Ligand exchange between proteins. Exchange of biotin and biotin derivatives between avidin and streptavidin

We have studied the structural elements that affect ligand exchange between the two high affinity biotin-binding proteins, egg white avidin and its bacterial analogue, streptavidin. For this purpose, we have developed a simple assay based on the antipodal behavior of the two proteins toward hydrolysis of biotinyl p-nitrophenyl ester (BNP). The assay provided the experimental basis for these studies. It was found that biotin migrates unidirectionally from streptavidin to avidin. Conversely, the biotin derivative, BNP, is transferred in the opposite direction, from avidin to streptavidin. A previous crystallographic study (Huberman, T., Eisenberg-Domovich, Y., Gitlin, G., Kulik, T., Bayer, E. A., Wilchek, M., and Livnah, O. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 32031-32039) provided insight into a plausible explanation for these results. These data revealed that the non-hydrolyzable BNP analogue, biotinyl p-nitroanilide, was almost completely sheltered in streptavidin as opposed to avidin in which the disordered conformation of a critical loop resulted in the loss of several hydrogen bonds and concomitant exposure of the analogue to the solvent. In order to determine the minimal modification of the biotin molecule required to cause the disordered loop conformation, the structures of avidin and streptavidin were determined with norbiotin, homobiotin, and a common long-chain biotin derivative, biotinyl epsilon-aminocaproic acid. Six new crystal structures of the avidin and streptavidin complexes with the latter biotin analogues and derivatives were thus elucidated. It was found that extending the biotin side chain by a single CH(2) group (i.e. homobiotin) is sufficient to result in this remarkable conformational change in the loop of avidin. These results bear significant biotechnological importance, suggesting that complexes containing biotinylated probes with streptavidin would be more stable than those with avidin. These findings should be heeded when developing new drugs based on lead compounds because it is difficult to predict the structural and conformational consequences on the resultant protein-ligand interactions.     

Factors dictating the pseudocatalytic efficiency of avidins

The hydrolysis of biotinyl p-nitrophenyl ester (BNP) by a series of avidin derivatives was examined. Surprisingly, a hyperthermostable avidin-related protein (AVR4) was shown to display extraordinary yet puzzling hydrolytic activity. In order to evaluate the molecular determinants that contribute to the reaction, the crystal structure of AVR4 was compared with those of avidin, streptavidin and key mutants of the two proteins in complex with biotinyl p-nitroanilide (BNA), the inert amide analogue of BNP. The structures revealed that a critical lysine residue contributes to the hydrolysis of BNP by avidin but has only a minor contribution to the AVR4-mediated reaction. Indeed, the respective rates of hydrolysis among the different avidins reflect several molecular parameters, including binding-site architecture, the availability of the ligand to solvent and the conformation of the ligand and consequent susceptibility to efficient nucleophilic attack. In avidin, the interaction of BNP with Lys111 and disorder of the L3,4 loop (and consequent solvent availability) together comprise the major driving force behind the hydrolysis, whereas in AVR4 the status of the ligand (the pseudo-substrate) is a major distinguishing feature. In the latter protein, a unique conformation of the L3,4 loop restrains the pseudo-substrate, thereby exposing the carbonyl carbon atom to nucleophilic attack. In addition, due to its conformation, the pseudo-substrate in the AVR4 complex cannot interact with the conserved lysine analogue (Lys109); instead, this function is superseded by polar interactions with Arg112. The results demonstrate that, in highly similar proteins, different residues can perform the same function and that subtle differences in the active-site architecture of such proteins can result in alternative modes of reaction.     

Structure-based rational design of streptavidin mutants with pseudo-catalytic activity

Introduction of enzymatic activity into proteins or other types of polymers by rational design is a major objective in the life sciences. To date, relatively low levels of enzymatic activity could be introduced into antibodies by using transition-state analogues of haptens. In the present study, we identify the structural elements that contribute to the observed hydrolytic activity in egg white avidin, which promote the cleavage of active biotin esters (notably biotinyl p-nitrophenyl ester). The latter elements were then incorporated into bacterial streptavidin via genetic engineering. The streptavidin molecule was thus converted from a protector to an enhancer of hydrolysis of biotin esters. The conversion was accomplished by the combined replacement of a "lid-like loop" (L3,4) and a leucine-to-arginine point mutation in streptavidin. Interestingly, neither of these elements play a direct role in the hydrolytic reaction. The latter features were thus shown to be responsible for enhanced substrate hydrolysis. This work indicates that structural and non-catalytic elements of a protein can be modified to promote the induced fit of a substrate for subsequent interaction with either a catalytic residue or water molecules. This approach complements the conventional design of active sites that involves direct modifications of catalytic residues.     

Easily reversible desthiobiotin binding to streptavidin,avidin, and other biotin-binding proteins: uses for protein labeling,detection, and isolation

The high-affinity binding of biotin to avidin, streptavidin, and related proteins has been exploited for decades. However, a disadvantage of the biotin/biotin-binding protein interaction is that it is essentially irreversible under physiological conditions. Desthiobiotin is a biotin analogue that binds less tightly to biotin-binding proteins and is easily displaced by biotin. We synthesized an amine-reactive desthiobiotin derivative for labeling proteins and a desthiobiotin-agarose affinity matrix. Conjugates labeled with desthiobiotin are equivalent to their biotinylated counterparts in cell-staining and antigen-labeling applications. They also bind to streptavidin and other biotin-binding protein-based affinity columns and are recognized by anti-biotin antibodies. Fluorescent streptavidin conjugates saturated with desthiobiotin, but not biotin, bind to a cell-bound biotinylated target without further processing. Streptavidin-based ligands can be gently stripped from desthiobiotin-labeled targets with buffered biotin solutions. Thus, repeated probing with fluorescent streptavidin conjugates followed by enzyme-based detection is possible. In all applications, the desthiobiotin/biotin-binding protein complex is easily dissociated under physiological conditions by either biotin or desthiobiotin. Thus, our desthiobiotin-based reagents and techniques provide some distinct advantages over traditional 2-iminobiotin, monomeric avidin, or other affinity-based techniques.     

Affinity cleavage and targeted catalysis of proteins using the avidin-biotin system

The avidin-biotin system was used in order to target enzymes to their substrates in complex mixtures of proteins in solution. The approach described here thus mimics natural systems in which enzymes usually act in selective fashion, due, perhaps, to proximity effects. For affinity cleavage studies, biotinyl transferrin was used as a model target substrate. Avidin or streptavidin was then employed to bridge between the biotinylated target protein and a biotinyl protease. Bovine serum albumin was included in the reaction mixtures to assess the level of nonspecific cleavage. In the case of an unbiotinylated target protein, avidin could be used to inhibit the hydrolytic action of the biotinyl protease. In some systems, a biotinyl antibody could be used to direct the avidin-bridged biotinyl protease to an unbiotinylated target antigen. The data support the contention that preferential cleavage reflects two separate phenomena: (i) avidin confers a conformational alteration of the biotinylated target protein, and (ii) the biotinyl protease is targeted (via the avidin bridge) to the proximity of the biotinylated target protein, thereby promoting cleavage of the conformationally altered molecule. This is the first report in which a proteolytic enzyme could be selectively targeted to specifically hydrolyze a defined protein substrate in solutions containing a complex mixture of other proteins. The approach appears to be a general phenomenon for "targeted catalysis", appropriate for other applications, particularly for affinity cleavage and targeted catalysis of cell-based macromolecules.     

Syntheses of functionalized biotin N-1' derivatives: new tools for the control of gene expression with small molecules

The exceptionally high affinity of biotin toward avidin and streptavidin is at the basis of (strept)avidin-biotin biotechnology, which has numerous applications in life sciences. Recent biotin developments for in vivo and in vitro acylation of selective targeted protein and intein-mediated site specific protein biotinylation require the free biotin carboxyl function to covalently bind with the targeted protein. However, recently this carboxylic function has been used to substitute biotin with numerous ligands and flags. In the present work, we propose the N-1' labeling possibilities of biotin, keeping the valeric chain free. We describe liquid and solid-phase syntheses of functionalized biotin N-1' derivatives. Although the N-1' modification involves a two-log decrease in affinity, in vitro these molecules kept their high avidin affinity (around 10(-12) M) and the in vivo acylation ability of new biotin derivatives.     

Neoglycoproteins: preparation and properties of complexes of biotinylated asparagine-oligosaccharides with avidin and streptavidin

Neoglycoproteins in which the oligosaccharide moieties are attached noncovalently to the protein through a high-affinity ligand have been prepared from biotinylated oligosaccharides and avidin or the nonglycosylated microbial analogue streptavidin. One of the asparagine-oligosaccharides purified from Pronase-digested ovalbumin (Man6-GlcNAc2-Asn) was reacted with an excess of the hydroxysuccinimide ester of biotin or, for the purpose of quantitation, [3H]biotin. Derivatives were also prepared with an extension "arm", a 6-aminohexanoyl group, between biotin and asparagine. When the purified biotinyl-Asn-oligosaccharide was added to avidin or streptavidin, a complex was formed containing 3 mol of oligosaccharide/mol of protein. The complexes were stable at neutral pH in the absence of biotin and could be dialyzed for 2 weeks without any significant loss of ligand. In the presence of biotin, or under denaturing conditions, the oligosaccharide derivative was released and could be quantitatively recovered. To assess the influence of the protein matrix on the reactivity of the oligosaccharide units, free biotinyl-Asn-oligosaccharide and the corresponding avidin and streptavidin complexes were exposed to alpha-mannosidase in parallel experiments. The rate of hydrolysis of the free derivative was severalfold faster than that of the two protein complexes, and at the time when about 90% of the free derivative had all five alpha-mannosyl residues removed, the majority of the protein-bound derivatives contained two to four undigested alpha-mannosyl residues and also had a significant amount of undigested starting material. The ease of preparation and the properties of these neoglycoproteins suggest that they should be excellent models for the study of glycoprotein-receptor binding and glycoprotein processing.     

Mutation of a critical tryptophan to lysine in avidin or streptavidin may explain why sea urchin fibropellin adopts an avidin-like domain

Sea urchin fibropellins are epidermal growth factor homologues that harbor a C-terminal domain, similar in sequence to hen egg-white avidin and bacterial streptavidin. The fibropellin sequence was used as a conceptual template for mutation of designated conserved tryptophan residues in the biotin-binding sites of the tetrameric proteins, avidin and streptavidin. Three different mutations of avidin, Trp-110-Lys, Trp-70-Arg and the double mutant, were expressed in a baculovirus-infected insect cell system. A mutant of streptavidin, Trp-120-Lys, was similarly expressed. The homologous tryptophan to lysine (W-->K) mutations of avidin and streptavidin were both capable of binding biotin and biotinylated material. Their affinity for the vitamin was, however, significantly reduced: from K(d) approximately 10(-15) M of the wild-type tetramer down to K(d) approximately 10(-8) M for both W-->K mutants. In fact, their binding to immobilized biotin matrices could be reversed by the presence of free biotin. The Trp-70-Arg mutant of avidin bound biotin very poorly and the double mutant (which emulates the fibropellin domain) failed to bind biotin at all. Using a gel filtration fast-protein liquid chromatography assay, both W-->K mutants were found to form stable dimers in solution. These findings may indicate that mimicry in the nature of the avidin sequence and fold by the fibropellins is not designed to generate biotin-binding, but may serve to secure an appropriate structure for facilitating dimerization.     

Identification of the tRNA-binding protein Arc1p as a novel target of in vivo biotinylation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Biotin is an essential cofactor of cell metabolism serving as a protein-bound coenzyme in ATP-dependent carboxylation, in transcarboxylation, and certain decarboxylation reactions. The involvement of biotinylated proteins in other cellular functions has been suggested occasionally, but available data on this are limited. In the present study, a Saccharomyces cerevisiae protein was identified that reacts with streptavidin on Western blots and is not identical to one of the known biotinylated yeast proteins. After affinity purification on monomeric avidin, the biotinylated protein was identified as Arc1p. Using 14C-labeled biotin, the cofactor was shown to be incorporated into Arc1p by covalent and alkali-stable linkage. Similar to the known carboxylases, Arc1p biotinylation is mediated by the yeast biotin:protein ligase, Bpl1p. Mutational studies revealed that biotinylation occurs at lysine 86 within the N-terminal domain of Arc1p. In contrast to the known carboxylases, however, in vitro biotinylation of Arc1p is incomplete and increases with BPL1 overexpression. In accordance to this fact, Arc1p lacks the canonical consensus sequence of known biotin binding domains, and the bacterial biotin:protein ligase, BirA, is unable to use Arc1p as a substrate. Arc1p was shown previously to organize the association of MetRS and GluRS tRNA synthetases with their cognate tRNAs thereby increasing the substrate affinity and catalytic efficiency of these enzymes. Remarkably, not only biotinylated but also the biotin-free Arc1p obtained by replacement of lysine 86 with arginine were capable of restoring Arc1p function in both arc1Delta and arc1Deltalos1Delta mutants, indicating that biotinylation of Arc1p is not essential for activity.     

Improved affinity of engineered streptavidin for the Strep-tag II peptide is due to a fixed open conformation of the lid-like loop at the binding site

The Strep-tag II is a nine-amino acid peptide that was developed as an affinity tool for the purification of corresponding fusion proteins on streptavidin columns. The peptide recognizes the same pocket of streptavidin where the natural ligand is normally bound so that biotin or its chemical derivatives can be used for competitive elution. We report here the crystal structures of the streptavidin mutants '1' and '2,' which had been engineered for 10-fold higher affinity towards the Strep-tag II. Both streptavidin mutants carry mutations at positions 44, 45, and 47, that is, in a flexible loop region close to the binding site. The crystal structures of the two apo-proteins and their complexes with the Strep-tag II peptide were refined at resolutions below 2 A. Both in the presence and absence of the peptide, the lid-like loop next to the ligand pocket--comprising residues 45 through 52--adopts an 'open' conformation in all four subunits within the asymmetric unit. The same loop was previously described to be disordered in the wild-type apo-streptavidin and to close over the pocket upon complexation of the natural ligand biotin. Our findings suggest that stabilization of the 'open' loop conformation in the absence of a ligand abolishes the need for conformational rearrangement prior to the docking of the voluminous peptide. Because no direct contacts between the flexible part of the loop and the peptide ligand were detected, it seems likely that the higher affinity of the two streptavidin mutants for the Strep-tag II is caused by a predominantly entropic mechanism.     

A sensitive enzyme assay for biotin, avidin, and streptavidin

Reciprocal enzyme assays are described for the vitamin biotin and for the biotin-binding proteins avidin and streptavidin. The assays are based on the following steps: (a) biotinylated bovine serum albumin is adsorbed onto microtiter plates; (b) streptavidin (or avidin) is bound to the biotin-coated plates; (c) biotinylated enzyme (in this case alkaline phosphatase) is then interacted with the free biotin-binding sites on the immobilized protein. For biotin assay, competition between the free vitamin and the biotinylated enzyme is carried out between steps (b) and (c). The method takes advantage of the four biotin-binding sites which characterize both avidin and streptavidin. The method is extremely versatile and accurate over a concentration range exceeding three orders of magnitude. The lower limits of detection are approximately 2 pg/ml (0.2 pg/sample) for biotin and less than 100 ng/ml (10 ng/sample) for either avidin or streptavidin.     

A plasmid expression system for quantitative in vivo biotinylation of thioredoxin fusion proteins in Escherichia coli.

The high affinity binding interaction of biotin to avidin or streptavidin has been used widely in biochemistry and molecular biology, often in sensitive protein detection or protein capture applications. However, in vitro chemical techniques for protein biotinylation are not always successful, with some common problems being a lack of reaction specificity, inactivation of amino acid residues critical for protein function and low levels of biotin incorporation. This report describes an improved expression system for the highly specific and quantitative in vivo biotinylation of fusion proteins. A short 'biotinylation peptide', described previously by Schatz, is linked to the N-terminus of Escherichia coli thioredoxin (TrxA) to form a new protein, called BIOTRX. The 'biotinylation peptide' serves as an in vivo substrate mimic for E. coli biotin holoenzyme synthetase (BirA), an enzyme which usually performs highly selective biotinylation of E.coli biotin carboxyl carrier protein (BCCP). A plasmid expression vector carrying the BIOTRX and birA genes arranged as a bacterial operon can be used to obtain high level production of soluble BIOTRX and BirA proteins and, under appropriate culture conditions, BIOTRX protein produced by this system is completely biotinylated. Fusions of BIOTRX to other proteins or peptides, whether these polypeptides are linked to the C-terminus or inserted into the BIOTRX active site loop, are also quantitatively biotinylated. Both types of BIOTRX fusion can be captured efficiently on avidin/streptavidin media for purification purposes or to facilitate interaction assays. We illustrate the utility of the system by measurements of antibody and soluble receptor protein binding to BIOTRX fusions immobilized on streptavidin-conjugated BIAcore chips.     

Colorimetric competitive inhibition method for the quantification of avidin, streptavidin and biotin.

A colorimetric competitive inhibition assay for avidin, streptavidin and biotin was developed. The method for avidin or streptavidin was based on the competitive binding between avidin or streptavidin and a streptavidin-enzyme conjugate for biotinylated dextrin immobilized on the surface of a microtitre plate. For biotin quantitation the competition is between free biotin and the immobilized biotin for the streptavidin-enzyme conjugate. The limits of detection which was determined as the concentration of competitor required to give 90% of maximal absorbency (100% inhibition) was approximately 20 ng/100 microl per assay for avidin and streptavidin and 0.4 pg/100 microl per assay for biotin. The methods are simple, rapid, highly sensitive and adaptable to high throughput analysis.     

Chicken avidin-related protein 4/5 shows superior thermal stability when compared with avidin while retaining high affinity to biotin

The protein chicken avidin is a commonly used tool in various applications. The avidin gene belongs to a gene family that also includes seven other members known as the avidin-related genes (AVR). We report here on the extremely high thermal stability and functional characteristics of avidin-related protein AVR4/5, a member of the avidin protein family. The thermal stability characteristics of AVR4/5 were examined using a differential scanning calorimeter, microparticle analysis, and a microplate assay. Its biotin-binding properties were studied using an isothermal calorimeter and IAsys optical biosensor. According to these analyses, in the absence of biotin AVR4/5 is clearly more stable (T(m) = 107.4 +/- 0.3 degrees C) than avidin (T(m) = 83.5 +/- 0.1 degrees C) or bacterial streptavidin (T(m) = 75.5 degrees C). AVR4/5 also exhibits a high affinity for biotin (K(d) approximately 3.6 x 10(-14) m) comparable to that of avidin and streptavidin (K(d) approximately 10(-15) m). Molecular modeling and site-directed mutagenesis were used to study the molecular details behind the observed high thermostability. The results indicate that AVR4/5 and its mutants have high potential as new improved tools for applications where exceptionally high stability and tight biotin binding are needed.     

An improved method for the single-step purification of streptavidin

A new method for the preparation of a more efficient, stable iminobiotin-containing resin for the isolation of streptavidin was developed. CL-Sepharose was activated with p-nitrophenyl chloroformate, and the resultant carbonate derivative was reacted with diaminohexane. Subsequent reaction of the amino-containing resin with iminobiotin-N-hydroxysuccinimide ester (in an organic solvent) yielded the stable affinity resin. The capacity of this resin for either avidin or streptavidin was 12 mg per ml resin, and streptavidin could be purified in one step directly from the culture broth of Streptomyces avidinii. The biotin-binding protein isolated in this manner exhibited a major band at about 75 kDa and a minor band at about 150 kDa. Under denaturing conditions, a spectrum of subunit molecular weights ranging between 15 and 19 kDa was detected, the distribution of which depended upon the specific preparation.     

Tissue distribution of avidin and streptavidin injected to mice. Effect of avidin carbohydrate, streptavidin truncation and exogenous biotin

Radioionated avidin and streptavidin were characterized for their biodistribution and tissue association in Balb/c mice, in comparison to their interaction with cells in vitro. Binding of avidin to spleen and bone-marrow cells in vitro was up to 20-fold higher than that of streptavidin, but when tested in vivo avidin clearance from blood and tissues was considerably faster than that of streptavidin. Levels of avidin at 24 h after an intravenous injection were below 1% (of the injected dose/mass tissue) in most organs. Non-glycosylated avidin was similar in its biodistribution to native avidin. Native streptavidin exhibited higher and prolonged tissue association with 5-10% levels in lung, liver, spleen, kidney and blood, whereas its truncated form showed low tissue levels (1-3%) but a remarkably high affinity to the kidney (80%). Exogenous biotin did not affect streptavidin distribution in vivo but caused a 2-7-fold increase in the retention of avidin (but not non-glycodylated avidin) in some of the organs.     

Avidin-like domain in an epidermal growth factor homolog from a sea urchin

We have found that a protein from the purple sea urchin has a carboxyl-terminal domain with striking sequence similarity to chicken avidin and bacterial streptavidin. All our evidence supports the homology of these sequences. Tetramers of avidin and streptavidin bind biotin strongly; the biotin binding site involves two to four tryptophans and probably an adjacent lysine in each chain. The presence of four tryptophans at equivalent positions in the sea urchin protein domain suggests that it may also be able to bind biotin and inhibit cell growth, as do the two other proteins. Alternatively, this domain may have acquired a new role as part of a multidomain protein.     

Peptide synthesis catalyzed by polyethylene glycol-modified chymotrypsin in organic solvents

Chymotrypsin modified with polyethylene glycol was successfully used for peptide synthesis in organic solvents. The benzene-soluble modified enzyme readily catalyzed both aminolysis of N-benzoyl-L-tyrosine p-nitroanilide and synthesis of N-benzoyl-L-tyrosine butylamide in the presence of trace amounts of water. A quantitative reaction was obtained when either hydrophobic or bulky amides of L- as well as D-amino acids were used as acceptor nucleophiles, while almost no reaction occurred with free amino acids or ester derivatives. The acceptor nucleophile specificity of modified chymotrypsin as a catalyst in the formation of both amide and peptide bonds in organic solvents was quite comparable to that in aqueous solution as well as to that of the leaving group in hydrolysis reactions. By contrast, the substrate specificity of modified chymotrypsin in organic solvents was different from that in water since arginine and lysine esters were found to be as effective as aromatic amino acids to form the acyl-enzyme with subsequent synthesis of a peptide bond.     

Affinity chromatography of DNA labeled with chemically cleavable biotinylated nucleotide analogs

DNA labeled with the chemically cleavable biotinylated nucleotide Bio-12-SS-dUTP was chromatographed on biotin cellulose affinity columns using either avidin or streptavidin as the affinity reagent. Although both proteins were equally effective in binding the Bio-12-SS-DNA to the affinity resin, two important differences were found. First, nonbiotinylated DNA bound to avidin, but not to streptavidin, in buffers containing 50 mM NaCl. Second, Bio-12-SS-DNA was released much more slowly from the streptavidin affinity column than from the avidin column upon washing with buffer containing dithiothreitol. This difficulty in reducing the disulfide bond of Bio-12-SS-DNA bound to streptavidin is most likely due to steric protection of the disulfide bond by the protein. This conclusion is supported by our finding that DNA labeled with another biotinylated nucleotide analog, Bio-19-SS-dUTP, is rapidly and efficiently recovered from a streptavidin column. In Bio-19-SS-DNA, the distance between the disulfide bond and the biotin group is approximately 10 A greater than that in Bio-12-SS-DNA. Therefore, Bio-19-SS-dUTP and streptavidin form the basis of an efficient affinity system for the isolation and subsequent recovery of biotinylated DNA in the presence of low ionic strength buffers.     

Mild conditions for releasing mono and bis-biotinylated macromolecules from immobilized streptavidin

The high affinity (kd= approximately 10(-15)M) of streptavidin and avidin for biotin is key to a large number of biological applications and is essentially irreversible unless the complex is exposed to harsh conditions (e.g. heat (100 degrees C for 10 min)), detergents, and/or denaturants which damage macromolecules. Thus, high binding affinity becomes a disadvantage when a biotinylated target must be released for further processing. This work describes relatively mild conditions that release biotin and mono- and bis-biotinylated macromolecules from immobilized streptavidin on monodispersed magnetic beads.