pH-sensitive membrane peptides (pHLIPs) as a novel class of delivery agents

Abstract Here we review a novel class of delivery vehicles based on pH-sensitive, moderately polar membrane peptides, which we call pH (Low) Insertion Peptides (pHLIPs), that target cells located in the acidic environment found in many diseased tissues, including tumours. Acidity targeting by pHLIPs is achieved as a result of helix formation and transmembrane insertion. In contrast to the earlier technologies based on cell-penetrating peptides, pHLIPs act as monomeric membrane-inserting peptides that translocate one terminus across a membrane into the cytoplasm, while the other terminus remains in the extracellular space, locating the peptide in the membrane lipid bilayer. Therefore pHLIP has a dual delivery capability: it can tether cargo molecules or nanoparticles to the surfaces of cells in diseased tissues and/or it can move a cell-impermeable cargo molecule across the membrane into the cytoplasm. The source of energy for moving polar molecules attached to pHLIP through the hydrophobic layer of a membrane bilayer is the membrane-associated folding of the polypeptide. A drop in pH leads to the protonation of negatively charged residues (Asp or Glu), which enhances peptide hydrophobicity, increasing the affinity of the peptide for the lipid bilayer and triggering peptide folding and subsequent membrane insertion. The process is accompanied by the release of energy that can be utilized to move cell-impermeable cargo across a membrane. That the mechanism is now understood, and that targeting of tumours in mice has been shown, suggest a number of future applications of the pHLIP technology in the diagnosis and treatment of disease.     

pH-sensitive membrane peptides (pHLIPs) as a novel class of delivery agents

Abstract

Here we review a novel class of delivery vehicles based on pH-sensitive, moderately polar membrane peptides, which we call pH (Low) Insertion Peptides (pHLIPs), that target cells located in the acidic environment found in many diseased tissues, including tumours. Acidity targeting by pHLIPs is achieved as a result of helix formation and transmembrane insertion. In contrast to the earlier technologies based on cell-penetrating peptides, pHLIPs act as monomeric membrane-inserting peptides that translocate one terminus across a membrane into the cytoplasm, while the other terminus remains in the extracellular space, locating the peptide in the membrane lipid bilayer. Therefore pHLIP has a dual delivery capability: it can tether cargo molecules or nanoparticles to the surfaces of cells in diseased tissues and/or it can move a cell-impermeable cargo molecule across the membrane into the cytoplasm. The source of energy for moving polar molecules attached to pHLIP through the hydrophobic layer of a membrane bilayer is the membrane-associated folding of the polypeptide. A drop in pH leads to the protonation of negatively charged residues (Asp or Glu), which enhances peptide hydrophobicity, increasing the affinity of the peptide for the lipid bilayer and triggering peptide folding and subsequent membrane insertion. The process is accompanied by the release of energy that can be utilized to move cell-impermeable cargo across a membrane. That the mechanism is now understood, and that targeting of tumours in mice has been shown, suggest a number of future applications of the pHLIP technology in the diagnosis and treatment of disease.     

Modulation of the pHLIP transmembrane helix insertion pathway

The membrane-associated folding/unfolding of pH (low) insertion peptide (pHLIP) provides an opportunity to study how sequence variations influence the kinetics and pathway of peptide insertion into bilayers. Here, we present the results of steady-state and kinetics investigations of several pHLIP variants with different numbers of charged residues, with attached polar cargoes at the peptide's membrane-inserting end, and with three single-Trp variants placed at the beginning, middle, and end of the transmembrane helix. Each pHLIP variant exhibits a pH-dependent interaction with a lipid bilayer. Although the number of protonatable residues at the inserting end does not affect the ultimate formation of helical structure across a membrane, it correlates with the time for peptide insertion, the number of intermediate states on the folding pathway, and the rates of unfolding and exit. The presence of polar cargoes at the peptide's inserting end leads to the appearance of intermediate states on the insertion pathway. Cargo polarity correlates with a decrease of the insertion rate. We conclude that the existence of intermediate states on the folding and unfolding pathways is not mandatory and, in the simple case of a polypeptide with a noncharged and nonpolar inserting end, the folding and unfolding appears as an all-or-none transition. We propose a model for membrane-associated insertion/folding and exit/unfolding and discuss the importance of these observations for the design of new delivery agents for direct translocation of polar therapeutic and diagnostic cargo molecules across cellular membranes.     

Bilayer Thickness and Curvature Influence Binding and Insertion of a pHLIP Peptide

The physical properties of lipid bilayers, such as curvature and fluidity, can affect the interactions of polypeptides with membranes, influencing biological events. Additionally, given the growing interest in peptide-based therapeutics, understanding the influence of membrane properties on membrane-associated peptides has potential utility. pH low insertion peptides (pHLIPs) are a family of water-soluble peptides that can insert across cell membranes in a pH-dependent manner, enabling the use of pH to follow peptide-lipid interactions. Here we study pHLIP interactions with liposomes varying in size and composition, to determine the influence of several key membrane physical properties. We find that pHLIP binding to bilayer surfaces at neutral pH is governed by the ease of access to the membrane’s hydrophobic core, which can be facilitated by membrane curvature, thickness, and the cholesterol content of the membrane. After surface binding, if the pH is lowered, the kinetics of pHLIP folding to form a helix and subsequent insertion across the membrane depends on the fluidity and energetic dynamics of the membrane. We showed that pHLIP is capable of forming a helix across lipid bilayers of different thicknesses at low pH. However, the kinetics of the slow phase of insertion corresponding to the translocation of C-terminal end of the peptide across lipid bilayer, vary approximately twofold, and correlate with bilayer thickness and fluidity. Although these influences are not large, local curvature variations in membranes of different fluidity could selectively influence surface binding in mixed cell populations.     

A monomeric membrane peptide that lives in three worlds: in solution, attached to, and inserted across lipid bilayers

The membrane peptide pH (low) insertion peptide (pHLIP) lives in three worlds, being soluble in aqueous solution at pH 7.4, binding to the surface of lipid bilayers, and inserting as a transbilayer helix at low pH. With low pH driving the process, pHLIP can translocate cargo molecules attached to its C-terminus via a disulfide and release them in the cytoplasm of a cell. Here we examine a key aspect of the mechanism, showing that pHLIP is monomeric in each of its three major states: soluble in water near neutral pH (state I), bound to the surface of a membrane near neutral pH (state II), and inserted across the membrane as an alpha-helix at low pH (state III). The peptide does not induce fusion or membrane leakage. The unique properties of pHLIP made it attractive for the biophysical investigation of membrane protein folding in vitro and for the development of a novel class of delivery peptides for the transport of therapeutic and diagnostic agents to acidic tissue sites associated with various pathological processes in vivo.     

Bilayer interactions of pHLIP, a peptide that can deliver drugs and target tumors

The pH-dependent insertion of pHLIP across membranes is proving to be a useful property for targeting acidic tissues or tumors and delivering drugs attached to its C-terminus. It also serves as a model peptide for studies of protein insertion into membranes, so further elucidation of the insertion mechanism of pHLIP and its features is desirable. We examine how the peptide perturbs a model phosphatidylcholine membrane and how it associates with the lipid bilayer using an array of fluorescence techniques, including fluorescence anisotropy measurements of TMA-DPH anchored in bilayers, quenching of pHLIP fluorescence by brominated lipids and acrylamide, and measurements of energy transfer between aromatic residues of pHLIP and TMA-DPH. When pHLIP is bound to the surface of bilayers near neutral pH, the membrane integrity is preserved whereas the elastic properties of bilayers are changed as reported by an increase of membrane viscosity. When it is inserted, there is little perturbation of the lipids. The results also suggest that pHLIP can bind to the membrane surface in a shallow or a deep mode depending on the phase state of the lipids. Using parallax analysis, the change of the penetration depth of pHLIP was estimated to be 0.4 Å from the bilayer center and 2.8 Å from the membrane surface after the liquid-to-gel phase transition.     

Membrane interactions of two arginine-rich peptides with different cell internalization capacities

Cell penetrating peptides (CPPs) can cross cell membranes in a receptor independent manner and transport cargo molecules inside cells. These peptides can internalize through two independent routes: energy dependent endocytosis and energy independent translocation across the membrane, but the exact mechanisms are still unknown. The interaction of the CPP with different membrane components is certainly a preliminary key point that triggers internalization, such as the interaction with lipids to lead to the translocation process. In this study, we used two arginine-rich peptides, RW9 (RRWWRRWRR-NH(2)), which is a potent CPP, and RL9 (RRLLRRLRR-NH(2)) that, although binding tightly and accumulating on membranes, does not enter into cells. Using a set of experimental and theoretical techniques, we studied the binding, insertion and orientation of the peptides into different model membranes as well as the subsequent membrane reorganization. Herein we show that although the two peptides had rather similar behavior regarding lipid membrane interaction, subtle differences were found concerning the depth of peptide insertion, effect on the lipid chain ordering and kinetics of peptide insertion in the membrane, which altogether might explain their different cell internalization capacities. Molecular dynamics simulation studies show that some peptide molecules flipped their orientation over the course of the simulation such that the hydrophobic residues penetrated deeper in the lipid core region while Arg-residues maintained H-bonds with the lipid headgroups, serving as a molecular hinge in a conformation that appeared to correspond to the equilibrium one.     

Energetics of Transport through the Nuclear Pore Complex

Molecular transport across the nuclear envelope in eukaryotic cells is solely controlled by the nuclear pore complex (NPC). The NPC provides two types of nucleocytoplasmic transport: passive diffusion of small molecules and active chaperon-mediated translocation of large molecules. It has been shown that the interaction between intrinsically disordered proteins that line the central channel of the NPC and the transporting cargoes is the determining factor, but the exact mechanism of transport is yet unknown. Here, we use coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations to quantify the energy barrier that has to be overcome for molecules to pass through the NPC. We focus on two aspects of transport. First, the passive transport of model cargo molecules with different sizes is studied and the size selectivity feature of the NPC is investigated. Our results show that the transport probability of cargoes is significantly reduced when they are larger than ∼5 nm in diameter. Secondly, we show that incorporating hydrophobic binding spots on the surface of the cargo effectively decreases the energy barrier of the pore. Finally, a simple transport model is proposed which characterizes the energy barrier of the NPC as a function of diameter and hydrophobicity of the transporting particles.     

Tuning the insertion properties of pHLIP

The pH (low) insertion peptide (pHLIP) has exceptional characteristics: at neutral pH it is an unstructured monomer in solution or when bound to lipid bilayer surfaces, and it inserts across a lipid bilayer as a monomeric alpha-helix at acidic pH. The peptide targets acidic tissues in vivo and may be useful in cancer biology for delivery of imaging or therapeutic molecules to acidic tumors. To find ways to vary its useful properties, we have designed and analyzed pHLIP sequence variants. We find that each of the Asp residues in the transmembrane segment is critical for solubility and pH-dependent membrane insertion of the peptide. Changing both of the Asp residues in the transmembrane segment to Glu, inserting an additional Asp into the transmembrane segment, or replacing either of the Asp residues with Ala leads to aggregation and/or loss of pH-dependent membrane insertion of the peptide. However, variants with either of the Asp residues changed to Glu remained soluble in an aqueous environment and inserted into the membrane at acidic pH with a higher pK_app of membrane insertion.     

Lipid Headgroups Modulate Membrane Insertion of pHLIP Peptide

The pH low insertion peptide (pHLIP) is an important tool for drug delivery and visualization of acidic tissues produced by various maladies, including cancer, inflammation, and ischemia. Numerous studies indicate that pHLIP exists in three states: unfolded and soluble in water at neutral pH (State I), unfolded and bound to the surface of a phosphatidylcholine membrane at neutral pH (State II), and inserted across the membrane as an α-helix at low pH (State III). Here we report how changes in lipid composition modulate this insertion scheme. First, the presence of either anionic lipids, cholesterol, or phosphoethanolamine eliminates membrane binding at neutral pH (State II). Second, the apparent pK_a for the insertion transition (State I → State III) is increased with increasing content of anionic lipids, suggesting that electrostatic interactions in the interfacial region modulate protonation of acidic residues of pHLIP responsible for transbilayer insertion. These findings indicate a possibility for triggering protonation-coupled conformational switching in proteins at membrane interfaces through changes in lipid composition.     

Dissecting the membrane binding and insertion kinetics of a pHLIP peptide

When it is bound to lipid bilayers, the conformation and location of the membrane pH (low) insertion peptide (pHLIP) depend on pH. This unique feature allows us to explicitly measure the kinetics leading to different membrane-bound states of pHLIP using a model membrane and stopped-flow technique. Our results show that the membrane association kinetics of pHLIP are multiexponential and are consistent with a parallel membrane interaction mechanism. Interestingly, our results also show that the overall rate at which the membrane-inserted state is formed is almost identical to that of formation of the surface-bound state, while prebinding slows the rate of peptide insertion.     

pH-induced insertion of pHLIP into a lipid bilayer: In-situ SEIRAS characterization of a folding intermediate at neutral pH

The pH low insertion peptide (pHLIP) is a pH-sensitive cell penetrating peptide that transforms from an unstructured coil on the membrane surface at pH > 7, to a transmembrane (TM) α-helix at pH < 5. By exploiting this unique property, pHLIP attracts interest as a potential tool for drug delivery and visualisation of acidic tissues produced by various maladies such as cancer, inflammation, hypoxia etc. Even though the structures of initial and end states of pHLIP insertion have been widely accepted, the intermediate structures in between these two states are less clear. Here, we have applied in situ Surface-Enhanced Infrared Absorption spectroscopy to examine the pH-induced insertion and folding processes of pHLIP into a solid-supported lipid bilayer. We show that formation of partially helical structure already takes place at pH only slightly below 7.0, but with the helical axis parallel to the membrane surface. The peptide starts to reorientate its helix from horizontal to vertical direction, accompanied by the insertion into the TM region at pH < 6.2. Further insertion into the TM region of the peptide results in an increase of inherent α-helical structure and complete secondary structure formation at pH 5.3. Analysis of the changes of the carboxylate vibrational bands upon pH titration shows two distinctive groups of aspartates and glutamates with pK_a values of 4.5 and 6.3, respectively. Comparison to the amide bands of the peptide backbone suggests that the latter Asp/Glu groups are directly involved in the conformational changes of pHLIP in the respective intermediate states.     

Phosphatidylserine Asymmetry Promotes the Membrane Insertion of a Transmembrane Helix

The plasma membrane (PM) contains an asymmetric distribution of lipids between the inner and outer bilayer leaflets. A lipid of special interest in eukaryotic membranes is the negatively charged phosphatidylserine (PS). In healthy cells, PS is actively sequestered to the inner leaflet of the PM, but PS redistributes to the outer leaflet when the cell is damaged or at the onset of apoptosis. However, the influence of PS asymmetry on membrane protein structure and folding are poorly understood. The pH low insertion peptide (pHLIP) adsorbs to the membrane surface at a neutral pH, but it inserts into the membrane at an acidic pH. We have previously observed that in symmetric vesicles, PS affects the membrane insertion of pHLIP by lowering the pH midpoint of insertion. Here, we studied the effect of PS asymmetry on the membrane interaction of pHLIP. We developed a modified protocol to create asymmetric vesicles containing PS and employed Annexin V labeled with an Alexa Fluor 568 fluorophore as a new probe to quantify PS asymmetry. We observed that the membrane insertion of pHLIP was promoted by the asymmetric distribution of negatively charged PS, which causes a surface charge difference between bilayer leaflets. Our results indicate that lipid asymmetry can modulate the formation of an α-helix on the membrane. A corollary is that model studies using symmetric bilayers to mimic the PM may fail to capture important aspects of protein-membrane interactions.     

Heterogeneous Diffusion of a Membrane-Bound pHLIP Peptide

Lateral diffusion of cell membrane constituents is a prerequisite for many biological functions. However, the diffusivity (or mobility) of a membrane-bound species can be influenced by many factors. To provide a better understanding of how the conformation and location of a membrane-bound biological molecule affect its mobility, herein we study the diffusion properties of a pH low insertion peptide (pHLIP) in model membranes using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. It is found that when the pHLIP peptide is located on the membrane surface, its lateral diffusion is characterized by a distribution of diffusion times, the characteristic of which depends on the peptide/lipid ratio. Whereas, under conditions where pHLIP adopts a well-defined transmembrane α-helical conformation the peptide still exhibits heterogeneous diffusion, the distribution of diffusion times is found to be independent of the peptide/lipid ratio. Taken together, these results indicate that the mobility of a membrane-bound species is sensitive to its conformation and location and that diffusion measurement could provide useful information regarding the conformational distribution of membrane-bound peptides. Furthermore, the observation that the mobility of a membrane-bound species depends on its concentration may have important implications for diffusion-controlled reactions taking place in membranes.     

Overcoming the membrane barrier: Recruitment of γ-glutamyl transferase for intracellular release of metabolic cargo from peptide vectors

Semipermeable membranes of cells frequently pose an obstacle in metabolic engineering by limiting uptake of substrates, intermediates, or xenobiotics. Previous attempts to overcome this barrier relied on the promiscuous nature of peptide transport systems, but often suffered from low versatility or chemical instability. Here, we present an alternative strategy to transport cargo molecules across the inner membrane of Escherichia coli based on chemical synthesis of a stable cargo-peptide vector construct, transport through the peptide import system, and efficient intracellular release of the cargo by the promiscuous enzyme γ-glutamyl transferase (GGT). Retaining the otherwise periplasmic GGT in the cytoplasm was critical for the functionality of the system, as was fine-tuning its expression in order to minimize toxic effects associated to cytoplasmic GGT expression. Given the established protocols of peptide synthesis and the flexibility of peptide transport and GGT, the system is expected to be suitable for a broad range of cargoes.     

Roles of carboxyl groups in the transmembrane insertion of peptides

We have used pHLIP® [pH (low) insertion peptide] to study the roles of carboxyl groups in transmembrane (TM) peptide insertion. pHLIP binds to the surface of a lipid bilayer as a disordered peptide at neutral pH; when the pH is lowered, it inserts across the membrane to form a TM helix. Peptide insertion is reversed when the pH is raised above the characteristic pK_a (6.0). A key event that facilitates membrane insertion is the protonation of aspartic acid (Asp) and/or glutamic acid (Glu) residues, since their negatively charged side chains hinder membrane insertion at neutral pH. In order to gain mechanistic understanding, we studied the membrane insertion and exit of a series of pHLIP variants where the four Asp residues were sequentially mutated to nonacidic residues, including histidine (His). Our results show that the presence of His residues does not prevent the pH-dependent peptide membrane insertion at ∼ pH 4 driven by the protonation of carboxyl groups at the inserting end of the peptide. A further pH drop leads to the protonation of His residues in the TM part of the peptide, which induces peptide exit from the bilayer. We also find that the number of ionizable residues that undergo a change in protonation during membrane insertion correlates with the pH-dependent insertion into the lipid bilayer and exit from the lipid bilayer, and that cooperativity increases with their number. We expect that our understanding will be used to improve the targeting of acidic diseased tissue by pHLIP.     

Roles of key residues and lipid dynamics reveal pHLIP-membrane interactions at intermediate pH

The pH-low insertion peptide (pHLIP) and its analogs sense the microenvironmental pH variations in tumorous cells and serve as useful anticancer drug deliveries. The pHLIP binds peripherally to membranes and adopts random coil conformation at the physiological pH. The peptide switches from random coil to α-helical conformation and inserts unidirectionally into membrane bilayers when pH drops below a critical transition value that has been routinely determined by the Trp fluorescence spectroscopy. Recent high-resolution studies using solid-state NMR spectroscopy revealed the presence of thermodynamically stable intermediate states of membrane-associated pHLIP around the fluorescence-based transition pH-value. However, the molecular structural features and their mechanistic roles of these intermediate states in the pH-driven membrane insertion process of pHLIP remain largely unknown. This work utilizes solid-state NMR spectroscopy to explore 1) the mechanistic roles of key proline and arginine residues within the pHLIP sequence at intermediate pH-values, and 2) the changes in lipid dynamics at intermediate pH-values in multiple types of model bilayers with anionic phospholipid and/or cholesterol. Our results demonstrate several molecular structural and dynamics changes at around the transition pH-values, including the isomerization of proline-threonine backbone configuration, breaking of arginine-aspartic acid salt bridge and the formation of arginine-lipid interactions, and a universal decreasing of dynamics in lipid headgroups and alkyl chains. Overall, the outcomes provide important insights on the molecular interactions between pHLIP and membrane bilayers at intermediate pH-values and, therefore, prompt the understanding of pH-driven membrane insertion process of this anticancer drug-delivering peptide.     

Biophysical and biological studies of end-group-modified derivatives of Pep-1

Pep-1 is a tryptophane-rich cell-penetrating peptide (CPP) that has been previously proposed to bind protein cargoes by hydrophobic assembly and translocate them across cellular membranes. To date, however, the molecular mechanisms responsible for cargo binding and translocation have not been clearly identified. This study was conducted to gain insight into the interaction between Pep-1 with its cargo and the biological membrane to identify the thereby involved structural elements crucial for translocation. We studied three peptides differing in their N- and C-termini: (i) Pep-1, carrying an acetylated N-terminus and a C-terminal cysteamine elongation, (ii) AcPepWAmide, with an acetylated N-terminus and an amidated C-terminus, and (iii) PepW, with two free termini. Thioredoxin (TRX) and beta-galactosidase were used as protein cargoes. To study CPP-membrane interactions, we performed biophysical as well as biological assays. To mimic biological membranes, we used phospholipid liposomes in a dye leakage assay and surfactant micelles for high-resolution NMR studies. In addition, membrane integrity, cell viability, and translocation efficiency were analyzed in HeLa cells. An alpha-helical structure was found for all peptides in the hydrophobic N-terminal region encompassing residues 4-13, whereas the hydrophilic region remained unstructured in the presence of micelles. Our results show that the investigated peptides interacted with the micelles as well as with the protein cargo via their tryptophan-rich domain. All peptides displayed an orientation parallel to the micelle surface. The C-terminal cysteamine group formed an additional membrane anchor, leading to more efficient translocation properties in cells. No membrane permeabilization was observed, and our data were largely compatible with an endocytic pathway for cellular uptake.     

易位子辅助膜蛋白插入热力学

易位子辅助膜蛋白插入内质网膜是膜蛋白质生物生成的关键过程。了解不同类分子插入生物膜的机制是预测溶质分子透膜速度的先决条件,这也是药物设计和药理学领域的关键因素。根据插入机制,可以设计插膜肽直接用于疾病治疗,或者作为载体有选择性地将药物靶向特定细胞。自从2004年第1个易位子通道蛋白（Sec）的晶体结构被解析后,近十几年来大量的实验和理论研究,都在致力于揭示Sec辅助膜蛋白插入过程的分子机制。本文总结了过去该领域的实验和分子动力学模拟研究进展,从热力学方面重点分析了造成膜蛋白插入自由能分子动力学模拟计算值,以及实验值间偏差的原因。其中,根据研究条件精确设置模拟参数、插入造成的膜变形对自由能计算有很大的影响;核糖体为新生肽插入到Sec通道过程提供了能量,核糖体与Sec的结合影响Sec侧门的开放程度和Sec通道的结构,从而降低膜插入自由能。Sec辅助膜蛋白插入是一个极其复杂的过程,但整个过程仍然符合热力学和动力学的基本原理,尽管疏水性是Sec辅助膜蛋白质插入的关键性因素,但也不能忽略动力学因素的影响。     

Analysis on folding of misgurin using two-dimensional HP model

Misgurin is an antimicrobial peptide from the loach, while the hydrophobic-polar (HP) model is a way to study the folding conformations and native states in peptide and protein although several amino acids cannot be classified either hydrophobic or polar. Practically, the HP model requires extremely intensive computations, thus it has yet to be used widely. In this study, we use the two-dimensional HP model to analyze all possible folding conformations and native states of misgurin with conversion of natural amino acids according to the normalized amino acid hydrophobicity index as well as the shortest benchmark HP sequence. The results show that the conversion of misgurin into HP sequence with glycine as hydrophobic amino acid at pH 2 has 1212 folding conformations with the same native state of minimal energy -6; the conversion of glycine as polar amino acid at pH 2 has 13,386 folding conformations with three native states of minimal energy -5; the conversion of glycine as hydrophobic amino acid at pH 7 has 2538 folding conformations with three native states of minimal energy -5; and the conversion of glycine as polar amino acid at pH 7 has 12,852 folding conformations with three native states of minimal energy -4. Those native states can be ranked according to the normalized amino acid hydrophobicity index. The detailed discussions suggest two ways to modify misgurin.