IL-1 induces high affinity IL-2 receptor expression of CD4-8- thymocytes

We investigated the role of cytokines for the growth of CD4-8-thymocytes (double negative thymocytes) (DNT) in vitro and found that IL-1-induced IL-2-dependent proliferation of only the IL-2R-positive DNT subpopulation. The presence of IL-1 during the first 18 h of culture was sufficient for an optimal response and suggested that IL-1 induced DNT differentiation. We could indeed show by RNA dot blot analysis that IL-1 stimulated de novo expression of the p55 chain of the IL-2R thus initiating high affinity IL-2 binding and a proliferative response. Because macrophages and epithelial cells in the thymus produce IL-1 we propose that IL-1 is involved in early events during maturation of immature thymocytes.     

Growth-promoting activity of IL-1 alpha, IL-6, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha in combination with IL-2, IL-4, or IL-7 on murine thymocytes. Differential effects on CD4/CD8 subsets and on CD3+/CD3- double-negative thymocytes

Many cytokines (including IL-1, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, and TNF-alpha) have been shown to induce thymocyte proliferation in the presence of PHA. In this report, we demonstrate that certain cytokine combinations induce thymocyte proliferation in the absence of artificial comitogens. IL-1 alpha, IL-6, and TNF-alpha enhanced the proliferation of whole unseparated thymocytes in the presence of IL-2, whereas none of them induced thymocyte proliferation alone. In contrast, of these three enhancing cytokines, only IL-6 enhanced IL-4-induced proliferation. We also separated thymocytes into four groups based on their expression of CD4 and CD8, and investigated their responses to various cytokines. The results indicate that each cytokine combination affects different thymocyte subsets; thus, IL-1 alpha enhanced the proliferation of CD4-CD8- double negative (DN) thymocytes more efficiently than IL-6 in the presence of IL-2, whereas IL-6 enhanced the responses of CD4+CD8- and CD4-CD8+ single positive (SP) thymocytes to IL-2 or IL-4 better than IL-1 alpha. TNF-alpha enhanced the proliferation of both DN and both SP subsets in the presence of IL-2 and/or IL-7. None of these combinations induced the proliferation of CD4+CD8+ double positive thymocytes. Finally, DN were separated into CD3+ and CD3- populations and their responsiveness was investigated, because recent reports strongly suggest that CD3+ DN thymocytes are a mature subset of different lineage rather than precursors of SP thymocytes. CD3+ DN proliferated in response to IL-7, TNF-alpha + IL-2, and IL-1 + IL-2. CD3- DN did not respond to IL-7 or to IL-1 + IL-2, but did respond to TNF-alpha + IL-2. Finally, we detected TNF-alpha production by a cloned line of thymic macrophages, as well as by DN adult thymocytes. These results suggest that cytokines alone are capable of potent growth stimuli for thymocytes, and indicate that different combinations of these molecules act selectively on thymocytes at different developmental stages.     

Immature, double negative (CD4-,CD8-) rat thymocytes do not express IL-2 receptors

IL-2R alpha-chain is expressed on a subset of mouse CD4- and CD8-, double negative (DN) thymocytes. This expression of IL-2R alpha-chain on some DN thymocytes in the mouse has led to the proposal that IL-2 might serve as a principal growth and/or differentiation factor for immature thymocytes. However, previous histologic observations have indicated that IL-2R alpha-chain is not expressed on the subcapsular thymic blasts (an area rich in DN cells) in either huma or rat thymus, whereas all three species display IL-2R expression on a few cells in the thymic medulla. Therefore, we characterized rat DN thymocytes to determine whether they contained an IL-2R+ population. The results show that rat thymic DN cells share several characteristics with mouse DN cells. However, most of the rat strains do not express the IL-2R on DN cells as shown either by immunofluorescence or by IL-2 binding and receptor cross-linking. Thus, the rare medullary IL-2R+ cells were not found in the DN cells. Only in the exceptional F344 rat strain is the IL-2R alpha-chain expressed on a major proportion of thymocytes, including both DN cells and small cortical-type thymocytes. Furthermore, rat DN cells do not contain detectable IL-2 mRNA or cytoplasmic IL-2 activity, thus supporting the conclusion that it is unlikely that IL-2 and IL-2R serve to maintain the proliferation of rat DN thymocytes in vivo. The possible significance of in vivo expression of IL-2R alpha-chain on immature thymocytes in the mouse and in a single rat strain is discussed.     

IL-7 maintains the T cell precursor potential of CD3-CD4-CD8- thymocytes.

We and other investigators have reported that IL-4 (in the presence of PMA) or IL-7 (used alone) induce proliferation of both adult and fetal (gestation day 15) CD4-CD8- thymocytes. These results suggested that these cytokines may be growth factors for pre-T cells. However, we recently observed that among adult CD4-CD8- thymocytes, only the CD3+ subset proliferates in response to IL-7, whereas IL-4 + PMA induces proliferative responses in both CD3- and CD3+ subsets. Thus, we concluded that IL-7 used alone is not a potent growth stimulus for adult thymic CD3-CD4-CD8- triple negative (TN) T cell precursors. Interestingly, the viability of adult TN thymocytes in culture was improved by IL-7 for up to 1 wk, in spite of the inability of IL-7 to induce significant [3H]TdR incorporation in these cells. After culture in IL-7 for 4 days, the viable cells remained CD4-CD8-, but 25 to 35% expressed CD3 whereas the rest remained CD3-. In contrast, most of the cells cultured with IL-4 + PMA for 4 days remained TN. To investigate whether adult TN thymocytes that survive in vitro in the presence of IL-4 + PMA or IL-7 retain T cell progenitor potential, we tested whether they could reconstitute lymphoid cell-depleted (2-deoxyguanosine-treated) fetal thymus organ cultures. Our results demonstrate that TN cells cultured in IL-7 retain T cell progenitor potential.     

Activation of CD 4-, CD 8- thymocytes with IL 4 vs IL 1 + IL 2

Thymocytes from C57BL/6 mice were highly purified to obtain the CD 4-, CD 8- subpopulation which constitutes only 5% of all thymocytes. Substantial proliferation was induced in vitro with either IL-1 + IL-2 or with IL-4 in the presence of PMA. IL-1 and IL-2 synergized in inducing proliferation of these purified CD 4-, CD 8- thymocytes whereas neither synergized with IL-4. In order to determine whether stimulation with IL-1 + IL-2 acted via IL-4 or vice versa, cultures were treated reciprocally with affinity-purified anti-IL-2 or anti-IL-4 antibodies. Cultures with IL-4 were inhibited by anti-IL-4 but were unaffected by anti-IL-2. The CD 4-, CD 8- thymocytes cultured with IL-1 + IL-2 + anti-IL-2 were inhibited to baseline IL-1 stimulation. At low concentrations of IL-1 (1 U/ml) and IL-2 (100 U/ml), anti-IL-4 had no effect, whereas at higher levels of IL-1 (2 U/ml IL-1), and 100 or 200 U/ml IL-2, anti-IL-4 significantly reduced DNA synthesis. This result suggests that at higher concentrations the combination of IL-1 + IL-2 can induce cells to produce IL-4 which then contributes to overall proliferation. When CD 4-, CD 8- thymocytes were cultured with the low doses of IL-1 + IL-2 for 72 h, 62% expressed cell surface T3 complex (vs 11% at initiation) and 27% were F23.1+ (vs 5% at initiation). In contrast, culture with IL-4 led to no increase in numbers of T3+ cells and none were F23.1+; however, there was coexpression of Thy1 and 6B2 on 20% of cells at the end of culture (vs 4% at initiation). Thus, IL-1 + IL-2 causes expansion of a CD 4-, CD 8- thymocyte population expressing the alpha, beta-T cell receptor, whereas IL-4 induces cells to express a phenotype present in small numbers in the periphery of normal mice and in larger numbers in mice bearing the lpr gene.     

T cell antigen receptor expression by subsets of Ly-2-L3T4- (CD8-CD4-) thymocytes

The V beta 8-specific mAb F23.1 and KJ16 were used as fluorescent stains to test for TCR expression on the surface of subpopulations of early, CD4-CD8- (L3T4-Ly-2-) thymocytes from adult CBA mice. A surprisingly high proportion (27%) of Ly-2-L3T4- thymocytes were strongly F23.1 and KJ16 positive. No positive cells were detected among Ly-2-L3T4- thymocytes from V beta 8-negative SJL mice. In contrast to the adult thymus, Ly-2-L3T4- cells from embryonic CBA thymus lacked F23.1-positive cells. Subsets of adult CBA Ly-2-L3T4- thymocytes were separated to determine which expressed V beta 8. The major subset, Ly-1 low B2A2-M1/69+Thy-1+Pgp-1-, representing a phenotype similar to embryonic Ly-2-L3T4- thymocytes and the phenotype commonly isolated from adult thymocytes as Ly-1 "dull," lacked cells strongly positive for F23.1. In contrast, a series of subsets of adult CBA Ly-2-L3T4- thymocytes which were B2A2-M1/69- and Pgp-1+ all included strongly F23.1-positive cells. A minor subset, negative for most markers except Pgp-1 and presumed on the basis of this phenotype and some reconstitution studies to include the earliest intrathymic precursors, contained 28% F23.1-positive cells. However, no F.23.1-positive cells were detected in equivalent "prethymic" populations from bone marrow or from athymic mouse spleen. The subsets of Ly-2-L3T4- thymocytes which were Ly-1 high, B2A2-M1/69-, and Pgp-1+ all contained about 70% F23.1-positive cells, indicating a V beta 8 usage much higher than the mature T cell average. These results indicate that a series of distinct developmental events have occurred within these CD4-CD8- thymocytes previously considered as a single group of early precursor cells, and that some aspects of repertoire selection may be occurring amongst thymocytes which lack CD4 or CD8.     

High levels of CD45 are coordinately expressed with CD4 and CD8 on avian thymocytes.

In this paper we describe the avian homolog of mammalian CD45. We show that this Ag is expressed on all leukocytes but not on erythroid cells or their immediate precursors. Immunoprecipitations demonstrated that B lineage cells from the bursa of Fabricius expressed a higher molecular mass variant (215 kDa) than did T lineage cells from the thymus (190 kDa), and crucially, these high molecular mass molecules had intrinsic phosphotyrosine phosphatase activity characteristic of mammalian CD45. We show that levels of CD45 expression as detected by mAb LT40 in the avian thymus are heterogeneous and further that mAb LT40 can deplete all phosphotyrosine phosphatase activity from thymocyte membrane preparations. Therefore total levels of CD45 are heterogeneous among avian thymocytes. Specifically, 87 to 89% of thymocytes expressed fourfold higher levels of surface CD45 (CD45hi) than the remaining 11 to 13% (CD45lo). The CD45lo population contained exclusively thymocytes with the phenotype CD3-4-8lo, characteristic of the immediate precursors to the CD3-4+8+ thymic population which are CD45hi. The shift from low to high levels of surface CD45 expression therefore occurred at the same stage as the transition from CD4-8lo to CD4+8+ and before the expression of CD3. The protein tyrosine kinase activity associated with CD4 and CD8 (p56lck) and the phosphatase activity of CD45 have been implicated elsewhere in jointly regulating peripheral T cell signal transduction and subsequent cellular responses. The coordinated expression of high levels of CD45 with both CD4 and CD8 in the avian thymus supports the possibility that these molecules may function together in regulating thymocyte growth and/or differentiation.     

Subpopulations of mature murine thymocytes: properties of CD4-CD8+ and CD4+CD8- thymocytes lacking the heat-stable antigen

The heat-stable antigen (HSA), recognized by the monoclonal antibodies M1/69, B2A2, and J11d, is low or absent on the surface of most murine peripheral T cells but present on all but 3% of thymocytes. The CD4-CD8+ and CD4+CD8- or "single positive" thymic populations may be divided into further subgroups based on surface HSA expression. One group, CD4-CD8+ and expressing very high levels of HSA (HSA++), is an immature, T cell antigen receptor (TcR) negative, outer cortical blast cell. However, a further subdivision of CD4-CD8+ and CD4+CD8- single positives may be made, into those negative to low for HSA (HSA-) and those expressing moderate amounts of HSA (HSA+). The proportion of HSA- single positives is low in the thymus of young mice, whereas the proportion of HSA+ single positives is similar to that of the adult. Both the HSA- and the HSA+ subsets of single positive thymocytes from adult mice are CD3+ and express the normal peripheral T cell incidence of V beta 8 determinants on the TcR. On stimulation with concanavalin A in limit-dilution culture both HSA- and HSA+ subsets of single positive thymocytes give a high frequency of proliferating clones, and the clones from both HSA- and HSA+ subsets of CD4-CD8+ thymocytes are cytotoxic. Thus both HSA- and HSA+ single positive thymocytes are functionally mature. The HSA- subsets of single positive thymocytes differ from the HSA+ subsets in being slightly larger in size, in expressing higher levels of MEL-14, in binding more peanut agglutinin, and in including a proportion of cells expressing high levels of the Pgp-1 glycoprotein. It is suggested that HSA- CD4-CD8+ and HSA- CD4+CD8- thymocytes are more mature than their HSA+ counterparts, and might represent a previously activated or "memory" thymic subpopulation.     

Serum levels of soluble IL-2R, CD4 and CD8 in bronChial asthma

The aim of the present study was to compare serum levels of soluble forms of interleukin-2 receptor, CD4 and CD8, released by lymphocytes during activation of the immune system, in patients with allergic bronchial asthma, with those in healthy subjects. Significantly higher levels of soluble IL-2R and soluble CD4 were found in patients with asthma compared with the control group. In contrast, lower levels of soluble CD8 values were found in patients with asthma compared to the control group. Significant correlations were found for both sIL-2R and sCD4 and these two molecules, with lung function measured as bronchial responsiveness to inhaled methacholine. These results strengthen previous suggestions that in allergic bronchial asthma, activation of T cells plays a significant role in the disease pathogenesis.     

IL-4 inhibits IL-2 synthesis and IL-2-induced up-regulation of IL-2R alpha but not IL-2R beta chain in CD4+ human T cells.

There is growing evidence to suggest a regulatory role of IL-4 in the immune system affecting both proliferation and lymphokine production. In the present work we have analyzed the effect of IL-4 on IL-2 and IFN-gamma synthesis by stimulating CD4+ human T cells (+10% accessory cells) with Con A in the presence of several doses (1 to 100 U/ml) of human rIL-4. The results showed an impaired IL-2 and IFN-gamma synthesis in the presence of IL-4. This inhibition was dose dependent and was evident only when IL-4 was added in the first 2 h of culture. Moreover, the external addition of IL-2 did not revert the inhibitory effect of IL-4 on IL-2 and IFN-gamma synthesis induced by Con A. We have also analyzed the effect of IL-4 on the expression of both alpha- and beta-chains of the IL-2R. Although the expression of IL-2R alpha mRNA was not modified after 6 h in culture in the presence of IL-4, a decrease was observed at 24 and 48 h. The addition of rIL-2 showed that the inhibition in IL-2R alpha expression could be explained by an impairment in the up-regulatory signal transmitted through the IL-2R. In addition to this, IL-4 did not modify the IL-2R beta mRNA expression at 6 and 24 h although a decreased expression was observed at 48 h which could be explained by the defective IL-2 production. The differential effect of IL-4 on the up-regulatory effect of IL-2 in the expression of IL-2R alpha and IL-2R beta suggest the existence of different regulatory mechanisms acting on the expression of both chains.     

The DTH-initiating Thy-1+ cell is double-negative (CD4-, CD8-) and CD3-, and expresses IL-3 receptors, but no IL-2 receptors

The elicitation of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) requires an early-acting Thy-1+ cell that produces an Ag-specific, non-MHC-restricted factor that initiates DTH by sensitizing the local tissue for release of the vasoactive amine serotonin. We characterized the phenotype of this DTH-initiating cell by treating cells from sensitized mice with different antibodies and then either with rabbit C or anti-Ig panning or bead separation to deplete various subpopulations. We then transferred these cells i.v. into naive recipients that were challenged to elicit DTH. Our findings indicate that the early DTH-initiating cell is Thy-1+, Lyt-1+, CD4-, CD8- and CD3-, whereas the classical, late DTH effector T cell is Thy-1+, Lyt-1+, CD4+, CD8-, and CD3+. We hypothesize that DTH-initiating cells are primitive T cells with Ag receptors that can bind Ag without MHC-restriction. This hypothesis was supported by the finding that two different antibodies, that both bind T cell-derived Ag-binding molecules, eliminated the DTH-initiating, cell but did not affect the late component, MHC-restricted CD4+, CD3+ T cell. Additional experiments with antibodies against restricted determinants of the T-200 glycoprotein family (CD45R) showed that the early but not the late cell is positive for B220, which is usually present on B cells, and on some activated T cells. Also, the DTH-initiating cell is Il-2R-, but Il-3R+; whereas the late component DTH T cell is IL-2R+ and IL-3-. Our findings suggest that DTH-initiating cells may be Ag-specific lymphoid precursor cells that arise before final differentiation along the pathway leading to mature T or B cells. Our results indicate that antigen-specific Thy-1+, CD3-, CD4-, CD8- cells function in vivo to initiate DTH reactions.     

High IL-4 production is a stable phenotype of CD8CD45RACD27 T cells

CD27^neg T cells are found only among CD4^pos-CD45RO^pos T cells and represent a T cell subset functionally distinct from CD27^pos T cells. We examined CD4^posCD45RO^pos T cells that were sorted into CD27^neg and CD27^pos populations for their cytokine production in response to different activation pathways. We found that CD27^neg T cells are characterized by high IL-4 and low IL-2 production, regardless of whether the cells were activated through CD3 plus CD28, CD2 plus CD28, or PHA plus PMA. However, subpopulation-specific patterns of cytokines were the clearest demonstrable following CD2 plus CD28 stimulation. We conclude from these data that high IL-4 production is a stable phenotype of CD27^neg T cells.     

Responsiveness of fetal and adult CD4-, CD8- thymocytes to T cell activation

Day-14 fetal CD4-, CD8- thymocytes showed a greater proliferative response to PMA + IL-4 than did adult double-negative thymocytes. In contrast, adult double-negative thymocytes were more responsive to PMA + IL-1 + IL-2 or to IL-1 + IL-2 alone. The adult double-negative thymocytes showed significantly greater proliferation than fetal thymocytes after stimulation via anti-CD3 or anti-Thy-1 in the presence or absence of interleukins (IL-1 + IL-2 or IL-4). Adult CD4-, CD8- thymocytes also exhibited greater calcium mobilization following anti-CD3 stimulation IL-2-dependent activation with anti-Thy-1 or IL-1 + IL-2 in the absence of PMA resulted in marked expansion of CD 3+, F23.1+, CD4-, CD8- thymocytes, a population absent in fetal thymocytes but constituting 4% of pre-cultured CD4-, CD8- adult thymocytes. IL-4 + PMA failed to expand this CD 3+ population. It is hypothesized that before expression of functional TCR, T cell development may be more dependent on activation pathways not using IL-2; after TCR expression, IL-2-dependent pathways, including Thy-1-mediated stimulation, become functional.     

Characterization and differentiation of CD4-, CD8- thymocytes sorted with the Ly-24 marker

Heterogeneity within the CD4-, CD8- thymocyte population was explored by flow microfluorometry on thymocytes from 6-wk-old female C57BL/6 mice. Double negative cells were obtained by twice killing thymocytes with anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 antibodies. The resultant population lacked CD4, CD8, and Ig on cell surfaces; it contained cells bearing Ly-24 (27%), Ly-6C (6%), and Ly-5 (B220) detected by 6B2 (6%). These markers are the same as those characteristic of lpr/lpr T cells; they also are found on bone marrow cells. In order to investigate the maturational pathway of CD4-, CD8- thymocytes, such cells were cultured in vitro for 6 days with phorbol myristate acetate + calcium ionophore. There was a marked increase in cells bearing Ly-24 with time; by 6 days essentially all bore Ly-24. A lesser increase (to 15%) in 6B2 + Thy-1 positive cells was observed. Small numbers of cells bearing CD4 and/or CD8 also were found after 6 days in vitro. In additional studies, CD4-, CD8- cells were first sorted with respect to Ly-24 and then cultured with phorbol myristate acetate + calcium ionophore. Ly-24+ cells proliferated vigorously and formed clusters whereas Ly-24- cells did not. The former gave rise to large numbers of CD4+, CD8+ cells; the latter exhibited little differentiation. These studies demonstrate substantial heterogeneity within the CD4-, CD8- thymocyte population. Use of the markers Ly-24, Ly6C, and 6B2 allows a subdivision of such progenitor thymocytes. Different stages of maturation as well as possible lineages of cells may be investigated by combining such hemopoietic cell surface markers with in vitro culture.     

NK1.1+ thymocytes. Adult murine CD4-, CD8- thymocytes contain an NK1.1+, CD3+, CD5hi, CD44hi, TCR-V beta 8+ subset.

CD4-, CD8- thymocytes were purified from thymi obtained from normal C57BL/6 mice. By flow cytometry analysis, 5 to 10% of these double negative (DN) thymocytes were found to express NK1.1 on their surface. The NK1.1+ DN thymocytes were demonstrated, by two-color fluorescence, to be CD3lo, CD5hi, CD44hi, J11d-, B220-, MEL 14-, IL2R- with 60% expressing TCR-V beta 8 as determined by the mAb F23.1. In contrast, splenic and peripheral blood NK cells were NK1.1+, CD3-, CD5-, TCR-V beta 8- with 40 to 60% being MEL 14+. Unlike peripheral NK cells, fresh DN thymocytes enriched for NK1.1+ cells were unable to kill YAC-1, the classical murine NK cell target. However, these cells were able to mediate anti-CD3 redirected lysis even when they were assayed immediately after purification, i.e., with no culture or stimulation. These data demonstrate that adult murine thymocytes contain NK1.1+ cells which are distinct, both by function and phenotype, from peripheral NK cells. These data also raise the issue of a possible NK/T bipotential progenitor cell.     

Rapid response to Con A by CD4+CD45R- rat memory lymphocytes as compared to CD4+CD45R+ lymphocytes

Functionally distinct subpopulations within the CD4+ subset of T lymphocytes have been described in man, rat, and mouse. In the rat different functions have been assigned to CD45R+ and CD45R- T helper cells. The CD45R+ in contrast to the CD45R- T helper cells have been reported to produce IL-2 and to proliferate well in response both to Con A and in MLR. In the present investigation the kinetics of the response to Con A by the CD45R+ and CD45R- rat T helper subsets have been analyzed. We confirm a strong proliferative response to Con A by CD4+CD45R+ rat T lymphocytes and also that they are the best IL-2 producers. We further demonstrate that CD4+CD45R- cells also produce IL-2, although in order to appreciate this production quantitatively by assays of the culture supernatants it was necessary to block IL-2 absorption by IL-2 receptor (IL-2R) antibodies. This blockage was of importance also in comparisons of the two subsets, since they showed different kinetics of IL-2R appearance. It is demonstrated that the CD4+CD45R- cells respond more rapidly to Con A than the CD4+CD45R+ cells as reflected by phenotypic conversion, IL-2 production, and proliferation. The fast response of the CD4+CD45R- T subset shown in the present study of rat cells and analogous studies of human cells suggests that the memory compartment of T cells besides other characteristics also has the capacity for a more rapid response than naive lymphocytes.     

Production of lymphokine mRNA by CD45R+ and CD45R- helper T cells from human peripheral blood and by human CD4+ T cell clones

The expression of lymphokine mRNA by human CD4+CD45R+ and CD4+CD45R- Th cells was assessed after mitogen stimulation. These Ag have previously been shown to relate closely to virgin and primed T cells, respectively. CD4+CD45R+ (virgin) and CD4+CD45R- (primed) cell fractions were isolated by sorting double-labeled cells with a fluorescence-activated cell sorter. CD4+CD45R+ cells produced high levels of IL-2 mRNA when stimulated with either PMA together with calcium ionophore, or with PHA, but they expressed only trace quantities of mRNA for IL-4 or IFN-gamma. In contrast, CD4+CD45R- cells produced high levels of mRNA for IL-2, IL-4, and IFN-gamma. After 14 days of continuous culture, CD4+CD45R+ Th cells lost expression of the CD45R Ag, but gained high level expression of CDw29, such that they were indistinguishable from the cell population which originally expressed this Ag. At the same time, they acquired the ability to synthesize IL-4 mRNA. It seemed likely that the broad lymphokine profile of primed Th cells might mask clonal heterogeneity. Analysis of 122 CD4+ T cell clones showed that all of them synthesized IL-2 mRNA. One clone failed to express IL-4 mRNA, but did produce those for IL-2 and IFN-gamma. A total of 34 of the clones was investigated to determine expression of IFN-gamma mRNA; two of these clones were negative for IFN-gamma mRNA, and both expressed IL-2 and IL-4 message. These data suggest that while fresh virgin and primed peripheral blood T cells show a clear resolution of lymphokine production, a simple subdivision of human CD4+ T cell clones on the basis of their lymphokine production (such as that reported for mouse Th cell clones) is not possible.