Evaluation of Recovery Methods to Detect Coliforms in Water

Various recovery methods used to detect coliforms in water were evaluated by applying the membrane filter chamber technique. The membrane filter chambers, containing pure-culture suspensions of Escherichia coli or natural suspensions of raw sewage, were immersed in the stream environment. Samples were withdrawn from the chamber at regular time intervals and enumerated by several detection methods. In general, multiple-tube fermentation techniques gave better recovery than plating or membrane filtration procedures. The least efficient method of recovery resulted when using membrane filtration procedures, especially as the exposure period of the organisms to the stream environment increased. A 2-h enrichment on a rich, nonselective medium before exposure to selective media improved the recovery of fecal coliforms with membrane filtration techniques. Substantially enhanced recoveries of E. coli from pure-culture suspensions and of fecal coliforms from raw-sewage suspensions were observed when compared with recoveries obtained by direct primary exposure to selective media. Such an enrichment period appears to provide a nontoxic environment for the gradual adjustment and repair of injured cells.     

Method for the Detection of Injured Vibrio parahaemolyticus in Seafoods

The sensitivity of Vibrio parahaemolyticus cells to refrigeration and frozen storage and the development of a method for detecting injured and uninjured V. parahaemolyticus cells were studied. Cell suspensions in different kinds of seafood homogenates were either regrigerated (4°C) or frozen (−20°C), stored, and examined for cell survival during storage. V. parahaemolyticus cells were sensitive to both storage temperatures. Many cells died, and many survivors were sublethally injured. In general, refrigeration storage appeared to be more injurious than frozen storage. The initial recovery of the sublethally injured cells was highest in a nutritionally rich, nonselective liquid medium such as Trypticase soy broth, whereas maximum cell multiplication was observed in Trypticase soy broth containing 3% NaCl. The sublethally injured V. parahaemolyticus cells demonstrated sensitivity to the selective enrichment medium, glucose salt teepol broth. From these findings, a new method (designated as the “repair-detection” method) was developed for the isolation and enumeration of V. parahaemolyticus. Comparative studies between the recommended and the repair-detection methods showed that injured V. parahaemolyticus cells were present in commercial seafoods and that the repair-detection method was definitely more effective for the detection of total numbers of V. parahaemolyticus cells.     

Proceedings: Repair of injury in Salmonella anatum cells after freezing and thawing in milk

Fast freezing and slow thawing of Salmonella anatum cells in nonfat milk solids resulted in about 20% death and 50% injury of the cells surviving the treatment. Death was defined as the inability to form colonies on a nonselective plating medium [xylose-lysine-peptone agar (XLP)] after freezing and thawing. Injury was defined as the inability to form colonies on a selective plating medium (XLP with 0.2% sodium desoxycholate added). The injured cells repaired rapidly and within 2 hr at 25 °C, in the presence of 0.1% milk solids; all the injured cells regained the ability to form colonies on the selective medium. The treated cells showed a 1-hr extended lag phase of growth as compared to the unfrozen cells. Milk solids concentration in the freezing and repair menstrua influenced injury, repair of injury, and death. The repair process was affected by the pH and temperature of environment in which the injured cells were incubated. Maximum repair occurred at pH values between 6.0 and 7.4 and temperatures from 25 to 42 °C. The data suggested repair did not require the synthesis of protein, ribonucleic acid, or cell-wall mucopeptide but did require energy synthesis.     

Effect of Rehydration on Recovery, Repair, and Growth of Injured Freeze-Dried Salmonella anatum

From 70 to 90% of the Salmonella anatum cells that survived freeze-drying in nonfat milk solids were injured. After rehydration, these injured survivors failed to grow on a selective plating medium containing deoxycholate but could form colonies on a nonselective medium. In a suitable environment after rehydration, injury disappeared in most of these cells. The rate of this repair at 25 C was very rapid initially and, in a medium containing milk solids, was completed within 1 hr after rehydration. The repaired cells initiated growth about 1 hr later than normal cells and grew at a slower rate. In a medium containing milk solids, initial recovery, extent of repair of injury, initiation of growth, and rate of growth were not influenced by supplementation with extra nutrients in other rehydration media. Rehydration controlled by modifying the concentrations of lactose, sucrose, or milk solids in the rehydration medium influenced the recovery of cells and the time that growth was initiated. Glycerol failed to increase recovery. Higher numbers of cells were recovered by rehydrating at 15 to 25 C, but an earlier initiation of growth and more rapid growth were observed at 35 C.     

Method for the detection of injured Vibrio parahaemolyticus in seafoods.

The sensitivity of Vibrio parahaemolyticus cells to refrigeration and frozen storage and the development of a method for detecting injured and uninjured V. parahaemolyticus cells were studied. Cell suspensions in different kinds of seafood homogenates were either regrigerated (4 degrees C) or frozen (-20 degrees C), stored, and examined for cell survival during storage. V. parahaemolyticus cells were sensitive to both storage temperatures. Many cells died, and many survivors were sublethally injured. In general, refrigeration storage appeared to be more injurious than frozen storage. The initial recovery of the sublethally injured cells was highest in a nutritionally rich, nonselective liquid medium such as Trypticase soy broth, whereas maximum cell multiplication was observed in Trypticase soy broth containing 3% NaCl. The sublethally injured V. parahaemolyticus cells demonstrated sensitivity to the selective enrichment medium, glucose salt teepol broth. From these findings, a new method (designated as the "repair-detection" method) was developed for the isolation and enumeration of V. parahaemolyticus. Comparative studies between the recommended and the repair-detection methods showed that injured V. parahaemolyticus cells were present in commercial seafoods and that the repair-detection method was definitely more effective for the detection of total numbers of V. parahaemolyticus cells.     

Agar Underlay Method for Recovery of Sublethally Heat-Injured Bacteria

A method of recovering sublethally heat-injured bacteria was developed. The procedure (termed the agar underlay method) uses a nonselective agar underlaid with a selective medium. In a two-chambered petri dish, the Lutri plate (LP), a nonselective agar is inoculated with a population of sublethally heat-injured bacteria. After a 2-h repair incubation period, selective agar is added to the bottom chamber of the LP and incubated. By diffusing through the nonselective top agar, selective agents from the underlay medium impart selectivity to the system. By the agar underlay method, recovery rates of the heat-injured food-borne pathogens Escherichia coli O157:H7 and Salmonella typhimurium were not different (P > 0.05) from recovery rates determined with nonselective media. Sublethally heat-injured cells (60°C for 1.5 min in buffer or 80°C for 30 s on meat surfaces) grew and produced a typical colony morphology and color reaction when the agar underlay procedure was used with the appropriate respective selective agars. Unlike agar overlay methods for injury repair, the agar underlay procedure allows the typical selective-medium colony morphology to develop and allows colonies to be more easily picked for further characterization. Higher recovery rates of heat-injured fecal enterococci from bovine fecal samples and total coliforms from animal waste lagoons were obtained by the agar underlay method with selective agars than by direct plating on the respective selective media.     

THE INFLUENCE OF THE MODE OF NUTRITION ON THE DIGESTIVE SYSTEM OF OCHROMONAS MALHAMENSIS

The intracellular distribution and level of acid hydrolases in Ochromonas malhamensis were studied in cells grown osmotrophically in a defined medium, in a carbon-free starvation medium, and during phagotrophy in each of these media. By cytochemical techniques, little enzymic reaction product was observed in the vacuoles of osmotrophic cells grown in the defined medium. Starved cells, however, contained autophagic vacuoles and cannibalized other Ochromonas cells. Dense enzymic reaction product was observed in the digestive vacuoles and in the Golgi cisternae of these starved cells. Moreover, starved cells and cells grown in a nutritionally complete medium ingested Escherichia coli which appeared in digestive vacuoles containing enzymic reaction product. Biochemical assays for lysosomal acid phosphatase (E.C. 3.1.3.2 orthophosphoric monoester phosphohydrolase) and acid ribonuclease (E.C. 2.7.7.16 ribonucleate nucleotido-2'-transferase) were done on Ochromonas cultures in the same experimental treatments and under identical assay conditions as the cytochemical study. During starvation, the acid hydrolase specific activities were consistently twice those found in cells grown in an osmotrophic complete medium. Ochromonas fed E. coli showed no increase in acid hydrolase specific activity as compared to controls not fed E. coli. The latency of lysosomal acid hydrolases in cells fixed with glutaraldehyde was reduced, suggesting that this fixative increases lysosomal membrane permeability and may release enzymes or their reaction products into the cytoplasmic matrix during cytochemical analysis. This could explain the cytoplasmic staining artifact sometimes observed with glutaraldehyde-fixed cells when studied by the Gomori technique. This study confirms that Ochromonas malhamensis, a phytoflagellate, does produce digestive vacuoles and can ingest bacteria, thereby fulfilling its role as a heterotroph in an aquatic food chain. When Ochromonas is grown in a nutritionally complete osmotrophic medium, phagocytosis causes appearance of acid hydrolases in the digestive vacuoles, whereas the total activity of the enzymes remains unchanged. An organic carbon-free medium strongly stimulates acid hydrolaes activity and causes these enzymes to appear in the digestive vacuoles whether phagocytosis occurs or not.     

Cell envelope damage in Escherichia coli caused by short-term stress in water.

Physiological and morphological changes in Escherichia coli exposed to oligotrophic natural waters and reagent grade water were studied. Several lines of evidence indicated that short-term exposure in water causes cellular envelope damage. Increasing susceptibility to lysozyme, lag time before cell division, and injury as defined by differential counts on selective and nonselective media occurred with exposure time. Electron micrographs of injured cells showed morphological changes in cell envelope.     

Survival ofEscherichia coli andYersinia enterocolitica in stream water: Comparison of field and laboratory exposure

Experiments were done to compare the influence of three aquatic exposure methods on the behavior of pathogenic and nonpathogenic enteric bacteria (Yersinia enterocolitica andEscherichia coli). Bacterial suspensions were exposed to stream water in membrane diffusion chambers in situ as well as in the laboratory using a large vessel of stream water and in enclosed bottles. The persistence of culturability of the bacterial suspensions was dependent upon the method of aquatic exposure. This difference was most apparent during the initial six days of each experiment. A steady decline in colony forming units was seen after a short stationary period in chambers in situ, while there was an abrupt increase in bacteria within chambers exposed in the laboratory. A rapid initial decrease was observed in the experimental variation using bottles, accompanied by higher levels of injury inE. coli and reduced expression of plasmid-borne virulence phenotypes inY. enterocolitica. However, there were no changes in the plasmid profiles of either organism throughout the 21-day duration of the experiments. In addition, the survival and injury of pathogenic and nonpathogenic strains of both test bacteria was very similar with aquatic exposure. These results suggest that the response of enteric bacteria in aquatic environments is influenced by experimental design as well as other factors and that the comparison of survival data should only be attempted when similar methods are used.     

Minimal Medium Recovery of Thermally Injured Salmonella senftenberg 4969

Exposure of Salmonella senftenberg 4969 to sublethal heating in phosphate buffer, pH 7·0, at 52· produced thermally injured cells characterized by their relative inability to form colonies on trypticase soy yeast extract agar compared to minimal medium (M9) agar. During subsequent incubation at 37· in liquid media, more injured cells were capable of repair in M9 than in nutrient media used for pre-enrichment purposes. M9 was superior to lactose broth as a liquid holding medium to restore the ability of injured cells to grow on both rich and selective agar media. The addition of food products produced a more favourable environment for the repair of thermally injured cells in M9 rather than lactose broth. Pre-enrichment in M9 was 100 times more effective than using lactose broth as the preliminary step in the detection of S. senftenberg in laboratory pasteurized liquid egg albumen.     

The effect of free chlorine onEscherichia coli populations

The effect of free chlorine onEscherichia coli populations was studied by chlorination of a population of 10⁵ cells/ml. This cell density was low enough for the free-to-combined chlorine ratio to be 6.01 or greater. The predominance of free chlorine resulted in rapid and complete population death.Survivors obtained by dechlorination prior to complete population death were recovered equally well on nonselective and selective media. Although this suggests that survivors are not injured, evidence of survivor injury was observed.Colonies resulting from growth of these survivors had a smaller diameter than colonies from unchlornated controls. This suggests that the chlorinated cells have an increased lag and provides indirect evidence of survivor injury. Injury was indicated directly by an increase in the lag time of surviving cells in slide culture. Variability in the severity of free-chlorine-induced injury was indicated by a broadened range in the survivor lag times.     

Survival and virulence of copper- and chlorine-stressed Yersinia enterocolitica in experimentally infected mice.

The effect of gastric pH on the viability and virulence of Yersinia enterocolitica O:8 after exposure to sublethal concentrations of copper and chlorine was determined in mice. Viability and injury were assessed with a nonselective TLY agar (tryptic soy broth containing lactose, yeast extract, and agar) and two selective media, TLYD agar (TLY agar plus sodium deoxycholate) and CIN agar (cefsulodin-Irgasan-novobiocin agar). Both copper and chlorine caused injury which was manifested by the inability of the cells to grow on selective media. CIN agar was more restrictive to the growth of injured cells than TLYD agar. Injury of the exposed cells was further enhanced in the gastric environment of mice. Besides injury, the low gastric pH caused extensive loss of viability in copper-exposed cells. Lethality in the chlorine-exposed cells was less extensive, and a portion of the inoculum (5.2 X 10(5) of 1 X 10(7) inoculated cells) reached the small intestine 5 min postinoculation. No adverse effect on the injured cells was apparent in the small intestine, and a substantial revival (approximately 70%) of the injury occurred in 3 to 4 h after intraluminal inoculation. The virulence of chlorine-stressed Y. enterocolitica in orally inoculated mice was similar to that of the control culture, but copper-stressed cells showed reduced virulence. Virulence was partly restored by oral administration of sodium bicarbonate before the inoculation of copper-exposed cells. Neutralization of gastric acidity had no effect on the virulence of the control or chlorine-stressed cells. The results of this study indicate that the extensive injury caused by the low gastric pH does not affect the virulence potential of chlorine-exposed cells. However, extensive cell death in the mouse stomach is responsible for the reduced virulence of the copper-stressed bacteria.     

The enumeration of chlorine-injured Escherichia coli and Enterococcus faecalis is enhanced under conditions where reactive oxygen species are neutralized

AIM: To investigate the effect of neutralization of reactive oxygen species (ROS-neutralized conditions) on the enumeration of chlorine-injured Escherichia coli and Enterococcus faecalis using selective and nonselective media. METHODS: Pure cultures of E. coli NCTC8912 and Ent. faecalis NCTC775 were injured using dilute sodium hypochlorite, at free chlorine levels of 0.6 and 0.9 microg ml(-1), respectively, and then enumerated at 37 degrees C by surface plate counts on nonselective nutrient (N) agar and on several selective media, either under (i) standard aerobic conditions; (ii) aerobic conditions using growth medium, supplemented with 0.05%-w/v sodium pyruvate, to neutralize peroxides; or (iii) conditions designed to neutralize ROS, using a combination of 0.05%-w/v sodium pyruvate in the growth medium, together with incubation in an anaerobic jar. RESULTS: The counts obtained on the nonselective medium were lowest under aerobic conditions in unsupplemented medium, higher in pyruvate-supplemented (peroxide-neutralized) medium and highest for ROS-neutralized conditions. Counts for the selective media were often lower than those for nonselective N (nutrient) agar, with enhancement under peroxide-neutralized conditions and a further increase in counts under ROS-neutralized conditions. Broadly similar observations were made for three other strains of each organism. CONCLUSIONS: Chlorine-injured E. coli and Ent. faecalis become sensitive to ROS, giving higher counts under ROS-neutralized enumeration conditions than under conventional aerobic conditions. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The enhancement in counts observed under ROS-neutralized conditions indicate that the addition of pyruvate to the growth medium may not fully counteract the effects of sublethal injury under aerobic conditions, which is a novel observation. Thus, ROS-neutralized conditions may be required for optimal enumeration of faecal indicator bacteria. Furthermore, the lower counts, obtained using selective media indicate that the sensitivity of chlorine-injured bacteria to selective agents is not necessarily reversed under ROS-neutralized conditions.     

Survival and virulence of copper- and chlorine-stressed Yersinia enterocolitica in experimentally infected mice

The effect of gastric pH on the viability and virulence of Yersinia enterocolitica O:8 after exposure to sublethal concentrations of copper and chlorine was determined in mice. Viability and injury were assessed with a nonselective TLY agar (tryptic soy broth containing lactose, yeast extract, and agar) and two selective media, TLYD agar (TLY agar plus sodium deoxycholate) and CIN agar (cefsulodin-Irgasan-novobiocin agar). Both copper and chlorine caused injury which was manifested by the inability of the cells to grow on selective media. CIN agar was more restrictive to the growth of injured cells than TLYD agar. Injury of the exposed cells was further enhanced in the gastric environment of mice. Besides injury, the low gastric pH caused extensive loss of viability in copper-exposed cells. Lethality in the chlorine-exposed cells was less extensive, and a portion of the inoculum (5.2 X 10(5) of 1 X 10(7) inoculated cells) reached the small intestine 5 min postinoculation. No adverse effect on the injured cells was apparent in the small intestine, and a substantial revival (approximately 70%) of the injury occurred in 3 to 4 h after intraluminal inoculation. The virulence of chlorine-stressed Y. enterocolitica in orally inoculated mice was similar to that of the control culture, but copper-stressed cells showed reduced virulence. Virulence was partly restored by oral administration of sodium bicarbonate before the inoculation of copper-exposed cells. Neutralization of gastric acidity had no effect on the virulence of the control or chlorine-stressed cells. The results of this study indicate that the extensive injury caused by the low gastric pH does not affect the virulence potential of chlorine-exposed cells. However, extensive cell death in the mouse stomach is responsible for the reduced virulence of the copper-stressed bacteria.     

The Recovery of Indicator Bacteria on Selective Media

S ummary . The recovery of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Escherichia coli , and Streptococcus faecalis from aqueous suspending media has been studied with a rich plating medium (trypticase-soy agar) and selective media. Tap water was highly toxic to all strains investigated. Recovery of Ps. aeruginosa was most successful when phosphate buffer was the diluent. Phosphate buffer did not improve the recovery of E. coli. Streptococcus faecalis remained viable when suspended in double distilled water, deionized distilled water or phosphate buffer. Following a lag period all strains grew in 0.1% peptone water or stream water. Injury preventing recovery of viable cells on selective media occurred during suspension in all aqueous media tested, including those which supported growth. These observations suggest difficulties inherent in the interpretation of bacteriological results obtained during surveys of water sources and a need to reduce the selectivity of recovery media against injured cells.     

Induction of Excessive Deoxyribonucleic Acid Synthesis in Escherichia coli by Nalidixic Acid

Prior treatment of Escherichia coli with nalidixic acid in nutritionally complete medium altered the subsequent pattern of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) synthesis normally observed in nutritionally deficient medium. Transfer of E. coli 15 TAU to an amino acid- and pyrimidine-deficient medium usually resulted in a 40 to 50% increase in DNA content. Previous treatment with nalidixic acid caused a 200 to 300% increase in DNA content under these conditions. The extent of this DNA synthesis depended on the duration of prior exposure to nalidixic acid. The maximal rate of synthesis was obtained after a 40- to 60-min exposure to nalidixic acid and was two to three times that of the control. The induction of this excessive DNA synthesis was prevented by chloramphenicol or phenethyl alcohol, but the synthesis of this DNA was only partially sensitive to these agents. With E. coli TAU-bar, the rate of DNA synthesis, after removal of nalidixic acid, was similar to that of E. coli 15 TAU, but the maximal amount of DNA synthesized was 180 to 185% of that initially present. Cesium chloride density gradient analysis demonstrated that DNA synthesis after removal of nalidixic acid occurs by a semiconservative mode of replication. The density distribution of this DNA was similar to that obtained after thymine starvation. These results suggest that nalidixic acid treatment may induce additional sites for DNA synthesis in E.coli.     

Selective medium for isolation and enumeration of Bifidobacterium spp

A new method was developed for the isolation and enumeration of Bifidobacterium spp. from natural aquatic environments. The method was based on the utilization of a new medium, Bifidobacterium iodoacetate medium 25, and resuscitation techniques were used to isolate injured bifidobacteria. The new medium was tested with a nonselective reference medium on sewage and sewage-polluted surface waters. Relatively little colonial growth of any other bacterial genera occurred; when such colonies did grow, Bifidobacterium could be easily differentiated by its colonial morphology or, after Gram staining, by its typical bifidobacterial morphology.     

Selective medium for isolation and enumeration of Bifidobacterium spp.

A new method was developed for the isolation and enumeration of Bifidobacterium spp. from natural aquatic environments. The method was based on the utilization of a new medium, Bifidobacterium iodoacetate medium 25, and resuscitation techniques were used to isolate injured bifidobacteria. The new medium was tested with a nonselective reference medium on sewage and sewage-polluted surface waters. Relatively little colonial growth of any other bacterial genera occurred; when such colonies did grow, Bifidobacterium could be easily differentiated by its colonial morphology or, after Gram staining, by its typical bifidobacterial morphology.     

Superoxide and hydrogen peroxide in oxygen damage.

Escherichia coli were damaged and killed by exposure to hyperbaric oxygen. Lethality was measured as the decrease in the number of colonies formed upon plating the exposed cells onto rich agar. Damage was assessed by plating onto both rich and minimal agar. Cells which gave rise to visible colonies on rich but not on minimal agar were considered to be damaged. That this differential colony count was largely due to reparable damage rather than to stable mutagenesis was shown by replica plating from the rich onto the minimal agar. Most of the cells which had been unable to grow when directly plated onto minimal agar regained this ability after growth upon rich agar. Repair of the damage imposed by exposure to oxygen was thus more readily accomplished on a nutritionally rich medium. The enzymes superoxide dismutase, catalase, and peroxidase appeared to protect against oxygen damage. It is thus likely that both O₂^? and H₂O₂ are important agents of oxygen toxicity. In accord with this conclusion were the observations that augmented intracellular levels of these enzymes correlated with increased resistance towards oxygen damage, whereas increased respiratory capacity correlated with increased sensitivity towards hyperbaric oxygen.     

Viability of Salmonella spp and indicator microorganisms in seawater using membrane diffusion chambers

Diffusion chambers with polycarbonate membrane-filter side walls were used to study the comparative survival of fecal indicators (Escherichia coli and Streptococcus faecalis) and enteric pathogens (Salmonella enteritidis, S. postdam, S. typhimurium, S. london and S. infantis) in natural seawater. It was observed that the percentages of sublethal injury increased with exposure to the marine environment, and that these environmental injuries depended on the microorganism considered. A large proportion of cells lost their ability to produce colonies on the selective media, but retained this capability on a nonselective medium. All microorganisms showed low survival percentages (less than 11%) after 48 hrs of exposure to seawater, but there is not a high difference among the microbial species studied. The results obtained in the present study showed that there were no differences in the survival rates between the serotypes of Salmonella tested. Moreover, Salmonella spp exhibited a similar persistence to E. coli in the marine environment.