Recognition of Phytophthora infestans Avr4 by potato R4 is triggered by C-terminal domains comprising W motifs

Oomycete RXLR-dEER effector proteins are rapidly evolving proteins with the selective pressure targeted predominantly at their C-terminal ends. The majority of RXLR-dEER proteins have recognizable motifs of 21–30 amino acids in the C-terminal domain that are named after conserved amino acid residues at fixed positions within the respective motifs. In this article, it is reported that the Phytophthora infestans RXLR-dEER protein Avr4 contains three W motifs and one Y motif in its C-terminal domain. Agroinfection assays using constructs encoding modified forms of PiAvr4 have shown that the region containing the W2 motif, in combination with either the W1 or W3 motif, triggers a necrotic response in potato plants carrying the resistance gene R4 . By mining the superfamily of avirulence homologues (Avh) deduced from three sequenced Phytophthora genomes, several Avh proteins were identified as homologues of PiAvr4: six in P. infestans , one in P. ramorum and seven in P. sojae . One very close homologue of PiAvr4 was cloned from the sibling species, P. mirabilis. This species is not pathogenic on potato but, similar to PiAvr4, PmirAvh4 triggered a necrotic response on potato clones carrying R4 , but not on clones lacking R4 . Genes encoding RXLR-dEER effectors are often located in regions showing genome rearrangements. Alignment of the genomic region harbouring PiAvr4 with syntenic regions in P. sojae and P. ramorum revealed that PiAvr4 is located on a 100-kb indel block and is surrounded by transposable elements.     

Agroinfiltration and PVX Agroinfection in Potato and Nicotiana benthamiana

Agroinfiltration and PVX agroinfection are two efficient transient expression assays for functional analysis of candidate genes in plants. The most commonly used agent for agroinfiltration is Agrobacterium tumefaciens, a pathogen of many dicot plant species. This implies that agroinfiltration can be applied to many plant species. Here, we present our protocols and expected results when applying these methods to the potato (Solanum tuberosum), its related wild tuber-bearing Solanum species (Solanum section Petota) and the model plant Nicotiana benthamiana. In addition to functional analysis of single genes, such as resistance (R) or avirulence (Avr) genes, the agroinfiltration assay is very suitable for recapitulating the R-AVR interactions associated with specific host pathogen interactions by simply delivering R and Avr transgenes into the same cell. However, some plant genotypes can raise nonspecific defense responses to Agrobacterium, as we observed for example for several potato genotypes. Compared to agroinfiltration, detection of AVR activity with PVX agroinfection is more sensitive, more high-throughput in functional screens and less sensitive to nonspecific defense responses to Agrobacterium. However, nonspecific defense to PVX can occur and there is a risk to miss responses due to virus-induced extreme resistance. Despite such limitations, in our experience, agroinfiltration and PVX agroinfection are both suitable and complementary assays that can be used simultaneously to confirm each other''s results.     

Qualitative and quantitative late blight resistance in the potato cultivar Sarpo Mira is determined by the perception of five distinct RXLR effectors

Potato defends against Phytophthora infestans infection by resistance (R)-gene-based qualitative resistance as well as a quantitative field resistance. R genes are renowned to be rapidly overcome by this oomycete, and potato cultivars with a decent and durable resistance to current P. infestans populations are hardly available. However, potato cultivar Sarpo Mira has retained resistance in the field over several years. We dissected the resistance of 'Sarpo Mira' in a segregating population by matching the responses to P. infestans RXLR effectors with race-specific resistance to differential strains. The resistance is based on the combination of four pyramided qualitative R genes and a quantitative R gene that was associated with field resistance. The qualitative R genes include R3a, R3b, R4, and the newly identified Rpi-Smira1. The qualitative resistances matched responses to avirulence (AVR)3a, AVR3b, AVR4, and AVRSmira1 RXLR effectors and were overcome by particular P. infestans strains. The quantitative resistance was determined to be conferred by a novel gene, Rpi-Smira2. It was only detected under field conditions and was associated with responses to the RXLR effector AvrSmira2. We foresee that effector-based resistance breeding will facilitate selecting and combining qualitative and quantitative resistances that may lead to a more durable resistance to late blight.     

Inducible Positive Mutant Screening System to Unveil the Signaling Pathway of Late Blight Resistance

Late blight is the most devastating potato disease and it also causes serious yield loss in tomato.Several disease resistance genes (R genes) to late blight have been cloned from potato in the past decade.However,the resistance mechanisms remain elusive.Tomato and potato belong to the botanical family Solanaceace and share remarkably conserved genome structure.Since tomato is a model system in genetic and plant pathology research,we used tomato to develop a powerful mutant screening system that will greatly facilitate the analysis of the signaling pathway of resistance to Phytophthora infestans.First we proved that the R3a transgenic tomatoes developed specific hypersensitive cell death response (HR) to P.infestans strains carrying the corresponding avirulence gene Avr3a,indicating that the signaling pathway from the R3a-Avr3a recognition to HR is conserved between potato and tomato.Second,we generated transgenic tomatoes carrying both R3a and Avr3a genes,with the latter under the control of a glucocorticiod-inducible promoter.Dexamethasone induced expression of Avr3a and resulted in localized HR.This versatile system can be used to construct a mutant library to screen surviving mutants whose resistance signal transduction was interrupted,providing the basis to identify key genes involved in the resistance to late blight in Solanaceae.     

Agroinfection-based high-throughput screening reveals specific recognition of INF elicitins in Solanum

We adapted and optimized the use of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens binary PVX expression system (PVX agroinfection) to screen Solanum plants for response to pathogen elicitors and applied the assay to identify a total of 11 clones of Solanum huancabambense and Solanum microdontum , out of 31 species tested, that respond to the elicitins INF1, INF2A and INF2B of Phytophthora infestans . Prior to this study, response to INF elicitins was only known in Nicotiana spp. within the Solanaceae. The identified S. huancabambense and S. microdontum clones also exhibited hypersensitivity-like cell death following infiltration with purified recombinant INF1, INF2A and INF2B, thereby validating the screening protocol. Comparison of INF elicitin activity revealed that Nicotiana plants responded to significantly lower concentrations than Solanum , suggesting variable levels of sensitivity to INF elicitins. We exploited natural variation in response to INF elicitins in the identified Solanum accessions to evaluate the relationship between INF recognition and late blight resistance. Interestingly, several INF-responsive Solanum plants were susceptible to P. infestans . Also, an S. microdontum  × Solanum tuberosum (potato) population that segregates for INF response was generated but failed to identify a measurable contribution of INF response to resistance. These results suggest that in Solanum , INF elicitins are recognized as general elicitors and do not have a measurable contribution to disease resistance.     

Agroinfiltration is a versatile tool that facilitates comparative analyses of Avr9/Cf-9-induced and Avr4/Cf-4-induced necrosis

The avirulence genes Avr9 and Avr4 from the fungal tomato pathogen Cladosporium fulvum encode extracellular proteins that elicit a hypersensitive response when injected into leaves of tomato plants carrying the matching resistance genes, Cf-9 and Cf-4, respectively. We successfully expressed both Avr9 and Avr4 genes in tobacco with the Agrobacterium tumefaciens transient transformation assay (agroinfiltration). In addition, we expressed the matching resistance genes, Cf-9 and Cf-4, through agroinfiltration. By combining transient Cf gene expression with either transgenic plants expressing one of the gene partners, Potato virus X (PVX)-mediated Avr gene expression, or elicitor injections, we demonstrated that agroinfiltration is a reliable and versatile tool to study Avr/Cf-mediated recognition. Significantly, agroinfiltration can be used to quantify and compare Avr/Cf-induced responses. Comparison of different Avr/Cf-interactions within one tobacco leaf showed that Avr9/Cf-9-induced necrosis developed slower than necrosis induced by Avr4/Cf-4. Quantitative analysis demonstrated that this temporal difference was due to a difference in Avr gene activities. Transient expression of matching Avr/Cf gene pairs in a number of plant families indicated that the signal transduction pathway required for Avr/Cf-induced responses is conserved within solanaceous species. Most non-solanaceous species did not develop specific Avr/Cf-induced responses. However, co-expression of the Avr4/Cf-4 gene pair in lettuce resulted in necrosis, providing the first proof that a resistance (R) gene can function in a different plant family.     

Effector genomics accelerates discovery and functional profiling of potato disease resistance and phytophthora infestans avirulence genes

Potato is the world's fourth largest food crop yet it continues to endure late blight, a devastating disease caused by the Irish famine pathogen Phytophthora infestans. Breeding broad-spectrum disease resistance (R) genes into potato (Solanum tuberosum) is the best strategy for genetically managing late blight but current approaches are slow and inefficient. We used a repertoire of effector genes predicted computationally from the P. infestans genome to accelerate the identification, functional characterization, and cloning of potentially broad-spectrum R genes. An initial set of 54 effectors containing a signal peptide and a RXLR motif was profiled for activation of innate immunity (avirulence or Avr activity) on wild Solanum species and tentative Avr candidates were identified. The RXLR effector family IpiO induced hypersensitive responses (HR) in S. stoloniferum, S. papita and the more distantly related S. bulbocastanum, the source of the R gene Rpi-blb1. Genetic studies with S. stoloniferum showed cosegregation of resistance to P. infestans and response to IpiO. Transient co-expression of IpiO with Rpi-blb1 in a heterologous Nicotiana benthamiana system identified IpiO as Avr-blb1. A candidate gene approach led to the rapid cloning of S. stoloniferum Rpi-sto1 and S. papita Rpi-pta1, which are functionally equivalent to Rpi-blb1. Our findings indicate that effector genomics enables discovery and functional profiling of late blight R genes and Avr genes at an unprecedented rate and promises to accelerate the engineering of late blight resistant potato varieties.     

Cloning and characterization of r3b; members of the r3 superfamily of late blight resistance genes show sequence and functional divergence

Massive resistance (R) gene stacking is considered to be one of the most promising approaches to provide durable resistance to potato late blight for both conventional and genetically modified breeding strategies. The R3 complex locus on chromosome XI in potato is an example of natural R gene stacking, because it contains two closely linked R genes (R3a and R3b) with distinct resistance specificities to Phytophthora infestans. Here, we report about the positional cloning of R3b. Both transient and stable transformations of susceptible tobacco and potato plants showed that R3b conferred full resistance to incompatible P. infestans isolates. R3b encodes a coiled-coil nucleotide-binding site leucine-rich repeat protein and exhibits 82% nucleotide identity with R3a located in the same R3 cluster. The R3b gene specifically recognizes Avr3b, a newly identified avirulence factor from P. infestans. R3b does not recognize Avr3a, the corresponding avirulence gene for R3a, showing that, despite their high sequence similarity, R3b and R3a have clearly distinct recognition specificities. In addition to the Rpi-mcd1/Rpi-blb3 locus on chromosome IV, the R3 locus on chromosome XI is the second example of an R-gene cluster with multiple genes recognizing different races of P. infestans.     

The R1 gene for potato resistance to late blight (Phytophthora infestans) belongs to the leucine zipper/NBS/LRR class of plant resistance genes

Late blight caused by the oomycete Phytophthora infestans is the most destructive disease in potato cultivation worldwide. New, more virulent P. infestans strains have evolved which overcome the genetic resistance that has been introgressed by conventional breeding from wild potato species into commercial varieties. R genes (for single-gene resistance) and genes for quantitative resistance to late blight are present in the germplasm of wild and cultivated potato. The molecular basis of single-gene and quantitative resistance to late blight is unknown. We have cloned R1, the first gene for resistance to late blight, by combining positional cloning with a candidate gene approach. The R1 gene is member of a gene family. It encodes a protein of 1293 amino acids with a molecular mass of 149.4 kDa. The R1 gene belongs to the class of plant genes for pathogen resistance that have a leucine zipper motif, a putative nucleotide binding domain and a leucine-rich repeat domain. The most closely related plant resistance gene (36% identity) is the Prf gene for resistance to Pseudomonas syringae of tomato. R1 is located within a hot spot for pathogen resistance on potato chromosome V. In comparison to the susceptibility allele, the resistance allele at the R1 locus represents a large insertion of a functional R gene.     

Molecular and biochemical basis of the interaction between tomato and its fungal pathogen Cladosporium fulvum

The interaction between the biotrophic fungal pathogen Cladosporium fulvum and tomato complies with the genefor-gene model. Resistance, expressed as a hypersensitive response (HR) followed by other defence responses, is based on recognition of products of avirulence genes from C. fulvum (race-specific elicitors) by receptors (putative products of resistance genes) in the host plant tomato. The AVR9 elicitor is a 28 amino acid (aa) peptide and the AVR4 elicitor a 106 aa peptide which both induce HR in tomato plants carrying the complementary resistance genes Cf9 and Cf4, respectively. The 3-D structure of the AVR9 peptide, as determined by 1H NMR, revealed that AVR9 belongs to a family of peptides with a cystine knot motif. This motif occurs in channel blockers, peptidase inhibitors and growth factors. The Cf9 resistance gene encodes a membrane-anchored extracellular glycoprotein which contains leucine-rich repeats (LRRs). 125I labeled AVR9 peptide shows the same affinity for plasma membranes of Cf9+ and Cf9- tomato leaves. Membranes of solanaceous plants tested so far all contain homologs of the Cf9 gene and show similar affinities for AVR9. It is assumed that for induction of HR, at least two plant proteins (presumably CF9 and one of his homologs) interact directly or indirectly with the AVR9 peptide which possibly initiates modulation and dimerisation of the receptor, and activation of various other proteins involved in downstream events eventually leading to HR. We have created several mutants of the Avr9 gene, expressed them in the potato virus X (PVX) expression system and tested their biological activity on Cf9 genotypes of tomato. A positive correlation was observed between the biological activity of the mutant AVR9 peptides and their affinity for tomato plasma membranes. Recent results on structure and biological activity of AVR4 peptides encoded by avirulent and virulent alleles of the Avr4 gene (based on expression studies in PVX) are also discussed as well as early defence responses induced by elicitors in tomato leaves and tomato cell suspensions.     

Extreme resistance to potato virus X infection in plants expressing a modified component of the putative viral replicase.

Three types of mutation were introduced into the sequence encoding the GDD motif of the putative replicase component of potato virus X (PVX). All three mutations rendered the viral genome completely noninfectious when inoculated into Nicotiana clevelandii or into protoplasts of Nicotiana tabacum (cv. Samsun NN). In order to test whether these negative mutations could inactivate the viral genome in trans, the mutant genes were expressed in transformed N.tabacum (cv. Samsun NN) under control of the 35S RNA promoter of cauliflower mosaic virus and the transformed lines were inoculated with PVX. In 10 lines tested in which the GDD motif was expressed as GAD or GED there was no effect on susceptibility to PVX. In two of four lines transformed to express the ADD form of the conserved motif, the F1 and F2 progeny plants were highly resistant to infection by PVX, although only to strains closely related to the source of the transgene. The resistance was associated with suppression of PVX accumulation in the inoculated and systemic leaves and in protoplasts of the transformed plants, although some low level viral RNA production was observed in the inoculated but not the systemic leaves when the inoculum was as high as 100 or 250 micrograms/ml PVX RNA. These results suggest for a plant virus, as reported previously for Q beta phage, that virus resistance may be engineered by expression of dominant negative mutant forms of viral genes in transformed cells.     

A single region of the Phytophthora infestans avirulence effector Avr3b functions in both cell death induction and plant immunity suppression

As a destructive plant pathogen, Phytophthora infestans secretes diverse host-entering RxLR effectors to facilitate infection. One critical RxLR effector, PiAvr3b, not only induces effector-triggered immunity (ETI), which is associated with the potato resistance protein StR3b, but also suppresses pathogen-associated molecular pattern (PAMP)-triggered immunity (PTI). To date, the molecular basis underlying such dual activities remains unknown. Based on phylogenetic analysis of global P. infestans isolates, we found two PiAvr3b isoforms that differ by three amino acids. Despite this sequence variation, the two isoforms retain the same properties in activating the StR3b-mediated hypersensitive response (HR) and inhibiting necrosis induced by three PAMPs (PiNpp, PiINF1, and PsXeg1) and an RxLR effector (Pi10232). Using a combined mutagenesis approach, we found that the dual activities of PiAvr3b were tightly linked and determined by 88 amino acids at the C-terminus. We further determined that either the W60 or the E134 residue of PiAvr3b was essential for triggering StR3b-associated HR and inhibiting PiNpp- and Pi10232-associated necrosis, while the S99 residue partially contributed to PTI suppression. Additionally, nuclear localization of PiAvr3b was required to stimulate HR and suppress PTI, but not to inhibit Pi10232-associated cell death. Our study revealed that PiAvr3b suppresses the plant immune response at different subcellular locations and provides an example in which a single amino acid of an RxLR effector links ETI induction and cell death suppression.     

Revealing the importance of meristems and roots for the development of hypersensitive responses and full foliar resistance to Phytophthora infestans in the resistant potato cultivar Sarpo Mira

The defence responses of potato against Phytophthora infestans were studied using the highly resistant Sarpo Mira cultivar. The effects of plant integrity, meristems, and roots on the hypersensitive response (HR), plant resistance, and the regulation of PR genes were analysed. Sarpo Mira shoots and roots grafted with the susceptible Bintje cultivar as well as non-grafted different parts of Sarpo Mira plants were inoculated with P. infestans. The progress of the infection and the number of HR lesions were monitored, and the regulation of PR genes was compared in detached and attached leaves. Additionally, the antimicrobial activity of plant extracts was assessed. The presented data show that roots are needed to achieve full pathogen resistance, that the removal of meristems in detached leaves inhibits the formation of HR lesions, that PR genes are differentially regulated in detached leaves compared with leaves of whole plants, and that antimicrobial compounds accumulate in leaves and roots of Sarpo Mira plants challenged with P. infestans. While meristems are necessary for the formation of HR lesions, the roots of Sarpo Mira plants participate in the production of defence-associated compounds that increase systemic resistance. Based on the literature and on the presented results, a model is proposed for mechanisms involved in Sarpo Mira resistance that may apply to other resistant potato cultivars.     

Agrobacterium transient expression system as a tool for the isolation of disease resistance genes: application to the Rx2 locus in potato

Rx2 confers resistance against potato virus X (PVX). To clone Rx2, we developed a system based on Agrobacterium-mediated transient expression of candidate R genes in transgenic tobacco leaves expressing the PVX coat protein elicitor of Rx2-mediated resistance. Using this system, a potato gene eliciting HR specifically in the presence of the elicitor was identified. Based on genetical and functional analysis, it is concluded that the cloned gene is Rx2. The transient expression system is potentially adaptable to cloning of any other resistance gene. The Rx2 locus is on chromosome V of potato and the encoded protein is highly similar to the products of Rx1 and Rxh1 encoded on potato chromosome XII. Rxh1 has been shown elsewhere to encode a potato cyst nematode resistance gene Gpa2. All three proteins are in the leucine zipper-nucleotide binding site-leucine rich repeat class of resistance gene products. Rx1 and Rx2 are functionally identical and are almost identical in the C terminal region consistent with a role of the leucine rich repeats in recognition of the PVX coat protein. In the N terminal, half there are some regions where the Rx1 and Rx2 proteins are more similar to each other than to the Rxh1 protein. However, in other regions these proteins are more similar to Rxh1 than to each other. Based on this mosaic pattern of sequence similarity, we conclude that sequence exchange occurs repeatedly between genetically unlinked disease resistance genes through a process of gene conversion.     

A RanGAP protein physically interacts with the NB-LRR protein Rx, and is required for Rx-mediated viral resistance

Race-specific disease resistance in plants is mediated by the products of host disease resistance (R) genes. Plant genomes possess hundreds of R gene homologs encoding nucleotide-binding and leucine-rich repeat (NB-LRR) proteins. NB-LRR proteins induce a disease resistance response following recognition of pathogen-encoded avirulence (Avr) proteins. However, little is known about the general mechanisms by which NB-LRR proteins recognize Avr proteins or how they subsequently induce defense responses. The Rx NB-LRR protein of potato confers resistance to potato virus X (PVX). Using a co-purification strategy, we have identified a Ran GTPase-activating protein (RanGAP2) as an Rx-interacting protein. We show by co-immunoprecipitation that this interaction is mediated in planta through the putative signaling domain at the Rx amino terminus. Overexpression of RanGAP2 results in activation of certain Rx derivatives. Likewise, knocking down RanGAP2 expression in Nicotiana benthamiana by virus-induced gene silencing compromises Rx-mediated resistance to PVX. Thus, we have demonstrated a novel role for a RanGAP in the function of a plant disease resistance response.     

Molecular Determinants of Resistance Activation and Suppression by Phytophthora infestans Effector IPI-O

Despite intensive breeding efforts, potato late blight, caused by the oomycete pathogen Phytophthora infestans, remains a threat to potato production worldwide because newly evolved pathogen strains have consistently overcome major resistance genes. The potato RB gene, derived from the wild species Solanum bulbocastanum, confers resistance to most P. infestans strains through recognition of members of the pathogen effector family IPI-O. While the majority of IPI-O proteins are recognized by RB to elicit resistance (e.g. IPI-O1, IPI-O2), some family members are able to elude detection (e.g. IPI-O4). In addition, IPI-O4 blocks recognition of IPI-O1, leading to inactivation of RB-mediated programmed cell death. Here, we report results that elucidate molecular mechanisms governing resistance elicitation or suppression of RB by IPI-O. Our data indicate self-association of the RB coiled coil (CC) domain as well as a physical interaction between this domain and the effectors IPI-O4 and IPI-O1. We identified four amino acids within IPI-O that are critical for interaction with the RB CC domain and one of these amino acids, at position 129, determines hypersensitive response (HR) elicitation in planta. IPI-O1 mutant L129P fails to induce HR in presence of RB while IPI-O4 P129L gains the ability to induce an HR. Like IPI-O4, IPI-O1 L129P is also able to suppress the HR mediated by RB, indicating a critical step in the evolution of this gene family. Our results point to a model in which IPI-O effectors can affect RB function through interaction with the RB CC domain.