Effects of amino acid substitutions outside an antigenic site on protein binding to monoclonal antibodies of predetermined specificity obtained by peptide immunization: Demonstration with region 94–100 (antigenic site 3) of myoglobin

Amino acid substitutions outside protein antigenic sites are very frequently assumed to exert no effect on binding to antiprotein antibodies, especially if these are monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). In fact, a very popular method for localization of residues in protein antigenic sites is based on the interpretation that whenever a replacement causes a change in binding to antibody, then that residue will be located in the antigenic site. To test this assumption, mAbs of predetermined specificity were prepared by immunization with a free (i.e., without coupling to any carrier) synthetic peptide representing region 94–100 of sperm whale myoglobin (Mb). The cross-reactivities and relative affinities of three mAbs with eight Mb variants were studied. Five Mb variants which had no substitutions within the boundaries of the designed antigenic site exhibited remarkable, and in two cases almost complete, loss in cross-reactivity relative to the reference antigen, sperm whale Mb. Two myoglobins, each of which had one substitution within region 94–100, showed little or no reactivity with the three mAbs. It is concluded that substitutions outside an antigenic site can exert drastic effects on the reactivity of a protein with mAbs against the site and that caution should be exercised in interpreting cross-reactivity data of proteins to implicate residues directly in an antigenic site.     

Effects of amino acid substitutions outside an antigenic site on protein binding to monoclonal antibodies of predetermined specificity obtained by peptide immunization: demonstration with region 94-100 (antigenic site 3) of myoglobin.

Amino acid substitutions outside protein antigenic sites are very frequently assumed to exert no effect on binding to antiprotein antibodies, especially if these are monoclonal antibodies (mAbs). In fact, a very popular method for localization of residues in protein antigenic sites is based on the interpretation that whenever a replacement causes a change in binding to antibody, then that residue will be located in the antigenic site. To test this assumption, mAbs of predetermined specificity were prepared by immunization with a free (i.e., without coupling to any carrier) synthetic peptide representing region 94–100 of sperm whale myoglobin (Mb). The cross-reactivities and relative affinities of three mAbs with eight Mb variants were studied. Five Mb variants which had no substitutions within the boundaries of the designed antigenic site exhibited remarkable, and in two cases almost complete, loss in cross-reactivity relative to the reference antigen, sperm whale Mb. Two myoglobins, each of which had one substitution within region 94–100, showed little or no reactivity with the three mAbs. It is concluded that substitutions outside an antigenic site can exert drastic effects on the reactivity of a protein with mAbs against the site and that caution should be exercised in interpreting cross-reactivity data of proteins to implicate residues directly in an antigenic site.     

Effects of amino acid substitutions outside an antigenic site on protein binding to monoclonal antibodies of predetermined specificity obtained by peptide immunization: Demonstration with region 113–120 (antigenic site 4) of myoglobin

Immunochemical cross-reactivity of protein variants has been very frequently used to map protein antigenic sites. The approach is based on the assumption that amino acid substitutions affecting the binding of a protein to its antibody, particularly when monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are used, must be part of the antigenic site and not far from it. The assumption was investigated in this study by determining the effects of amino acid substitutions outside the antigenic site on the reactivity of six myglobin (Mb) variants with three mAbs of predetermined specificity prepared by immunization with a free synthetic peptide representing region 113–120 (antigenic site 4) of Mb. Two of the Mb variants used had no substitutions within residues 113–120 (the region to which the specificity of the mAbs is directed) and yet exhibited markedly decreased cross-reactions and binding affinities, relative to the reference antigen, sperm-whale Mb. The other three Mb variants possessed substitutions within, as well as outside, region 113–120 and showed very little cross-reactivities. The results of this study, particularly with the Mbs that have no substitutions within the indicated antigenic site, clearly show that substitutions outside the site, and which by design are not part of the site, can influence very markedly the reactivity of the protein variant with the anti-site mAbs. The approach can, therefore, lead to serious errors if used to identify residues of protein antigenic sites.     

Use of antibodies specific to defined regions of scorpion alpha-toxin to study its interaction with its receptor site on the sodium channel

Five antibody populations selected by immunoaffinity chromatography for their specificity toward various regions of toxin II of the scorpion Androctonus australis Hector were used to probe the interaction of this protein with its receptor site on the sodium channel. These studies indicate that two antigenic sites, one located around the disulfide bridge 12-63 and one encompassing residues 50-59, are involved in the molecular mechanisms of toxicity neutralization. Fab fragments specific to the region around disulfide bridge 12-63 inhibit binding of the 125I-labeled toxin to its receptor site. Also, these two antigenic regions are inaccessible to their antibodies when the toxin is bound to its receptor site. In contrast, the two other antigenic sites encompassing the only alpha-helix region (residues 23-32) and a beta-turn structure (residues 32-35) are accessible to their respective antibodies when the toxin is bound to its receptor. Together, these data support the recent proposal that a region made of residues that are conserved in the scorpion toxin family is involved in the binding of the toxin to the receptor.     

Trimeric gp120-specific bovine monoclonal antibodies require cysteine and aromatic residues in CDRH3 for high affinity binding to HIV Env

We isolated HIV-1 Envelope (Env)-specific memory B cells from a cow that had developed high titer polyclonal immunoglobulin G (IgG) with broad neutralizing activity after a long duration vaccination with HIV-1_AD8 Env gp140 trimers. We cloned the bovine IgG matched heavy (H) and light (L) chain variable (V) genes from these memory B cells and constructed IgG monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) with either a human constant (C)-region/bovine V-region chimeric or fully bovine C and V regions. Among 42 selected Ig+ memory B cells, two mAbs (6A and 8C) showed high affinity binding to gp140 Env. Characterization of both the fully bovine and human chimeric isoforms of these two mAbs revealed them as highly type-specific and capable of binding only to soluble AD8 uncleaved gp140 trimers and covalently stabilized AD8 SOSIP gp140 cleaved trimers, but not monomeric gp120. Genomic sequence analysis of the V genes showed the third heavy complementarity-determining region (CDRH3) of 6A mAb was 21 amino acids in length while 8C CDRH3 was 14 amino acids long. The entire V heavy (VH) region was 27% and 25% diverged for 6A and 8C, respectively, from the best matched germline V genes available, and the CDRH3 regions of 6A and 8C were 47.62% and 78.57% somatically mutated, respectively, suggesting a high level of somatic hypermutation compared with CDRH3 of other species. Alanine mutagenesis of the VH genes of 6A and 8C, showed that CDRH3 cysteine and tryptophan amino acids were crucial for antigen binding. Therefore, these bovine vaccine-induced anti-HIV antibodies shared some of the notable structural features of elite human broadly neutralizing antibodies, such as CDRH3 size and somatic mutation during affinity-maturation. However, while the 6A and 8C mAbs inhibited soluble CD4 binding to gp140 Env, they did not recapitulate the neutralizing activity of the polyclonal antibodies against HIV infection.     

A Similar Pattern of Interaction for Different Antibodies with a Major Antigenic Site of Foot-and-Mouth Disease Virus: Implications for Intratypic Antigenic Variation

The three-dimensional structures of the Fab fragment of a neutralizing antibody raised against a foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) of serotype C₁, alone and complexed to an antigenic peptide representing the major antigenic site A (G-H loop of VP1), have been determined. As previously seen in a complex of the same antigen with another antibody which recognizes a different epitope within antigenic site A, the receptor recognition motif Arg-Gly-Asp and some residues from an adjacent helix participate directly in the interaction with the complementarity-determining regions of the antibody. Remarkably, the structures of the two antibodies become more similar upon binding the peptide, and both undergo considerable induced fit to accommodate the peptide with a similar array of interactions. Furthermore, the pattern of reactivities of five additional antibodies with versions of the antigenic peptide bearing amino acid replacements suggests a similar pattern of interaction of antibodies raised against widely different antigens of serotype C. The results reinforce the occurrence of a defined antigenic structure at this mobile, exposed antigenic site and imply that intratypic antigenic variation of FMDV of serotype C is due to subtle structural differences that affect antibody recognition while preserving a functional structure for the receptor binding site.     

What you should know about PR3-ANCA. Structural aspects of antibodies to proteinase 3 (PR3)

Reactive antigenic epitopes on presumed autoantigens of biologic interest have been examined by many researchers. The central third complementarity-determining region (CDR3) residues of a human monoclonal anti-proteinase 3 (PR3) antibody contained many negatively charged aspartic acid residues, perhaps contributing to its reactivity with positively charged PR3 regions. Examination of four other human monoclonal anti-PR3 antibodies shows a number of negatively charged residues within their CDR3 regions. Mapping of segments of linear PR3-epitopes reacting with anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCA) demonstrated a preliminary estimate of structures contributing to antigenic determinants. T-cell epitopes on PR3 are reported in studies of chronic myeloid leukemia. These T-cell epitopes appear to be human leukocyte antigen (HLA) A2.1 restricted.     

What you should know about PR3-ANCA: Structural aspects of antibodies to proteinase 3 (PR3)

Reactive antigenic epitopes on presumed autoantigens of biologic interest have been examined by many researchers. The central third complementarity-determining region (CDR3) residues of a human monoclonal anti-proteinase 3 (PR3) antibody contained many negatively charged aspartic acid residues, perhaps contributing to its reactivity with positively charged PR3 regions. Examination of four other human monoclonal anti-PR3 antibodies shows a number of negatively charged residues within their CDR3 regions. Mapping of segments of linear PR3-epitopes reacting with anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCA) demonstrated a preliminary estimate of structures contributing to antigenic determinants. T-cell epitopes on PR3 are reported in studies of chronic myeloid leukemia. These T-cell epitopes appear to be human leukocyte antigen (HLA) A2.1 restricted.     

Effects of amino acid substitutions outside an antigenic site on protein binding to monoclonal antibodies of predetermined specificity obtained by peptide immunization: Demonstration with region 145–151 (antigenic site 5) of myoglobin

Monoclonal antibodies of predetermined specificity were prepared by immunization with a free (i.e., without coupling to any protein carrier) synthetic peptide representing region 145–151 of sperm whale myoglobin (SpMb) and their cross-reactions with eight Mb variants were determined. Five Mbs—bottle-nose dolphin myoglobin (BdMb), pacific common dolphin myoglobin (PdMb), horse myoglobin (HsMb), dog myoglobin (DgMb), and badger myoglobin (BgMb)—have an identical sequence in that region. Nevertheless, these Mbs exhibited very different cross-reactivities. BdMb and PdMb exhibited cross-activities which were comparable to that of the reference antigen, SpMb; while the reactivity of HsMb was remarkedly decreased, DgMb and BgMb showed almost no cross-reactions with these mAbs. Since the region 145–151 has an identical sequence in all the five Mbs, it is concluded that the differences in their antigenic reactivities with anti-region 145–151 mAbs are due to the effects of amino acid substitutions outside the region 145–151. Another pair of myoglobins, echidna myoglobin (EdMb) and chicken myoglobin (ChMb), have the same sequence in that region, but reacted very differently with anti-region 145–151 mAbs. The reactivity and affinity of EdMb were substantially decreased while those of ChMb were almost completely absent, relative to SpMb. It is concluded, contrary to popular assumptions, that when an amino acid substitution influences the binding of a protein variant to a mAb, it is not necessary for that substitution to be an actual contact residue (i.e., a residue within the antigenic site where the mAb binds). Such effects, which are often very drastic, could be due to indirect influences of the substitution on the chemical and binding properties of the site residues. Furthermore, residues which had been postulated, on the basis of these assumptions, to constitute discontinuous antigenic sites in SpMb, were found [from the present studies and those recently reported with mAbs against the other four antigenic site of Mb (regions 15–22, 56–62, 94–100, and 113–120 of SpMb)] to merely be exerting indirect effects on the known five antigenic sites of Mb. The effects of substitutions, which can happen even in the absence of conformational changes, are determined by many factors, such as the chemical nature of the substitution, its environment, its distance from the site, and the nature of the site residue(s) being affected.     

Light chain variable region sequence of rabbit antipneumococcal type III polysaccharide antibody 3368.

The amino acid sequence of the amino-terminal 111 residues (variable region) for the light chain of the homogeneous rabbit antipneumococcal type III polysaccharide antibody 3368 was determined. This sequence was obtained principally through automated Edmann degradations of the intact light chain and of peptides generated by tryptic digestion of the citraconylated light chain. With these methods only 2 mumol of purified light chain was required to determine the reported sequence. When compared with the light chains of four other antipneumococcal type III polysaccharide antibodies, the 3368 light chain exhibits a unique sequence in those segments of the variable region that contribute to formation of the antigen binding site (complementarity-determining regions) (10 or 11 residue differences in 12 positions). The 3368 light chain also demonstrates an insertion of three residues relative to the other four light chains in the complementarity-determining region at positions 89 to 98. These five light chains have greater than 80% sequence homology for the portion of the variable region which is not involved in antigen binding (framework).     

Molecular modeling of cardiac glycoside binding by the human sequence monoclonal antibody 1B3

The amino acid sequences of the heavy- and light-chain variable regions of the high-affinity human sequence antidigoxin monoclonal antibody 1B3 (mAb 1B3) were determined, and a structural model for the mAb's variable region was developed by homology modeling techniques. The structural model provided the basis for computationally docking digoxin and eight related cardiac glycosides into the putative binding site of mAb 1B3. Analysis of the consensus binding mode obtained for digoxin showed that the cardenolide moiety of digoxin is deeply embedded in a predominantly hydrophobic, narrow cavity, whereas the terminal, gamma-carbohydrate group is solvent-exposed. The docking results indicated that the primary driving forces for digoxin binding by mAb 1B3 are hydrophobic interactions with the digoxin steroid ring system and hydrogen bonds with the digitoxose groups. The binding model accounts for the experimentally observed variations in mAb 1B3 binding affinity for various structural analogs of digoxin used previously to develop a 3D structure-activity relationship model of drug binding (Farr CD, Tabet MR, Ball WJ Jr, Fishwild DM, Wang X, Nair AC, Welsh WJ. Three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationship analysis of ligand binding to human sequence antidigoxin monoclonal antibodies using comparative molecular field analysis. J Med Chem 2002;45:3257-3270). In particular, the hydrogen bond pattern is consistent with the unique sensitivity of mAb 1B3's binding affinity to the number of sugar residues present in a cardiac glycoside. The hydrophobic environment about the steroid moiety of digoxin is compatible with the mAb's reduced affinity for ligands that possess hydrophilic hydroxyl and acetyl group modifications in this region. The model also indicated that most of the amino acid residues in contact with the ligand reside in or about the three complementarity determining regions (CDRs) of the heavy chain and the third CDR of the light chain. A comparison of the 1B3 binding model with the crystal structures of two murine antidigoxin mAbs revealed similar binding patterns used by the three mAbs, such as a high frequency of occurrence of aromatic, hydrophobic residues in the CDRs and a dominant role of the heavy chain CDR3 in antigen binding.     

Characterization of a high-affinity human antibody with a disulfide bridge in the third complementarity-determining region of the heavy chain

Disulfide bridges are common in the antigen-binding site from sharks (new antigen receptor) and camels (single variable heavy-chain domain, VHH), in which they confer both structural diversity and domain stability. In human antibodies, cysteine residues in the third complementarity-determining region of the heavy chain (CDR-H3) are rare but naturally encoded in the IGHD germline genes. Here, by panning a phage display library designed based on human germline genes and synthetic CDR-H3 regions against a human cytokine, we identified an antibody (M3) containing two cysteine residues in the CDR-H3. It binds the cytokine with high affinity (0.4?nM), recognizes a unique epitope on the antigen, and has a distinct neutralization profile as compared with all other antibodies selected from the library. The two cysteine residues form a disulfide bridge as determined by mass spectrometric peptide mapping. Replacing the cysteines with alanines did not change the solubility and stability of the monoclonal antibody, but binding to the antigen was significantly impaired. Three-dimensional modeling and dynamic simulations were employed to explore how the disulfide bridge influences the conformation of CDR-H3 and binding to the antigen. On the basis of these results, we envision that designing human combinatorial antibody libraries to contain intra-CDR or inter-CDR disulfide bridges could lead to identification of human antibodies with unique binding profiles.     

Characterization of potent RSV neutralizing antibodies isolated from human memory B cells and identification of diverse RSV/hMPV cross-neutralizing epitopes

ABSTRACT

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is a leading cause of lower respiratory tract infection in young children and older adults. Currently, no licensed vaccine is available, and therapeutic options are limited. The primary target of neutralizing antibodies to RSV is the surface fusion (F) glycoprotein. Understanding the recognition of antibodies with high neutralization potencies to RSV F antigen will provide critical insights in developing efficacious RSV antibodies and vaccines. In this study, we isolated and characterized a panel of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) with high binding affinity to RSV prefusion F trimer and neutralization potency to RSV viruses. The mAbs were mapped to previously defined antigenic sites, and some that mapped to the same antigenic sites showed remarkable diversity in specificity, binding, and neutralization potencies. We found that the isolated site III mAbs shared highly conserved germline V-gene usage, but had different cross-reactivities to human metapneumovirus (hMPV), possibly due to the distinct modes/angles of interaction with RSV and hMPV F proteins. Furthermore, we identified a subset of potent RSV/hMPV cross-neutralizing mAbs that target antigenic site IV and the recently defined antigenic site V, while the majority of the mAbs targeting these two sites only neutralize RSV. Additionally, the isolated mAbs targeting site Ø were mono-specific for RSV and showed a wide range of neutralizing potencies on different RSV subtypes. Our data exemplify the diversity of anti-RSV mAbs and provide new insights into the immune recognition of respiratory viruses in the Pneumoviridae family.     

Prediction of methionine oxidation risk in monoclonal antibodies using a machine learning method

ABSTRACT

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) have become a major class of protein therapeutics that target a spectrum of diseases ranging from cancers to infectious diseases. Similar to any protein molecule, mAbs are susceptible to chemical modifications during the manufacturing process, long-term storage, and in vivo circulation that can impair their potency. One such modification is the oxidation of methionine residues. Chemical modifications that occur in the complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) of mAbs can lead to the abrogation of antigen binding and reduce the drug’s potency and efficacy. Thus, it is highly desirable to identify and eliminate any chemically unstable residues in the CDRs during the therapeutic antibody discovery process. To provide increased throughput over experimental methods, we extracted features from the mAbs’ sequences, structures, and dynamics, used random forests to identify important features and develop a quantitative and highly predictive in silico methionine oxidation model.     

Structural consensus among antibodies defines the antigen binding site

The Complementarity Determining Regions (CDRs) of antibodies are assumed to account for the antigen recognition and binding and thus to contain also the antigen binding site. CDRs are typically discerned by searching for regions that are most different, in sequence or in structure, between different antibodies. Here, we show that ~20% of the antibody residues that actually bind the antigen fall outside the CDRs. However, virtually all antigen binding residues lie in regions of structural consensus across antibodies. Furthermore, we show that these regions of structural consensus which cover the antigen binding site are identifiable from the sequence of the antibody. Analyzing the predicted contribution of antigen binding residues to the stability of the antibody-antigen complex, we show that residues that fall outside of the traditionally defined CDRs are at least as important to antigen binding as residues within the CDRs, and in some cases, they are even more important energetically. Furthermore, antigen binding residues that fall outside of the structural consensus regions but within traditionally defined CDRs show a marginal energetic contribution to antigen binding. These findings allow for systematic and comprehensive identification of antigen binding sites, which can improve the understanding of antigenic interactions and may be useful in antibody engineering and B-cell epitope identification.     

Chimeric and humanized antibodies with specificity for the CD33 antigen.

L and H chain cDNAs of M195, a murine mAb that binds to the CD33 Ag on normal and leukemic myeloid cells, were cloned. The cDNAs were used in the construction of mouse/human IgG1 and IgG3 chimeric antibodies. In addition, humanized antibodies were constructed which combined the complementarity-determining regions of the M195 antibody with human framework and constant regions. The human framework was chosen to maximize homology with the M195 V domain sequence. Moreover, a computer model of M195 was used to identify several framework amino acids that are likely to interact with the complementarity-determining regions, and these residues were also retained in the humanized antibodies. Unexpectedly, the humanized IgG1 and IgG3 M195 antibodies, which have reshaped V regions, have higher apparent binding affinity for the CD33 Ag than the chimeric or mouse antibodies.     

Beyond CDR-grafting: Structure-guided humanization of framework and CDR regions of an anti-myostatin antibody

Antibodies are an important class of biotherapeutics that offer specificity to their antigen, long half-life, effector function interaction and good manufacturability. The immunogenicity of non-human-derived antibodies, which can be a major limitation to development, has been partially overcome by humanization through complementarity-determining region (CDR) grafting onto human acceptor frameworks. The retention of foreign content in the CDR regions, however, is still a potential immunogenic liability. Here, we describe the humanization of an anti-myostatin antibody utilizing a 2-step process of traditional CDR-grafting onto a human acceptor framework, followed by a structure-guided approach to further reduce the murine content of CDR-grafted antibodies. To accomplish this, we solved the co-crystal structures of myostatin with the chimeric (Protein Databank (PDB) id 5F3B) and CDR-grafted anti-myostatin antibody (PDB id 5F3H), allowing us to computationally predict the structurally important CDR residues as well as those making significant contacts with the antigen. Structure-based rational design enabled further germlining of the CDR-grafted antibody, reducing the murine content of the antibody without affecting antigen binding. The overall “humanness” was increased for both the light and heavy chain variable regions.     

A combinatorial mutagenesis approach for functional epitope mapping on phage-displayed target antigen

Although multiple different procedures to characterize the epitopes recognized by antibodies have been developed, site-directed mutagenesis remains the method of choice to define the energetic contribution of antigen residues to binding. These studies are useful to identify critical residues and to delineate functional maps of the epitopes. However, they tend to underestimate the roles of residues that are not critical for binding on their own, but contribute to the formation of the target epitope in an additive, or even cooperative, way. Mapping antigenic determinants with a diffuse energetic landscape, which establish multiple individually weak interactions with the antibody paratope, resulting in high affinity and specificity recognition of the epitope as a whole, is thus technically challenging. The current work was aimed at developing a combinatorial strategy to overcome the limitations of site-directed mutagenesis, relying on comprehensive randomization of discrete antigenic regions within phage-displayed antigen libraries. Two model antibodies recognizing epidermal growth factor were used to validate the mapping platform. Abrogation of antibody recognition due to the introduction of simultaneous replacements was able to show the involvement of particular amino acid clusters in epitope formation. The abundance of some of the original residues (or functionally equivalent amino acids sharing their physicochemical properties) among the set of mutated antigen variants selected on a given antibody highlighted their contributions and allowed delineation of a detailed functional map of the corresponding epitope. The use of the combinatorial approach could be expanded to map the interactions between other antigens/antibodies.     

A combinatorial mutagenesis approach for functional epitope mapping on phage-displayed target antigen: Application to antibodies against epidermal growth factor

Although multiple different procedures to characterize the epitopes recognized by antibodies have been developed, site-directed mutagenesis remains the method of choice to define the energetic contribution of antigen residues to binding. These studies are useful to identify critical residues and to delineate functional maps of the epitopes. However, they tend to underestimate the roles of residues that are not critical for binding on their own, but contribute to the formation of the target epitope in an additive, or even cooperative, way. Mapping antigenic determinants with a diffuse energetic landscape, which establish multiple individually weak interactions with the antibody paratope, resulting in high affinity and specificity recognition of the epitope as a whole, is thus technically challenging. The current work was aimed at developing a combinatorial strategy to overcome the limitations of site-directed mutagenesis, relying on comprehensive randomization of discrete antigenic regions within phage-displayed antigen libraries. Two model antibodies recognizing epidermal growth factor were used to validate the mapping platform. Abrogation of antibody recognition due to the introduction of simultaneous replacements was able to show the involvement of particular amino acid clusters in epitope formation. The abundance of some of the original residues (or functionally equivalent amino acids sharing their physicochemical properties) among the set of mutated antigen variants selected on a given antibody highlighted their contributions and allowed delineation of a detailed functional map of the corresponding epitope. The use of the combinatorial approach could be expanded to map the interactions between other antigens/antibodies.