Membrane-protein structural mapping of chloroplast coupling factor in asolectin vesicles

The spatial relationship of specific sites on chloroplast coupling factor, reconstituted in asolectin vesicles, to the bilayer surface has been studied with fluorescence methods. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer measurements have been used to map the distances of closest approach of the N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide-binding site and the disulfide on the gamma-polypeptide to the bilayer center. The dicyclohexylcarbodiimide site was labeled with N-cyclohexyl-N'-pyrenylcarbodiimide and the gamma-disulfide site with a coumarinyl derivative. The bilayer center was labeled with 25-[N-(7-nitro-2,1,3-benzoxadiazol-4-yl)-N-methylamino]-27-norc holesterol. The distances obtained, 15 and 43 A, respectively, were combined with previous measurements of the distance of closest approach between these sites and the membrane surface to estimate the perpendicular distances of the sites from the membrane surface. The depth of the dicyclohexylcarbodiimide site was also determined by studying the quenching of fluorescence by 5-, 7-, 12-, and 16-doxylstearic acids. The model developed suggests that the dicyclohexylcarbodiimide site is 6-10 A below the membrane surface and the gamma-disulfide is 16 A above the membrane surface. The distances measured are subject to a considerable uncertainty, but the proposed model provides a useful starting point for further structural studies.     

Structural mapping of chloroplast coupling factor

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer measurements have been used to investigate the spatial relationships between the nucleotide binding sites and the gamma-subunit of the H+-ATPase from chloroplasts and the orientation of these sites with respect to the membrane surface. Fluorescent maleimides reacted covalently at specific sulfhydryl sites on the gamma-subunit served as energy donors. One sulfhydryl site can be labeled only under energized conditions on the thylakoid membrane surface (light site). The two gamma-sulfhydryls exposed after catalytic activation served as a second donor site (disulfide site). In one set of experiments, the nucleotide analogue 2'(3')-(trinitrophenyl)adenosine triphosphate, selectively bound at each of the three nucleotide binding sites of the solubilized coupling factor, was used as an energy acceptor; in another, octadecylrhodamine with its acyl chain inserted in the vesicle bilayer and the rhodamine fluorophore exposed along the membrane surface was the energy acceptor. The distance between the sulfhydryl and disulfide sites was also obtained by sequentially labeling the sites with coumarin (donor) and fluorescein (acceptor) maleimide derivatives, respectively. The results indicate that all three nucleotide sites are approximately equal to 50 A from the light-labeled gamma-sulfhydryl. Two of the nucleotide sites are very far from the gamma-disulfide (greater than 74 A), while the third site, which binds nucleotides reversibly under all conditions, is 62 A from this sulfhydryl. The light-labeled sulfhydryl and disulfide sites are about 42-47 A apart. Finally, the distance of closest approach between the membrane surface of the reconstituted system and the gamma-disulfide is 31 A.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Binding of the chloroplast coupling factor CF to lipid vesicles

The binding of the chloroplast coupling factor CF to lipid vesicles was analyzed by gel filtration. CF can be bound to vesicles made of chloroplast lipids but not of lecithin. The presence in the vesicle walls of a proteolipid subunit of the hydrophobic component of the coupling factor increases the binding of CF. The apparent binding constant and the maximum protein/lipid ratio are calculated. The Ca2+-ATPase activity of bound CF is markedly lower than that of dissolved CF. It is confirmed that the proteolipid is a N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide sensitive proton channel. The binding of CF on proteolipid vesicles decreases their proton permeability.     

Modifications of the gamma subunit of chloroplast coupling factor 1 alter interactions with the inhibitory epsilon subunit.

The treatment of chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF1) with dithiothreitol or with trypsin modifies the gamma subunit. Reduction of the gamma subunit disulfide bond in CF1 in solution with dithiothreitol enhances the dissociation of epsilon (Duhe, R. J., and Selman, B. R. (1990) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1017, 70-78). The Ca(2+)-ATPase activity of either oxidized or reduced CF1 increases as the enzyme is diluted. Added epsilon subunit inhibits the Ca(2+)-ATPase activity of both forms of the diluted CF1, suggesting that epsilon dissociation is the cause of activation by dilution. Half-maximal activation occurred at much higher concentrations of the reduced CF1, indicating that reduction decreases the affinity for epsilon about 20-fold. Immunoblotting techniques show that there is only one epsilon subunit/CF1 in intact chloroplasts, in thylakoid membranes, and in solution. No epsilon is released from CF1 in thylakoids under conditions of ATP synthesis. The gamma subunit of CF1 in illuminated thylakoids is specifically cleaved by trypsin. CF1 purified from thylakoids treated with trypsin in the light is deficient in epsilon subunit, and has a high rate of ATP hydrolysis. Added epsilon neither inhibits the ATPase activity of, nor binds tightly to the cleaved enzyme.     

Structural mapping of nucleotide binding sites on chloroplast coupling factor

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer was used to measure the distances between three nucleotide binding sites on solubilized chloroplast coupling factor from spinach and between each nucleotide site and two tyrosine residues which are important for catalytic activity. The nucleotide energy donor was 1,N6-ethenoadenosine di- or triphosphate, and the nucleotide energy acceptor was 2'(3')-(trinitrophenyl)adenosine diphosphate. The tyrosine residues were specifically labeled with 7-chloro-4-nitro-2,1,3-benzoxadiazole, which served as an energy acceptor. The results obtained indicate the three nucleotide binding sites form a triangle with sides of 44, 48, and 36 A. (The assumption has been made in calculating these distances that the energy donor and acceptor rotate rapidly relative to the fluorescence lifetime.) Two of the nucleotide sites are approximately equidistant from each of the two tyrosines: one of the nucleotide sites is about 37 A and the other about 41 A from each tyrosine. The third nucleotide site is about 41 A from one of the tyrosines and greater than or equal to 41 A from the other tyrosine.     

Binding and exchange of nucleotides on the chloroplast coupling factor CF1. The role of magnesium

On the soluble part of the coupling factor (CF1), extracted from spinach chloroplasts, three nucleotide-binding sites are identified. Three ADP are bound per CF1 when the enzyme is incubated with ADP either with or without Mg2+. Two ADP and one ATP are bound per CF1 when the enzyme is incubated with a limiting concentration of ATP, in the presence of Mg2+. At high ATP concentration, in the presence of Mg2+, one free ATP exchanges with one bound ADP and two ATP and one ADP remain bound per CF1. When Mg2+ is omitted from the incubation medium of ATP and CF1, only two ADP and around 0.5 ATP are bound per CF1. The three nucleotide binding sites of CF1 fall into two different and independent categories according to the ability of the bound nucleotides to be exchanged with free nucleotides. On one site the bound ADP is difficult to exchange. On the other two sites, the bound nucleotides. ADP or ATP, are readily exchangable. We propose that the two exchangeable sites form the catalytic part of the enzyme where ATP is hydrolyzed. When ATP concentration is high enough, in the presence of Mg2+, one ATP displaces one bound ADP and allows the ATP hydrolysis to proceed. We propose too that the site where ADP is difficult to exchange may represent the 'tight' ADP-binding site, different from the catalytic ones, which becomes exchangeable on the CF1 in vivo when the thylakoid membranes are energized by light, as stressed by Bickel-Sandk?tter and Strotman [(1976) FEBS Lett. 65, 102-106].     

Cytoplasmic inheritance of chloroplast coupling factor 1 subunits

An analysis of interspecific hybrids of Nicotiana spp. in which one of the parents was sensitive to tentoxin showed that this sensitivity was transmitted only through the female parent. Since tentoxin acts by selectively binding to the alpha,beta subunit complex of chloroplast coupling factor 1, the gene(s) specifying either one or both of these subunits is located in the cytoplasm.     

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer mapping of the fourth of six nucleotide-binding sites of chloroplast coupling factor 1.

Equilibrium dialysis measurements of adenine nucleotide binding to chloroplast coupling factor 1 suggest that the enzyme has six binding sites for ADP, adenylyl-beta,gamma-imidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP), and 2'(3')-O-2,4,6-trinitrophenyl-ATP (TNP-ATP). High affinity binding at all six sites requires the divalent cation, Mg2+. Three of the nucleotide-binding sites, sites 1, 2, and 3, have been mapped by fluorescence resonance energy transfer distance measurements (see McCarty, R. E., and Hammes, G. G. (1987) Trends Biochem. Sci. 12, 234-237). Using the same technique, we mapped the location of nucleotide-binding site 4, a tight, exchangeable site (Shapiro, A. B., Huber, A. H., and McCarty, R. E. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 4194-4200). Two arrangements of the energy transfer map of coupling factor 1 were found which are compatible with the available data. The two arrangements make different predictions about which sites interact in cooperative catalysis.     

Delta subunit of chloroplast coupling factor 1 inhibits proton leakage through coupling factor O

The ATP synthase of chloroplasts consists of a proton-conducting portion, CF0, and a catalytic portion, CF1. The smaller subunits of CF1, in particular delta, may play a key role in the coupling of proton transport to ATP synthesis. Purified subunit delta, when added to partially CF1-depleted thylakoid membranes, can restore photophosphorylation (Engelbrecht, S., and Junge, W. (1987) Eur. J. Biochem. 172, 213-218). We report here that it does so by blocking proton conduction through CF0. Thylakoids were CF1-depleted by incubation in hypoosmolar NaCl/EDTA solutions. Variation of the NaCl concentrations and of the incubation times not only changed the overall degree of CF1 depletion but also the subunit composition of solubilized CF1, namely CF1 containing delta and CF1(-delta). This was quantified by immunoelectrophoresis and by fast protein liquid chromatography. Proton conduction was measured by flash spectrophotometry by using standard electrochromic and pH-indicating absorption changes. The removal of integral CF1 was correlated with high electric conductance of thylakoid membranes, an increased extent of rapid proton leakage, and loss of ATP synthesis activity, which exceeded the percentual loss of CF1. The removal of predominantly CF1(-delta) resulted in comparatively lesser effects on the loss of ATP synthesis and on the extent and velocity of proton leakage. On the same line, addition of integral CF1 and of purified delta diminished the electric leak in CF1-depleted thylakoids. Both approaches, the controlled removal of CF1 and CF1(-delta), respectively, and addition of delta and CF1 showed that delta can act as a "stopcock" to the exposed proton channel CF0.     

Lack of site-specificity of spinach chloroplast coupling factor 1

The irreversible inhibition of chloroplast phosphorylation by either sulfate anions, or N-ethylmaleimide, is energy dependent. Chloroplasts must first be illuminated in the presence of the inhibitors and a mediator of electron flow, for the subsequent phosphorylation to show any inhibition. Both inhibitors affect the chloroplast coupling factor 1.Electron transport only through Photosystem I can be used to activate either of these inhibitions. The subsequent inhibition in a second light reaction is the same whether ATP synthesis is supported by Photosystem I, or by Photosystem II electron transport. The reverse experiment, activating inhibition by electron transport only through Photosystem II, is possible in the case of sulfate. Again, the inhibition is expressed whether Photosystem II or Photosystem I electron flow supports ATP synthesis. We conclude that the two electron transport regions probably generate the same high energy state which is able to activate all members of a functionally uniform coupling factor population. These enzyme molecules must catalyze phosphorylation coupled to electron transport through either region of the chain. The results tend to discredit models requiring a separate group of coupling factor molecules unique to each part of the chain.     

Interaction of oxyanions with thioredoxin-activated chloroplast coupling factor 1

Interaction between F(1)-ATPase activity stimulating oxyanions and noncatalytic sites of coupling factor CF(1) was studied. Carbonate, borate and sulfite anions were shown to inhibit tight binding of [14C]ATP and [14C]ADP to CF(1) noncatalytic sites. The demonstrated change of their inhibitory efficiency in carbonate-borate-sulfite order coincides with the previously found change in efficiency of these anions as stimulators of CF(1)-ATPase activity [Biochemistry (Mosc.) 43 (1978) 1206-1211]. Inhibition of tight nucleotide binding to noncatalytic sites was accompanied by stimulation of nucleotide binding to catalytic sites. This suggests that stimulation of CF(1)-ATPase activity is caused by interaction between oxyanions and noncatalytic sites. A most efficient stimulator of CF(1)-ATPase activity, sulfite oxyanion, appeared to be a competitive inhibitor with respect to ATP and a partial noncompetitive inhibitor with respect to ADP. The inhibition weakened with increasing time of CF(1) incubation with sulfite and nucleotides. Sulfite is believed to inhibit fast reversible interaction between nucleotides and noncatalytic sites and to produce no effect on subsequent tight binding of nucleotides. A possible mechanism of the oxyanion-stimulating effect is discussed.     

Chemical cross-linking studies of chloroplast coupling factor 1.

Cross-linking reagents have been used to link covalently adjacent subunits of solubilized spinach chloroplast coupling factor 1, which is a latent ATPase. 1,5-Difluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene, dimethyl-3,3'-dithiobispropionimidate, and dimethylsuberimidate are able to form bridges of 3 to 11 A between amino groups, and hydrogen peroxide and the o-phenanthroline-cupric ion complex catalyze the oxidation of intrinsic sulfhydryl groups. The five individual subunit bands (alpha, beta, gamma, delta, and epsilon) and several new aggregate bands can be separated by means of sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The same four fastest moving aggregate bands, as characterized by their mobilities, migrate more slowly than the heaviest subunit band and appear with all of the cross-linkers employed. The subunit composition of the aggregate bands has been determined through the use of the reversible cross-linkers, dimethyldithiobispropionimidate, (o-phenanthroline)2Cu(II), and H2O2, and two-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in which aggregates are separated in the first dimension, the disulfide cross-links are cleaved, and the individual subunits present in the aggregates are separated in the second dimension. The subunits are detected by Coomassie brilliant blue staining and by labeling some of the sulfhydryl groups of the gamma and epsilon subunits with radioactive N-ethylmaleimide. The results obtained indicate that the alpha and beta subunits can cross-link directly with each of the other subunits, that two beta subunits are adjacent, and that gamma epsilon, gamma epsilon 2, alpha delta, and beta delta aggregates are present. A minimal subunit stoichiometry consistent with these results is alpha 2 beta 2 gamma delta epsilon 2. A possible structural model of the coupling factor is derived from the data. Similar, but less extensive, experiments have been carried out with the heat-activated coupling factor (which is an ATPase); no differences in the spatial arrangement of subunits are detected from the two-dimensional gel electrophoresis analysis of the cross-linked aggregates.     

Detergent activation of the ATPase activity of chloroplast coupling factor 1

The activation of the ATPase activity of coupling factor 1 (CF1) from chloroplasts by several detergents was studied. Further evidence that detergent micelles are important in the activation of Ca2+-ATPase was obtained. Maximal activation of CA2+-ATPase was achieved with short-chain alkyl-beta-D-glucopyranoside (alkylglucosides) detergents. Treatment of CF1 with hexylglucoside or heptylglucoside followed by hydroxylapatite chromatography caused nearly total removal of the epsilon subunit of the enzyme, whereas treatment with decylglucoside caused less ATPase activation and less loss of the epsilon subunit. The ATPase activity of detergent-activated CF1 was inhibited by purified epsilon subunit. Detergents that form small micelles appear to be most effective in removing the epsilon subunit and in activating the Ca2+-ATPase of CF1. When present during assay, the alkylglucosides also induce a Mg2+-ATPase activity in CF1. Octyl- and nonylglucoside are most effective in promoting this reaction. If, however, CF1 deficient in the epsilon subunit was used, even decylglucoside elicited rapid Mg2+-ATPase hydrolysis. It is concluded that removal of the epsilon subunit, although necessary for the expression of Mg2+-ATPase, is not sufficient. The detergents that cause maximal displacement of the epsilon subunit are less effective in inducing Mg2+-ATPase activity. The selective removal of subunits from CF1 by specific detergents points to potential problems with the use of these detergents in the solubilization of oligomeric membrane proteins.     

Integrated functioning of the chloroplast coupling factor

This review is focused on some functional characteristics of the chloroplast coupling factor. The structure of the enzyme and the putative role of its subunits are recalled. An attempt is made to discriminate the driving force and the activator effects of the electrochemical proton gradient. Respective roles of delta pH, delta phi, external and internal pH are discussed with regard to mechanistic implications. The hypothesis of a functional switch of the enzyme between two states with better efficiency either in ATP synthesis or in ATP hydrolysis is also examined. A brief survey is made on some problems complicating quantitative studies of energy coupling, such as localized chemiosmosis, delta pH and delta phi computations, and scalar ATPases. The main data on the enzyme activation and the energy-dependent release of tightly bound nucleotides are summarized. The arguments for and against the catalytic competence of theses nucleotides are reviewed. Lastly, some prevailing models of the catalytic mechanism are presented. The relevance of nucleotides binding change events in this process is discussed.     

The site of synthesis of pea chloroplast coupling factor 1

Inhibitors of cytoplasmic polyribosome function and chloroplastpolyribosome function were used to study the site of synthesisof the five subunits of coupling factor I (CF₁) in Pisum sativum.The results of these in vivo experiments are presented as evidencefor the cytoplasmic synthesis of two subunits, C and D, andthe synthesis in the chloroplast of the other three, A, B andE. ¹ Supported in part by grant PCM-74-13534 from the NationalScience Foundation. (Received April 17, 1978; )     

Properties of noncatalytic sites of thioredoxin-activated chloroplast coupling factor 1

Nucleotide binding properties of two vacant noncatalytic sites of thioredoxin-activated chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF(1)) were studied. Kinetics of nucleotide binding to noncatalytic sites is described by the first-order equation that allows for two nucleotide binding sites that differ in kinetic features. Dependence of the nucleotide binding rate on nucleotide concentration suggests that tight nucleotide binding is preceded by rapid reversible binding of nucleotides. ADP binding is cooperative. The preincubation of CF(1) with Mg(2+) produces only slight effect on the rate of ADP binding and decreases the ATP binding rate. The ATP and ADP dissociation from noncatalytic sites is described by the first-order equation for similar sites with dissociation rate constants k(-2)(ADP)=1.5 x 10(-1) min(-1) and k(-2)(ATP) congruent with 10(-3) min(-1), respectively. As follows from the study, the noncatalytic sites of CF(1) are not homogeneous. One of them retains the major part of endogenous ADP after CF(1) precipitation with ammonium sulfate. Its other two sites can bind both ADP and ATP but have different kinetic parameters and different affinity for nucleotides.     

Properties of noncatalytic sites of thioredoxin-activated chloroplast coupling factor 1

Nucleotide binding properties of two vacant noncatalytic sites of thioredoxin-activated chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF₁) were studied. Kinetics of nucleotide binding to noncatalytic sites is described by the first-order equation that allows for two nucleotide binding sites that differ in kinetic features. Dependence of the nucleotide binding rate on nucleotide concentration suggests that tight nucleotide binding is preceded by rapid reversible binding of nucleotides. ADP binding is cooperative. The preincubation of CF₁ with Mg²⁺ produces only slight effect on the rate of ADP binding and decreases the ATP binding rate. The ATP and ADP dissociation from noncatalytic sites is described by the first-order equation for similar sites with dissociation rate constants k₋₂(ADP)=1.5×10⁻¹ min⁻¹ and k₋₂(ATP)≅10⁻³ min⁻¹, respectively. As follows from the study, the noncatalytic sites of CF₁ are not homogeneous. One of them retains the major part of endogenous ADP after CF₁ precipitation with ammonium sulfate. Its other two sites can bind both ADP and ATP but have different kinetic parameters and different affinity for nucleotides.     

Tentoxin An uncompetitive inhibitor of lettuce chloroplast coupling factor 1

The interaction of tentoxin $\text{[cyclo}\text{(-}\text{l}\text{-leucyl}\text{-N-}\text{methyl-(Z)-dehydrophenyl-analyl-glycyl}\text{-N-}\text{methyl-}\text{l}\text{-alanyl-)}\text{]}$ with solubilized lettuce chloroplast coupling factor 1 was characterized by direct binding studies, measurement of the time course of ATPase inhibition, and steady-state enzyme kinetics. Neither substrates, products or Ca²⁺ competed with the tentoxin binding site, nor did they induce any large change in tentoxin affinity. The inhibition of lettuce chloroplast coupling factor 1 ATPase was found to be the time dependent, and at equilibrium the affinities estimated by equilibrium ultrafiltration and enzyme inhibition were similar (1.8 · 10⁸M^?1). The steady-state kinetics best fit an uncompetitive pattern suggesting that the inhibited steps follow an irreversible step occurring after ATP binding.