Cell size and the initiation of DNA replication in bacteria

In eukaryotes, DNA replication is coupled to the cell cycle through the actions of cyclin-dependent kinases and associated factors. In bacteria, the prevailing view, based primarily from work in Escherichia coli, is that growth-dependent accumulation of the highly conserved initiator, DnaA, triggers initiation. However, the timing of initiation is unchanged in Bacillus subtilis mutants that are ~30% smaller than wild-type cells, indicating that achievement of a particular cell size is not obligatory for initiation. Prompted by this finding, we re-examined the link between cell size and initiation in both E. coli and B. subtilis. Although changes in DNA replication have been shown to alter both E. coli and B. subtilis cell size, the converse (the effect of cell size on DNA replication) has not been explored. Here, we report that the mechanisms responsible for coordinating DNA replication with cell size vary between these two model organisms. In contrast to B. subtilis, small E. coli mutants delayed replication initiation until they achieved the size at which wild-type cells initiate. Modest increases in DnaA alleviated the delay, supporting the view that growth-dependent accumulation of DnaA is the trigger for replication initiation in E. coli. Significantly, although small E. coli and B. subtilis cells both maintained wild-type concentration of DnaA, only the E. coli mutants failed to initiate on time. Thus, rather than the concentration, the total amount of DnaA appears to be more important for initiation timing in E. coli. The difference in behavior of the two bacteria appears to lie in the mechanisms that control the activity of DnaA.     

Control of the replication initiator DnaA by an anti-cooperativity factor

Proper coordination of DNA replication with cell growth and division is critical for production of viable progeny. In bacteria, coordination of DNA replication with cell growth is generally achieved by controlling activity of the replication initiator DnaA and its access to the chromosomal origin of replication, oriC. Here we describe a previously unknown mechanism for regulation of DnaA. YabA, a negative regulator of replication initiation in Bacillus subtilis, interacts with DnaA and DnaN, the sliding (processivity) clamp of DNA polymerase. We found that in vivo, YabA associated with the oriC region in a DnaA-dependent manner and limited the amount of DnaA at oriC. In vitro, purified YabA altered binding of DnaA to DNA by inhibiting cooperativity. Although previously undescribed, proteins that directly inhibit cooperativity may be a common mechanism for regulating replication initiation. Conditions that cause release of DnaN from the replisome, or overproduction of DnaN, caused decreased association of YabA and increased association of DnaA with oriC. This effect of DnaN, either directly or indirectly, is likely responsible, in part, for enabling initiation of a new round of replication following completion of a previous round.     

Role of DNA methylation at GATC sites in the dnaA promoter, dnaAp2

DnaA protein is required for the initiation of DNA replication at the bacterial chromosomal origin, oriC, and at the origins of many plasmids. The concentration of DnaA protein is an important factor in determining when initiation occurs during the cell cycle. Methylation of GATC sites in the dnaAp2 promoter, two of which are in the -35 and -10 sequences, has been predicted to play an important role in regulating dnaA gene expression during the cell cycle because the promoter is sequestered from methylation immediately following replication. Mutations that eliminate these two GATC sites but do not substantially change the activity of the promoter were introduced into a reporter gene fusion and into the chromosome. The chromosomal mutants are able to initiate DNA replication synchronously at both moderately slow and fast growth rates, demonstrating that GATC methylation at these two sites is not directly involved in providing the necessary amount of DnaA for precise timing of initiation during the cell cycle. Either sequestration does not involve these GATC sites, or cell cycle control of DnaA expression is not required to supply the concentration necessary for correct timing of initiation.     

Stable nucleotide binding to DnaA requires a specific glutamic acid residue within the AAA+ box II motif

In complex with ATP, but not ADP, DnaA protein multimers unwind a specific region of duplex DNA within the chromosomal replication origin, oriC, triggering a series of reactions that result in initiation of DNA replication. Following replication initiation, ATP hydrolysis, which is coupled to DNA replication, results in the generation of initiation-incompetent ADP-DnaA. Suppression of overinitiation of replication requires that ADP-DnaA complexes be stably maintained until the next round of replication. Thus, the functional and structural requirements that ensure stable nucleotide binding to DnaA are crucial for proper regulation of replication. Here, we demonstrate that Glu143 of DnaA, located within the AAA+ box II N-linker motif, is a key residue involved in stable nucleotide binding. A Glu143 substitution variant of DnaA (DnaA E143A) bound to ADP on ice with an affinity similar to wild-type DnaA, but the resultant ADP-DnaA E143A complex was more labile at 37 °C than wild-type ADP-DnaA complexes. Consistent with this, conversion of ADP-DnaA E143A to ATP-DnaA E143A was stimulated at 37°C in the presence of ATP, which also stimulated replication of a minichromosome in an in vitro reconstitution reaction. Expression of DnaA E143A in vivo inhibited cell growth in an oriC-dependent manner, suggesting that DnaA E143A caused over-initiation of replication, consistent with the in vitro results. Glu is a highly conserved residue at the corresponding position of γ-proteobacterial DnaA orthologs. Our finding of the novel role for the DnaA N-linker region may represent a conserved function of this motif among those DnaA orthologs.     

The DnaA protein determines the initiation mass of Escherichia coli K-12

DNA replication was studied in a dnaA(Ts) strain containing a plasmid with the dnaA+ gene under plac control. At 42 degrees C, initiation of DNA replication was totally dependent upon the gratuitous inducer isopropyl beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG). Flow cytometric measurements showed that at 13% induction of the lac promoter the growth rate, cell size, DNA content, and timing of initiation of DNA replication were indistinguishable from those observed in a wild-type control cell. Higher levels of induction resulted in initiations earlier in the cell cycle and a corresponding increase in the time from initiation to termination. We conclude that the concentration of DnaA protein determines the time of initiation and thereby the initiation mass. With an induction level equal to or above 13%, the synchrony of multiple initiations within one cell was close to that found in a wild-type control cell, showing that a cyclic variation in DnaA content is not necessary for a high degree of synchrony.     

Regulated degradation of chromosome replication proteins DnaA and CtrA in Caulobacter crescentus

DnaA protein binds bacterial replication origins and it initiates chromosome replication. The Caulobacter crescentus DnaA also initiates chromosome replication and the C. crescentus response regulator CtrA represses chromosome replication. CtrA proteolysis by ClpXP helps restrict chromosome replication to the dividing cell type. We report that C. crescentus DnaA protein is also selectively targeted for proteolysis but DnaA proteolysis uses a different mechanism. DnaA protein is unstable during both growth and stationary phases. During growth phase, DnaA proteolysis ensures that primarily newly made DnaA protein is present at the start of each replication period. Upon entry into stationary phase, DnaA protein is completely removed while CtrA protein is retained. Cell cycle arrest by sudden carbon or nitrogen starvation is sufficient to increase DnaA proteolysis, and relieving starvation rapidly stabilizes DnaA protein. This starvation-induced proteolysis completely removes DnaA protein even while DnaA synthesis continues. Apparently, C. crescentus relies on proteolysis to adjust DnaA in response to such rapid nutritional changes. Depleting the C. crescentus ClpP protease significantly stabilizes DnaA. However, a dominant-negative clpX allele that blocks CtrA degradation, even when combined with a clpA null allele, did not decrease DnaA degradation. We suggest that either a novel chaperone presents DnaA to ClpP or that ClpX is used with exceptional efficiency so that when ClpX activity is limiting for CtrA degradation it is not limiting for DnaA degradation. This unexpected and finely tuned proteolysis system may be an important adaptation for a developmental bacterium that is often challenged by nutrient-poor environments.     

Robust control of initiation of prokaryotic chromosome replication: essential considerations for a minimal cell

A genomically and chemically detailed mathematical model of a "minimal cell" would be useful to understand better the "design logic" of cellular regulation. A "minimal cell" will be a prokaryote with the minimum number of genes necessary for growth and replication in an ideal environment (i.e., preformed precursors, constant temperature, etc.). The Cornell single-cell model of Escherichia coli serves as the basic framework upon which a minimal cell model can be constructed. A critical issue for any cell model is to describe a mechanism for control of initiation of chromosome replication. There is strong evidence that the essence of chromosome replication control is highly conserved in eubacteria and even extends to the archae. A generalized mechanism is possible based on binding of the protein DnaA-ATP to the origin of replication (oriC) as a primary control. Other features, such as regulatory inactivation of DnaA (RIDA) by conversion of DnaA-ATP to DnaA-ADP and titration of DnaA by binding to other DnaA boxes on the chromosome, have emerged as critical elements in obtaining a functional system to control initiation of chromosome synthesis. We describe a biologically realistic model of chromosome replication initiation control embedded in a complete whole-cell model that explicitly links the external environment to the mechanism of replication control. The base model is deterministic and then modified to include stochastic variation in the components for replication control. The stochastic model allows evaluation of the model's robustness, employing a low standard deviation of interinitiation time as a measure of robustness. Four factors were examined: DnaA synthesis rate; DnaA-ATP binding sites at oriC; the binding rate of DnaA-ATP to the nonfunctional DnaA boxes; and the effect of changing the number of nonfunctional binding sites. The observed DnaA synthesis rate (2000 molecules/cell) and the number of DnaA binding sites per origin (30) are close to the values predicted by the model to provide good control (low variance of interinitiation time), with a reasonable expenditure of cell resources. At relatively high binding rates for DnaA-ATP to the DnaA boxes (10(16) M(-1) s(-1)), increasing the number of DnaA binding sites to about 300, improved control (but little further improvement was seen by extension to 1000 boxes); however, at a low binding rate (10(10) M(-1) s(-1)), an increase in DnaA boxes had an adverse effect on control. The combination of all four factors is probably necessary to obtain a robust control system. Although this mechanism of replication initiation control is highly conserved, it is not clear if simpler control in a minimal cell might exist based on experimental observations with Mycoplasma. This issue is discussed in this investigation.     

Two oppositely oriented arrays of low-affinity recognition sites in oriC guide progressive binding of DnaA during Escherichia coli pre-RC assembly

The onset of chromosomal DNA replication requires highly precise and reproducible interactions between initiator proteins and replication origins to assemble a pre-replicative complex (pre-RC) that unwinds the DNA duplex. In bacteria, initiator protein DnaA, bound to specific high- and low-affinity recognition sites within the unique oriC locus, comprises the pre-RC, but how complex assembly is choreographed to ensure precise initiation timing during the cell cycle is not well understood. In this study, we present evidence that higher-order DnaA structures are formed at oriC when DnaA monomers are closely positioned on the same face of the DNA helix by interaction with two oppositely oriented essential arrays of closely spaced low-affinity DnaA binding sites. As DnaA levels increase, peripheral high-affinity anchor sites begin cooperative loading of the arrays, which is extended by sequential binding of additional DnaA monomers resulting in growth of the complexes towards the centre of oriC. We suggest that this polarized assembly of unique DnaA oligomers within oriC plays an important role in mediating pre-RC activity and may be a feature found in all bacterial replication origins.     

Restoration of growth to acidic phospholipid-deficient cells by DnaA(L366K) is independent of its capacity for nucleotide binding and exchange and requires DnaA

In the absence of adequate levels of cellular acidic phospholipids, Escherichia coli remain viable but are arrested for growth. Expression of a DnaA protein that contains a single amino acid substitution in the membrane-binding domain, DnaA(L366K), in concert with expression of wild-type DnaA protein, restores growth. DnaA protein has high affinity for ATP and ADP, and in vitro lipid bilayers that are fluid and contain acidic phospholipids reactivate inert ADP-DnaA by promoting an exchange of ATP for ADP. Here, nucleotide and lipid interactions and replication activity of purified DnaA(L366K) were examined to gain insight into the mechanism of how it restores growth to cells lacking acidic phospholipids. DnaA(L366K) behaved like wild-type DnaA with respect to nucleotide binding affinities and hydrolysis properties, specificity of acidic phospholipids for nucleotide release, and origin binding. Yet, DnaA(L366K) was feeble at initiating replication from oriC unless augmented with a limiting quantity of wild-type DnaA, reflecting the in vivo requirement that both wild-type and a mutant form of DnaA must be expressed and act together to restore growth to acidic phospholipid deficient cells.     

Arrest of cell division and nucleoid partition by genetic alterations in the sliding clamp of the replicase and in DnaA

In Escherichia coli, an interaction between the replication initiator DnaA and the sliding clamp protein, the beta subunit (DnaN) of DNA polymerase III, is required to regulate the chromosomal replication cycle. We report here that colony formation by, and cell division of, the temperature (42 degrees C)-sensitive dnaN59 mutant are inhibited at 34-35 degrees C when DnaA is moderately (4-to 8-fold ) overexpressed, although chromosomal replication and the beta subunit-dependent regulation of DnaA activity are not significantly inhibited. Immunoblotting analysis revealed that the beta subunit is abundant (present at a level of about 5000 dimers per cell) at 34 degrees C, and its concentration per unit cell volume was practically unaffected in the dnaN59 mutant by the overexpression of DnaA. The dnaN mutant cells that overexpress DnaA become filamentous at 34 degrees C via an sfiA-independent pathway, different from that activated by the SOS response. This filamentation is accompanied by inhibition of nucleoid partition and FtsZ ring formation. In the dnaN59 mutant, oversupply of DnaA may disturb the coordinated action of cell cycle-regulating molecules, thus leading to the inhibition of these events.     

Mutations in DnaA protein suppress the growth arrest of acidic phospholipid-deficient Escherichia coli cells

Cell growth arrests when the concentrations of anionic phospholipids drop below a critical level in Escherichia coli, with the insufficient amounts of acidic phospholipids adversely affecting the DnaA-dependent initiation of DNA replication at the chromosomal origin (oriC). Mutations have been introduced into the carboxyl region of DnaA, including the portion identified as essential for productive in vitro DnaA-acidic phospholipid interactions. Expression of DnaA proteins possessing certain small deletions or substituted amino acids restored growth to cells deficient in acidic phospholipids, whereas expression of wild-type DnaA did not. The mutations include substitutions and deletions in the phospholipid-interacting domain as well as some small deletions in the DNA-binding domain of DnaA. Marker frequency analysis indicated that initiation of replication occurs at or near oriC in acidic phospholipid- deficient cells rescued by the expression of DnaA having a point mutation in the membrane-binding domain, DnaA(L366K). Flow cytometry revealed that expression in wild-type cells of plasmid-borne DnaA(L366K) and DnaA(Delta363-367) reduced the frequency with which replication was initiated and disturbed the synchrony of initiations.     

A robust screen for novel antibiotics: specific knockout of the initiator of bacterial DNA replication

We have developed a novel type of a positive screen for the discovery of antibacterial compounds that target the Escherichia coli replication initiator protein DnaA. DnaA is an essential replication protein, conserved in (almost) all bacteria--including all human pathogens--and no existing antibiotics target the main components of the DNA replication machinery. This makes DnaA an attractive target and compounds discovered by this screen will constitute a new group of antibiotics. The conditional mutant, dnaA219, has a cold sensitive phenotype due to overreplication. In the screen, a DnaA inhibitor will reduce DnaA overactivity and thus restore growth at the nonpermissive temperature. This positive type of selection utilizes the rare phenomenon of lethal overactivity. In addition, the mutant strain has been made independent of DnaA activity by introduction of an alternative initiation pathway that allows growth under conditions of complete knockdown of DnaA. The resulting dnaA219rnhA strain is the basis of a robust, cell-based assay amenable to high-throughput screening. The screening assay has been validated against (1) a library of microbial fermentation extracts and (2) a known intracellular DnaA inhibitor.     

The Escherichia coli SeqA protein destabilizes mutant DnaA204 protein

In wild-type Escherichia coli cells, initiation of DNA replication is tightly coupled to cell growth. In slowly growing dnaA204 (Ts) mutant cells, the cell mass at initiation and its variability is increased two- to threefold relative to wild type. Here, we show that the DnaA protein concentration was two- to threefold lower in the dnaA204 mutant compared with the wild-type strain. The reason for the DnaA protein deficiency was found to be a rapid degradation of the mutant protein. Absence of SeqA protein stabilized the DnaA204 protein, increased the DnaA protein concentration and normalized the initiation mass in the dnaA204 mutant cells. During rapid growth, the dnaA204 mutant displayed cell cycle parameters similar to wild-type cells as well as a normal DnaA protein concentration, even though the DnaA204 protein was highly unstable. Apparently, the increased DnaA protein synthesis compensated for the protein degradation under these growth conditions, in which the doubling time was of the same order of magnitude as the half-life of the protein. Our results suggest that the DnaA204 protein has essentially wild-type activity at permissive temperature but, as a result of instability, the protein is present at lower concentration under certain growth conditions. The basis for the stabilization in the absence of SeqA is not known. We suggest that the formation of stable DnaA-DNA complexes is enhanced in the absence of SeqA, thereby protecting the DnaA protein from degradation.     

Three distinct chromosome replication states are induced by increasing concentrations of DnaA protein in Escherichia coli.

The DnaA protein concentration in Escherichia coli was increased above the wild-type level by inducing a lacP-controlled dnaA gene located on a plasmid. In these cells with different DnaA protein levels, we measured several parameters: dnaA gene expression; cell size, amount of DNA per cell, and number of origins per cell by flow cytometry; and origin-to-terminus ratio and the frequencies of five other markers on the chromosome by Southern hybridization. The response of the cells to higher levels of DnaA protein could be divided into three states. From the normal level to a level 1.5-fold higher, DnaA protein had little effect on dnaA gene expression and the rate of DNA replication but led to nearly proportional increases in DNA and origin concentrations. Between 1.5- and 3-fold, the normal DnaA protein concentration, dnaA gene expression was gradually decreased. In this interval, the origin concentration increased significantly; however, the replication rate was severely affected, becoming slower--especially near the origin--the higher the DnaA protein concentration, and as a result, the DNA concentration was constant. Further increases in the DnaA protein concentration did not lead to an increased origin concentration. Thus, the initiation mass was set by the DnaA protein from the normal level to an at least twofold-increased level, but the increased initiation did not lead to a large increase in the amount of DNA per unit of mass because of the inhibition of replication fork velocity.     

Soj/ParA stalls DNA replication by inhibiting helix formation of the initiator protein DnaA

Control of DNA replication initiation is essential for normal cell growth. A unifying characteristic of DNA replication initiator proteins across the kingdoms of life is their distinctive AAA+ nucleotide-binding domains. The bacterial initiator DnaA assembles into a right-handed helical oligomer built upon interactions between neighbouring AAA+ domains, that in vitro stretches DNA to promote replication origin opening. The Bacillus subtilis protein Soj/ParA has previously been shown to regulate DnaA-dependent DNA replication initiation; however, the mechanism underlying this control was unknown. Here, we report that Soj directly interacts with the AAA+ domain of DnaA and specifically regulates DnaA helix assembly. We also provide critical biochemical evidence indicating that DnaA assembles into a helical oligomer in vivo and that the frequency of replication initiation correlates with the extent of DnaA oligomer formation. This work defines a significant new regulatory mechanism for the control of DNA replication initiation in bacteria.