T cell growth factor from human splenic cell cultures: conditions for its production, and its utilization for maintenance of cytotoxic T cell lines

We prepared the T cell growth factor (TCGF) from human spleen cell cultures stimulated with phytohemagglutinin (PHA). Various cell culture conditions and agents supporting the active TCGF production of the spleen cells were examined. The highest TCGF activity was obtained in the supernatants under the conditions that 2 x 10(6)/ml spleen cells were stimulated with PHA for 48 hr. Production of TCGF from spleen cells depended markedly on their individual sources. Addition of indomethacin to the culture or irradiation of the responding spleen cells increased TCGF activity in the supernatant of the culture. Further, addition of irradiated cells of an Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-transformed lymphoblastoid cell line (LCL) to spleen cell cultures stimulated with PHA greatly enhanced TCGF production. Human splenic TCGF facilitated the establishment of human cytotoxic T cell (Tc) lines specific for EBV-transformed LCL cells when those Tc line cells were stimulated periodically with irradiated autologous LCL cells but not with the other two types (K-562 or Molt-4) of cells. Allogeneic LCL stimulators allowed the Tc line cells to proliferate. However, Tc line cells cocultured once with allogeneic LCL stimulators no longer exhibited EBV-specificity in their cytotoxicities.     

Helper factor production in murine secondary syngeneic mixed leukocyte reactions

Culture supernatants of murine thymocytes or spleen cells responding in a secondary syngeneic mixed leukocyte reaction (SMLR) were studied for their biologic effects on cell-mediated immune responses in vitro. Such supernatants contained helper factor(s) that facilitated the development of alloantigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses from thymocyte precursors. Thymocytes, but not spleen cells, required activation by allogeneic effect factor (AEF) in primary culture in order to proliferate and produce biologically active mediator(s) during a secondary SMLR. The same culture supernatants possessed, in some instances, weak T cell growth factor (TCGF; IL 2) activity. However, TCGF activity could be dissociated from helper factor(s) active in the CTL induction assay because some culture supernatants that had potent helper activity were devoid of TCGF activity. This lack of TCGF activity was not due to a lower degree of sensitivity of the TCGF assay or to the presence of a selective TCGF inhibitor in the SMLR-derived supernatants, indicating that the helper factor(s) studied is distinct from TCGF. Production of immunoregulatory lymphokines during the SMLR may serve as a physiologically relevant model for studying the role of T cell-derived lymphokines in immunoregulation.     

Positively selected Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2- mouse T lymphocytes are comparable, after Con A stimulation, in release of IL 2 and of lymphokines acting on B cells, macrophages, and mast cells, but differ in interferon production

Purified mouse T lymphocytes were separated into Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2- populations by the procedure of panning, in which a monoclonal rat anti-Lyt-2 antibody and dishes coated with affinity-purified mouse anti-rat Ig antibodies were used. The populations obtained were 95 to 99% pure as determined by immunofluorescence. Graded doses of these T cells were cultured with optimal mitogenic doses of concanavalin A and the 0 to 24 and 24 to 48-hr culture supernatants were collected. The dose-curve assays of the supernatants of Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2- cells showed comparable activity in interleukin 2 (IL 2) and T cell-replacing factor (TRF), assayed on antigen-stimulated culture of T-depleted spleen cells. Limiting dilution assays of IL 2-secreting precursor cells stimulated by Con A showed a high frequency of precursors in both populations, slightly higher among Lyt-2- cells. The supernatants also contained comparable levels of IPA (inducer of plasminogen activator production by the macrophages), MAF (macrophage-activating factor, assayed by induction of their cytolytic function), and MCGF (mast cells growth factor, assayed on a mast cell line). IPA and MAF were not produced with the same kinetics and in the same T cell concentration conditions as IL 2 and TRF. In contrast, interferon was principally produced by the Lyt-2+ cells.     

Mechanism of T cell activation. II. Antigen- and lectin-dependent acquisition of responsiveness to TCGF is a nonmitogenic, active response of resting T cells

Small resting T cells, which do not respond to T cell growth factor (TCGF), acquire responsiveness upon a short (4-hr) pulse of specific ligands by presenting growth receptors for TCGF. The results demonstrate that the same mechanisms operate in the specific induction of primary MLR in that a 5-hr MLR is sufficient to render the responder cells reactive to TCGF. Furthermore, the results demonstrate that an active "response" by the resting T cells is required for expression of functional growth receptors, as demonstrated by the fact that: 1) a 4-hr pulse of concanavalin A (Con A) at 4 degrees C did not result in gain of reactivity to TCGF, whereas a 4-hr pulse at 37 degrees C did; 2) this metabolic requirement for acquisition of responsiveness to TCGF was not due to a secondary requirement for cap-formation of Con A-binding membrane structures, as normal responses were observed in the presence of cytochalasin B (cyt B); 3) the process of Con A-induced acquisition of susceptibility to TCGF was puromycin sensitive.     

Capacity of purified unprimed Lyt-2+ cells to reject Ia- H-2-different tumor cells in the Winn assay

To examine which cells participate in primary anti-H-2 responses to Ia- tumors in vivo, irradiated mice were injected intracutaneously with small doses of tumor cells mixed with purified populations of host-type lymphoid cells. Studies with three different Ia- H-2-different tumors showed that purified unprimed Lyt-2+ cells were highly efficient at suppressing tumor growth. Lyt-2+ cells were appreciably more effective at suppressing tumor growth than unseparated T cells, and no protection was seen with injection of L3T4+ cells (except in the late states of tumor growth). It is suggested that class I alloantigens on the tumors are directly immunogenic for Lyt-2+ cells. Without need for help from L3T4+ cells, the responding Lyt-2+ cells rapidly differentiate into cytotoxic cells and destroy the tumor cells before macroscopic tumors can arise.     

T-T interactions in the induction of antigen-specific human suppressor T lymphocytes in vitro.

We intended to investigate whether the suppression of antigen-induced antibody responses in vitro in man by T suppressor cells required contact of T suppressor cells with target cells or whether this effect was mediated by factors released by T suppressor cells. To this end supernatants of antigen-induced T suppressor cells were tested (by a plaque forming cell assay) for their capacity to suppress antibody responses of autologous and allogeneic human peripheral blood lymphocytes. We have shown that supernatants of antigen-specific T suppressor cells, designated as TsF24: a) can suppress an antibody response of autologous but not allogeneic lymphocytes to the inducing antigen; b) are antigen-specific in their effect; and 3) are produced by radiosensitive T cells. Furthermore, the target of the factor is a radiosensitive T cell. These findings taken together indicate that, in the generation of T-effector suppressor cells in man, T-T interactions occur, and in addition, that cellfree factors may be involved in these interactions.     

Class I restricted interaction between suppressor and cytolytic cells in the response to minor histocompatibility antigens

Inoculation of 10(8) unirradiated, minor H antigen-incompatible spleen cells into recipients leads to a failure of the induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) specific for these antigens. In contrast, a strong CTL response against minor H antigens is obtained when the inoculated cells are irradiated or treated with Thy-1-, Lyt-1- or Lyt-2-specific antibody and complement. Thus the failure of CTL induction is probably due to suppression mediated by radiosensitive, Lyt-1+2+ T cells in the immunizing inoculum. We demonstrate here that the inoculated cells must share class I MHC loci with the recipients for the suppression to occur. Thus, the interaction between the suppressor T (Ts) cells and their targets (presumably the CTL precursors) is restricted by class I molecules. A disparity at class II loci between the inoculated cells and the recipients overrides the class I-restricted suppression, possibly through a positive allogeneic effect. The simplest interpretation of the class I restriction of Ts cell-target cell interaction is that the CTL precursors recognize minor H antigens in the context of class I molecules on the surface of the Ts cells themselves.     

The nature of the interaction between suppressor and helper T cells in the response to LDHB

Purified Lyt-1+2+ T cells were depleted of alloreactive cells by BUdR and light treatment, and then were primed in vitro against LDHB presented on allogeneic APC. Such cells could be restimulated by LDHB on the same allogeneic APC, but not by LDHB on APC syngeneic with the T cells. The restimulated T cells suppressed the proliferative response of Lyt-1+2- T cells primed and restimulated by the same antigen. The suppression, which was antigen specific, occurred after a 6-hr co-culture of the suppressor (Tse) and proliferating helper (Th) cells. The successful interaction (as measured by suppression) between allogeneic Th and Tse cells was found to be determined by the restriction specificity but not the MHC haplotype of Th cells, and the MHC haplotype but not the restriction specificity of Tse cells. Thus, suppression occurred only when the Tse cells carried genes controlling the MHC molecules that served as restriction elements for antigen recognition by the Th cells. No evidence could be obtained for the participation of APC in the Tse-Th interaction. The data suggest the interaction is based on the recognition by the Th cell of the antigen presented in the context of MHC molecules controlled by the Tse cell.     

Growth of an interleukin 2/interleukin 4-dependent T cell line induced by granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF)

Lymphokine activities in conditioned medium from activated helper T cell lines are most commonly defined by the proliferation of "specific" lymphokine-dependent cell lines. Various sublines of IL 2-dependent (and ostensibly specific) HT-2 and CTLL cells have now been shown to proliferate in response to BSF-1/IL 4 as well. After activation with antigen or mitogen, D10.G4.1, an antigen-specific cloned T helper cell that has recently been shown to produce IL 4 but not IL 2, secretes two distinct cytokines that induce the growth of HT-2 cells. These "T cell growth factors" (TCGF) can be separated by reversed phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC). The TCGF activity of one of these factors can be blocked by 11B11, an antibody specific for IL 4. The second TCGF activity is not affected by 11B11 or by antibodies specific for IL 2. This TCGF activity can be neutralized by a goat polyclonal antibody to granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), and has a RP-HPLC elution profile identical to that of recombinant GM-CSF. Recombinant GM-CSF induces both proliferation and long-term growth of HT-2 but not CTLL cells, and this activity can be neutralized by the same antibody to GM-CSF. GM-CSF is best known as a factor that induces the maturation and growth of granulocytes and macrophages from bone marrow-derived hematopoietic precursor cells. The ability of GM-CSF to induce the growth of certain T cell lines indicates that this molecule may play a role in T cell-mediated immune responses, either as an autocrine growth factor or a paracrine stimulus from both lymphoid and nonlymphoid tissues that produce this cytokine.     

Antigen-specific Lyt-2+ cytolytic T lymphocytes from mice infected with the intracellular bacterium Listeria monocytogenes

In vitro expanded T cell lines were used to determine whether antigen-specific cytolytic T lymphocytes are generated after infection with the intracellular bacterium, Listeria monocytogenes. Spleen cells from infected mice were cultured in the presence of syngeneic accessory cells, listerial antigen, and interleukin 2 containing supernatants. Cell lines were greater than 98% Thy-1+, L3T4-, Lyt-2+. Bone-marrow macrophages were used as target cells in two in vitro cytolytic assay systems. The Lyt-2+ T cells killed bone marrow macrophages only when infected with L. monocytogenes as assessed in a 4-hr 51Cr release assay and in an 18-hr neutral red uptake assay. Cytolysis was blocked by anti-LFA-1 and anti-Lyt-2 monoclonal antibodies. These cytolytic T cells produced interferon-gamma after co-stimulation with antigen, accessory cells, and recombinant interleukin 2. Bone marrow macrophages infected with Mycobacterium bovis were not killed by T cells from L. monocytogenes-infected mice but by T cell lines from M. bovis-infected mice, indicating that cytolysis was antigen specific. L. monocytogenes-infected target cells of different haplotype were lysed by the Lyt-2+ T cells. By using a low cell density split culture system, antigen-specific, H-2-restricted cytolytic T cells could be identified. These findings demonstrate that during infection with intracellular bacteria, Lyt-2+ T cells with cytolytic activity are generated that may be involved in antibacterial protection.     

Radiosensitivity of murine T-lymphocyte cytotoxicity

A biphasic curve was observed when surviving allogeneic lytic activity was plotted as a function of irradiation delivered before sensitization. Flow cytometry analysis demonstrated that the number of cells was reduced in response to increasing dose and that subset precursors Lyt 1+2+ were proportionally more radiosensitive than the other subsets. Paradoxically, the presence of exogenous T-cell growth factor (TCGF) in limiting dilution analysis changed the shape of the survival curve, and the mere addition of TCGF or Lyt 2- TCGF-producing cells abrogated the irradiation effect even though they were not shown to be the target of low dose irradiation in flow cytometry analysis. It is proposed that TCGF acted by enhancing the proliferation of surviving cells. This effect may be responsible for the relative radioresistance at higher doses due to enhanced availability of TCGF for the remaining cells.     

Antigen-presenting cells for Lyt-2+ cells. I. Stimulation of unprimed Lyt-2+ cells by H-2 different Thy-1-Ia- cells prepared from spleen and bone marrow

In agreement with previous studies on Ia- tumor cells, evidence is presented that primary MLR of purified Lyt-2+ T cells to class I alloantigens can be elicited by a minor population of Thy 1- Ia- cells present in normal spleen, bone marrow, and day-13 fetal liver; these cells are non-stimulatory for L3T4+ T cells. The data strengthen the view that primary responses of Lyt-2+ cells do not require the presence of Ia+ cells.     

Interaction between MHC-encoded products and cloned T cells

The interaction between class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) products and T cells was studied using H-2K^b-specific alloreactive T-cell lines and clones obtained by repeated in vitro stimulation with allogeneic cells. Induction of proliferation of these T cells appeared to involve two signals: the H-2K^b alloantigen and interleukins. Immunopurified liposome-inserted H-2K^b, which stimulates specific secondary in vitro cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses, could not replace cell-associated H-2K^b in the stimulation of these T-cell lines, even in the presence of feeder cells and interleukins. When T-cell lines were initiated in vitro and repeatedly stimulated with H-2K^b liposomes and feeder cells, it was possible to obtain T cells that could proliferate in response to H-2K^b liposomes in the presence of feeder cells and interleukin-2-containing supernatants or on H-2K ^b -expressing cells. Only stimulation with cells permitted maintenance of these T cells in culture for more than 12 weeks. Analyses of cell surface markers and of patterns of inhibition of proliferation by monoclonal antibodies (mAb) of T-cell lines induced in vitro with cell- or liposome-associated H-2K^b indicated that T-cell stimulation by class I antigen can occur in at least two ways. In the first, the H-2K^b-induced proliferation of Lyt-1^- Lyt-2⁺ T4^- T cells is inhibited by H-2K^b- and by Lyt-2-specific mAb, but not by Ia or T4-specific mAb. In the second, both Lyt-2⁺ and T4⁺ T cells are involved and the H-2K^b-induced proliferation is inhibited by H-2K^b- and Lyt-2-specific mAb and by Ia- and T4-specific mAb.Abbreviations used in this paper Ab antibody - mAb monoclonal antibody - C complement - i.p. intraperitoneally - PBS phosphate-buffered saline - PBS-B-N PBS containing bovine serum albumin and NaN₃ - CTL cytotoxic T lymphocyte - Th T helper cell - MHC major histocompatibility complex - PMA 4-phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate - SCA concanavalin A-stimulated rat spleen cell supernatant - SC16 EL4 clone 16 supernatant - IL-1 interleukin-1 - IL-2 interleukin-2 (T-cell growth factor) - FCS fetal calf serum - H-2K^b-lip. H-2K^b inserted in liposomes - C. E. cell equivalents     

Functional activity in vivo of effector T cell populations. I. Antitumor activity exhibited by allogeneic mixed leukocyte culture cells

The in vivo activity of murine cytolytic T lymphocyte-containing effector cell populations generated in vitro was studied in a tumor allograft model system by monitoring the elimination of 131I-IUdR-labeled tumor cells with whole-body counting techniques. Mice were irradiated sublethally and 16 hr later 131I-labeled tumor cells were injected either subcutaneously or i.p. Simultaneously, graded doses of various effector cell populations were injected i.v. and the mice were counted daily to assess the potential elimination of the radiolabeled tumor cells. Thus, allogeneic 2 degrees mixed leukocyte culture cells were observed to eliminate allogeneic but not syngeneic tumor cells in a dose-dependent manner, with as few as 0.2 x 10(6) effector cells causing significant destruction of 2 x 10(6) allogeneic tumor cells. The protective effect of the mixed leukocyte culture cells was considerably reduced when Lyt-2+-bearing lymphocytes were eliminated by treatment with monoclonal antibody plus complement. In additional experiments, Lyt-2+ lymphocytes positively selected by enrichment on antibody-coated petri dishes gave efficient protection, in the absence of Lyt-2- cells. Surprisingly, when several different cloned, specific, long-term allogeneic cytolytic T cells lines were injected either i.p. of i.v., tumor cell destruction was observed only after i.p. injection.     

Adoptive immunotherapy of a syngeneic murine leukemia with a tumor-specific cytotoxic T cell clone and recombinant human interleukin 2: correlation with clonal IL 2 receptor expression

The successful adoptive immunotherapy of the syngeneic Friend virus-induced murine leukemia FBL-3 was mediated by a proliferative MHC-restricted, tumor-specific CTL clone in combination with recombinant human IL 2. This clone was previously shown to express the L3T4-, Lyt-1+, Lyt-2+ surface phenotype. Activation of the clone for 48 hr in vitro with irradiated tumor cells induced the expression of IL 2 receptors and markedly increased clonal proliferation in response to recombinant IL 2. Intravenous injection of 2 X 10(7) 48 hr in vitro-activated cloned cells, followed by 6 days of systemic (i.p.) administration of IL 2 resulted in the complete regression of tumors and the cure of 50% of the treated mice. IL 2 alone had no effect on tumor growth, whereas the injection of nonactivated (resting) clone plus IL 2 or activated clone without IL 2 had small but insignificant effects on tumor growth and survival. These results indicated that the in vivo effector functions of cloned T cells may be markedly enhanced by the concurrent systemic administration of recombinant IL 2 and by the induction of optimal IL 2 receptor expression on the cloned T cells at the time of cell administration.     

The production of T-cell growth factor (TCGF) in vivo in sheep

Lymph and supernatants derived from efferent lymphocytes leaving the popliteal lymph nodes of sheep responding to human red cells or dinitrophenylated bovine serum albumin were examined for the presence of T-cell growth factor (TCGF). Efferent cells from normal sheep, but not from antigen-stimulated sheep, were found to release low levels of TCGF when incubated in medium for 12 hr in the absence of any exogenous stimulus. High levels of TCGF were found in normal lymph and also in immune lymph collected from sheep during the first 6 hr of immune responses. There were no detectable levels of TCGF in lymph collected later in the response. The lymphokine appeared to be a single molecular species of 10,000–20,000 molecular weight as assessed by exclusion chromatography. Efferent cells expressing receptors for TCGF were found in efferent lymph during the first 12 hr of the response. The results demonstrate for the first time that TCGF is produced in vivo and that asynchrony exists between TCGF production and expression of receptors for TCGF on efferent cells released by the stimulated node. Based on the known kinetics of previously reported synergistic factors, mitogenic factors, and T-cell-replacing factors in sheep efferent lymph and their physical characteristics it was concluded that the TCGF detected in lymph is distinct from these factors.     

Study of DTH and resistance in Mycobacterium lepraemurium infection using a T-cell line isolated from mice infected with Mycobacterium bovis (BCG)

A T-cell line of mixed phenotype (60% L3T4+, 40% Lyt-2+) was isolated from mice infected with Mycobacterium bovis (BCG). This line responded to M. lepraemurium and BCG but not to M. leprae and produced TCGF spontaneously. It also produced factors which stimulated macrophages to secrete hydrogen peroxide and superoxide anion. In vivo studies showed that only L3T4+ cells were required to transfer DTH responses and that Lyt-2+ cells suppressed this response. Both L3T4+ and Lyt-2+ cells were required to inhibit M. lepraemurium multiplication in vivo.     

Regulation of T cell growth factor production: arrest of TCGF production after 18 hours in normal lectin-stimulated mouse spleen cell cultures

The detailed kinetics of TCGF accumulation in Con A-stimulated spleen cell cultures shows a maximum at 24 hr, with a subsequent decrease in activity. This decrease is not due to the appearance of inhibitory substances "masking" TCGF activity. Pulse experiments show that the rate of TCGF production falls sharply after 18 hr and is completely arrested after 24 hr of Con A stimulation. The arrest in TCGF production is the result neither of culture depletion in medium components nor of limiting accessory cell function or inactivation of the lectin, and it thus seem to be the result of inactivation of TCGF-producing T cells. This regulation is not the result of a TCGF-mediated feedback mechanism but rather of lectin-induced suppressive cells that appear in culture after 24 hr and turn off de novo production of TCGF in fresh cultures.     

Immunoregulation in the rat: characteristics of a suppressor T cell that inhibits antigen-dependent cell proliferation

We have examined the characteristics of a rat suppressor T cell (Ts) that inhibited the antigen-dependent proliferative response of antigen-primed T cells. The kinetics of in vitro induction of Ts from lymph node T cells obtained from antigen-primed rats indicated that Ts were induced in the presence of the priming antigen within 48 hr of culturing. The Ts produced during the first 48 hr of in vitro cultures were radiosensitive (2000 rad) but became partially radioresistant within the next 48 hr of culturing. In the presence but not the absence of priming antigen, Ts inhibited the antigen-dependent proliferative response to the priming antigen as well as to heterologous antigens. Suppression appeared to be mediated via a nondialyzable suppressor factor (TsF). The induction of Ts in cultures required the presence of OX-6-/OX-8- T cells, antigen-presenting cells, and the antigen. Although a majority of cells recovered from the induced cultures were OX-8+, there was no evidence that OX-8+ antigen expression per se was related to Ts activity. Addition of highly purified IL 2 augmented the Ts-mediated suppression. The immunoregulatory implications of these findings are discussed.     

Cell interactions in alveolar macrophage-mediated suppression of the immune response: an unusual suppressor pathway involving a population of T-cells that express Lyt-1, L3T4, and I-J

Studies from this laboratory have demonstrated that incubation of murine alveolar macrophages (AM) with SRBC-primed spleen cells (SC) results in suppression of the in vitro plaque-forming cell (PFC) response and that suppression is mediated by a soluble factor contained in supernatants obtained from cultures of AM and SC. In the present study, immunological techniques employing monoclonal antibody (MoAb) were used to isolate various T-cell subsets in order to determine the phenotype of the cells which interact with AM to produce suppression. Spleen cell populations depleted of Thy-1+-, Lyt-1+-, L3T4+-, or I-J+-bearing cells failed to generate suppressive supernatants when cultured with AM. Depletion of Lyt-2+ T-cells (the classical suppressor/effector subset) did not alter the ability of the remaining cell population to cooperate with AM for generation of suppressive supernatants. Direct suppression of the PFC response in cultures containing AM was abrogated after treatment of the spleen cells with anti-I-J, but not anti-Lyt-2 MoAbs. Reconstitution of the AM-mediated suppressive response with enriched populations of SC required the presence of T-cells which expressed Lyt-1, L3T4, and I-J. These results suggest the existence of an unusual suppressor pathway involving I-J restriction but which appears to be mediated by the interaction of AM with a population of T-cells that expresses surface markers characteristic of T-helper cells.