Effect of sodium butyrate on mammalian cells in culture: A review

Summary Sodium butyrate produces reversible changes in morphology, growth rate, and enzyme activities of several mammalian cell types in culture. Some of these changes are similar to those produced by agents which increase the intracellular level of adenosine 3′,5′-cyclic monophosphate (cAMP) or by analogs of cAMP. Sodium butyrate increases the intracellular level of cAMP by about two fold in neuroblastoma cells; therefore, some of the effects of sodium butyrate on these cells may in part be mediated by cAMP. Sodium butyrate appears to have properties of a good chemotherapeutic agent for neuroblastoma tumors because the treatment of neuroblastoma cells in culture causes cell death and “differentiation”; however, it is either innocuous or produces reversible morphological and biochemical alterations in other cell types.     

Butyric acid: A small fatty acid with diverse biological functions

Butyric acid, a 4-carbon fatty acid, affects morphology, growth rate and gene expression in mammalian cells in culture. Sodium butyrate (0.5 to 3 mM) produces reversible growth inhibition in several mammalian tumor cells in culture, but it causes cell death only in human neuroblastomas and human glioma cells in culture. Sodium butyrate in combination with currently used tumor therapeutic agents produced a synergistic, an additive or no effect on growth of mouse neuroblastoma cells and rat glioma cells in culture. At least in NB cells, the cell death and growth inhibition may be related to the reduction in anaerobic glycolysis. Sodium butyrate increases the expression of one or more differentiated functions in mouse NB cells, mouse erythroleukemic cells, human epidermoid carcinoma, human colon carcinoma cells and Chinese hamster ovary cells. The induction of differentiation by butyrate may in part be related to an increase in the cellular cyclic AMP level. Sodium butyrate increases the activities of several enzymes, whereas, it decreases the activities of some. The increase of some enzymes appears to be correlated to hyperacetylation of histones. $\text{In}$$\text{vitro}$ studies suggest that sodium butyrate may be useful in the management of neoplasms by causing selective cell death, and/or cell differentiation and by increasing the cell killing effect in conjuction with currently used tumor therapeutic agents. Sodium butyrate can also be used as a tool to study the regulation of gene expression in mammalian cells.     

Sodium Butyrate Induces Apoptosis in MSN Neuroblastoma Cells in a Calcium Independent Pathway

Sodium butyrate (NaBt), a histone deacetylase inhibitor, can cause apoptosis in a number of cancer cells. However, the mechanism of this action is poorly understood. Increased intracellular [Ca²⁺] level has been suggested as a likely mechanism, but there is little corroborating data. In this report we provide evidence that NaBt-treated MSN neuroblastoma cells undergo massive apoptosis in the presence of serum and regardless of external or internal [Ca²⁺] levels. Presented data suggest that apoptotic effect of NaBt is both time- and dose-dependent (LD₅₀ 1 mM); and that, presence of serum or cAMP, a second messenger molecule that modulates the apoptotic program in a wide variety of cells could not circumvent the apoptotic effect of NaBt. Our findings suggest that NaBt-induced apoptosis in MSN neuroblastoma cells occurs via a pathway that is independent of Ca²⁺flux, intracellular [Ca²⁺] or cAMP levels. Further, we also present data that exclude a role for PKC or histones acetylation.Special issue dedicated to Lawrence F. Eng     

Effects of sodium butyrate, a new pharmacological agent, on cells in culture

Sodium butyrate, at millimolar concentrations, when added to cell cultures produces many morphological and biochemical modifications in a reversible manner. Some of them occur in all cell lines. They concern regulatory mechanisms of gene expression and cell growth: an hyperacetylation of histone resulting from an inhibition of histone deacetylase and an arrest of cell proliferation are almost constantly observed. Some other modifications vary from one cell type to another: induction of proteins, including enzymes, hormones, hemoglobin, inhibition of cell differentiation, reversion of transformed characteristics of cells to normal morphological and biochemical pattern, increase in interferon antiviral efficiency and induction of integrated viruses. Most if not all these effects of butyrate could result from histone hyperacetylation, from changes in chromatin structures as measured by accessibility to DNases and from modifications in cytoskeleton assembly. We do not know at the present time whether butyrate acts on a very specific target site in cell or if it acts on several cell components.     

The role of butyrate in the reverse transformation reaction in mammalian cells.

The reverse transformation reaction of Chinese hamster ovary cells from compact, epithelial-like, randomly growing, heavily knobbed, lectin reactive cells into stretched, tighly adherent, smooth-surfaced, lectin resistant, fibroblast-like cells normally elicited by dibutyryl cAMP can be produced to its complete extent by N6-monobutyryl cAMP or 8-bromo-cAMP, O2'-monobutyryl cAMP is ineffective as is cAMP itself in the absence of an inhibitor of phosphodiesterase activity. In the presence of a phosphodiesterase inhibitor, cAMP is fully effective. These results indicate that the role of the butyryl groups of dibutyryl cAMP and, especially, the N6-butyryl, in the reverse transformation reaction is protection of the cAMP analogue from degradation. Butyrate at concentrations of about 1 mM does produce a response which to some extent mimics that of cAMP analogues. The cells, however, fail to assume a fibroblastic-like shape, but rather become flattened. The butyrate effect is much slower and less readily reversible than that evoked by cAMP analogues. Butyrate produces an approximately 2-fold increase in intracellular cAMP levels. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that butyrate effects, in part, are mediated by AMP.     

Effects of sodium butyrate,a new pharmacological agent,on cells in culture

Summary Sodium butyrate, at millimolar concentrations, when added to cell cultures produces many morphological and biochemical modifications in a reversible manner. Some of them occur in all cell lines. They concern regulatory mechanisms of gene expression and cell growth: an hyperacetylation of histone resulting from an inhibition of histone deacetylase and an arrest of cell proliferation are almost constantly observed. Some other modifications vary from one cell type to another: induction of proteins, including enzymes, hormones, hemoglobin, inhibition of cell differentiation, reversion of transformed characteristics of cells to normal morphological and biochemical pattern, increase in interferon antiviral efficiency and induction of integrated viruses. Most if not all these effects of butyrate could result from histone hyperacetylation, from changes in chromatin structures as measured by accessibility to DNases and from modifications in cytoskeleton assembly. We do not know at the present time whether butyrate acts on a very specific target site in cell or if it acts on several cell components.     

Effects of cyclic AMP and butyrate on cell cycle,DNA, RNA,and purine synthesis of cultured astrocytes

Dibutyryl cyclic monophosphate (dBcAMP) has been shown to inhibit growth, and alter the morphology of astrocytes. However, the potential contribution of its hydrolytic product, butyrate, in inducing some of the changes that have been attributed to dBcAMP, is not clear. DNA, RNA, and purine synthesis were therefore studied in primary astrocyte cultures after 24 hours of exposure to varying concentrations of butyrate, dBcAMP, and agents that increase intracellular cAMP levels. Progression of cells through cell cycle was also studied by flow cytometry. Dibutyryl cAMP partially arrested cells in Go/G1 phase of cell cycle while sodium butyrate increased the percentage population of cells in G2/M phase. DNA synthesis and de novo purine synthesis were inhibited after treatment with dBcAMP, sodium butyrate, and various drugs that increase intracellular cAMP levels. RNA synthesis was increased with cAMP but was not affected by sodium butyrate. Our study shows that at millimolar concentrations, butyrate is capable of altering the cell cycle and inhibiting DNA synthesis in primary astrocyte cultures, in a manner that is similar although not identical to the effects of dBcAMP.     

Effects of adenosine 3':5'-monophosphate and related agents on ribonucleic acid synthesis and morphological differentiation in mouse neuroblastoma cells in culture.

A variety of compounds were assessed for their ability to induce morphological differentiation and to affect the synthesis of RNA in uncloned mouse neuroblastoma cells in culture. The stimulation of morphological differentiation in uncloned cells after exposure for 48 hours to concentrations of 3 times 10-7 to 3 times 10-4 M papavarine or 10-9 to 10-3 M dibutyryl adenosine 3':5'-monophosphate (dibutyryl-cAMP) was associated, in part, with a concentration-dependent decrease in incorporation of [5-3H]uridine into ribosomal RNA (rRNA) and heterogeneous RNA (HnRNA). The latter effect on cellular RNA produced by papavarine occurred within 1 hour after its addition to the medium and was associated with impaired uptake of radioactive precursor into uridine nucleotides and reduction in the intracellular concentration of uridine 5'-triphosphate (UTP). Dibutytyl-cAMP produced a decreased in the specific radioactivity of UTP without affecting the concentration of UTP in the tumor cells. The effects of papavarine and dibutyryl-cAMP could be distinguished further by the 50% reduction of acetylcholinesterase activity produced by papavarine, but not by dibutyryl-cAMP. Papavarine did not, however, reduce the cellular level of the soluble enzyme, adenine phosphoribosyltransferase. Sodium butyrate, while producing morphological effects similar to those of papavarine and dibutyryl-cAMP at equimolar concentrations, caused no significant changes in the incorporation of [5-3H]uridine into rRNA and HnRNA; however, acetylcholinesterase activity was stimulated 6- to 7-fold above control levels. In contrast to the other differentiating agents examined, addition of 10-9 to 3 times 10-4 M concentrations of cAMP to the tissue culture medium enhanced morphological differentiation of nueroblastoma cells, and caused a 10- to 20-fold stimulation of the incorporation of [5-3H]uridine into rRNA and HnRNA at concentrations of 10-4 M and higher. This effect observed only at high concentrations of cyclic nucleotide was accompanied by an elevation in the specific acitivty of UTP, These studies suggest that the morphological response of neuroblastoma cells is not necessarily associated with concomitant alterations in the synthesis of RNA with agents other than cAMP. Observed changes in incorporation of [5-3H]uridine into RNA appear in most instances to be due to alterations in the uptake of uridine, and in the pool size and specific radioactivity of UTP.     

Redistribution of cyclic GMP in response to sodium butyrate in colon cells

The effect of butyrate on the response to guanylin and Escherichia coli heat-stable enterotoxin, STa, was assessed in T84 cells and Caco-2 cells, cultured colon cell lines possessing the guanylyl cyclase C which is the receptor for these peptides. Butyrate treatment of these cells resulted in an apparent increase in cyclic GMP (cGMP) accumulation when the cGMP content of cells and the supernatant medium was measured. Butyrate treatment did not change the guanylyl cyclase activity or (125)I-STa binding parameters in T84 cells, but the butyrate effect was completely blocked by cycloheximide. Butyrate did not have any effect on STa-stimulated cGMP accumulation in COS cells transfected with the human or porcine GC-C. Further experiments showed that butyrate treatment caused a large increase in the cGMP released into the culture medium, and in cells grown in polarized fashion in Transwell inserts, cGMP efflux was predominantly from the basolateral surface of the cell; intracellular cGMP was actually lowered by butyrate treatment. Exposure of T84 cells to butyrate had no effect on the disposition of cyclic AMP generated in response to forskolin. The effects of butyrate on cGMP were reversible within 24 h of butyrate withdrawal. In colon cells, butyrate treatment induced a previously undescribed, cGMP-specific efflux mechanism which lowered intracellular cGMP and elevated extracellular cGMP in response to peptide agonists such as guanylin and STa.     

Selective inhibition by sodium butyrate of glucocorticoid-induced tyrosine aminotransferase synthesis in hepatoma tissue-cultured cells

Sodium butyrate in a 5 mM concentration prevents the induction of tyrosine aminotransferase in hepatoma culture cells, without affecting the basal level of the enzyme. This effect is reversible immediately after the removal of butyrate, or after a lag, if butyrate was present for more than 2 h. Neither the amount of cellular RNA nor the rate of total RNA synthesis were affected by sodium butyrate. Furthermore, butyrate does not inhibit protein synthesis: [35S]methionine incorporation into proteins, measured in a reticulocyte lysate system, shows no significant difference between the translation capacity of the RNAs from butyrate-treated cells and from dexamethasone-induced or uninduced cells. Nevertheless, when tyrosine aminotransferase was isolated from the translation products by its specific antiserum and analyzed by gel electrophoresis, we observed that the amount of the enzyme synthetized in the presence of RNAs from dexamethasone/butyrate-treated cells was strongly diminished relative to that synthesized in the presence of RNA from dexamethasone-induced cells. These experiments indicate that the treatment of the cells with butyrate decreases the activity of the specific messenger RNA for tyrosine aminotransferase to a level close to the basal level.     

Calcium Independence of Phosphoinositide Hydrolysis-Induced Increase in Cyclic AMP Accumulation in SK-N-SH Human Neuroblastoma Cells

Previous work has shown that stimulation of muscarinic receptors in various cell lines increases intracellular cyclic AMP (cAMP) levels. This unusual response has been hypothesized to be mediated by stimulation of calcium/calmodulin-sensitive adenylate cyclase, secondary to inositol trisphosphate (IP3)-mediated calcium mobilization. To test this hypothesis, we stimulated muscarinic receptors in SK-N-SH human neuroblastoma cells while blocking the IP3-mediated rise in intracellular calcium concentration using two different methods. Loading cells with the intracellular calcium chelator 1,2-bis(o-aminophenoxy)ethane-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid (BAPTA) abolished the carbachol-mediated intracellular calcium release without abolishing the carbachol-mediated increase in cAMP level. Similarly, in cells preexposed to carbachol, the agonist-induced change in intracellular calcium level was blocked, but the cAMP response was not. Thus, both of these methods failed to block the muscarinic receptor-mediated increase in cAMP level, thereby demonstrating that this cAMP level increase is not mediated by a detectable rise in intracellular calcium concentration.     

Sodium butyrate is a potent modulator of smooth muscle cell proliferation and gene expression

Sodium butyrate is a small, naturally occurring molecule with demonstrated activity on cell growth and differentiation. However, its effect on smooth muscle cells had not been examined. We have found that sodium butyrate and its more stable in vivo analogue tributyrin are potent DNA synthesis and cell proliferation inhibitors. The inhibitory activity of sodium butyrate was not mediated by an elevation of endogenous cAMP levels, a known pathway involved in SMC growth-arrest and maintenance of the contractile phenotype. Consistent with the concept that its activity is mediated by a cAMP-independent pathway, butyrate was able to augment the maximum DNA synthesis inhibitory effect of various agents that elevated intracellular cAMP levels. Additionally, butyrate present for just the initial 8 h or present as late as 16 h after serum addition was able to inhibit DNA synthesis. By contrast, the cAMP analogue, 8Br-cAMP had to be present throughout the entire G₀ to S phase of the cell cycle to effectively inhibit DNA synthesis. These results indicated that sodium butyrate inhibited SMC growth through a cAMP-independent mechanism. We also found that sodium butyrate was unable to abrogate the expression of the serum-inducible genes c- fos , c- myc , Ki-Ras and PS4, but was able to directly stimulate the expression of PS4 and thrombospondin. These results indicate that a number of important early G₁ events initiated by serum growth factors are unaltered by sodium butyrate and that this compound is able to directly stimulate the expression of certain genes normally associated with SMC proliferation.     

Effect of sodium butyrate on S-100 protein levels and the cAMP response

Sodium butyrate (NaB), when added to cell cultures, produces a variety of morphological and biochemical changes. We examined its effects, in nM concentrations, on the expression of two glioma cell-associated proteins, glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) and S-100 protein in human glioma-derived cell line (RF), and of S-100 protein in the C6 rat glioma cell line. GFAP levels decreased by about 50% in the RF cell line, and S-100 protein levels decreased protein levels decreased by about 40% after treatment with 1 mM NaB for 48 h. In the C6 rat glioma cell line, isoproterenol with theophylline was found to increase S-100 levels by two-fold over basal levels. NaB was found to inhibit the induction of S-100 protein but exhibited no effect on the basal levels of the protein. Other short chain fatty acids, including sodium propionate and sodium isobutyrate, exhibited partial inhibitory activity. NaB, at an EC50 of 1 mM, was also found to inhibit both the beta-adrenergic and the forskolin-mediated increase in cAMP levels in these cells. This suggests that NaB may inhibit cells from expressing S-100 protein by attenuating cAMP levels.     

Altered expression of genes regulating cell growth,proliferation, and apoptosis during adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate-induced differentiation of neuroblastoma cells in culture

An elevation of the intracellular levels of adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cAMP) induces terminal differentiation in neuroblastoma (NB) cells in culture; however, genetic alterations during differentiation have not been fully identified. To investigate this, we used Mouse Genome U74A microarray containing approximately 6000 functionally characterized genes to measure changes in gene expression in murine NB cells 30 min and 4, 24, and 72 h after treatment with cAMP-stimulating agents. Based on the time of increase in differentiated functions and their status (reversible versus irreversible) after treatment with cAMP-stimulating agents, the induction of differentiation in NB cells was divided into three distinct phases: initiation (about 4 h after treatment when no increase in differentiated functions is detectable), promotion (about 24 h after treatment when an increase in differentiated functions occurs, but they are reversible upon the removal of cAMP), and maintenance (about 72 h after treatment when differentiated functions are maximally expressed, but they are irreversible upon the removal of cAMP). Results showed that alterations in expression of genes regulating cell growth, proliferation, apoptosis, and necrosis occurred during cAMP-induced differentiation of NB cells. Genes that were upregulated during the initiation, promotion, or maintenance phase were called initiators, promoters, or maintainers of differentiation. Genes that were downregulated during the initiation, promotion, or maintenance phase were called suppressors of initiation, promotion, or maintenance phase. Genes regulating growth may act as initiators, promoters, maintainers, or suppressors of these phases. Genes regulating cell proliferation may primarily act as suppressors of promotion. Genes regulating cell cycle may behave as suppressors of initiation or promotion, whereas those regulating apoptosis and necrosis may act as initiators or suppressors of initiation or promotion. The fact that genetic signals for differentiation occurred 30 min after treatment with cAMP, whereas cell-cycle genes were downregulated at a later time, suggests that decision for NB cells to differentiate is made earlier and not at the cell-cycle stage, as commonly believed.     

Differential effect of sodium butyrate on cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase activities in butyrate sensitive and resistant mastocytoma cells

The effect of sodium butyrate on the intracellular cyclic AMP levels and the activities of cyclic AMP-regulating enzymes were examined in two types of mastocytoma p-815 cells in culture: one type (S cell) was sensitive and the other (R cell) was resistant to the induction of differentiation by sodium butyrate. In the presence of sodium butyrate, adenylate cyclase activity increased in both S and R cells to the same degree, whereas the level of cyclic AMP was elevated only in S cells. Cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase activity increased in R cells but not in S cells. Cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase activities of two cell populations differed in their response to sodium butyrate and they seem to have an important role in regulating cellular level of cyclic AMP that might be an important factor in controlling cell differentiation.     

The role of cyclic nucleotides in the regulation of mitotic activity in SSPE virus-infected human brain tissue.

The intracellular level of cGMP was independent of the rate of cell division in cells derived from virally infected brain tissue. The phosphodiesterase inhibitor R07-2956 (4-dimethoxybenzyl-2-imidazolidinone) increased the intracellular level of cGMP in virally infected brain cells, but it did not effect the level of cAMP. There was no correction between the increase in cGMP levels following addition of R07-2956 and changes in mitotic activity in the brain cell cultures. Experimental manipulations which increased the cAMP level were accompanied by a decreased mitotic rate indicating there was a correlation between mitotic activity and the level of cAMP in the same cells. Raising the intracellular level of cAMP by exogenous db-cAMP or cAMP or the use of other phosphodiesterase inhibitors routinely increased the level of cGMP as well. Conversely increasing the intracellular cGMP level by adding the exogenous cGMP increased the level of both cGMP and cAMP.A tissue culture system was used with the cell line derived from viral infected human brain tissue originally obtained from a patient with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE). The intracellular levels of cAMP and cGMP were monitored by radioimmunoassay following manipulation of the system by addition of exogenous cGMP (0.05 mM), addition of exogenous db-cAMP (0.5 mM), or cAMP (0.5 mM) and the use of phosphodiesterase inhibitors: theophylline (1.0 mM), papaverine (50 μg/ml), 4-3-butoxy-4-methoxy benzyl-2-imidozalidinone (R020-1724) and R07-2956. Cell division was monitored in treated and non-treated cultures at 24 h intervals by analyzing the cell number and mitotic index.High levels of cGMP were found in cells which were not actively dividing but high levels were just as apt to be present in dividing cells. There was an inverse relationship between cell division and the level of cAMP.     

Regulatory factors that determine growth and phenotype of normal human melanocytes

Normal human melanocytes, unlike malignant melanoma cells, required at least three growth-promoting agents, i.e., phorbol ester for protein kinase C activation and the growth factors basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) and insulin, for growth in chemically defined W489 medium. Cell growth was further stimulated by addition of agents that increase intracellular levels of cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (cAMP) to the medium. Among these agents, the pituitary hormones alpha-melanocyte-stimulating hormone (alpha-MSH) and follicle-stimulating hormone were the most potent, whereas bacterial toxins, including cholera, tetanus, and pertussis toxin and their subunits either were less mitogenic or gave variable results depending on the culture tested. Medium containing phorbol ester PMA, growth factors bFGF and insulin (or insulin-like growth factor-I), and synthetic alpha-MSH supported melanocyte growth for more than 5 months with doubling times between 5 and 8 days. Two copper-binding proteins, ceruloplasmin and tyrosinase, were mitogenic when added to medium and ceruloplasmic induced a long bi- to tripolar-shape of cells. Addition of 1 mM dibutyryl cAMP to the medium led to the formation of dendrites in all cells, with an average of 28 extensions per cell. Although cell growth was inhibited by dibutyryl cAMP, cells were not terminally differentiated and continued to proliferate. Dendritic melanocytes showed a 2.2-fold increase in activity of the tyrosine kinase pp60c-src. The induction of dendritic processes in melanocytes by dibutyryl cAMP or sodium butyrate was reversible and appears to reflect the expression of the mature melanocytic phenotype in situ.