Isothermal Titration Calorimetry for Measuring Macromolecule-Ligand Affinity

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a useful tool for understanding the complete thermodynamic picture of a binding reaction. In biological sciences, macromolecular interactions are essential in understanding the machinery of the cell. Experimental conditions, such as buffer and temperature, can be tailored to the particular binding system being studied. However, careful planning is needed since certain ligand and macromolecule concentration ranges are necessary to obtain useful data. Concentrations of the macromolecule and ligand need to be accurately determined for reliable results. Care also needs to be taken when preparing the samples as impurities can significantly affect the experiment. When ITC experiments, along with controls, are performed properly, useful binding information, such as the stoichiometry, affinity and enthalpy, are obtained. By running additional experiments under different buffer or temperature conditions, more detailed information can be obtained about the system. A protocol for the basic setup of an ITC experiment is given.     

Comparative thermodynamic analysis of cyclic nucleotide binding to protein kinase A

We have investigated the thermodynamic parameters and binding of a regulatory subunit of cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) to its natural low-molecular-weight ligand, cAMP, and analogues thereof. For analysis of this model system, we compared side-by-side isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) with surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Both ITC and SPR analyses revealed that binding of the protein to cAMP or its analogues was enthalpically driven and characterised by similar free energy values (DeltaG=-9.4 to -10.7 kcal mol-1) for all interactions. Despite the similar affinities, binding of the cyclic nucleotides used here was characterised by significant differences in the contribution of entropy (-TDeltaS) and enthalpy (DeltaH) to DeltaG. The comparison of ITC and SPR data for one cAMP analogue further revealed deviations caused by the method. These equilibrium parameters could be complemented by thermodynamic data of the transition state (DeltaHnot equal, DeltaGnot equal, DeltaSnot equal) for both association and dissociation measured by SPR. This direct comparison of ITC and SPR highlights method-specific advantages and drawbacks for thermodynamic analyses of protein/ligand interactions.     

Advances in the analysis of isothermal titration calorimetry data for ligand-DNA interactions

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a well established technique for the study of biological interactions. The strength of ITC is that it directly measures enthalpy changes associated with interactions. Experiments can also yield binding isotherms allowing quantification of equilibrium binding constants, hence an almost complete thermodynamic profile can be established. Principles and application of ITC have been well documented over recent years, experimentally the technique is simple to use and in ideal scenarios data analysis is trivial. However, ITC experiments can be designed such that previously inaccessible parameters can be evaluated. We outline some of these advances, including (1) exploiting different experimental conditions; (2) low affinity systems; (3) high affinity systems and displacement assays. In addition we ask the question: What if data cannot be fit using the fitting functions incorporated in the data-analysis software that came with your ITC? Examples where such data might be generated include systems following non 1:n binding patterns and systems where binding is coupled to other events such as ligand dissociation. Models dealing with such data are now appearing in literature and we summarise examples relevant for the study of ligand-DNA interactions.     

Interaction of porphyrin with G-quadruplex structures

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a sensitive technique for probing bimolecular processes and can provide direct information about the binding affinity and stoichiometry and the key thermodynamic parameters involved. ITC has been used to investigate the interaction of the ligand H2TMPyP to the two DNA quadruplexes, [d(AGGGT)]4 and [d(TGGGGT)]. Analysis of the ITC data reveals that porphyrin/quadruplex binding stoichiometry under saturating conditions is 1:2 for [d(AGGGT)]4 and 2:1 for [d(TGGGGT)], respectively.     

Collecting Variable-concentration Isothermal Titration Calorimetry Datasets in Order to Determine Binding Mechanisms

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is commonly used to determine the thermodynamic parameters associated with the binding of a ligand to a host macromolecule. ITC has some advantages over common spectroscopic approaches for studying host/ligand interactions. For example, the heat released or absorbed when the two components interact is directly measured and does not require any exogenous reporters. Thus the binding enthalpy and the association constant (Ka) are directly obtained from ITC data, and can be used to compute the entropic contribution. Moreover, the shape of the isotherm is dependent on the c-value and the mechanistic model involved. The c-value is defined as c = n[P]tKa, where [P]t is the protein concentration, and n is the number of ligand binding sites within the host. In many cases, multiple binding sites for a given ligand are non-equivalent and ITC allows the characterization of the thermodynamic binding parameters for each individual binding site. This however requires that the correct binding model be used. This choice can be problematic if different models can fit the same experimental data. We have previously shown that this problem can be circumvented by performing experiments at several c-values. The multiple isotherms obtained at different c-values are fit simultaneously to separate models. The correct model is next identified based on the goodness of fit across the entire variable-c dataset. This process is applied here to the aminoglycoside resistance-causing enzyme aminoglycoside N-6''-acetyltransferase-Ii (AAC(6'')-Ii). Although our methodology is applicable to any system, the necessity of this strategy is better demonstrated with a macromolecule-ligand system showing allostery or cooperativity, and when different binding models provide essentially identical fits to the same data. To our knowledge, there are no such systems commercially available. AAC(6'')-Ii, is a homo-dimer containing two active sites, showing cooperativity between the two subunits. However ITC data obtained at a single c-value can be fit equally well to at least two different models a two-sets-of-sites independent model and a two-site sequential (cooperative) model. Through varying the c-value as explained above, it was established that the correct binding model for AAC(6'')-Ii is a two-site sequential binding model. Herein, we describe the steps that must be taken when performing ITC experiments in order to obtain datasets suitable for variable-c analyses.Download video file.^{(61M, mov)}     

What can isothermal titration microcalorimetry experiments tell us about the self‐organization of surfactants into micelles?

The aim of the present review is to give a concise analysis of the thermodynamic parameters obtained from isothermal titration microcalorimetry (ITC) experiments for the characterization of the self‐organization of surfactants into micelles. This review is also focused on works describing some methods allowing to overcome ITC limitation and to extract accurate thermodynamic values from ITC data. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Misuse of thermodynamics in the interpretation of isothermal titration calorimetry data for ligand binding to proteins

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) has given a mass of data on the binding of small molecules to proteins and other biopolymers, with particular interest in drug binding to proteins chosen as therapeutic indicators. Interpretation of the enthalpy data usually follows an unsound protocol that uses thermodynamic relations in circumstances where they do not apply. Errors of interpretation include incomplete definitions of ligand binding and equilibrium constants and neglect of the non-ideality of the solutions under study, leading to unreliable estimates of standard free energies and entropies of binding. The mass of reported thermodynamic functions for ligand binding to proteins estimated from ITC enthalpies alone is consequently of uncertain thermodynamic significance and utility. ITC and related experiments to test the protocol assumptions are indicated. A thermodynamic procedure avoiding equilibrium constants or other reaction models and not requiring protein activities is given. The discussion draws attention to the fundamental but neglected relation between the thermodynamic activity and bioactivity of drugs and to the generally unknown thermodynamic status of ligand solutions, which for drugs relates directly to effective therapeutic dosimetry.     

Ligand binding affinity determined by temperature-dependent circular dichroism: cyclin-dependent kinase 2 inhibitors

To support drug discovery efforts for cyclin-dependent kinase 2 (CDK2), a moderate-throughput binding assay that can rank order or estimate the affinity of lead inhibitors has been developed. The method referred to as temperature-dependent circular dichroism (TdCD) uses the classical temperature-dependent unfolding of proteins by circular dichroism (CD) to measure the degree of protein unfolding in the absence and presence of potential inhibitors. The midpoint of unfolding is the Tm value. Rank ordering the affinity and predictions of the dissociation constant of compounds is obtained by measuring the increase in Tm for different protein-inhibitor complexes. This is the first time an extensive characterization of the TdCD method has been described for characterizing lead inhibitors in a drug discovery mode. The method has several favorable properties. Using the new six-cell Peltier temperature controller for the Jasco 810 spectropolarimeter, one can determine the affinity of 12-18 compounds per day. The method also requires only 20-40 microg protein per sample and can be used to estimate the affinity of compounds with dissociation constants of picomolar to micromolar. An important property of the method for lead discovery is that dissociation constants of approximately 5 microM can be estimated from a single experiment using a low concentration of compound such as 20 microM, which is generally low enough for most small molecules to be soluble for testing. In addition, the method does not require labeling the compound or protein. Although other methods such as isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) can provide a full thermodynamic characterization of binding, ITC requires 1-2 mg protein per sample, cannot readily determine binding constants below nanomolar values, is most versatile with soluble compounds, and has a throughput of two to three experiments per day. The ITC method is not usually used in a high-throughput drug discovery mode; however, using the thermodynamic information from several ITC experiments can make the TdCD method very robust in determining reliable binding constants. Using the kinase inhibitors BMS-250595, purvalanol B, AG-12275, flavopiridol, and several other compounds, it is demonstrated that one can obtain excellent comparisons between the Kd values of binding to CDK2 obtained by TdCD and ITC.     

Impact of protein and ligand impurities on ITC-derived protein–ligand thermodynamics

Background

The thermodynamic characterization of protein–ligand interactions by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a powerful tool in drug design, giving valuable insight into the interaction driving forces. ITC is thought to require protein and ligand solutions of high quality, meaning both the absence of contaminants as well as accurately determined concentrations.

Methods

Ligands synthesized to deviating purity and protein of different pureness were titrated by ITC. Data curation was attempted also considering information from analytical techniques to correct stoichiometry.

Results and conclusions

We used trypsin and tRNA-guanine transglycosylase (TGT), together with high affinity ligands to investigate the effect of errors in protein concentration as well as the impact of ligand impurities on the apparent thermodynamics. We found that errors in protein concentration did not change the thermodynamic properties obtained significantly. However, most ligand impurities led to pronounced changes in binding enthalpy. If protein binding of the respective impurity is not expected, the actual ligand concentration was corrected for and the thus revised data compared to thermodynamic properties obtained with the respective pure ligand. Even in these cases, we observed differences in binding enthalpy of about 4 kJ ⋅ mol^− 1, which is considered significant.

General significance

Our results indicate that ligand purity is the critical parameter to monitor if accurate thermodynamic data of a protein–ligand complex are to be recorded. Furthermore, artificially changing fitting parameters to obtain a sound interaction stoichiometry in the presence of uncharacterized ligand impurities may lead to thermodynamic parameters significantly deviating from the accurate thermodynamic signature.     

Protonation linked equilibria and apparent affinity constants: the thermodynamic profile of the α-chymotrypsin–proflavin interaction

Protonation/deprotonation equilibria are frequently linked to binding processes involving proteins. The presence of these thermodynamically linked equilibria affects the observable thermodynamic parameters of the interaction (K _obs, ΔH _obs⁰). In order to try and elucidate the energetic factors that govern these binding processes, a complete thermodynamic characterisation of each intrinsic equilibrium linked to the complexation event is needed and should furthermore be correlated to structural information. We present here a detailed study, using NMR and ITC, of the interaction between α-chymotrypsin and one of its competitive inhibitors, proflavin. By performing proflavin titrations of the enzyme, at different pH values, we were able to highlight by NMR the effect of the complexation of the inhibitor on the ionisable residues of the catalytic triad of the enzyme. Using ITC we determined the intrinsic thermodynamic parameters of the different equilibria linked to the binding process. The possible driving forces of the interaction between α-chymotrypsin and proflavin are discussed in the light of the experimental data and on the basis of a model of the complex. This study emphasises the complementarities between ITC and NMR for the study of binding processes involving protonation/deprotonation equilibria. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Recent trends and some applications of isothermal titration calorimetry in biotechnology

Isothermal titration calorimeters (ITCs) are thermodynamic instruments used for the determination of enthalpy changes in any physical/chemical reaction. This can be applied in various fields of biotechnology. This review explains ITC applications, especially in bioseparation, drug development and cell metabolism. In liquid chromatography, the separation/purification of specific proteins or polypeptides in a mixture is usually achieved by varying the adsorption affinities of the different proteins/polypeptides for the adsorbent under different mobile-phase conditions and temperatures. Using ITC analysis, the binding mechanism of proteins with adsorbent solid material is derived by elucidating enthalpy and entropy changes, which offer valuable guidelines for designing experimental conditions in chromatographic separation. The binding affinity of a drug with its target is studied by deriving binding enthalpy and binding entropy. To improve the binding affinity, suitable lead compounds for a drug can be identified and their affinity tested by ITC. Recently ITC has also been used in studying cell metabolism. The heat produced by animal cells in culture can be used as a primary indicator of the kinetics of cell metabolism, which provides key information for drug bioactivity and operation parameters for process cell culture.     

INTERACTION OF PORPHYRIN WITH G-QUADRUPLEX STRUCTURES

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a sensitive technique for probing bimolecular processes and can provide direct information about the binding affinity and stoichiometry and the key thermodynamic parameters involved. ITC has been used to investigate the interaction of the ligand H₂TMPyP to the two DNA quadruplexes, [d(AGGGT)]₄ and [d(TGGGGT)]₄. Analysis of the ITC data reveals that porphyrin/quadruplex binding stoichiometry under saturating conditions is 1:2 for [d(AGGGT)]₄ and 2:1 for [d(TGGGGT)]₄, respectively.     

Open-ITC: an alternate computational approach to analyze the isothermal titration calorimetry data of complex binding mechanisms

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is an important technique used in quantitatively analyzing the global mechanism of protein-protein or protein-ligand interactions through thermodynamic measurements. Among different binding mechanisms, the parallel and ligand induced protein oligomerization mechanisms are technically difficult to analyze compared with a sequential binding mechanism. Here, we present a methodology implemented as a program "Open-ITC" that eliminates the need for exact analytical expressions for free ligand concentrations [L] and mole fractions of bound ligand θ that are required for the thermogram analysis. Adopting a genetic algorithm-based optimization, the thermodynamic parameters are determined, and its standard error is evaluated at the global minimum by calculating the Jacobian matrix. This approach yielded a statistically consistent result for a single-site and a two-site binding protein-ligand system. Further, a comparative simulation of a two-step sequential, a parallel, and a ligand induced oligomerization model revealed that their mechanistic differences are discernable in ITC thermograms, only if the first binding step is weaker compared with the second binding step (K(1) 相似文献   

Hot Biological Catalysis: Isothermal Titration Calorimetry to Characterize Enzymatic Reactions

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a well-described technique that measures the heat released or absorbed during a chemical reaction, using it as an intrinsic probe to characterize virtually every chemical process. Nowadays, this technique is extensively applied to determine thermodynamic parameters of biomolecular binding equilibria. In addition, ITC has been demonstrated to be able of directly measuring kinetics and thermodynamic parameters (k_cat, K_M, ΔH) of enzymatic reactions, even though this application is still underexploited. As heat changes spontaneously occur during enzymatic catalysis, ITC does not require any modification or labeling of the system under analysis and can be performed in solution. Moreover, the method needs little amount of material. These properties make ITC an invaluable, powerful and unique tool to study enzyme kinetics in several applications, such as, for example, drug discovery.In this work an experimental ITC-based method to quantify kinetics and thermodynamics of enzymatic reactions is thoroughly described. This method is applied to determine k_cat and K_M of the enzymatic hydrolysis of urea by Canavalia ensiformis (jack bean) urease. Calculation of intrinsic molar enthalpy (ΔH_int) of the reaction is performed. The values thus obtained are consistent with previous data reported in literature, demonstrating the reliability of the methodology.     

Survey of the year 2008: applications of isothermal titration calorimetry

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a fast, accurate and label‐free method for measuring the thermodynamics and binding affinities of molecular associations in solution. Because the method will measure any reaction that results in a heat change, it is applicable to many different fields of research from biomolecular science, to drug design and materials engineering, and can be used to measure binding events between essentially any type of biological or chemical ligand. ITC is the only method that can directly measure binding energetics including Gibbs free energy, enthalpy, entropy and heat capacity changes. Not only binding thermodynamics but also catalytic reactions, conformational rearrangements, changes in protonation and molecular dissociations can be readily quantified by performing only a small number of ITC experiments. In this review, we highlight some of the particularly interesting reports from 2008 employing ITC, with a particular focus on protein interactions with other proteins, nucleic acids, lipids and drugs. As is tradition in these reviews we have not attempted a comprehensive analysis of all 500 papers using ITC, but emphasize those reports that particularly captured our interest and that included more thorough discussions we consider exemplify the power of the technique and might serve to inspire other users. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

The development of a continuous isothermal titration calorimetric method for equilibrium studies

A continuous isothermal titration calorimetry (cITC) method for microcalorimeters has been developed. The method is based on continuous slow injection of a titrant into the calorimetric vessel. The experimental time for a cITC binding experiment is 12-20 min and the number of data points obtained is on the order of 1000. This gives an advantage over classical isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) binding experiments that need 60-180 min to generate 20-30 data points. The method was validated using two types of calorimeters, which differ in calorimetric principle, geometry, stirring, and way of delivering the titrant into the calorimetric vessel. Two different experimental systems were used to validate the method: the binding of Ba(2+) to 18-crown-6 and the binding of cytidine 2'-monophosphate to RNAse A. Both systems are used as standard test systems for titration calorimetry. Computer simulations show that the dynamic range for determination of equilibrium constants can be increased by three orders of magnitude compared to that of classical ITC, making it possible to determine high affinities. Simulations also show an improved possibility to elucidate the actual binding model from cITC data. The simulated data demonstrate that cITC makes it easier to discriminate between different thermodynamic binding models due to the higher density of data points obtained from one experiment.     

Application of ITC in foods: A powerful tool for understanding the gastrointestinal fate of lipophilic compounds

BackgroundIsothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a biophysical technique widely used to study molecular interactions in biological and non-biological systems. It can provide important information about molecular interactions (such as binding constant, number of binding sites, free energy, enthalpy, and entropy) simply by measuring the heat absorbed or released during an interaction between two liquid solutions.Scope of the reviewIn this review, we present an overview of ITC applications in food science, with particular focus on understanding the fate of lipids within the human gastrointestinal tract. In this area, ITC can be used to study micellization of bile salts, inclusion complex formation, the interaction of surface-active molecules with proteins, carbohydrates and lipids, and the interactions of lipid droplets.Major conclusionsITC is an extremely powerful tool for measuring molecular interactions in food systems, and can provide valuable information about many types of interactions involving food components such as proteins, carbohydrates, lipids, surfactants, and minerals. For systems at equilibrium, ITC can provide fundamental thermodynamic parameters that can be used to establish the physiochemical origin of molecular interactions.General significanceIt is expected that ITC will continue to be utilized as a means of providing fundamental information about complex materials such as those found in foods. This knowledge may be used to create functional foods designed to behave in the gastrointestinal tract in a manner that will improve human health and well-being. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Microcalorimetry in the BioSciences — Principles and Applications, edited by Fadi Bou-Abdallah.     

Isothermal titration calorimetry of RNA

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a fast and robust method to study the physical basis of molecular interactions. A single well-designed experiment can provide complete thermodynamic characterization of a binding reaction, including K(a), DeltaG, DeltaH, DeltaS and reaction stoichiometry (n). Repeating the experiment at different temperatures allows determination of the heat capacity change (DeltaC(P)) of the interaction. Modern calorimeters are sensitive enough to probe even weak biological interactions making ITC a very popular method among biochemists. Although ITC has been applied to protein studies for many years, it is becoming widely applicable in RNA biochemistry as well, especially in studies which involve RNA folding and RNA interactions with small molecules, proteins and with other RNAs. This review focuses on best practices for planning, designing and executing effective ITC experiments when one or more of the reactants is an RNA.