In situ responses to elevated CO2 in tropical forest understorey plants

1. Plants growing in deep shade and high temperature, such as in the understorey of humid tropical forests, have been predicted to be particularly sensitive to rising atmospheric CO₂. We tested this hypothesis in five species whose microhabitat quantum flux density (QFD) was documented as a covariable. After 7 (tree seedlings of Tachigalia versicolor and Beilschmiedia pendula ) and 18 months (shrubs Piper cordulatum and Psychotria limonensis, and grass Pharus latifolius ) of elevated CO₂ treatment ( c. 700 μl litre^–1) under mean QFD of less than 11 μmol m^–2 s^–1, all species produced more biomass (25–76%) under elevated CO₂.
2. Total plant biomass tended to increase with microhabitat QFD (daytime means varying from 5 to 11μmol m^–2 s^–1) but the relative stimulation by elevated CO₂ was higher at low QFD except in Pharus .
3. Non-structural carbohydrate concentrations in leaves increased significantly in Pharus (+ 27%) and Tachigalia (+ 40%).
4. The data support the hypothesis that tropical plants growing near the photosynthetic light compensation point are responsive to elevated CO₂. An improved plant carbon balance in deep shade is likely to influence understorey plant recruitment and competition as atmospheric CO₂ continues to rise.     

N2 fixation by Acacia species increases under elevated atmospheric CO2

In the present study the effect of elevated CO₂ on growth and nitrogen fixation of seven Australian Acacia species was investigated. Two species from semi‐arid environments in central Australia (Acacia aneura and A. tetragonophylla) and five species from temperate south‐eastern Australia (Acacia irrorata, A. mearnsii, A. dealbata, A. implexa and A. melanoxylon) were grown for up to 148 d in controlled greenhouse conditions at either ambient (350 µmol mol^?1) or elevated (700 µmol mol^?1) CO₂ concentrations. After establishment of nodules, the plants were completely dependent on symbiotic nitrogen fixation. Six out of seven species had greater relative growth rates and lower whole plant nitrogen concentrations under elevated versus normal CO₂. Enhanced growth resulted in an increase in the amount of nitrogen fixed symbiotically for five of the species. In general, this was the consequence of lower whole‐plant nitrogen concentrations, which equate to a larger plant and greater nodule mass for a given amount of nitrogen. Since the average amount of nitrogen fixed per unit nodule mass was unaltered by atmospheric CO₂, more nitrogen could be fixed for a given amount of plant nitrogen. For three of the species, elevated CO₂ increased the rate of nitrogen fixation per unit nodule mass and time, but this was completely offset by a reduction in nodule mass per unit plant mass.     

Potential effects of elevated CO2 and changes in temperature on tropical plants

Abstract. Very little attention has been directed at the responses of tropical plants to increases in global atmospheric CO₂ concentrations and the potential climatic changes. The available data, from greenhouse and laboratory studies, indicate that the photosynthesis, growth and water use efficiency of tropical plants can increase at higher CO₂ concentrations. However, under field conditions abiotic (light, water or nutrients) or biotic (competition or herbivory) factors might limit these responses. In general, elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations seem to increase plant tolerance to stress, including low water availability, high or low temperature, and photoinhibition. Thus, some species may be able to extend their ranges into physically less favourable sites, and biological interactions may become relatively more important in determining the distribution and abundance of species. Tropical plants may be more narrowly adapted to prevailing temperature regimes than are temperate plants, so expected changes in temperature might be relatively more important in the tropics. Reduced transpiration due to decreased stomatal conductance could modify the effects of water stress as a cue for vegetative or reproductive phenology of plants of seasonal tropical areas. The available information suggests that changes in atmospheric CO₂ concentrations could affect processes as varied as plant/herbivore interactions, decomposition and nutrient cycling, local and geographic distributions of species and community types, and ecosystem productivity. However, data on tropical plants are few, and there seem to be no published tropical studies carried out in the field. Immediate steps should be undertaken to reduce our ignorance of this critical area.     

Sensing of atmospheric CO2 by plants

Abstract. Despite recent interest in the effects of high CO₂ on plant growth and physiology, very little is known about the mechanisms by which plants sense changes in the concentration of this gas. Because atmospheric CO₂ concentration is relatively constant and because the conductance of the cuticle to CO₂ is low, sensory mechanisms are likely to exist only for intercellular CO₂ concentration. Therefore, responses of plants to changes in atmospheric CO₂ will depend on the effect of these changes on intercellular CO₂ concentration. Although a variety of plant responses to atmospheric CO₂ concentration have been reported, most of these can be attributed to the effects of intercellular CO₂ on photosynthesis or stomatal conductance. Short-term and long-term effects of CO₂ on photosynthesis and stomatal conductance are discussed as sensory mechanisms for responses of plants to atmospheric CO₂. Available data suggest that plants do not fully realize the potential increases in productivity associated with increased atmospheric CO₂. This may be because of genetic and environmental limitations to productivity or because plant responses to CO₂ have evolved to cope with variations in intercellular CO₂ caused by factors other than changes in atmospheric CO₂.     

Seasonal changes in the effects of elevated CO2 on rice at three levels of nitrogen supply: a free air CO2 enrichment (FACE) experiment

Over time, the stimulative effect of elevated CO₂ on the photosynthesis of rice crops is likely to be reduced with increasing duration of CO₂ exposure, but the resultant effects on crop productivity remain unclear. To investigate seasonal changes in the effect of elevated CO₂ on the growth of rice (Oryza sativa L.) crops, a free air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiment was conducted at Shizukuishi, Iwate, Japan in 1998–2000. The target CO₂ concentration of the FACE plots was 200 µmol mol^?1 above that of ambient. Three levels of nitrogen (N) were supplied: low (LN, 4 g N m^?2), medium [MN, 8 (1998) and 9 (1999, 2000) g N m^?2] and high N (HN, 12 and 15 g N m^?2). For MN and HN but not for LN, elevated CO₂ increased tiller number at panicle initiation (PI) but this positive response decreased with crop development. As a result, the response of green leaf area index (GLAI) to elevated CO₂ greatly varied with development, showing positive responses during vegetative stages and negative responses after PI. Elevated CO₂ decreased leaf N concentration over the season, except during early stage of development. For MN crops, total biomass increased with elevated CO₂, but the response declined linearly with development, with average increases of 32, 28, 21, 15 and 12% at tillering, PI, anthesis, mid‐ripening and grain maturity, respectively. This decline is likely to be due to decreases in the positive effects of elevated CO₂ on canopy photosynthesis because of reductions in both GLAI and leaf N. Up to PI, LN‐crops tended to have a lower response to elevated CO₂ than MN‐ and HN‐crops, though by final harvest the total biomass response was similar for all N levels. For MN‐ and HN‐crops, the positive response of grain yield (ca. 15%) to elevated CO₂ was slightly greater than the response of final total biomass while for LN‐crops it was less. We conclude that most of the seasonal changes in crop response to elevated CO₂ are directly or indirectly associated with N uptake.     

The density dependence of plant responses to elevated CO2

1 Stands of the annual Brassica kaber were grown at a range of six densities in both ambient and elevated CO₂ environments, and measurements of shoot growth were made from seedling emergence through to reproduction.
2 Early in stand development (21 days following emergence), CO₂ enhancement (β) for above-ground biomass was highly density-dependent, ranging from 1.41 at the lowest density (20 plants m−2) to 0.59 at the highest density (652 plants m−2).
3 As stands matured and total biomass exceeded a relatively low threshold level (<10.0 g m^{−2; c.}  20% of final yield), the density-dependence of β disappeared. Above this shoot biomass threshold, β-values remained remarkably stable (β = 0.34) across a broad range of stand biomass, independent of a stand's initial density or age.
4 Average stand-level reproductive β-values at a final harvest were very similar to biomass values (β = 0.38) and, as with biomass values at later stages, showed no apparent density-dependence.
5 These results highlight the importance of considering density and the time-course of stand development simultaneously when assessing the potential for CO₂-induced growth enhancements in plants.     

Carbon gains by desiccation-tolerant plants at elevated CO2

1. There have been no reports of the long-term responses of the desiccation-tolerant (DT) plants to elevated CO₂. Xerophyta scabrida is a DT woody shrub, which loses chlorophylls and thylakoids during desiccation: a so-called poikilochlorophyllous desiccation-tolerant species (PDT). When the leaves of X. scabria are allowed to desiccate, the species shows many of the normal features of (P)DT plants.
2. However, the duration of photosynthesis in X. scabria is prolonged by 300% when the measurements are made at 700 as opposed to 350p.p.m. CO₂. The implication is that the carboxylating enzymes must still have been active at this time to enable appreciable photosynthetic activity. This response could have far-reaching implications for the success of such species in a future climate.
3. Lichens and mosses, representing the homoiochlorophyllous DTs (HDT), retain their chlorophyll content and photosynthetic apparatus during desiccation. We show the desiccation responses of two common HDT species ( Cladonia convoluta and Tortula ruralis ) to elevated CO₂ for comparison. Both HDT species showed increased net CO₂ uptake in the material grown at high CO₂ by more than 30% in moss and by more than 50% in lichen. It is concluded that desiccation-tolerant plants will be among the main beneficiaries of a high CO₂ future.     

Increased leaf reflectance in tropical trees under elevated CO2

Globally increasing atmospheric CO₂ concentrations are known to affect many aspects of plant physiology and development; however, little attention has been given to leaf and canopy optical properties. Three tropical trees in the Leguminosae, an important canopy tree family in many tropical forests, responded similarly to an experimental doubling of CO₂ partial pressure with a 9–23% increase in spectral leaf reflectance to light in the visible (400–700 nm) waveband. Decreased leaf chlorophyll content under elevated CO₂ may explain part of the observed increase in reflectance. However, analyses that statistically corrected for chlorophyll content effects on reflectance still indicated a significant CO₂ effect. This results, in conjunction with the spectral pattern of the response, suggests that the primary mechanism is increased optical masking of chlorophyll under elevated CO₂. The magnitude of the increase in leaf reflectance is sufficient to suggest that increased canopy reflectance of tropical forests (and possibly other terrestrial ecosystems) may be an important negative feedback in the response of global net radiative climate forcing to increasing atmospheric CO₂.     

Nitrogen nutrition of C3 plants at elevated atmospheric CO2 concentrations

The atmospheric CO₂ concentration has risen from the preindustrial level of approximately 290 μl l⁻¹ to more than 350 μl l⁻¹ in 1993. The current rate of rise is such that concentrations of 420 μl l⁻¹ are expected in the next 20 years. For C₃ plants, higher CO₂ levels favour the photosynthetic carbon reduction cycle over the photorespiratory cycle, resulting in higher rates of carbohydrate production and plant productivity. The change in balance between the two photosynthetic cycles appears to alter nitrogen and carbon metabolism in the leaf, possibly causing decreases in nitrogen concentrations in the leaf. This may result from increases in the concentration of storage carbohydrates of high molecular weight (soluble or insoluble) and/or changes in distribution of protein or other nitrogen containing compounds. Uptake of nitrogen may also be reduced at high CO₂ due to lower transpiration rates. Decreases in foliar nitrogen levels have important implications for production of crops such as wheat, because fertilizer management is often based on leaf chemical analysis, using standards estimated when the CO₂ levels were considerably lower. These standards will need to be re-evaluated as the CO₂ concentration continues to rise. Lower levels of leaf nitrogen will also have implications for the quality of wheat grain produced, because it is likely that less nitrogen would be retranslocated during grain filling.     

In situ studies of water relations and CO2 exchange of the tropical macrolichen, Sticta tomentosa

Diel (24-h) time courses of CO₂ exchange, water relations, and microclimate of the foliose lichen, Sticta tomentosa (Swartz) Ach., and responses to experimentally manipulated conditions were measured at a forest edge in a lower montane rainforest in Panama.
Similar to earlier observations on two other rain forest lichens, daily desiccation suppressed net photosynthesis (NP) during the period when irradiation was highest. Not surprisingly, the light response curves of NP showed saturation at rather low light levels. Rehydration was associated with an initial resaturation burst of short duration, which could be demonstrated both under natural conditions and experimentally. This additional loss of CO₂ seems too low to be ecologically relevant. Moreover, high thallus hydration was also detrimental to NP: at maximum water content net CO₂ uptake was depressed by >50%. Although NP was well adapted to the prevailing high temperatures, the latter also stimulated dark respiration. On average, almost 60% of the diurnal carbon gain was lost during the night.
In spite of these limitations, the integrated 24-h C gain was quite high, on average 0·5% of the thallus C content. Whilst these figures were determined for horizontally exposed samples, we also assessed the role of different exposures on photosynthetic performance. Diel C gain was highest under conditions of semi-shade (westerly exposure), which allowed long periods of activity, whilst much higher irradiance at other exposures could not be utilized for photosynthetic production: easterly exposed thalli dried out even faster than horizontally exposed samples.     

Interactive effects of low atmospheric CO2 and elevated temperature on growth, photosynthesis and respiration in Phaseolus vulgaris

For most of the past 250 000 years, atmospheric CO₂ has been 30–50% lower than the current level of 360 μmol CO₂ mol^–1 air. Although the effects of CO₂ on plant performance are well recognized, the effects of low CO₂ in combination with abiotic stress remain poorly understood. In this study, a growth chamber experiment using a two-by-two factorial design of CO₂ (380 μmol mol^–1, 200 μmol mol^–1) and temperature (25/20 °C day/night, 36/29 °C) was conducted to evaluate the interactive effects of CO₂ and temperature variation on growth, tissue chemistry and leaf gas exchange of Phaseolus vulgaris. Relative to plants grown at 380 μmol mol^–1 and 25/20 °C, whole plant biomass was 36% less at 380 μmol mol^–1× 36/29 °C, and 37% less at 200 μmol mol^–1× 25/20 °C. Most significantly, growth at 200 μmol mol^–1× 36/29 °C resulted in 77% less biomass relative to plants grown at 380 μmol mol^–1× 25/20 °C. The net CO₂ assimilation rate of leaves grown in 200 μmol mol^–1× 25/20 °C was 40% lower than in leaves from 380 μmol mol^–1× 25/20 °C, but similar to leaves in 200 μmol mol^–1× 36/29 °C. The leaves produced in low CO₂ and high temperature respired at a rate that was double that of leaves from the 380μmol mol^–1× 25/20 °C treatment. Despite this, there was little evidence that leaves at low CO₂ and high temperature were carbohydrate deficient, because soluble sugars, starch and total non-structural carbohydrates of leaves from the 200μmol mol^–1× 36/29 °C treatment were not significantly different in leaves from the 380μmol mol^–1× 25/20 °C treatment. Similarly, there was no significant difference in percentage root carbon, leaf chlorophyll and leaf/root nitrogen between the low CO₂× high temperature treatment and ambient CO₂ controls. Decreased plant growth was correlated with neither leaf gas exchange nor tissue chemistry. Rather, leaf and root growth were the most affected responses, declining in equivalent proportions as total biomass production. Because of this close association, the mechanisms controlling leaf and root growth appear to have the greatest control over the response to heat stress and CO₂ reduction in P. vulgaris.     

Seeing the forest for the trees: long-term exposure to elevated CO2 increases some herbivore densities

The effects of elevated CO₂ on plant growth and insect herbivory have been frequently investigated over the past 20 years. Most studies have shown an increase in plant growth, a decrease in plant nitrogen concentration, an increase in plant secondary metabolites and a decrease in herbivory. However, such studies have generally overlooked the fact that increases in plant production could cause increases of herbivores per unit area of habitat. Our study investigated leaf production, herbivory levels and herbivore abundance per unit area of leaf litter in a scrub‐oak system at Kennedy Space Center, Florida, under conditions of ambient and elevated CO₂, over an 11‐year period, from 1996 to 2007. In every year, herbivory, that is leafminer and leaftier abundance per 200 leaves, was lower under elevated CO₂ than ambient CO₂ for each of three species of oaks, Quercus myrtifolia, Quercus chapmanii and Quercus geminata. However, leaf litter production per 0.1143 m² was greater under elevated CO₂ than ambient CO₂ for Q. myrtifolia and Q. chapmanii, and this difference increased over the 11 years of the study. Leaf production of Q. geminata under elevated CO₂ did not increase. Leafminer densities per 0.1143 m² of litterfall for Q. myrtifolia and Q. chapmanii were initially lower under elevated CO₂. However, shortly after canopy closure in 2001, leafminer densities per 0.1143 m² of litter fall became higher under elevated CO₂ and remained higher for the remainder of the experiment. Leaftier densities per 0.1143 m² were also higher under elevated CO₂ for Q. myrtifolia and Q. chapmanii over the last 6 years of the experiment. There were no differences in leafminer or leaftier densities per 0.1143 m² of litter for Q. geminata. These results show three phenomena. First, they show that elevated CO₂ decreases herbivory on all oak species in the Florida scrub‐oak system. Second, despite lower numbers of herbivores per 200 leaves in elevated CO₂, increased leaf production resulted in higher herbivore densities per unit area of leaf litter for two oak species. Third, they corroborate other studies which suggest that the effects of elevated CO₂ on herbivores are species specific, meaning they depend on the particular plant species involved. Two oak species showed increases in leaf production and herbivore densities per 0.1143 m² in elevated CO₂ over time while another oak species did not. Our results point to a future world of elevated CO₂ where, despite lower plant herbivory, some insect herbivores may become more common.     

Plant growth and reproduction along CO2 gradients: non-linear responses and implications for community change

The effects of rising atmospheric CO₂ concentrations on natural plant communities will depend upon the cumulative responses of plant growth and reproduction to gradual, incremental changes in climatic conditions. We analysed published studies of plant responses to elevated CO₂ to address whether reproductive and total biomass exhibit similar enhancement to elevated vs. ambient CO₂ concentrations, and to assess the patterns of plant response along gradients of CO₂ concentrations. In six annual plant species, mean enhancement at double ambient vs. ambient CO₂ was 1.13 for total biomass and 1.30 for reproductive biomass. The two measures were significantly correlated, but there was considerable scatter in the relationship, indicating that reproductive responses cannot be consistently predicted from enhancement of total biomass. Along experimental CO₂ gradients utilizing three concentrations, there was a great diversity of response patterns, including positive, negative, non-monotonic and non-significant (flat) responses. The distribution of response patterns differed for plants grown in stands compared to those grown individually. Positive responses were less frequent in competitive environments, and non-monotonic responses were more frequent. These results emphasize that interpolation of plant response based on enhancement ratios measured at elevated vs. ambient CO₂ concentrations is not sufficient to predict community responses to incremental changes in atmospheric conditions. The consequences of differential response patterns were assessed in a simulation of community dynamics for four species of annual plants. The model illustrates that the final community composition at a future point in time depends critically on both the magnitude and the rate of increase of atmospheric CO₂.