Encircled: large-scale purification of replication origins from Mammalian chromosomes

A novel cloning strategy for sequences comprising mammalian replication origins, described by Mesner et al. (2006) in a recent issue of Molecular Cell, utilizes an origin trapping assay in which replication bubbles are selectively retained in agarose due to their circular nature.     

Mammalian DNA enriched for replication origins is enriched for snap-back sequences

Using the instability of replication loops as a method for the isolation of double-stranded nascent DNA, extruded DNA enriched for replication origins was obtained and denatured. Snap-back DNA, single-stranded DNA with inverted repeats (palindromic sequences), reassociates rapidly into stem-loop structures with zero-order kinetics when conditions are changed from denaturing to renaturing, and can be assayed by chromatography on hydroxyapatite. Origin-enriched nascent DNA strands from mouse, rat and monkey cells growing either synchronously or asynchronously were purified and assayed for the presence of snap-back sequences. The results show that origin-enriched DNA is also enriched for snap-back sequences, implying that some origins for mammalian DNA replication contain or lie near palindromic sequences.     

Cybernetic origins of replication

An evolutionary progression leading toward replication is resolved into several phases; (a) the replication of RNA segments by self-priming and -templating, (b) the replication of single stranded molecules by elongation and controlled scission, (c) replication of complementary duplexes and (d) replication of DNA. The initial phase is suggested by evidence for the existence of tandem repeats in an early population of molecules presumed to be ancestral to today's structurl RNAs. Relics of these repeats are seen in the positioning of sequence matches between transfer and ribosomal RNAs. Conservation of the positions of the matches is indicated by persistence of a periodicity in their spacings along the molecules.Selection is viewed as a vector, with a source and a focus. The evolutionary progression entails shifts in the source of selection, from external catalysts to the replicating molecule itself, and in its focus, from substrate to replicator, to the products of the replicator's activity. When the source and focus of selection are the same selection becomes internalized, and replication and Darwinian evolution follow.Catalytic specificity is regarded as an antecedent to natural selection. Shifting of the source and focus of selection and switches in evolution's vehicle, the most fundamental thing that evolves, result in profound changes in the modes of evolution. Control provides a conceptual framwork within which entry into a Darwinian mode of evolution, and ultimately liberation from Darwinian evolution might be explained.This paper was prepared for posthumous publication by H. S. Forrest and M. P. Staves. Reprint requests should be addressed to M. P. Staves, Dept. of Biochemistry, University of Alabama at Birmingham, AL 35294, U.S.A.     

Mapping replication origins in yeast chromosomes.

The replicon hypothesis, first proposed in 1963 by Jacob and Brenner, states that DNA replication is controlled at sites called origins. Replication origins have been well studied in prokaryotes. However, the study of eukaryotic chromosomal origins has lagged behind, because until recently there has been no method for reliably determining the identity and location of origins from eukaryotic chromosomes. Here, we review a technique we developed with the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae that allows both the mapping of replication origins and an assessment of their activity. Two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis and Southern hybridization with total genomic DNA are used to determine whether a particular restriction fragment acquires the branched structure diagnostic of replication initiation. The technique has been used to localize origins in yeast chromosomes and assess their initiation efficiency. In some cases, origin activation is dependent upon the surrounding context. The technique is also being applied to a variety of eukaryotic organisms.     

DNA methylation at mammalian replication origins.

In Escherichia coli, DNA methylation regulates both origin usage and the time required to reassemble prereplication complexes at replication origins. In mammals, at least three replication origins are associated with a high density cluster of methylated CpG dinucleotides, and others whose methylation status has not yet been characterized have the potential to exhibit a similar DNA methylation pattern. One of these origins is found within the approximately 2-kilobase pair region upstream of the human c-myc gene that contains 86 CpGs. Application of the bisulfite method for detecting 5-methylcytosines at specific DNA sequences revealed that this region was not methylated in either total genomic DNA or newly synthesized DNA. Therefore, DNA methylation is not a universal component of mammalian replication origins. To determine whether or not DNA methylation plays a role in regulating the activity of origins that are methylated, the rate of remethylation and the effect of hypomethylation were determined at origin beta (ori-beta), downstream of the hamster DHFR gene. Remethylation at ori-beta did not begin until approximately 500 base pairs of DNA was synthesized, but it was then completed by the time that 4 kilobase pairs of DNA was synthesized (<3 min after release into S phase). Thus, DNA methylation cannot play a significant role in regulating reassembly of prereplication complexes in mammalian cells, as it does in E. coli. To determine whether or not DNA methylation plays any role in origin activity, hypomethylated hamster cells were examined for ori-beta activity. Cells that were >50% reduced in methylation at ori-beta no longer selectively activated ori-beta. Therefore, at some loci, DNA methylation either directly or indirectly determines where replication begins.     

Conserved DNA structures in origins of replication.

According to the model of Bramhill and Kornberg, initiation of DNA replication in prokaryotes involves binding of an initiator protein to origin DNA and subsequent duplex opening of adjacent direct repeat sequences. In this report, we have used computer analysis to examine the higher-order DNA structure of a variety of origins of replication from plasmids, phages, and bacteria in order to determine whether these sequences are localized in domains of altered structure. The results demonstrate that the primary sites of initiator protein binding lie in discrete domains of DNA bending, while the direct repeats lie within well-defined boundaries of an unusual anti-bent domain. The anti-bent structures arise from a periodicity of A3 and T3 tracts which avoids the 10-11 bp bending periodicity. Since DNA fragments which serve as replicators in yeast also contain these two conserved structural elements, the results provide new insight into the universal role of conserved DNA structures in DNA replication.     

Geminivirus replication origins have a modular organization.

Tomato golden mosaic virus (TGMV) and bean golden mosaic virus (BGMV) are closely related geminiviruses with bipartite genomes. The A and B DNA components of each virus have cis-acting sequences necessary for replication, and their A components encode trans-acting factors are required for this process. We showed that virus-specific interactions between the cis- and trans-acting functions are required for TGMV and BGMV replication in tobacco protoplasts. We also demonstrated that, similar to the essential TGMV AL1 replication protein, BGMV AL1 binds specifically to its origin in vitro and that neither TGMV nor BGMV AL1 proteins bind to the heterologous origin. The in vitro AL1 binding specificities of the B components were exchanged by site-directed mutagenesis, but the resulting mutants were not replicated by either A component. These results showed that the high-affinity AL1 binding site is necessary but not sufficient for virus-specific origin activity in vivo. Geminivirus genomes also contain a stem-loop sequence that is required for origin function. A BGMV B mutant with the TGMV stem-loop sequence was replicated by BGMV A, indicating that BGMV AL1 does not discriminate between the two sequences. A BGMV B double mutant, with the TGMV AL1 binding site and stem-loop sequences, was not replicated by either A component, indicating that an additional element in the TGMV origin is required for productive interaction with TGMV AL1. These results suggested that geminivirus replication origins are composed of at least three functional modules: (1) a putative stem-loop structure that is required for replication but does not contribute to virus-specific recognition of the origin, (2) a specific high-affinity binding site for the AL1 protein, and (3) at least one additional element that contributes to specific origin recognition by viral trans-acting factors.     

Locations of bacteriophage T4 origins of replication.

Partially replicated bacteriophage T4 DNA containing cytosine was isolated from cells 6.5 and 7 min after infection and cleaved with restriction endonuclease BglII or BamHI. Positions of replication eyes relative to the cleavage sites were observed by electron microscopy. Four groups of eyes were found. They are consistent with replication from origins located at map positions 34, 60, 73, and 86 kilobases. In individual molecules that contained two or three eyes, the distribution of the eyes agreed with the initiation of replication at more than one of these four assigned origins and possibly at two additional origins located near 15 and 110 kilobases, which were reported by P. M. Macdonald, R. M. Seaby, W. Brown, and G. Mosig (p. 111-116, in D. Schlessinger, ed., Microbiology--1983, 1983) and M. E. Halpern, T. Mattson, and A. W. Kozinski (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 76:6137-6141, 1979).     

Physical and genetic mapping of mammalian replication origins.

The neutral/neutral and neutral/alkaline two-dimensional gel electrophoretic techniques are sensitive physical mapping methods that have been used successfully to identify replication initiation sites in genomes of widely varying complexity. We present detailed methodology for the preparation of replication intermediates from mammalian cells and their analysis by both neutral/neutral and neutral/alkaline two-dimensional gel approaches. The methods described allow characterization of the replication pattern of single-copy loci, even in mammalian cells. When applied to metazoans, initiation is found to occur at multiple sites scattered throughout zones that can be as long as 50 kb, with some subregions being preferred. Although these observations do not rule out the possibility of genetically defined replicators, they offer the alternative or additional possibility that chromosomal context may play an important role in defining replication initiation sites in complex genomes. We discuss novel recombination strategies that can be used to test for the presence of sequence elements critical for origin function if the origin lies in the vicinity of a selectable gene. Application of this strategy to the DHFR locus shows that loss of sequences more than 25 kb from the local initiation zone can markedly affect origin activity in the zone.     

Localization of replication origins in pea chloroplast DNA.

The locations of the two replication origins in pea chloroplast DNA (ctDNA) have been mapped by electron microscopic analysis of restriction digests of supercoiled ctDNA cross-linked with trioxalen. Both origins of replication, identified as displacement loops (D-loops), were present in the 44-kilobase-pair (kbp) SalI A fragment. The first D-loop was located at 9.0 kbp from the closest SalI restriction site. The average size of this D-loop was about 0.7 kbp. The second D-loop started 14.2 kbp in from the same restriction site and ended at about 15.5 kbp, giving it a size of about 1.3 kbp. The orientation of these two D-loops on the restriction map of pea ctDNA was determined by analyzing SmaI, PstI, and SalI-SmaI restriction digests of pea ctDNA. One D-loop has been mapped in the spacer region between the 16S and 23S rRNA genes. The second D-loop was located downstream of the 23S rRNA gene. Denaturation mapping of recombinants pCP 12-7 and pCB 1-12, which contain both D-loops, confirmed the location of the D-loops in the restriction map of pea ctDNA. Denaturation-mapping studies also showed that the two D-loops had different base compositions; the one closest to a SalI restriction site denatured readily compared with the other D-loop. The recombinants pCP 12-7 and pCB 1-12 were found to be highly active in DNA synthesis when used as templates in a partially purified replication system from pea chloroplasts. Analysis of in vitro-synthesized DNA with either of these recombinants showed that full-length template DNA was synthesized. Recombinants from other regions of the pea chloroplast genome showed no significant DNA synthesis activity in vitro.     

Multiple origins of replication in archaea

Until recently, the only archaeon for which a bona fide origin of replication was reported was Pyrococcus abyssi, where a single origin was identified. Although several in silico analyses have suggested that some archaeal species might contain more than one origin, this has only been demonstrated recently. Two studies have shown that multiple origins of replication function in two archaeal species. One study identified two origins of replication in the archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus, whereas a second study used a different technique to show that both S. solfataricus and Sulfolobus acidocaldarius have three functional origins. These are the first reports of archaea having multiple origins. This finding has implications for research on the mechanisms of DNA replication and evolution.     

The effect on chromosome stability of deleting replication origins.

The observed spacing between chromosomal DNA replication origins in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is at least four times shorter than should be necessary to ensure complete replication of chromosomal DNA during the S phase. To test whether all replication origins are required for normal chromosome stability, the loss rates of derivatives of chromosome III from which one or more origins had been deleted were measured. In the case of a 61-kb circular derivative of the chromosome that has two highly active origins and one origin that initiates only 10 to 20% of the time, deletion of either highly active origin increased its rate of loss two- to fourfold. Deletion of both highly active origins caused the ring chromosome to be lost in approximately 20% of cell divisions. This very high rate of loss demonstrates that there are no efficient cryptic origins on the ring chromosome that are capable of ensuring its replication in the absence of the origins that are normally used. Deletion of the same two origins from the full-length chromosome III, which contains more than six replication origins, had no effect on its rate of loss. These results suggest that the increase in the rate of loss of the small circular chromosome from which a single highly active origin was deleted was caused by the failure of the remaining highly active origin to initiate replication in a small fraction (approximately 0.003) of cell cycles.     

Initiation of DNA replication in ColE1 plasmids containing multiple potential origins of replication.

We have investigated the frequency of replication origin usage in bacterial plasmids containing more than one potential origin. Escherichia coli recA- cells were selectively transformed with pBR322 monomers, dimers, or trimers. Plasmid DNA was isolated and digested with a restriction enzyme that cut the monomer only once, and the replicative intermediates (RIs) were analyzed by neutral/neutral two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis. Evidence for initiation outside the linearized plasmid was found only for oligomers. Moreover, in dimers, the intensity of the signal indicative for external initiation was equivalent to that reflecting internal initiation, whereas it was approximately twice as strong in trimers. To determine whether initiation could occur simultaneously at two origins in a single plasmid, we studied the replication of a neodimer in which both units could be unambiguously distinguished. The results showed that although both origins were equally competent to initiate replication, only one was active per plasmid. These observations strongly suggest that in ColE1 plasmids, replication initiates at a single site even when there are several identical potential origins per plasmid. In addition to the conventional two-dimensional gel patterns, novel specific patterns were observed with intensities that varied from one DNA sample to another. These unique patterns were the result of breakage of the RIs at a replication fork. This type of breakage changes both the mass and shape of RIs. When the entire population of RIs is affected, a new population of molecules is formed that may generate a novel pattern in two-dimensional gels.     

Densely methylated DNA islands in mammalian chromosomal replication origins.

Densely methylated DNA sequence islands, designated DMIs, have been observed in two Chinese hamster cell chromosomal replication origins by using a PCR-based chemical method of detection. One of the origins, oriS14, is located within or adjacent to the coding sequence for ribosomal protein S14 on chromosome 2q, and the other, ori-beta, is approximately 17 kbp downstream of the dhfr (dihydrofolic acid reductase) locus on chromosome 2p. The DMI in oriS14 is 127 bp long, and the DMI in ori-beta is 516 bp long. Both DMIs are bilaterally methylated (i.e., all dCs are modified to 5-methyl dC) only in cells that are replicating their DNA. When cell growth and DNA replication are arrested, methylation of CpA, CpT, and CpC dinucleotides is lost and the sequence islands display only a subset of their originally methylated CpG dinucleotides. Several possible roles for DMI-mediated regulation of mammalian chromosomal origins are considered.