Comparison of the efficiencies of different affinity tags in the purification of a recombinant secretory protein expressed in silkworm larval hemolymph

Silkworms are useful bioreactors for heterologous protein expression when used in conjunction with the Bombyx mori nucleopolyhedrovirus (BmNPV) bacmid system. However, purification from silkworm hemolymph is difficult since it contains various kinds of proteins. In this study, we investigated an effective single-step method for the purification of affinity-tagged single-chain antibody variable region fragment (scFv) from silkworm larval hemolymph. A 5-fold higher expression level was obtained when scFv was fused with the His tag than when it was fused with the Strep II or GST tags. However, the His tag was inadequate for single-step purification since it led to the nonspecific binding of contaminants. The purification recoveries of GST-, Strep II-, and His-tagged scFvs were 91.8%, 43.7%, and 27.2%, respectively. The specific amount of single-step purified GST-tagged scFv was 2.2∼2.7 fold higher than the amounts of the His- and Strep II-tagged constructs. The purities of Strep II- and GST-tagged scFvs in the eluent were 98.4% and 83.0%, respectively. Thus, both the short peptide Strep II and GST protein are suitable fusion tags for the affinity purification of proteins from silkworm larvae.     

Comparison of affinity tags for protein purification

Affinity tags are highly efficient tools for purifying proteins from crude extracts. To facilitate the selection of affinity tags for purification projects, we have compared the efficiency of eight elutable affinity tags to purify proteins from Escherichia coli, yeast, Drosophila, and HeLa extracts. Our results show that the HIS, CBP, CYD (covalent yet dissociable NorpD peptide), Strep II, FLAG, HPC (heavy chain of protein C) peptide tags, and the GST and MBP protein fusion tag systems differ substantially in purity, yield, and cost. We find that the HIS tag provides good yields of tagged protein from inexpensive, high capacity resins but with only moderate purity from E. coli extracts and relatively poor purification from yeast, Drosophila, and HeLa extracts. The CBP tag produced moderate purity protein from E. coli, yeast, and Drosophila extracts, but better purity from HeLa extracts. Epitope-based tags such as FLAG and HPC produced the highest purity protein for all extracts but require expensive, low capacity resin. Our results suggest that the Strep II tag may provide an acceptable compromise of excellent purification with good yields at a moderate cost.     

A fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based binding assay for characterizing kinase inhibitors: Important role for C-terminal biotin tagging of the kinase

Novel biochemical strategies are needed to identify the next generation of protein kinase inhibitors. One promising new assay format is a competition binding approach that employs time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR–FRET). In this assay, a FRET donor is bound to the kinase via a purification tag, whereas a FRET acceptor is bound via a tracer-labeled inhibitor. Displacement of the tracer by an unlabeled inhibitor eliminates FRET between the fluorophores and provides a readout on binding. Although promising, this technique has so far been limited in applicability in part by a lack of signal strength is some cases and also by an inability to predict whether a particular tagging strategy will show robust FRET. In this work, we sought to better understand the factors that give rise to a strong FRET signal in this assay. We determined the magnitude of FRET for several tyrosine kinases using different purification tags (biotin, glutathione S-transferase [GST], and His) placed at either the N terminus or C terminus of the kinase. It was observed that coupling the FRET acceptor to the kinase C terminus using a biotin/streptavidin interaction resulted in the greatest increase in FRET. Specifically, for multiple kinases, the signal/background ratio was at least 3-fold better using C-terminal biotinylation compared with tagging at the N terminus using a His/anti-His antibody or GST/anti-GST antibody interaction. In one case, the FRET signal using C-terminal biotin tagging was more than 150-fold over background. This strong FRET signal facilitated development of improved inhibitor binding assays that required only tens of picomolar enzyme or tracer-labeled inhibitor. Together, these results indicate that C-terminal biotinylation is a promising tagging strategy for developing an optimal FRET-based competition binding assay for tyrosine kinases.     

Tandem affinity purification in Drosophila: the advantages of the GS-TAP system

Tandem affinity purification (TAP) has been widely used for the analysis of protein complexes. We investigated the parameters of the recently developed TAP method (GS-TAP) and its application in Drosophila. This new tag combination includes two Protein G modules and a streptavidin binding peptide (SBP), separated by one or two TEV protease cleavage sites. We made pMK33-based GS-TAP vectors to allow for generation of stable cell lines using hygromycin selection and inducible expression from a metallothionein promoter, as well as pUAST-based vectors that can be used for inducible expression in flies. Rescue experiments in flies demonstrated that the GS-TAP tag preserves the function of the tagged protein. We have done parallel purifications of proteins tagged with the new GS-TAP tag or with the conventional TAP tag (containing the Protein A and calmodulin binding peptide domains) at the amino terminus, using both cultured cells and embryos. A major difference between the two tags was in the levels of contaminating proteins, which were significantly lower in the GS-TAP purifications. The GS-TAP procedure also resulted in higher yield of the bait protein. Overall, GS-TAP is an improved method of protein complex purification because it provides a superior signal-to-noise ratio of the bait protein relative to contaminants in purified material.     

Fluorogen-Activating scFv Biosensors Target Surface Markers on Live Cells Via Streptavidin or Single-Chain Avidin

Fluorescence biosensors are indispensable tools for understanding protein behavior and function in cells. Recent advancements utilize fluorogen-activating-proteins (FAPs) that form complexes with small organic molecules (fluorogens) and result in their fluorescence activation. The technology has found multiple uses in protein discovery applications; however, the current method of detection requires the expression of FAPs as gene fusion tags in cells—a process that is time- and labor-intensive. In this report, we present an alternate method that utilizes FAPs as affinity reagents. Accordingly, we isolated soluble reagents based on FAP fusions with streptavidin (Strep) or avidin proteins, both highly selective for biotin. When tested in vitro, the reagents displayed bi-functional activity, fluorogen activation, and biotin affinity. For live-cell protein discovery, surface targets were biotinylated via biotin-tagged immunoglobulins or a genetically encoded biotin acceptor peptide. As a result, when the cells were labeled with FAP–Strep or FAP–avidin reagent, the in vivo fluorescence measurements indicated high target specificity, minimal background, and bright signal detection. In summary, we present a novel FAP reagent platform that offers a rapid and efficient approach for cell surface protein detection.     

Analysis of protein tyrosine phosphatase interactions with microarrayed phosphopeptide substrates using imaging mass spectrometry

Microarrays of peptide and recombinant protein libraries are routinely used for high-throughput studies of protein–protein interactions and enzymatic activities. Imaging mass spectrometry (IMS) is currently applied as a method to localize analytes on thin tissue sections and other surfaces. Here, we have applied IMS as a label-free means to analyze protein–peptide interactions in a microarray-based phosphatase assay. This IMS strategy visualizes the entire microarray in one composite image by collecting a predefined raster of matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight (MALDI–TOF) mass spectrometry spectra over the surface of the chip. Examining the bacterial tyrosine phosphatase YopH, we used IMS as a label-free means to visualize enzyme binding and activity with a microarrayed phosphopeptide library printed on chips coated with either gold or indium–tin oxide. Furthermore, we demonstrate that microarray-based IMS can be coupled with surface plasmon resonance imaging to add kinetic analyses to measured binding interactions. The method described here is within the capabilities of many modern MALDI–TOF instruments and has general utility for the label-free analysis of microarray assays.     

Identification of Protein Interacting Partners Using Tandem Affinity Purification

A critical and often limiting step in understanding the function of host and viral proteins is the identification of interacting cellular or viral protein partners. There are many approaches that allow the identification of interacting partners, including the yeast two hybrid system, as well as pull down assays using recombinant proteins and immunoprecipitation of endogenous proteins followed by mass spectrometry identification¹. Recent studies have highlighted the utility of double-affinity tag mediated purification, coupled with two specific elution steps in the identification of interacting proteins. This approach, termed Tandem Affinity Purification (TAP), was initially used in yeast^2,3 but more recently has been adapted to use in mammalian cells^4-8.As proof-of-concept we have established a tandem affinity purification (TAP) method using the well-characterized eukaryotic translation initiation factor eIF4E^9,10.The cellular translation factor eIF4E is a critical component of the cellular eIF4F complex involved in cap-dependent translation initiation¹⁰. The TAP tag used in the current study is composed of two Protein G units and a streptavidin binding peptide separated by a Tobacco Etch Virus (TEV) protease cleavage sequence. The TAP tag used in the current study is composed of two Protein G units and a streptavidin binding peptide separated by a Tobacco Etch Virus (TEV) protease cleavage sequence⁸. To forgo the need for the generation of clonal cell lines, we developed a rapid system that relies on the expression of the TAP-tagged bait protein from an episomally maintained plasmid based on pMEP4 (Invitrogen). Expression of tagged murine eIF4E from this plasmid was controlled using the cadmium chloride inducible metallothionein promoter.Lysis of the expressing cells and subsequent affinity purification via binding to rabbit IgG agarose, TEV protease cleavage, binding to streptavidin linked agarose and subsequent biotin elution identified numerous proteins apparently specific to the eIF4E pull-down (when compared to control cell lines expressing the TAP tag alone). The identities of the proteins were obtained by excision of the bands from 1D SDS-PAGE and subsequent tandem mass spectrometry. The identified components included the known eIF4E binding proteins eIF4G and 4EBP-1. In addition, other components of the eIF4F complex, of which eIF4E is a component were identified, namely eIF4A and Poly-A binding protein. The ability to identify not only known direct binding partners as well as secondary interacting proteins, further highlights the utility of this approach in the characterization of proteins of unknown function.     

High resolution structure of streptavidin in complex with a novel high affinity peptide tag mimicking the biotin binding motif

A novel peptide was designed which possesses nanomolar affinity of less than 20 nM for streptavidin. Therefore it was termed Nano-tag and has been used as an affinity tag for recombinant proteins. The minimized version of the wild type Nano-tag is a seven-amino acid peptide with the sequence fMDVEAWL. The three-dimensional structure of wild type streptavidin in complex with the minimized Nano-tag was analyzed at atomic resolution of 1.15 A and the details of the binding motif were investigated. The peptide recognizes the same pocket of streptavidin where the natural ligand biotin is bound, but the peptide requires significantly more space than biotin. Therefore the binding loop adopts an "open" conformation in order to release additional space for the peptide. The conformation of the bound Nano-tag corresponds to a 3(10) helix. However, the analysis of the intermolecular interactions of the Nano-tag with residues of the binding pocket of streptavidin reveals astonishing similarities to the biotin binding motif. In principle the three-dimensional conformation of the Nano-tag mimics the binding mode of biotin. Our results explain why the use of the Nano-tag in fusion with recombinant proteins is restricted to their N-terminus and we describe the special significance of the fMet residue for the high affinity binding mode.     

Plasmid vectors for proteomic analyses in Giardia: purification of virulence factors and analysis of the proteasome

In recent years, proteomics has come of age with the development of efficient tools for purification, identification, and characterization of gene products predicted by genome projects. The intestinal protozoan Giardia intestinalis can be transfected, but there is only a limited set of vectors available, and most of them are not user friendly. This work delineates the construction of a suite of cassette-based expression vectors for use in Giardia. Expression is provided by the strong constitutive ornithine carbamoyltransferase (OCT) promoter, and tagging is possible in both N- and C-terminal configurations. Taken together, the vectors are capable of providing protein localization and production of recombinant proteins, followed by efficient purification by a novel affinity tag combination, streptavidin binding peptide-glutathione S-transferase (SBP-GST). The option of removing the tags from purified proteins was provided by the inclusion of a PreScission protease site. The efficiency and feasibility of producing and purifying endogenous recombinant Giardia proteins with the developed vectors was demonstrated by the purification of active recombinant arginine deiminase (ADI) and OCT from stably transfected trophozoites. Moreover, we describe the tagging, purification by StrepTactin affinity chromatography, and compositional analysis by mass spectrometry of the G. intestinalis 26S proteasome by employing the Strep II-FLAG-tandem affinity purification (SF-TAP) tag. This is the first report of efficient production and purification of recombinant proteins in and from Giardia, which will allow the study of specific parasite proteins and protein complexes.     

Microarray analysis of protein-protein interactions based on FRET using subnanosecond-resolved fluorescence lifetime imaging

The detection of protein-protein binding on microarrays using the fluorescence lifetime as a dynamic analytical parameter was investigated in a model system. The assay is based on F?rster resonance energy transfer (FRET) and carried out with biotinylated Bovine Serum Albumin and streptavidin, labeled with the commonly used microarray dyes Alexa 555 and Alexa 647, respectively. This efficient FRET donor/acceptor pair was employed in a competitive assay format on three different microarray surfaces. The fluorescence was excited by 200ps laser pulses from a mode-locked and cavity-dumped argon-ion laser, adapted to an intensified CCD camera as detection unit allowing time resolution with subnanosecond precision. Lifetime maps were recorded according to the Rapid Lifetime Determination (RLD) scheme. Interaction between the proteins could clearly be detected on all formats and resulted in almost complete quenching on CEL Epoxy surfaces upon addition of excess streptavidin labeled the FRET acceptor dye. In this case, the fluorescence lifetimes dropped by 90%, whereas on ARChip Epoxy and ARChip Gel the reduction was 54% and 47%, respectively. Good linearity of the quenching curve was obtained in all cases. The method is applicable to all types of protein interaction analysis on microarrays, particularly in cases where evaluation of fluorescence intensity is prone to erroneous results and a more robust parameter is required.     

Comparison of quantum dot-binding protein tags: Affinity determination by ultracentrifugation and FRET

Background

Hybrid complexes of proteins and colloidal semiconductor nanocrystals (quantum dots, QDs) are of increasing interest in various fields of biochemistry and biomedicine, for instance for biolabeling or drug transport. The usefulness of protein–QD complexes for such applications is dependent on the binding specificity and strength of the components. Often the binding properties of these components are difficult and time consuming to assess.

Methods

In this work we characterized the interaction between recombinant light harvesting chlorophyll a/b complex (LHCII) and CdTe/CdSe/ZnS QDs by using ultracentrifugation and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) assay experiments. Ultracentrifugation was employed as a fast method to compare the binding strength between different protein tags and the QDs. Furthermore the LHCII:QD stoichiometry was determined by separating the protein–QD hybrid complexes from unbound LHCII via ultracentrifugation through a sucrose cushion.

Results

One trimeric LHCII was found to be bound per QD. Binding constants were evaluated by FRET assays of protein derivatives carrying different affinity tags. A new tetra-cysteine motif interacted more strongly (K_a = 4.9 ± 1.9 nM^− 1) with the nanoparticles as compared to a hexahistidine tag (His₆ tag) (K_a ~ 1 nM^− 1).

Conclusion

Relative binding affinities and binding stoichiometries of hybrid complexes from LHCII and quantum dots were identified via fast ultracentrifugation, and binding constants were determined via FRET assays.

General significance

The combination of rapid centrifugation and fluorescence-based titration will be useful to assess the binding strength between different types of nanoparticles and a broad range of proteins.     

Fluorescent labeling agents change binding profiles of glycan-binding proteins

Interactions of glycan-binding proteins (GBPs) with glycans are essential in cell adhesion, bacterial/viral infection, and cellular signaling pathways. Experimental characterization of these interactions based on glycan microarrays typically involves (1) labeling GBPs directly with fluorescent reagents before incubation with the microarrays, or (2) labeling GBPs with biotin before the incubation and detecting the captured GBPs after the incubation using fluorescently labeled streptavidin, or (3) detecting the captured GBPs after the incubation using fluorescently labeled antibodies raised against the GBPs. The fluorescent signal is mostly measured ex situ after excess fluorescent materials are washed off. In this study, by using a label-free optical scanner for glycan microarray detection, we measured binding curves of 7 plant lectins to 24 glycans: four β1-4-linked galactosides, three β1-3-linked galactosides, one β-linked galactoside, one α-linked N-acetylgalactosaminide, eight α2-3-linked sialosides, and seven α2-6-linked sialosides. From association and dissociation constants deduced by global-fitting the binding curves, we found that (1) labeling lectins directly with fluorescent agents change binding profiles of lectins, in some cases by orders of magnitude; (2) those lectin-glycan binding reactions characterized with large dissociation rates, though biologically relevant, are easily missed or deemed insignificant in ex situ fluorescence-based assays as most captured lectins are washed off before detection. This study highlights the importance of label-free real-time detection of protein-ligand interactions and the potential pitfall in interpreting fluorescence-based assays for characterization of protein-glycan interactions.     

Measurement of genome wide DNA methylation by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography

Intrinsic affinity tags are useful tools for the study of macromolecular targets. Although polypeptide affinity tags are routinely used in purification and detection of protein complexes, there has been a relative lack of powerful RNA affinity tags that can be embedded within RNA sequences. Here, the preparation and use of two RNA affinity tags against Sephadex or streptavidin are described. The two tags have different strengths that make them appropriate for slightly different uses. One is a high-affinity ligand for streptavidin that can be specifically eluted by competition with biotin under otherwise native binding conditions. The other tag binds selectively to Sephadex beads, and can be eluted by competition with the soluble dextran that composes Sephadex. When properly placed within another RNA molecule, the tags can be used to effect dramatic purification of RNA or ribonucleoprotein complexes from complex mixtures of cellular RNA.     

Fcγ1 fragment of IgG1 as a powerful affinity tag in recombinant Fc-fusion proteins: immunological,biochemical and therapeutic properties

Affinity tags are vital tools for the production of high-throughput recombinant proteins. Several affinity tags, such as the hexahistidine tag, maltose-binding protein, streptavidin-binding peptide tag, calmodulin-binding peptide, c-Myc tag, glutathione S-transferase and FLAG tag, have been introduced for recombinant protein production. The fragment crystallizable (Fc) domain of the IgG1 antibody is one of the useful affinity tags that can facilitate detection, purification and localization of proteins and can improve the immunogenicity, modulatory effects, physicochemical and pharmaceutical properties of proteins. Fcγ recombinant forms a group of recombinant proteins called Fc-fusion proteins (FFPs). FFPs are widely used in drug discovery, drug delivery, vaccine design and experimental research on receptor–ligand interactions. These fusion proteins have become successful alternatives to monoclonal antibodies for drug developments. In this review, the physicochemical, biochemical, immunological, pharmaceutical and therapeutic properties of recombinant FFPs were discussed as a new generation of bioengineering strategies.     

Highly efficient purification of protein complexes from mammalian cells using a novel streptavidin-binding peptide and hexahistidine tandem tag system: application to Bruton's tyrosine kinase

Tandem affinity purification (TAP) is a generic approach for the purification of protein complexes. The key advantage of TAP is the engineering of dual affinity tags that, when attached to the protein of interest, allow purification of the target protein along with its binding partners through two consecutive purification steps. The tandem tag used in the original method consists of two IgG‐binding units of protein A from Staphylococcus aureus (ProtA) and the calmodulin‐binding peptide (CBP), and it allows for recovery of 20–30% of the bait protein in yeast. When applied to higher eukaryotes, however, this classical TAP tag suffers from low yields. To improve protein recovery in systems other than yeast, we describe herein the development of a three‐tag system comprised of CBP, streptavidin‐binding peptide (SBP) and hexa‐histidine. We illustrate the application of this approach for the purification of human Bruton's tyrosine kinase (Btk), which results in highly efficient binding and elution of bait protein in both purification steps (>50% recovery). Combined with mass spectrometry for protein identification, this TAP strategy facilitated the first nonbiased analysis of Btk interacting proteins. The high efficiency of the SBP‐His₆ purification allows for efficient recovery of protein complexes formed with a target protein of interest from a small amount of starting material, enhancing the ability to detect low abundance and transient interactions in eukaryotic cell systems.     

Non-natural cell surface receptors: synthetic peptides capped with N-cholesterylglycine efficiently deliver proteins into Mammalian cells

Protein toxins such as shiga toxin and cholera toxin penetrate into cells by binding small molecule-based cell surface receptors localized to cholesterol and sphingolipid-rich lipid raft subdomains of cellular plasma membranes. Molecular recognition between these toxins and their receptors triggers endocytic protein uptake through endogenous membrane trafficking pathways. We report herein the synthesis of functionally related non-natural cell surface receptors comprising peptides capped with N-cholesterylglycine as the plasma membrane anchor. The peptide moieties of these receptors were based on high-affinity epitopes of anti-hemaglutinin antibodies (anti-HA), anti-Flag antibodies, and a moderate-affinity Strep Tag II peptide ligand of the streptavidin protein from Streptomyces avidini. These non-natural receptors were directly loaded into plasma membranes of Jurkat lymphocytes to display peptides from lipid rafts on the cell surface. Molecular recognition between these receptors and added cognate anti-HA, anti-Flag, or streptavidin proteins resulted in rapid clathrin-mediated endocytosis; fluorescent target proteins were completely internalized within 4-12 h of protein addition. Analysis of protein uptake by epifluorescence microscopy and flow cytometry revealed intracellular fluorescence enhancements of 100-fold to 200-fold (10 microM non-natural receptor) with typically >99% efficiency. This method enabled intracellular delivery of a functional Escherichia coli beta-galactosidase enzyme conjugated to Protein A from Staphylococcus aureus. We termed this novel delivery strategy "synthetic receptor targeting", which is an efficient method to enhance macromolecular uptake by decorating mammalian cells with chemically defined synthetic receptors that access the molecular machinery controlling the organization of cellular plasma membranes.     

A highly efficient multifunctional tandem affinity purification approach applicable to diverse organisms

Determining the localization, binding partners, and secondary modifications of individual proteins is crucial for understanding protein function. Several tags have been constructed for protein localization or purification under either native or denaturing conditions, but few tags permit all three simultaneously. Here, we describe a multifunctional tandem affinity purification (MAP) method that is both highly efficient and enables protein visualization. The MAP tag utilizes affinity tags inserted into an exposed surface loop of mVenus offering two advantages: (1) mVenus fluorescence can be used for protein localization or FACS-based selection of cell lines; and (2) spatial separation of the affinity tags from the protein results in high recovery and reduced variability between proteins. MAP purification was highly efficient in multiple organisms for all proteins tested. As a test case, MAP combined with liquid chromatography-tandem MS identified known and new candidate binding partners and modifications of the kinase Plk1. Thus the MAP tag is a new powerful tool for determining protein modification, localization, and interactions.     

Plug-and-Play Pairing via Defined Divalent Streptavidins

Streptavidin is one of the most important hubs for molecular biology, either multimerizing biomolecules, bridging one molecule to another, or anchoring to a biotinylated surface/nanoparticle. Streptavidin has the advantage of rapid ultra-stable binding to biotin. However, the ability of streptavidin to bind four biotinylated molecules in a heterogeneous manner is often limiting. Here, we present an efficient approach to isolate streptavidin tetramers with two biotin-binding sites in a precise arrangement, cis or trans. We genetically modified specific subunits with negatively charged tags, refolded a mixture of monomers, and used ion-exchange chromatography to resolve tetramers according to the number and orientation of tags. We solved the crystal structures of cis-divalent streptavidin to 1.4 Å resolution and trans-divalent streptavidin to 1.6 Å resolution, validating the isolation strategy and explaining the behavior of the Dead streptavidin variant. cis- and trans-divalent streptavidins retained tetravalent streptavidin's high thermostability and low off-rate. These defined divalent streptavidins enabled us to uncover how streptavidin binding depends on the nature of the biotin ligand. Biotinylated DNA showed strong negative cooperativity of binding to cis-divalent but not trans-divalent streptavidin. A small biotinylated protein bound readily to cis and trans binding sites. We also solved the structure of trans-divalent streptavidin bound to biotin-4-fluorescein, showing how one ligand obstructs binding to an adjacent biotin-binding site. Using a hexaglutamate tag proved a more powerful way to isolate monovalent streptavidin, for ultra-stable labeling without undesired clustering. These forms of streptavidin allow this key hub to be used with a new level of precision, for homogeneous molecular assembly.