Combining sequence-based prediction methods and circular dichroism and infrared spectroscopic data to improve protein secondary structure determinations

Background  

A number of sequence-based methods exist for protein secondary structure prediction. Protein secondary structures can also be determined experimentally from circular dichroism, and infrared spectroscopic data using empirical analysis methods. It has been proposed that comparable accuracy can be obtained from sequence-based predictions as from these biophysical measurements. Here we have examined the secondary structure determination accuracies of sequence prediction methods with the empirically determined values from the spectroscopic data on datasets of proteins for which both crystal structures and spectroscopic data are available.     

The protein circular dichroism data bank, a Web-based site for access to circular dichroism spectroscopic data

The Protein Circular Dichroism Data Bank (PCDDB) is a newly released resource for structural biology. It is a web-accessible (http://pcddb.cryst.bbk.ac.uk) data bank for circular dichroism (CD) and synchrotron radiation circular dichroism (SRCD) spectra and their associated experimental and secondary metadata, with links to protein sequence and structure data banks. It is designed to provide a public repository for CD spectroscopic data on macromolecules, to parallel the Protein Data Bank (PDB) for crystallographic, electron microscopic, and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic data. Similarly to the PDB, it includes validation checking procedures to ensure good practice and the integrity of the deposited data. This paper reports on the first public release of the PCDDB, which provides access to spectral data that comprise standard reference datasets.     

Protein secondary structure from circular dichroism spectra

Circular dichroism spectra of proteins are extremely sensitive to secondary structure. Nevertheless, circular dichroism spectra should not be analyzed for protein secondary structure unless they are measured to at least 184 nm. Even if all the various types ofβ-turns are lumped together, there are at least 5 different types of secondary structure in a protein (α-helix, antiparallelβ-sheet, parallelβ-sheet,β-turn, and other structures not included in the first 4 categories). It is not possible to solve for these 5 parameters unless there are 5 equations. Singular value decomposition can be used to show that circular dichroism spectra of proteins measured to 200 nm contain only 2 pieces of information, while spectra measured to 190 nm contain about 4. Adding the constraint that the sum of secondary structures must equal 1 provides another piece of information, but even with this constraint, spectra measured to 190 nm simply do not analyze well for the 5 unknowns in secondary structure. Spectra measured to 184 nm do contain 5 pieces of information and we have used such spectra successfully to analyze a variety of proteins for their component secondary structures.     

Test of circular dichroism (CD) methods for crambin and CD-assisted secondary structure prediction of its homologous toxins

Methods that analyze protein circular dichroism (CD) spectra for fractions of secondary structure are evaluated for the plant protein crambin, which has a known high-resolution crystal structure. In addition, a two-step secondary structure prediction scheme is presented and used for the toxins homologous to crambin, shown by others to have secondary structures similar to crambin. The test of CD spectral analysis methods with the protein crambin employed two computer programs and several CD basis sets. Crambin's crystal structure, known to 0.945A resolution (Hendrickson, W.A., Teeter, M.M. Nature 290:107-113, 1981), allows accurate evaluation of results. Analysis with the protein spectra basis sets (Provencher, S.W., Gl?ckner, J. Biochemistry 20:33-37, 1981) as modified (Manavalan, P., Johnson, W.C., Jr. Anal. Biochem. 167:76-85, 1987) agreed most closely with crambin's crystal structure. This method was then applied to the CD spectra of the membrane-active toxins homologous to crambin (alpha 1- and beta-purothionin, phoratoxin A and B, and viscotoxin A3 and B). The new program SEQ (pronounced "seek") was developed to assign the secondary structure along the protein chain in a hierarchical fashion and applied to the plant toxins. The method constrained the secondary structure fractions to those from CD analysis and combined standard statistical methods with amphipathic helix location. Both CD-arrived secondary structure percentages and sequence assignment indicate that the viscotoxins are structurally most similar to crambin. Purothionin's secondary structure was predicted to be fundamentally similar to crambin's with a difference at the start of the first helix. This assignment agreed with Raman and NMR analyses of purothionin and lends validity to the method presented here. Differences from the NMR in the CD secondary structure fraction analysis for phoratoxin suggest interference in the CD from tryptophan residues.     

Determination of secondary structure of globular proteins using circular dichroism spectra

A ridge regression method is presented for prediction of the secondary structure of proteins by the circular dichroism spectra (CD) from 190 to 236 nm. Eight types of the secondary structure were calculated on a microcalculator. The method is based on the X-ray data of Kabsh and Sander. The teaching rule is constructed on CD spectra of 30 proteins of all structural classes of the globular proteins (alpha, alpha/beta, alpha + beta and beta-proteins). The errors of the methods are analysed by removing each protein from the reference set and analyzing its structure in terms of the remaining proteins. Correlation coefficients and root-mean square deviations between CD and X-ray data were: 0.99 and 0.03 for alpha-helix, 0.86 and 0.02 for 3(10)-helix, 0.92 and 0.06 for antiparallel beta-sheet, 0.86 and 0.03 for parallel beta-sheet, 0.94 and 0.01 for T3 beta-turn, 0.85 and 0.02 for other beta-turn, 0.84 and 0.03 for S-bends, 0.83 and 0.04 for "random" structure.     

Protein secondary structure analyses from circular dichroism spectroscopy: methods and reference databases

Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy has been a valuable method for the analysis of protein secondary structures for many years. With the advent of synchrotron radiation circular dichroism (SRCD) and improvements in instrumentation for conventional CD, lower wavelength data are obtainable and the information content of the spectra increased. In addition, new computation and bioinformatics methods have been developed and new reference databases have been created, which greatly improve and facilitate the analyses of CD spectra. This article discusses recent developments in the analysis of protein secondary structures, including features of the DICHROWEB analysis webserver.     

Accuracy of protein secondary structure determination from circular dichroism spectra based on immunoglobulin examples

Strong contribution of the aromatic amino acid side chain chromophores to the far-UV circular dichroism (CD) spectra substantially distorts a relatively weak CD signal originating from beta sheet, the main type of immunoglobulin secondary structure. In this study we compared the secondary structure calculated from the far-UV CD spectra with the X-ray data for three antibody Fab fragments. Calculations were performed with three different algorithms, using two sets of reference proteins. Low standard deviations between all six estimates indicate stable mathematical solutions. Despite pronounced differences in the shape and amplitude of the CD spectra, we found a strong correlation between CD and X-ray data in the secondary structure for every protein studied. The number and average length of the secondary structure elements estimated from the CD spectra closely resemble those of the X-ray data. Agreement between spectroscopic and crystallographic results demonstrates that modern methods of secondary structure calculation are resilient to distortions of the far-UV CD spectra of immunoglobulins caused by aromatic side chain chromophores.     

The optimization of protein secondary structure determination with infrared and circular dichroism spectra.

We have used the circular dichroism and infrared spectra of a specially designed 50 protein database [Oberg, K.A., Ruysschaert, J.M. & Goormaghtigh, E. (2003) Protein Sci. 12, 2015-2031] in order to optimize the accuracy of spectroscopic protein secondary structure determination using multivariate statistical analysis methods. The results demonstrate that when the proteins are carefully selected for the diversity in their structure, no smaller subset of the database contains the necessary information to describe the entire set. One conclusion of the paper is therefore that large protein databases, observing stringent selection criteria, are necessary for the prediction of unknown proteins. A second important conclusion is that only the comparison of analyses run on circular dichroism and infrared spectra independently is able to identify failed solutions in the absence of known structure. Interestingly, it was also found in the course of this study that the amide II band has high information content and could be used alone for secondary structure prediction in place of amide I.     

Concentration-independent estimation of protein secondary structure by circular dichroism: a comparison of methods

Estimation of a protein's secondary structure from its circular dichroism spectrum usually requires accurate knowledge of the concentration and pathlength of the sample. Two recently described methods avoid this problem by analysis of g-factor spectra (McPhie, Anal. Biochem. 293, 109-119) or scaling of relative intensities (Raussens et al., Anal. Biochem. 319, 114-121). Application of the two methods to the same samples shows that they can have similar efficacies. Calculation with the latter method is more rapid, but the performance of the former is maintained over reduced wavelength ranges.     

Using circular dichroism spectra to estimate protein secondary structure

Circular dichroism (CD) is an excellent tool for rapid determination of the secondary structure and folding properties of proteins that have been obtained using recombinant techniques or purified from tissues. The most widely used applications of protein CD are to determine whether an expressed, purified protein is folded, or if a mutation affects its conformation or stability. In addition, it can be used to study protein interactions. This protocol details the basic steps of obtaining and interpreting CD data, and methods for analyzing spectra to estimate the secondary structural composition of proteins. CD has the advantage that measurements may be made on multiple samples containing < or =20 microg of proteins in physiological buffers in a few hours. However, it does not give the residue-specific information that can be obtained by x-ray crystallography or NMR.     

Applicability of the fluorescence-detected circular dichroism method for the determination of the secondary structure of glucagon and albumin

The fluorescence detected circular dichroism (FDCD) spectra of dansyl-leucine are reported. These spectra were obtained with the use of an unique device. FDCD, circular dichroism (CD) and absorption spectra of dansyl-leucine are combined to calculate CD spectra of the dansyl group in the given environment. A new method for determination of the secondary protein structure from the CD spectra taking into account the contribution of tryptophan residues is proposed. This contribution is defined from FDCD. The secondary structure of glucagon and human serum albumin, all containing a single, fluorescent tryptophan, were analysed. A good correspondence between these results and those reported for glucagon structure were found, while the usual method (without determination on tryptophan contribution) leads to unsatisfactory results.     

A reference database for circular dichroism spectroscopy covering fold and secondary structure space

MOTIVATION: Circular Dichroism (CD) spectroscopy is a long-established technique for studying protein secondary structures in solution. Empirical analyses of CD data rely on the availability of reference datasets comprised of far-UV CD spectra of proteins whose crystal structures have been determined. This article reports on the creation of a new reference dataset which effectively covers both secondary structure and fold space, and uses the higher information content available in synchrotron radiation circular dichroism (SRCD) spectra to more accurately predict secondary structure than has been possible with existing reference datasets. It also examines the effects of wavelength range, structural redundancy and different means of categorizing secondary structures on the accuracy of the analyses. In addition, it describes a novel use of hierarchical cluster analyses to identify protein relatedness based on spectral properties alone. The databases are shown to be applicable in both conventional CD and SRCD spectroscopic analyses of proteins. Hence, by combining new bioinformatics and biophysical methods, a database has been produced that should have wide applicability as a tool for structural molecular biology.     

SOMCD: method for evaluating protein secondary structure from UV circular dichroism spectra

This article presents SOMCD, an improved method for the evaluation of protein secondary structure from circular dichroism spectra, based on Kohonen's self-organizing maps (SOM). Protein circular dichroism (CD) spectra are used to train a SOM, which arranges the spectra on a two-dimensional map. Location in the map reflects the secondary structure composition of a protein. With SOMCD, the prediction of beta-turn has been included. The number of spectra in the training set has been increased, and it now includes 39 protein spectra and 6 reference spectra. Finally, SOM parameters have been chosen to minimize distortion and make the network produce clusters with known properties. Estimation results show improvements compared with the previous version, K2D, which, in addition, estimated only three secondary structure components; the accuracy of the method is more uniform over the different secondary structures.     

CDtool-an integrated software package for circular dichroism spectroscopic data processing, analysis, and archiving

CDtool is a software package written to facilitate circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopic studies on both conventional lab-based instruments and synchrotron beamlines. It takes format-independent input data from any type of CD instrument, enables a wide range of standard and advanced processing methods, and, in a single user-friendly graphics-based package, takes raw data through the entire processing procedure and, importantly, uses data-mining techniques to retain in the final output all the information associated with the processing. It permits the facile comparison of data obtained from different instruments without the need for reformatting and displays it in graphical formats suitable for publication. It also includes the ability to automatically archive the processed data. This latter feature may be especially useful in light of recent funding institution directives with regard to data sharing and archiving and requirements for "good practice" and "traceability" within the pharmaceutical industry. In addition, CDtool includes a means of interfacing with protein data bank coordinate files and calculating secondary structures from them using alternate definitions and algorithms. This feature, along with a function that permits the facile production of new reference databases, enables the creation of specialized databases for secondary structural analyses of specific types of proteins. Thus the CDtool software not only enables rapid data processing and analyses but also includes many enhanced features not available in other CD data processing/analysis packages.     

Novel circular dichroism spectroscopic approach for detection of ligand binding of proteins: Avidin as example

Various globular proteins having low or no α-helical content exhibit atypical far-ultraviolet (UV) circular dichroism (CD) spectra due to aromatic-aromatic residue and aromatic residue-peptide bond exciton coupling interactions. As a representative example of such proteins, far-UV CD spectra of chicken avidin were recorded before and after the addition of different small molecules. Intensity increase-decrease and/or wavelength shift of the positive CD peak of avidin at 228 nm were observed in the presence of various drugs, dyes, and natural compounds. The results were interpreted by exciton interactions between the aromatic residues of the biotin binding site and the substances bound to it. This novel, fast, microgram (μg) scale approach can be applied for detection of ligand binding of additional proteins displaying avidin-like far-UV CD spectra.     

Going deep into protein secondary structure with synchrotron radiation circular dichroism spectroscopy

Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy is a fast, powerful, well-established, and widely used analytical technique in the biophysical and structural biology community to study protein secondary structure and to track changes in protein conformation in different environments. The use of the intense light of a synchrotron beam as the light source for collecting CD measurements has emerged as an enhanced method, known as synchrotron radiation circular dichroism (SRCD) spectroscopy, that has several advantages over the conventional CD method, including a significant spectral range extension for data collection, deeper access to the lower limit (cut-off) of conventional CD spectroscopy, an improved signal-to-noise ratio to increase accuracy in the measurements, and the possibility to collect measurements in highly absorbing solutions. In this review, we discuss different applications of the SRCD technique by researchers from Latin America. In this context, we specifically look at the use of this method for examining the secondary structure and conformational behavior of proteins belonging to the four main classes of the hierarchical protein domain classification CATH (Class, Architecture, Topology, Homology) database, focusing on the advantages and improvements associated with SRCD spectroscopy in terms of characterizing proteins composed of different structural elements.