Antigen-specific inhibition of immune interferon production by suppressor cells of autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Previous work from this laboratory has revealed that spleen and/or lymph node cells from Lewis rats, that have recovered from an acute episode of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), suppress the development of EAE when injected into syngeneic recipients subsequently challenged with myelin basic protein (MBP) in CFA. In an effort to understand the mechanism of this suppression, we measured the production of immune IFN-gamma, which may be required for the induction of an immune response, by EAE effector T cells (which transfer disease) and EAE suppressor cells when cultured in vitro with MBP. We now report that EAE effector T cells produce IFN-gamma when cultured in vitro with MBP. In contrast, spleen cells from recovered rats (which manifest suppressor activity in vivo) do not produce IFN-gamma. Moreover, in cell mixing experiments, these suppressor spleen cells inhibited the production of IFN-gamma by EAE effector cells. This inhibition was not eliminated by the removal of macrophages nor by the inhibition of PG synthesis by indomethacin. Furthermore, the inhibition was shown to be Ag-specific and mediated by nylon-adherent, radiation-sensitive splenic T cells. The findings suggest that suppressor cells regulate EAE by inhibiting IFN-gamma production by effector cells. This inhibition may result in the down-regulation of IFN-gamma-induced expression of class II major histocompatibility Ag on cells of the central nervous system, thus reducing the presentation of tissue-specific Ag (i.e., MBP) to autoreactive lymphocytes.     

LF 15-0195 inhibits the development of rat central nervous system autoimmunity by inducing long-lasting tolerance in autoreactive CD4 T cells

Experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) is a T cell-dependent autoimmune disease induced in susceptible animals by a single immunization with myelin basic protein (MBP). LF 15-0195 is a novel immunosuppressor that has been shown to have a potent immunosuppressive effect in several pathological manifestations. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of this drug on the induction and progression of established rat EAE and to dissect the mechanisms involved. We show that LF 15-0195 administration at the time of MBP immunization reduces the incidence and severity of EAE in Lewis rats. This drug also inhibits ongoing and passively induced EAE, indicating that LF 15-0195 affects already differentiated pathogenic lymphocytes. Compared with lymph node cells from untreated rats, lymphocytes from MBP-immunized rats treated with LF 15-0195 proliferated equally well in response to MBP in vitro, while their ability to produce effector cytokines and to transfer EAE into syngeneic recipients was significantly reduced. This phenomenon is stable and long-lasting. Indeed, neither IL-12 nor repeated stimulation with naive APC and MBP in vitro rendered MBP-specific CD4 T cells from protected rats encephalitogenic. In conclusion, LF 15-0195 treatment suppresses EAE by interfering with both the differentiation and effector functions of autoantigen-specific CD4 T cells.     

Decreased IL-12 production underlies the decreased ability of male lymph node cells to induce experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Myelin basic protein (MBP)-specific T lymphocytes from male SJL mice were shown to be less encephalitogenic than MBP-specific T lymphocytes from females. Mechanisms underlying this gender difference in the induction phase of EAE were examined. Following immunization with MBP, draining lymph nodes contained fewer cells, and Ag-specific proliferative responses were decreased in males as compared with females. These gender differences in the proliferative response were not unique to MBP-specific responses since they were also observed after immunization with hen eggwhite lysozyme. Short-term MBP-specific T cell lines derived from females and males mapped with identical specificity, indicating no defect in the ability of male APCs to process Ag. Interestingly, IL-12 and IFN-gamma production was decreased following Ag-specific stimulation of draining lymph node cells (LNC) from males as compared with females, but IL-10 and IL-4 were no different. While male-derived LNCs were less encephalitogenic than female derived LNCs, cotransfer and coculture of male LNCs with female LNCs demonstrated that male LNCs were not immunosuppressive. Administration of IL-12 to LNCs from male mice enhanced encephalitogenicity. These data indicate that deficient endogenous IL-12 production within draining LNCs of male SJL mice is central to gender differences in the induction phase of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis.     

Suppression of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis by oral administration of myelin basic protein. II. Suppression of disease and in vitro immune responses is mediated by antigen-specific CD8+ T lymphocytes

We have previously demonstrated that the oral administration of guinea pig myelin basic protein (MBP) protects Lewis rats against the induction of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) when subsequently immunized with guinea pig MBP in CFA. In addition, animals made orally tolerant to MBP also have diminished proliferative and antibody responses to MBP, but not to other Ag. Nonetheless, the mechanism of oral tolerance to MBP in the EAE model remains undefined. In the present study, we report that T cells isolated from the spleen and mesenteric lymph nodes of MBP orally tolerized animals can adoptively transfer protection against EAE. Furthermore, these T cells are of the CD8+ subclass. In addition, CD8+ T cells from MBP orally tolerized animals also suppress in vitro proliferative responses and antibody responses to MBP in an Ag-specific fashion. These results demonstrate that active cellular mechanisms are initiated after oral administration of an autoantigen that can down-regulate an experimental autoimmune disease and provide the basis for the isolation and characterization of the cells mediating both in vivo and in vitro suppression.     

Indomethacin augments in vitro proliferative responses of Lewis rat lymphocytes to myelin basic protein. Implications for experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Indomethacin (IM), a specific inhibitor of prostaglandin (PG) synthesis, and PGE2 were studied in terms of their ability to modulate in vitro immune responses associated with experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) in Lewis rats. Lymphoid cells from either the spleens or the draining lymph nodes of myelin basic protein (MBP)-sensitized rats exhibited in vitro immune responses which were enhanced in the presence of IM. Specifically, IM enhanced (i) guinea pig MBP (GPMBP)- and rat MBP (RMBP)-stimulated lymphocyte proliferation, (ii) background proliferation, and (iii) interleukin 2 (IL-2)-stimulated proliferation. Conversely, PGE2 inhibited both GPMBP- and IL-2-stimulated proliferation of MBP-sensitized lymphocytes. Together, these results indicate that PGs secreted by cultured lymphoid cells can directly mitigate MBP- or IL-2-stimulated lymphocyte proliferation. Furthermore, the observation that IM and PGE2 modulate in vitro responses of MBP-specific lymphocytes may provide insight into how the in vivo administration of IM potentiates the severity of EAE (H. Ovadia and P.Y. Paterson, Clin. Exp. Immunol. 49, 386, 1982) and how PGs may be involved in the spontaneous remission of EAE in rats.     

PHA activation of encephalitogenic T cells: in vitro line selection overcomes splenic suppression

In this study we compared myelin basic protein (MBP) and phytohemagglutinin (PHA) for their ability to induce proliferation and experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) transfer activity in mixed cell cultures obtained from spleen and lymph nodes versus highly selected MBP-specific T cell lines and clones. Established MBP-specific cells derived initially from immune lymph nodes attained both proliferative and EAE-transfer activities after in vitro activation with either MBP or PHA. In contrast, PHA was unable to induce immune spleen cells to transfer EAE, in spite of its potent mitogenic activity. On the basis of these results, we evaluated the in vitro proliferation and differentiation responses of MBP-specific T cells during the line selection process using cells derived from both immune lymph node and immune spleen. During the initial selection process with MBP, proliferation of MBP-specific T cell precursors from immunized spleen populations was reduced relative to lymph node cells. After antigen-dependent selection the encephalitogenic cells from either organ exhibited identical in vitro response characteristics. Freshly isolated immune spleen cells were potent suppressors of MBP-specific T cell proliferation suggesting that the in vitro differences between the two organs was due to splenic suppression of the encephalitogenic cells.     

Correlation of cytotoxicity with experimental allergic encephalomyelitis.

Cytotoxicity of immune lymph node cells in experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) was maximal 9 days after injection of encephalitogenic emulsion. The ability of these cells to passively transfer EAE was also maximal at this time. Immune spleen cells were more cytotoxic than lymph node cells 9 days after injection; however, these cells did not passively transfer EAE. Twelve days after injection of encephalitogenic emulsion immune spleen cells passively transferred EAE with resulting mild histopathologic lesions. At this time the spleen cells were 50% more cytotoxic than comparable lymph node cells. Cyclophosphamide suppressed the development of clinical EAE and the development of cytotoxic lymphoid cells. It also reduced clinical signs and cytotoxic activity of lymph node cells. Spleen cell cytotoxic activity was enhanced by Cyclophosphamide. It was concluded that cytotoxic activity of lymph node and spleen cells was correlated with the ability of these cells to produce EAE. Lymph node cell populations differed qualitatively and/or quantitatively from immune spleen cell populations in EAE. Capacity to passively transfer EAE coincided with the maximal Cytotoxicity of the lymphoid cells from each tissue.     

Suppression of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis by MBP-coupled lymphoid cells and by MBP-liposomes: a comparison.

In previous experiments, we showed that administration of myelin basic protein (MBP) inserted into phosphatidyl-serine liposomes, to susceptible animals suppressed the clinical manifestations of both acute and chronic-relapsing EAE. In this report we compare the effectiveness of treatment with MBP-liposomes and with MBP-coupled syngeneic spleen cells in EAE protection. Lewis rats treated with 150 micrograms MBP-liposomes or with 160 micrograms (35 x 10(6] MBP-coupled spleen cells, given 7 days before and 7 days after encephalitogenic challenge were equally protected against clinical EAE, when compared to untreated controls. In addition to clinical protection, in vitro proliferative responses of lymphocytes from treated rats were significantly reduced, but delayed hypersensitivity (DTH) reactions remained unaffected. Proliferation of lymphocytes from MBP-sensitized donors was inhibited by the addition of spleen cells but not of lymph node cells from treated donors. The inhibitory effect was observed with spleen cells regardless of whether the donors were treated or not, was antigen nonspecific, and localized in a radio-resistant, adherent cell population. Adoptive transfers of spleen cells from treated donors, after a 48-hr in vitro incubation with concanavalin A, showed that the cells from donors treated with MBP-coupled spleen cells, but not with MBP-liposomes, suppressed the disease in recipients, following challenge with MBP-complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA). These results suggest that two distinct mechanisms operate in the protection by MBP-coupled cells and MBP-liposomes, respectively.     

Suppression of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis by the oral administration of myelin basic protein

The oral administration of myelin basic protein (MBP) to Lewis rats prior to an encephalitogenic challenge resulted in total inhibition or a significant delay in the onset of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE). In vitro lymphocyte proliferative responses to MBP were significantly decreased in MBP-fed rats when compared with vehicle-fed controls. Suppression of EAE and in vitro proliferative responses to MBP were observed to be antigen specific, since oral feeding of a control protein exerted no suppressive effect. Moreover, the specificity of MBP-induced oral tolerance was shown to be species specific, since feeding guinea pig MBP (GPMBP) or human MBP (HuMBP) induced protection only against a GPMBP or HuMBP challenge, respectively. Conversely, Lewis rats could not be orally tolerized to the self antigen rat MBP.     

Rapid depletion of peripheral antigen-specific T cells in TCR-transgenic mice after oral administration of myelin basic protein

In myelin basic protein (MBP)-specific TCR-transgenic (Tg) mice, peripheral T cells express the Valpha2.3/Vbeta8.2-Tg TCR, demonstrate vigorous proliferative responses to MBP in vitro, and can exhibit experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) within 5 days of pertussis toxin injection. We explored the effects of oral administration of MBP on the cellular trafficking of the MBP-specific TCR-Tg cells and the ability of oral MBP to protect Tg mice from EAE. Tg mice were fed MBP, OVA or vehicle and sacrificed at various times after feeding. An immediate and dramatic decrease in Valpha2.3/Vbeta8.2(+)-Tg cells was observed in the periphery within 1 h after feeding. By 3 days after feeding, the percentage of Tg cells increased to near control levels, but decreased again by 10 days. When MBP or vehicle-fed Tg mice were challenged for EAE at this point, disease was severe in the vehicle-fed mice and reduced in the MBP-fed mice over the 40-day observation period. In vitro studies revealed a biphasic pattern of MBP proliferative unresponsiveness and an induction of Th1 cytokines. Immunohistochemical staining showed that the number of Tg cells found in the intestinal lamina propria increased dramatically as the number of Tg cells in the periphery decreased. There was no apparent proliferation of Tg cells in the lamina propria, indicating that Tg cells trafficked there from the periphery. Taken together, these results suggest that T cell trafficking into the site of Ag deposition acts to protect the TCR-Tg mouse from EAE.     

Regulatory T cells maintain long-term tolerance to myelin basic protein by inducing a novel, dynamic state of T cell tolerance

The pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis involves a breakdown in T cell tolerance to myelin proteins like myelin basic protein (MBP). Most MBP-specific T cells are eliminated by central tolerance in adult mice, however, the developmentally regulated expression of MBP allows MBP-specific thymocytes in young mice to escape negative selection. It is not known how these T cells that encounter MBP for the first time in the periphery are regulated. We show that naive MBP-specific T cells transferred into T cell-deficient mice induce severe autoimmunity. Regulatory T cells prevent disease, however, suppression of the newly transferred MBP-specific T cells is abrogated by activating APCs in vivo. Without APC activation, MBP-specific T cells persist in the periphery of protected mice but do not become anergic, raising the question of how long-term tolerance can be maintained if APCs presenting endogenous MBP become activated. Our results demonstrate that regulatory T cells induce naive MBP-specific T cells responding to nonactivated APCs to differentiate into a unique, tolerized state with the ability to produce IL-10 and TGF-beta1 in response to activated, but not nonactivated, APCs presenting MBP. This tolerant response depends on continuous activity of regulatory T cells because, in their absence, these uniquely tolerized MBP-specific T cells can again induce autoimmunity.     

Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis: clinical disease and enhanced cellular transfer in the absence of lymphocyte proliferative responses against syngeneic MBP

Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) was induced in Lewis rats using several different immunization protocols, and draining lymph node cells from these animals were assayed for proliferation against heterologous, homologous, and syngeneic MBP, and syngeneic spinal cord. Proliferative responses were largely stimulated by nonsyngeneic antigenic determinants and correlated better with the antigen used to induce EAE than with signs of autoimmune disease. Lymph node cells from rats immunized with either guinea pig spinal cord or syngeneic MBP did not proliferate measurably when restimulated in vitro with syngeneic MBP, yet lymphoid cells from these animals were enhanced in their capacity to transfer EAE following in vitro stimulation with syngeneic MBP.     

CD4+ suppressor cells differentially affect the production of IFN-gamma by effector cells of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Spleen cells from rats that have recovered from experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) suppress the production of IFN-gamma by effector T cells of EAE in an Ag-specific manner. These postrecovery suppressor cells also inhibit EAE in vivo. Fractionation of the postrecovery suppressor spleen cells on nylon wool and OX-8 coated plates yields a nylon wool-adherent CD4+ suppressor cell population that, when cocultured with effector T cells, suppresses IFN-gamma production by these effector cells. In contrast, the nylon wool-adherent, CD4+ postrecovery suppressor cell population fails to inhibit the production of IL-2 by the effector T cells. In further experiments, the effector T cell population was depleted of CD8+ cells and cocultured with the nylon wool-adherent, CD4+ postrecovery suppressor cells, and the supernatants were assayed for IFN-gamma and IL-2. IFN-gamma production was inhibited in these cultures but IL-2 production was not inhibited. Irradiated effector T cells were cocultured with CD4+ postrecovery suppressor cells, without myelin basic protein, in an effort to determine whether the mechanism of differential lymphokine suppression involved an anti-idiotypic response against effector T cells. No IL-2 was produced, indicating that there was no CD4+ suppressor cell mediated anti-idiotypic response against effector T cells. These studies suggest that the suppressor cell is a nylon wool adherent, CD4+ T cell that functions to down-regulate EAE effector T cells by differential inhibition of lymphokine production.     

Studies on the mechanism of suppression of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis induced by myelin basic protein-cell conjugates

The mechanism of suppression of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) induced in Lewis rats by pretreatment with myelin basic protein (MBP) coupled to syngeneic spleen leukocytes (SL) was examined. Studies on the kinetics of the tolerance induction showed that pretreatment with MBP-SL suppressed EAE if given 7 but not 3 days before the disease-inducing injection of MBP in Freund's complete adjuvant. Treatment with cyclophosphamide 48 hr before administration of MBP-SL completely abolished the suppression of EAE. Transfer of lymph node and spleen cells from MBP-syngeneic erythrocyte conjugate (MBP-RBC) but not MBP-SL-pretreated rats resulted in suppression of disease in recipients subsequently given a disease-inducing injection of MBP. Administration of MBP coupled to SL from the histocompatible rat strain F344 resulted in suppression of the MBP-induced proliferative response of spleen cells from Lewis rats which had been given a disease-inducing injection of MBP. Taken together these results are consistent with the suppression of EAE induced by MBP-SL being mediated by suppressor T cells.     

Modulation of adoptive cell transfers in experimental allergic encephalomyelitis by antigen treatment of donors

Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis has been adoptively transferred using lymph node cells from Strain 13 guinea pig donors sensitized with purified encephalitogenic myelin basic protein. Adoptive cell transfer was used to examine the immunocompetence of lymph node cells obtained from guinea pigs protected from disease development by treatment with MBP. Lymph node cells from guinea pigs unresponsive to EAE challenge do not adoptively transfer disease. Cells obtained from guinea pigs treated with MBP following encephalitogenic challenge are competent in adoptive transfer with respect to pathologic lesions, but not clinical disease. The clinical and pathologic responses of recipients of the histocompatible lymphocyte populations are similar to those seen in the treatment-matched donor controls, suggesting that under these circumstances lymphoid cells, rather than circulating soluble factors, are responsible for disease induction and suppression.     

Inhibition of adoptive secondary responses by lymphoid cell populations

The ability of normal and tolerant lymphoid cells to inhibit the adoptive secondary response was investigated in order to delineate the influence which the host can exert on a memory cell population as the host recovers from the effects of irradiation. LBN rats were irradiated with 500R whole body X-irradiation, reconstituted with either normal or tolerant lymphoid cells, then they were given immune spleen cells and challenged with soluble antigen (DNP-BGG). Cells capable of suppressing the adoptive secondary responses were shown to possess the following characteristics: 1) in nonimmune donors they were found in the greatest concentration in lymph nodes, followed by spleen and bone marrow and were practically absent in the thymus; 2) their numbers were not increased in donors rendered tolerant by long term treatment with deaggregated DNP-BGG plus cyclophosphamide nor in donors given large doses of DNP-BGG 48 to 72 hr before sacrifice; 3) in animals rendered tolerant by long term antigen treatment alone some enhancement of suppressor function was seen; 4) the suppressor cells could be shown among both glass wool adherent and nonadherent cells and 5) the nonantigen specific suppressor cells did not affect the kinetics of antibody formation nor the affinity of the antibody which was produced. These results are discussed in terms of the nature and source of the suppressor cell populations and their relevance to the control of secondary responses in intact animals.     

Competition between foreign and self proteins in antigen presentation. Ovalbumin can inhibit activation of myelin basic protein-specific T cells.

Experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) is an inflammatory neurological disease initiated by activated T cells specific for the autoantigen, myelin basic protein (MBP). The ability of Lewis rat splenic T cells to transfer EAE after in vitro incubation with MBP-pulsed dendritic cells (DC) was used as an index of MBP-specific T cell activation. OVA, previously processed by macrophages, was incubated with MBP and DC at the pulsing stage to determine whether it could inhibit presentation of the autoantigen. At molar equivalents of 2.5:1 and 20:1 relative to MBP, processed OVA increasingly inhibited the ability of DC to activate MBP-specific T cells for EAE transfer. Unprocessed OVA, which cannot be presented immunogenically by Lewis rat DC, was much less effective. However, processed OVA added to DC after they had been pulsed with MBP could not compete. OVA also blocked appearance of EAE when mixed with MBP/CFA in the inoculum used for active induction of the disease. Splenic T cells from MBP + OVA/CFA-immunized rats transferred EAE with a substantially delayed onset, suggesting that a reduced number of MBP-specific T cells was generated by immunizing with the OVA + MBP mixture compared with MBP alone. Overall, the data indicate that fragments of a foreign protein, OVA, which can be bound by APC, can also inhibit presentation of encephalitogenic determinants of MBP to T cells.     

The role of myelin lipids in experimental allergic encephalomyelitis. III. Transfer of suppression from guinea pigs recovering from EAE, induced by myelin basic protein--galactocerebroside complexes

Juvenile strain 13 guinea pigs were immunized with myelin basic protein (MBP) combined with galactocerebrosides (MBP + GC) or with total myelin lipids without GC [MBP + (TL-GC)] in CFA. Control animals received dinitrophenylated-ovalbumin (DNP-OA) in CFA, CFA or IFA alone. The animals injected with MBP + GC showed a higher rate of recovery from the first EAE episode (83%) than those treated with MBP + (TL-GC) (50%). With the exception of the group treated with IFA alone, all animals were refractory to EAE following rechallenge with MBP in CFA 90 days after the first exposure. The in vitro proliferative response to MBP, of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) derived from guinea pigs freshly sensitized to MBP in CFA, was drastically suppressed in the presence of PBLs from animals injected with MBP + GC. Upon transfer to normal syngeneic recipients, spleen cells from MBP + GC-treated animals completely suppressed the clinical and histological manifestations of EAE following recipient challenge with MBP in CFA. Cell-free supernatants from PBLs and spleen cells of strain 13 guinea pigs treated with MBP + GC inhibited lymphocyte proliferation to MBP, of allogeneic responder cells, and spleen cell supernatants completely suppressed the induction of EAE upon transfer to allogeneic recipients. Suppression could not be transferred with cells from other treated groups. These results suggest that animals immunized with MBP + galactocerebrosides in CFA develop suppressor cells that may be in part responsible for the recovery from the first EAE episode and for protection against rechallenge with MBP in CFA. Their cell-free supernatants act in an MHC-nonrestricted fashion. These results do not rule out an additional protective mechanism since all animals exposed to CFA were refractory to rechallenge despite lack of demonstrable suppressor cell activity.     

3H-uridine incorporation by small lymphocytes of tolerant rats: relationship to T and B lymphocytes.

Tissue tolerance was induced in neonatal rats by the intravenous injection of bone marrow cells from adult allogeneic rat donors. After 6 to 8 weeks, lymphoid cells from rats in which tolerance had been induced were tested for mixed lymphocyte reactivity (MLR), 3H-uridine uptake, and the relationship of uridine incorporation to B and T lymphocytes. Lymph node (LN) and spleen (SPL) cells from the adult inoculated rats showed no reactivity in the MLR or normal lymphocyte transfer reaction (NLTRx), indicating that the animals were tolerant. After in vitro exposure to 3H-uridine, an abundance of small lymphocytes (SL) from these same tolerant rats were heavily labeled, in contrast to nontolerant controls, where relatively few SL were heavily labeled. In order to determine whether the heavily uridine-labeled cells were T cells or B cells, lymphoid cells from the LN and SPL of tolerant animals were exposed to either rabbit anti-AKR brain serum or rabbit anti-rat Ig conjugated with ferritin. The results showed that the heavily uridine-labeled SL of the tolerant rats were mainly Ig-positive cells.