Degenerate oligonucleotide gene shuffling (DOGS) and random drift mutagenesis (RNDM): two complementary techniques for enzyme evolution

Improvement of the biochemical characteristics of enzymes has been aided by misincorporation mutagenesis and DNA shuffling. Many gene shuffling techniques result predominantly in the regeneration of unshuffled (parental) molecules. We describe a procedure for gene shuffling using degenerate primers that allows control of the relative levels of recombination between the genes that are shuffled, and reduces the regeneration of unshuffled parental genes. This shuffling procedure avoids the use of endonucleases for gene fragmentation prior to shuffling and allows the inclusion of random mutagenesis of selected portions of the chimeric genes as part of the procedure. We illustrate the use of the shuffling technique with a family of beta-xylanase genes that possess widely different G+C contents. In addition, we introduce a new method (RNDM) for rapid screening of mutants from libraries where no adaptive selection has been imposed on the cells. They are identified only by their retention of enzymatic activity. The combination of RNDM followed by DOGS allows a comprehensive exploration of a protein's functional sequence space.     

Extending the diversity of cytochrome P450 enzymes by DNA family shuffling

The cytochrome P450 enzymes involved in xenobiotic metabolism are an excellent starting point for the directed evolution of novel biocatalysts due to their wide substrate specificity. A shuffled library of three highly homologous mammalian genes (for P450 2C9, P450 2C11 and P450 2C19) was constructed by applying a modified DNA family shuffling procedure. The modifications made to the traditional DNA shuffling protocols involved non-random digestion via the use of different combinations of restriction enzymes (REs) followed by isolation of fragments under 300 bp by size-selective filtration. Shuffled cytochrome P450 mutants were co-expressed in Escherichia coli with their redox partner, NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase (NPR). We report here how non-random fragmentation may help in chimeragenesis within the areas of low sequence similarity such as substrate recognition sites (SRSs) that are generally underrepresented in recombination using the random fragmentation process. Size-selective filtration was used to limit recovery of incompletely digested fragments and consequently minimize the chances for contamination of the shuffled library with parental forms. No parental forms could be detected in the shuffled library using restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis, suggesting the library was free of parental contamination. Sequencing of randomly selected mutants demonstrated a high level of chimeragenesis with on average of 8.0+/-2.2 crossovers and a low level of mutagenesis with 5.2+/-2.8 spontaneous mutations per approximately 1.5 kbp of the full-length P450 sequence. The proportion of properly folded protein as indicated by the observation of characteristic Fe(II).CO vs. Fe(II) difference spectra was 15% (4/27) of analysed mutants. Screening of the shuffled library for indole oxidation revealed four clones with similar or higher levels of indigo pigment production to those of the parental P450s and two clones with elevated P450 expression. In this paper we present a method for the effective family shuffling of cytochrome P450 enzymes, applicable to the creation of mutant libraries with expanded metabolic diversity and with a significant proportion of functional clones.     

Improvement of the movement and host range properties of a plant virus vector through DNA shuffling

Virus expression vectors based on the tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) genome are powerful tools for foreign gene expression in plants. However, the inclusion of increased genetic load in the form of foreign genes limits the speed of systemic plant invasion and host range of these vectors due to reduced replication and movement efficiencies. To improve these properties of TMV vectors, the gene encoding the 30-kDa movement protein was subjected to mutagenesis and DNA shuffling. A vector that expresses the green fluorescent protein was used to allow simple visual discrimination of mutants with enhanced movement phenotypes. An initial round of mutagenesis produced 53 clones with a faster local movement phenotype. Two subsequent rounds of DNA shuffling produced additional clones that showed further increased rates of cell-to-cell movement and degrees of systemic invasion in restrictive hosts. Surprisingly, sequence analysis of the best performing shuffled genes revealed alterations resulting in coding and silent changes in the movement protein gene. Separation of these coding and silent alterations into distinct gene backgrounds revealed that each contributes to improved movement protein function to differing degrees. The resulting vectors demonstrate that the complex activities of the movement protein genes of viruses can be evolved to have improved movement phenotypes, as evidenced by cell-to-cell and systemic invasion. The experiments produced improved vectors that will be of use both for in planta functional screening and for therapeutic protein production and demonstrated the power of shuffling for plant virus vector improvement.     

DNA改组技术在水蛭素实验进化中的应用

蛋白质的改造是生物工程的重大研究课题.由于结构和功能预测的不精确性,而使按照三维结构信息进行定位诱变往往达不到预期的目的.近年来,另一条改造蛋白质的途径有较大的发展,即在实验室条件下模拟生物分子的自然进化,通过变异和靶功能的选择来获得改进性能的蛋白质[1],此过程称为生物分子实验定向进化.DNA改组(DNAshuffling)是一种改造基因和蛋白质的有效实验进化技术[2].它是在体外进行基因随机片段的重组,从而增加基因的多样性,促使有利变异与不利变异分离,通过选择使有利变异得到优化组合[3].DNA改组包含3个步骤:基因的随机片段化,自身引发PCR和重组合PCR.经过DNA改组的突变体库有可能选择到性能更优的突变体.为进行亲和淘选,需将突变体展示在噬菌体的表面[4].     

Prospecting metagenomic enzyme subfamily genes for DNA family shuffling by a novel PCR-based approach

DNA family shuffling is a powerful method for enzyme engineering, which utilizes recombination of naturally occurring functional diversity to accelerate laboratory-directed evolution. However, the use of this technique has been hindered by the scarcity of family genes with the required level of sequence identity in the genome database. We describe here a strategy for collecting metagenomic homologous genes for DNA shuffling from environmental samples by truncated metagenomic gene-specific PCR (TMGS-PCR). Using identified metagenomic gene-specific primers, twenty-three 921-bp truncated lipase gene fragments, which shared 64-99% identity with each other and formed a distinct subfamily of lipases, were retrieved from 60 metagenomic samples. These lipase genes were shuffled, and selected active clones were characterized. The chimeric clones show extensive functional and genetic diversity, as demonstrated by functional characterization and sequence analysis. Our results indicate that homologous sequences of genes captured by TMGS-PCR can be used as suitable genetic material for DNA family shuffling with broad applications in enzyme engineering.     

DNA shuffling method for generating highly recombined genes and evolved enzymes

We introduce a method of in vitro recombination or "DNA shuffling" to generate libraries of evolved enzymes. The approach relies on the ordering, trimming, and joining of randomly cleaved parental DNA fragments annealed to a transient polynucleotide scaffold. We generated chimeric libraries averaging 14.0 crossovers per gene, a several-fold higher level of recombination than observed for other methods. We also observed an unprecedented four crossovers per gene in regions of 10 or fewer bases of sequence identity. These properties allow generation of chimeras unavailable by other methods. We detected no unshuffled parental clones or duplicated "sibling" chimeras, and relatively few inactive clones. We demonstrated the method by molecular breeding of a monooxygenase for increased rate and extent of biodesulfurization on complex substrates, as well as for 20-fold faster conversion of a nonnatural substrate. This method represents a conceptually distinct and improved alternative to sexual PCR for gene family shuffling.     

In vitro rapid evolution of fungal immunomodulatory proteins by DNA family shuffling

Fungal immunomodulatory proteins (FIPs) found in a wide variety of mushrooms hold significant therapeutic potential. Despite much research, the structural determinants for their immunomodulatory functions remain unknown. In this study, a DNA shuffling technique was used to create two shuffled FIP protein libraries: an intrageneric group containing products of shuffling between FIP-glu (FIP gene isolated from Ganoderma lucidum) and FIP-gsi (FIP gene isolated from Ganoderma sinense) genes and an intergeneric group containing the products of shuffling between FIP-glu, FIP-fve (FIP gene isolated from Flammulina velutipes), and FIP-vvo (FIP gene isolated from Volvariella volvacea) genes. The gene shuffling generated 426 and 412 recombinant clones, respectively. Using colony blot analysis, we selected clones that expressed relatively high levels of shuffled gene products recognized by specific polyclonal antibodies. We analyzed the DNA sequences of the selected shuffled genes, and testing of their protein products revealed that they maintained functional abilities to agglutinate blood cells and induce cytokine production by splenocytes from Kunming mice in vitro. Meanwhile, the relationships between protein structure and the hemagglutination activity and between the changed nucleotide sites and expression levels were explored by bioinformatic analysis. These combined analyses identified the nucleotide changes involved in regulating the expression levels and hemagglutination activities of the FIPs. Therefore, we were able to generate recombinant FIPs with improved biological activities and expression levels by using DNA shuffling, a powerful tool for the generation of novel therapeutic proteins and for their structural and functional studies.     

Analysis of shuffled gene libraries

In vitro recombination of homologous genes (family shuffling) has been proposed as an effective search strategy for laboratory evolution of genes and proteins. Few data are available, however, on the composition of shuffled gene libraries, from which one could assess the efficiency of recombination and optimize protocols. Here, probe hybridization is used in a macroarray format to analyze chimeric DNA libraries created by DNA shuffling. Characterization of hundreds of shuffled genes encoding dioxygenases has elucidated important biases in the shuffling reaction. As expected, crossovers are favored in regions of high sequence identity. A sequence-based model of homologous recombination that captures this observed bias was formulated using the experimental results. The chimeric genes were found to show biases in the incorporation of sequences from certain parents, even before selection. Statistically different patterns of parental incorporation in genes expressing functional proteins can help to identify key sequence-function relationships.     

Genome shuffling of Lactobacillus for improved acid tolerance

Fermentation-based bioprocesses rely extensively on strain improvement for commercialization. Whole-cell biocatalysts are commonly limited by low tolerance of extreme process conditions such as temperature, pH, and solute concentration. Rational approaches to improving such complex phenotypes lack good models and are especially difficult to implement without genetic tools. Here we describe the use of genome shuffling to improve the acid tolerance of a poorly characterized industrial strain of Lactobacillus. We used classical strain-improvement methods to generate populations with subtle improvements in pH tolerance, and then shuffled these populations by recursive pool-wise protoplast fusion. We identified new shuffled lactobacilli that grow at substantially lower pH than does the wild-type strain on both liquid and solid media. In addition, we identified shuffled strains that produced threefold more lactic acid than the wild type at pH 4.0. Genome shuffling seems broadly useful for the rapid evolution of tolerance and other complex phenotypes in industrial microorganisms.     

拟南芥K+转运蛋白AtKup1基因的DNA改组

采用同源重组法制备钾离子转运蛋白TRK1和TRK2缺失的酿酒酵母钾营养缺陷型,通过RNA 反转录PCR方法从拟南芥幼根扩增获得片段长度为2139bp 的Atkup1基因,以此片段为模板,采用DNA 改组技术,经Dnase I降解,Primerless PCR , PrimerPCR,建立Atkup1 基因突变库。将突变库和未经DNA 重排处理的Atkup1基因分别构建酵母穿梭载体导入K+转运蛋白基因TRK1和TRK2缺失的酿酒酵母中,分别在低钾(5.0mM KCl)不含色氨酸的培养基上筛选转化子, 突变基因库酵母转化子中获得2株长势明显好于Atkup1 基因转化子的突变基因转化菌株,菌株质粒上的突变Atkup1基因核苷酸测序结果发现突变基因Atkup1发生2个碱基的置换,造成2个氨基酸的改变,转化烟草烟叶化学成分分析证实突变基因的吸钾活性显著提高。     

Modeling DNA shuffling.

In vitro evolution is a new, important laboratory method to evolve molecules with desired properties. It has been used in a variety of biological studies and drug development. In this paper, we study one important mutagenesis method used in in vitro evolution experiments called DNA shuffling. We construct a mathematical model for DNA shuffling and study the properties of molecules after DNA shuffling experiments based on this model. The model for DNA shuffling consists of two parts. First we apply the Lander-Waterman model for physical mapping by fingerprinting random clones to model the distribution of regions that can be reassembled through DNA shuffling. Then we present a model for recombination between different DNA species with different mutations. We compare our theoretical results with experimental data. Finally we propose novel applications of the theoretical results to the optimal design of DNA shuffling experiments and to physical mapping using DNA shuffling.     

Functional analysis of the plant disease resistance gene Pto using DNA shuffling

Pto is a serine/threonine kinase that mediates resistance in tomato to strains of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato expressing the (a)virulence proteins AvrPto or AvrPtoB. DNA shuffling was used as a combinatorial in vitro genetic approach to dissect the functional regions of Pto. The Pto gene was shuffled with four of its paralogs from a resistant haplotype to create a library of recombinant products that was screened for interaction with AvrPto in yeast. All interacting clones and a representative sample of noninteracting clones were sequenced, and their ability to signal downstream was tested by the elicitation of a hypersensitive response in an AvrPto-dependent or -independent manner in planta. Eight candidate regions important for binding to AvrPto or for downstream signaling were identified by statistical correlations between individual amino acid positions and phenotype. A subset of the regions had previously been identified as important for recognition, confirming the validity of the shuffling approach. Three novel regions important for Pto function were validated by site-directed mutagenesis. Several chimeras and point mutants exhibited a differential interaction with (a)virulence proteins in the AvrPto and VirPphA family, demonstrating distinct binding requirements for different ligands. Additionally, the identification of chimeras that are both constitutively active as well as capable of binding AvrPto indicates that elicitation of downstream signaling does not involve a conformational change that precludes binding of AvrPto, as previously hypothesized. The correlations between phenotypes and variation generated by DNA shuffling paralleled natural variation observed between orthologs of Pto from Lycopersicon spp.     

An effective family shuffling method using single-stranded DNA

Family shuffling, which is one of the most powerful techniques for in vitro protein evolution, always involves the problem of reassembling the gene fragments into parental gene sequences, because such a process prevents the formation of chimeric sequences. In order to improve the efficiency of hybrid formation in family shuffling, single-stranded DNAs (ssDNAs) were used as templates. The ssDNAs of two catechol 2,3-dioxygenase genes, nahH and xylE, were prepared, the xylE strand being complementary to the nahH strand. When these ssDNAs were digested by DNase I and reassembled, chimeric genes were obtained at a rate of 14%, which was much higher than the rate of less than 1% obtained by shuffling with double-stranded DNAs. Chimeric catechol 2,3-dioxygenases that were more thermally stable than the parental enzymes, XylE and NahH, were obtained by this ssDNA-based DNA shuffling.     

Evolution of a cytokine using DNA family shuffling.

DNA shuffling of a family of over 20 human interferon-alpha (Hu-IFN-alpha) genes was used to derive variants with increased antiviral and antiproliferation activities in murine cells. A clone with 135,000-fold improved specific activity over Hu-IFN-alpha2a was obtained in the first cycle of shuffling. After a second cycle of selective shuffling, the most active clone was improved 285,000-fold relative to Hu-IFN-alpha2a and 185-fold relative to Hu-IFN-alpha1. Remarkably, the three most active clones were more active than the native murine IFN-alphas. These chimeras are derived from up to five parental genes but contained no random point mutations. These results demonstrate that diverse cytokine gene families can be used as starting material to rapidly evolve cytokines that are more active, or have superior selectivity profiles, than native cytokine genes.     

Optimization of DNA shuffling for high fidelity recombination.

A convenient 'DNA shuffling' protocol for random recombination of homologous genes in vitro with a very low rate of associated point mutagenesis (0.05%) is described. In addition, the mutagenesis rate can be controlled over a wide range by the inclusion of Mn2+or Mg2+during DNase I digestion, by choice of DNA polymerase used during gene reassembly as well as how the genes are prepared for shuffling (PCR amplification versus restriction enzyme digestion of plasmid DNA). These protocols should be useful for in vitro protein evolution, for DNA based computing and for structure-function studies of evolutionarily related genes.     

Construction of a chimeric aminopeptidase by a combination of gene shuffling and mutagenesis

Three chimeric genes were constructed by gene shuffling of aminopeptidases from Aeromonas caviae and Vibrio proteolyticus. Although expressed chimeric enzymes formed inclusion bodies in Escherichia coli, the introduction of two amino acid mutations into the chimeric genes by site-saturated mutagenesis and a random mutation on error-prone PCR resulted in solubilization of the chimeric enzyme. In addition, active chimeric enzyme showed a different thermostability and thermoactivity to parental enzymes.     

Breeding of retroviruses by DNA shuffling for improved stability and processing yields

Manufacturing of retroviral vectors for gene therapy is complicated by the sensitivity of these viruses to stress forces during purification and concentration. To isolate viruses that are resistant to these manufacturing processes, we performed breeding of six ecotropic murine leukemia virus (MLV) strains by DNA shuffling. The envelope regions were shuffled to generate a recombinant library of 5 x 106 replication-competent retroviruses. This library was subjected to the concentration process three consecutive times, with amplification of the surviving viruses after each cycle. Several viral clones with greatly improved stabilities were isolated, with the best clone exhibiting no loss in titer under conditions that reduced the titers of the parental viruses by 30- to 100-fold. The envelopes of these resistant viruses differed in DNA and protein sequence, and all were complex chimeras derived from multiple parents. These studies demonstrate the utility of DNA shuffling in breeding viral strains with improved characteristics for gene therapy.     

Genome shuffling enhanced L-lactic acid production by improving glucose tolerance of Lactobacillus rhamnosus

Genome shuffling is a powerful strategy for rapid engineering of microbial strains for desirable industrial phenotypes. Here we applied the genome shuffling to improve the glucose tolerance of Lactobacillus rhamnosus ATCC 11443 while simultaneously enhancing the L-lactic acid production. The starting population was generated by ultraviolet irradiation and nitrosoguanidine mutagenesis and then subjected for the recursive protoplast fusion. The positive colonies from library created by fusing the inactivated protoplasts were more likely to be screened on plates containing different concentrations of high glucose and 2% CaCO(3). Characterization of all mutants and wild-type strain in the shake flask indicated the compatibility of two optimal phenotypes of glucose tolerance and lactic acid enhancement. The lactic acid production, cell growth and glucose consumption of the best performing strain from the second round genome shuffled populations were 71.4%, 44.9% and 62.2% higher than those of the wild type at the initial glucose concentration of 150 g/l in the 16l bioreactor. Furthermore, the higher lactic acid concentrations were obtained when the initial glucose concentrations increased to 160 and 200 g/l in batch fermentation.