Suitability of Different Protein A-Gold Markers for Immunogold-Silver Staining in Paraffin Sections

An incubation protocol to immunolabel Lowicryl semithin sections was applied to paraffin probes. To improve the labeling density, colloidal gold complexes of different preparations and sizes were compared. The type of colloidal gold preparation used was found to affect the specificity of the immunostaining. Gold colloid of 5 nm diameter particle size prepared with white phosphorus minimized nonspecific background labeling of β-casein in paraffin embedded sections of the mammary epithelium of pregnant mice. Gold colloids of 5 nm and 9 nm diameter particle size prepared in varying concentrations of tannic acid generated significant nonspecific staining in similar tissue preparations.     

Effect of particle size on labeling density for catalase in protein A-gold immunocytochemistry

Effect of particle size on labeling intensity in protein A-gold immunocytochemistry was studied. Catalase labeling of rat liver peroxisomes was used as a labeling model. Ultra-thin sections of Lowicryl K4M-embedded rat liver were stained for catalase with protein A-gold (pAg) probes. Five different sizes of colloidal gold probes, from 5 nm to 38 nm in diameter, were prepared. Labeling intensity decreased as the particle size of the pAg probes increased. The highest labeling was obtained by the 5-nm pAg probe and the lowest by the 38-nm pAg probe. Quantitative analysis also showed that labeling density was inversely proportional to the size of gold particles. The results suggest that the pAg probe with small gold particles has high sensitivity.     

Pitfalls of immunogold labeling: analysis by light microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, and photoelectron microscopy

The immunogold method is widely used to localize, identify, and distinguish cellular antigens. There are, however, some pitfalls that can lead to nonspecific binding, particularly in cytoskeletal studies with gold probes prepared from small gold particles. We present a list of suggestions for minimizing nonspecific binding, with particular attention to two problems identified in this study. First, we find that the method used to prepare the colloidal gold particles affects the degree of nonspecific binding. Second, the standard BSA-stabilized small gold probes evidently possess exposed regions that bind to the proteins of cytoskeletal preparations. This was investigated in whole-mount cytoskeletal preparations of cultured cells by use of light microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, and photoelectron microscopy of silver-enhanced specimens. Gold probes were made from approximately 5-nm particles generated by reduction of HAuCl4 with three different reducing agents: white phosphorus, sodium borohydride, and citrate-tannic acid. All three preparations stabilized in the conventional way showed significant levels of nonspecific binding, which was highest with citrate-tannic acid. This problem was largely solved with all three types of probes by including fish gelatin in the probe buffer, by substituting fish gelatin for the BSA stabilizer used to prepare the probes, or by pre-adsorption methods. Application of these techniques resulted in clear immunogold labeling patterns with minimal nonspecific background.     

Sizing of protein A-colloidal gold probes for immunoelectron microscopy

Gold particles in colloidal solutions often vary considerably in size. The finest sols (diameter less than 15 nm), especially, are very heterogeneous, as is indicated by coefficients of variance (CV) of 25- 35%. We have complexed staphylococcal protein A with gold particles (PA/Au) and then fractionated the preparations by glycerol or sucrose gradient centrifugation into very homogeneous subfractions. In this way, PA/Au probes of almost any size between 4.5 and 15 nm could be prepared. The variation of the gold particles in these fractions resulted in CV's between 9 and 16%. The reactivity of the PA/Au complex was not affected by the gradient procedure, as was shown by single- and double-labeling immunocytochemistry of ultrathin cryosections of rat pancreatic tissue.     

Immunolabeling efficiency of protein A-gold complexes

A systematic study of the adsorption of protein A on colloidal gold particles varying in size from 5-16 nm was performed at different protein concentrations. The number of protein A molecules bound per colloidal particle was evaluated and the Scatchard analysis of the adsorption parameters was applied for each size of the colloid. The binding of protein A to the colloidal gold surface exhibited the same affinity pattern for all of the particle sizes. At low concentrations of stabilizing protein, adsorption took place with high affinity (Kd 1.96-3.3 nM) and the maximum number of protein A molecules attached with this affinity correlated well with the surface of the particle. At higher concentrations of protein A, adsorption exhibited a significantly lower affinity (Kd 530-800 nM), and no saturation was recorded. Competition by albumin did not reveal a preferential removal of the "low-affinity" bound protein A molecules, contradicting the model of successive shells of stabilizing protein around the colloidal particle. The immunolabeling efficiency of conjugates having the same size of gold nucleus but carrying different numbers of protein A molecules was comparatively investigated by quantitative post-embedding immunocytochemistry. Protein A-gold formed with 5-10-nm colloids gave the highest intensity of labeling when carrying the maximum number of protein A molecules that could be adsorbed with high affinity. Overloading as well as underloading these complexes resulted in a significant decrease of their immunoreactivity. The most efficient conjugates were obtained when stabilization was performed with 6 micrograms protein A/ml gold sol of 5 and 10 nm particle diameter, and 15 micrograms protein/ml of 15-nm colloid.     

Cationic colloidal gold--a new probe for the detection of anionic cell surface sites by electron microscopy

Particles of colloidal gold were coated with poly-L-lysine to prepare cationic colloidal gold. Monodispersed colloidal gold with a particle diameter of 5, 8, or 15 nm and poly-L-lysine with a molecular weight of 350,000 or 1500-8000 were used. The resulting complexes were used to label red blood cell membranes. The labeling was sensitive to neuraminidase treatment or acid hydrolysis, demonstrating that cationic colloidal gold binds preferentially to anionic cell surface constituents. Cationic colloidal gold can be used at physiological pH values and ionic strength, as well as at low pH values, making it a flexible probe for detection of anionic cellular components.     

Analysis of colloidal gold probes by isoelectric focusing in agarose gels

Colloidal gold particles of different size (3-20 nm in diameter) were prepared by tannic acid-citrate and citrate reduction methods. From these colloids, different probes were prepared using sheep anti-rabbit antiserum, sheep anti-rabbit IgG, bovine serum albumin, polyethylene glycol, and protein A as the primary stabilizers and polyethylene glycol and/or bovine serum albumin as secondary and tertiary stabilizers, in different combinations. The probes were analyzed by isoelectric focusing in agarose gels, which allow the migration of particles in the size range 3-20 nm. (P. Sewer and S. J. Hayes, 1986, Anal. Biochem. 158, 72-78). Isoelectric focusing revealed that the surface charge of colloidal gold probes is dependent upon the size of the gold particle, the reduction method used, the primary ligand, and the pH at which this is adsorbed, as well as upon the secondary and tertiary stabilizers used. It is proposed that such differences in surface charge may underlie the different results which may sometimes be observed in colloidal gold labeling, especially when novel ligands are used.     

Effective diameters of protein A-gold and goat anti-rabbit-gold conjugates visualized by field emission scanning electron microscopy.

High-voltage (15-30 kV) field emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM) was used to evaluate the effects of gold particle size and protein concentration on the formation of protein-gold complexes. Six colloidal gold sols were prepared, ranging in diameter from 7.6 to 39.8 nm. The minimal protecting amounts (m.p.a.) of protein A and goat anti-rabbit antibody (GAR) were experimentally determined. Gold particles were conjugated at the m.p.a., one half the m.p.a., and ten times the m.p.a. for both proteins, and protein-gold complexes prepared for FESEM. The smallest colloidal gold particles required the most protein per milliliter of gold suspension for stabilization. Transmission electron microscopy was found to be the preferred method for accurate sizing of gold particles, whereas FESEM of protein-gold complexes permitted visualization of a protein halo around a spherical gold core. Protein halo width varied significantly with changes in gold particle size. Measurements of protein halos indicated that conjugation with the m.p.a. of protein A resulted in the thickest protein layers for all gold sizes. GAR conjugation with the m.p.a. again produced the thickest protein layers. However, GAR halos were significantly smaller than those obtained with protein A conjugation. The proteins used showed similar adsorption patterns for the larger gold particles. For smaller gold particles, proteins may act differently, and these complexes should be further characterized by low-voltage FESEM.     

Polymyxin B binding sites in Escherichia coli as revealed by polymyxin B-gold labeling

A complex of polymyxin B, bovine serum albumin, and colloidal gold was prepared and used for the ultrastructural localization of polymyxin B binding sites on thin sections of Epon-embedded Escherichia coli cells. Gold particles were found on the outer membrane of E. coli, which is consistent with reported biochemical findings. We concluded that gold labeling with polymyxin B is useful in localizing the binding sites of polymyxin.     

Post-embedding colloidal gold immunolocalization of laminin to the lamina rara interna, lamina densa, and lamina rara externa of renal glomerular basement membranes

Ultrastructural distribution of laminin within renal glomerular (GBM) and tubular basement membranes (TBM) was investigated using post-embedding immunolocalization with colloidal gold. Rat kidneys were fixed with 4% formaldehyde and embedded at 4 degrees C in Lowicryl K4M medium. Thin sections were then sequentially treated with affinity-purified rabbit anti-laminin IgG and anti-rabbit IgG conjugated to 10 nm diameter colloidal gold. Gold bound specifically to the GBM and TBM with particle densities of 690/micron2 and 731/micron2, respectively. In the GBM, the number of gold particles bound/micron2 of lamina densa greater than lamina rara externa greater than lamina rara interna. Closely similar binding patterns were found when kidneys were fixed with 0.5% glutaraldehyde plus 3% formaldehyde and embedded at 60 degrees C in L.R. White resin, but slightly less gold bound to sections overall than that seen with formaldehyde alone and Lowicryl. Taken together, these results illustrate that anti-laminin IgG, whether applied to fixed sections in vitro or introduced in vivo, bound to the lamina rara interna, lamina densa, and lamina rara externa of the GBM and throughout the TBM.     

Controlled growth of colloidal gold particles and implications for labelling efficiency

Summary A new method is reported for the preparation of colloidal gold particles with diameters ranging between 5 and 12 nm. The initial gold particle population, with an average diameter of 5.6±0.9 nm, is prepared by reduction of chloroauric acid with white phosphorous. An increase in particle diameter by growth is obtained by reduction of chloroauric acid with white phosphorous in the presence of colloidal gold particles. The labelling efficiency of these gold particles, conjugated with protein A, in indirect immunolabelling experiments is investigated by labelling of -galactosidase on ultrathin cryosections of Escherichia coli cells. We demonstrate that the labelling efficiency is at least dependent on particle diameter, probe concentration and preparation method. In addition it is shown, that with this new method, gold particle populations can be prepared with minor overlap in diameter spreading. Therefore these gold probes are suitable for qualitative double labelling experiments. The quantitative aspect of immunolabelling is discussed.     

Immunogold-silver staining method for light and electron microscopic detection of lymphocyte cell surface antigens with monoclonal antibodies

We used the immunogold-silver staining method (IGSS) for detection of lymphocyte cell surface antigens with monoclonal antibodies in light and electron microscopy and compared this procedure with the immunogold staining method. Two different sizes of colloidal gold particles (5 nm and 15 nm) were used in this study. Immunolabeling on cell surfaces was visualized as fine granules only by IGSS in light microscopy. The labeling density (silver-gold complexes/cell) and diameters of silver-enhanced gold particles on cell surfaces were examined by electron microscopy. Labeling density was influenced not by the enhancement time of the physical developer but by the size of the gold particles. However, the development of shells of silver-enhanced gold particles correlated with the enhancement time of the physical developer rather than the size of the colloidal gold particles. Five-nm gold particles enhanced with the physical developer for 3 min were considered optimal for this IGSS method because of reduced background staining and high specific staining in the cell suspensions in sheep lymph. Moreover, this method may make it possible to show the ultrastructure of identical positive cells detected in 1-micron sections counterstained with toluidine blue by electron microscopy, in addition to the percentage of positive cells by light microscopy.     

Silver-enhanced colloidal gold as a cell surface marker for photoelectron microscopy

Colloidal gold labeling in conjunction with silver enhancement was investigated as a labeling technique for photoelectron microscopy (PEM). PEM uses UV-stimulated electron emission to image uncoated cell surfaces, and markers for cell surfaces need to be sufficiently photoemissive to be clearly visible against this background. Label contrast provided by 6 nm or 20 nm colloidal gold markers alone was compared to that provided by 6 nm markers after silver enhancement, using both direct and indirect labeling methods for fibronectin on human fibroblast cell surfaces. In all cases, details of the fibrillar fibronectin labeling distribution which were barely discernible before silver enhancement became highly visible against the cellular surface features. Two factors evidently contribute to the pronounced increase in label contrast with silver enhancement: (1) Increased particle size, which was documented by transmission electron microscopy, and (2) increased photoemission resulting from a silver coating on the enhanced gold markers, compared with the protein coating on the unenhanced gold markers. These data demonstrate that silver enhancement of colloidal gold labeling patterns in PEM images is a highly effective method for localization of specific sites on cell surfaces.     

Electron microscopic immunocytochemistry. Silver enhancement of colloidal gold marker allows double labeling with the same primary antibody

Electron microscopic sections, immunocytochemically labeled with colloidal gold, can be prepared for double labeling by applying the "EM-silver enhancement" procedure. This method, a photographic, so-called physical, development, increases the size of the gold marker to a predeterminable value and thereby inactivates the anti-species antibody present on the gold grain, thus allowing the labeling of a second antigen with antibody raised in the same species.     

Coloidal gold, ferritin and peroxidase as markers for electron microscopic double labeling lectin techniques

Three markers, colloidal gold, ferritin and peroxidase, were checked for usefulness in double labeling of lectin-binding sites. The amount of various lectins for the stabilization of good sols of a different particle size was evaluated. Several lectin-gold complexes were prepared for electron microscopic labeling purposes, and the optimal amount of various lectins needed for stabilization of gold solutions of a different particle size was determined. The following combinations were investigated for their usefulness in labeling two different lectin-binding sites: lectin-gold and lectin-gold (different particle size), lectin-gold and lectin-ferritin, as well as lectin-ferritin and lectin-peroxidase. Of these combinations the latter did not give satisfactory results for double labeling. In all single and double labeling techniques with the above mentioned markers the quantitative evaluation of the number of lectin-binding sites is not feasible, but these techniques will be of considerable value for the investigation of the dynamics of different lectin-binding sites on the cell surface.     

Colloidal gold probes in immunocytochemistry. An optimization of their application in light microscopy by use of silver intensification procedures

Colloidal gold particles are the markers of choice for ultrastructural localization of antigens. By reducing gold chloride with tannic acid and trisodium citrate, a broad range of narrowly determined particle sizes can be obtained. Such particles can easily be coupled to a number of proteins and the resulting conjugates are conveniently purified on a gel-chromatography column. Their application in light microscopy requires an amplification step with a silver physical developer. Silver-intensified colloidal gold probes can advantageously be used for immunostaining of cryostat, paraffin and plastic sections. Moreover, permeabilized cultured cells and whole-mount preparations can also be stained with gold-silver techniques. Silver intensification does not affect reactivity of a number of tissue antigens, thus permitting double staining combinations with immunoperoxidase or immunofluorescence methods.     

Enhancement of Antigenic Site Detection with Gold Labeled Secondary and Tertiary Antibodies Using the Immunogold-Silver Staining Method

We report a modification of the immunogold-silver staining method (IGSS) for localizing hepatic phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (PEPCK) in tissue sections, and we compare the efficacy of localizing the primary antibody with either a 5 nm gold labeled secondary antibody or 5 nm gold labeled secondary and tertiary antibodies. Light microscope examination of 10 μm frozen sections demonstrated that the use of combined secondary and tertiary gold labeled antibodies was superior to using a secondary gold labeled antibody alone. The increased labeling density (number of colloidal gold particles/antigenic site/cell) achieved by combined gold labeled antibodies was confirmed by electron microscopy. The increased labeling density resulted in a two-thirds reduction in the time needed for the IGSS physical development of the silver shells and less background. We achieved intense specific staining of hepatocytes expressing PEPCK while minimizing background staining. The use of combined secondary and tertiary gold labeled antibodies enhances the signal-to-noise ratio, achieves high resolution and is a suitable method for use in both light and electron microscopy.     

Comparison of detecting sensitivities of different sizes of gold particles with electron-microscopic immunogold staining using atrial natriuretic peptide in rat atria as a model

The detecting sensitivities of different-sized gold particles were compared in the localization of atrial natriuretic peptide (ANP) in rat atria. The secondary antibodies were goat antirabbit labeled with 5, 15, 30, or 40 nm colloidal gold diluted 1:2 to 1:100 in Tris buffer. The relative quantity of alpha-ANP immunoreactivity in specific granules was determined by subtracting the number of gold particles in 1 micron 2 nongranule area from that in 1 micron 2 granule area measured with a computerized image analyzer. The optimal dilution that achieved the maximal contrast between specific and background label was influenced by the particle size. Optimal dilutions were 1:80, 1:30, 1:20, and 1:5 for 5, 15, 30, and 40 nm gold, respectively. At optimal dilutions, the maximal detecting sensitivity (MDS) was in inverse proportion to the gold particle size; however, this relationship is not entirely linear. The ratio among the MDSs of 5, 15, 30, and 40 nm gold particles was approximately 34:9:3:2. A double immunogold staining was performed to localize alpha- and beta-ANPs with 15 and 5 nm gold, respectively. Both antigens were detected in the same granules. If the ratios established from the single staining data were used, the ratio between the alpha- and the beta-ANP antigens in the same granules was approximately 2.8:1. The data obtained in this study provide a useful reference for applications of immunogold electron microscopy in a quantitative manner, particularly for double immunogold labeling.     

Commercial preparations of colloidal gold-antibody complexes frequently contain free active antibody

Using a simple fluorescence test, we show that commercially prepared colloidal gold complexes with goat second antibodies often contain free active antibody. Because such antibodies will compete with antibody-colloidal gold particles for antigen binding sites, labeling intensity at the ultrastructural level must necessarily be submaximal to an unknown degree with such preparations. A survey of five preparations suggests that the problem may be widespread. We recommend that a test of the sort described be incorporated routinely into protocols with all colloidal gold products.     

Immunoelectron microscopic double labeling of alkaline phosphatase and penicillinase with colloidal gold in frozen thin sections of Bacillus licheniformis 749/C.

The subcellular distribution of alkaline phosphatase and penicillinase was determined by double labeling frozen thin sections of Bacillus licheniformis 749/C with colloidal gold-immunoglobulin G (IgG). Antipenicillinase and anti-alkaline phosphatase antibodies were used to prepare complexes with 5- and 15-nm colloidal gold particles, respectively. The character of the labeling of membrane-bound alkaline phosphatase and penicillinase was different: the immunolabels for alkaline phosphatase (15-nm particles) were bound to a few sites at the inner surface of the plasma membrane, and the gold particles formed clusters of various sizes at the binding sites; the immunolabels for penicillinase (5-nm particles), on the other hand, were bound to the plasma membrane in a dispersed and random fashion. In the cytoplasm, immunolabels for both proteins were distributed randomly, and the character of their binding was similar. The labeling was specific: pretreating the frozen thin sections with different concentrations of anti-alkaline phosphatase or penicillinase blocked the binding of the immunolabel prepared with the same antibody. Binding could be fully blocked by pretreatment with 800 micrograms of either antibody per ml.