The interaction between maternal stress and the ontogeny of the innate immune system during teleost embryogenesis: implications for aquaculture practice

The barrier defences and acellular innate immune proteins play critical roles during the early‐stage fish embryos prior to the development of functional organ systems. The innate immune proteins in the yolk of embryos are of maternal origin. Maternal stress affects the maternal‐to‐embryo transfer of these proteins and, therefore, environmental stressors may change the course of embryo development, including embryonic immunocompetency, via their deleterious effect on maternal physiology. This review focuses on the associations that exist between maternal stress, maternal endocrine disturbance and the responses of the acellular innate immune proteins of early‐stage fish embryos. Early‐stage teleostean embryos are dependent upon the adult female for the formation of the zona pellucida as an essential barrier defence, for their supply of nutrients, and for the innate immunity proteins and antibodies that are transferred from the maternal circulation to the oocytes; maternally derived hormones are also transferred, some of which (such as cortisol) are known to exert a suppressive action on some aspects of the immune defences. This review summarizes what is known about the effects of oocyte cortisol content on the immune system components in early embryos. The review also examines recent evidence that embryonic cells during early cleavage have the capacity to respond to increased maternal cortisol transfer; this emphasizes the importance of maternal and early immune competence on the later life of fishes, both in the wild and in intensive culture.     

Early arterial differentiation and patterning in the avian embryo model

Of the many models to study vascular biology the avian embryo remains an informative and powerful model system that has provided important insights into endothelial cell recruitment, assembly and remodeling during development of the circulatory system. This review highlights several discoveries in the avian system that show how arterial patterning is regulated using the model of dorsal aortae development along the embryo midline during gastrulation and neurulation. These discoveries were made possible through spatially and temporally controlled gain-of-function experiments that provided direct evidence that BMP signaling plays a pivotal role in vascular recruitment, patterning and remodeling and that Notch-signaling recruits vascular precursor cells to the dorsal aortae. Importantly, BMP ligands are broadly expressed throughout embryos but BMP signaling activation region is spatially defined by precisely regulated expression of BMP antagonists. These discoveries provide insight into how signaling, both positive and negative, regulate vascular patterning. This review also illustrates similarities of early arterial patterning along the embryonic midline in amniotes both avian and mammalians including human, evolutionarily specialized from non-amniotes such as fish and frog.     

The importance of the posterior midline region for axis initiation at early stages of the avian embryo

The avian blastoderm acts during its early stages of development as an integrative system programmed to form a single embryonic axis. Here, I report the results of a variety of transplantation experiments of the midline region at stages X-XII, which were carried out to study their relevance for axis initiation. The results of the experimental series discussed herein emphasizes the importance of the posterior midline region (including the marginal zone and Koller's sickle) for axis initiation. This ability resides mainly at stage X in the posterior side of a narrow midline region, while at stages XI-XII it is exhibited at the region which is located more anterior and lateral to the posterior midline region. This posterior midline region has developmental abilities which allow it to initiate a single embryonic axis and at the same time to prevent other regions that also have such abilities to do so. Therefore, in normal development only one embryonic axis develops in the avian blastoderm. It is proposed that the cells which are important to initiate the avian embryonic axis are concentrated mainly at the region of the posterior midline region. These cells may have organizer properties which determine the initiation site of the axis in the avian embryo.     

Oxygen Transport in the Avian Egg at High Altitude

Oxygen transport to avian embryo tissues occurs by three steps,two of which are driven by diffusion. This results in a seriesof stepwise decrements in PO₂ between atmosphere and tissue.The PO₂ decrements for embryos of the domestic fowl incubatedat different altitudes are used here to examine potential adaptationsto hypobanc hypoxia. With exposure to moderate hypoxia embryosof the domestic fowl appear to maintain adequate tissue oxygenation.Adaptive adjustments in the shell, shell membranes and chorioallantoiscomplex were not observed. However, hemoglobin O₂ affinity wasincreased and preliminary evidence suggests a redistributionof blood flow to maintain adequate oxygenation in higher priorityareas of embryonic tissue. At severe hypoxia, embryos of thedomestic fowl show decreased O₂ consumption, embryo mass andlengthened incubition period. Thus at severe hypoxin the embryoof the domestic fowl does not appear to provide a realisticmodel. Evidence from avian embryos of species native to highaltitude suggest that they are able to maintain adequate tissueoxygenation even at severe hypoxia. Preliminary evidence suggeststhat some of the blood vascular system and tissue level adaptationspresent in the chicken embryo are also present in species nativeto high altitude. One of these, an increase in embryonic hemoglobin-O₂affinity which is physiologically mediated in the chicken embryois genetically-based in the embryo of the native high-altitudespecies.     

Ecoimmunology and microbial ecology: Contributions to avian behavior,physiology, and life history

Bacteria have had a fundamental impact on vertebrate evolution not only by affecting the evolution of the immune system, but also generating complex interactions with behavior and physiology. Advances in molecular techniques have started to reveal the intricate ways in which bacteria and vertebrates have coevolved. Here, we focus on birds as an example system for understanding the fundamental impact bacteria have had on the evolution of avian immune defenses, behavior, physiology, reproduction and life histories. The avian egg has multiple characteristics that have evolved to enable effective defense against pathogenic attack. Microbial risk of pathogenic infection is hypothesized to vary with life stage, with early life risk being maximal at either hatching or fledging. For adult birds, microbial infection risk is also proposed to vary with habitat and life stage, with molt inducing a period of increased vulnerability. Bacteria not only play an important role in shaping the immune system as well as trade-offs with other physiological systems, but also for determining digestive efficiency and nutrient uptake. The relevance of avian microbiomes for avian ecology, physiology and behavior is highly topical and will likely impact on our understanding of avian welfare, conservation, captive breeding as well as for our understanding of the nature of host-microbe coevolution.     

Culture system for embryos of blue-breasted quail from the blastoderm stage to hatching.

The blue-breasted quail (Coturnix chinensis), the smallest species in the order Galliforms, is a candidate model animal for avian developmental engineering because it is precocious and prolific. This species requires 17 days to hatch and 8 to 9 weeks to mature to an adult body weight of about 50 g, whereas the Japanese quail (Coturnix japonica) requires 16 days to hatch and 6 to 8 weeks to mature to an adult body weight of 100 to 150 g. The early embryo is the most challenging embryonic stage in terms of culture and manipulation for avian biotechnology. We have evaluated various conditions for the culture of blue-breasted quail embryos from the blastoderm stage to hatching. A hatchability rate of 26% (10/39) is among the best of the various culture conditions examined in the present study and the embryo culture system should facilitate advances in avian biotechnology.     

Developmental imaging: Insights into the avian embryo

The study of embryonic events using different animal model systems is crucial for gaining insights into human development and birth defects. Biological imaging plays a major role in this effort by providing a spatiotemporal framework to link complex cell movements with molecular data. However, depending on the age of the embryo and the location of a morphogenetic event, visualization often requires the design of novel culture and imaging techniques. One of the primary model systems for biological imaging is the avian embryo, due to its accessibility to manipulation, relatively two-dimensional morphogenesis early on, and viability when grown in culture. Significant work in avian embryo culture and cell labeling, together with advances in imaging technology, now make it possible to monitor many developmental events within the period from egg laying to hatching. Here, we present the latest in avian developmental imaging, focusing on cell labeling, embryo culture, and imaging technologies.     

The Claude Bernard lecture, 1987. Embryonic chimeras: a tool for studying the development of the nervous and immune systems

Chimeras have been constructed in the avian embryo following the observation of the particular structure of the interphase nucleus in the Japanese quail (Coturnix coturnix japonica). In all embryonic and adult cell types of this species a large amount of heterochromatin is associated with the nucleolus, making quail cells readily distinguishable from those of the chick where the constitutive heterochromatin is evenly dispersed in the nucleus. These structural differences have been used to devise a cell-marking technique through which cell migrations and cell interactions during embryogenesis can be followed in the embryo in ovo by grafting quail cells into chick embryos or vice versa. This method was applied to the ontogeny of the neural crest and of the immune system. Recently quail-chick chimeras have been allowed to hatch and the immunological status of the embryonic grafts after birth scrutinized. Xenogeneic tissue grafts made in the embryo are rejected after birth with a more or less prolonged delay according to the nature of the graft. However, rejection can be prevented and a permanent state of tolerance induced for the embryonic tissue grafts by isotopically implanting the thymic epithelium from the same quail donor.     

Early ontogeny of sunbleak

The early development of sunbleak Leucaspius delineatus , from activation of ovum to juvenile, was recorded using both living and preserved materials. Five embryonic steps, one free embryo and five larval steps were identified. Hatching occurred between 73 h 25 min and 85 h 25 min (post‐activation); the free embryo period was extremely short in duration (3–16 h). The transition from larva to juvenile occurred in c . 96 days when the fish were fully scaled and the lateral line organ clearly visible. During early development, developmental thresholds were identified between steps, which suggested possible switches in ecology, microhabitat, behaviour, performance or any combination of these. During both embryo and larva periods of development, steps increased in time duration, indicating different rates of complexity of physiological and morphological developments within each step. From the results, a 'step like' model is proposed for the early development of sunbleak.     

Drosophila melanogaster embryonic haemocytes: masters of multitasking

Drosophila melanogaster haemocytes constitute the cellular arm of a robust innate immune system in flies. In the adult and larva, these cells operate as the first line of defence against invading microorganisms: they phagocytose pathogens and produce antimicrobial peptides. However, in the sterile environment of the embryo, these important immune functions are largely redundant. Instead, throughout development, embryonic haemocytes are occupied with other tasks: they undergo complex migrations and carry out several non-immune functions that are crucial for successful embryogenesis.     

Somatic transgenesis in the avian model system

The chick embryo is a versatile model system, in which classical embryology can be combined with modern molecular approaches. In the last two decades, several efficient methods have been developed to introduce exogenous genes into the chick embryo. These techniques allow alteration of gene expression levels in a spatially and temporally restricted manner, thereby circumventing embryonic lethality and/or eliminating secondary effects in other tissues. Here, we present the current status of avian somatic transgenic techniques, focusing on electroporation and retrovirus-mediated gene transfer. Electroporation allows quick and efficient gain-of-function studies based on transient misexpression of genes. Retroviral vectors, which are capable of integrating exogenous genes into the host chromosome, permit analysis of long-term effects of gene misexpression. The variety of methods available for somatic transgenesis, along with the recent completion of the chicken genome, are transforming the chick embryo into one of the most attractive model systems to examine function of genes that are important for embryonic development.     

Avian reoviruses cause apoptosis in cultured cells: viral uncoating,but not viral gene expression,is required for apoptosis induction

The cytopathic effect evidenced by cells infected with avian reovirus S1133 suggests that this virus may induce apoptosis in primary cultures of chicken embryo fibroblasts. In this report we present evidence that avian reovirus infection of cultured cells causes activation of the intracellular apoptotic program and that this activation takes place during an early stage of the viral life cycle. The ability of avian reoviruses to induce apoptosis is not restricted to a particular virus strain or to a specific cell type, since different avian reovirus isolates were able to induce apoptosis in several avian and mammalian cell lines. Apoptosis was also provoked in ribavirin-treated avian reovirus-infected cells and in cells infected with UV-irradiated reovirions, indicating that viral mRNA synthesis and subsequent steps in viral replication are not needed for apoptosis induction in avian reovirus-infected cells and that the number of inoculated virus particles, not their infectivity, is the critical factor for apoptosis induction by avian reovirus. Our finding that apoptosis is no longer induced when intracellular viral uncoating is blocked indicates that intraendosomal virion disassembly is required for apoptosis induction and that attachment and uptake of parental reovirions are not sufficient to cause apoptosis. Taken together, our results suggest that apoptosis is triggered from within the infected cell by viral products generated after intraendosomal uncoating of parental reovirions.     

A comparative study of embryonic development of some bird species with different patterns of postnatal growth

Some studies show that birds with high postnatal growth rates (e.g. altricial species) are characterized by a rapid early development of "supply" organs, such as digestive organs. Birds with low postnatal growth rates (e.g. precocial species) exhibit a slower early development of these organs and a more rapid early development of other "demand" organs, such as brain, muscles, skeleton and feathers. To test whether these differences can be traced back to early embryonic development and whether they can be associated with changes in developmental timing, i.e. heterochrony, we compared embryos of the precocial quail and the altricial fieldfare, two bird species with low and high postnatal growth rates, respectively. We used classical staging techniques that use developmental landmarks to categorize embryonic maturity as well as morphological measurements. These techniques were combined with immune detection of muscle specific proteins in the somites. Our data showed that the anlagen of the head, brain and eyes develop earlier in the quail than in the fieldfare in contrast to the gut which develops earlier in the fieldfare than in the quail. Our data also showed that the quail and the fieldfare displayed different rates of myotome formation in the somites which contribute to muscle formation in the limbs and thorax. We believe these observations are connected with important differences in neonatal characteristics, such as the size of the brain, eyes, organs for locomotion and digestion. This leads us to the conclusion that selection for late ontogenetic characteristics can alter early embryonic development and that growth rate is of fundamental importance for the patterning of avian embryonic development. It also appears that this comparative system offers excellent opportunities to test hypotheses about heterochrony.     

SUMO-specific protease 1 is critical for early lymphoid development through regulation of STAT5 activation

Small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) modification has emerged as an important regulatory mechanism during embryonic development. However, it is not known whether SUMOylation plays a role in the development of the immune system. Here, we show that SUMO-specific protease 1 (SENP1) is essential for the development of early T and B cells. STAT5, a key regulator of lymphoid development, is modified by SUMO-2 and is specifically regulated by SENP1. In the absence of SENP1, SUMO-2 modified STAT5 accumulates in early lymphoid precursors, resulting in a block in its acetylation and subsequent signaling. These results demonstrate a crucial role of SENP1 in?the regulation of STAT5 activation during early lymphoid development.     

Growth and metabolism in the embryonic white-spotted bamboo shark, Chiloscyllium plagiosum: comparison with embryonic birds and reptiles

Birds and reptiles have been important models for studying the energetics of embryonic development. Studies on these groups reveal three metabolic patterns: an exponential increase in metabolism with embryo age, a sigmoidal increase with age, or a sigmoidal increase followed by a decrease before hatching. Models developed to explain avian metabolic patterns and developmental costs partition total costs between growth and maintenance. To test the generality of these models, we examined embryonic energetics of the oviparous white-spotted bamboo shark Chiloscyllium plagiosum. Oviparous sharks must actively ventilate during development, which could increase their development costs relative to birds and reptiles. Our results demonstrated that bamboo shark embryos have a peaked metabolic pattern and sigmoidal increase in body mass similar to ratites, crocodilians, and some turtles. The total cost of development was higher in bamboo sharks than in reptiles and many birds. However, calculations reveal that the high cost of bamboo shark development can be explained by the relatively long incubation time rather than the additional cost of muscular movement. Finally, an avian model can reasonably describe shark embryonic metabolism, suggesting that movement costs do not significantly alter the metabolic pattern during development.     

Thymic dependence of cell-mediated immunity to avian sarcomas in chickens. Immunological characterization of a nonvirion antigen in virus-infected cells.

Chickens bearing tumors which have been induced by avian retroviruses express cellmediated immune responsiveness against antigens which are associated with these neoplasms. We have employed a peripheral lymphocyte stimulation test to characterize antigens which are found in the supernatant fluids of avian retrovirus-infected chicken embryo fibroblast (CEF) cells and in the plasma of birds which have been inoculated with avian myeloblastosis virus (AMV). The results indicated that the antigenic activity being measured was virus group specific, cell transformation independent, and nonvirion in nature. Paradoxically, expression of such antigen(s) was restricted to cells which were actively synthesizing progeny avian retrovirus particles, and was absent in mammalian nonproducer cells which had been transformed by avian sarcoma viruses. Ability to respond immunologically to such antigen(s) was present in animals which had been inoculated with either leukosis or sarcoma viruses. Thymectomy, but not bursectomy, was stimulatory to tumor growth and abolished sensitized lymphocyte immune responsiveness in this system.     

Role of the thyroid in the involution of the mesonephric Malpighian corpuscles in the chick embryo

The mesonephros of the chick embryo normally begins to regress during the second half of embryonic life. Experimental methods, such as adenohypophysis grafting, hypophysectomy or use of antithyroid drugs, which stimulate or depress the thyroid function of the embryo, modified accordingly the regressive processes occurring in the mesonephric Malpighian corpuscles, particularly at the level of the glomerular basement laminae. These results as well as the known sensitivity of the mesonephros to thyroxine and the concordance between the steps of embryonic thyroid development and the mesonephric modifications show that the thyroid normally plays a major determining role in this phenomenon.