Interaction between sunflower plants and five isolates of Plasmopara halstedii on the level of pathogenicity

The interaction between sunflower plants showing a high level of quantitative resistance and five Plasmopara halstedii (the causal agent of downy mildew) isolates of several races were studied using five single zoosporangium isolates per pathogen isolate. Aggressiveness criteria were analyzed for 25 P. halstedii single zoosporangium isolates. Based on the reaction for the P. halstedii isolates to four sunflower hybrids H1–H4 varying only in their downy mildew resistance genes, there were differences in virulence spectrum in pathogen isolates. Analysis of five single zoosporangium isolates for P. halstedii isolates showed significant variability within pathogen isolate for all aggressiveness criteria but not for all pathogen isolates. The hypothesis explaining the interaction between P. halstedii and its host plant was discussed on the level of pathogenicity.     

Sunflower resistance to multiple downy mildew pathotypes revealed by recognition of conserved effectors of the oomycete Plasmopara halstedii

Over the last 40 years, new sunflower downy mildew isolates (Plasmopara halstedii) have overcome major gene resistances in sunflower, requiring the identification of additional and possibly more durable broad‐spectrum resistances. Here, 354 RXLR effectors defined in silico from our new genomic data were classified in a network of 40 connected components sharing conserved protein domains. Among 205 RXLR effector genes encoding conserved proteins in 17 P. halstedii pathotypes of varying virulence, we selected 30 effectors that were expressed during plant infection as potentially essential genes to target broad‐spectrum resistance in sunflower. The transient expression of the 30 core effectors in sunflower and in Nicotiana benthamiana leaves revealed a wide diversity of targeted subcellular compartments, including organelles not so far shown to be targeted by oomycete effectors such as chloroplasts and processing bodies. More than half of the 30 core effectors were able to suppress pattern‐triggered immunity in N. benthamiana, and five of these induced hypersensitive responses (HR) in sunflower broad‐spectrum resistant lines. HR triggered by PhRXLRC01 co‐segregated with Pl22 resistance in F3 populations and both traits localized in 1.7 Mb on chromosome 13 of the sunflower genome. Pl22 resistance was physically mapped on the sunflower genome recently sequenced, unlike all the other downy mildew resistances published so far. PhRXLRC01 and Pl22 are proposed as an avirulence/resistance gene couple not previously described in sunflower. Core effector recognition is a successful strategy to accelerate broad‐spectrum resistance gene identification in complex crop genomes such as sunflower.     

Relationship between virulence and aggressiveness in Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew)

Relationship between virulence and aggressiveness was studied in seven Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew) pathotypes including five progeny pathotypes of races 300, 304, 314, 704 and 714 arising from two parental pathotypes of races 100 and 710. Aggressiveness criteria including percentage infection, latent period, sporulation density and reduction of hypocotyl length were analysed in one sunflower inbred line showing a high level of quantitative resistance. There were significant differences between P. halstedii pathotypes for all aggressiveness criteria. Pathogenicity of progeny pathotypes as compared with parental ones (relationship between virulence and aggressiveness) seems to be positive, negative or uncorrelated. Hypothesis explaining these cases are discussed.     

Twelve polymorphic expressed sequence tags‐derived markers for Plasmopara halstedii,the causal agent of sunflower downy mildew

Twelve expressed sequence tags‐derived markers were isolated from Plasmopara halstedii (Oomycetes), the causal agent of sunflower downy mildew. A total of 25 single nucleotide polymorphisms and five indels were detected by single‐strand conformation polymorphism analysis and developed for high‐throughput genotyping of 32 isolates. There was a high level of genetic diversity (H_E = 0.484). Observed heterozygosity ranged from 0 to 0.143 indicating that P. halstedii is probably a selfing species. These markers were also useful in detecting significant genetic variations among French populations (F_ST = 0.193) and between French and Russian populations (F_ST = 0.23). Cross‐amplification tests on three closely related species indicated that no loci amplified in other Oomycete species.     

Variation in two components of pathogenicity and its relationship with genetic diversity in Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew)

The specificity of the two components of pathogenicity: virulence and aggressiveness and its relationship with genetic variability were analysed in a local Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew) population. Pathogenic and molecular analyses were carried out on seven isolates including five progeny isolates of five races arising from two parental races 100 and 710. P. halstedii isolates showed significant differences for all aggressiveness criteria and important genetic variations. Three cases of relationship between virulence and aggressiveness for progeny isolates as compared with parental ones were found as positive, negative or uncorrelated. For solving the specificity of these cases, relationship between the two components of pathogenicity among the isolates of three different races localised in the same genetic clade was positive. The hypothesis explaining these cases is discussed.     

Pathogenicity and its alternation with both morphological and genetic variation in Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew)

Morphological, pathogenic and genetic variation was studied in seven Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew) isolates of several races using five singlezoosporangium isolates per pathogen isolate. Aggressiveness criteria were analysed in one sunflower inbred line showing a high level of quantitative resistance. Genetic relationships were detected between the single zoosporangium isolates using 12 expressed sequence tags (EST)-derived markers. Analysis of the five single zoosporangium isolates for P. halstedii isolates showed variability within pathogen isolates for all aggressiveness criteria, but not for all pathogen isolates. Isolates of races 100 and 3xx were characterised with shorter latent period and higher sporulation density than the isolate of races 7xx. All pathogen isolates showed high percentage infection values and caused a large reduction in seedling size except for one isolate involved in dwarfing. There was no relation between zoosporangia form or size and race virulence profiles or aggressiveness criteria. There was no intra-genetic variation for all pathogen isolates, but it was observed an important genetic variation between single zoosporangium isolates of all races. No correlation was detected between pathogenicity traits and EST genotypes.     

Pathogenic groups identified among Plasmopara halstedii isolates belonging to several races

Pathogenic groups among 50 Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew) isolates belonging to races 100, 300, 304, 314, 710, 704 and 714 were identified. Based on the reaction for the P. halstedii isolates to sunflower differential line D3, these isolates were divided into two groups as more virulent isolates of the 7xx races and the less virulent isolates of 100 and 3xx races. Index of aggressiveness (sporulation density/latent period) was calculated for each isolate and the presence of significant differences between isolates of 100 and 3xx races (more aggressive) and isolates of 7xx races (less aggressive) was revealed. Consequently, it seems that P. halstedii isolates may be divided into two pathogenic groups as more virulent and less aggressive isolates of 7xx races and less virulent and more aggressive isolates of the 100 and 3xx races.     

Development of PCR markers for the<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Pl5/Pl8</Emphasis> locus for resistance to<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Plasmopara halstedii</Emphasis> in sunflower,<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Helianthus annuus</Emphasis> L. from complete CC-NBS-LRR sequences

Sunflower downy mildew, caused by Plasmopara halstedii, is one of the major diseases of this crop. Development of elite sunflower lines resistant to different races of this oomycete seems to be the most efficient method to limit downy mildew damage. At least two different gene clusters conferring resistance to different races of P. halstedii have been described. In this work we report the cloning and mapping of two full-length resistance gene analogs (RGA) belonging to the CC-NBC-LRR class of plant resistance genes. The two sequences were then used to develop 14 sequence tagged sites (STS) within the Pl5/Pl8 locus conferring resistance to a wide range of P. halstedii races. These STSs will be useful in marker-assisted selection programs.Communicated by C. Möllers     

Can percentage infection and dwarfing be used to differentiate aggressiveness in Plasmopara halstedii?

Aggressiveness was studied in seven Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew) parental isolates of races 100, 300, 304, 314, 704, 710 and 714 using five single zoosporangium isolates per parental isolate. Aggressiveness criteria, including percentage infection and dwarfing (reduction of hypocotyl length), were analysed in one sunflower inbred line showing a high level of quantitative resistance. Analysis of five single zoosporangium isolates of each parental isolate showed variability within parental isolate for the two aggressiveness criteria, but not for all parental isolates for percentage infection and vice versa for the reduction of hypocotyl length. Percentage infection showed high values irrespective of the parental isolate used. However, all the parental isolates caused a large reduction in seedling size except for the isolate of race 314. Although percentage infection and reduction of hypocotyl length could be used to differentiate aggressiveness in P. halstedii, it seems that these criteria played a limited role to define P. halstedii isolates according to their aggressiveness.     

Relationship between aggressiveness and zoosporangia viability in Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew)

Relationship between aggressiveness and zoosporangia viability was studied in seven Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew) isolates of races 100, 300, 304, 314, 710, 704 and 714. Aggressiveness criteria including latent period and sporulation density were analysed on sunflower inbred line showing a high level of quantitative resistance. There were significant differences between pathogen isolates for the two aggressiveness criteria. Viability analyses were performed on oval and spheric zoosporangia. The number of zoospores released from oval zoosporangia was significantly higher than those released from spheric ones. The oval zoosporangia for more aggressive isolates of races 100 and 3xx produced more zoospores than the oval ones for less aggressive isolates of races 7xx. There was a significant correlation between aggressiveness criteria and the number of zoospores released from oval zoosporangia and vice versa for zoospores released from spheric ones. It is concluded that the relationship between aggressiveness and oval zoosporangia viability may be established in P. halstedii.     

Virulence cost in Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew)

Virulence cost (trade-off between virulence and aggressiveness) was studied in seven Plasmopara halstedii (sunflower downy mildew) isolates of races 100, 300, 304, 314, 710, 704 and 714. The seven isolates were divided, according to their virulence and aggressiveness, into two main groups as more aggressive isolates of the 100 and 3xx races that do not overcome the sunflower differential host D3, and less aggressive isolates of 7xx races that can overcome D3. Consequently, the 100 and 3xx avirulent races had a virulence cost measured by differences in aggressiveness (from 58.3 to 78.2%) compared to 7xx virulent races carrying unnecessary virulence gene.     

Resurgence of cucurbit downy mildew in the United States: Insights from comparative genomic analysis of Pseudoperonospora cubensis

Pseudoperonospora cubensis, the causal agent of cucurbit downy mildew (CDM), is known to exhibit host specialization. The virulence of different isolates of the pathogen can be classified into pathotypes based on their compatibility with a differential set composed of specific cucurbit host types. However, the genetic basis of host specialization within P. cubensis is not yet known. Total genomic DNA extracted from nine isolates of P. cubensis collected from 2008 to 2013 from diverse cucurbit host types (Cucumis sativus, C. melo var. reticulatus, Cucurbita maxima, C. moschata, C. pepo, and Citrullus lanatus) in the United States were subjected to whole‐genome sequencing. Comparative analysis of these nine genomes confirmed the presence of two distinct evolutionary lineages (lineages I and II) of P. cubensis. Many fixed polymorphisms separated lineage I comprising isolates from Cucurbita pepo, C. moschata, and Citrullus lanatus from lineage II comprising isolates from Cucumis spp. and Cucurbita maxima. Phenotypic characterization showed that lineage II isolates were of the A1 mating type and belonged to pathotypes 1 and 3 that were not known to be present in the United States prior to the resurgence of CDM in 2004. The association of lineage II isolates with the new pathotypes and a lack of genetic diversity among these isolates suggest that lineage II of P. cubensis is associated with the resurgence of CDM on cucumber in the United States.     

New Races of Sunflower Downy Mildew (Plasmopara Halstedii) in Germany

Plasmopara halstedii, the causal agent of downy mildew of cultivated sunflower (Helianthus annuus), was documented in Germany for the first time in commercial fields. The pathogen was first observed in the Württemberg area, where races 1 and 4 were identified using a set of differential lines. Later, commericial fields near Baden were found to be infected by race 5, which is the first occurrence of that race outside of North America. Withthe discovery of race 5, there are now eight races of the sunflower downy mildew fungus that have been found in Europe. The sunflower cultivars most frequently grown in Germany were investigated for resistance to race 1, 4 and 5; while all were resistant to race 1, none were resistant to either race, 4 or 5.     

New Races of Sunflower Downy Mildew (Plasmopara Halstedii) in Germany

Plasmopara halstedii, the causal agent of downy mildew of cultivated sunflower (Helianthus annuus), was documented in Germany for the first time in commercial fields. The pathogen was first observed in the Württemberg area, where races 1 and 4 were identified using a set of differential lines. Later, commercial fields near Baden were found to be infected by race 5, which is the first occurrence of that race outside of North America. With the discovery of race 5, there are now eight races of the sunflower downy mildew fungus that have been found in Europe. The sunflower cultivars most frequently grown in Germany were investigated for resistance to race 1, 4 and 5; while all were resistant to race 1, none were resistant to either race 4 or 5.     

Molecular analysis of a major locus for resistance to downy mildew in sunflower with specific PCR-based markers

Resistance of sunflower to the obligate parasite Plasmopara halstedii is conferred by specific dominant genes, denoted Pl. The Pl6 locus confers resistance to all races of P. halstedii except one, and must contain at least 11 tightly linked genes each giving resistance to different downy mildew races. Specific primers were designed and used to amplify 13 markers covering a genetic distance of about 3 cM centred on the Pl6 locus. Cloning and sequence analysis of these 13 markers indicate that Pl6 contains conserved genes belonging to the TIR-NBS-LRR class of plant resistance genes. Received: 9 April 2001 / Accepted: 10 August 2001     

RFLP and RAPD mapping of the sunflower Pl1 locus for resistance to Plasmopara halstedii race 1

The Pl1 locus in sunflower, Helianthus annuus L., conferring resistance to downy mildew, Plasmopara halstedii, race 1 has been located in linkage group 1 of the consensus RFLP map of the cultivated sunflower. Bulked segregant analyses were used on 135 plants of an F₂ progeny from a cross between a downy mildew susceptible line, GH, and RHA266, a line carrying Pl1. Two RFLP markers and one RAPD marker linked to the Pl1 locus have been identified. The RFLP markers are located at 5.6 cM and 7.1 cM on either side of Pl1. The RAPD marker is situated at 43.7 cM from Pl1. The significance and applications of these markers in sunflower breeding are discussed.     

Induction of resistance against downy mildew on sunflower by rhizobacteria

Abstract

Induction of resistance to downy mildew caused by Plasmopara halstedii in sunflower was studied after treatment with PGPR (plant growth promoting rhizobacteria) strain INR7 (Bacillus spp). Treatment of sunflower seeds with 1×10⁸cfu/ml of PGPR strain INR7 resulted in decreased disease severity and offered 51 and 54% protection under green house and field conditions, respectively. The induction of resistance to P. halstedii by PGPR strain INR7 was accompanied by the accumulation of various host defense-related enzymes in susceptible sunflower seedlings. Enhanced activation of catalase (CAT), phenylalanine ammonia-lyase (PAL), peroxidase (POX), polyphenol oxidase (PPO) and chitinase (CHI) was evident at 6, 9, 12, 12 and 12h post inoculation, respectively, in sunflower seedlings raised from seeds treated with PGPR strain INR7. This enhanced and early activation of defense-related responses in the susceptible cultivar after treatment with PGPR strain INR7 was comparable to that in the resistant cultivar. The results indicate that PGPR strain INR7 induced resistance against P. halstedii in sunflower is mediated through enhanced expression of defense mechanism.     

Hypothesis of durable resistance in sunflower plants against Plasmopara halstedii

Sunflower downy mildew is considered as one of the most serious diseases. Therefore, vertical resistance has been used intensively, but with the appearance of many races since 2000, research on more durable resistance has been undertaken. In this review, we present new results concerning the evolution of pathogenicity under artificial conditions in order to underline a mixture model assuming durable resistance against Plasmopara halstedii. Examples of host–parasite interactions including the influence of plant mixture against pathogens and durable resistance are presented to integrate in our couple P. halstedii/Helianthus annuus.