Quorum quenching quandary: resistance to antivirulence compounds

Quorum sensing (QS) is the regulation of gene expression in response to the concentration of small signal molecules, and its inactivation has been suggested to have great potential to attenuate microbial virulence. It is assumed that unlike antimicrobials, inhibition of QS should cause less Darwinian selection pressure for bacterial resistance. Using the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa, we demonstrate here that bacterial resistance arises rapidly to the best-characterized compound that inhibits QS (brominated furanone C-30) due to mutations that increase the efflux of C-30. Critically, the C-30-resistant mutant mexR was more pathogenic to Caenorhabditis elegans in the presence of C-30, and the same mutation arises in bacteria responsible for chronic cystic fibrosis infections. Therefore, bacteria may evolve resistance to many new pharmaceuticals thought impervious to resistance.     

Quorum sensing regulation of gene expression: A promising target for drugs against bacterial pathogenicity

Bacteria are sensitive to an increase in population density and respond quickly and coordinately by induction of certain sets of genes. This mode of regulation, known as quorum sensing (QS), is based on the effect of low-molecular-weight signal molecules, autoinducers (AIs). When the population density is high, AIs accumulate in the medium and interact with regulatory receptor proteins. QS systems are global regulators of bacterial gene expression and play a key role in controlling many metabolic processes in the cell, including bacterial virulence. The review considers the molecular mechanisms of QS in different taxonomic groups of bacteria and discusses QS regulation as a possible target in treating bacterial infections. This is a new, alternative strategy of antibacterial therapy, which includes the construction of drugs acting directly against bacterial pathogenicity by suppressing QS (antipathogenicity drugs). This strategy makes it possible to avoid a wide distribution of antibiotic-resistant pathogenic bacteria and the formation of biofilms, which dramatically increase drug resistance.     

细菌群体感应信号网络及其应用

群体感应（Quorum sensing,QS）是一种细菌细胞与细胞间的通讯系统,即细菌通过分泌扩散性小分子信号感知细菌群体的密度,从而引起一组特定基因在转录水平协调表达。大量研究已表明,群体感应系统控制细菌多种生理行为和过程,以及与真核宿主（寄主）的互作。参与群体感应调控的信号分子多种多样,QS系统所调控的功能也具有多样性,甚至菌株专化性。通过聚焦同一细菌中由多个QS系统组成的信号网络,综合评述了不同QS系统之间如何相互作用全局调控基因表达,以及QS系统如何通过与其它全局调控系统整合精细调节细菌的社会行为以及环境适应性及其应用前景。     

Bacterial cell‐to‐cell signaling promotes the evolution of resistance to parasitic bacteriophages

The evolution of host–parasite interactions could be affected by intraspecies variation between different host and parasite genotypes. Here we studied how bacterial host cell‐to‐cell signaling affects the interaction with parasites using two bacteria‐specific viruses (bacteriophages) and the host bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa that communicates by secreting and responding to quorum sensing (QS) signal molecules. We found that a QS‐signaling proficient strain was able to evolve higher levels of resistance to phages during a short‐term selection experiment. This was unlikely driven by demographic effects (mutation supply and encounter rates), as nonsignaling strains reached higher population densities in the absence of phages in our selective environment. Instead, the evolved nonsignaling strains suffered relatively higher growth reduction in the absence of the phage, which could have constrained the phage resistance evolution. Complementation experiments with synthetic signal molecules showed that the Pseudomonas quinolone signal (PQS) improved the growth of nonsignaling bacteria in the presence of a phage, while the activation of las and rhl quorum sensing systems had no effect. Together, these results suggest that QS‐signaling can promote the evolution of phage resistance and that the loss of QS‐signaling could be costly in the presence of phages. Phage–bacteria interactions could therefore indirectly shape the evolution of intraspecies social interactions and PQS‐mediated virulence in P. aeruginosa.     

Quorum sensing of genes expression--perspective drug target against bacterial pathogenicity

Bacteria are capable to sense an increase of cell density population and to reply quickly and coordinately by the induction of special sets of genes. This type of the regulation was named Quorum Sensing (QS); it is based on the effect of low-molecular-weight signaling molecules of different nature (autoinducers) which accumulate in the culture at high density of bacterial population and interact with receptor regulatory proteins. QS systems are the global regulators of bacterial genes expression and play a key role in the control of many metabolic processes in cell including the regulation of virulence of bacteria. Here we review the molecular mechanisms of QS systems functioning in bacteria belonging to different taxonomic groups and discuss the potential of QS regulation as a new drug target for the treatment of bacterial infections. At present this approach is accounted as a new alternative strategy of antimicrobial therapy directed on the development of drugs inhibiting QS regulation and active just against pathogenicity of bacteria (antipathogenic drugs). Such a strategy allows to avoid a wide dissemination of resistant forms of pathogenic bacteria and the formation of biofilms increasing in many times the resistance of bacteria to drug preparations.     

群体感应与病原菌致病性研究进展

群体感应是细菌根据细胞密度变化进行基因表达调控的一种生理行为。当细菌密度达到临界阈值时能释放一些特定的自诱导信号分子,从而调节本种群或同环境中其他种群的群体行为。细菌群体感应参与包括人类、动植物、病原菌在内的多种生物的生物学功能调节,如生物膜的形成、毒力因子的产生、病原菌的耐药性等。深入研究病原菌群体感应系统的调控机制,将提高对病原菌发病机制的认识,有利于以群体感应作为防治疾病策略的研究。系统阐述了群体感应系统的组成类型、群体感应与病原菌致病性的关系,及其在抑制病原菌致病方面的应用。     

Anti-activator QslA defines the quorum sensing threshold and response in Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Quorum sensing (QS) in a bacterial population is activated when extracellular concentration of QS signal reaches a threshold, but how this threshold is determined remains largely unknown. In this study, we report the identification and characterization of a novel anti-activator encoded by qslA in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The null mutation of qslA elevated AHL-dependent QS and PQS signalling, increased the expression of QS-dependent genes, and enhanced the virulence factor production and pathogenicity. We further present evidence that modulation of QS by QslA is due to protein-protein interaction with LasR, which prevents LasR from binding to its target promoter. QslA also influences the threshold concentration of QS signal needed for QS activation; in the absence of qslA, QS is activated by nine times less N-3-oxo-dodecanoyl-homoserine lactone (3-oxo-C12-HSL) than that in wild type. The findings from this study depict a new mechanism that governs the QS threshold in P. aeruginosa.     

细菌群体感应调控多样性及群体感应淬灭

群体感应(Quorum sensing, QS)是细菌通过信号分子分泌、识别,从而调控基因水平转移、毒力因子分泌、芽孢产生及生物膜形成等群体行为的细胞交流机制。干扰信号分子的分泌、识别,可以阻断群体感应,实现群体淬灭。群体淬灭(Quorum quenching, QQ)是目前致病性控制、致腐性预防以及生物膜污染削减的重要策略之一。本文以群体感应信号分泌-识别-响应为主线,将群体感应分为等级、平行及竞争型三类调控方式,并对其特征进行了详细阐述;同时,探讨了信号分子类似物、信号分子降解酶剂、信号受体激活剂/抑制剂等策略在不同调控方式淬灭中的适用性;最后,对群体感应调控及淬灭进行了展望,以期为丰富细菌群体感应认知、促进群体淬灭应用提供参考。     

Questions about the behaviour of bacterial pathogens in vivo

Bacterial pathogens cause disease in man and animals. They have unique biological properties, which enable them to colonize mucous surfaces, penetrate them, grow in the environment of the host, inhibit or avoid host defences and damage the host. The bacterial products responsible for these five biological requirements are the determinants of pathogenicity (virulence determinants). Current knowledge comes from studies in vitro, but now interest is increasing in how bacteria behave and produce virulence determinants within the infected host. There are three aspects to elucidate: bacterial activities, the host factors that affect them and the metabolic interactions between the two. The first is relatively easy to accomplish and, recently, new methods for doing this have been devised. The second is not easy because of the complexity of the environment in vivo and its ever-changing face. Nevertheless, some information can be gained from the literature and by new methodology. The third aspect is very difficult to study effectively unless some events in vivo can be simulated in vitro. The objectives of the Discussion Meeting were to describe the new methods and to show how they, and conventional studies, are revealing the activities of bacterial pathogens in vivo. This paper sets the scene by raising some questions and suggesting, with examples, how they might be answered. Bacterial growth in vivo is the primary requirement for pathogenicity. Without growth, determinants of the other four requirements are not formed. Results from the new methods are underlining this point. The important questions are as follows. What is the pattern of a developing infection and the growth rates and population sizes of the bacteria at different stages? What nutrients are present in vivo and how do they change as infection progresses and relate to growth rates and population sizes? How are these nutrients metabolized and by what bacterial mechanisms? Which bacterial processes handle nutrient deficiencies and antagonistic conditions that may arise? Conventional and new methods can answer the first question and part of the second; examples are described. The difficulties of trying to answer the last two are discussed. Turning to production in vivo of determinants of mucosal colonization, penetration, interference with host defence and damage to the host, here are the crucial questions. Are putative determinants, which have been recognized by studies in vitro, produced in vivo and are they relevant to virulence? Can hitherto unknown virulence determinants be recognized by examining bacteria grown in vivo? Does the complement of virulence determinants change as infection proceeds? Are regulatory processes recognized in vitro, such as ToxR/ToxS, PhoP/PhoQ, quorum sensing and type III secretion, operative in vivo? What environmental factors affect virulence determinant production in vivo and by what metabolic processes? Examples indicate that the answers to the first four questions are ''yes'' in most but not all cases. Attempts to answer the last, and most difficult, question are also described. Finally, sialylation of the lipopolysaccharide of gonococci in vivo by host-derived cytidine 5''-mono-phospho-N-acetyl neuraminic acid, and the effect of host lactate are described. This investigation revealed a new bacterial component important in pathogenicity, the host factors responsible for its production and the metabolism involved.     

Regulation of bacterial virulence by two-component systems

In bacteria, two-component systems (TCS) are widely used signal transduction devices which are engaged in a multitude of gene regulatory systems that respond to changing growth conditions. Many pathogenic bacteria encounter different microenvironments during their infectious cycle and their ability to efficiently adapt to different niches inside and outside of their host organisms is frequently mediated by TCSs, which can, therefore, be considered as an essential prerequisite for their pathogenicity. Although significant progress has been made in the elucidation of basic principles of the signal transduction process itself, in many pathogens the contribution of TCS to bacterial virulence is insufficiently recognized.     

细菌群体感应及其干扰策略的研究进展

群体感应（QS）广泛存在于细菌中,是细菌根据细胞密度变化调控基因表达的一种机制。许多植物病原菌依赖QS调控致病基因和毒性因子的表达,导致植物发病,因此通过抑制QS效应就为控制细菌病害提供了一种有效的方法。目前发现许多途径可以干扰细菌的QS,如：产生可使信号分子降解的酶,产生病原菌信号分子的类似物与信号分子受体蛋白竞争结合来阻断病原菌的群体感应,利用QS中信号分子来诱发寄主抗性。系统阐述了细菌QS及其干扰策略。     

Multiplicity of Quorum Quenching Enzymes: A Potential Mechanism to Limit Quorum Sensing Bacterial Population

Bacteria express certain of their characteristics especially, pathogenicity factors at high cell densities. The process is termed as quorum sensing (QS). QS operates via signal molecules such as acylhomoserine lactones (AHLs). Other bacteria inhibit QS through the inactivation of AHL signals by producing enzymes like AHL-lactonases and -acylases. Comparative genomic analysis has revealed the multiplicity of genes for AHL lactonases (up to 12 copies per genome) among Bacillus spp. and that of AHL-acylases (up to 5 copies per genome) among Pseudomonas spp. This genetic evolution can be envisaged to enable host to withstand the attacks from bacterial population, which regulates its functioning through QS.     

细菌群体感应及其信号分子介导的植物-细菌跨界信息交流

细菌利用群体感应(Quorum sensing,QS)系统进行细胞间的通讯联系,进而参与调控细菌多种生物学功能。近年的研究表明,细菌QS信号分子也可以被细菌的真核植物宿主感应,从而介导植物-细菌的跨界信息交流。本文综述细菌QS及其介导的植物-细菌信息交流的最新研究进展,以期为通过操纵细菌QS达到提高植物病害防治效果提供理论基础和指导。     

Incorporating LsrK AI‐2 quorum quenching capability in a functionalized biopolymer capsule

Antibacterial resistance is an issue of increasing severity as current antibiotics are losing their effectiveness and fewer antibiotics are being developed. New methods for combating bacterial virulence are required. Modulating molecular communication among bacteria can alter phenotype, including attachment to epithelia, biofilm formation, and even toxin production. Intercepting and modulating communication networks provide a means to attenuate virulence without directly interacting with the bacteria of interest. In this work, we target communication mediated by the quorum sensing (QS) bacterial autoinducer‐2, AI‐2. We have assembled a capsule of biological polymers alginate and chitosan, attached an AI‐2 processing kinase, LsrK, and provided substrate, ATP, for enzymatic alteration of AI‐2 in culture fluids. Correspondingly, AI‐2 mediated QS activity is diminished. All components of this system are “biofabricated”—they are biologically derived and their assembly is accomplished using biological means. Initially, component quantities and kinetics were tested as assembled in microtiter plates. Subsequently, the identical components and assembly means were used to create the “artificial cell” capsules. The functionalized capsules, when introduced into populations of bacteria, alter the dynamics of the AI‐2 bacterial communication, attenuating QS activated phenotypes. We envision the assembly of these and other capsules or similar materials, as means to alter QS activity in a biologically compatible manner and in many environments, including in humans.

     

The role of AiiA, a quorum-quenching enzyme from Bacillus thuringiensis, on the rhizosphere competence

Bacteria sense their population density and coordinate the expression of target genes, including virulence factors in Gram-negative bacteria, by the N-acylhomoserine lactones (AHLs)-dependent quorum-sensing (QS) mechanism. In contrast, several soil bacteria are able to interfere with QS by enzymatic degradation of AHLs, referred to as quorum quenching. A potent AHL-degrading enzyme, AiiA, of Bacillus thuringiensis has been reported to effectively attenuate the virulence of bacteria by quorum quenching. However, little is known about the role of AiiA in B. thuringiensis itself. In the present study, an aiiA-defective mutant was generated to investigate the role of AiiA in rhizosphere competence in the root system of pepper. The aiiA mutant showed no detectable AHL-degrading activity and was less effective for suppression of soft-rot symptom caused by Erwinia carotovora on the potato slice. On the pepper root, the survival rate of the aiiA mutant significantly decreased over time compared with that of wild type. Interestingly, viable cell count analysis revealed that the bacterial number and composition of E. carotovora were not different between treatments of wild type and the aiiA mutant, although root application of the aiiA mutant in pepper failed to protect the plant from root rot. These results provide evidence that AiiA can play an important role in rhizosphere competentce of B. thuringiensis and bacterial quorum quenching to Gram-negative bacteria without changing bacterial number or composition.     

密度感应系统：对细菌致病力的自行调控

细菌通过密度感应系统感受环境中的信号分子,进而调控菌群一系列生物学性状。研究发现密度感应系统能够调控细菌生物被膜形成、毒力基因表达及噬菌体感染等功能,其中基于密度感应系统调控细菌抵御噬菌体感染更是新发现,预期也将是未来数年的研究热点,其调控机制的阐明将为有效应用噬菌体开展耐药菌的防控展现广阔前景。本文将重点综述细菌密度感应系统对细菌致病相关功能的调控机制,旨在为病原菌的防控提供新思路。     

植物精油对铜绿假单胞菌群体感应系统的抑制作用研究进展

群体感应（quorum sensing,QS）是细菌个体与个体之间的一种交流机制,广泛存在于细菌中。铜绿假单胞菌是人类的一种条件致病菌,它具有至少3种QS系统,即las、rhl和pqs系统,且各系统之间存在着级联调控关系,它们共同作用调控着该菌众多毒力基因的表达和毒力因子的产生。近年来,通过抑制铜绿假单胞菌的QS系统以控制其毒力和致病力,成为一种新型的铜绿假单胞菌感染防控策略。植物精油是一种天然的群体感应抑制剂（quorum sensing inhibitors, QSI）,多种精油活性化合物都能抑制铜绿假单胞菌的QS系统,而且尚未发现细菌对其产生耐药性。基于此,梳理了铜绿假单胞菌QS系统的组成及其级联调控关系,简要介绍了植物精油的QS抑制机制和抑制活性,并重点综述了萜烯类化合物、芳香族化合物、脂肪族化合物、含硫含氮化合物4类精油化合物对铜绿假单胞菌QS系统抑制作用的研究进展,以期为从天然化合物中发现和筛选安全、高效的细菌QSI的相关研究提供参考,并为致病菌的防控奠定理论基础。