Differential inhibition of mRNA degradation pathways by novel cap analogs

mRNA degradation predominantly proceeds through two alternative routes: the 5'-->3' pathway, which requires deadenylation followed by decapping and 5'-->3' hydrolysis; and the 3'-->5' pathway, which involves deadenylation followed by 3'-->5' hydrolysis and finally decapping. The mechanisms and relative contributions of each pathway are not fully understood. We investigated the effects of different cap structure (Gp(3)G, m(7)Gp(3)G, or m(2)(7,3'-O) Gp(3)G) and 3' termini (A(31),A(60), or G(16)) on both translation and mRNA degradation in mammalian cells. The results indicated that cap structures that bind eIF4E with higher affinity stabilize mRNA to degradation in vivo. mRNA stability depends on the ability of the 5' terminus to bind eIF4E, not merely the presence of a blocking group at the 5'-end. Introducing a stem-loop in the 5'-UTR that dramatically reduces translation, but keeping the cap structure the same, does not alter the rate of mRNA degradation. To test the relative contributions of the 5'-->3' versus 3'-->5' pathways, we designed and synthesized two new cap analogs, in which a methylene group was substituted between the alpha- and beta-phosphate moieties, m(2)(7,3'-O)Gpp(CH2)pG and m(2)(7,3'-O)Gp(CH2)ppG, that are predicted to be resistant to cleavage by Dcp1/Dcp2 and DcpS, respectively. These cap analogs were recognized by eIF4E and conferred cap-dependent translation to mRNA both in vitro and in vivo. Oligonucleotides capped with m(2)(7,3'-O)Gpp(CH2)pG were resistant to hydrolysis by recombinant human Dcp2 in vitro. mRNAs capped with m(2)(7,3'-O)Gpp(CH2)pG, but not m(2)(7,3'-O)Gp(CH2)ppG, were more stable in vivo, indicating that the 5'-->3' pathway makes a major contribution to overall degradation. Luciferase mRNA containing a 5'-terminal m(2)(7,3'-O)Gpp(CH2)pG and 3'-terminal poly(G) had the greatest stability of all mRNAs tested.     

Synthesis and characterization of mRNA cap analogs containing phosphorothioate substitutions that bind tightly to eIF4E and are resistant to the decapping pyrophosphatase DcpS

Analogs of the mRNA cap are widely employed to study processes involved in mRNA metabolism as well as being useful in biotechnology and medicinal applications. Here we describe synthesis of six dinucleotide cap analogs bearing a single phosphorothioate modification at either the alpha, beta, or gamma position of the 5',5'-triphosphate chain. Three of them were also modified with methyl groups at the 2'-O position of 7-methylguanosine to produce anti-reverse cap analogs (ARCAs). Due to the presence of stereogenic P centers in the phosphorothioate moieties, each analog was obtained as a mixture of two diastereomers, D1 and D2. The mixtures were resolved by RP HPLC, providing 12 different compounds. Fluorescence quenching experiments were employed to determine the association constant (K(AS)) for complexes of the new analogs with eIF4E. We found that phosphorothioate modifications generally stabilized the complex between eIF4E and the cap analog. The most strongly bound phosphorothioate analog (the D1 isomer of the beta-substituted analog m(7)Gpp(S)pG) was characterized by a K(AS) that was more than fourfold higher than that of its unmodified counterpart (m(7)GpppG). All analogs modified in the gamma position were resistant to hydrolysis by the scavenger decapping pyrophosphatase DcpS from both human and Caenorhabditis elegans sources. The absolute configurations of the diastereomers D1 and D2 of analogs modified at the alpha position (i.e., m(7)Gppp(S)G and m(2) (7,2'-O )Gppp(S)G) were established as S(P) and R(P) , respectively, using enzymatic digestion and correlation with the S(P) and R(P) diastereomers of guanosine 5'-O-(1-thiodiphosphate) (GDPalphaS). The analogs resistant to DcpS act as potent inhibitors of in vitro protein synthesis in rabbit reticulocyte lysates.     

Synthesis and properties of mRNA cap analogs containing phosphorothioate moiety in 5',5'-triphosphate chain

Nucleosides and oligonucleotides with an oxygen replaced by sulfur atom are an interesting class of compounds because of their improved stability toward enzymatic cleavage by nucleases. We have synthesized several dinucleotide mRNA cap analogs containing a phosphorothioate moiety in the alpha, beta, or gamma position of 5',5'-triphosphate chain [m7Gp(s)ppG, m7Gpp(s)pG, and m7Gppp(s)G]. These are the first examples of the biologically important 5'mRNA cap analogs containing a phosphorothioate moiety, and these compounds may be useful in a variety of biochemical and biotechnological applications. Incorporation of a sulfur atom in the alpha or gamma position within the dinucleotide cap analog was achieved using PSCl3 in a nucleoside phosphorylation reaction followed by coupling the phosphorothioate of nucleoside with a second nucleotide. Synthesis of cap analogs with the phosphorothioate moiety in beta position was performed using an organic phosphorothioate salt in a coupling reaction with an activated nucleotide. The structures of newly synthesized compounds was confirmed using MS and 1H and 31P NMR spectroscopy. We present here the results of preliminary studies on their interaction with translation initiation factor eIF4E and enzymatic hydrolysis with human and nematode DcpS scavengers.     

SYNTHESIS AND PROPERTIES OF mRNA CAP ANALOGS CONTAINING PHOSPHOROTHIOATE MOIETY IN 5′,5′-TRIPHOSPHATE CHAIN

Nucleosides and oligonucleotides with an oxygen replaced by sulfur atom are an interesting class of compounds because of their improved stability toward enzymatic cleavage by nucleases. We have synthesized several dinucleotide mRNA cap analogs containing a phosphorothioate moiety in the α, β, or γ position of 5′,5′-triphosphate chain [m⁷Gp(s)ppG, m⁷Gpp(s)pG, and m⁷Gppp(s)G]. These are the first examples of the biologically important 5′mRNA cap analogs containing a phosphorothioate moiety, and these compounds may be useful in a variety of biochemical and biotechnological applications. Incorporation of a sulfur atom in the α or γ position within the dinucleotide cap analog was achieved using PSCl₃ in a nucleoside phosphorylation reaction followed by coupling the phosphorothioate of nucleoside with a second nucleotide. Synthesis of cap analogs with the phosphorothioate moiety in β position was performed using an organic phosphorothioate salt in a coupling reaction with an activated nucleotide. The structures of newly synthesized compounds was confirmed using MS and ¹H and ³¹P NMR spectroscopy. We present here the results of preliminary studies on their interaction with translation initiation factor eIF4E and enzymatic hydrolysis with human and nematode DcpS scavengers.     

Dcp2 Decaps m2,2,7GpppN-capped RNAs, and its activity is sequence and context dependent

Hydrolysis of the mRNA cap plays a pivotal role in initiating and completing mRNA turnover. In nematodes, mRNA metabolism and cap-interacting proteins must deal with two populations of mRNAs, spliced leader trans-spliced mRNAs with a trimethylguanosine cap and non-trans-spliced mRNAs with a monomethylguanosine cap. We describe here the characterization of nematode Dcp1 and Dcp2 proteins. Dcp1 was inactive in vitro on both free cap and capped RNA and did not significantly enhance Dcp2 activity. Nematode Dcp2 is an RNA-decapping protein that does not bind cap and is not inhibited by cap analogs but is effectively inhibited by competing RNA irrespective of RNA sequence and cap. Nematode Dcp2 activity is influenced by both 5' end sequence and its context. The trans-spliced leader sequence on mRNAs reduces Dcp2 activity approximately 10-fold, suggesting that 5'-to-3' turnover of trans-spliced RNAs may be regulated. Nematode Dcp2 decaps both m(7)GpppG- and m(2,2,7)GpppG-capped RNAs. Surprisingly, both budding yeast and human Dcp2 are also active on m(2,2,7)GpppG-capped RNAs. Overall, the data suggest that Dcp2 activity can be influenced by both sequence and context and that Dcp2 may contribute to gene regulation in multiple RNA pathways, including monomethyl- and trimethylguanosine-capped RNAs.     

Assignment of the absolute configuration of P-chiral 5' mRNA cap analogues containing phosphorothioate moiety

Enzymatic cleavage of the P-chiral diastereoisomers of the 5' mRNA cap analogue bearing phosphorothioate moiety in alfa position of 5',5'-triphosphate bridge (m(7)Gppp(S)G D1 and D2) was performed by human Decapping Scavenger (DcpS) enzyme. Analysis of the degradation products allowed to estimate the absolute configuration at the asymmetric phosphorus atoms in examined compounds via correlation with the R(P) and S(P) diastereoisomers of guanosine 5'-O-(1-thiodiphosphate) (GDPalphaS).     

Synthesis,properties, and biological activity of boranophosphate analogs of the mRNA cap: versatile tools for manipulation of therapeutically relevant cap-dependent processes

Modified mRNA cap analogs aid in the study of mRNA-related processes and may enable creation of novel therapeutic interventions. We report the synthesis and properties of 11 dinucleotide cap analogs bearing a single boranophosphate modification at either the α-, β- or γ-position of the 5′,5′-triphosphate chain. The compounds can potentially serve either as inhibitors of translation in cancer cells or reagents for increasing expression of therapeutic proteins in vivo from exogenous mRNAs. The BH₃-analogs were tested as substrates and binding partners for two major cytoplasmic cap-binding proteins, DcpS, a decapping pyrophosphatase, and eIF4E, a translation initiation factor. The susceptibility to DcpS was different between BH₃-analogs and the corresponding analogs containing S instead of BH₃ (S-analogs). Depending on its placement, the boranophosphate group weakened the interaction with DcpS but stabilized the interaction with eIF4E. The first of the properties makes the BH₃-analogs more stable and the second, more potent as inhibitors of protein biosynthesis. Protein expression in dendritic cells was 2.2- and 1.7-fold higher for mRNAs capped with m₂^7,2′-OGpp_BH3pG D1 and m₂^7,2′-OGpp_BH3pG D2, respectively, than for in vitro transcribed mRNA capped with m₂^7,3′-OGpppG. Higher expression of cancer antigens would make mRNAs containing m₂^7,2′-OGpp_BH3pG D1 and m₂^7,2′-OGpp_BH3pG D2 favorable for anticancer immunization.     

Kinetics of C. elegans DcpS cap hydrolysis studied by fluorescence spectroscopy

DcpS (scavenger decapping enzyme) from nematode C. elegans readily hydrolyzes both monomethyl- and trimethylguanosine cap analogues. The reaction was followed fluorimetrically. The marked increase of fluorescence intensity after the cleavage of pyrophosphate bond in dinucleotides was used to determine K(m) and V(max)values. Kinetic parameters were similar for both classes of substrates and only slightly dependent on pH. The hydrolysis was strongly inhibited by methylene cap analogues (m(7)Gp(CH(2))ppG and m(7)Gpp(CH(2))pG) and less potently by ARCA (m(7,3' O)GpppG).     

Translation, stability, and resistance to decapping of mRNAs containing caps substituted in the triphosphate chain with BH3, Se, and NH

Decapping is an essential step in multiple pathways of mRNA degradation. Previously, we synthesized mRNAs containing caps that were resistant to decapping, both to dissect the various pathways for mRNA degradation and to stabilize mRNA for more sustained protein expression. mRNAs containing an α-β CH₂ group are resistant to in vitro cleavage by the decapping enzyme hDcp2 but poorly translated. mRNAs containing an S substitution at the β-phosphate are well translated but only partially resistant to hDcp2. We now describe seven new cap analogs substituted at the β-phosphate with BH₃ or Se, or substituted at either the α-β or β-γ O with NH. The analogs differ in affinity for eIF4E and efficiency of in vitro incorporation into mRNA by T7 RNA polymerase. Luciferase mRNAs capped with these analogs differ in resistance to hDcp2 hydrolysis in vitro, translational efficiency in rabbit reticulocyte lysate and in HeLa cells, and stability in HeLa cells. Whereas mRNAs capped with m₂^7,2′-OGpp_SpG were previously found to have the most favorable properties of translational efficiency and stability in mammalian cells, mRNAs capped with m⁷Gpp_BH3pm⁷G are translated with the same efficiency but are more stable. Interestingly, some mRNAs exhibit a lag of up to 60 min before undergoing first-order decay (t_1/2 ≅ 25 min). Only mRNAs that are efficiently capped, resistant to decapping in vitro, and actively translated have long lag phases.     

Amino acid residues within conserved domain VI of the vesicular stomatitis virus large polymerase protein essential for mRNA cap methyltransferase activity

During mRNA synthesis, the polymerase of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) copies the genomic RNA to produce five capped and polyadenylated mRNAs with the 5'-terminal structure 7mGpppA(m)pApCpApGpNpNpApUpCp. The 5' mRNA processing events are poorly understood but presumably require triphosphatase, guanylyltransferase, [guanine-N-7]- and [ribose-2'-O]-methyltransferase (MTase) activities. Consistent with a role in mRNA methylation, conserved domain VI of the 241-kDa large (L) polymerase protein shares sequence homology with a bacterial [ribose-2'-O]-MTase, FtsJ/RrmJ. In this report, we generated six L gene mutations to test this homology. Individual substitutions to the predicted MTase active-site residues K1651, D1762, K1795, and E1833 yielded viruses with pinpoint plaque morphologies and 10- to 1,000-fold replication defects in single-step growth assays. Consistent with these defects, viral RNA and protein synthesis was diminished. In contrast, alteration of residue G1674 predicted to bind the methyl donor S-adenosylmethionine did not significantly perturb viral growth and gene expression. Analysis of the mRNA cap structure revealed that alterations to the predicted active site residues decreased [guanine-N-7]- and [ribose-2'-O]-MTase activity below the limit of detection of our assay. In contrast, the alanine substitution at G1674 had no apparent consequence. These data show that the predicted MTase active-site residues K1651, D1762, K1795, and E1833 within domain VI of the VSV L protein are essential for mRNA cap methylation. A model of mRNA processing consistent with these data is presented.     

RNA decapping inside and outside of processing bodies

Decapping is a central step in eukaryotic mRNA turnover. Recent studies have identified several factors involved in catalysis and regulation of decapping. These include the following: an mRNA decapping complex containing the proteins Dcp1 and Dcp2; a nucleolar decapping enzyme, X29, involved in the degradation of U8 snoRNA and perhaps of other capped nuclear RNAs; and a decapping 'scavenger' enzyme, DcpS, that hydrolyzes the cap structure resulting from complete 3'-to-5' degradation of mRNAs by the exosome. Several proteins that stimulate mRNA decapping by the Dcp1:Dcp2 complex co-localize with Dcp1 and Dcp2, together with Xrn1, a 5'-to-3' exonuclease, to structures in the cytoplasm called processing bodies. Recent evidence suggests that the processing bodies may constitute specialized cellular compartments of mRNA turnover, which suggests that mRNA and protein localization may be integral to mRNA decay.     

Structure of the 5' terminus of hen oviduct lysozyme messenger ribonucleic acid

Lysozyme mRNA (mRNAlys) was purified from hen oviduct poly(A)-containing RNA by hybridization, labeled with NaB[3H]4 and digested with RNase T1. This revealed the presence of equal amounts of two major oligonucleotides having structures of m7Gppp(Np)7 and m7Gppp(Np)4 plus minor amounts of m7Gppp(Np)2 and m7GpppNp. The total mRNAlys contained the cap structures m7Gpppm6Am, m7GpppGm, m7GpppAm, m7GpppCm, m7GpppA, and m7GpppG, in decreasing order of abundance. The m7Gppp(Np)7 oligonucleotide contained only A-caps and the m7Gppp(Np)4, only G-caps. 32P-labeled 5'-terminal T1-oligonucleotides were prepared, and at least 12 different types were observed, the most abundant being m7Gppp(Np)7 and m7Gppp(Np)4. Their sequences were determined to be m7Gppp(m6)AmNmUCCCG and m7GpppGmNmAG. Taken together with the findings of Grez et al. (Grez, M., Land, H., Giesecke, K., Schutz, G., Jung, A., and Sippel, A. E. (1981) Cell 25, 743-752), these results indicate that in the genomic sequence AGCTTGCAGTCCCGT, 52% of the mRNAlys molecules begin at the underlined A residue and 38% at the underlined G residue.     

Comparison of methylated sequences in messenger RNA and heterogeneous nuclear RNA from mouse L cells

A variety of methylated oligonucleotides were derived from mouse L cell messenger RNA and heterogeneous nuclear RNA by digestion with specific ribonucleases, and the cap-containing oligonucleotides separated from those containing internal m⁶A by chromatography on diborylaminoethyl-cellulose. Cap-containing sequences of the type m⁷GpppX^mpG, m⁷GpppX^mpY^(m)pG, m⁷GpppX^mpY^(m) pNpG and m⁷GpppX^mpY^(m)p(Np)_{> 1}G have distinctive non-random compositions of the 2′-O-methylated constituent X^m; yet sequences of a particular type and composition occur with a remarkably similar frequency in mRNA and hnRNA². For example, approximately 20% of the cap sequences in both hnRNA and mRNA are m⁷Gppp(m⁶)A^mG, whereas less than 1% are m⁷GpppU^mpG. The high degree of similarity in cap sequences is consistent with the previously postulated precursor-product relationship between hnRNA caps and mRNA caps.The composition of the Y position in capped hnRNA molecules was determined to be (29% G, 20% A, 51% Py), which differs considerably from the composition of Y^m in the cap II forms of mRNA (8% G^m, 11% A^m, 81% Py). Given the precursor-product relationship between hnRNA caps and mRNA caps, this result provides strong evidence that only a restricted subclass of mRNA molecules receive the secondary methylation at position Y.In both hnRNA and mRNA the internal m⁶A occurs in well-defined sequences of the type: $\text{-N}{}_1\text{-(}\text{G}\text{A}\text{)-m}{}^6\text{A-C-N}{}_2\text{-}$, the 5′ nearest-neighbor of m⁶A being G in about three-quarters of the molecules and A in about one-quarter of the molecules. The nucleotide N¹ is a purine about 90% of the time and the nucleotide N² is rarely a G. These same sequences are present in large (> 50 S), as well as small (14 S to 50 S) hnRNA. These results raise the possibility that the internal m⁶A, like caps, may be conserved during the processing of large hnRNA into mRNA. Two models based on this idea are discussed.     

Nematode m7GpppG and m3(2,2,7)GpppG decapping: activities in Ascaris embryos and characterization of C. elegans scavenger DcpS

A spliced leader contributes the mature 5'ends of many mRNAs in trans-splicing organisms. Trans-spliced metazoan mRNAs acquire an m3(2,2,7)GpppN cap from the added spliced leader exon. The presence of these caps, along with the typical m7GpppN cap on non-trans-spliced mRNAs, requires that cellular mRNA cap-binding proteins and mRNA metabolism deal with different cap structures. We have developed and used an in vitro system to examine mRNA degradation and decapping activities in nematode embryo extracts. The predominant pathway of mRNA decay is a 3' to 5' pathway with exoribonuclease degradation of the RNA followed by hydrolysis of resulting mRNA cap by a scavenger (DcpS-like) decapping activity. Direct decapping of mRNA by a Dcp1/Dcp2-like activity does occur, but is approximately 15-fold less active than the 3' to 5' pathway. The DcpS-like activity in nematode embryo extracts hydrolyzes both m7GpppG and m3(2,2,7)GpppG dinucleoside triphosphates. The Dcp1/Dcp2-like activity in extracts also hydrolyzes these two cap structures at the 5' ends of RNAs. Interestingly, recombinant nematode DcpS differs from its human ortholog in its substrate length requirement and in its capacity to hydrolyze m3(2,2,7)GpppG.     

Phosphorylation of mRNA Decapping Protein Dcp1a by the ERK Signaling Pathway during Early Differentiation of 3T3-L1 Preadipocytes

Background

Turnover of mRNA is a critical step in the regulation of gene expression, and an important step in mRNA decay is removal of the 5′ cap. We previously demonstrated that the expression of some immediate early gene mRNAs is controlled by RNA stability during early differentiation of 3T3-L1 preadipocytes.

Methodology/Principal Findings

Here we show that the mouse decapping protein Dcp1a is phosphorylated via the ERK signaling pathway during early differentiation of preadipocytes. Mass spectrometry analysis and site-directed mutagenesis combined with a kinase assay identified ERK pathway–mediated dual phosphorylation at Ser 315 and Ser 319 of Dcp1a. To understand the functional effects of Dcp1a phosphorylation, we examined protein-protein interactions between Dcp1a and other decapping components with co-immunoprecipitation. Dcp1a interacted with Ddx6 and Edc3 through its proline-rich C-terminal extension, whereas the conserved EVH1 (enabled vasodilator-stimulated protein homology 1) domain in the N terminus of Dcp1a showed a stronger interaction with Dcp2. Once ERK signaling was activated, the interaction between Dcp1a and Ddx6, Edc3, or Edc4 was not affected by Dcp1a phosphorylation. Phosphorylated Dcp1a did, however, enhanced interaction with Dcp2. Protein complexes immunoprecipitated with the recombinant phosphomimetic Dcp1a(S315D/S319D) mutant contained more Dcp2 than did those immunoprecipitated with the nonphosphorylated Dcp1a(S315A/S319A) mutant. In addition, Dcp1a associated with AU-rich element (ARE)-containing mRNAs such as MAPK phosphatase-1 (MKP-1), whose mRNA stability was analyzed under the overexpression of Dcp1a constructs in the Dcp1a knockdown 3T3-L1 cells.

Conclusions/Significance

Our findings suggest that ERK-phosphorylated Dcp1a enhances its interaction with the decapping enzyme Dcp2 during early differentiation of 3T3-L1 cells.