Alternate interfaces may mediate homomeric and heteromeric assembly in the transmembrane domains of SNARE proteins

The fusion of a vesicle to a target membrane is mediated by temporally and spatially regulated interactions within a set of evolutionarily conserved proteins. Integral to proper fusion is the interaction between proteins originating on both vesicle and target membranes to form a protein bridge between the two membranes, known as the SNARE complex. This protein complex includes the single-pass transmembrane helix proteins: syntaxin and synaptobrevin. Experimental data and amino acid sequence analysis suggest that an interface of interaction is conserved between the transmembrane regions of the two proteins. However, conflicting reports have been presented on the role of the synaptobrevin transmembrane domain in mediating important protein-protein interactions. To address this question, a thermodynamic study was carried out to determine quantitatively the self-association propensities of the transmembrane domains of synaptobrevin and syntaxin. Our results show that the transmembrane domain of synaptobrevin has only a modest ability to self-associate, whereas the transmembrane domain of syntaxin is able to form stable homodimers. Nevertheless, by a single amino acid substitution, synaptobrevin can be driven to dimerize with the same affinity as syntaxin. Furthermore, crosslinking studies show that dimerization of synaptobrevin is promoted by oxidizing agents. Despite the presence of a conserved cysteine residue in the same location as in synaptobrevin, syntaxin dimerization is not promoted by oxidization. This analysis suggests that subtle yet distinct differences are present between the two transmembrane dimer interfaces. A syntaxin/synaptobrevin heterodimer is able to form under oxidizing conditions, and we propose that the interface of interaction for the heterodimer may resemble the homodimer interface formed by the synaptobrevin transmembrane domain. Computational analysis of the transmembrane sequences of syntaxin and synaptobrevin reveal structural models that correlate with the experimental data. These data may provide insight into the role of transmembrane segments in the mechanism of vesicle fusion.     

Mutational analysis of synaptobrevin transmembrane domain oligomerization

Synaptobrevin 2 is thought to facilitate fusion of synaptic vesicles with the presynaptic membrane through formation of a soluble NSF attachment protein receptor complex (SNARE) with syntaxin 1a and a synaptosomal associated protein of 25 kDa (SNAP-25). Previous reports have described a homodimer of synaptobrevin that is dependent on the transmembrane domain. However, these reports disagree about the magnitude of dimerization, which makes it difficult to assess the biological relevance of this interaction. We used SDS-PAGE and the TOXCAT genetic assay to reexamine the homodimerization of the synaptobrevin transmembrane domain in detergents and the Escherichia coli inner membrane, respectively. To gauge the magnitude of synaptobrevin homodimerization, we used the well-characterized glycophorin A homodimer as a positive standard. In contrast to previous studies, we found synaptobrevin homodimerization in E. coli is very weak when compared to glycophorin A. Recombinant synaptobrevin forms a small amount of dimer and higher order oligomers in detergents that are highly dependent on solublization conditions. We estimate a dissociation constant of 10 mM for synaptobrevin dimerization in detergent. Thus, the dimerization of synaptobrevin in membranes is very weak, questioning any possible functional role for this association in vivo.     

Sequence-specific dimerization of the transmembrane domain of the "BH3-only" protein BNIP3 in membranes and detergent

Mitochondria-mediated apoptosis is regulated by proteins of the Bcl-2 superfamily, most of which contain a C-terminal hydrophobic domain that plays a role in membrane targeting. Experiments with BNIP3 have implicated the transmembrane (TM) domain in its proapoptotic function, homodimerization, and interactions with Bcl-2 and Bcl-xL. We show that the BNIP3 TM domain self-associates strongly in Escherichia coli cell membranes and causes reversible dimerization of a soluble protein in the detergent SDS when expressed as an in-frame fusion. Limited mutational analysis identifies specific residues that are critical for BNIP3 TM self-association in membranes, and these residues are also important for dimerization in SDS micelles, suggesting that the self-association observed in membranes is preserved in detergent. The effects of sequence changes at positions Ala176 and Gly180 suggest that the BNIP3 TM domain associates using a variant of the GXXXG motif previously shown to be important in the dimerization of glycophorin A. The importance of residue His173 in BNIP3 TM domain dimerization indicates that polar residues, which have been implicated in self-association of model TM peptides, can act in concert with the AXXXG motif to stabilize TM domain interactions. Our results demonstrate that the hydrophobic C-terminal TM domain of the pro-apoptotic BNIP3 protein dimerizes tightly in lipidic environments, and that this association has a strong sequence dependence but is independent of the identity of flanking regions. Thus, the transmembrane domain represents another region of the Bcl-2 superfamily of proteins that is capable of mediating strong and specific protein-protein interactions.     

Geranylgeranylated SNAREs are dominant inhibitors of membrane fusion

Exocytosis in yeast requires the assembly of the secretory vesicle soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (v-SNARE) Sncp and the plasma membrane t-SNAREs Ssop and Sec9p into a SNARE complex. High-level expression of mutant Snc1 or Sso2 proteins that have a COOH-terminal geranylgeranylation signal instead of a transmembrane domain inhibits exocytosis at a stage after vesicle docking. The mutant SNARE proteins are membrane associated, correctly targeted, assemble into SNARE complexes, and do not interfere with the incorporation of wild-type SNARE proteins into complexes. Mutant SNARE complexes recruit GFP-Sec1p to sites of exocytosis and can be disassembled by the Sec18p ATPase. Heterotrimeric SNARE complexes assembled from both wild-type and mutant SNAREs are present in heterogeneous higher-order complexes containing Sec1p that sediment at greater than 20S. Based on a structural analogy between geranylgeranylated SNAREs and the GPI-HA mutant influenza virus fusion protein, we propose that the mutant SNAREs are fusion proteins unable to catalyze fusion of the distal leaflets of the secretory vesicle and plasma membrane. In support of this model, the inverted cone-shaped lipid lysophosphatidylcholine rescues secretion from SNARE mutant cells.     

Dimerization of the erythropoietin receptor transmembrane domain in micelles

Erythropoietin receptor (EpoR) homodimerization is an initial regulatory step in erythrocyte formation. Receptor dimers form before ligand binding, suggesting that association between receptor proteins is dependent on the receptor itself. EpoR dimerization is an essential step in erythropoiesis, and misregulation of this dimerization has been implicated in several disease states, including multi-lineage leukemias; nevertheless, how EpoR regulates its own dimerization is unclear. In vivo experiments suggest the single-pass transmembrane helix is the strongest candidate for driving ligand-independent association. To address the self-association potential of this transmembrane segment, we studied its interaction energetics in micelles by utilizing a previously successful Staphylococcal nuclease (SN-EpoR TM) fusion protein. This fusion protein strategy allows expression of the EpoR transmembrane domain in Escherichia coli independent of the other EpoR domains. Sedimentation equilibrium analytical ultracentrifugation of the detergent-solubilized SN-EpoR TM demonstrated that the murine EpoR transmembrane domain self-associates to form dimers. Although this interaction is not as stable as the dimerization of the well-studied glycophorin A transmembrane dimer, the murine EpoR transmembrane domain dimer is more stable than the interactions of the colon carcinoma kinase 4 transmembrane domain. The same experiments with the human EpoR transmembrane domain, which differs from the mouse sequence by only three residues, revealed a less favorable interaction than that of the murine sequence and is only slightly more favorable than that expected for non-preferential binding. These results suggest that the mouse and human receptor proteins may differ in the roles they play in signaling.     

Modification of a hydrophobic layer by a point mutation in syntaxin 1A regulates the rate of synaptic vesicle fusion

Both constitutive secretion and Ca²⁺-regulated exocytosis require the assembly of the soluble N-ethylmaleimide–sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE) complexes. At present, little is known about how the SNARE complexes mediating these two distinct pathways differ in structure. Using the Drosophila neuromuscular synapse as a model, we show that a mutation modifying a hydrophobic layer in syntaxin 1A regulates the rate of vesicle fusion. Syntaxin 1A molecules share a highly conserved threonine in the C-terminal +7 layer near the transmembrane domain. Mutation of this threonine to isoleucine results in a structural change that more closely resembles those found in syntaxins ascribed to the constitutive secretory pathway. Flies carrying the I254 mutant protein have increased levels of SNARE complexes and dramatically enhanced rate of both constitutive and evoked vesicle fusion. In contrast, overexpression of the T254 wild-type protein in neurons reduces vesicle fusion only in the I254 mutant background. These results are consistent with molecular dynamics simulations of the SNARE core complex, suggesting that T254 serves as an internal brake to dampen SNARE zippering and impede vesicle fusion, whereas I254 favors fusion by enhancing intermolecular interaction within the SNARE core complex.     

Leucine Zipper Motif Drives the Transmembrane Domain Dimerization of E-cadherin

E-cadherin is a transmembrane glycoprotein which is involved in the Ca²⁺-dependent cell–cell adhesion, and the adhesiveness is heavily dependent on the homodimerization of this molecule. Previous studies have shown that both the extracellular domain and cytoplasmic domain of E-cadherin contribute to its homodimerization. However, the roles of the transmembrane(TM) domain in the E-cadherin homodimerization have not been discussed in detail. In our experiments, SDS-PAGE showed higher molecular weight bands for the synthetic E-cadherin TM peptide, which indicated that the E-cadherin TM peptide is able to dimerize in the SDS micelle. The TOXCAT assay proved that the E-cadherin TM domain can form a moderate homo-oligomer in the Escherichia coli inner membrane. Furthermore, mutational analyses using the TOXCAT assays revealed that, instead of the common GxxxG dimerization motif, the leucine zipper motif is essential for the dimerization of the E-cadherin TM domain. Combining our experiment data and the computational simulation results, we provide insights for understanding the roles of the TM domain in the E-cadherin dimerization.     

Transmembrane homodimerization of receptor-like protein tyrosine phosphatases

Receptor-like protein tyrosine phosphatases (RPTPs) are type I integral membrane proteins. Together with protein tyrosine kinases, RPTPs regulate the phosphotyrosine levels in the cell. Studies of two RPTPs, CD45 and PTPalpha, have provided strong evidence that dimerization leads to inactivation of the receptors, and that the dimerization of PTPalpha involves interactions in the transmembrane domain (TMD). Using the TOXCAT assay, a genetic approach for analyzing TM interactions in Escherichia coli membranes, we show that the TMD of RPTPs interact in the membrane, albeit to different extents. Using fusion proteins of TMDs, we also observe an equilibrium between monomer and dimer in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles. Through a mutational study of the DEP1 TMD, we demonstrate that these interactions are specific. Taken together, our results define a subset of the RPTP family in which TM homodimerization may act as a mediator of protein function.     

Coarse-Grain Simulations Reveal Movement of the Synaptobrevin C-Terminus in Response to Piconewton Forces

Fusion of neurosecretory vesicles with the plasma membrane is mediated by SNARE proteins, which transfer a force to the membranes. However, the mechanism by which this force transfer induces fusion pore formation is still unknown. The neuronal vesicular SNARE protein synaptobrevin 2 (syb2) is anchored in the vesicle membrane by a single C-terminal transmembrane (TM) helix. In coarse-grain molecular-dynamics simulations, self-assembly of the membrane occurred with the syb2 TM domain inserted, as expected from experimental data. The free-energy profile for the position of the syb2 membrane anchor in the membrane was determined using umbrella sampling. To predict the free-energy landscapes for a reaction pathway pulling syb2 toward the extravesicular side of the membrane, which is the direction of the force transfer from the SNARE complex, harmonic potentials were applied to the peptide in its unbiased position, pulling it toward new biased equilibrium positions. Application of piconewton forces to the extravesicular end of the TM helix in the simulation detached the synaptobrevin C-terminus from the vesicle's inner-leaflet lipid headgroups and pulled it deeper into the membrane. This C-terminal movement was facilitated and hindered by specific mutations in parallel with experimentally observed facilitation and inhibition of fusion. Direct application of such forces to the intravesicular end of the TM domain resulted in tilting motion of the TM domain through the membrane with an activation energy of ～70 kJ/mol. The results suggest a mechanism whereby fusion pore formation is induced by movement of the charged syb2 C-terminus within the membrane in response to pulling and tilting forces generated by C-terminal zippering of the SNARE complex.     

Role of the Vam3p transmembrane segment in homodimerization and SNARE complex formation

Intracellular membrane fusion in eukaryotic cells is mediated by SNARE (soluble N-ethylmaleimide sensitive factor (NSF) attachment protein receptor) proteins and is known to involve assembly of cognate subunits to heterooligomeric complexes. For synaptic SNAREs, it has previously been shown that the transmembrane segments drive homotypic and support heterotypic interactions. Here, we demonstrate that a significant fraction of the yeast vacuolar SNARE Vam3p is a homodimer in detergent extracts of vacuolar membranes. This homodimer exists in parallel to the heterooligomeric SNARE complex. A Vam3p homodimer also formed from the isolated recombinant protein. Interestingly, homodimerization depended on the transmembrane segment. In contrast, formation of the quaternary SNARE complex from recombinant Vam3p, Nyv1p, Vti1p, and Vam7p subunits did not depend on the transmembrane segment of Vam3p nor on the transmembrane segments of its partner proteins. We conclude that Vam3p homodimerization, but not quaternary SNARE complex formation, is promoted by TMS-TMS interaction. As the transmembrane segments of Vam3p and other SNARE homologues were previously shown to be critical for membrane fusion downstream of membrane apposition, our results may shed light on the functional significance of SNARE TMS-TMS interactions.     

Synaptobrevin transmembrane domain dimerization-revisited

Synaptobrevin is a membrane-spanning soluble N-ethyl maleimid-sensitive factor (NSF) attachment protein receptor (SNARE) protein of synaptic vesicles that is essential for neurotransmitter release. Various lines of evidence indicate that it exists alternatively as a monomer, as a homodimer, as a heterodimer with synaptophysin, or as a ternary complex with other SNAREs at the various stages of the synaptic vesicle cycle. Homodimerization of synaptobrevin was previously shown by different authors to depend on its single transmembrane segment, and the crucial residues forming the helix-helix interface have been mapped. Since another recent study challenged these results, we reinvestigated this issue. Here, we show that native synaptobrevin can be cross-linked in synaptic vesicle membranes to a homodimer by disulfide bond formation between cysteine residues of the transmembrane segment. Further, we demonstrate that determination of synaptobrevin transmembrane segment interactions in membranes or in detergent solution requires careful control of experimental conditions. Thus, our present results corroborate that homodimerization of synaptobrevin is mediated by its transmembrane segment.     

Self-interaction of a SNARE transmembrane domain promotes the hemifusion-to-fusion transition

SNARE proteins mediate intracellular fusion of eukaryotic membranes. Some SNAREs have previously been shown to dimerise via interaction of their transmembrane domains. However, the functional significance of these interactions had remained unclear. Here, we show that mutating alternate faces of the transmembrane helix of the yeast vacuolar Q-SNARE Vam3p reduces the ability of the full-length protein to induce contents mixing in yeast vacuole fusion to different extents. Examination of liposome fusion induced by synthetic transmembrane domains revealed that inner leaflet mixing is delayed relative to outer leaflet mixing, suggesting that fusion transits through a hemifusion intermediate. Interestingly, one of the mutations impaired inner leaflet mixing in the liposome system. This suggests that the defect seen in vacuolar contents mixing is due to partial arrest of the reaction at hemifusion. Since covalent dimerisation of this mutant recovered wild-type behaviour, homodimerisation of a SNARE transmembrane domain appears to control the transition of a hemifusion intermediate to complete lipid mixing.     

The transmembrane domain sequence affects the structure and function of the Newcastle disease virus fusion protein

The role of specific sequences in the transmembrane (TM) domain of Newcastle disease virus (NDV) fusion (F) protein in the structure and function of this protein was assessed by replacing this domain with the F protein TM domains from two other paramyxoviruses, Sendai virus (SV) and measles virus (MV), or the TM domain of the unrelated glycoprotein (G) of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV). Mutant proteins with the SV or MV F protein TM domains were expressed, transported to cell surfaces, and proteolytically cleaved at levels comparable to that of the wild-type protein, while mutant proteins with the VSV G protein TM domain were less efficiently expressed on cell surfaces and proteolytically cleaved. All mutant proteins were defective in all steps of membrane fusion, including hemifusion. In contrast to the wild-type protein, the mutant proteins did not form detectable complexes with the NDV hemagglutinin-neuraminidase (HN) protein. As determined by binding of conformation-sensitive antibodies, the conformations of the ectodomains of the mutant proteins were altered. These results show that the specific sequence of the TM domain of the NDV F protein is important for the conformation of the preactivation form of the ectodomain, the interactions of the protein with HN protein, and fusion activity.     

The Sec1p/Munc18 (SM) protein,Vps45p,cycles on and off membranes during vesicle transport

Protein phosphatase 1 (PP1, Glc7p) functions in the final stage of SNARE-mediated vesicle transport between docking and fusion. During this process, trans-SNARE complexes, formed between molecules in opposing membranes, convert to cis-complexes, with all participants in the same lipid bilayer. Here, we show that glc7 mutant cells accumulate SNARE complexes. These complexes are clearly different from those found in either wild-type or sec18-1 cells as the Sec1p/Munc18 (SM) protein Vps45p does not bind to them. Given that PP1 controls fusion, the SNARE complexes that accumulate in glc7 mutants likely represent trans-SNARE complexes. Vps45p dissociates from the membrane in the absence of PP1 activity, but rapidly reassociates after its reactivation. These data reveal that SM proteins cycle on and off membranes in a stage-specific manner during the vesicle transport reaction, and suggest that protein phosphorylation plays a key role in the regulation of this cycle.     

Identification of SNAP-47, a novel Qbc-SNARE with ubiquitous expression

The SNARE proteins are essential components of the intracellular fusion machinery. It is thought that they form a tight four-helix complex between membranes, in effect initiating fusion. Most SNAREs contain a single coiled-coil region, referred to as the SNARE motif, directly adjacent to a single transmembrane domain. The neuronal SNARE SNAP-25 defines a subfamily of SNARE proteins with two SNARE helices connected by a longer linker, comprising also the proteins SNAP-23 and SNAP-29. We now report the initial characterization of a novel vertebrate homologue termed SNAP-47. Northern blot and immunoblot analysis revealed ubiquitous tissue distribution, with particularly high levels in nervous tissue. In neurons, SNAP-47 shows a widespread distribution on intracellular membranes and is also enriched in synaptic vesicle fractions. In vitro, SNAP-47 substituted for SNAP-25 in SNARE complex formation with the neuronal SNAREs syntaxin 1a and synaptobrevin 2, and it also substituted for SNAP-25 in proteoliposome fusion. However, neither complex assembly nor fusion was as efficient as with SNAP-25.     

Two point mutations in the transmembrane domain of P68gag-ros inactive its transforming activity and cause a delay in membrane association.

The transforming protein of the avian sarcoma virus UR2 is a 68-kDa transmembrane tyrosine protein kinase. We examined the relationship between membrane localization and transforming activity of P68 by changing Val-168-Val-169 in its hydrophobic domain into Asp-168-Glu-169. The resulting transmembrane (TM) mutant (P68TM) lost transforming activity toward chicken embryo fibroblasts (CEF). We found that the mutant protein was expressed and rapidly degraded into a smaller form which was still membrane associated and kinase active. The instability of the TM mutant protein is a phenomenon only manifested in CEF, because the same mutant protein was expressed with efficiency and stability similar to those of the wild-type protein in a transient expression system in COS cells. However, there are several differences between the wild-type and the TM mutant proteins in COS cells. The wild-type protein is more heavily phosphorylated and associated with membrane fractions in a cotranslational manner. It is enzymatically active when recovered from membrane fractions. The TM mutant protein is less phosphorylated, more labile toward protease degradation, and delayed in membrane association, with a lag period of 30 min or longer, and has little kinase activity when recovered from membrane fractions. Most of the kinase-active TM mutant protein was found in the cytosol fractions. Despite the delay, most of the TM protein in COS cells was found to be membrane associated, and its orientation on the cell surface was similar to that of the wild-type protein. It is probable that loss of the CEF-transforming activity of the TM mutant protein is due to its susceptibility to protease degradation resulting from improper membrane association of the newly synthesized product. The differences in the kinetics of membrane association and the distribution of kinase activity in COS cells might not be directly applicable in explaining the inability of the TM mutant to transform CEF but are intriguing as regards protein biosynthesis and translocation. The difference between CEF and COS cells implies that different factors or pathways are involved in the biosynthesis and processing of the TM mutant protein in these two cellular environments. Changes of P68TM in the kinetics of membrane association indicate that the transmembrane domain of ros, besides functioning as a membrane anchor, also plays a role in directing initial membrane association.     

A Highly Tilted Membrane Configuration for the Prefusion State of Synaptobrevin

The SNARE complex plays a vital role in vesicle fusion arising during neuronal exocytosis. Key components in the regulation of SNARE complex formation, and ultimately fusion, are the transmembrane and linker regions of the vesicle-associated protein, synaptobrevin. However, the membrane-embedded structure of synaptobrevin in its prefusion state, which determines its interaction with other SNARE proteins during fusion, is largely unknown. This study reports all-atom molecular-dynamics simulations of the prefusion configuration of synaptobrevin in a lipid bilayer, aimed at characterizing the insertion depth and the orientation of the protein in the membrane, as well as the nature of the amino acids involved in determining these properties. By characterizing the structural properties of both wild-type and mutant synaptobrevin, the effects of C-terminal additions on tilt and insertion depth of membrane-embedded synaptobrevin are determined. The simulations suggest a robust, highly tilted state for membrane-embedded synaptobrevin with a helical connection between the transmembrane and linker regions, leading to an apparently new characterization of structural elements in prefusion synaptobrevin and providing a framework for interpreting past mutation experiments.     

RIM proteins activate vesicle priming by reversing autoinhibitory homodimerization of Munc13

At a synapse, the presynaptic active zone mediates synaptic vesicle exocytosis. RIM proteins are active zone scaffolding molecules that--among others--mediate vesicle priming and directly or indirectly interact with most other essential presynaptic proteins. In particular, the Zn2+ finger domain of RIMs binds to the C?A domain of the priming factor Munc13, which forms a homodimer in the absence of RIM but a heterodimer with it. Here, we show that RIMs mediate vesicle priming not by coupling Munc13 to other active zone proteins as thought but by directly activating Munc13. Specifically, we found that the isolated Zn2+ finger domain of RIMs autonomously promoted vesicle priming by binding to Munc13, thereby relieving Munc13 homodimerization. Strikingly, constitutively monomeric mutants of Munc13 rescued priming in RIM-deficient synapses, whereas wild-type Munc13 did not. Both mutant and wild-type Munc13, however, rescued priming in Munc13-deficient synapses. Thus, homodimerization of Munc13 inhibits its priming function, and RIMs activate priming by disrupting Munc13 homodimerization.     

The dimerization interface of the glycoprotein Ibβ transmembrane domain corresponds to polar residues within a leucine zipper motif

Experiments with the transmembrane (TM) domains of the glycoprotein (GP) Ib-IX complex have indicated that the associations between the TM domains of these subunits play an important role in the proper assembly of the complex. As a first step toward understanding these associations, we previously found that the Ibβ TM domain dimerized strongly in Escherichia coli cell membranes and led to Ibβ TM-CYTO (cytoplasmic domain) dimerization in the SDS-PAGE assay, while neither Ibα nor IX TM-CYTO was able to dimerize. In this study, we used the TOXCAT assay to probe the Ibβ TM domain dimerization interface by Ala- and Leu-scanning mutagenesis. Our results show that this interface is based on a leucine zipper-like heptad repeat pattern of amino acids. Mutating either one of polar residues Gln129 or His139 to Leu or Ala disrupted Ibβ TM dimerization dramatically, indicating that polar residues might form part of the leucine zipper-based dimerization interface. Furthermore, these specific mutational effects in the TOXCAT assay were confirmed in the thiol-disulfide exchange and SDS-PAGE assays. The computational modeling studies further revealed that the most likely leucine zipper interface involves hydrogen bonding of Gln129 and electrostatic interaction of the His139 side chain. Correlation of computer modeling results with experimental mutagenesis studies on the Ibβ TM domain may provide insights for understanding the role of the association of TM domains on the assembly of GP Ib-IX complex.