Spontaneous mutagenesis: the roles of DNA repair, replication, and recombination

There appears to be no dearth of mechanisms to explain spontaneous mutagenesis. In the case of base substitutions, data for bacteriophage T4 and especially for E. coli and S. cerevisiae suggest important roles in spontaneous mutagenesis for the error-prone repair of DNA damage (to produce mutations) and for error-free repair of DNA damage (to avoid mutagenesis). Data from the very limited number of studies on the subject suggest that about 50% of the spontaneous base substitutions in E. coli, and perhaps 90% in S. cerevisiae are due to error-prone DNA repair. On the other hand, spontaneous frameshifts and deletions seem to result from mechanisms involving recombination and replication. Spontaneous insertions have been shown to be important in the strongly polar inactivation of certain loci, but it is less important at other loci. Perhaps with continued study, the term "spontaneous mutagenesis" will be replaced by more specific terms such as 5-methylcytosine deamination mutagenesis, fatty acid oxidation mutagenesis, phenylalanine mutagenesis, and imprecise-recombination mutagenesis. While most studies have concentrated on mutator mutations, the most conclusive data for the actual source of spontaneous mutations have come from the study of antimutator mutations. Further study in this area, perhaps along with an understanding of chemical antimutagens, should be invaluable in clarifying the bases of spontaneous mutagenesis.     

Comparison of the mutations induced by p-benzoquinone, a benzene metabolite, in human and mouse cells

Benzene is one of the chemicals widely contaminating the environment. Benzene is suggested to be a human leukemogen. When benzene is absorbed in the human body, it is metabolized firstly in the liver and subsequently in the bone marrow where it provokes initiation of leukemia. In the present study, we analyzed mutations induced by p-benzoquinone (p-BQ), a benzene metabolite, in human cells using a shuttle vector plasmid pMY189, and compared frequencies, types and spectra of the mutations with those of the mutations previously revealed in mouse cells using a similar plasmid pNY200. We found that p-BQ induces mutations in human and mouse cells at similar frequencies but with different types of mutagenesis. The proportion of tandem base mutations was significantly lower in human cells than in mouse cells. Most base substitutions were induced in G:C base pairs in both human and mouse cells. However, the proportion of G:C-->C :G transversion is significantly higher in human cells. These findings indicate that the p-BQ-induced DNA damage in human and mouse cells is processed in a different manner, and that extrapolation of mice findings on experimental benzene carcinogenesis to human cancer risk assessment should be conducted carefully.     

Environmental carcinogenesis: an integrative model.

An integrative theory is proposed in which environmental carcinogenesis is viewed as a process by which the genetic control of cell division and differentiation is altered by carcinogens. In this theory, carcinogens include physical, chemical, and viral "mutagens," as well as chemical and viral gene modulators. Existing explanations of carcinogenesis can be considered either as somatic mutation theories or as epigenetic theories. Evidence seems to support the hypothesis that both mutations and epigenetic processes are components of carcinogenesis. The mutational basis of cancer is supported by the clonal nature of tumors, the mutagenicity of most carcinogens, high mutation frequencies in cells of cancer-prone human fibroblasts lacking DNA repair enzymes, the correlation of in vitro DNA damage and in vitro mutation and transformation frequencies with in vivo tumorigenesis, age-related incidences of various hereditary tumors, and the correlation between photoreactivation of DNA damage and the biological amelioration of UV-induced neoplasms. Since both mutagens and gene modulators can be carcinogenic it may be that carcinogens affect genes which control cell division. An integration of the mutation and epigenetic theories of cancer with the "two-stage" theory and Comings's general theory of carcinogenesis is proposed. This integrative theory postulates that carcinogens can affect regulatory genes which control a series of "transforming genes." A general hypothesis is advanced that involves a common mechanism of somatic mutagenesis via error-prone repair of DNA damage which links carcinogenesis, teratogenesis, atherosclerosis and aging. Various concepts are presented to provide a framework for evaluating the scientific, medical, and social implications of cancer.     

Use of phi X174 as a shuttle vector for the study of in vivo mammalian mutagenesis

The most promising new techniques for the study of in vivo mammalian mutagenesis make use of transgenic mice carrying a recoverable vector. Mutation systems in mammals can be based on the selection of altered phenotypes among cells sampled from the whole animal, but they are then limited to the very few cell types in which the marker gene is expressed. Such systems require both in vivo and in vitro cell proliferation for expression and verification of the mutations. To avoid these complications, the study of mutations in most tissues must be based on the detection of genetic alterations in a vector that is independent of the phenotype of the mammalian cell. The vector is only a small portion of the mammalian genome, and many of the procedures for recovering the vector are inhibited by the host DNA. For this reason, partial purification is necessary. The purification is made possible by using vectors which are not cut by restriction enzymes that cut the host DNA to pieces of an average size considerably smaller than the vector. The efficiency for measuring mutation frequencies depends on the number of vectors which can be recovered from a certain amount of DNA and is affected by the number of vectors per mammalian genome and the transfection efficiency of the partially-purified vector. In order to avoid selection against or for the spontaneous or induced mutations, the transfection efficiency of the vector from the transformed DNA and of the pure vector DNA should be of the same order of magnitude. Differences in the response to mutagens between the mammalian genome and the procaryotic vector may be expected due to the lack of unique mammalian topographical features in the vectors. Any mutation induction which depends preferentially on these unique features of the mammalian genome may not be detected in a shuttle vector system unless the vector has been engineered or specifically designed to include such topographical characters. The shortcoming of short-term tests that use mutagenicity for predicting human carcinogenicity is usually lack of correlation between mutagenesis in the short-term tests and the corresponding results in carcinogenesis bioassays in mammals. One factor which could contribute to the lack of correlation between the short-term test systems and the bioassays is that we are comparing mutations in totally different genes in different organisms. By using the phi X174 shuttle system, one of the variables may be eliminated.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

DNA sequence analysis of spontaneous mutations in the SUP4-o gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

A collection of 196 spontaneous mutations in the SUP4-o gene of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae was analyzed by DNA sequencing. The classes of mutation identified included all possible types of base-pair substitution, deletions of various lengths, complex alterations involving multiple changes, and insertions of transposable elements. Our findings demonstrate that at least several different mechanisms are responsible for spontaneous mutagenesis in S. cerevisiae.     

Sequence specificity of point mutations induced during passage of a UV-irradiated shuttle vector plasmid in monkey cells.

A simian virus 40-based shuttle vector was used to characterize UV-induced mutations generated in mammalian cells. The small size and placement of the mutagenesis marker (the supF suppressor tRNA gene from Escherichia coli) within the vector substantially reduced the frequency of spontaneous mutations normally observed after transfection of mammalian cells with plasmid DNA; hence, UV-induced mutations were easily identified above the spontaneous background. UV-induced mutations characterized by DNA sequencing were found primarily to be base substitutions; about 56% of these were single-base changes, and 17% were tandem double-base changes. About 24% of the UV-induced mutants carried multiple mutations clustered within the 160-base-pair region sequenced. The majority (61%) of base changes were the G . C----A . T transitions; the other transition (A . T----G . C) and all four transversions occurred at about equal frequencies. Hot spots for UV mutagenesis did not correspond to hot spots for UV-induced photoproduct formation (determined by a DNA synthesis arrest assay); in particular, sites of TT dimers were underrepresented among the UV-induced mutations. These observations suggest to us that the DNA polymerase(s) responsible for mutation induction exhibits a localized loss of fidelity in DNA synthesis on UV-damaged templates such that it synthesizes past UV photoproducts, preferentially inserting adenine, and sometimes misincorporates bases at undamaged sites nearby.     

Mutagenic spectrum resulting from DNA damage by oxygen radicals.

Oxygen free radicals are highly reactive species that damage DNA and cause mutations. We determined the mutagenic spectrum of oxygen free radicals produced by the aerobic incubation of single-stranded M13mp2 DNA with Fe2+. The Fe2(+)-treated DNA was transfected into component Escherichia coli, and mutants within the nonessential lac Z alpha gene for beta-galactosidase were identified by decreased alpha-complementation. The frequency of mutants obtained with 10 microM Fe2+ was 20- to 80-fold greater than that obtained with untreated DNA. Mutagenesis was greater after the host cells were exposed to UV irradiation to induce the SOS "error-prone" response. The ability of catalase, mannitol, and superoxide dismutase to diminish mutagenesis indicates the involvement of oxygen free radicals. The sequence data on 94 of the mutants establish that mutagenesis results primarily from an increase in single-base substitutions. Ninety-four percent of the mutants with detectable changes in nucleotide sequence were single-base substitutions, the most frequent being G----C transversions, followed by C----T transitions and G----T transversions. The clustering of mutations at distinct gene positions suggests that Fe2+/oxygen damage to DNA is nonrandom. This mutational spectrum provides evidence that a multiplicity of DNA lesions produced by oxygen free radicals in vitro are promutagenic and could be a source of spontaneous mutations.     

Comparison of the mutations induced by p-benzoquinone, a benzene metabolite, in human and mouse cells

Benzene is one of the chemicals widely contaminating the environment. Benzene is suggested to be a human leukemogen. When benzene is absorbed in the human body, it is metabolized firstly in the liver and subsequently in the bone marrow where it provokes initiation of leukemia. In the present study, we analyzed mutations induced by p-benzoquinone (p-BQ), a benzene metabolite, in human cells using a shuttle vector plasmid pMY189, and compared frequencies, types and spectra of the mutations with those of the mutations previously revealed in mouse cells using a similar plasmid pNY200. We found that p-BQ induces mutations in human and mouse cells at similar frequencies but with different types of mutagenesis. The proportion of tandem base mutations was significantly lower in human cells than in mouse cells. Most base substitutions were induced in G:C base pairs in both human and mouse cells. However, the proportion of G:C→C :G transversion is significantly higher in human cells. These findings indicate that the p-BQ-induced DNA damage in human and mouse cells is processed in a different manner, and that extrapolation of mice findings on experimental benzene carcinogenesis to human cancer risk assessment should be conducted carefully.     

Errors in DNA synthesis: a source of spontaneous mutations

Spontaneous mutations in somatic cells may engender several pathologic processes, including cancer. The sources of these mutations remain to be established. We present a conceptual framework in which to analyze the sources of spontaneous mutations and focus here on 3 endogenous processes that have the potential to generate spontaneous sequence alterations in DNA. These are: replication errors, depurination of DNA, and damage to DNA by the generation of active-oxygen species. Each of these processes occurs more frequently than the rate of mutagenesis in somatic cells, but are repaired by different and overlapping mechanisms. Model systems are being developed to determine the spectrum of mutations produced by each of these processes in vitro. A comparison of these spectra with the overall spectrum of spontaneous mutations in somatic cells may help to determine the contribution of each of these processes to spontaneous mutation.     

An aerobic recA-, umuC-dependent pathway of spontaneous base-pair substitution mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

Antimutator alleles indentify genes whose normal products are involved in spontaneous mutagenesis pathways. Mutant alleles of the recA and umuC genes of Escherichia coli, whose wild-type alleles are components of the inducible SOS response, were shown to cause a decrease in the level of spontaneous mutagenesis. Using a series of chromosomal mutant trp alleles, which detect point mutations, as a reversion assay, it was shown that the reduction in mutagenesis is limited to base-pair substitutions. Within the limited number of sites than could be examined, transversions at AT sites were the favored substitutions. Frameshift mutagenesis was slightly enhanced by a mutant recA allele and unchanged by a mutant umuC allele. The wild-type recA and umuC genes are involved in the same mutagenic base-pair substitution pathway, designated "SOS-dependent spontaneous mutagenesis" (SDSM), since a recAumuC strain showed the same degree and specificity of antimutator activity as either single mutant strain. The SDSM pathway is active only in the presence of oxygen, since wild-type, recA, and umuC strains all show the same levels of reduced spontaneous mutagenesis anaerobically. The SDSM pathway can function in starving/stationary cells and may, or may not, be operative in actively dividing cultures. We suggest that, in wild-type cells, SDSM results from basal levels of SOS activity during DNA synthesis. Mutations may result from synthesis past cryptic DNA lesions (targeted mutagenesis) and/or from mispairings during synthesis with a normal DNA template (untargeted mutagenesis). Since it occurs in chromosomal genes of wild-type cells, SDSM may be biologically significant for isolates of natural enteric bacterial populations where extended starvation is often a common mode of existence.     

The effect of 2-micron DNA on survival and mutagenesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, with and without endogenous 2-microns DNA, were studied in experiments designed to determine the effect of this plasmid on survival and mutagenesis in yeast. Comparison of the two strains exposed to ultraviolet light, 4-nitroquinoline oxide, or methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), revealed that the presence of 2-microns DNA slightly enhanced survival after exposure to each agent. Spontaneous frequencies of mutations (histidine reversion, canavanine resistance, and mitochondrial petites, but not adenine auxotrophy) were reduced by the presence of 2-microns DNA. MMS-induced His+ reversion was weak, and both strains responded similarly. No difference was found between the two strains when induced forward mutation to canavanine resistance was examined. The extent of induction of mitochondrial petites was about the same in both strains. Therefore, it appears that under these experimental conditions with these mutagens, 2-microns DNA has an effect on spontaneous mutation and survival after DNA damage but not on induced mutagenesis in S. cerevisiae.     

Mutational extinction induced by sequential X irradiation and actinomycin D treatments in Chinese hamster ovary cells

The interactions of sequential X irradiation and actinomycin D (AMD) treatments for mutagenesis to 6-thioguanine resistance were investigated in CHO cells. Cells were exposed to single doses of X rays followed immediately by 1-h treatments with 0.1 or 1 microgram/ml AMD. X Rays alone induced mutagenesis which increased monotonically with dose to at least 8 Gy. AMD-treated control cultures showed slight to moderate cytotoxicity and little induced mutation. X Rays followed by AMD treatment produced bell-shaped mutagenesis dose-response curves with maximal mutation at approximately 5 or 4 Gy for 0.1 or 1.0 microgram/ml AMD, respectively. Induced mutation frequencies then fell to a negligible level at fractional survival levels below 0.10 for either combination treatment. Application of a stochastic Poisson distribution model to these data led to the prediction that two possible components govern induced mutation frequencies. First, X ray +AMD induced mutations may be depleted progressively with dose from the surviving populations by selective lethality, which we term mutational extinction. Second, X ray +AMD treatments were calculated to induce potentially much greater than additive mutagenesis. However, due to the overriding mutational extinction effect, most of these mutations are not recovered as viable colonies. These studies suggest that AMD binding to DNA immediately following irradiation may cause considerably enhanced mutagenic and often lethal DNA damage, and that mutational extinction may occur because these types of damage are statistically correlated in a sensitive subpopulation of exponentially growing CHO cells.     

Roles of RecA protein in spontaneous mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

To verify the extent of contribution of spontaneous DNA lesions to spontaneous mutagenesis, we have developed a new genetic system to examine simultaneously both forward mutations and recombination events occurring within about 600 base pairs of a transgenic rpsL target sequence located on Escherichia coli chromosome. In a wild-type strain, the recombination events were occurring at a frequency comparable to that of point mutations within the rpsL sequence. When the cells were UV-irradiated, the recombination events were induced much more sharply than point mutations. In a recA null mutant, no recombination event was observed. These data suggest that the blockage of DNA replication, probably caused by spontaneous DNA lesions, occurs often in normally growing E. coli cells and is mainly processed by cellular functions requiring the RecA protein. However, the recA mutant strain showed elevated frequencies of single-base frameshifts and large deletions, implying a novel mutator action of this strain. A similar mutator action of the recA mutant was also observed with a plasmid-based rpsL mutation assay. Therefore, if the recombinogenic problems in DNA replication are not properly processed by the RecA function, these would be a potential source for mutagenesis leading to single-base frameshift and large deletion in E. coli. Furthermore, the single-base frameshifts induced in the recA-deficient cells appeared to be efficiently suppressed by the mutS-dependent mismatch repair system. Thus, it seems likely that the single-base frameshifts are derived from slippage errors that are not directly caused by DNA lesions but made indirectly during some kind of error-prone DNA synthesis in the recA mutant cells.     

A Major Role for Bacteriophage T4 DNA Polymerase in Frameshift Mutagenesis

T4 DNA polymerase strongly influences the frequency and specificity of frameshift mutagenesis. Fifteen of 19 temperature-sensitive alleles of the DNA polymerase gene substantially influenced the reversion frequencies of frameshift mutations measured in the T4 rII genes. Most polymerase mutants increased frameshift frequencies, but a few alleles (previously noted as antimutators for base substitution mutations) decreased the frequencies of certain frameshifts while increasing the frequencies of others. The various patterns of enhanced or decreased frameshift mutation frequencies suggest that T4 DNA polymerase is likely to play a variety of roles in the metabolic events leading to frameshift mutation. A detailed genetic study of the specificity of the mutator properties of three DNA polymerase alleles (tsL56, tsL98 and tsL88) demonstrated that each produces a distinctive frameshift spectrum. Differences in frameshift frequencies at similar DNA sequences within the rII genes, the influence of mutant polymerase alleles on these frequencies, and the presence or absence of the dinucleotide sequence associated with initiation of Okazaki pieces at the frameshift site has led us to suggest that the discontinuities associated with discontinuous DNA replication may contribute to spontaneous frameshift mutation frequencies in T4.     

Methionine reduces spontaneous and alkylation-induced mutagenesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells deficient in O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase

The exposure of DNA to reactive intracellular metabolites is thought to be a major cause of spontaneous mutagenesis. DNA alkylation is implicated in the above process by the fact that bacterial and yeast cells lacking DNA alkylation-specific repair genes exhibit elevated spontaneous mutation rates. The origin of the intracellular alkylating molecules is not clear; however, S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) has been proposed as one source because it has a reactive methyl group known to methylate proteins and DNA. We supplemented yeast cultures with excess methionine and examined the effects of increased endogenous SAM concentration on spontaneous and alkylation-induced mutagenesis in the absence of various DNA repair pathways. Our results show that either the excess methionine, or the increased SAM produced as a result of this treatment, is able to protect yeast cells from mutagenesis, and that this effect is alkylation-damage-specific. The protective effect was observed only in the mgt1 mutant deficient in the O(6)-methylguanine-DNA repair methyltransferase, but not in the wild type or other DNA repair-deficient strains, indicating that the protection is specific for O-methyl lesions. Thus, our results may lend support to the recently reported chemopreventive effect of SAM in rodents and further suggest that the observed tumor prevention by SAM may be, in part, due to its suppression of spontaneous mutagenesis in mammals. Given that a strong correlation has been established between O(6)-methylguanine and carcinogenicity, this study may offer a novel approach to preventing carcinogenesis.     

Dot1 and Set2 histone methylases control the spontaneous and UV-induced mutagenesis levels in the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Saccharomyces cerevisiae</Emphasis> yeasts

In the Saccharomyces cerevisiae yeasts, the DOT1 gene product provides methylation of lysine 79 (K79) of histone H3 and the SET2 gene product provides the methylation of lysine 36 (K36) of the same histone. We determined that the dot1 and set2 mutants suppress the UV-induced mutagenesis to an equally high degree. The dot1 mutation demonstrated statistically higher sensitivity to the low doses of MMC than the wild type strain. The analysis of the interaction between the dot1 and rad52 mutations revealed a considerable level of spontaneous cell death in the double dot1 rad52 mutant. We observed strong suppression of the gamma-induced mutagenesis in the set2 mutant. We determined that the dot1 and set2 mutations decrease the spontaneous mutagenesis rate in both single and double mutants. The epistatic interaction between the dot1 and set2 mutations and almost similar sensitivity of the corresponding mutants to the different types of DNA damage allow one to conclude that both genes are involved in the control of the same DNA repair pathways, the homologous-recombination-based and the postreplicative DNA repair.     

Specific RecA amino acid changes affect RecA–UmuD'C interaction

The UmuD'C mutagenesis complex accumulates slowly and parsimoniously after a 12 J m⁻² UV flash to attain after 45 min a low cell concentration between 15 and 60 complexes. Meanwhile, RecA monomers go up to 72 000 monomers. By contrast, when the UmuD'C complex is constitutively produced at a high concentration, it inhibits recombinational repair and then markedly reduces bacterial survival from DNA damage. We have isolated novel recA mutations that enable RecA to resist UmuD'C recombination inhibition. The mutations, named recA [UmuR], are located on the RecA three-dimensional structure at three sites: (i) the RecA monomer tail domain (four amino acid changes); (ii) the RecA monomer head domain (one amino acid change, which appears to interface with the amino acids in the tail domain); and (iii) in the core of a RecA monomer (one amino acid change). RecA [UmuR] proteins make recombination more efficient in the presence of UmuD'C while SOS mutagenesis is inhibited. The UmuR amino acid changes are located at a head-tail joint between RecA monomers and some are free to possibly interact with UmuD'C at the tip of a RecA polymer. These two RecA structures may constitute possible sites to which the UmuD'C complex might bind, hampering homologous recombination and favouring SOS mutagenesis.     

Chemical synthesis of oligonucleotides containing damaged bases for biological studies

Since nucleic acids are organic molecules, even DNA, which carries genetic information, is subjected to various chemical reactions in cells. Alterations of the chemical structure of DNA, which are referred to as DNA damage or DNA lesions, induce mutations in the DNA sequences, which lead to carcinogenesis and cell death, unless they are restored by the repair systems in each organism. Formerly, DNA from bacteria and bacteriophages and DNA fragments treated with UV or gamma radiation, alkylating or crosslinking agents, and other carcinogens were used as damaged DNA for biochemical studies. With these materials, however, it is difficult to understand the detailed mechanisms of mutagenesis and DNA repair. Recent progress in the chemical synthesis of oligonucleotides has enabled us to incorporate a specific lesion at a defined position within any sequence context. This method is especially important for studies on mutagenesis and translesion synthesis, which require highly pure templates, and for the structural biology of repair enzymes, which necessitates large amounts of substrate DNA as well as modified substrate analogs. In this review, the various phosphoramidite building blocks for the synthesis of lesion-containing oligodeoxyribonucleotides are described, and some examples of their applications to molecular and structural biology are presented.