A 1H NMR comparison of the met-cyano complexes of elephant and sperm whale myoglobin. Assignment of labile proton resonances in the heme cavity and determination of the distal glutamine orientation from relaxation data

The met-cyano complex of elephant myoglobin has been investigated by high field 1H NMR spectroscopy, with special emphasis on the use of exchangeable proton resonances in the heme cavity to obtain structural information on the distal glutamine. Analysis of the distance dependence of relaxation rates and the exchange behavior of the four hyperfine shifted labile proton resonances has led to the assignment of the proximal His-F8 ring and peptide NHs and the His-FG3 ring NH and the distal Gln-E7 amide NH. The similar hyperfine shift patterns for both the apparent heme resonances as well as the labile proton peaks of conserved resonances in elephant and sperm whale met-cyano myoglobins support very similar electronic/molecular structures for their heme cavities. The essentially identical dipolar shifts and dipolar relaxation times for the distal Gln-E7 side chain NH and the distal His-E7 ring NH in sperm whale myoglobin indicate that those labile protons occupy the same geometrical position relative to the iron and heme plane. This geometry is consistent with the distal residue hydrogen bonding to the coordinated ligand. The similar rates and identical mechanisms of exchange with bulk water of the labile protons for the three conserved residues in the elephant and sperm whale heme cavity indicate that the dynamic stability of the proximal side of the heme pocket is unaltered upon the substitution (His----Gln). The much slower exchange rate (by greater than 10(4] of the distal NH in elephant relative to sperm whale myoglobin supports the assignment of the resonance to the intrinsically less labile amide side chain.     

Characterization of heme orientational disorder in myoglobin by proton nuclear Overhauser effects

Freshly reconstituted sperm whale myoglobin is a mixture of two components distinguishable by proton nuclear magnetic resonance. The two species are interconvertible and the equilibrium composition is about 90% of one form, the form studied by X-ray methods. We have used the nuclear Overhauser effect to characterize the other (minor) component in its metcyano complex. Whereas in the major form there is dipolar contact between residue 99 and the heme pyrrole ring III, in the minor form the same residue is in contact with pyrrole IV, related to ring III by a 180 degrees rotation about the alpha-gamma meso axis. This interaction proves the validity of the heme rotational disorder proposition and confirms that the apoprotein does not discriminate between the two sides of the heme in the rapid insertion process. It is proposed that the differences in nuclear Overhauser effect between the protein matrix and the heme moiety can be used to define qualitatively the structural consequences of this heterogeneity. The altered heme-protein contacts could be related to the enhanced oxygen affinity in the minor form.     

1H nuclear magnetic resonance study of the prosthetic group in sulfhemoglobin.

The molecular and electronic structure of the modified prosthetic group of sulfhemoglobin (SHb) was investigated by 1H NMR for the low-spin ferric cyano-met and high-spin ferrous deoxy sulfhemoglobin complex. The 1H NMR resonances of the two subunits in the cyano-met SHb complex were differentiated on the basis of the differential stability toward regeneration of native subunits. The subunit origin for the two sets of resonances was established by formation of the sulfglobin protein for the isolated alpha-chain prior to assembling with the native beta-subunit to yield a tetramer with sulfhemin in the alpha-subunits. The subunit peak assignments establish that it is the beta-subunit of SHb which regenerates more rapidly to native protein. The hyperfine shifted sulfhemin peaks were assigned based on steady-state nuclear Overhauser effects which demonstrated that similarly hyperfine shifted peaks exhibit the same dipolar connectivities observed in the analogous sulfmyoglobin complex. Hence it is concluded that pyrrole B is the site of reaction in both hemoglobin and myoglobin. The initially formed SHb complex failed to equilibrate to yield a complex with a sulfhemin sufficiently stable to extraction as found previously for sulfmyoglobin. However, apoHb readily bound the green sulfhemin extracted from the terminal alkaline equilibration product of sulfmyoglobin. The inhibition on the equilibration to the alkaline form with the exocyclic thiolene ring is attributed to the interaction with Val FG5. The observations of the same dipolar connectivities among similarly hyperfine shifted peaks in the directly prepared and reconstituted SHb complexes further support the same structure for the sulfhemin in sulfmyoglobin and SHb. The strongly hyperfine shifted peaks in the deoxy form of both SHb complexes were found very similar to those of the analogous sulfmyoglobin complexes. The proximal His labile ring proton signal appears to experience a 5- to 10-ppm decrease upon conversion of a native globin to sulfglobin. This attenuation may provide a probe for differentiating chlorins and hemins in globin pockets.     

Solution 1H NMR investigation of the seating and rotational "hopping" of centrosymmetric etioheme-I in myoglobin: effect of globin origin and its oxidation/spin state on heme dynamics

Solution 1H NMR spectroscopy was used to investigate the heme active-site structure and dynamics of rotation about the Fe-His bond of centrosymmetric etioheme-I reconstituted into sperm whale and horse myoglobin (Mb). Comparison of the NOESY cross-peak pattern and paramagnetic relaxation properties of the cyanomet complexes confirm a heme pocket that is essentially the same as Mb with either native protoheme or etioheme-I. Dipolar contacts between etioheme and the conserved heme pocket residues establish a unique seating of etioheme that conserves the orientation of the N-Fe-N vector relative to the axial His plane, with ethyl groups occupying the vinyl positions of protoheme. Saturation transfer between methyls on adjacent pyrroles in etioheme-reconstituted horse Mb in all accessible oxidation/spin states reveals rotational hopping rates that decrease dramatically with either loss of ligands or reduction of the heme, and correlate qualitatively with expectations based on the Fe-His bond strength and the rate of heme dissociation from Mb. The rate of hopping for etioheme in metMbCN, in contrast to hemes with propionates, is the same in the sperm whale and horse proteins.     

Identification of the titrating group in the heme cavity of myoglobin. Evidence for the heme-protein pi-pi interaction

The pH dependence of the proton NMR chemical shifts of met-cyano and deoxy forms of native and reconstituted myoglobins reflects a structural transition in the heme pocket modulated by a single proton with pK 5.1-5.6. Comparison of this pH dependence of sperm whale and elephant myoglobin and that of the former protein reconstituted with esterified hemin eliminates both the distal histidine as well as the heme propionates as the titrating residue. Reconstitution of sperm whale met-cyano myoglobin with hemin modified at the 2,4-positions leads to a systematic variation in the pK for the structural transition, thus indicating the presence of a coupling between the titrating group and the heme pi system. The results are consistent with histidine FG3 (His-FG3) being the titrating group, and a donor-acceptor pi-pi interaction between its imidazole and the heme is proposed.     

High-pressure 1H NMR study of pressure-induced structural changes in the heme environments of metcyanomyoglobins

The effect of pressure on the heme environment structure of sperm whale and horse heart metcyanomyoglobins was investigated up to 300 MPa by high-pressure (1)H NMR spectroscopy. Pressure-induced changes in the distances between the observed protons and the heme iron atom were estimated from changes in the dipolar shift due to the paramagnetic effect on the protons. The changes showed that the heme peripheral structure as a whole was compressed by pressure; the movements of the protons in the heme peripheral residues were in the range of +0.16 to -0.54 A/300 MPa. One-dimensional compressibilities for the protons, excluding the protons of the distal His residue, were in the range of 1.0 x 10(-4) to 6.1 x 10(-4)/MPa. The movements of the protons induced by pressure correlated well with the distance between the protons and cavities in the protein. The distal His residue (His 64) moved toward the outside of the heme pocket, but remained in the pocket even at 300 MPa. This movement was driven dominantly by a change in the dihedral angle around the C(alpha)-C(beta) rotational bond of the residue. Comparative work on horse heart metcyanomyoglobin implied that the conformational change of the His 64 imidazole ring was larger in the horse heart metcyanomyoglobin than in the sperm whale metcyanomyoglobin.     

Rearrangement of the distal pocket accompanying E7 His----Gln substitution in elephant carbonmonoxy- and oxymyoglobin: 1H NMR identification of a new aromatic residue in the heme pocket

Two-dimensional 1H NMR methods have been used to assign side-chain resonances for the residues in the distal heme pocket of elephant carbonmonoxymyoglobin (MbCO) and oxymyoglobin (MbO2). It is shown that, while the other residues in the heme pocket are minimally perturbed, the Phe CD4 residue in elephant MbCO and MbO2 resonates considerably upfield compared to the corresponding residue in sperm whale MbCO. The new NOE connectivities to Val E11 and heme-induced ring current calculations indicate that Phe CD4 has been inserted into the distal heme pocket by reorienting the aromatic side chain and moving the CD corner closer to the heme. The C zeta H proton of the Phe CD4 was found to move toward the iron of the heme by approximately 4 A relative to the position of sperm whale MbCO, requiring minimally a 3-A movement of the CD helical backbone. The significantly altered distal conformation in elephant myoglobin, rather than the single distal E7 substitution, forms a plausible basis for its altered functional properties of lower autoxidation rate, higher redox potential, and increased affinity for CO ligand. These results demonstrate that one-to-one interpretation of amino acid residue substitution (E7 His----Gln) is oversimplified and that conformational changes of substituted proteins which are not readily predicted have to be considered for interpretation of their functional properties.     

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance study of the solution distal histidine orientation in monomeric Chironomus thummi thummi cyanomet hemoglobins. Dynamic stability of the heme pocket as monitored by labile proton exchange.

The 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectral characteristics of the cyano-Met form of Chironomus thummi thummi monomeric hemoglobins I, III and IV in 1H2O solvent are reported. A set of four exchangeable hyperfine-shifted resonances is found for each of the two heme-insertion isomers in the hyperfine-shifted region downfield of ten parts per million. An analysis of relaxation, exchange rates and nuclear Overhauser effects leads to assignments for all these resonances to histidine F8 and the side-chains of histidine E7 and arginine FG3. It is evident that in aqueous solution, the side-chain from histidine E7 does not occupy two orientations, as found for the solid state, rather the histidine E7 side-chain adopts a conformation similar to that of sperm whale myoglobin or hemoglobin A, oriented into the heme pocket and in contact with the bound ligand. Evidence is presented to show that the allosteric transition in the Chironomus thummi thummi hemoglobins arises from the "trans effect". An analysis of the exchange with bulk solvent of the assigned histidine E7 labile proton confirms that the group is completely buried within the heme pocket in a manner similar to that found for sperm whale cyano-Met myoglobin, and that the transient exposure to solvent is no more likely than in mammalian myoglobins with the "normal" distal histidine orientation. Finally, a comparison of solvent access to the heme pocket of the three monomeric C. thummi thummi hemoglobins, as measured from proton exchange rates of heme pocket protons, is made and correlated to binding studies with the diffusible small molecules such as O2.     

Proton magnetic resonance study of the influence of heme 2,4 substituents on the exchange rates of labile protons in the heme pocket of myoglobin.

Four exchangeable protons with large hyperfine shifts are assigned in the heme pocket of sperm whale met-cyano myoglobin reconstituted with heme possessing acetyl groups, ethyl groups, bromines, and hydrogens at the 2,4 position, using both relaxation and chemical-shift data. The four protons arise from the ring NH's of the proximal (F8), distal (E7), and FG2 histidines, and the peptide NH of His F8. The similarity of all chemical shifts to those of the native protein as well as the invariance of the relaxation rates of the distal histidyl ring NH dictate essentially the same structure for the heme cavity of both native and reconstituted proteins. The exchange rates with bulk water of the four labile proteins in each modified protein were determined by saturation-transfer and line width methods. All four labile protons were found to have the same exchange rate as in the native protein for acetyl and ethyl 2,4 substituents; the two resolved labile protons in the derivative with 2,4 bromine were also unchanged. The reconstituted protein with hydrogens at the 2,4 position exhibited slower exchange rates for three of the four protons, indicating an increased dynamic stability of the heme pocket in the absence of bulky 2,4 substituents.     

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance study of the molecular and electronic structure of the heme cavity in Aplysia cyanometmyoglobin

The 1H NMR spectrum of the low-spin, cyanide-ligated ferric complex of the myoglobin from the mollusc Aplysia limacina has been investigated. All of the resolved resonances from both the hemin and the proximal histidine have been assigned by a combination of isotope labeling, spin decoupling, analysis of differential paramagnetic relaxation, and nuclear Overhauser (NOE) experiments. The pattern of the heme contact shifts is unprecedented for low-spin ferric hemoproteins in exhibiting minimal rhombic asymmetry. This low in-plane asymmetry is correlated with the X-ray-determined orientation of the proximal histidyl imidazole plane relative to the heme and provides an important test case for the interpretation of hyperfine shifts of low-spin ferric hemoproteins. The bonding of the proximal histidine is shown to be similar to that in sperm whale myoglobin and is largely unperturbed by conformational transitions down to pH approximately 4. The two observed conformational transitions appear to be linked to the titration of the two heme propionate groups, which are suggested to exist in various orientations as a function of both pH and temperature. Heme orientational disorder in the ratio 5:1 was demonstrated by both isotope labeling and NOE experiments. The exchange rate with bulk water of the proximal histidyl labile ring proton is faster in Aplysia than in sperm whale myoglobin, consistent with a greater tendency for local unfolding of the heme pocket in the former protein. A similar increased heme pocket lability in Aplysia myoglobin has been noted in the rate of heme reorientation [Bellelli, A., Foon, R., Ascoli, F., & Brunori, M. (1987) Biochem. J. 246, 787-789].     

The homonuclear Overhauser effect in H2O solution of low-spin hemeproteins

Proton-proton Overhauser effects were observed in ¹H₂O solutions of sperm whale metcyano myoglobin. Dipolar connectivities involving hyperfine-shifted exchangeable protons such as the proximal and distal histidine ring NH's allowed us to categorize signals as arising from residues located on one side of the heme plane or on the other. With these connectivities, as well as spin-lattice relaxation times, spectral assignments were reached that were used to derive structural and dynamic information about the heme environment. Thus, it was shown that the distal histidine residue does not titrate down to pH 4.1 and that the CH₂ of the proximal histidine side chain tumbles with the same correlation time as the protein. Some other applications and limitations are presented.     

Solvent accessibility of the heme pocket in tuna myoglobin

The accessibility of the heme binding site of two apomyoglobins, i.e. tuna and sperm whale apomyoglobin, has been evaluated by quenching the fluorescence of their ANS-conjugates. The quenching pattern obtained by using charged and uncharged quenchers revealed that the heme pocket of tuna apomyoglobin is more accessible than that of sperm whale. Moreover, a larger number of positively charged groups is present in the heme pocket of tuna apomyoglobin as indicated by comparing the extent of quenching produced by iodide and cesium ion. The relaxation time of ANS bound to tuna apomyoglobin is lower than that of the same chromophore bound to sperm whale globin thus indicating that there is some localized flexibility in the tuna globin.     

Myoglobin structure and regulation of solvent accessibility of heme pocket

The effects of heme removal on the molecular structure of tuna and sperm whale myoglobin have been investigated by comparing the solvent accessibility to the heme pocket of the two proteins with that of the corresponding apoproteins. Although the heme microenvironment of tuna myoglobin is more polar than that of sperm whale myoglobin, the accessibility of solvent to heme is identical in the two proteins as revealed by thermal perturbation of Soret absorption. The removal of heme produces loss of helical folding and increase of solvent accessibility but the effects are rather different for the two proteins. More precisely, the loss of helical structure upon heme removal is 50% for tuna myoglobin and 15% for sperm whale myoglobin; moreover, the solvent accessibility of the heme pocket of tuna apomyoglobin is 2-3-fold greater than that of sperm whale apomyoglobin. These results have been explained in terms of the lack of helical folding in segment D, the structural organization of which may have a relevant effect in regulating the accessibility of ligands to the heme. The effects produced by charged quenchers reveal that the ligand path from the surface of the molecule to the ion atom of the heme involves a positively charged residue which may reasonably be identified as Arg-45 (sperm whale myoglobin) or Lys-41 (tuna myoglobin) on the basis of recent X-ray crystallographic information.     

Solution structural characteristics of cyanometmyoglobin: resonance assignment of heme cavity residues by two-dimensional NMR

Steady-state nuclear Overhauser effects (NOE), two-dimensional (2D) nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy (NOESY), and 2D spin correlation spectroscopy (COSY) have been applied to the fully paramagnetic low-spin, cyanide-ligated complex of sperm whale ferric myoglobin to assign the majority of the heme pocket side-chain proton signals and the remainder of the heme signals. It is shown that the 2D NOESY map reveals essentially all dipolar connectivities observed in ordinary 1D NOE experiments and expected on the basis of crystal coordinates, albeit often more weakly than in a diamagnetic analogue. For extremely broad (approximately 600-Hz) and rapidly relaxing (Tf1 approximately 3 ms) signals which show no NEOSY peaks, we demonstrate that conventional steady-state NOEs obtained under very rapid pulsing conditions still allow detection of the critical dipoar connectivities that allow unambiguous assignments. The COSY map was found to be generally less useful for the hyperfine-shifted residues, with cross peaks detected only for protons greater than 6 A from the iron. Nevertheless, numerous critical COSY cross peaks between strongly hyperfine-shifted peaks were resolved and assigned. In all, 95% (53 of 56 signals) of the total proton sets within approximately 7.5 A of the iron, the region experiencing the strongest hyperfine shifts and paramagnetic relaxation, are now unambiguously assigned. Hence it is clear that the 2D methods can be profitably applied to paramagnetic proteins. The scope and limitations of such application are discussed. The resulting hyperfine shift pattern for the heme confirmed expectations based on model compounds. In contrast, while exhibiting fortuitous 1H NMR spectral similarities, a major discrepancy was uncovered between the hyperfine shift pattern of the axially bound (F8 histidyl) imidazole in the protein and that of the imidazole in a relevant model compound [Chacko, V.P., & La Mar, G. N. (1982) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 104, 7002-7007], providing direct evidence for a protein-based deformation of axial bonding in the protein.     

Solution 1H NMR study of the active site structure for the double mutant H64Q/V68F cyanide complex from mouse neuroglobin

Solution (1)H NMR spectroscopy has been carried out to investigate the molecular and electronic structures of the active site in H64Q/V68F double mutant mouse neuroglobin in the cyanomet form. Two heme orientations resulting from a 180 degrees rotation about the alpha-gamma-meso axis were observed with a population ratio about 1:1, and the clearly distinguished B isomer was used to perform the study. Based on the analysis of the dipolar shifts and paramagnetic relaxation constants, the distal Gln(64)(E7) side chain is obtained to adopt an orientation that may produce hydrogen bond between the N(epsilon)H(1) and the Fe-bound cyanide. The side chain of Phe(68)(E11) is oriented out of the heme pocket just like that in triple mutant of cyanide complex of sperm whale myoglobin. A 15 degrees rotation of the imidazole ring in axial His(96) is observed, which is close to the varphi angle determined from the crystal structure of NgbCO. The quantitative determinations of the orientation and anisotropies of the paramagnetic susceptibility tensor reveal that cyanide is tilted by 8 degrees from the heme normal which allows for contact to the Gln(64)(E7) N(epsilon)H(1). The E7 and E11 residues appear to control the direction and the extent of tilt of the bound ligand. Furthermore, the tilt of the ligand has no obvious influence on the heme heterogeneity of cyanide ligation for isomer A/B of the wild type and mutant protein, indicating that factors other than steric effects, such as polarity of heme pocket, impacts on ligand binding affinity.     

Picosecond geminate recombination of nitrosylmyoglobins

The kinetics of NO geminate recombination to sperm whale and elephant myoglobins has been studied on the picosecond time scale using an amplified colliding-pulse mode-locked ring dye laser. The dynamics of ligand rebinding are shown to be affected by the distal structure of the protein surrounding the heme pocket.     

Proton NMR characterization of isomeric sulfmyoglobins: preparation, interconversion, reactivity patterns, and structural features

The preparations of sulfmyoglobin (sulf-Mb) by standard procedures have been found heterogeneous by 1H NMR spectroscopy. Presented here are the results of a comprehensive study of the factors that influence the selection among the three dominant isomeric forms of sperm whale sulf-Mb and their resulting detailed optical and 1H NMR properties as related to their detectability and structural properties of the heme pocket. A single isomer is formed initially in the deoxy state; further treatment in any desired oxidation/ligation state can yield two other major isomers. Acid catalysis and chromatography facilitate formation of a second isomer, particularly in the high-spin state. At neutral pH, a third isomer is formed by a first-order process. The processes that alter oxidation/ligation state are found to be reversible and are judged to affect only the metal center, but the three isomeric sulf-Mbs are found to exhibit significantly different ligand affinity and chemical stability. The present results allow, for the first time, a rational approach for preparing a given isomeric sulf-Mb in an optimally pure state for subsequent characterization by other techniques. While optical spectroscopy can distinguish the alkaline forms, only 1H NMR clearly distinguishes all three ferric isomers. The ring current shifts in the carbonyl complexes of reduced sulf-Mb complexes support saturation for a pyrrole in each isomer. The hyperfine shift patterns in the various oxidation/spin states of sulf-Mbs indicate relatively small structural alteration, and the proximal and distal sides of the heme suggest that peripheral electronic effects are responsible for the differentially reduced ligand affinities for the three isomeric sulf-Mbs. The first 1H NMR spectra of sulfhemoglobins are presented, which indicate a structure similar to that of the initially formed sulf-Mb isomer but also suggest the presence of a similar molecular heterogeneity as found for sulf-Mb, albeit to a smaller extent.     

Assignment of heme and distal amino acid resonances in the 1H-NMR spectra of the carbon monoxide and oxygen complexes of sperm whale myoglobin

Assignments of resonances of the heme and distal amino acid protons in spectra of the CO and O2 complexes of sperm whale myoglobin are reported. These resonances provide information on the conformation of the heme pocket. For oxymyoglobin, the assignments of the heme meso protons disagree with those proposed previously on the basis of partial deuteration experiments. Rapid ring flips about the C beta-C gamma bond are detected for Phe-CD1. Recent claims for two conformational substates of valine-E11 in carbonmonoxymyoglobin (Bradbury, J.H. and Carver, J.A. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 4905-4913) are shown to be in error. The pK of His-97 (FG3) in carbonmonoxymyoglobin has been determined (pK = 5.9). This residue appears to influence many spectroscopic properties of myoglobin. The distal His-E7 in carbonmonoxymyoglobin has pK less than 5.0. Differences in the heme pocket conformation in the CO complexes of myoglobin and leghemoglobin are discussed. These differences may be influential in O2 and CO association reactions.     

1H NMR study of the molecular structure and magnetic properties of the active site for the cyanomet complex of O2-avid hemoglobin from the trematode Paramphistomum epiclitum.

The solution molecular and electronic structures of the active site in the extremely O2-avid hemoglobin from the trematode Paramphistomum epiclitum have been investigated by 1H NMR on the cyanomet form in order to elucidate the distal hydrogen-bonding to a ligated H-bond acceptor ligand. Comparison of the strengths of dipolar interactions in solution with the alternate crystal structures of methemoglobin establish that the solution structure of wild-type Hb more closely resembles the crystal structure of the recombinant wild-type than the true wild-type met-hemoglobin. The distal Tyr66(E7) is found oriented out of the heme pocket in solution as found in both crystal structures. Analysis of dipolar contacts, dipolar shift and paramagnetic relaxation establishes that the Tyr32(B10) hydrogen proton adopts an orientation that allows it to make a strong H-bond to the bound cyanide. The observation of a significant isotope effect on the heme methyl contact shifts confirms a strong contact between the Tyr32(B10) OH and the ligated cyanide. The quantitative determination of the orientation and anisotropies of the paramagnetic susceptibility tensor reveal that the cyanide is tilted approximately 10 degrees from the heme normal so as to avoid van der Waals overlap with the Tyr32(B10) Oeta. The pattern of heme contact shifts with large low-field shifts for 7-CH3 and 18-CH3 is shown to arise not from the 180 degrees rotation about the alpha-gamma-meso axis, but due to the approximately 45 degrees rotation of the axial His imidazole ring, relative to that in mammalian globins.     

1H NMR study of labile proton exchange in the heme cavity as a probe for the potential ligand entry channel in myoglobin

The exchange rates of heme cavity histidine nitrogen-bound protons in horse and dog metcyanomyoglobins have been determined at 40 degrees C as a function of pH by 1H NMR spectroscopy. They were compared to the results reported for the sperm whale homologue [Cutnell, J. D., La Mar, G. N., & Kong, S. B. (1981) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 103, 3567-3572]. The rate profiles suggest that the exchange follows EX2-type kinetics, and the relative rate values favor a penetration model over a local unfolding model. It was found that the behavior of protons located on the proximal side of the heme is similar in the three proteins. The distal histidyl imidazole NH, however, shows a highly accelerated hydroxyl ion catalyzed rate in horse and dog myoglobins relative to that in sperm whale myoglobin. NMR spectral and relaxational characteristics of the assigned heme cavity protons indicate that the global geometry of the heme pocket is highly conserved in the ground-state structure of the three proteins. We propose a model that attributes the different distal histidine exchange behavior to the relative dynamic stability of the distal heme pocket in dog or horse myoglobin vs. sperm whale myoglobin. This model involves a dynamic equilibrium between a closed heme pocket as found in metaquomyoglobin [Takano, T. (1977) J. Mol. Biol. 110, 537-568] and an open pocket as found in phenylmetmyoglobin [Ringe, D., Petsko, G. A., Kerr, D. E., & Ortiz de Montellano, P. R. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 2-4].(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)