Effect of different East Coast Fever control strategies on fertility, milk production and weight gain of Sanga cattle in the Central Province of Zambia

Five different East Coast Fever (ECF) (Theileria parva infection) control strategies, based on tick control and/or ECF immunization, were tested in groups of traditionally managed Sanga cattle in the Central Province of Zambia over a period of 2.5 years. Two groups were kept under intensive tick control (sprayed weekly), one group immunized and one non-immunized. Two further groups were under no tick control, one group immunized and one non-immunized, while a fifth group was immunized against ECF and maintained under strategic tick control (18 sprays per year). Tick control increased milk production and weight gain but not fertility. Immunization had neither marked detrimental nor beneficial effects on the cattle productivity. The combination of strategic tick control and immunization resulted in the highest level of production and at the same time reduced the potential risk from other tick-borne diseases.     

Issues in tick vaccine development: identification and characterization of potential candidate vaccine antigens

It is well established that acquired immunity against tick infestation can be induced by repeated tick infestation or by active immunization with either crude or purified native as well as recombinant antigens. This review provides insights into the development of tick vaccines with reference to identification, purification and molecular cloning of candidate target antigens.     

Perspectives for subunit vaccines for the control of ticks

For the first time, successful vaccination against a tick has been carried out using a single defined antigen. Further, it has been shown that it is feasible to produce active antigenic material by recombinant DNA technology. This represents a significant advance towards the development of an alternative means of tick control. Nevertheless, as with any new product and new technology, much developmental work still has to be done before one can be confident that a practical means of tick control will result. From the published information, it does not seem that research on vaccines against other tick species is as advanced as that on Boophilus microplus. The work on B. microplus may, however, provide a short cut to the development of further tick vaccines.     

Amblyomma variegatum and associated diseases in the Caribbean: strategies for control and eradication in Guadeloupe

Amblyomma variegatum, introduced into Guadelopue 150 years ago, has recently spread in the Lesser Antilles and threatens North America. Two important diseases are associated with the tick: heartwater and dermatophilosis. Heartwater occurs in Guadeloupe, Marie-Galante and Antigua; acute dermatophilosis exists almost everywhere the tick is present. Both are very pathogenic for upgraded or newly-infested cattle. After 15 years of A. variegatum control in Guadeloupe, a balance is established between a tick population maintained at a low level by spraying acaricides and an animal population either completely resistant to heartwater and dermatophilosis (creole cattle) or regularly treated against ticks (upgraded cattle). An eradication campaign against A. variegatum in Guadeloupe, to avoid the spread of the associated diseases, appears technically difficult but possible, economically profitable, but socially completely utopian. We suggest for Guadeloupe a reinforced control of the tick with a persistent acaricide, hoping that a general decrease of the tick infestation rate on cattle will eliminate heartwater and acute dermatophilosis.     

Methods currently used for the control of heartwater: their validity and proposals for future control strategies

Major advances made in the last few years in the knowledge of heartwater have not yet resulted in significant improvement of its prevention and control. Acaricide resistance and the high cost of chemical vector control stimulate research on alternative methods of vector control, such as immunization against the tick and the use of pheromones. Recently developed in vitro methods for the culture of Cowdria ruminantium may make it possible to arrive at safe recombinant or molecular vaccines. Specific chemotherapy may be improved by new laboratory screening methods, and studies on the pathogenesis of heartwater could lead to better non-specific treatment as well. Studies on the heritability of natural resistance to heartwater should determine whether or not practical selection and transfer of resistance is feasible. More research is also needed on the immunology and diagnosis of the disease and the factors involved in the resistance of young animals.     

Characterization of tick antigens inducing host immune resistance. I. Immunization of guinea pigs with Amblyomma americanum-derived salivary gland extracts and identification of an important salivary gland protein antigen with guinea pig anti-tick antibodies

Guinea pigs immunized by subcutaneous injection of an emulsion of incomplete Freund's adjuvant (IFA) containing tick salivary gland extract antigens (SGA) from partially fed female ticks expressed a significant level of tick rejection when challenged 17 days later. This level of tick rejection was similar to animals actively sensitized by tick feeding and challenged at the same time. SGA emulsified with complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) or administered with saline was ineffective. However, ticks that fed on animals immunized with SGA+IFA or SGA+CFA expressed significant reductions in engorgement weight. SGA was active when prepared with or without protease inhibitors. The minimum effective immunizing dose of SGA was between 100 and 280 micrograms per animal. Extracts made from salivary gland-derived cement material (CA) from partially fed female ticks administered at 50 micrograms in IFA induced levels of tick rejection comparable to animals immunized with 280 micrograms of SGA+IFA. Sodium dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS/PAGE) of 35S- and 125I-radiolabeled SGA and CA extracts immunoprecipitated by guinea pig anti-tick serum that transferred immune resistance demonstrated a unique protein of 20,000 m.w. Serum from animals immunized with SGA+IFA (successful immunization) recognized this same protein, whereas serum from animals immunized with SGA+CFA (unsuccessful immunization) did not. The results of this study suggest that a 20,000 m.w. protein derived from the tick salivary gland may be responsible for the induction and perhaps elicitation of host immune resistance responses to Amblyomma americanum ticks.     

Tick saliva in anti-tick immunity and pathogen transmission

When feeding on vertebrate host ticks (ectoparasitic arthropods and potential vectors of bacterial, rickettsial, protozoal, and viral diseases) induce both innate and specific acquired host-immune reactions as part of anti-tick defenses. In a resistant host immune defense can lead to reduced tick viability, sometimes resulting in tick death. Tick responds to the host immune attack by secreting saliva containing pharmacologically active molecules and modulating host immune response. Tick saliva-effected immunomodulation at the attachment site facilitates both tick feeding and enhances the success of transmission of pathogens from tick into the host. On the other hand, host immunization with antigens from tick saliva can induce anti-tick resistance and is seen to be able to induce immunity against pathogens transmitted by ticks. Many pharmacological properties of saliva described in ticks are shared widely among other blood-feeding arthropods.     

Towards a permanent solution for controlling cattle ticks

Acaricides are essential in the short-term but do not offer a permanent solution to tick control. This situation will not change without a change of approach. A vaccine against Boophilus microplus confers partial long-term control but has little immediate effect on tick burdens. The effectiveness of acaricides and vaccination is greatest for breeds of high tick resistance. High host resistance is the key to effective long-term tick control with total resistance the ultimate aim. While improvements to acaricides and vaccines are continuously pursued, improvements to the most important single factor controlling ticks, host resistance, have been neglected. Resistance is as heritable as milk yield or growth and in tropical breeds can be increased to very high levels by selection. Despite this there are no current examples of sustained selection for tick resistance. Temperate breeds have low resistance but because of high production potentials are favoured for crossbreeding with tropical breeds. This perpetuates the need for reliance on acaricides. Selection to increase polygenic resistance of temperate breeds is impractical. However, a quantum increase can be achieved by introgressing major resistance genes. Such a gene occurs in the Belmont Adaptaur and in suitable genetic backgrounds confers 100% resistance. Total resistance is achievable and provides a permanent solution to ticks.     

Sustained testicular atrophy in bulls actively immunized against GnRH: potential to control carcase characteristics

The objectives were to determine whether active immunization against gonadotrophin releasing hormone (GnRH) induced a long-term suppression of testicular function in bulls, and to ascertain the effects of immunization against GnRH on carcase and meat quality characteristics. In experiment 1, 6-month-old Zebu bulls were assigned to: control (n=25), no treatment; immunized (n=31), immunized against GnRH at 0 and 4 months (anti-GnRH(2)), with a sub-set of bulls (n=17) immunized again at 10 months (anti-GnRH(3)). After the second immunization, testicular growth ceased for 2 months in 14/31 (45%) bulls and for at least 6 months in 17/31 (55%) bulls. Among the latter bulls (anti-GnRH(3)) the testes did not grow for >1 year after the third immunization in 5/17 (30%) bulls. In experiment 2, 22-month-old Zebu bulls were assigned to: control (n=14), no treatment; immunized (n=17), immunized against GnRH at 0, 2 and 4 weeks. The testes decreased (P<0.05) in size for 2 months after immunization in 11/17 (65%) bulls and then re-initiated growth, whilst in 6/17 (35%) bulls the testes continued to decrease in size for 4 months and did not re-initiate growth for 1 year. At slaughter, the latter immunocastrated bulls had carcase and meat quality characteristics the same as contemporary bulls that had been castrated before puberty. The findings demonstrated that active immunization against GnRH can induce a long-term suppression of testicular function in a proportion of bulls. Also, when bulls are immunocastrated after puberty, carcase and meat quality traits change from those typical of entire bulls to traits that are characteristic of long-term castrated bulls.     

Evaluating the economic damage threshold for bont tick (Amblyomma hebraeum) control in Zimbabwe

Controlling ticks and tick-borne diseases by frequent applications of acaricides (e.g., dipping) is costly, and can leave treated livestock vulnerable to epizootics of tick-borne diseases should the system of applying acaricides break down. The concept of only applying acaricides on an infrequent (strategic) basis often relies on the target tick population displaying a seasonal cycle. However, as adult bont tick (Amblyomma hebraeum) infestations in Zimbabwe's lowveld do not have a strictly seasonal pattern of occurrence, it is recommended that tick control only be applied when bont tick infestations are equal to, or greater than, their economic damage threshold. The economic damage threshold is the minimum average weekly standard female tick burden sufficient to cause damage equal in dollar value to the costs of applying tick control. Assuming that each standard female tick represents a 10 gram weight loss, the economic damage threshold (standard female ticks/week) is equivalent to the ratio of the producer price of beef (liveweight equivalent): per head cost of dipping (Eqn (3)). To illustrate the application of the threshold methodology, it was assumed that the producer price of beef was Z$1.63/kg (U.S.$0.33/kg) and that tick control cost Z$0.29/hd/dip (U.S.$0.06/hd/dip). This gave a threshold of 18 standard female ticks/head/week. Using tick counts obtained from 20 Brahman cattle held at Mbizi in southeastern Zimbabwe, it was shown that for the 1988 calendar year there were only 32 weeks when the economic damage threshold was met or exceeded. This is substantially less that the 44 dippings per year that have been, until very recently, legally required in Zimbabwe. Sensitivity analysis showed that a 10% rise in the cost of dipping reduced to 23 (a 28% decrease) the number of weeks when tick burdens exceeded the economic damage threshold. By further assuming that an acaricide application and residual effects will cause a 3–5 week interval before the next application may be required, the number of weeks when the tick burden was equal to or greater than the threshold of 18 standard females/week fell to just 9–12 weeks. Three factors may cause an alteration in the economic damage threshold: i) tick burdens may cause damage to the udders; ii) secondary infestations (e.g., screw-worm) may cause economic damage; and iii) nutritional stress of the cattle may reduce the actual average per tick weight loss. Until further data becomes available, it is recommended that the economic damage threshold methodology be used as described here, and that farmers closely observe their herds during the suggested weekly tick sampling for udder damage and secondary infestations.     

Augmentation of host's naturally acquired immunity by solubilized membrane-bound midgut proteins of the tick Rhipicephalus appendiculatus.

Immune resistance of rabbits to the hard tick Rhipicephalus appendiculatus induced by combined tick infestations and immunization with solubilized midgut membrane proteins were compared with resistance due to 1-3 infestations or immunization alone. Results demonstrate that the level of exposure of rabbits to ticks used in the study does not significantly affect the immune expression resulting from immunization and that the latter augments the resistance due to infestation.     

Methods currently used for the control of one-host ticks: their validity and proposals for future control strategies

Available methods for the control of one-host ticks as well as their possible applications in control programmes are reviewed. The advantages and disadvantages of current methods (dipping vats, spray races, hand sprays) are compared to other chemical control methods (ear-tags, pour-ons, systemics, slow-release devices). Their integrated application with other technologies based on immunological, genetic or biological approaches is discussed. Because of the great diversity of geographic, climatic, infrastructural and scientific-technological developments in vast areas of the world, the author concludes that there is no universal method of application. What really matters is to be able to develop control programmes based on local ecological, socio-economic and political facts, integrating the best of available technology. Future tick control prospects are discussed with reference to the need for standardization of criteria on requirements and the legal basis for acaricide registration, introduction of new evaluation techniques for acaricide efficacy and development of faster techniques to recognize resistance. Special emphasis is laid on the need to establish control programmes integrating diagnosis, research and production of vaccines against one-host ticks and their haemoparasites.     

Enhanced control of sheep ticks in upland sheep flocks: repercussions for red grouse co-hosts

Sheep ticks Ixodes ricinus (Acari: Ixodidae) and tick-borne diseases cause major economic losses in both upland sheep farming and moorland shoots of red grouse Lagopus lagopus scoticus. Sheep were treated with acaricide four times between March and October and double-vaccinated against louping ill virus (LIV), instead of the conventional regime of two acaricide treatments and no vaccinations, on two moors in northern England. Enhanced treatment started at Westerdale Moor in 1995 and at Danby Moor in 2000; the latter had previously represented a spatial control site. From 1992 to 2003, grouse chick condition, tick burdens, reproductive success, shooting bags and LIV seroprevalence were measured. A total of 1297 grouse chicks from 398 broods were examined for ticks. Enhanced acaricide treatment reduced tick burdens by 90%, and LIV seroprevalence decreased in relation to the number of years since treatment began. Breeding success and post-breeding densities of grouse in the current sample area remained unrelated to acaricide treatment, tick burdens or LIV seroprevalence, but 25% and 60% more grouse were shot on Westerdale and Danby, respectively, after treatment enhancement than before. By improving shooting bags, tick management schemes help to maintain the economic viability of grouse moors, which, in turn, provide upland landscape and wildlife benefits.     

Methods currently used for the control of multi-host ticks: their validity and proposals for future control strategies

Ticks have a world distribution and pest status reputation of hampering livestock production through transmission of fatal disease such as theileriosis, anaplasmosis, babesiosis, etc. and bites which cause blood loss, pain and other debilitating effects. Control of ticks is largely more effective on the host. The multi-host ticks spend most of the time off the host with short feeding periods of between four and ten days. Chemical control using dips or sprays has been the traditional method of attempting to kill these ticks during the infestation period. In many situations control, using acaricides, has been quite successful. This has been possible through correct timing of the ticks' seasonal activity and feeding periods to determine the application interval, and efficacy of the acaricides. However, the rising costs of acaricides have made it almost impossible to use these chemicals on a regular basis according to the pest problem. This is particularly true in many Third World tropical countries in which tick-associated problems are more pronounced. This has necessitated the search for alternative tick control methods on an integrated approach to pest management. For this reason, vaccination against ticks and breeding for host resistance against ticks are being studied in the hope that future control strategies will involve only the economically effective acaricide application in conjunction with these and other methods.     

On the relevance of abundance and spatial pattern for interpretations of host-parasite association data

The quantification of host-parasite associations from field data is a fundamental step towards understanding host-parasite and host-parasite-pathogen dynamics. For parasites that are not rigid host specialists, exemplified in this paper by ticks, the interpretation of host-parasite association data is difficult. Interpretations of tick collection records have largely assumed that off-host collection records offer a valid basis from which to make claims about the host specificity or generality of tick species. A simple simulation analysis of rudimentary tick-host interactions in a hypothetical 50 x 50-cell habitat demonstrates that perceptions of tick-host relationships can be strongly biased by spatial patterns. Regardless of their true level of host specificity or generality, it seems that: (i) more abundant ticks will be perceived as generalists, while rarer species will be considered specialists; and (ii) tick species that have patchy, strongly aggregated distributions will be more likely to be perceived as host specialists than species that have more dispersed or uniform distributions. Since all available evidence suggests that abundances and spatial patterns vary between tick species, there is no way of assessing the true validity of claims about host specificity without first undertaking detailed research on the relative abundances and spatial and temporal patterns of both tick and host distributions.     

Vaccination with 'concealed' antigens for tick control

Ticks are responsible for substantial economic losses to the livestock industry, necessitating intensive use of chemical acoricides in many parts of the world. Problems of chemical residues, cost of acoricides, and development of resistance by ticks, have long been recognized and have helped to stimulate interest in tick control by immunological means (see Box 1). One approach has been to seek ways to enhance the natural immunity often acquired by animals in response to tick infestation. An alternative, discussed here by Peter Willadsen and David Kemp, is to vaccinate with 'concealed' tick antigens not normally encountered by the host, and so stimulate a different immune effector mechanism.     

Vaccines for control of fertility.

Major developments in birth control vaccines are on the horizon. The human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) vaccine has entered phase II clinical trials after successful completion of phase I studies at 5 centers in India and 4 centers abroad. It is the most advanced vaccine of its type in the world. The trials are being conducted on women of proven fertility who are sexually active. The available results indicate the efficiency of the vaccine to prevent pregnancy in women at or above titres of 50 ng/ml. A vaccine inducing antibodies against gonadotropin releasing hormone (GnRH) has been approved in India for trials in postpartum women, to determine whether immunization can help prolong lactational amenorrhea. The GnRH vaccine is also in clinical trial in prostate cancer patients at 2 centers in India and in Austria and the Dominican Republic. The follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) vaccine is about to enter phase I clinical trial after completing experimental and toxicological studies. A vaccine against FSH has been developed for human males employing ovine FSH (oFSH) as an immunogen. oFSH adsorbed on alum induces antibodies reactive with human FSH in bonnet monkeys. Immunization leads to oligospermia with resultant impairment of fertilization potential. No reduction in testosterone levels has been reported. Research is in progress to identify antigens on spermatozoa, which could serve as vaccine candidates. PH-20, a protein located on the inner acrosomal membrane of capacitated sperms, has been reported to have 100% contraceptive efficacy in both sexes of guinea pigs in active immunization studies. cDNA probes of PH-20 cross-react with genomic DNAs of mouse, rat, hamster, and human. The sperm antigen, lactate dehydrogenase C4 (LDH-C4), is a glycolytic enzyme. Active immunization with LDH-C4 suppressed fertility in mice, rabbits, and baboons. SP-10, which is a testis-specific human sperm protein, is also a promising candidate.     

Strategic tick control in Burundi

Strategic tick control is an attempt to control ticks and reduce losses in animal production due to tick infestations while decreasing the cost for this control. Tick control is understood as a necessity to achieve maximum animal production from animals raised in tick-infested areas. At the same time, it has become difficult to justify intensive, year-round tick control for local breeds and their crosses. The increasing costs of acaricides, maintenance of the infrastructures, salaries for personnel, etc. have created a tick control programme where the benefits may not be adequate to justify the expense. This has been the case in Burundi. This programme with adequate participation from the cattle owners of Burundi and organizational support from government personnel can help solve this economic problem. The strategic programme reduces the period of tick control to four months each year. Once optimal participation is achieved, this period can probably be reduced to three months (Kaiser et al., 1988). The period of treatment corresponds to when there is maximal feeding activity of adult female ticks on the bovine population within a certain region. Cattle should be treated once each week throughout the four-month period in order to prevent female tick engorgement (based on the life cycle of R. appendiculatus). This will greatly reduce the number of female ticks which are available to recycle the population of ticks in the participating area. At the same time, a certain population of ticks must be maintained in order to assure contact between the cattle, ticks, and tick-borne diseases of this particular region.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Efficacy of pheromone-acaricide-impregnated tail-tag decoys for controlling the bont tick,Amblyomma hebraeum (Acari: Ixodidae), on cattle in Zimbabwe

A large-scale field test using pheromone-acaricide-impregnated plastic tail-tag decoys demonstrated excellent efficacy of these devices for control of the bont tick,Amblyomma hebraeum, on cattle in Zimbabwe. The tail tags were impregnated with a mixture containingo-nitrophenol, methyl salicylate, 2,6-dichlorophenol and phenylacetaldehyde and one of three different acaricides (cyfluthrin, flumethrin or alphacypermethrin).o-Nitrophenol and methyl salicylate are components of theA. hebraeum attraction-aggregation-attachment pheromone, while 2,6-dichlorophenol and phenylacetaldehyde are proven attractants for this tick. Botho-nitrophenol and methyl salicylate were lost gradually from the tags over 12 and 14 week periods, respectively. In field trials, tick counts were compared between cattle that received tail tags either impregnated with pheromone mixture alone, cyfluthrin and pheromone mixture, flumethrin and pheromone mixture, alphacypermethrin and pheromone mixture or were left untreated. During the first 3 month trial period, control of adult bont ticks was 94.9% with cyfluthrin tail tags and 87.5% with flumethrin tail tags. In general, there was no significant difference in bont tick numbers on cattle without tags and those with tail tags containing pheromone only. When the trial was repeated for another 3 month period, control of bont ticks with tail tags containing cyfluthrin and flumethrin was 99.3 and 95.1%, respectively. However, control of bont ticks using alphacypermethrin was only 79.2%. Overall, retention of tail tags was excellent although some loss was encountered during the rainy season. In addition to controlling bont ticks, the tail tags provided moderate control of other tick species (Rhipicephalus evertsi evertsi, Rhipicephalus zambeziensis andHyalomma spp.) simultaneously infesting cattle in the trials.Deceased.