R46-derived recombinant plasmids affecting DNA repair and mutation in E. coli

Summary Recombinant plasmids which render their host less mutable and more sensitive to some DNA-damaging agents have been isolated from the N-group plasmid R46. These plasmids have been physically mapped and found to originate from the region of R46 that has been deleted in pKM101. This deleted region is well removed from the muc region of R46 and pKM101 which is responsible for the mutator effects of these plasmids.The effect of these anti-mutagenic plasmids on the ability of pKM101 to complement umuC mutations has been examined, and they have been found to inhibit the complementation of such strains. We propose that these plasmids may code for a negative control function acting on the muc gene.     

Temperature-sensitive replication of plasmid pKM101

A mutant of Escherichia coli K-12, IB10 carrying the ts10 mutation has been isolated. The mutation affects replication and inheritance of pKM101 plasmid. Incubation of the mutant under non-selective conditions of 42 degrees C resulted in the formation of R-cell population. The frequency of temperature-independent clones was 2,1 X 10(-5). The defect of pKM101 replication was shown to result in growth inhibition of host cells at a non-permissive temperature. The host growth only started after elimination of the plasmid. The mechanisms are likely to exist governing the participation of plasmid gene products in processes related to host growth. The influence of ts10 mutation on replication of other plasmids was studied. It was established that ts10 did not affect replication of R6K, RP4 and Flac+ plasmids. However, replication of R15, R205 as well as of pKM101 plasmid stopped under conditions of non-permissive temperature in IB10 mutant. Obviously, ts10 mutation results in defective replication of plasmids only belonging to the N-incompatibility group (IncPN). It is shown that R6K, RP4, Flac+ plasmids are not able to correct pKM101 replication in the mutant at 42 degrees C.     

Restriction endonuclease cleavage map of pKM101: Relationship to parental plasmid R46

Summary A detailed restriction endonuclease cleavage map of the plasmid pKM101 has been constructed. pKM101 plasmids containing individual Tn5 insertions were used to facilitate the ordering of restriction fragments generated by enzymes cleaving pKM101 at multiple sites. By restriction enzyme analysis, pKM101 (35.4 kilobases) appears to have arisen from its clinically-isolated parent by deletion of a single DNA region which codes for three of the four drug resistances carried by R46.     

Isolation of plasmid pKM101 in the Stocker laboratory

pKM101 is a mutagenesis-enhancing resistance transfer plasmid (R plasmid) that was introduced into several tester strains used in the Salmonella/microsome mutation assay (Ames test). Plasmid pKM101 has contributed substantially to the effectiveness of the Ames assay, which is used on a world-wide basis to detect mutagens and is required by many government regulatory agencies for approval to market new drugs and other chemical agents. Widely used since 1975, the Ames test is still regarded as one of the most sensitive genetic toxicity assays and a useful short-term test for predicting carcinogenicity in animals. Plasmid pKM101, which is a deletion derivative of plasmid R46 (also referred to as R-Brighton after its origin of isolation in Brighton, England), has also been used to elucidate molecular mechanisms of mutagenesis. It was isolated in the laboratory of Professor Bruce A.D. Stocker at Stanford University as part of my doctoral research with 20 R plasmids. Professor Stocker's phenomenal insight into the genetics of Salmonella typhimurium and plasmid behavior was a major factor that led to the isolation of pKM101. This paper includes a tribute to Bruce Stocker, together with a summary of my research with mutagenesis-enhancing R plasmids and a brief discussion of the molecular mechanisms involved in pKM101 plasmid-mediated bacterial mutagenesis.     

Effect of plasmids col I and pKM101, alone or in combination, on spontaneous and induced mutability of salmonellae

Comparative studies of plasmids col I and pKM101 effect on lethal and mutagenic response to UV-light and chemical agents (4NQ0, EMS, agent N012074) has been carried out in Salmonella strains used for screening of mutagens (potential carcinogens). It has been found that the plasmid pKM101 has more pronounced effect as compared with coll plasmid. Contrary to plasmid pKM101-mediated ability to form UV-induced frameshift mutation, colI factor lacks this ability and very slightly enhances the rate of frameshift mutagenesis induced by chemical agents under study. The colicinogenic factor is found to enhance only the rate of base-pair substitutions, whereas plasmid pKM101 enhances the rate of both base-pair substitutions and frameshift mutations. We were unable to demonstrate combined effect of these two plasmids on the rate of either spontaneous or induced mutations. Possible mechanisms of plasmid-mediated bacterial mutagenesis and repair are discussed.     

Intergeneric conjugation between Escherichia coli and Streptomyces species.

We have constructed Escherichia coli-Streptomyces shuttle plasmids which are capable of conjugal transfer from E. coli to Streptomyces spp. These plasmids contained the pBR322 and pIJ101 origins of replication and the RK2 (IncP) origin of transfer. The transfer of plasmid was specifically dependent the presence of a 760-base-pair, cis-acting, oriT-containing fragment and on RP4 (IncP) functions supplied in trans. Conditions of mating and selection of exconjugants were analyzed with Streptomyces lividans as recipient. Plasmid transfer to other Streptomyces species was also demonstrated.     

Isolation and characterization of mutants of the plasmid pKM101 deficient in their ability to enhance mutagenesis and repair.

A screening procedure was developed for identifying mutants of the plasmid pKM101 no longer capable of enhancing mutagenesis. The test was based on the large pKM101-mediated increase in the number of Gal+ papillae observed on colonies of Salmonella typhimurium gal mutants plated on tetrazolium-galactose plates in the presence of a mutagen. The pKM101 mutant plasmids transferred normally, were stably maintained in cells, caused normal levels of ampicillin resistance, and still imparted sensitivity to phage Ike to their hosts. However, the pKM101 mutants had lost the ability to (i) enhance the reversion of both point and frameshift mutations, (ii) protect the cells against killing by UV irradiation, (iii) increase the spontaneous reversion rates of point mutations, (iv) enhance plasmid-mediated reactivation of UV-irradiated phage P22, (v) enhance Weigle reactivation. One pKM101 mutant with different properties from the others was identified by its increased spontaneous mutator effect. It is suggested that pKM101 amplifies the activity of the inducible error-prone repair systems in bacteria and that this is the function of pKM101 in the Ames Salmonella tester strains used for detection of carcinogens as mutagens.     

Plasmid-dosage effects on ultraviolet, visible light and methyl methanesulfonate mutagenesis in Salmonella typhimurium

Salmonella typhimurium LT2 strains bearing plasmids pKM101, R64 or pColIb-P9 demonstrated enhanced UV survival when compared with strains not bearing plasmids. A strain of S. typhimurium bearing both pKM101 and pColIb-P9 survived UV irradiation slightly better than either of the single-plasmid strains. Spontaneous reversion of the hisG46 and trpE8 missense alleles was enhanced in each single-plasmid strain, and for the dual-plasmid strain containing pKM101 and pColIb-P9 enhancement represented a near additivity of the response seen for the single-plasmid strains. Following exposure to UV or visible-light irradiation, reversion of hisG46 and trpE8 was also enhanced in each single-plasmid strain, but quantitatively greater in the dual-plasmid strain and was equal to or slightly greater than additive the responses of the single-plasmid strains. In contrast to visible-light irradiation, UV exposure resulted in two phenotypic Trp+-revertant classes. One Trp+ class, having normal colony size (2.0 mm) and similar in number to His+ revertants, was comprised of intragenic revertants of trpE8, while the predominant Trp+ class, having smaller colony size (0.8 mm), represented intergenic suppressor revertants, illuminating the differences in mutation and/or repair specificity for UV and visible-light exposure. Methyl methane-sulfonate (MMS)-induced reversion of hisG46 was similar in effect to that seen with UV or visible-light irradiation. Plasmids pKM101 or pColIb-P9 enhanced the frequency of hisG46 reversion, while a more than additive response was seen in a strain with both plasmids. Furthermore, MMS-induced reversion of hisG46 was also observed to be greatest in a strain bearing plasmid R64 (incompatibility group I alpha) and pKM101, when compared with single-plasmid strains bearing either R64 or pKM101.     

Mutagenesis by neocarzinostatin in Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium: requirement for umuC+ or plasmid pKM101.

Neocarzinostatin, a protein with antibiotic activity, is a bacterial mutagen. We have investigated the mutagenicity of neocarzinostatin towards Salmonella typhimurium and discovered that, unlike the situation in Escherichia coli, neocarzinostatin will revert base pair substitution mutations (missense or nonsense). However, when the R46 factor derivative, plasmid pKM101, was introduced, the mutagenicity of neocarzinostatin towards base pair substitution-carrying mutants of S. typhimurium was readily detected. Neocarzinostatin had only modest activity in reverting a frameshift mutation in S. typhimurium, but that activity, too, required the presence of pKM101. Mutant pKM101 plasmids which no longer enhanced mutagenesis also lost their ability to promote neocarzinostatin-induced mutations. Finally, the umuC36 mutation, which renders E. coli nonmutable by ultraviolet light, also rendered the bacteria nonmutable by neocarzinostatin. The effect of the umuC36 mutation was suppressed by plasmid pKM101.     

Effect of pKM101 plasmid on lethal and mutagenic damage in UV-irradiated E. coli strains

Introduction of the R-factor plasmid pKM101 increased resistance to UV-killing in uvr lexA(Ind-) recA+ strains of E. coli K12 as well as B, while their UV mutability was not affected. Similar effects were also observed in those strains when the 18-B plasmid (a pBR322 derivative carrying the region (about 5 kb) of the 35.4 kb pKM101 plasmid) was introduced. The muc genes which are considered to be involved in error-prone repair are contained in 18-B. These results suggest the possibility that the pKM101 effect requires the host recA gene and a common genetic region, including the muc genes, in both plasmids and is associated with some unmutable repair systems.     

IncN plasmid pKM101 and IncI1 plasmid ColIb-P9 encode homologous antirestriction proteins in their leading regions.

The IncN plasmid pKM101 (a derivative of R46), like the IncI1 plasmid ColIb-P9, carries a gene (ardA, for alleviation of restriction of DNA) encoding an antirestriction function. ardA was located about 4 kb from the origin of transfer, in the region transferred early during bacterial conjugation. The nucleotide sequence of ardA was determined, and an appropriate polypeptide with the predicted molecular weight of about 19,500 was identified in maxicells of Escherichia coli. Comparison of the deduced amino acid sequences of the antirestriction proteins of the unrelated plasmids pKM101 and ColIb (ArdA and Ard, respectively) revealed that these proteins have about 60% identity. Like ColIb Ard, pKM101 ArdA specifically inhibits both the restriction and modification activities of five type I systems of E. coli tested and does not influence type III (EcoP1) restriction or the 5-methylcytosine-specific restriction systems McrA and McrB. However, in contrast to ColIb Ard, pKM101 ArdA is effective against the type II enzyme EcoRI. The Ard proteins are believed to overcome the host restriction barrier during bacterial conjugation. We have also identified two other genes of pKM101, ardR and ardK, which seem to control ardA activity and ardA-mediated lethality, respectively. Our findings suggest that ardR may serve as a genetic switch that determines whether the ardA-encoded antirestriction function is induced during mating.     

Plasmid-mediated expression of the UmuDC mutagenesis proteins in an Escherichia coli strain engineered for human cytochrome P450 1A2-catalyzed activation of aromatic amines.

The mutagenic actions of many chemicals depend on the activities of bacterial "mutagenesis proteins", which allow replicative bypass of DNA lesions. Genes encoding these proteins occur on bacterial chromosomes and plasmids, often in the form of an operon (such as umuDC or mucAB) encoding two proteins. Many bacterial strains used in mutagenicity testing carry mutagenesis protein genes borne on plasmids, such as pKM101. Our objective was to introduce mutagenesis protein function into Escherichia coli strain DJ4309. This strain expresses recombinant human cytochrome P450 1A2 and NADPH-P450 reductase and carries out the metabolic conversion of aromatic and heterocyclic amines into DNA-reactive mutagens. We discovered that many mutagenesis-protein plasmids severely inhibit the response of strain DJ4309 to 2-amino-3,4-dimethylimid-azo[4,5-f]quinoline (MeIQ), a typical heterocyclic amine mutagen. Among many plasmids examined, one, pGY8294, a pSC101 derivative carrying the umuDC operon, did not inhibit MeIQ mutagenesis. Strain DJ4309 pGY8294 expresses active mutagenesis proteins, as shown by its response to mutagens such as 1-nitropyrene and 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide (4-NQO), and is as sensitive as the parent strain DJ4309 to P450-dependent mutagens, such as MeIQ and 1-aminopyrene.     

Inhibition of Homologous Recombination by the Plasmid MucA′B Complex

By its functional interaction with a RecA polymer, the mutagenic UmuD′C complex possesses an antirecombination activity. We show here that MucA′B, a functional homolog of the UmuD′C complex, inhibits homologous recombination as well. In F⁻ recipients expressing MucA′B from a P_tac promoter, Hfr × F⁻ recombination decreased with increasing MucA′B concentrations down to 50-fold. In damage-induced pKM101-containing cells expressing MucA′B from the native promoter, recombination between a UV-damaged F lac plasmid and homologous chromosomal DNA decreased 10-fold. Overexpression of MucA′B together with UmuD′C resulted in a synergistic inhibition of recombination. RecA[UmuR] proteins, which are resistant to UmuD′C inhibition of recombination, are inhibited by MucA′B while promoting MucA′B-promoted mutagenesis efficiently. The data suggest that MucA′B and UmuD′C contact a RecA polymer at distinct sites. The MucA′B complex was more active than UmuD′C in promoting UV mutagenesis, yet it did not inhibit recombination more than UmuD′C does. The enhanced mutagenic potential of MucA′B may result from its inherent superior capacity to assist DNA polymerase in trans-lesion synthesis. In the course of this work, we found that the natural plasmid pKM101 expresses around 45,000 MucA and 13,000 MucB molecules per lexA(Def) cell devoid of LexA. These molecular Muc concentrations are far above those of the chromosomally encoded Umu counterparts. Plasmid pKM101 belongs to a family of broad-host-range conjugative plasmids. The elevated levels of the Muc proteins might be required for successful installation of pKM101-like plasmids into a variety of host cells.     

Plasmid pGW16, a derivative of pKM101, increases post-UV DNA synthesis, but sensitises some strains of Escherichia coli to UV

Plasmid pKM101, which carries muc genes that are analogous in function to chromosomal umu genes, protected Escherichia coli strains AB1157 uvrB+ umuC+, JC3890 uvrB umuC+, TK702 uvrB+ umuC and TK501 uvrB umuC against ultraviolet irradiation (UV). Plasmid pGW16, a derivative of pKM101 selected for its increased spontaneous mutator effect, also gave some protection to the UmuC-deficient strains, TK702 and TK501. However, it sensitised the wild-type strain AB1157 to low, but protected against high doses of UV, whilst sensitising strain JC3890 to all UV doses tested. Even though its UV-protecting effects varied, pGW16 was shown to increase both spontaneous and UV-induced mutation in all strains. Another derivative of pKM101, plasmid pGW12, was shown to have lost all spontaneous and UV-induced mutator effects and did not affect post-UV survival. Plasmids pKM101 and pGW16 increased post-UV DNA synthesis in strains AB1157 and TK702, whereas pGW12 had no effect. Similarly, the wild-type UV-protecting plasmids R46, R446b and R124 increased post-UV DNA synthesis in strain TK501, but the non-UV-protecting plasmids R1, RP4 and R6K had no effect. These results accord with the model for error-prone DNA repair that requires umu or muc gene products for chain elongation after base insertion opposite non-coding lesions. They also suggest that the UV-sensitizing effects of pGW16 on umu+ strains can be explained in terms of overactive DNA repair resulting in lethal, rather than repaired UV-induced lesions.     

Genetic localization and characterization of a pKM101-coded endonuclease.

The genetic and biochemical properties of an endonuclease mediated by the mutagenesis-enhancing plasmid pKM101 have been investigated. Taking advantage of the observation that this endonuclease, unlike host-coded DNases, is active in the presence of EDTA, we have developed an assay with nondenaturing acrylamide gels containing DNA. We have localized the plasmid DNA sufficient for nuclease expression to a 0.8-kilobase sequence that is near regions of DNA necessary for conjugal transfer, and we have determined that this gene is transcribed clockwise on the pKM101 map. The pKM101 gene mediating this activity codes for a 16,000-dalton protein, which is the same molecular mass as the nuclease monomer, leading us to conclude that this gene codes for the nuclease itself rather than for an activator of some host-coded enzyme. Cellular fractionation experiments have shown that the enzyme is localized in the periplasm. We have not been able to demonstrate any physiological role for the enzyme, but we have ruled out a direct involvement of the nuclease in any of the following known plasmid-associated phenotypes: (i) mutagenesis enhancement, (ii) conjugal transfer, (iii) entry exclusion, (iv) fertility inhibition of coresident P-group plasmids, (v) killing of Klebsiella pneumoniae used as conjugal recipients, and (vi) plasmid curing induced by treatment of cells with fluorodeoxyuridine. In addition, we have shown that the enzyme does not restrict bacteriophage or affect the ability of the host to utilize DNA as a source of thymine. Finally, we have shown that 11 of the 26 other plasmids tested also elaborated EDTA-resistant DNases.     

Conserved regions at the DNA primase locus of IncP alpha and IncP beta plasmids

Genes specifying DNA primases (pri) are common in all IncP plasmids examined so far. These plasmids suppress the thermosensitive character of the Escherichia coli dnaG3 mutation. The mechanism of suppression appears to be identical to that known for RP4 and IncI alpha plasmids. The DNA primases of both these plasmid types can substitute for the dnaG protein in chromosomal DNA replication. The pri genes of the alpha and beta subgroup of IncP plasmids are related to each other as judged from Southern hybridization and immunological data. Extensive DNA and protein sequence homology has been detected although the gene products of the alpha and beta subgroups exhibit substantial differences in size. The arrangement of overlapping genes at the pri locus of IncP alpha plasmids also appears to be present in the IncP beta group.     

Comparison of 10 IncP plasmids: homology in the regions involved in plasmid replication.

We have examined the DNA homology in the replication regions of 10 IncP plasmids independently isolated from several different countries. Two regions of RK2, the best-studied plasmid of this group, are required for vegetative DNA replication: the origin of replication (oriV) and the trfA region, which codes for a gene product necessary for replication. Six of nine IncP plasmids studied were identical to RK2 in the oriV and trfA regions as shown by Southern hybridization. Three P plasmids, R751, R772, and R906, showed weaker homology with the RK2 trfA, region and hybridized to different-sized HaeII fragments than the other six plasmids. R751, R772, and R906 hybridized to the region of the RK2 replication origin which expresses P incompatibility but differed markedly from RK2 and the other six plasmids in the GC-rich region of the origin required for replication. These data indicate that the P-group plasmids can be divided into two subgroups: IncP alpha, which includes the RK2-like plasmids, and IncP beta which includes the R751-like plasmids.     

Genetic analysis of the mobilization and leading regions of the IncN plasmids pKM101 and pCU1

The conjugative IncN plasmids pKM101 and pCU1 have previously been shown to contain identical oriT sequences as well as conserved restriction endonuclease cleavage patterns within their tra regions. Complementation analysis and sequence data presented here indicate that these two plasmids encode essentially identical conjugal DNA-processing proteins. This region contains three genes, traI, traJ, and traK, transcribed in the same orientation from a promoter that probably lies within or near the conjugal transfer origin (oriT). Three corresponding proteins were visualized by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and complementation analysis confirmed that this region contains three tra complementation groups. All three proteins resemble proteins of the IncW plasmid R388 and other plasmids thought to have roles in processing of plasmid DNA during conjugation. The hydropathy profile of TraJ suggests a transmembrane topology similar to that of several homologous proteins. Both traK and traI were required for efficient interplasmid site-specific recombination at oriT, while traJ was not required. The leading region of pKM101 contains three genes (stbA, stbB, and stbC), null mutations in which cause elevated levels of plasmid instability. Plasmid instability was observed only in hosts that are proficient in interplasmid recombination, suggesting that this recombination can potentially lead to plasmid loss and that Stb proteins somehow overcome this, possibly via site-specific multimer resolution.     

Common ancestry between IncN conjugal transfer genes and macromolecular export systems of plant and animal pathogens

The DNA sequence of a cluster of pKM101 conjugal transfer genes was determined and aligned with the genetic map of the plasmid. Eighteen genes were identified, at least eight and probably 11 of which are required for efficient conjugation. These tra genes are homologous to and colinear with genes found in the virB operon of Agrobacterium tumefaciens TI plasmids. Seven pKM101 tra genes are also homologous to ptl genes of Bordetella pertussis, which direct the export of pertussis toxin. We used TnphoA to construct translational fusions between pKM101 genes and the Escherichia coli phoA gene, which encodes alkaline phosphatase, and provide evidence that at least 11 of the 18 genes are either fully or partially exported from the cytoplasm.     

Identification and mapping of regions of the plasmid pKM101 which influence the growth rate and resistance to phleomycin E of Escherichia coli WP2.

The effects of deletion of various regions of the pKM101 genome on several phenotypes conferred by pKM101 in Escherichia coli WP2 cells were investigated. Differences in the response of cells carrying pKM101 or various pKM101 deletion derivatives to the mutagenic effects of phleomycin E can be attributed to differences in sensitivity to the lethal effects of phleomycin E. Resistance to phleomycin E is conferred by the pKM101 mucAB genes (or an adjacent gene) but observed only with pKM101 derivatives which have lost a 2.2-kilobase (BalI-KpnI-2) segment which completely includes the pKM101 endonuclease gene nuc. A pKM101 slow-growth determinant, distinct from the slo gene, has also been identified and localized in the 2.4-kilobase (BalI-KpnI-3) segment which is adjacent to the nuc gene. Loss of this region does not appear to substantially influence the toxic or mutagenic effects of phleomycin E.