse particles, on working in neutral or basic solutions, and on the presence of free APols. In order to investigate the role of the latter, a fluorescently labeled version of A8-35 has been synthesized. F?rster resonance energy transfer measurements show that extensive dilution of tOmpA/A8-35 particles into an APol-free medium does not entail any detectable desorption of A8-35, even after extended periods of time (hours-days). The fluorescent APol, on the other hand, readily exchanges for other surfactants, be they detergent or unlabeled APol. These findings are discussed in the contexts of sample optimization for MP solution studies and of APol-mediated MP functionalization.     

Amphipol-assisted folding of bacteriorhodopsin in the presence or absence of lipids: functional consequences

Amphipols are short amphipathic polymers designed to stabilize membrane proteins in aqueous solutions in the absence of detergent. Bacteriorhodopsin (BR), a light-driven proton pump, has been denatured, either by direct solubilization of the purple membrane in sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS) solution or by a procedure that involves delipidation with organic solvent followed by transfer to SDS, and renatured in amphipol A8-35. The effect of different renaturation procedures and of the presence or absence of lipids and the cofactor retinal have been investigated. The resulting samples have been characterized by absorbance spectroscopy, size-exclusion chromatography, thermostability measurements, and determination of photocycle kinetics. Transfer to A8-35 can be achieved by SDS precipitation, dilution, or dialysis, the first route resulting in the highest yield of refolding. Functional BR can be refolded whether in the presence or absence of lipids, higher yields being achieved in their presence. Retinal is not required for the protein to refold, but it stabilizes the refolded form and, thereby, improves folding yields. Lipids are not required for BR to perform its complete photocycle, but their presence speeds up the return to the ground state. Taken together, these data indicate that a membrane or membrane-mimetic environment is not required for correct decoding of the chemical information contained in the sequence of BR; functional folding is possible even in the highly foreign environment of lipid-free amphipols. BR interactions with lipids, however, contribute to an effective photocycle.     

The Use of Amphipols for Solution NMR Studies of Membrane Proteins: Advantages and Constraints as Compared to Other Solubilizing Media

Solution-state nuclear magnetic resonance studies of membrane proteins are facilitated by the increased stability that trapping with amphipols confers to most of them as compared to detergent solutions. They have yielded information on the state of folding of the proteins, their areas of contact with the polymer, their dynamics, water accessibility, and the structure of protein-bound ligands. They benefit from the diversification of amphipol chemical structures and the availability of deuterated amphipols. The advantages and constraints of working with amphipols are discussed and compared to those associated with other non-conventional environments, such as bicelles and nanodiscs.     

High water solubility and fold in amphipols of proteins with large hydrophobic regions: oleosins and caleosin from seed lipid bodies

Seed lipid bodies constitute natural emulsions stabilized by specialized integral membrane proteins, among which the most abundant are oleosins, followed by the calcium binding caleosin. These proteins exhibit a triblock structure, with a highly hydrophobic central region comprising up to 71 residues. Little is known on their three-dimensional structure. Here we report the solubilization of caleosin and of two oleosins in aqueous solution, using various detergents or original amphiphilic polymers, amphipols. All three proteins, insoluble in water buffers, were maintained soluble either by anionic detergents or amphipols. Neutral detergents were ineffective. In complex with amphipols the oleosins and caleosin contain more beta and less alpha secondary structures than in the SDS detergent, as evaluated by synchrotron radiation circular dichroism. These are the first reported structural results on lipid bodies proteins maintained in solution with amphipols, a promising alternative to notoriously denaturing detergents.     

The Use of Amphipols for NMR Structural Characterization of 7-TM Proteins

While amphipols have been proven useful for refolding of seven transmembrane helical (7-TM) proteins including G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) and it could be shown that an amphipol environment is in principle suitable for NMR structural studies of the embedded protein, high-resolution NMR insights into amphipol refolded and isotopically labeled GPCRs are still very limited. Here we report on the recent progress toward NMR structural studies of the melanocortin-2 and -4 receptors, two class A GPCRs which so far have not been reported to be incorporated into an amphipol environment. Making use of the established 7-TM protein bacteriorhodopsin (BR) we initially tested and optimized amphipol refolding conditions. Most promising conditions were transferred to the refolding of the two melanocortin receptors. Analytical-scale refolding experiments on the melanocortin-2 receptor show very similar behavior to the results obtained on BR. Using cell-free protein expression we could generate sufficient amounts of isotopically labeled bacteriorhodopsin as well as melanocortin-2 and -4 receptors for an initial NMR analysis. Upscaling of the amphipol refolding protocol to protein amounts needed for NMR structural studies was, however, not straightforward and impeded detailed NMR insights for the two GPCRs. While well-resolved and dispersed NMR spectra could only be obtained for bacteriorhodopsin, a comparison of NMR data recorded on the melanocortin-4 receptor in SDS and in an amphipol environment indicates that amphipol refolding induces larger structural modifications in the receptor.     

Solution NMR mapping of water-accessible residues in the transmembrane β-barrel of OmpX

The atomic structure of OmpX, the smallest member of the bacterial outer membrane protein family, has been previously established by X-ray crystallography and NMR spectroscopy. In apparent conflict with electrophysiological studies, the lumen of its transmembrane β-barrel appears too tightly packed with amino acid side chains to let any solute flow through. In the present study, high-resolution solution NMR spectra were obtained of OmpX kept water-soluble by either amphipol A8-35 or the detergent dihexanoylphosphatidylcholine. Hydrogen/deuterium exchange measurements performed after prolonged equilibration show that, whatever the surfactant used, some of the amide protons of the membrane-spanning region exchange much more readily than others, which likely reflects the dynamics of the barrel.     

Folding and stability of outer membrane protein A (OmpA) from Escherichia coli in an amphipathic polymer, amphipol A8-35

Amphipols are a class of amphipathic polymers designed to maintain membrane proteins in aqueous solutions in the absence of detergents. Denatured β-barrel membrane proteins, like outer membrane proteins OmpA from Escherichia coli and FomA from Fusobacterium nucleatum, can be folded by dilution of the denaturant urea in the presence of amphipol A8-35. Here, the folding kinetics and stability of OmpA in A8-35 have been investigated. Folding is well described by two parallel first-order processes, whose half-times, ~5 and ~70 min, respectively, are independent of A8-35 concentration. The faster process contributed ~55–64 % to OmpA folding. Folding into A8-35 was faster than into dioleoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers and complete at ratios as low as ~0.17 g/g A8-35/OmpA, corresponding to ~1–2 A8-35 molecules per OmpA. Activation energies were determined from the temperature dependence of folding kinetics, monitored both by electrophoresis, which reports on the formation of stable OmpA tertiary structure, and by fluorescence spectroscopy, which reflects changes in the environment of tryptophan side chains. The two methods yielded consistent estimates, namely ~5–9 kJ/mol for the fast process and ~29–37 kJ/mol for the slow one, which is lower than is observed for OmpA folding into dioleoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers. Folding and unfolding titrations with urea demonstrated that OmpA folding into A8-35 is reversible and that amphipol-refolded OmpA is thermodynamically stable at room temperature. Comparison of activation energies for folding and unfolding in A8-35 versus detergent indicates that stabilization of A8-35-trapped OmpA against denaturation by urea is a kinetic, not a thermodynamic phenomenon.     

Solution Behavior and Crystallization of Cytochrome bc 1 in the Presence of Amphipols

Detergents classically are used to keep membrane proteins soluble in aqueous solutions, but they tend to destabilize them. This problem can be largely alleviated thanks to the use of amphipols (APols), small amphipathic polymers designed to substitute for detergents. APols adsorb at the surface of the transmembrane region of membrane proteins, keeping them water-soluble while stabilizing them bio-chemically. Membrane protein/APol complexes have proven, however, difficult to crystallize. In this study, the composition and solution properties of complexes formed between mitochondrial cytochrome bc ₁ and A8-35, the most extensively used APol to date, have been studied by means of size exclusion chromatography, sucrose gradient sedimentation, and small-angle neutron scattering. Stable, monodisperse preparations of bc ₁/A8-35 complexes can be obtained, which, depending on the medium, undergo either repulsive or attractive interactions. Under crystallization conditions, diffracting three-dimensional crystals of A8-35-stabilized cytochrome bc ₁ formed, but only in the concomitant presence of APol and detergent.     

Determination of the molecular mass and dimensions of membrane proteins by size exclusion chromatography

Size exclusion chromatography is an established technique for the determination of hydrodynamic volumes of proteins or protein complexes. When applied to membrane proteins, the contribution of the detergent micelle, which is required to keep the protein soluble in the aqueous phase, needs to be determined to obtain accurate measurements for the protein. In a detergent series, in which the detergents differ only by the length of the alkyl chain, the contribution of the detergent micelle to the hydrodynamic volume is variable, whereas the contribution of the protein is constant. By using this approach, several parameters of membrane proteins can be estimated by extrapolation, such as the radius at the midpoint of the membrane, the average radius, the Stokes radius, and the excluded volume. The molecular mass of the protein can be determined by two independent measurements that arise from the behaviour of the free detergent micelle and protein-detergent micelle during size exclusion chromatography and the determination of the detergent-protein ratio. Determining the dimensions of protein-detergent micelles may facilitate membrane protein purification and crystallization by defining the accessibility of the protein surface.