Membrane fusion induced by vesicular stomatitis virus depends on histidine protonation

Entry of enveloped animal viruses into their host cells always depends on a step of membrane fusion triggered by conformational changes in viral envelope glycoproteins. Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) infection is mediated by virus spike glycoprotein G, which induces membrane fusion at the acidic environment of the endosomal compartment. VSV-induced membrane fusion occurs at a very narrow pH range, between 6.2 and 5.8, suggesting that His protonation is required for this process. To investigate the role of His in VSV fusion, we chemically modified these residues using diethylpyrocarbonate (DEPC). We found that DEPC treatment inhibited membrane fusion mediated by VSV in a concentration-dependent manner and that the complete inhibition of fusion was fully reversed by incubation of modified virus with hydroxylamine. Fluorescence measurements showed that VSV modification with DEPC abolished pH-induced conformational changes in G protein, suggesting that His protonation drives G protein interaction with the target membrane at acidic pH. Mass spectrometry analysis of tryptic fragments of modified G protein allowed the identification of the putative active His residues. Using synthetic peptides, we showed that the modification of His-148 and His-149 by DEPC, as well as the substitution of these residues by Ala, completely inhibited peptide-induced fusion, suggesting the direct participation of these His in VSV fusion.     

Molecular architecture of the bipartite fusion loops of vesicular stomatitis virus glycoprotein G, a class III viral fusion protein

The glycoprotein of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV G) mediates fusion of the viral envelope with the host cell, with the conformational changes that mediate VSV G fusion activation occurring in a reversible, low pH-dependent manner. Based on its novel structure, VSV G has been classified as class III viral fusion protein, having a predicted bipartite fusion domain comprising residues Trp-72, Tyr-73, Tyr-116, and Ala-117 that interacts with the host cell membrane to initiate the fusion reaction. Here, we carried out a systematic mutagenesis study of the predicted VSV G fusion loops, to investigate the functional role of the fusion domain. Using assays of low pH-induced cell-cell fusion and infection studies of mutant VSV G incorporated into viral particles, we show a fundamental role for the bipartite fusion domain. We show that Trp-72 is a critical residue for VSV G-mediated membrane fusion. Trp-72 could only tolerate mutation to a phenylalanine residue, which allowed only limited fusion. Tyr-73 and Tyr-116 could be mutated to other aromatic residues without major effect but could not tolerate any other substitution. Ala-117 was a less critical residue, with only charged residues unable to allow fusion activation. These data represent a functional analysis of predicted bipartite fusion loops of VSV G, a founder member of the class III family of viral fusion proteins.     

Vesicular stomatitis virus G protein acquires pH-independent fusion activity during transport in a polarized endometrial cell line

Entry of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), the prototype member of the rhabdovirus family, occurs by receptor-mediated endocytosis. Subsequently, during traversal through the endosomal compartments, the VSV G protein acquires a low-pH-induced fusion-competent form, allowing for fusion of the viral membrane with endosomal and lysosomal membranes. This fusion event releases genomic RNA into the cytoplasm of the cell. Here we provide evidence that the VSV G protein acquires a fusion-competent form during exocytosis in a polarized endometrial cell line, HEC-1A. VSV infection of HEC-1A cells results in high viral yields and giant cell formation. Syncytium formation is blocked in a concentration-dependent manner by treatment with the lysosomotropic weak base ammonium chloride, which raises intravesicular pH. Virus release is somewhat delayed by treatment with ammonium chloride, but virus yields gradually reach those of control cells. In addition, inhibition of vacuolar H(+)-ATPases by treatment with bafilomycin A1 also inhibited cell to cell fusion without altering virus yields. Virions released from infected HEC cells were themselves not fusion competent, since viral entry required an active H(+)-ATPase and a low-pH-induced conformational change in the viral G protein. Thus, the conformation change leading to fusion competence during exocytotic transport is reversible and reverts during or after release of the virion from the infected cell.     

Activation of vesicular stomatitis virus fusion with cells by pretreatment at low pH

Fusion of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) with Vero cells was measured after exposure of the virus to low pH under a variety of experimental conditions. The method of relief of fluorescence self-quenching of the probe octadecylrhodamine was used to monitor fusion. Incubation of the virus at pH 5.5 prior to binding to cells led to significant enhancement of fusion at the plasma membrane, whereas fusion via the endocytic pathway was inhibited. Fusion of pH 5.5-pretreated VSV showed a similar pH threshold for fusion as nontreated virus, and it was blocked by antibody to VSV G protein. Activation of VSV by pretreatment at low pH was only slightly dependent on temperature. In contrast, when VSV was first bound to target cells and subsequently exposed at 4 degrees C to the low pH, activation of the fusion process did not occur. The pH 5.5-mediated activation of VSV could be reversed by returning the pH to neutral in the absence of target membranes. The low pH pretreatment also led to aggregation of virus; large aggregates could be pelleted by low speed centrifugation and only the effects of the supernatant, which consist of single virions and/or microaggregates, were considered. The data were analyzed in the framework of an allosteric model according to which viral spike glycoproteins undergo a pH-dependent conformational transition to an active (fusion-competent) state. Based on that analysis we conclude that the conformational transition to the active state is rate-limiting for fusion and that the viral spike glycoproteins are fusion-competent only in their protonated form.     

Role of viral envelope sialic acid in membrane fusion mediated by the vesicular stomatitis virus envelope glycoprotein.

Fusion of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) with cells and liposomes before and after treatment with neuraminidase was studied using the R18 dequenching assay. Desialylation of VSV significantly enhanced the extent of fusion with Vero cells but affected neither the pH dependence nor the binding of VSV to Vero cells. The enhanced fusion of asialo-VSV was observed both at the plasma membrane as well as via the endocytic pathway. Both VSV and asialo-VSV fused with liposomes made of neutral phospholipid, but only asialo-VSV fused with liposomes containing a 1:1 mixture of neutral and negatively charged phospholipid. To examine factors which contribute to the extent of fusion, we analyzed the various activation and inactivation reactions that take place as a result of low-pH triggering of VSV prebound to the target membrane. Lag times for the onset of fusion were similar for VSV and asialo-VSV, indicating that desialylation did not affect the activation reactions. However, exposure of VSV bound to target membranes at pH 6.5 for 400 s led to considerable inactivation, whereas little inactivation was seen after desialylation of VSV. These results are analyzed in terms of a model which allows us to determine which components of the overall fusion process are dominated by viral envelope sialic acid.     

Cell surface expression of fusogenic vesicular stomatitis virus G protein from cloned cDNA.

Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) enters the host cell by the receptor-mediated endocytotic pathway. This brings the virus particle into acidic vesicles inside the cell where infection occurs through a fusion event between the viral and the host vesicle membrane. In this work we have shown that the VSV glycoprotein (G) carries the fusion activity of this virus. The G protein was expressed on the surface of baby hamster kidney 21 cells from cloned cDNA which had been engineered into an expression vector and introduced into cell nuclei with the aid of a glass microneedle. A short (60 s) treatment with acid (pH less than or equal to 6.0) medium induced fusion of cells having G protein on their surface. For efficient G protein expression and cell-cell fusion we had to trim the 5' end of the G cDNA and to use as promoter the long terminal repeat of the mouse Moloney sarcoma virus.     

Propagation of viruses on micropatterned host cells

We have developed a technique to characterize the in vitro propagation of viruses. Microcontact printing was used to generate linear arrays of alkanethiols on gold surfaces, which served as substrates for the patterned culture of baby hamster kidney (BHK-21) cells. Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) was added to unpatterned cell reservoirs adjacent to the patterned cells and incubated, setting in motion a continuously advancing viral infection into the patterned cells. At different incubation times, multiple arrays were chemically fixed to stop the viral propagation. Viral propagation distances into the patterned cells were determined by indirect immunofluorescent labeling and visualization of the VSV surface glycoprotein (G). The infection spread at approximately 50 microm/h in the 140-microm lines. Moreover, different temporal stages of the infection process were simultaneously visualized along individual lines. These stages included initiation of infection, based on G protein expression; cell-cell fusion, based on virus-induced clustering of cell nuclei; and cytoskeletal degradation, based on localized release of cells from the surface. This work sets a foundation for parallel, high-throughput characterization of viral and cellular processes.     

Morphological and biochemical characterization of viral particles produced by the tsO45 mutant of vesicular stomatitis virus at restrictive temperature.

The growth at restrictive temperature of tsO45, a group V (glycoprotein) conditional lethal mutant of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), was demonstrated to result in the production of large numbers of noninfectious viral particles. The infectivity of these tsO45 particles could be enhanced by procedures known to promote membrane fusion. Morphologically and biochemically these particles differed from wild-type VSV by their lack of viral glycoprotein. The other structural proteins of VSV were present and indistinguishable by size and relative proportion from those of virus grown at the permissive temperature. Examination of glycoprotein maturation at the restrictive temperature (39.5 degrees C) in tsO45-infected cells demonstrated the synthesis of normal viral glycoprotein but failed to demonstrate the presence of this glycoprotein in either the cell membrane or the envelope of free virions. The further absence of soluble viral glycoprotein from the supernatants of such cells strongly suggests that viral glycoprotein may not be necessary for the successful budding of VSV.     

Mechanisms for generating cell membrane antigens that are recognized by cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Studies with many viruses have revealed that viral specific protein synthesis is an obligatory step in generating antigens on target cells for antiviral cytotoxic T lymphocytes. This has been most clearly demonstrated with DI particles, virions that are structurally complete but lack infectious RNA. Adsorption of such particles onto target cell membranes does not render these cells susceptible to lytic attack by antiviral effector cells, unless some viral protein synthesis transpires. However, some viruses, such as Sendai virus, circumvent the requirement for viral protein synthesis via fusion of the viral envelope with the target cell membrane, a process mediated by a specialized fusion protein. Once inserted into the lipid bilayer, it is likely that viral components and self H-2 noncovalently associate so that the complex can be recognized by antiviral cytotoxic T cells. This idea is supported by the demonstration that viral proteins and H-2 containing membrane proteins, incorporated into reconstituted membrane vesicles or liposomes are recognized by cytotoxic T cells. These data further show that native rather than altered viral and H-2 molecules are the moieties recognized. Associations between antigen and H-2 have been detected by a variety of techniques and in some cases are not random but selective; that is, viral antigens perferentially associate with some H-2 alleles and not others. In summary, these findings indicate that although viral antigens are present in the mature virions, these components are not recognized by antiviral killer cells until integrated into the plasma membrane. This may be achieved either through direct fusion of the viral envelope with the target cell or following viral protein synthesis and insertion of viral antigens into the plasma membrane.     

A recombinant vesicular stomatitis virus bearing a lethal mutation in the glycoprotein gene uncovers a second site suppressor that restores fusion

Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), a prototype of the Rhabdoviridae family, contains a single surface glycoprotein (G) that is responsible for attachment to cells and mediates membrane fusion. Working with the Indiana serotype of VSV, we employed a reverse genetic approach to produce fully authentic recombinant viral particles bearing lethal mutations in the G gene. By altering the hydrophobicity of the two fusion loops within G, we produced a panel of mutants, W72A, Y73A, Y116A, and A117F, that were nonfusogenic. Propagation of viruses bearing those lethal mutations in G completely depended on complementation by expression of the glycoprotein from the heterologous New Jersey serotype of VSV. The nonfusogenic G proteins oligomerize and are transported normally to the cell surface but fail to mediate acid pH-triggered membrane fusion. The nonfusogenic G proteins also interfered with the ability of wild-type G to mediate fusion, either by formation of mixed trimers or by inhibition of trimer function during fusion. Passage of one recombinant virus, A117F, identified a second site suppressor of the fusion block, E76K. When analyzed in the absence of the A117F substitution, E76K rendered G more sensitive to acid pH-triggered fusion, suggesting that this compensatory mutation is destabilizing. Our work provides a set of authentic recombinant VSV particles bearing lethal mutations in G, confirms that the hydrophobic fusion loops of VSV G protein are critical for membrane fusion, and underscores the importance of the sequence elements surrounding the hydrophobic tips of the fusion loops in driving fusion. This study has implications for understanding dominant targets for inhibition of G-mediated fusion. Moreover, the recombinant viral particles generated here will likely be useful in dissecting the mechanism of G-catalyzed fusion as well as study steps of viral assembly.     

Large-population passages of vesicular stomatitis virus in interferon-treated cells select variants of only limited resistance.

Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) populations were repeatedly passaged in L-929 cells treated with alpha interferon (IFN-alpha) at levels of 25 U/ml. This IFN-alpha concentration induced a 99.9% inhibition of viral yield in standard infections. Analysis of viral fitness (overall replicative ability measured in direct competition with a reference wild-type VSV) after 21 passages in IFN-treated cells showed only a limited increase or no increase in fitness, compared with the greater increase upon parallel passage in cells not treated with IFN-alpha. However, this limited increase in fitness was more pronounced when competition assays were carried out with IFN-alpha-treated cells, suggesting the selection of VSV populations with a low level of resistance to IFN-alpha. Thus, despite the extensively documented capacity of VSV to adapt to changing environments, the antiviral state induced by IFN-alpha imposes adaptive constraints on VSV which are not readily overcome.     

The entry into host cells of Sindbis virus, vesicular stomatitis virus and Sendai virus.

We have compared the mechanisms of entry into host cells of three enveloped viruses: Sendai virus, vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) and Sindbis virus. Virus entry by membrane fusion should antigenically modify the surface of a newly infected cell in such a way that it will be killed by anti-viral antibody and complement. On the other hand, virus entry by a mechanism involving uptake by the cell of the whole virion should not make cells sensitive to antibody and complement. As expected, cells newly infected with Sendai virus were readily and completely lysed by anti-Sendai antibody and complement. In marked contrast, however, cells newly infected with either Sindbis virus or VSV were killed by anti-viral antibody and complement only when infected at an extremely high multiplicity of infection, in excess of 1000 plaque-forming units per cell. We favor the following explanation for these results with Sindbis virus and VSV: a very large majority of the Sindbis and VSV virions entered the infected cells by some means other than membrane fusion, presumably engulfment of the whole particle. Efficient entry by way of membrane fusion may therefore not be a general characteristic of enveloped viruses.     

Characterization of the Bas-Congo Virus Glycoprotein and Its Function in Pseudotyped Viruses

Bas-Congo virus (BASV) is a novel rhabdovirus recently identified from a patient with acute hemorrhagic fever in the Bas-Congo province of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). Here we show that the BASV glycoprotein (BASV-G) can be successfully used to pseudotype glycoprotein-deficient vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), allowing studies of BASV-G-driven membrane fusion and viral entry into target cells without replication-competent virus. BASV-G displayed broad tissue and species tropism in vitro, and BASV-G-mediated membrane fusion was pH dependent. The conformational changes induced in BASV-G by acidification were fully reversible and did not lead to inactivation of the viral fusion protein. Our data combined with comparative sequence similarity analyses suggest that BASV-G shares structural and functional features with other rhabdovirus glycoproteins and falls into the group of class III viral fusion proteins. However, activation of BASV-G-driven fusion required a lower pH and higher temperatures than did VSV-G-mediated fusion. Moreover, in contrast to VSV-G, mature BASV-G in VSV pseudotypes consists of a mixture of high-mannose and complex glycans that enables it to bind to certain C-type lectins, thereby enhancing its attachment to target cells. Taken together, the results presented in this study will facilitate future investigations of BASV-G-mediated cell entry and its inhibition in the absence of an infectious cell culture assay for BASV and at lower biosafety levels. Moreover, serology testing based on BASV-G pseudotype neutralization can be used to uncover the prevalence and importance of BASV as a potential novel human pathogen in the DRC and throughout Central Africa.     

Reconstitution and fusogenic properties of Sendai virus envelopes

Sendai virus membranes were reconstituted by detergent dialysis, using the non-ionic detergents Triton X-100 and octyl glucoside. Membrane reassembly was determined by measuring the surface-density-dependent efficiency of resonance energy transfer between two fluorescent phospholipid analogues, which were co-reconstituted with the viral envelopes. The functional incorporation of the viral proteins was established by monitoring the ability of the reconstitution products to fuse with erythrocyte membranes, utilizing assays based on either resonance energy transfer or on relief of fluorescence selfquenching. The persistent adherence of residual Triton X-100 with the reconstituted membrane was revealed by an artificial detergent-effect on the resonance energy transfer efficiency and the occurrence of hemolysis of human erythrocytes under conditions where fusion does not occur. Properly reconstituted Sendai virus envelopes were obtained with octyl glucoside. The fusion activity of the viral envelopes was dependent on the initial concentration of octyl glucoside used to disrupt the virus and the rate of detergent removal. Rapid removal of detergent by dialysis against large volumes of dialysis buffer (ratio 1:850) or by gel filtration produced reconstituted membranes capable of inducing hemagglutination but significant fusion activity was not detected. By decreasing the volume ratio of dialysate versus dialysis buffer to 1:250 or 1:25, fusogenic viral envelopes were obtained. The initial fusion kinetics of the reconstituted viral membrane and the parent virus were different in that both the onset and the initial rate of fusion of the reconstituted membranes were faster, whereas the extents to which both particles eventually fused with the target membrane were similar. The differences in the initial fusion kinetics lead us to suggest that the details of the fusion mechanism between Sendai virus and the target membrane involve factors other than the mere presence of glycoproteins F and HN in the viral bilayer. Finally, the results also indicate that determination of the viral fusion activity in a direct manner, rather than by an indirect assay, such as hemolysis, is imperative for a proper evaluation of the functional properties retained upon viral reconstitution.     

Dissecting Virus Entry: Replication-Independent Analysis of Virus Binding,Internalization, and Penetration Using Minimal Complementation of β-Galactosidase

Studies of viral entry into host cells often rely on the detection of post-entry parameters, such as viral replication or the expression of a reporter gene, rather than on measuring entry per se. The lack of assays to easily detect the different steps of entry severely hampers the analysis of this key process in virus infection. Here we describe novel, highly adaptable viral entry assays making use of minimal complementation of the E. coli β-galactosidase in mammalian cells. Enzyme activity is reconstituted when a small intravirion peptide (α-peptide) is complementing the inactive mutant form ΔM15 of β-galactosidase. The method allows to dissect and to independently detect binding, internalization, and fusion of viruses during host cell entry. Here we use it to confirm and extend current knowledge on the entry process of two enveloped viruses: vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) and murine hepatitis coronavirus (MHV).     

Specific incorporation of host cell surface proteins into budding vesicular stomatitis virus particles

The specific incorporation of cell surface proteins into budding Vesicular Stomatitis Virus (VSV) particles was shown by two approaches. In the first, monolayer cultures of Vero or L cells were labeled by lactoperoxidase-catalyzed iodination and the cells were then infected with VSV. Approximately 2% of the cell surface ¹²⁵1 radioactivity was incorporated into particles which co-purify with normal, infectious virions by both velocity and equilibrium gradient centrifugation and which are precipitated by antiserum specific for the VSV glycoprotein. Control experiments establish that these ¹²⁵I-labeled particles are not cell debris or cellular material which aggregate with or adhere to VSV virions. VSV virions contain only a subset of the 10–15 normal ¹²⁵1-labeled cell surface polypeptides resolved by SDS gel electrophoresis; VSV grown in L cells and Vero cells incorporate different host polypeptides. In a second approach, Vero cells were labeled with ³⁵S-methione, then infected with VSV. Two predominant host polypeptides (molecular weights 110,000 and 20,000) were incorporated into VSV virions. These proteins, like VSV G protein, are exposed to the surface of the virion. They co-migrate with the major incorporated ¹²⁵1 host polypeptides. These host proteins are present in approximately 10 and 80 copies, respectively, per virion. Specific incorporation of host polypeptides into VSV virions does not require the presence of viral glycoprotein. This was shown by use of a ts VSV mutant defective in maturation of VSV G protein to the cell surface. Budding from infected cells are noninfectious particles which contain all the viral proteins except for G; these particles contain the same proportion and spectrum of ¹²⁵1-labeled host surface polypeptides as do wild-type virions. These results extend previous conclusions implicating the submembrane viral matrix protein, or the viral nucleocapsid, as being of primary importance in selecting cell surface proteins for incorporation into budding VSV virions.     

Pressure-induced fusogenic conformation of vesicular stomatitis virus glycoprotein

Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) is composed of a ribonucleoprotein core surrounded by a lipid envelope presenting an integral glycoprotein (G). The homotrimeric VSV G protein exhibits a membrane fusion activity that can be elicited by low pH. The fusion event is crucial to entry into the cell and disassembly followed by viral replication. To understand the conformational changes involved in this process, the effects of high hydrostatic pressure and urea on VSV particles and isolated G protein were investigated. With pressures up to 3.0 kbar VSV particles were converted into the fusogenic conformation, as measured by a fusion assay and by the binding of bis-ANS. The magnitude of the changes was similar to that promoted by lowering the pH. To further understand the relationship between stability and conversion into the fusion-active states, the stability of the G protein was tested against urea and high pressure. High urea produced a large red shift in the tryptophan fluorescence of G protein whereas pressure promoted a smaller change. Pressure induced equal fluorescence changes in isolated G protein and virions, indicating that virus inactivation induced by pressure is due to changes in the G protein. Fluorescence microscopy showed that pressurized particles were capable of fusing with the cell membrane without causing infection. We propose that pressure elicits a conformational change in the G protein, which maintains the fusion properties but suppresses the entry of the virus by endocytosis. Binding of bis-ANS indicates the presence of hydrophobic cavities in the G protein. Pressure also caused an increase in light scattering of VSV G protein, reinforcing the hypothesis that high pressure elicits the fusogenic activity of VSV G protein. This "fusion-intermediate state" induced by pressure has minor changes in secondary structure and is likely the cause of nonproductive infections.     

Vesicular stomatitis virus mRNA and inhibition of translation of cellular mRNA--is there a P function in vesicular stomatitis virus?

Infection of animal cells by vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) results in inhibition of translation of cellular mRNA. We showed previously that, in BHK cells infected by the Glasgow isolate of VSV Indiana, this is due to competition during the initiation step of protein synthesis of viral and cellular mRNA for a constant, limiting number of ribosomes. We show here that infection of the same cells with the San Juan isolate of VSV resulted in a more rapid shutoff of host protein synthesis and that this was paralleled by a more rapid accumulation of viral mRNA. Extending our conclusion that shutoff is due to mRNA competition, we show further that the average size of polysomes translating viral and cellular mRNA was threefold smaller in cells infected by VSV San Juan than by VSV Glasgow, which, in turn, was about one-half that of uninfected cells. In all cases, cellular and viral mRNA's which encoded the same-sized polypeptides were found on the same-sized polysomes, a result indicating that the efficiency of translation of both types of mRNA's is about the same in the infected cell. Also, there was no preferential sequestration of viral or cellular mRNA's in ribonucleoprotein particles. Additional correlations between the levels of viral mRNA's and the inhibition of protein synthesis came from studies of three other wild-type VSV strains and also from studies with Vero and L cells. In particular, the rate of shutoff of L-cell protein synthesis after infection by any VSV isolate was slower than that in BHK cells, and this was correlated with a slower rate of accumulation of viral mRNA. VSV temperature-sensitive mutants which synthesized, at the nonper-missive temperature, no VSV mRNA failed to inhibit synthesis of cellular proteins. Stanners and co-workers (C. P. Stanners, A. M. Francoeur, and T. Lam, Cell 11:273-281, 1977) claimed that VSV mutant R1 inhibited synthesis of L cell protein synthesis less rapidly than did its parent wild-type strain HR. They concluded that this effect was due to a mutation in an unspecified VSV protein, “P.” We found, in both L and BHK cells, that R1 infection resulted in a slightly slower inhibition of cellular mRNA translation than did HR infection and that this was correlated with a slightly reduced accumulation of VSV mRNA. The level of VSV mRNA, rather than any specific VSV protein, appeared to be the key factor in determining the rate of shutoff of host protein synthesis.