Interactions between octopine and nopaline plasmids in Agrobacterium tumefaciens.

Transfer of octopine Ti plasmids to strains already carrying an octopine Ti plasmid was found to occur at the same (high) frequency as transfer to Ti plasmid lacking recipients, showing that resident Ti plasmids do not exhibit entry exclusion towards incoming Ti plasmids. The resident octopine Ti plasmid was lost by the recipient after the entrance of the incoming Ti plasmid, which is indicative of the incompatibility between the Ti plasmids. Octopine Ti plasmids were found to become established only infrequently in recipients with a nopaline Ti plasmid and, vice versa, nopaline Ti plasmids were only rarely established in recipients with an octopine Ti plasmid. Rare clones in which the incoming octopine (nopaline) Ti plasmid had been established despite the presence of a nopaline (octopine) Ti plasmid appeared to harbor cointegrates consisting of the entire incoming Ti plasmid and the entire resident Ti plasmid. The integration event invariably had occurred in a region of the plasmids that is highly conserved in evolution and that is essential for oncogenicity. These results show that octopine and nopaline Ti plasmids cannot be maintained as separate replicons by one and the same cell. Therefore, be definition, these plasmids belong to the same incompatibility group, which has been names inc Rh-1. Agrobacterial non-Ti octopine and nopaline plasmids were found to belong to another incompatibility group. The tumorigenic properties of strains harboring two different Ti plasmids, in a cointegrate structure, were indicative of the virulence genes of both of them being expressed. The agrobacterial non-Ti octopine and nopaline plasmids did not influence the virulence properties encoded by the Ti plasmid.     

Novel Toxin-Antitoxin System Composed of Serine Protease and AAA-ATPase Homologues Determines the High Level of Stability and Incompatibility of the Tumor-Inducing Plasmid pTiC58

Stability of plant tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmids differs among strains. A high level of stability prevents basic and applied studies including the development of useful strains. The nopaline type Ti plasmid pTiC58 significantly reduces the transconjugant efficiency for incoming incompatible plasmids relative to the other type, such as octopine-type plasmids. In this study we identified a region that increases the incompatibility and stability of the plasmid. This region was located on a 4.3-kbp segment about 38 kbp downstream of the replication locus, repABC. We named two open reading frames in the segment, ietA and ietS, both of which were essential for the high level of incompatibility and stability. Plasmid stabilization by ietAS was accomplished by a toxin-antitoxin (TA) mechanism, where IetS is the toxin and IetA is the antitoxin. A database search revealed that putative IetA and IetS proteins are highly similar to AAA-ATPases and subtilisin-like serine proteases, respectively. Amino acid substitution experiments in each of the highly conserved characteristic residues, in both putative enzymes, suggested that the protease activity is essential and that ATP binding activity is important for the operation of the TA system. The ietAS-containing repABC plasmids expelled Ti plasmids even in strains which were tolerant to conventional Ti-curing treatments.Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains bearing a tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmid are the etiological agents of crown gall disease. Most genes required for pathogenicity are located on the plasmids (17, 33). Ti plasmids are kept stable at a low copy number equivalent to that of the chromosomal DNA in the bacterial cells (32) due to the repABC locus (16, 30, 34). The stability of Ti plasmids differs among strains (11).Many genes for keeping plasmids stable have been reported in eubacteria, and these are divided into three categories based on their mechanism: multimer resolution systems, active partitioning systems, and toxin-antitoxin (TA) systems (15). Multimer resolution systems increase the number of plasmid molecules by resolving a multimer plasmid into monomers, resulting in a higher probability of plasmid distribution to daughter cells during cell division even when plasmid distribution occurs randomly (29). Active partitioning systems deliver plasmid copies to each progeny cell at cell division (21). In the repABC locus, the RepA and RepB proteins and parS site(s) ensure stable plasmid inheritance by the active partitioning system (2). TA systems contribute to plasmid maintenance in cell populations by initiating growth inhibition or death of plasmid-free cells and are widely distributed among eubacterial and archaeal plasmids as well as their chromosomes (9). Generally, the TA module consists of two genes which encode toxin and antitoxin. The antitoxin neutralizes the action of a cognate toxin by interaction with the toxin or its target molecules. When a plasmid harboring the TA module is lost from a host cell, the antitoxin molecules decrease to an ineffective level because the antitoxin is degraded quickly or diluted by cell division (15). Thereafter, the toxin exerts its toxicity and inhibits the host cell growth. RNA antitoxins can suppress toxin expression by binding to the toxin mRNA as an antisense RNA or repress toxicity effects by an unknown mechanism (6, 4). In pTi-SAKURA, the Ti plasmid in the A. tumefaciens strain MAFF301001, it was shown that the tiorf24 and tiorf25 module increased plasmid stability by the TA mechanism (40; also S. Yamamoto, unpublished data).Differences in Ti plasmid stability are critical for plasmid engineering and evolution (33). However, little is known about the stability factors of Ti plasmids other than the repABC locus. In our previous study (40), tiorf24 and tiorf25 were shown to increase the segregational stability and incompatibility of Ti plasmids and reduce the efficiency of transconjugants by the introduction of incompatible plasmids into host cells. The two genes are located 2.5-kbp downstream of repABC (8). Generally, incompatibility has been defined as a situation where two plasmids contain a related replication and/or partitioning system and are unable to exist in a cell simultaneously without external selection (1). A. tumefaciens strain C58, which contains a Ti plasmid pTiC58, allows entry of an incompatible repABC plasmid into the cell 60-fold less efficiently than a derivative of C58. The derivative of C58 harbors a small repABC vector instead of pTiC58 (40). This suggests the presence of incompatibility-enhancing genes on pTiC58.In this study, we located the responsible genes in pTiC58 and found that the novel genes ietA and ietS enhance the incompatibility and stability of the plasmid by the TA mechanism.     

The repABC plasmid family

repABC plasmids are widely distributed among alpha-proteobacteria. They are especially common in Rhizobiales. Some strains of this bacterial order can contain multiple repABC replicons indicating that this plasmid family includes several incompatibility groups. The replication and stable maintenance of these replicons depend on the presence of a repABC operon. The repABC operons sequenced to date share some general characteristics. All of them contain at least three protein-encoding genes: repA, repB and repC. The first two genes encode proteins involved in plasmid segregation, whereas repC encodes a protein crucial for replication. The origin of replication maps within the repC gene. In contrast, the centromere-like sequence (parS) can be located at various positions in the operon. In this review we will summarize current knowledge about this plasmid family, with special emphasis on their structural diversity and their complex genetic regulation. Finally, we will examine some ideas about their evolutionary origin and trends.     

A site-specific recombinase (RinQ) is required to exert incompatibility towards the symbiotic plasmid of Rhizobium etli

The replication/partition region of the symbiotic plasmid p42d of Rhizobium etli CE3 is characterized by the presence of the repABC operon. A recombinant plasmid containing this region is able to replicate in a R. etli derivative cured from p42d, with the same stability and copy number shown by the parental plasmid. However, when this construct is introduced into the wild-type strain, instead of exerting incompatibility against the p42d, it forms a stable cointegrate with it. In this paper, we show that a site-specific resolvase, and its action sites are essential factors to displace the symbiotic p42d. We propose a model for this novel incompatibility mechanism.     

Complete nucleotide sequence of a plant tumor-inducing Ti plasmid

Crown gall tumor disease in dicot plants is caused by Agrobacterium tumefaciens harboring a giant tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmid. Here, for the first time among agrobacterial plasmids, the nucleotide sequence of a typical nopaline-type Ti plasmid (pTi-SAKURA) was determined completely. In total, 195 open reading frames (ORFs) were estimated in the 206479 bp long sequence. 20 genes for conjugation, three for replication, 22 for pathogenesis and 37 for genetic colonization of host plants were found within two-thirds of the plasmid. These genes formed seven functional gene clusters with narrow inter-cluster spaces. In the remaining one-third of the plasmid, novel genes including homologs of mutT, Rhizobium nodQ and Sphingomonas ligE genes were found, which are likely to be responsible for the broad host range. Restriction fragment length variation indicates extreme plasticity of the part required for conjugational gene transfer and the above-mentioned one-third of the plasmid, even among closely related Ti plasmids.     

The RepA and RepB autorepressors and TraR play opposing roles in the regulation of a Ti plasmid repABC operon

The replicator regions of the Ti plasmids of Agrobacterium tumefaciens belong to the repABC family of replication and partitioning systems, members of which are widely distributed among alpha proteobacteria. In the region upstream of the octopine-type Ti plasmid repABC operon, three promoters were recently shown to be activated by the LuxR-type regulator TraR. Activation of these promoters by TraR led to enhanced rep gene expression and increased Ti plasmid copy number. Here we describe a fourth promoter, designated P4. This promoter lies directly upstream of repA and is not regulated by TraR. The promoter was localized by subcloning and demonstrated to be strongly autorepressed. RepA is the major cis-acting autorepressor of this promoter, though RepB enhanced repression and was essential for RepA-mediated repression in trans. Purified RepA bound to an approximately 70-nucleotide operator site overlapping the P4 promoter and extending well downstream. Binding affinity was increased by adenosine di- and tri-phosphates and also by purified RepB. Activation of P1, P2, and P3 enhanced the activity of P4, suggesting that P4 somehow communicates with the upstream promoters. These findings demonstrate that both autoinduction and autorepression play critical and opposing roles in regulating repABC expression and hence in the replication, stability and copy number of the Ti plasmid.     

Deletion analysis of sucrose metabolic genes from a Salmonella plasmid cloned in Escherichia coli K12

The sucrose operon from pUR400, a 78-kbp conjugative Salmonella plasmid, was cloned in Escherichia coli K12. The operon was located in a 5.7-kbp SalI restriction fragment and was subcloned, in each of two possible orientations, using the expression vector pUC18. The insert DNA was restriction mapped and duplicate restriction sites in the insert and in the polylinker of the vector were used to create various deletions promoter distal in the operon sequence. Additional deletions were made with the restriction exonuclease Bal31. Cells containing hybrid plasmids with specified deletions lacked the ability to transport sucrose or were constitutive for hydrolase and/or uptake activities. The scrA (enzyme IIScr) and scrR (regulatory) genes resided within 2900-bp SmaI-SalI DNA fragment and were assigned the order scrB, scrA, scrR. An amplified sucrose-inducible gene product, Mr 68,000, was detected only in the membrane fraction from recombinant cells that contained plasmid with the intact operon sequence. This protein represented 11% of the total membrane protein and was resistant to extraction with 0.5 M sodium chloride, 2% Triton X-100, and 0.5% sodium deoxycholate. The protein did not appear to be the product of either the scrA, scrB, or scrR gene and may therefore represent a previously unidentified membrane-bound sucrose protein. A new gene, scrC, is proposed. In addition, the cloned 5.7-kbp SalI and 2.5-kbp SmaI-SalI DNA fragments failed to hybridize to chromosomal DNA from Bacillus subtilis, Streptococcus lactis, Streptococcus mutans, and Lactobacillus acidophilus as well as to DNA from a sucrose plasmid from Salmonella tennessee. However, the probes showed weak homology with a 20-kbp EcoRI restriction fragment from Klebsiella pneumoniae.     

Cell-cell signaling and the Agrobacterium tumefaciens Ti plasmid copy number fluctuations

The Agrobacterium tumefaciens oncogenic Ti plasmids replicate and segregate to daughter cells via repABC cassettes, in which repA and repB are plasmid partitioning genes and repC encodes the replication initiator protein. repABC cassettes are encountered in a growing number of plasmids and chromosomes of the alpha-proteobacteria, and findings from particular representatives of agrobacteria, rhizobia and Paracoccus have began to shed light on their structure and functions. Amongst repABC replicons, Ti plasmids and particularly the octopine-type Ti have recently stood as model in regulation of repABC basal expression, which acts in plasmid copy number control, but also appear to undergo pronounced up-regulation of repABC, upon interbacterial and host-bacterial signaling. The last results in considerable Ti copy number increase and collective elevation of Ti gene expression. Inhibition of the Ti repABC is in turn conferred by a plant defense compound, which primarily affects Agrobacterium virulence and interferes with cell-density perception. Altogether, the above suggest that the entire Ti gene pool is subjected to the bacterium-eukaryote signaling network, a phenomenon quite unprecedented for replicons thought of as stringently controlled. It remains to be seen whether similar copy number variations characterize related replicons or if they are of even broader significance in plasmid biology.     

Identification of a megaplasmid centromere reveals genetic structural diversity within the repABC family of basic replicons

The basic replication unit of many plasmids and second chromosomes in the alpha-proteobacteria consists of a repABC locus that encodes the trans- and cis-acting components required for both semiautonomous replication and replicon maintenance in a cell population. In terms of physical genetic organization and at the nucleotide sequence level, repABC loci are well conserved across various genera. As with all repABC-type replicons that have been genetically characterized, the 1.4 Mb pSymA and 1.7 Mb pSymB megaplasmids from the plant endosymbiont Sinorhizobium meliloti encode strong incompatibility (inc) determinants. We have identified a novel inc sequence upstream of the repA2 gene in pSymA that is not present on pSymB and not reported in other repABC plasmids that have been characterized. This region, in concert with the repA and repB genes, stabilizes a test plasmid indicating that it constitutes a partitioning (par) system for the megaplasmid. Purified RepB binds to this sequence and binding may be enhanced by RepA. We have isolated 19 point mutations that eliminate incompatibility, reduce RepB binding or the stabilization phenotype associated with this sequence and all of these map to a 16-nucleotide palindromic sequence centred 330 bp upstream of the repA2 gene. An additional five near-perfect repeats of this palindrome are located further upstream of the repA2 gene and we show that they share some conservation with known RepB binding sites in different locations on other repABC plasmids and to two sequences found on the tumour inducing plasmid of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. These additional palindromes also bind RepB but one of them does not display obvious incompatibility effects. A heterogenic distribution of par sequences demonstrates unexpected diversity in the structural genetic organization of repABC loci, despite their obvious levels of similarity.     

Comparative characterization of repABC-type replicons of Paracoccus pantotrophus composite plasmids

The repABC replicons have an unusual structure, since they carry genes coding for partitioning (repA, repB) and replication (repC) proteins, which are organized in an operon. So far, the presence of these compact bi-functional modules has been reported only in the megaplasmids of the Rhizobiaceae and within the plasmid pTAV1 (107kb) of Paracoccus versutus. We studied the distribution of repABC-type replicons within bacteria belonging to the genus Paracoccus. We found that repABC replicons occur only in the group of pTAV1-like plasmids: pKLW1, pHG16-a, pWKS2, and pPAN1, harbored by different strains of Paracoccus pantotrophus. A partial sequencing approach followed by phylogenetic analysis revealed that these replicons constitute a distinct evolutionary branch of repABC replicons. Incompatibility studies showed that they represent two incompatibility groups designated IncABC1 (pTAV1, pKLW1, and pHG16-a) and IncABC2 (pPAN1). Sequence comparison using available databases allowed the identification, within plasmid pRS241d of Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1, of an additional sequence highly homologous to the paracoccal repABC replicons, which has been included in comparative analyses.     

Rhizobium etli CFN42 contains at least three plasmids of the repABC family: a structural and evolutionary analysis

In this paper, we report the identification of replication/partition regions of plasmid p42a and p42b of Rhizobium etli CFN42. Sequence analysis reveals that both replication/partition regions belong to the repABC family. Phylogenetic analysis of all the complete repABC replication/partition regions reported to date, shows that repABC plasmids coexisting in the same strain arose most likely by lateral transfer instead of by duplication followed by divergence. A model explaining how new incompatibility groups originate, is proposed.     

Molecular cloning and functional analysis of DNA regions of plasmid RP4 determining the incompatibility properties

Sau3A-generated DNA fragments determining incompatibility functions of the plasmid RP4 were cloned on the vectors pTK16 and pBR322. Inc+ recombinant plasmids were divided into two types: 1) expressing incompatibility only towards the homologous RP4 replicon, 2) expressing incompatibility - both towards the homologous RP4 replicon and towards the heterologous replicons of plasmids R906 and R751. For one member of the first type plasmids it was shown that the cloned Inc+-specific insertion derived from the region of location of the EcoRI restriction site. The majority of the Inc+ recombinant plasmids showed asymmetric expression of incompatibility, predominantly eliminating the resident IncP plasmid.     

Plasmid-encoded phthalate catabolic pathway in Arthrobacter keyseri 12B

Several 2-substituted benzoates (including 2-trifluoromethyl-, 2-chloro-, 2-bromo-, 2-iodo-, 2-nitro-, 2-methoxy-, and 2-acetyl-benzoates) were converted by phthalate-grown Arthrobacter keyseri (formerly Micrococcus sp.) 12B to the corresponding 2-substituted 3,4-dihydroxybenzoates (protocatechuates). Because these products lack a carboxyl group at the 2 position, they were not substrates for the next enzyme of the phthalate catabolic pathway, 3,4-dihydroxyphthalate 2-decarboxylase, and accumulated. When these incubations were carried out in iron-containing minimal medium, the products formed colored chelates. This chromogenic response was subsequently used to identify recombinant Escherichia coli strains carrying genes encoding the responsible enzymes, phthalate 3,4-dioxygenase and 3,4-dihydroxy-3,4-dihydrophthalate dehydrogenase, from the 130-kbp plasmid pRE1 of strain 12B. Beginning with the initially cloned 8.14-kbp PstI fragment of pRE824 as a probe to identify recombinant plasmids carrying overlapping fragments, a DNA segment of 33.5 kbp was cloned from pRE1 on several plasmids and mapped using restriction endonucleases. From these plasmids, the sequence of 26,274 contiguous bp was determined. Sequenced DNA included several genetic units: tnpR, pcm operon, ptr genes, pehA, norA fragment, and pht operon, encoding a transposon resolvase, catabolism of protocatechuate (3,4-dihydroxybenzoate), a putative ATP-binding cassette transporter, a possible phthalate ester hydrolase, a fragment of a norfloxacin resistance-like transporter, and the conversion of phthalate to protocatechuate, respectively. Activities of the eight enzymes involved in the catabolism of phthalate through protocatechuate to pyruvate and oxaloacetate were demonstrated in cells or cell extracts of recombinant E. coli strains.     

Evolutionary conservation of genes coding for meta pathway enzymes within TOL plasmids pWW0 and pWW53.

Pseudomonas putida MT53 contains a TOL plasmid, pWW53, that encodes toluene-xylene catabolism. pWW53 is nonconjugative, is about 105 to 110 kilobase pairs (kbp) in size, and differs significantly in its restriction endonuclease digestion pattern and incompatibility group from the archetypal TOL plasmid pWW0. An RP4::pWW53 cointegrate plasmid, pWW53-4, containing about 35 kbp of pWW53 DNA, including the entire catabolic pathway genes, was formed, and a restriction map for KpnI, HindIII, and BamHI was derived. The entire regulated meta pathway genes for the catabolism of m-toluate were cloned into pKT230 from pWW53 on a 17.5-kbp HindIII fragment. The recombinant plasmid supported growth on m-toluate when mobilized into plasmid-free P. putida PaW130. A restriction map of the insert for 10 restriction enzymes was derived, and the locations of xylD, xylL, xylE, xylG, and xylF were determined by subcloning and assaying for their gene products in both Escherichia coli and P. putida hosts. Good induction of the enzymes by m-toluate and m-methylbenzyl alcohol but not by m-xylene was measured in P. putida, but little or no regulation was found in E. coli. The restriction map and the gene order showed strong similarities with published maps of the DNA encoding both the entire meta pathway operon (xylDLEGFJIH) and the regulatory genes xylS and xylR on the archetype TOL plasmid pWW0, suggesting a high degree of conservation in DNA structure for the catabolic operon on the two different plasmids.     

Nature of the compatible inheritance of hybrid plasmid pAS8 and its deletion mutants with replicon ColE1]

Hybrid plasmid pAS8, that consists of RP4 and ColE1 replicons, is incompatible with RP4 but co-exists with ColE1 replicon. The deletion mutants of pAS8, that replicates under the control of ColE1 replicon only, are incompatible with ColE1 derivatives, although the copy number of pAS8 and its deletion mutants in the cell is the same (1-3 per the chromosome). Incompatibility effect of plasmids is expressed in a sharp decrease in transformant's yield during selection of incoming and resident plasmids markers. In this case incompatibility is a very fast process, that leads to the elimination of resident or incoming plasmid just before plating on the selective medium. On the base of negative control theory, the repressors yield, synthesized in the presence of 1-3 copies of the deletion mutant is enough for the expression of ColE1-specific incompatibility. This ColE1 incompatibility is probably connected with the functional activity of ColE1 replicon. When ColE1 factor replicates under the control of RP4 replicon the expression of ColE1-specific incompatibility does not occur. Possibly, the incompatibility effect takes place when pAS8 deletion mutants cause the synthesis of ColE1-specific repressor. Also, the replicons of ColE1 may competein the membrane attachment site.