Growth of Octopine-Catabolizing Pseudomonas spp. under Octopine Limitation in Chemostats and Their Potential To Compete with Agrobacterium tumefaciens

The growth characteristics of five octopine-catabolizing pseudomonads have been determined in batch and continuous cultures. All five strains belonged to rRNA homology group I and showed a more psychrotrophic growth pattern than did Agrobacterium tumefaciens B6 and ATCC 15955. In chemostats limited by octopine, either as the source of carbon and nitrogen or the sole source of nitrogen, maximum specific growth rates and substrate affinities were lower than those in chemostats limited by glutamate. These growth dynamics were similar to those observed for Agrobacterium strains B6 and ATCC 15955 even though the catabolic genes and pathways are believed to be different in the two genera. An analysis of the yields in octopine-limited chemostats indicated that the use of octopine as the sole source of carbon and nitrogen was grossly inefficient. Octopine and presumably lysopine and octopinic acid provided a better source of nitrogen than of carbon. One of the Pseudomonas fluorescens strains, E175D, was able to produce its highest yield on octopine as a nitrogen source. Competition models formulated on pure culture parameters indicated that two of the Pseudomonas spp. would dominate A. tumefaciens B6 and ATCC 15955 when in simple competition for octopine as a limiting substrate.     

Potential of Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Octopine-Utilizing Fluorescent Pseudomonas Strains To Attach to Susceptible Potato Tissues

The binding characteristics of two octopine-catabolizing pseudomonads, Pseudomonas fluorescens B99A and E175D, which were isolated from crown galls, have been examined. The binding of strain B99A to potato disks was very weak, followed a Freundlich isotherm, and was temperature and pH independent. Strain E175D displayed strong attachment and followed a Langmuir isotherm. Despite these fundamental differences in binding characteristics, when each strain was placed in competitive binding assays with either Agrobacterium tumefaciens B6 or A. tumefaciens ATCC 15955, the number of bound pseudomonad cells decreased compared with those obtained in independent trials. Furthermore, the binding of A. tumefaciens cells was increased. In prebinding experiments, in which the potato disks were bound with the pseudomonads before exposure to the agrobacteria, the number of bound pseudomonad cells again decreased. This implies that increased desorption was occurring. In these prebinding studies, the numbers of bound A. tumefaciens ATCC 15955 increased, but the number of bound A. tumefaciens B6 remained the same. The mechanism for this observed synergism on the binding of agrobacterial cells and the depression in bound pseudomonad cells is believed to be alterations in the electrostatic or ionic charges on the plant and bacterial cell surfaces. The synergistic effect on A. tumefaciens undermines the use of these pseudomonads as potential biocontrol agents for crown gall.     

Growth of Agrobacterium tumefaciens under octopine limitation in chemostats

Agrobacterium tumefaciens B6 and ATCC 15955 were grown under octopine or glutamate limitation in chemostats. Examination of the maximum specific growth rate (mu max) and substrate affinity (KS) for each strain indicated that strain B6 was highly inefficient in its use of octopine as either a nitrogen or carbon source compared with strain ATCC 15955. Examination of the yield coefficients showed that in both strains octopine was used more efficiently as a nitrogen source than as a carbon source. The data permitted predictions to be made concerning the outcome of competition for a single limiting substrate. Under octopine limitation, strain ATCC 15955 should dominate; under glutamate limitation, strain B6 should dominate. The results of an observed competition with glutamate as the limiting substrate confirmed the latter prediction, although B6 did dominate at a rate faster than was predicted from simple competition theory. B6 displayed higher growth rates and substrate affinities than ATCC 15955 on all concentrations of glutamate. The yield of B6 on octopine was also considerably higher. This latter attribute could provide an ecological advantage to B6 because of the importance of yield in the fate of competitions under multisubstrate regimens. These will be the most prevalent regimens in the area around the tumor (tumorosphere) or the rhizosphere. The increased performance on glutamate could provide an advantage in an opine-free environment when B6 is growing as a saprophyte.     

Growth of Agrobacterium tumefaciens under octopine limitation in chemostats.

Agrobacterium tumefaciens B6 and ATCC 15955 were grown under octopine or glutamate limitation in chemostats. Examination of the maximum specific growth rate (mu max) and substrate affinity (KS) for each strain indicated that strain B6 was highly inefficient in its use of octopine as either a nitrogen or carbon source compared with strain ATCC 15955. Examination of the yield coefficients showed that in both strains octopine was used more efficiently as a nitrogen source than as a carbon source. The data permitted predictions to be made concerning the outcome of competition for a single limiting substrate. Under octopine limitation, strain ATCC 15955 should dominate; under glutamate limitation, strain B6 should dominate. The results of an observed competition with glutamate as the limiting substrate confirmed the latter prediction, although B6 did dominate at a rate faster than was predicted from simple competition theory. B6 displayed higher growth rates and substrate affinities than ATCC 15955 on all concentrations of glutamate. The yield of B6 on octopine was also considerably higher. This latter attribute could provide an ecological advantage to B6 because of the importance of yield in the fate of competitions under multisubstrate regimens. These will be the most prevalent regimens in the area around the tumor (tumorosphere) or the rhizosphere. The increased performance on glutamate could provide an advantage in an opine-free environment when B6 is growing as a saprophyte.     

Genotypic variability of soybean response to agrobacterium strains harboring the ti or ri plasmids

Twenty four diverse cultivars of soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merrill) and three lines of its annual wild progenitor Glycine soja Sieb and Zucc. were tested for their response to Agrobacterium strains harboring either the Ti (tumor-inducing) plasmid (pTi) from Agrobacterium tumefaciens or the Ri (root-inducing) plasmid (pRi) from Agrobacterium rhizogenes following uniform wounding and inoculation. Based upon gall weight at 8 weeks postinfection, three G. max cultivars (Biloxi, Jupiter, and Peking) and one G. soja line, Plant Introduction (PI) 398.693B, were judged highly susceptible to A. tumefaciens strain A348 (pTiA6), ten genotypes moderately susceptible, 11 weakly susceptible, and two nonsusceptible. Of 26 genotypes inoculated with strain R1000 (pRiA4b), only seven responded in a clearly susceptible fashion by forming small, fleshy roots at internodal infection sites. Cotyledons excised from 1- or 3-day old seedlings of Peking and Biloxi cultivars also formed galls when infected in vitro with agrobacteria carrying either the Ti or Ri plasmid. Tumor lines established from cotyledon and stem galls induced by A. tumefaciens A348 (pTiA6) exhibited the T-DNA borne traits of phytohormone-independent growth and octopine synthesis. Additionally, DNA isolated from cultured tumors hybridized with labeled T-DNA probe.     

Specificity of Octopine Uptake by Rhizobium and Pseudomonas Strains

The octopine-utilizing strain Agrobacterium tumefaciens B6S3 and three nonagrobacteria which had the capacity to utilize this opine were compared for octopine uptake. The characteristics of uptake by Rhizobium meliloti A3 and strain B6S3 were similar. In both bacteria, uptake activity was inducible by octopine and by the related opine octopinic acid, and competition assays showed that these two opine substrates were accepted by the same uptake system with an equivalent affinity. Cells of Pseudomonas putida 203 accumulated octopine against a concentration gradient, and this activity was induced specifically by octopine. While strain 203 did not utilize octopinic acid, a spontaneous mutant with a combined capacity for octopine and octopinic acid utilization was obtained. Both opines induced octopine uptake by this mutant, but octopinic acid was not a substrate for the induced system. Thus, the Pseudomonas uptake system exhibited a different specificity for octopine than the corresponding Agrobacterium system. The nonfluorescent pseudomonad GU187j, which utilized the three related opines octopine, octopinic acid, and nopaline, was constitutive for octopine uptake. Strain GU187j possessed a system which accepted these three opines, but not arginine or ornithine, with a similar affinity.     

Characterization of the Opine-Utilizing Microflora Associated with Samples of Soil and Plants

Microorganisms utilizing an opine as the sole carbon source were recovered from crown gall tumors, soil, and surface-disinfected potato tubers. The effect of the opines octopine, nopaline, succinamopine, and mannopine as selective substrates was compared with that of the auxin indoleacetic acid. Selection on octopine and indoleacetic acid favored the fluorescent pseudomonads, whereas mannopine allowed the frequent recovery of agrobacteria. Coryneforms which utilized succinamopine or mannopine were detected in soil, but not in tumors. Fungi growing on succinamopine or mannopine and a mannopine-utilizing Pseudomonas putida were isolated from tumor and soil, respectively.     

In Vivo Synthesis of Crown Gall-specific Agrobacterium tumefaciens-directed Derivatives of Basic Amino Acids

Several kinds of primary sunflower (Helianthus annuus) crown gall tissues were established in tissue culture and then labeled in vivo with either [¹⁴C]arginine, [¹⁴C]histidine, [³H]lysine, or [³H]ornithine. Crown gall tissues incited by Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains that utilize octopine as a sole source of carbon or nitrogen for growth synthesized the four members of the N²-(1-carboxyethyl)-amino acid family: octopine, histopine, lysopine, and octopinic acid. Those tissues incited by A. tumefaciens strains that utilize nopaline synthesized nopaline and two new compounds, a lysine and an ornithine derivative (ornaline). A normal tissue culture, a habituated tissue culture, and a crown gall culture from a strain of the bacteria unable to utilize either octopine or nopaline did not synthesize any of the amino acid derivatives. We could not detect any other crown gall-specific derivatives of the four basic amino acids.     

Rp4 Promotion of Transfer of a Large Agrobacterium Plasmid Which Confers Virulence

Introduction of RP4 plasmid into Agrobacterium tumefaciens promotes the transfer on solid medium of large virulence-associated plasmids from virulent donor strains to a plasmidless avirulent recipient. Exconjugants were selected for the ability to utilize octopine or nopaline as the sole source of arginine, traits which are coded for by virulence-associated plasmids in the strains employed here. All exconjugants retained the arginine auxotrophy of the recipient strain, and were resistant to ampicillin and kanamycin, drugs to which RP4 confers resistance. Five exconjugant clones from one cross were shown by alkaline sucrose gradient analysis to contain both RP4 plasmid and the large virulence-associated plasmid of the donor strain. All five exconjugants exhibited virulence on carrot, sunflower and kalanchoe plants. These results indicate that virulence and the ability to degrade octopine are plasmid-borne traits in A. tumefaciens strains 15955 and A6, and extend the evidence that large plasmids in A. tumefaciens are vectors of virulence genes.     

Characterization of Exopolysaccharides Produced by Plant-Associated Fluorescent Pseudomonads

A total of 214 strains of plant-associated fluorescent pseudomonads were screened for the ability to produce the acidic exopolysaccharide (EPS) alginate on various solid media. The fluorescent pseudomonads studied were saprophytic, saprophytic with known biocontrol potential, or plant pathogenic. Approximately 10% of these strains exhibited mucoid growth under the conditions used. The EPSs produced by 20 strains were isolated, purified, and characterized. Of the 20 strains examined, 6 produced acetylated alginate as an acidic EPS. These strains included a Pseudomonas aeruginosa strain reported to cause a dry rot of onion, a strain of P. viridiflava with soft-rotting ability, and four strains of P. fluorescens. However, 12 strains of P. fluorescens produced a novel acidic EPS (marginalan) composed of glucose and galactose (1:1 molar ratio) substituted with pyruvate and succinate. Three of these strains were soft-rotting agents. Two additional soft-rotting strains of P. fluorescens produced a third acidic novel EPS composed of rhamnose, mannose, and glucose (1:1:1 molar ratio) substituted with pyruvate and acetate. When sucrose was present as the primary carbon source, certain strains produced the neutral polymer levan (a fructan) rather than an acidic EPS. Levan was produced by most strains capable of synthesizing alginate or the novel acidic EPS containing rhamnose, mannose, and glucose but not by strains capable of marginalan production. It is now evident that the group of bacteria belonging to the fluorescent pseudomonads is capable of elaborating a diverse array of acidic EPSs rather than solely alginate.     

Octopine Accumulation Early in Crown Gall Development is Progressive

A purification of octopine from crown gall tissue was developed to quantitate conversion of precursor [³H]arginine into [³H]octopine. Plant wound tissue which was sterile or infected with an avirulent strain of Agrobacterium tumefaciens did not accumulate detectable quantities of octopine, consistent with opine synthesis not being induced by wounding or infection. Octopine was only recovered from tissue infected with virulent tumor-inducing strains of A. tumefaciens. In every case tested, the morphological appearance of tumors preceded the accumulation of octopine by at least 1 week, and in some instances 3 weeks. Thus, what was necessary and sufficient for the expression of plant hormones (auxin and cytokinin) required for tumor growth was not sufficient for the accumulation of octopine. The possible nature of the temporal difference in the expression of hormone autotrophy and octopine synthesis is discussed.     

Characterization of an Unusual New Agrobacterium tumefaciens Strain from Chrysanthemum morifolium Ram

We characterized five isolates of Agrobacterium tumefaciens from naturally occurring galls on Chrysanthemum morifolium. The isolates are similar, possibly identical, members of a single strain of A. tumefaciens that we designate Chry5. The strain is a biotype I, as indicated by its response to both newly described and traditional biotype tests. Chry5 produces tumors on at least 10 plant species. It is unusual in its ability to form efficiently large tumors on soybean (Glycine max), a species normally refractory to transformation. Chry5 is unable to utilize octopine or mannopine as a carbon source. Although Chry5 can catabolize a single isomer each of nopaline and succinamopine, it differs from other known nopaline and succinamopine strains in its insensitivity to agrocin 84. This pattern of opine catabolism is unique among Agrobacterium strains examined to date. All five isolates of Chry5 contain at least two plasmids, one of which shares homology with pTiB6.     

Characteristics of teratomas regenerated in vitro from octopine-type crown gall

Crown galls induced by infection of tobacco plants with Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain C58-Cl(pTiB6S3) were excised and cultured in vitro. After about one year of culture on medium-lacking phytohormones, two noncloned lines spontaneously formed shoots. Leaf explants from shoots of tumor-line T5 were capable of growing on hormone-free medium, and the resulting mixture of organized and unorganized tissue synthesized octopine. Detached leaves from T5 shoots also synthesized octopine. These results establish that shoots from this octopine-type tumor contain transformed cells and are true crown-gall teratomas.     

Engineering Pseudomonas fluorescens for Biodegradation of 2,4-Dinitrotoluene

Using the genes encoding the 2,4-dinitrotoluene degradation pathway enzymes, the nonpathogenic psychrotolerant rhizobacterium Pseudomonas fluorescens ATCC 17400 was genetically modified for degradation of this priority pollutant. First, a recombinant strain designated MP was constructed by conjugative transfer from Burkholderia sp. strain DNT of the pJS1 megaplasmid, which contains the dnt genes for 2,4-dinitrotoluene degradation. This strain was able to grow on 2,4-dinitrotoluene as the sole source of carbon, nitrogen, and energy at levels equivalent to those of Burkholderia sp. strain DNT. Nevertheless, loss of the 2,4-dinitrotoluene degradative phenotype was observed for strains carrying pJS1. The introduction of dnt genes into the P.fluorescens ATCC 17400 chromosome, using a suicide chromosomal integration Tn5-based delivery plasmid system, generated a degrading strain that was stable for a long time, which was designated RE. This strain was able to use 2,4-dinitrotoluene as a sole nitrogen source and to completely degrade this compound as a cosubstrate. Furthermore, P. fluorescens RE, but not Burkholderia sp. strain DNT, was capable of degrading 2,4-dinitrotoluene at temperatures as low as 10°C. Finally, the presence of P. fluorescens RE in soils containing levels of 2,4-dinitrotoluene lethal to plants significantly decreased the toxic effects of this nitro compound on Arabidopsis thaliana growth. Using synthetic medium culture, P. fluorescens RE was found to be nontoxic for A.thaliana and Nicotiana tabacum, whereas under these conditions Burkholderia sp. strain DNT inhibited A.thaliana seed germination and was lethal to plants. These features reinforce the advantageous environmental robustness of P. fluorescens RE compared with Burkholderia sp. strain DNT.     

Culturability and Expression of Outer Membrane Proteins during Carbon, Nitrogen, or Phosphorus Starvation of Pseudomonas fluorescens DF57 and Pseudomonas putida DF14

Changes in culturability and outer membrane protein profiles were investigated in Pseudomonas fluorescens DF57 and Pseudomonas putida DF14 during starvation for carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus. P. fluorescens DF57 remained fully culturable for 4 days in all starvation regimes. The cell mass increased during starvation for nitrogen and phosphorus, indicating the accumulation of storage compounds, whereas it decreased slightly in carbon-starved cells. P. putida DF14 lost culturability during phosphorus starvation, and the mass of phosphate-starved cells did not increase. Analysis of additional P. fluorescens and P. putida strains, however, showed that the ability to preserve culturability during phosphorus starvation was not species but strain dependent. In DF57, an outer membrane protein of 55 kDa appeared during starvation for phosphorus, while another protein of 63 kDa was seen during all starvation conditions. DF14 induced two outer membrane proteins of 28 and 29 kDa during starvation for carbon and nitrogen, but no phosphorus-specific starvation protein could be detected. Therefore, starvation-induced outer membrane proteins do not seem to be conserved among the fluorescent pseudomonads and a unique starvation response might be found in individual strains.     

Genetic isolation and physical characterization of pAgK84, the plasmid responsible for agrocin 84 production

The plasmid responsible for agrocin 84 biosynthesis by Agrobacterium radiobacter strain K84 has been genetically isolated free from any opine-catabolic plasmids. This was accomplished by mobilizing the agrocin plasmid, pAgK84, into a Ti plasmid-free A. tumefaciens strain, A136. The mobilizing element, pAt84a, was then cured from such a transconjugant by cultivation at 37 °C. Derivatives of strain A136 harboring both plasmids or pAgK84 only produce agrocin 84. The agrocin plasmid isolated from these strains is indistinguishable by restriction endonuclease analysis from that in strain K84. A physical map of pAgK84 has been constructed with respect to six restriction endonucleases. The plasmid is cut only once by XbaI and twice by HpaI. Hybridization analysis shows that pAgK84 is closely related to pAtBo542a, a 25-Mdal plasmid from a virulent, agrocinogenic A. tumefaciens strain of European origin. Similar analyses indicate, however, that pAgK84 shows no detectable homology to octopine or nopaline-type Agrobacterium plasmids.     

Identification of Genomic Species in Agrobacterium Biovar 1 by AFLP Genomic Markers

Biovar 1 of the genus Agrobacterium consists of at least nine genomic species that have not yet received accepted species names. However, rapid identification of these organisms in various biotopes is needed to elucidate crown gall epidemiology, as well as Agrobacterium ecology. For this purpose, the AFLP methodology provides rapid and unambiguous determination of the genomic species status of agrobacteria, as confirmed by additional DNA-DNA hybridizations. The AFLP method has been proven to be reliable and to eliminate the need for DNA-DNA hybridization. In addition, AFLP fragments common to all members of the three major genomic species of agrobacteria, genomic species G1 (reference strain, strain TT111), G4 (reference strain, strain B6, the type strain of Agrobacterium tumefaciens), and G8 (reference strain, strain C58), have been identified, and these fragments facilitate analysis and show the applicability of the method. The maximal infraspecies current genome mispairing (CGM) value found for the biovar 1 taxon is 10.8%, while the smallest CGM value found for pairs of genomic species is 15.2%. This emphasizes the gap in the distribution of genome divergence values upon which the genomic species definition is based. The three main genomic species of agrobacteria in biovar 1 displayed high infraspecies current genome mispairing values (9 to 9.7%). The common fragments of a genomic species are thus likely “species-specific” markers tagging the core genomes of the species.     

Absolute stereochemistry of leucinopine,a crown gall opine

Crown gall tumors incited by Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain Bo542 have been reported to synthesize a tumor-specific substance identified as N-(1,3-dicarboxypropyl)-leucine (leucinopine), a compound with two centers of asymmetry. We report here evidence that leucinopine is indeed a crown gall opine, in that it is specifically catabolized by A. tumefaciens strains carrying the tumor-inducing plasmid pTi Bo542, as well as strains carrying closely related plasmids pTi AT1 and pTi AT4. We further report catabolism of leucinopine by the succinamopine-type strains A518, A519 and A532, carrying pTi EU6, pTi AT181 and pTi T10/73, respectively. Strains lacking any virulence plasmid, as well as those carrying octopine or nopaline type Ti plasmids or mannopine type Ri plasmids, did not catabolize leucinopine. On the basis of specificity of catabolism by bacteria carrying pTi Bo542, we conclude that the stereochemistry of natural leucinopine is l-threo, i.e. l^glu,l^leu. Such stereochemistry is novel in the opines known thus far: octopine, nopaline and succinamopine have d,l-stereochemistry: d^ala,l^arg (octopine), d^glu,l^arg (nopaline) and d^glu,l^asn (succinamopine).     

Promotion of crown-gall tumor growth by lysopine, octopine, nopaline, and carnosine

The growth of crown-gall tumors on primary bean leaves (Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv. “Pinto”) was promoted by the addition of d-lysopine, d-octopine, l-carnosine, or nopaline. Assayed on tumors induced by Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain B6, the relative activity was octopine = carnosine > lysopine nopaline; assayed on tumors induced by A. tumefaciens strain T-37, which induces tumors which form nopaline, the relative activity was nopaline = octopine = carnosine > lysopine. From one to three applications of carnosine or octopine gave equal additive increments in tumor growth, showing that a continual supply of these substances is required to maintain an increased rate of growth. At concentrations above 0.1 mm, pairs of these growth-promoting substances were less active than when applied singly. Inhibition of octopine-induced growth was obtained by applying 0.01 mm carnosine with 1 mm octopine and partial inhibition was obtained when carnosine was added 10 hr after octopine. Equimolar mixtures of lysopine, octopine, and carnosine, however, were at least as active in promoting tumor growth as any of the compounds added singly at equivalent concentrations. The activity of 0.1 to 0.5 mm lysopine, octopine, and carnosine was inhibited, respectively, by 1 mml-lysine, l-arginine, and l-histidine and this inhibition was limited in each case to the basic amino acid corresponding to that of the growth factor. Arginine fully inhibited octopine-induced tumor growth when applied as much as 6 hr after octopine, indicating that this inhibition was not due to prevention of octopine uptake. Although four separate substances were found which promoted tumor growth, the molecular specificity required for activity of each compound was high. Evidence is presented which suggests that a tumor growth-promoting substance extracted from tumorous leaves is a carnosine-like derivative of l-histidine.     

Virulence of Agrobacterium tumefaciens Strain A281 on Legumes

This study addresses the basis of host range on legumes of Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain A281, an l,l-succinamopine strain. We tested virulence of T-DNA and vir region constructs from this tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmid with complementary Ti plasmid regions from heterologous nopaline and octopine strains.