Epithelial control of periotic mesenchyme chondrogenesis

Morphogenesis of the cartilaginous otic capsule is directed by interactions between the epithelial anlage of the membranous labyrinth (otocyst) and its associated periotic mesenchyme. Utilizing a developmental series of high-density (micromass) cultures of periotic mesenchyme to model capsule chondrogenesis, we have shown that the early influence of otic epithelium in cultures of 10.5- or 14-gestation day (gd) periotic mesenchyme results in initiation or suppression of chondrogenesis, respectively. Furthermore, we have shown that introduction of otic epithelium at two distinct times during in vitro development to cultures of 10.5-gd mesenchyme cells results first in an initiation and then in an inhibition of their chondrogenic response. These influences of epithelial tissue on chondrogenic differentiation by periotic mesenchyme are not tissue specific but are characterized by temporal selectivity. The ability of otic epithelium to influence chondrogenesis and the competence of the periotic mesenchyme to respond to its signals are dependent upon the developmental stage of both tissues. This study provides conclusive evidence that otic epithelium acts as a developmental "switch" during otic capsule morphogenesis, signaling first the turning on and then the turning off of chondrogenic programs in the responding cephalic mesenchyme.     

Sonic hedgehog regulates otic capsule chondrogenesis and inner ear development in the mouse embryo

Development of the cartilaginous capsule of the inner ear is dependent on interactions between otic epithelium and its surrounding periotic mesenchyme. During these tissue interactions, factors endogenous to the otic epithelium influence the differentiation of the underlying periotic mesenchyme to form a chondrified otic capsule. We report the localization of Sonic hedgehog (Shh) protein and expression of the Shh gene in the tissues of the developing mouse inner ear. We demonstrate in cultures of periotic mesenchyme that Shh alone cannot initiate otic capsule chondrogenesis. However, when Shh is added to cultured periotic mesenchyme either in combination with otic epithelium or otic epithelial-derived fibroblast growth factor (FGF2), a significant enhancement of chondrogenesis occurs. Addition of Shh antisense oligonucleotide (AS) to cultured periotic mesenchyme with added otic epithelium decreases levels of endogenous Shh and suppresses the chondrogenic response of the mesenchyme cells, while supplementation of Shh AS-treated cultures with Shh rescues cultures from chondrogenic inhibition. We demonstrate that inactivation of Shh by targeted mutation produces anomalies in the developing inner ear and its surrounding capsule. Our results support a role for Shh as a regulator of otic capsule formation and inner ear development during mammalian embryogenesis.     

Interactions between the extracellular matrix and the cell surface determine tooth morphogenesis and the cellular differentiation of the dental mesenchyme

A series of reciprocal interactions between epithelial and mesenchymal tissues control the morphogenesis and cell differentiation in the developing tooth. The molecular mechanisms operating in these interactions are, however, unknown at present. Structural components of the extracellular matrix (ECM) affect cellular behavior in the embryo and appear to be involved also in these regulatory processes. The ECM molecules exert their effects on cells through binding to specific matrix receptors on the cell surface. This review article summarizes our findings on the distribution patterns during tooth development of the ECM glycoproteins, fibronectin and tenascin, and of the cell surface proteoglycan, syndecan, which functions as a receptor for interstitial matrix. Based on the observed changes in these distribution patterns and on experimental evidence, roles for these molecules in epithelial-mesenchymal interactions during tooth development are suggested. Fibronectin and tenascin are enriched in the dental basement membrane at the time of odontoblast differentiation. These matrix glycoproteins may be involved in the cell-matrix interaction which controls differentiation of the dental mesenchymal cells into odontoblasts. Tenascin and syndecan are accumulated in the dental mesenchyme during bud stage of development. We have shown in tissue recombination experiments that the presumptive dental epithelium induces the expression of tenascin and syndecan in mesenchyme. We suggest that these molecules are involved in cell-matrix interactions, which regulate mesenchymal cell condensation during the earliest stages of tooth morphogenesis.     

Dysmorphogenesis of the inner ear: disruption of extracellular matrix (ECM) formation by an L-proline analog in otic explants

L-azetidine-2-carboxylic acid (LACA), a l-proline analog, disrupts collagen secretion by cells and prevents normal morphogenesis of in vitro developing organ rudiments. Otic explants derived from 10.5-through 14-day-old mouse embryos were continuously exposed to LACA in the nutrient medium at concentrations of 75, 150, and 300 micrograms/ml. LACA disrupted normal in vitro otic morphogenesis in inner ears explanted from embryos of 10.5 through 13 days' gestation. Development of 14-day-old otic explants were not affected by LACA at the concentrations tested. There was a direct correlation between the embryonic age of the explant when exposed to LACA, and the severity of otic dysmorphogenesis. The younger explants (10.5-to 12-day-old) developed abnormalities of both vestibular and auditory structures, but with increasing embryonic age of the explants (12-to 13.5-day-old) abnormalities were confined more to the auditory portion of the inner ear. Disruption of collagen secretion of connective tissue cells of the otic explants are a major teratogenic action of LACA on inner ear development. Disrupted collagen secretion alters otic extracellular matrix production, which in turn affects the tissue interactions that regulate the progressive expression of otic morphogenesis and differentiation.     

Cell surface proteoglycan expression correlates with epithelial-mesenchymal interaction during tooth morphogenesis

Tooth morphogenesis and differentiation of the dental cells are guided by interactions between epithelial and mesenchymal tissues. Because the extracellular matrix is involved in these interactions, the expression of matrix receptors located at the cell surface may change during this developmental sequence. We have examined the distribution of an epithelial cell surface proteoglycan antigen, known to behave as a receptor for interstitial matrix, during tooth morphogenesis. Intense staining was seen around the cells of the embryonic oral epithelium as well as the dental epithelium at the early bud stage. With development, expression was greatly reduced in the enamel organ. Differentiation of these cells into ameloblasts was associated with the loss of expression, while the epithelial cells remaining in the stratum intermedium and stellate reticulum regained intense staining. The PG antigen was weakly expressed in the loose neural crest-derived jaw mesenchyme but it became strongly reactive in the condensed dental papilla mesenchyme when extensive morphogenetic movements took place. With development, the PG antigen disappeared from the advanced dental papilla mesenchyme but persisted in the dental sac mesenchyme, which gives rise to periodontal tissues. The PG antigen was not expressed by odontoblasts. Hence, the expression of the PG antigen changes during the epithelial-mesenchymal interactions of tooth development and is lost during terminal cell differentiation. The expression follows morphogenetic rather than histologic boundaries. The acquisition and loss of expression in epithelial and mesenchymal tissues during tooth development suggest that this proteoglycan has specific functions in the epithelial-mesenchymal interactions that guide morphogenesis.     

Keratan sulfate expression during avian craniofacial morphogenesis

Summary Using the monoclonal antibody MZ15 in immunocytochemical and ultrastructural studies we have been able to determine the spatiotemporal pattern of keratan sulfate (KS) distribution during quail craniofacial morphogenesis. KS-containing proteoglycans are found associated with invaginating placodes (olfactory, lens and otic), in developing pronephric tubules, notochord, pharynx and endocardium, and display developmental regulation. The appearance of such proteoglycans (PGs) during placode morphogenesis is particularly striking and we suggest that they may be an important component of the extracellular matrix which has been previously implicated in mediating the morphogenetic interactions and cell movements occurring at these sites. The otic vesicle during stage 18–22 displays a notable asymmetric distribution of KS-containing PGs. The role that these molecules may play and the reasons for this regionalization are, as yet, unclear but it is conceivable that the distribution of proteoglycans at this stage reflects subsequent differentiative events during otocyst development. Furthermore, our ultrastructural observations indicate that over the developmental period studied (H & H stages 8–22) keratan sulfate exists in at least two proteoglycan forms. Some spatiotemporal correlation has been found to exist between the distributions of KS-containing PGs and type II collagen as previously reported by Thorogood et al. (1986). We suggest that the proteoglycan detected at such sites is cartilage-specific proteoglycan and that it plays an important role, together with type II collagen, in the “signalling” mechanism which specifies the subsequent pattern of the chondrocranium. It is proposed that this interaction at epithelio-mesenchymal interfaces in the developing head parallels the matrix-mediated tissue interaction between notochord and somites which results in the formation of the cartilaginous primordia of the vertebrae from the sclerotomes as reported by Lash and Vasan (1978).     

Epithelial-mesenchymal transitions in the developing heart of the dogfish (Scyliorhinus canicula). A scanning electron microscopic study

An epithelial-mesenchymal transition is involved in two main morphogenetic events of cardiac morphogenesis, namely the differentiation of the valvuloseptal tissue from the endocardial endothelium, and the formation of subepicardial mesenchyme from the epicardial mesothelium. We have proposed that the dogfish ( Scyliorhinus canicula ) is a suitable model for the study of basic processes of cardiac morphogenesis in vertebrates, since the heart of this primitive fish probably outlines the original bauplan of the vertebrate heart. In order to study in this model the endocardial and epicardial epithelial-mesenchymal transition under scanning electron microscopy, we have used a technique of paraffin-embedding, partial sectioning, dewaxing and critical-point drying. Our results showed: 1) A centrifugal pattern of epicardial development from the atrioventricular groove to the sinus venosus and conus arteriosus; 2) A close spatial and temporal relationship between the endocardial and epicardial epithelial-mesenchymal transition, although the transformation of the endocardium starts earlier and ends later the epicardial transformation; 3) A complex arrangement of the fibrous extracellular matrix which is established prior to the migration of the mesenchymal cells. Subepicardial, but not subendothelial mesenchymal cells, coalesce in unicellular or pluricellular ring-like structures that probably are related to the origin of the cardiac vessels.     

Fgf9 signaling regulates inner ear morphogenesis through epithelial-mesenchymal interactions

The mammalian inner ear comprises the cochleovestibular labyrinth, derived from the ectodermal otic placode, and the encasing bony labyrinth of the temporal bone. Epithelial-mesenchymal interactions are thought to control inner ear development, but the modes and the molecules involved are largely unresolved. We show here that, during the precartilage and cartilage stages, Fgf9 is expressed in specific nonsensory domains of the otic epithelium and its receptors, Fgfr1(IIIc) and Fgfr2(IIIc), widely in the surrounding mesenchyme. To address the role of Fgf9 signaling, we analyzed the inner ears of mice homozygous for Fgf9 null alleles. Fgf9 inactivation leads to a hypoplastic vestibular component of the otic capsule and to the absence of the epithelial semicircular ducts. Reduced proliferation of the prechondrogenic mesenchyme was found to underlie capsular hypoplasticity. Semicircular duct development is blocked at the initial stages, since fusion plates do not form. Our results show that the mesenchyme directs fusion plate formation and they give direct evidence for the existence of reciprocal epithelial-mesenchymal interactions in the developing inner ear. In addition to the vestibule, in the cochlea, Fgf9 mutation caused defects in the interactions between the Reissner's membrane and the mesenchymal cells, leading to a malformed scala vestibuli. Together, these data show that Fgf9 signaling is required for inner ear morphogenesis.     

Effects of retinoids on chick face development.

Local application of retinoic acid to chick embryos produces severe bilateral clefting of the primary palate but does not affect the lower beak. This paper reviews what is known about the basis and specificity of this retinoid-induced defect by examining three major developmental processes: morphogenesis, cell differentiation, and pattern formation. The conclusion reached is that neither cytotoxicity nor cartilage inhibition is the basis of the specific retinoid-induced defect. Retinoid treatment interferes with reciprocal epithelial-mesenchymal interactions in the upper beak. These interactions are involved in linking pattern formation--the spatial ordering of cell differentiation--to morphogenesis and outgrowth. These results suggest that retinoids are interfering with the process of pattern formation in the upper beak, a conclusion that is supported by the similarities between retinoid effects on face and limb development. Thus, it appears that retinoids may be acting as general signaling molecules throughout the developing embryo. In the lower beak, pattern-forming cues may occur earlier in development. Alternatively, the cells may be unresponsive to retinoids. The molecular basis for the specificity of the facial defect--as well as for the action of retinoids on developing systems--is discussed with reference to recent advances in molecular biology.     

Epithelial-mesenchymal co-culture model for studying alveolar morphogenesis

Division of large, immature alveolar structures into smaller, more numerous alveoli increases the surface area available for gas exchange. Alveolar division requires precise epithelial-mesenchymal interactions. However, few experimental models exist for studying how these cell-cell interactions produce changes in 3-dimensional structure. Here we report an epithelial-mesenchymal cell co-culture model where 3-dimensional peaks form with similar cellular orientation as alveolar structures in vivo. Co-culturing fetal mouse lung mesenchyme with A549 epithelial cells produced tall peaks of cells covered by epithelia with cores of mesenchymal cells. These structures did not form when using adult lung fibroblasts. Peak formation did not require localized areas of cell proliferation or apoptosis. Mesenchymal cells co-cultured with epithelia adopted an elongated cell morphology closely resembling myofibroblasts within alveolar septa in vivo. Because inflammation inhibits alveolar formation, we tested the effects of E. coli lipopolysaccharide on 3-dimensional peak formation. Confocal and time-lapse imaging demonstrated that lipopolysaccharide reduced mesenchymal cell migration, resulting in fewer, shorter peaks with mesenchymal cells present predominantly at the base. This epithelial-mesenchymal co-culture model may therefore prove useful in future studies of mechanisms regulating alveolar morphogenesis.     

Epithelial-mesenchymal co-culture model for studying alveolar morphogenesis

Division of large, immature alveolar structures into smaller, more numerous alveoli increases the surface area available for gas exchange. Alveolar division requires precise epithelial-mesenchymal interactions. However, few experimental models exist for studying how these cell-cell interactions produce changes in 3-dimensional structure. Here we report an epithelial-mesenchymal cell co-culture model where 3-dimensional peaks form with similar cellular orientation as alveolar structures in vivo. Co-culturing fetal mouse lung mesenchyme with A549 epithelial cells produced tall peaks of cells covered by epithelia with cores of mesenchymal cells. These structures did not form when using adult lung fibroblasts. Peak formation did not require localized areas of cell proliferation or apoptosis. Mesenchymal cells co-cultured with epithelia adopted an elongated cell morphology closely resembling myofibroblasts within alveolar septa in vivo. Because inflammation inhibits alveolar formation, we tested the effects of E. coli lipopolysaccharide on 3-dimensional peak formation. Confocal and time-lapse imaging demonstrated that lipopolysaccharide reduced mesenchymal cell migration, resulting in fewer, shorter peaks with mesenchymal cells present predominantly at the base. This epithelial-mesenchymal co-culture model may therefore prove useful in future studies of mechanisms regulating alveolar morphogenesis.     

Serotonin and morphogenesis. I. Sites of serotonin uptake and -binding protein immunoreactivity in the midgestation mouse embryo

The possible involvement of the neurotransmitter serotonin (5-HT) in morphogenesis of the craniofacial region in the mouse embryo has been investigated using the method of whole-embryo culture. Day-12 embryos were incubated for 3-4 h in the presence of 5-HT or its precursors L-tryptophan (L-TRP) or 5-hydroxytryptophan (5-HTP), followed by fixation, sectioning and staining with a specific antiserum to 5-HT. Sites of 5-HT immunoreactivity were found in a variety of locations in tissues of the head and neck, which are either epithelia derived from the non-neural ectoderm or are non-neuronal midline brain structures. These sites include the surface epithelia of the head, face, nasal prominences, branchial arches, oral cavity and associated parts of the nasal epithelium, the epithelium covering the eye, parts of the otic vesicle, the epiphysis and roof of the diencephalon. With the exception of the oral cavity, sites of immunoreactivity for serotonin-binding protein were identified in the mesenchyme adjacent to these sites. This mesenchyme consists of ectodermally derived neural crest cells, which are known to receive inductive influences from the epithelia with which they interact during their migration through the craniofacial region. The presence of 5-HT uptake sites in epithelia and adjacent sites of SBP in the underlying mesenchyme raises the possibility that 5-HT might be involved in those epithelial-mesenchymal interactions known to be important for the development of structures in the craniofacial region.     

Distribution of fibronectin in the early phase of avian cephalic neural crest cell migration

Immunofluorescence and immunoperoxidase labeling for fibronectin was used to study the early events of cephalic neural crest cell migration in avian embryos. Prior to crest cell appearance, fibronectin was associated with the basement membranes of all tissues. The loose mesenchymal cells were also surrounded by this glycoprotein. The crest cell individualization phase included a transient rounding up and a rapid increase in cell number in a very limited space. Whereas the neural tube basement membrane was not formed dorsally at the site of emergence of crest cells, it was partially fused laterally with the ectoderm basement membrane apparently preventing immediate crest cell emigration. Further increase in cell number occurred concomitantly with their penetration between the two developing basement membranes of the neural tube and the ectoderm. The localization of migrating crest cells is apparently greatly influenced by local interactions between the ectoderm and the neural tube, whose morphogenesis differs considerably at each axial level: at the mesencephalic-rhombencephalic levels, crest cells rapidly reached a cell-free space that was mostly devoid of fibronectin. Further migration occurred laterally in that space while pioneer crest cells became surrounded by fibronectin in their environment. Crest cells progressed as a confluent multicellular layer with an apparent velocity of 70 μm/hr. At the prosencephalic and median rhombencephalic levels, crest cells accumulated between the fibronectin-rich basement membranes of the ectoderm and the neural tube. Pioneer crest cells were arrested at the site of attachment of the ectoderm and the neural tube basement membranes (i.e., optic vesicles and otic placodes). Crest cells resumed their migration when more space became available during the constriction of the optic vesicles and the invagination of the otic placodes.     

Evidence for an early role for BMP4 signaling in thymus and parathyroid morphogenesis

The thymus and parathyroids are pharyngeal endoderm-derived organs that develop from common organ primordia, which undergo a series of morphological events resulting in separate organs in distinct locations in the embryo. Previous gene expression and functional analyses have suggested a role for BMP4 signaling in early thymus organogenesis. We have used conditional deletion of Bmp4 or Alk3 from the pharyngeal endoderm and/or the surrounding mesenchyme using Foxg1-Cre, Wnt1-Cre or Foxn1-Cre. Deleting Bmp4 from both neural crest cells (NCC) and early endoderm-derived epithelial cells in Foxg1-Cre;Bmp4 conditional mutants resulted in defects in thymus-parathyroid morphogenesis. Defects included reduced condensation of mesenchymal cells around the epithelium, partial absence of the thymic capsule, a delay in thymus and parathyroid separation, and failed or dramatically reduced organ migration. Patterning of the primordia and initial organ differentiation were not affected in any of the mutants. Deleting Bmp4 from NCC-derived mesenchyme or differentiating thymic epithelial cells (TECs) had no effects on thymus-parathyroid development, while loss of Alk3 from either neural crest cells or TECs resulted in only a mild thymic hypoplasia. these results show that the processes of cell specification and morphogenesis during thymus-parathyroid development are independently controlled, and suggest a specific temporal and spatial role for BMP4-mediated epithelial-mesenchymal interactions during early thymus and parathyroid morphogenesis.     

The role of tissue interactions in the skeletogenic differentiation of avian neural crest cells

In the avian embryo, cranial neural crest (NC) cells migrate extensively throughout the head region and give rise to most of the cranial skeleton (Le Lievre, C. S. (1978). J. Embryol. Exp. Morphol.47, 17–37). To investigate the skeletogenic differentiation of these cells, NC explants from the mesencephalic level of st. 9+ embryos were grown in standard organ culture on Millipore filter substrates either in isolation or in combination with those tissues with which the cells normally associate during their in vivo migration and at their final tissue sites. The results demonstrate that interaction between premigratory NC and cranial ectoderm leads to chondrogenic differentiation of NC cells. Combination of premigratory NC with presumptive site tissues led to a pattern of NC cell differentiation normally expressed after in vivo migration: Combinations of NC with retinal pigmented epithelia gave cartilage, whereas NC with maxillary ectoderm formed cartilage and membrane bone. Both resulting skeletal tissues possessed their characteristic collagen types (II in cartilage and I in bone) as shown by indirect immunofluorescence using antibodies raised against specific types of collagen. It is concluded that avian cephalic NC cells require tissue interactions if chondrogenic and osteogenic differentiation is to ensue, but that migration per se is not an absolute prerequisite for these types of differentiation. The degree of specificity underlying such interactions is discussed.     

Use of the collagen I-deficient Mov13 mouse mutant to analyse epithelial-mesenchymal tissue interaction

The collagen I-deficient mouse mutant (Mov13 — an embryonic recessive lethal) was used to investigate the function of this major constituent of the extracellular matrix (ECM) in organ development. All epithelial-mesenchymal organs tested as explants (lung, kidney, pancreas, salivary glands, skin) developed normally and, in particular, showed typical branching morphogenesis in the absence of collagen I. It is concluded that the ECM of these organs can organize for proper developmental function in the absence of the major interstitial collagen, but a possible morphogenetic function of other fibrillar collagens (types III and V) cannot be excluded. The only insufficiencies in the mutant were seen in the cornea where deposition and organization of the collagenous stroma was highly inadequate; but even there, development and migration of cells proceeded normally. In summary, the results indicate that ‘cellular’ development in epithelial-mesenchymal organs (including growth, morphogenesis, and differentiation) does not depend on collagen I.     

Differentiation of mesenchymal tissues during phallic morphogenesis with emphasis on the os penis: Roles of androgens and other regulatory agents

This article reviews various aspects of differentiation and growth of phallic mesodermal tissues with special reference to the os penis. In many species of certain mammalian orders the penile interior contains an os penis or baculum with bona fide bone. Mechanisms of phenotypic sex differentiation and the androgenic regulation of morphogenesis of genitourinary tracts of both sexes are first overviewed. Thereafter the various mesodermal tissues in fully developed penes and clitorides are discussed. The developmental fate of mesenchymal cells in the fetal genital tubercles is then considered in detail, including consideration of epithelial-mesenchymal interactions. The review concludes with a discussion of the possible roles of certain polypeptide growth factors acting in concert with androgenic steroids. Special emphasis is placed on the potential role of bone morphogenetic proteins in formation of the os penis in a restricted number of eutherian mammalian taxa.     

Epidermal growth factor inhibits morphogenesis and cell differentiation in cultured mouse embryonic teeth

Although local epithelial-mesenchymal tissue interactions which are presumably mediated by extracellular matrix molecules are important regulators of tooth morphogenesis and differentiation, our studies have indicated that these developmental processes also depend on circulating molecules. The iron-carrying serum protein transferrin is necessary for the early morphogenesis of mouse tooth in organ culture (A-M. Partanen, I. Thesleff, and P. Ekblom, 1984, Differentiation 27, 59-66). In the present study we have examined the effects of other growth factors on mouse tooth germs grown in a chemically defined medium containing transferrin. Fibroblast growth factor and platelet derived growth factor had no detectable effects but epidermal growth factor (EGF) inhibited dramatically the morphogenesis of teeth, and prevented odontoblast and ameloblast cell differentiation. EGF stimulated cell proliferation in the explants measured as [3H]thymidine incorporation in DNA. However, when the distribution of dividing cells was visualized in autoradiographs, it was observed that cell proliferation was stimulated in the dental epithelium but was inhibited in the dental mesenchyme. The inhibition of cell proliferation in the dental mesenchyme apparently caused the inhibition of morphogenesis. We do not know whether the dental epithelium or mesenchyme was the primary target for the action of EGF in the inhibition of morphogenesis. It is, however, apparent that the response of the dental mesenchymal cells to EGF (inhibition of proliferation) is regulated by their local environment, since EGF enhanced proliferation when these cells were disaggregated and cultured as monolayers. This indicates that the organ culture system where the various embryonic cell lineages are maintained in their original environment corresponds better to the in vivo situation when the roles of exogenous growth factors during development are examined.     

Development of the mandibular skeleton in the embryonic chick as evaluated using the DNA-inhibiting agent 5-fluoro-2'-deoxyuridine

Mandibular development was examined in embryonic chicks following administration of 5-fluoro-2'-deoxyuridine (FUDR, 0.001-1.0 microgram/egg), an inhibitor of both DNA synthesis and of cell division. FUDR was injected in ovo at one of three developmental stages corresponding to 1) the migration of mandible-destined, midbrain-level neural crest cells (Hamburger and Hamilton [H.H.] stage 10); 2) midway through the epithelial-mesenchymal interaction required to initiate mandibular osteogenesis (H.H. stage 22), which is also after the epithelial-neural crest cell interaction required for the initiation of chondrogenesis in Meckel's cartilage; and 3) when prechondroblasts of Meckel's cartilage are beginning to differentiate (H.H. stage 25). Micromelia was induced following the administration of FUDR at either H.H. stages 22 or 25 but not when FUDR was given at H.H. stage 10. Although the micromelic mandibles were shorter than normal, Meckel's cartilage and the mandibular membrane bones both differentiated and grew along the full proximodistal length of the shortened mandibles. In contrast to the situation previously described by Ferguson for alligator embryos exposed to FUDR, the migration of neural crest cells in the embryonic chick was not inhibited by FUDR. In contrast to the situation previously described for rat embryos exposed to FUDR, differentiation of Meckel's cartilage was not inhibited in embryonic chicks exposed to FUDR. Differentiation of the membrane bones was also normal following either in ovo administration of FUDR or when mandibular processes were maintained in FUDR in vitro. Therefore, FUDR does not produce micromelia in the embryonic chick by interfering with the epithelial-mesenchymal/neural crest cell interactions, which are prerequisites or differentiation of cartilage or bone, nor by inhibiting the differentiation of chondrogenic or osteogenic mesenchymal cells after completion of these tissue interactions. Neither did the growth-inhibiting action of FUDR result from an inhibition of growth of Meckel's cartilage during the several days following initial chondrogenic differentiation. Rather, subsequent growth of the entire mandibular process was delayed. This mechanism of action differs from that in the alligator embryo, in which FUDR inhibits mandibular growth by removing mandible-destined, migrating neural crest cells, and in the rat, in which FUDR inhibits the differentiation of Meckel's cartilage but catch-up growth restores growth of the mandible to normal.