Cathodes as electron donors for microbial metabolism: Which extracellular electron transfer mechanisms are involved?

This review illuminates extracellular electron transfer mechanisms that may be involved in microbial bioelectrochemical systems with biocathodes. Microbially-catalyzed cathodes are evolving for new bioprocessing applications for waste(water) treatment, carbon dioxide fixation, chemical product formation, or bioremediation. Extracellular electron transfer processes in biological anodes, were the electrode serves as electron acceptor, have been widely studied. However, for biological cathodes the question remains: what are the biochemical mechanisms for the extracellular electron transfer from a cathode (electron donor) to a microorganism? This question was approached by not only analysing the literature on biocathodes, but also by investigating known extracellular microbial oxidation reactions in environmental processes. Here, it is predicted that in direct electron transfer reactions, c-type cytochromes often together with hydrogenases play a critical role and that, in mediated electron transfer reactions, natural redox mediators, such as PQQ, will be involved in the bioelectrochemical reaction. These mechanisms are very similar to processes at the bioanode, but the components operate at different redox potentials. The biocatalyzed cathode reactions, thereby, are not necessarily energy conserving for the microorganism.     

Mikroben unter Strom

Microbes wired up – From wastewater treatment to bioelectrotechnology Electron conducting microbes – this still sounds like science fiction or at least like an exotic natural phenomenon. Groundbreaking research in this area, however, indicates that this process seems to be widely spread within anaerobic microbial ecology. Microbes “wire up” with their living and non‐living surrounding to construct energetic networks. With microbial bioelectrochemical systems, we try to utilize this knowledge for environmental and biotechnological applications. While initially, the recovery of energy as electric current in microbial fuel cells was the main R&D target, our new scientific insights of microbial extracellular electron transfer allow us to make controlled use of this phenomenon for a multitude of further applications.     

Towards practical implementation of bioelectrochemical wastewater treatment

Bioelectrochemical systems (BESs), such as microbial fuel cells (MFCs) and microbial electrolysis cells (MECs), are generally regarded as a promising future technology for the production of energy from organic material present in wastewaters. The current densities that can be generated with laboratory BESs now approach levels that come close to the requirements for practical applications. However, full-scale implementation of bioelectrochemical wastewater treatment is not straightforward because certain microbiological, technological and economic challenges need to be resolved that have not previously been encountered in any other wastewater treatment system. Here, we identify these challenges, provide an overview of their implications for the feasibility of bioelectrochemical wastewater treatment and explore the opportunities for future BESs.     

Electron transfer mechanisms between microorganisms and electrodes in bioelectrochemical systems

Microbes have been shown to naturally form veritable electric grids in which different species acting as electron donors and others acting as electron acceptors cooperate. The uptake of electrons from cells adjacent to them is a mechanism used by microorganisms to gain energy for cell growth and maintenance. The external discharge of electrons in lieu of a terminal electron acceptor, and the reduction of external substrates to uphold certain metabolic processes, also plays a significant role in a variety of microbial environments. These vital microbial respiration events, viz. extracellular electron transfer to and from microorganisms, have attracted widespread attention in recent decades and have led to the development of fascinating research concerning microbial electrochemical sensors and bioelectrochemical systems for environmental and bioproduction applications involving different fuels and chemicals. In such systems, microorganisms use mainly either (1) indirect routes involving use of small redox-active organic molecules referred to as redox mediators, secreted by cells or added exogenously, (2) primary metabolites or other intermediates, or (3) direct modes involving physical contact in which naturally occurring outer-membrane c-type cytochromes shuttle electrons for the reduction or oxidation of electrodes. Electron transfer mechanisms play a role in maximizing the performance of microbe?Celectrode interaction-based systems and help very much in providing an understanding of how such systems operate. This review summarizes the mechanisms of electron transfer between bacteria and electrodes, at both the anode and the cathode, in bioelectrochemical systems. The use over the years of various electrochemical approaches and techniques, cyclic voltammetry in particular, for obtaining a better understanding of the microbial electrocatalysis and the electron transfer mechanisms involved is also described and exemplified.     

Growth medium and electrolyte—How to combine the different requirements on the reaction solution in bioelectrochemical systems using Cupriavidus necator

Microbial electrosynthesis is a relatively new research field where microbial carbon dioxide fixation based on the energy supplied by a cathode is investigated. Reaction media used in such bioelectrochemical systems have to fulfill requirements of classical biotechnology as well as electrochemistry. The design and characterization of a medium that enables fast electroautotrophic growth of Cupriavidus necator in microbial electrosynthesis was investigated in detail. The identified chloride‐free medium mainly consists of low buffer concentration and is supplied with trace elements. Biotechnologically relevant parameters, such as high‐specific growth rates and short lag phases, were determined for growth characterization. Fast growth under all conditions tested, i.e. heterotrophic, autotrophic and electroautotrophic was achieved. The lag phase was shortened by increasing the FeSO? concentration. Additionally, electrochemical robustness of the reaction media was proven. Under reductive conditions, no deposits on electrodes or precipitations in the media were observed and no detectable hydrogen peroxide evolved. In the bioelectrochemical system, no lag phase occurred and specific growth rate of C. necator was 0.09 h?¹. Using this medium shortens seed train drastically and enables fast electrobiotechnological production processes based on C. necator .     

Insights in the anode chamber influences on cathodic bioelectromethanogenesis – systematic comparison of anode materials and anolytes

Cathode and catholyte are usually optimized to improve microbial electrosynthesis process, whereas the anodic counter reaction was not systematically investigated and optimized for these applications yet. Nevertheless, the anolyte and especially the anode material can limit the cathodic bioelectrochemical process. This paper compares for the first time the performance of different anode materials as counter electrodes for a cathodic bioelectrochemical process, the bioelectromethanogenesis. It was observed that depending on the anode material the cathodic methane production varies from 0.96 µmol/d with a carbon fabric anode to 25.44 µmol/d with a carbon felt anode of the same geometrical surface area. The used anolyte also affected the methane production rate at the cathode. Especially, the pH of the anolyte showed an impact on the system; an anolyte with pH 5 produced up to 2.0 times more methane compared to one with pH 8.5. The proton availability is discussed as one reason for this effect. Although some of the measured effects cannot be explained completely so far this study advises researchers to strongly consider the anode impact during process development and optimization of a cathodic bioelectrochemical synthesis process.     

Electroactive bacteria—molecular mechanisms and genetic tools

In nature, different bacteria have evolved strategies to transfer electrons far beyond the cell surface. This electron transfer enables the use of these bacteria in bioelectrochemical systems (BES), such as microbial fuel cells (MFCs) and microbial electrosynthesis (MES). The main feature of electroactive bacteria (EAB) in these applications is the ability to transfer electrons from the microbial cell to an electrode or vice versa instead of the natural redox partner. In general, the application of electroactive organisms in BES offers the opportunity to develop efficient and sustainable processes for the production of energy as well as bulk and fine chemicals, respectively. This review describes and compares key microbiological features of different EAB. Furthermore, it focuses on achievements and future prospects of genetic manipulation for efficient strain development.     

Electrochemically active biofilms: facts and fiction. A review

This review examines the electrochemical techniques used to study extracellular electron transfer in the electrochemically active biofilms that are used in microbial fuel cells and other bioelectrochemical systems. Electrochemically active biofilms are defined as biofilms that exchange electrons with conductive surfaces: electrodes. Following the electrochemical conventions, and recognizing that electrodes can be considered reactants in these bioelectrochemical processes, biofilms that deliver electrons to the biofilm electrode are called anodic, ie electrode-reducing, biofilms, while biofilms that accept electrons from the biofilm electrode are called cathodic, ie electrode-oxidizing, biofilms. How to grow these electrochemically active biofilms in bioelectrochemical systems is discussed and also the critical choices made in the experimental setup that affect the experimental results. The reactor configurations used in bioelectrochemical systems research are also described and the authors demonstrate how to use selected voltammetric techniques to study extracellular electron transfer in bioelectrochemical systems. Finally, some critical concerns with the proposed electron transfer mechanisms in bioelectrochemical systems are addressed together with the prospects of bioelectrochemical systems as energy-converting and energy-harvesting devices.     

Electrochemically active biofilms: facts and fiction. A review

This review examines the electrochemical techniques used to study extracellular electron transfer in the electrochemically active biofilms that are used in microbial fuel cells and other bioelectrochemical systems. Electrochemically active biofilms are defined as biofilms that exchange electrons with conductive surfaces: electrodes. Following the electrochemical conventions, and recognizing that electrodes can be considered reactants in these bioelectrochemical processes, biofilms that deliver electrons to the biofilm electrode are called anodic, ie electrode-reducing, biofilms, while biofilms that accept electrons from the biofilm electrode are called cathodic, ie electrode-oxidizing, biofilms. How to grow these electrochemically active biofilms in bioelectrochemical systems is discussed and also the critical choices made in the experimental setup that affect the experimental results. The reactor configurations used in bioelectrochemical systems research are also described and the authors demonstrate how to use selected voltammetric techniques to study extracellular electron transfer in bioelectrochemical systems. Finally, some critical concerns with the proposed electron transfer mechanisms in bioelectrochemical systems are addressed together with the prospects of bioelectrochemical systems as energy-converting and energy-harvesting devices.     

Effect of the cathode potential and sulfate ions on nitrate reduction in a microbial electrochemical denitrification system

Recently, bioelectrochemical systems have been demonstrated as advantageous for denitrification. Here, we investigated the nitrate reduction rate and bacterial community on cathodes at different cathode potentials [?300, ?500, ?700, and ?900 mV vs. standard hydrogen electrode (SHE)] in a two-chamber microbial electrochemical denitrification system and effects of sulfate, a common nitrate co-contaminant, on denitrification efficiency. The results indicated that the highest nitrate reduction rates (3.5 mg L^?1 days^?1) were obtained at a cathode potential of ?700 mV, regardless of sulfate presence, while a lower rate was observed at a more negative cathode potential (?900 mV). Notably, although sulfate ions generally inhibited nitrate reduction, this effect was absent at a cathode potential of ?700 mV. Polymerase chain reaction–denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis revealed that bacterial communities on the graphite-felt cathode were significantly affected by the cathode potential change and sulfate presence. Shinella-like and Alicycliphilus-like bacterial species were exclusively observed on cathodes in reactors without sulfate. Ochrobactrum-like and Sinorhizobium-like bacterial species, which persisted at different cathode potentials irrespective of sulfate presence, were shown to contribute to bioelectrochemical denitrification. This study suggested that a cathode potential of around ?700 mV versus SHE would ensure optimal nitrate reduction rate and counteract inhibitory effects of sulfate. Additionally, sulfate presence considerably affects denitrification efficiency and microbial community of microbial electrochemical denitrification systems.     

Production of bioelectricity,bio-hydrogen,high value chemicals and bioinspired nanomaterials by electrochemically active biofilms

Microorganisms naturally form biofilms on solid surfaces for their mutual benefits including protection from environmental stresses caused by contaminants, nutritional depletion or imbalances. The biofilms are normally dangerous to human health due to their inherited robustness. On the other hand, a recent study suggested that electrochemically active biofilms (EABs) generated by electrically active microorganisms have properties that can be used to catalyze or control the electrochemical reactions in a range of fields, such as bioenergy production, bioremediation, chemical/biological synthesis, bio-corrosion mitigation and biosensor development. EABs have attracted considerable attraction in bioelectrochemical systems (BESs), such as microbial fuel cells and microbial electrolysis cells, where they act as living bioanode or biocathode catalysts. Recently, it was reported that EABs can be used to synthesize metal nanoparticles and metal nanocomposites. The EAB-mediated synthesis of metal and metal–semiconductor nanocomposites is expected to provide a new avenue for the greener synthesis of nanomaterials with high efficiency and speed than other synthetic methods. This review covers the general introduction of EABs, as well as the applications of EABs in BESs, and the production of bio-hydrogen, high value chemicals and bio-inspired nanomaterials.     

Screening of natural phenazine producers for electroactivity in bioelectrochemical systems

Mediated extracellular electron transfer (EET) might be a great vehicle to connect microbial bioprocesses with electrochemical control in stirred-tank bioreactors. However, mediated electron transfer to date is not only much less efficient but also much less studied than microbial direct electron transfer to an anode. For example, despite the widespread capacity of pseudomonads to produce phenazine natural products, only Pseudomonas aeruginosa has been studied for its use of phenazines in bioelectrochemical applications. To provide a deeper understanding of the ecological potential for the bioelectrochemical exploitation of phenazines, we here investigated the potential electroactivity of over 100 putative diverse native phenazine producers and the performance within bioelectrochemical systems. Five species from the genera Pseudomonas, Streptomyces, Nocardiopsis, Brevibacterium and Burkholderia were identified as new electroactive bacteria. Electron discharge to the anode and electric current production correlated with the phenazine synthesis of Pseudomonas chlororaphis subsp. aurantiaca. Phenazine-1-carboxylic acid was the dominant molecule with a concentration of 86.1 μg/ml mediating an anodic current of 15.1 μA/cm². On the other hand, Nocardiopsis chromatogenes used a wider range of phenazines at low concentrations and likely yet-unknown redox compounds to mediate EET, achieving an anodic current of 9.5 μA/cm². Elucidating the energetic and metabolic usage of phenazines in these and other species might contribute to improving electron discharge and respiration. In the long run, this may enhance oxygen-limited bioproduction of value-added compounds based on mediated EET mechanisms.     

Microbial extracellular electron transfer and its relevance to iron corrosion

Extracellular electron transfer (EET) is a microbial metabolism that enables efficient electron transfer between microbial cells and extracellular solid materials. Microorganisms harbouring EET abilities have received considerable attention for their various biotechnological applications, including bioleaching and bioelectrochemical systems. On the other hand, recent research revealed that microbial EET potentially induces corrosion of iron structures. It has been well known that corrosion of iron occurring under anoxic conditions is mostly caused by microbial activities, which is termed as microbiologically influenced corrosion (MIC). Among diverse MIC mechanisms, microbial EET activity that enhances corrosion via direct uptake of electrons from metallic iron, specifically termed as electrical MIC (EMIC), has been regarded as one of the major causative factors. The EMIC‐inducing microorganisms initially identified were certain sulfate‐reducing bacteria and methanogenic archaea isolated from marine environments. Subsequently, abilities to induce EMIC were also demonstrated in diverse anaerobic microorganisms in freshwater environments and oil fields, including acetogenic bacteria and nitrate‐reducing bacteria. Abilities of EET and EMIC are now regarded as microbial traits more widespread among diverse microbial clades than was thought previously. In this review, basic understandings of microbial EET and recent progresses in the EMIC research are introduced.     

Improved electrical wiring of microbes: anthraquinone-modified electrodes for biosensing of chlorinated hydrocarbons

The present study reports the development of a novel bioelectrochemical sensor for trichloroethene (TCE), a common subsurface contaminant, based on the measurement of the electrical current resulting from the microbially catalysed reduction of TCE at anthraquinone (AQ)-modified electrodes. Firstly, we describe the development and electrochemical characterisation of AQ-modified electrodes, prepared via spontaneous or electrochemical reduction of AQ diazonium derivatives. Finally, the proof-of-principle of the bioelectrochemical sensor for TCE was evaluated, using a TCE-dechlorinating microbial culture as the biosensing element. The response of the bioelectrochemical sensor was measured either as the peak current in cyclic voltammetry or the steady-state current in chronoamperometry; in both cases, it was found to be proportional to TCE concentrations in the range 0-100 μmol/L. On the other hand, the microorganisms in contact with the electrode surface caused severe fouling problems which drastically reduced the life-time of the sensor.     

Resource recovery from low strength wastewater in a bioelectrochemical desalination process

In this research, low strength synthetic wastewaters with chemical oxygen demand less than 300 mg L^?1 were treated at different concentrations in a bioelectrochemical desalination process. A process optimization model was utilized to study the performance of the photosynthetic bioelectrochemical desalination process. The variables include substrate (chemical oxygen demand) concentration, total dissolved solids, and microalgae biomass concentration in the cathode chamber. Relationships between the chemical oxygen demand concentration, microalgae, and salt concentrations were evaluated. Power densities and potential energy benefits from microalgal biomass growth were discussed. The results from this study demonstrated the reliability and reproducibility of the photosynthetic microbial desalination process performance followed by a response surface methodology optimization. This study also confirms the suitability of bioelectrochemical desalination process for treating low substrate wastewaters such as agricultural wastewaters, anaerobic digester effluents, and septic tank effluents for net energy production and water desalination.     

Electricity generation by microorganisms in the sediment-water interface of an extreme acidic microcosm

The attachment of microorganisms to electrodes is of great interest for electricity generation in microbial fuel cells (MFC) or other applications in bioelectrochemical systems (BES). In this work, a microcosm of the acidic ecosystem of Río Tinto was built and graphite electrodes were introduced at different points. This allowed the study of electricity generation in the sediment/water interface and the involvement of acidophilic microorganisms as biocatalysts of the anodic and cathodic reactions in a fuel-cell configuration. Current densities and power outputs of up to 3.5 A/m2 and 0.3 W/m2, respectively, were measured at pH 3. Microbial analyses of the electrode surfaces showed that Acidiphilium spp., which uses organic compounds as electron donors, were the predominant biocatalysts of the anodic reactions, whereas the aerobic iron oxidizers Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans and Leptospirillum spp. were detected mainly on the cathode surface.     

A bioelectrochemical reactor containing carbon fiber textiles enables efficient methane fermentation from garbage slurry

A packed-bed system includes supporting materials to retain microorganisms and a bioelectrochemical system influences the microbial metabolism. In our study, carbon fiber textiles (CFT) as a supporting material was attached onto a carbon working electrode in a bioelectrochemical reactor (BER) that degrades garbage slurry to methane, in order to investigate the effect of combining electrochemical regulation and packing CFT. The potential on the working electrode in the BER containing CFT was set to −1.0 V or −0.8 V (vs. Ag/AgCl). BERs containing CFT exhibited higher methane production, elimination of dichromate chemical oxygen demand, and the ratio of methanogens in the suspended fraction than reactors containing CFT without electrochemical regulation at an organic loading rate (OLR) of 27.8 gCODcr/L/day. In addition, BERs containing CFT exhibited higher reactor performances than BERs without CFT at this OLR. Our results revealed that the new design that combined electrochemical regulation and packing CFT was effective.     

Electrochemical control of redox potential affects methanogenesis of the hydrogenotrophic methanogen Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus

To investigate the precise effect of the redox potential on the methanogenesis of the hydrogenotrophic methanogen Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus by using an electrochemical redox controlling system without adding oxidizing or reducing agents. A bioelectrochemical system was applied to control the redox conditions in culture and to measure the methane‐producing activity of M. thermautotrophicus at a constant potential from +0·2 to ?0·8 V (vs Ag/AgCl). Methane production and growth of M. thermautotrophicus were 1·6 and 3·5 times increased at ?0·8 V, compared with control experiments without electrolysis, respectively, while methanogenesis was suppressed between +0·2 and ?0·2 V. A clear relationship between an electrochemically regulated redox potential and methanogenesis was revealed.

Significance and Impact of the Study

A novel bioelectrochemical method can activate the methanogenesis of M. thermautotrophicus by controlling the redox potential in culture conditions at ?0·8 V, which is a difficult potential to achieve by conventional methods (e.g. by adding reducing agents). This study provides useful insights for the application of a bioelectrochemical system in industrial processes involving methanogens, such as in anaerobic digesters.     

Electrochemically applied potentials induce growth and metabolic shift changes in the hyperthermophilic bacterium Thermotoga maritima MSB8

Bioelectrochemical systems are an attractive technology for regulating microbial activity. The effect of an applied potential on hydrolysis of starch in Thermotoga maritima as a model bacterium was investigated in this study. A cathodic potential (?0.6 and ?0.8 V) induced 5-h earlier growth initiation of T. maritima with starch as the polymeric substrate than that without electrochemical regulation. Moreover, metabolic patterns of starch consumption were altered by the cathodic potential. While acetate, H², and CO₂ were the major products of starch consumption in the control experiment without electrolysis, lactate accumulation was detected rather than decreased acetate and H₂ levels in the bioelectrochemical system experiments with the cathodic potential. These results indicate that the applied potential could control microbial activities related to the hydrolysis of polymeric organic substances and shift carbon and electron flux to a lactate-producing reaction in T. maritima.     

The electric picnic: synergistic requirements for exoelectrogenic microbial communities

Characterization of the various microbial populations present in exoelectrogenic biofilms provides insight into the processes required to convert complex organic matter in wastewater streams into electrical current in bioelectrochemical systems (BESs). Analysis of the community profiles of exoelectrogenic microbial consortia in BESs fed different substrates gives a clearer picture of the different microbial populations present in these exoelectrogenic biofilms. Rapid utilization of fermentation end products by exoelectrogens (typically Geobacter species) relieves feedback inhibition for the fermentative consortia, allowing for rapid metabolism of organics. Identification of specific syntrophic processes and the communities characteristic of these anodic biofilms will be a valuable aid in improving the performance of BESs.