Calmodulin-like Proteins from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis</Emphasis> and Tomato are Involved in Host Defense Against <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pseudomonas syringae</Emphasis> pv. <Emphasis Type="Italic">tomato</Emphasis>

Complex signal transduction pathways underlie the myriad plant responses to attack by pathogens. Ca²⁺ is a universal second messenger in eukaryotes that modulates various signal transduction pathways through stimulus-specific changes in its intracellular concentration. Ca²⁺-binding proteins such as calmodulin (CaM) detect Ca²⁺ signals and regulate downstream targets as part of a coordinated cellular response to a given stimulus. Here we report the characterization of a tomato gene (APR134) encoding a CaM-related protein that is induced in disease-resistant leaves in response to attack by Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato. We show that suppression of APR134 gene expression in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum), using virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS), compromises the plant’s immune response. We isolated APR134-like genes from Arabidopsis, termed CML42 and CML43, to investigate whether they serve a functionally similar role. Gene expression analysis revealed that CML43 is rapidly induced in disease-resistant Arabidopsis leaves following inoculation with Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato. Overexpression of CML43 in Arabidopsis accelerated the hypersensitive response. Recombinant APR134, CML42, and CML43 proteins all bind Ca²⁺ in vitro. Collectively, our data support a role for CML43, and APR134 as important mediators of Ca²⁺-dependent signals during the plant immune response to bacterial pathogens. This work was supported by a research grant (WAS) and postgraduate scholarships (DC, SLD) from the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada, the National Science Foundation (IBN-0109633; GBM), and the Swedish Research Council (SKE).     

Characterization of a pathogen-induced calmodulin-binding protein: mapping of four Ca2+-dependent calmodulin-binding domains

Ca²⁺ and calmodulin (CaM), a key Ca²⁺ sensor in all eukaryotes, have been implicated in defense responses in plants. To elucidate the role of Ca²⁺ and CaM in defense signaling, we used ³⁵S-labeled CaM to screen expression libraries prepared from tissues that were either treated with an elicitor derived from Phytophthora megasperma or infected with Pseudomonas syringae pv. tabaci. Nineteen cDNAs that encode the same protein, pathogen-induced CaM-binding protein (PICBP), were isolated. The PICBP fusion proteins bound ³⁵S-CaM, horseradish peroxidase-labeled CaM and CaM-Sepharose in the presence of Ca²⁺ whereas EGTA, a Ca²⁺ chelator, abolished binding, confirming that PICBP binds CaM in a Ca²⁺-dependent manner. Using a series of bacterially expressed truncated versions of PICBP, four CaM-binding domains, with a potential CaM-binding consensus sequence of WSNLKKVILLKRFVKSL, were identified. The deduced PICBP protein sequence is rich in leucine residues and contains three classes of repeats. The PICBP gene is differentially expressed in tissues with the highest expression in stem. The expression of PICBP in Arabidopsis was induced in response to avirulent Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato carrying avrRpm1. Furthermore, PICBP is constitutively expressed in the Arabidopsis accelerated cell death2-2 mutant. The expression of PICBP in bean leaves was also induced after inoculation with avirulent and non-pathogenic bacterial strains. In addition, the hrp1 mutant of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tabaci and inducers of plant defense such as salicylic acid, hydrogen peroxide and a fungal elicitor induced PICBP expression in bean. Our data suggest a role for PICBP in Ca²⁺-mediated defense signaling and cell-death. Furthermore, PICBP is the first identified CBP in eukaryotes with four Ca²⁺-dependent CaM-binding domains.     

The Arabidopsis calmodulin‐like protein,CML39, functions during early seedling establishment

During Ca²⁺ signal transduction, Ca²⁺‐binding proteins known as Ca²⁺ sensors function to decode stimulus‐specific Ca²⁺ signals into downstream responses. Plants possess extended families of unique Ca²⁺ sensors termed calmodulin‐like proteins (CMLs) whose cellular roles are not well understood. CML39 encodes a predicted Ca²⁺ sensor whose expression is strongly increased in response to diverse external stimuli. In the present study, we explored the biochemical properties of recombinant CML39, and used a reverse genetics approach to investigate its physiological role. Our data indicate that Ca²⁺ binding by CML39 induces a conformational change in the protein that results in an increase in exposed‐surface hydrophobicity, a property that is consistent with its predicted function as a Ca²⁺ sensor. Loss‐of‐function cml39 mutants resemble wild‐type plants under normal growth conditions but exhibit persistent arrest at the seedling stage if grown in the absence of sucrose or other metabolizable carbon sources. Under short‐day conditions, cml39 mutants display increased sucrose‐induced hypocotyl elongation. When grown in the dark, cml39 mutants show impaired hypocotyl elongation in the absence of sucrose. Promoter–reporter data indicate that CML39 expression is prominent in the apical hook in dark‐grown seedlings. Collectively, our data suggest that CML39 functions in Arabidopsis as a Ca²⁺ sensor that plays an important role in the transduction of light signals that promote seedling establishment.     

AtCML8, a calmodulin-like protein, differentially activating CaM-dependent enzymes in Arabidopsis thaliana

Plants express many calmodulins (CaMs) and calmodulin-like (CML) proteins that sense and transduce different Ca²⁺ signals. Previously, we reported divergent soybean (Glycine max) CaM isoforms (GmCaM4/5) with differential abilities to activate CaM-dependent enzymes. To elucidate biological functions of divergent CaM proteins, we isolated a cDNA encoding a CML protein, AtCML8, from Arabidopsis. AtCML8 shows highest identity with GmCaM4 at the protein sequence level. Expression of AtCML8 was high in roots, leaves, and flowers but low in stems. In addition, the expression of AtCML8 was induced by exposure to salicylic acid or NaCl. AtCML8 showed typical characteristics of CaM such as Ca²⁺-dependent electrophoretic mobility shift and Ca²⁺ binding ability. In immunoblot analyses, AtCML8 was recognized only by antiserum against GmCaM4 but not by GmCaM1 antibodies. Interestingly, AtCML8 was able to activate phosphodiesterase (PDE) but did not activate NAD kinase. These results suggest that AtCML8 acts as a CML protein in Arabidopsis with characteristics similar to soybean divergent GmCaM4 at the biochemical levels.     

Innate immunity signaling: cytosolic Ca2+ elevation is linked to downstream nitric oxide generation through the action of calmodulin or a calmodulin-like protein

Ca²⁺ rise and nitric oxide (NO) generation are essential early steps in plant innate immunity and initiate the hypersensitive response (HR) to avirulent pathogens. Previous work from this laboratory has demonstrated that a loss-of-function mutation of an Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) plasma membrane Ca²⁺-permeable inwardly conducting ion channel impairs HR and that this phenotype could be rescued by the application of a NO donor. At present, the mechanism linking cytosolic Ca²⁺ rise to NO generation during pathogen response signaling in plants is still unclear. Animal nitric oxide synthase (NOS) activation is Ca²⁺/calmodulin (CaM) dependent. Here, we present biochemical and genetic evidence consistent with a similar regulatory mechanism in plants: a pathogen-induced Ca²⁺ signal leads to CaM and/or a CaM-like protein (CML) activation of NOS. In wild-type Arabidopsis plants, the use of a CaM antagonist prevents NO generation and the HR. Application of a CaM antagonist does not prevent pathogen-induced cytosolic Ca²⁺ elevation, excluding the possibility of CaM acting upstream from Ca²⁺. The CaM antagonist and Ca²⁺ chelation abolish NO generation in wild-type Arabidopsis leaf protein extracts as well, suggesting that plant NOS activity is Ca²⁺/CaM dependent in vitro. The CaM-like protein CML24 has been previously associated with NO-related phenotypes in Arabidopsis. Here, we find that innate immune response phenotypes (HR and [avirulent] pathogen-induced NO elevation in leaves) are inhibited in loss-of-function cml24-4 mutant plants. Pathogen-associated molecular pattern-mediated NO generation in cells of cml24-4 mutants is impaired as well. Our work suggests that the initial pathogen recognition signal of Ca²⁺ influx into the cytosol activates CaM and/or a CML, which then acts to induce downstream NO synthesis as intermediary steps in a pathogen perception signaling cascade, leading to innate immune responses, including the HR.     

Experimental and computational approaches for the study of calmodulin interactions

Ca²⁺, a universal messenger in eukaryotes, plays a major role in signaling pathways that control many growth and developmental processes in plants as well as their responses to various biotic and abiotic stresses. Cellular changes in Ca²⁺ in response to diverse signals are recognized by protein sensors that either have their activity modulated or that interact with other proteins and modulate their activity. Calmodulins (CaMs) and CaM-like proteins (CMLs) are Ca²⁺ sensors that have no enzymatic activity of their own but upon binding Ca²⁺ interact and modulate the activity of other proteins involved in a large number of plant processes. Protein-protein interactions play a key role in Ca²⁺/CaM-mediated in signaling pathways. In this review, using CaM as an example, we discuss various experimental approaches and computational tools to identify protein-protein interactions. During the last two decades hundreds of CaM-binding proteins in plants have been identified using a variety of approaches ranging from simple screening of expression libraries with labeled CaM to high-throughput screens using protein chips. However, the high-throughput methods have not been applied to the entire proteome of any plant system. Nevertheless, the data provided by these screens allows the development of computational tools to predict CaM-interacting proteins. Using all known binding sites of CaM, we developed a computational method that predicted over 700 high confidence CaM interactors in the Arabidopsis proteome. Most (>600) of these are not known to bind calmodulin, suggesting that there are likely many more CaM targets than previously known. Functional analyses of some of the experimentally identified Ca²⁺ sensor target proteins have uncovered their precise role in Ca²⁺-mediated processes. Further studies on identifying novel targets of CaM and CMLs and generating their interaction network - “calcium sensor interactome” - will help us in understanding how Ca²⁺ regulates a myriad of cellular and physiological processes.     

The emerging function of IQD proteins as scaffolds in cellular signaling and trafficking

Calcium (Ca²⁺) signaling modules are essential for adjusting plant growth and performance to environmental constraints. Differential interactions between sensors of Ca²⁺ dynamics and their molecular targets are at the center of the transduction process. Calmodulin (CaM) and CaM-like (CML) proteins are principal Ca²⁺-sensors in plants that govern the activities of numerous downstream proteins with regulatory properties. The families of IQ67-Domain (IQD) proteins are a large class of plant-specific CaM/CML-targets (e.g., 33 members in A. thaliana) which share a unique domain of multiple varied CaM retention motifs in tandem orientation. Genetic studies in Arabidopsis and tomato revealed first roles for IQD proteins related to basal defense response and plant development. Molecular, biochemical and histochemical analysis of Arabidopsis IQD1 demonstrated association with microtubules as well as targeting to the cell nucleus and nucleolus. In vivo binding to CaM and kinesin light chain-related protein-1 (KLCR1) suggests a Ca²⁺-regulated scaffolding function of IQD1 in kinesin motor-dependent transport of multiprotein complexes. Furthermore, because IQD1 interacts in vitro with single-stranded nucleic acids, the prospect arises that IQD1 and other IQD family members facilitate cellular RNA localization as one mechanism to control and fine-tune gene expression and protein sorting.     

A novel rice calmodulin-like gene, <Emphasis Type="Italic">OsMSR2,</Emphasis> enhances drought and salt tolerance and increases ABA sensitivity in Arabidopsis

Many abiotic stimuli, such as drought and salt stresses, elicit changes in intracellular calcium levels that serve to convey information and activate adaptive responses. Ca²⁺ signals are perceived by different Ca²⁺ sensors, and calmodulin (CaM) is one of the best-characterized Ca²⁺ sensors in eukaryotes. Calmodulin-like (CML) proteins also exist in plants, but their functions at the physiological and molecular levels are largely unknown. In this report, we present data on OsMSR2 (Oryza sativa L. Multi-Stress-Responsive gene 2), a novel calmodulin-like protein gene isolated from rice Pei’ai 64S (Oryza sativa L.). Expression of OsMSR2 was strongly up-regulated by a wide spectrum of stresses, including cold, drought, and heat in different tissues at different developmental stages of rice, as revealed by both microarray and quantitative real-time RT-PCR analyses. Analysis of the recombinant OsMSR2 protein demonstrated its potential ability to bind Ca²⁺ in vitro. Expression of OsMSR2 conferred enhanced tolerance to high salt and drought in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) accompanied by altered expression of stress/ABA-responsive genes. Transgenic plants also exhibited hypersensitivity to ABA during the seed germination and post-germination stages. The results suggest that expression of OsMSR2 modulated salt and drought tolerance in Arabidopsis through ABA-mediated pathways.     

Kinase activity and calmodulin binding are essential for growth signaling by the phytosulfokine receptor PSKR1

The cell growth‐promoting peptide phytosulfokine (PSK) is perceived by leucine‐rich repeat (LRR) receptor kinases. To elucidate PSK receptor function we analyzed PSKR1 kinase activity and binding to Ca²⁺ sensors and evaluated the contribution of these activities to growth control in planta. Ectopically expressed PSKR1 was capable of auto‐ and transphosphorylation. Replacement of a conserved lysine within the ATP‐binding region by a glutamate resulted in the inhibition of auto‐ and transphosphorylation kinase activities. Expression of the kinase‐inactive PSKR1(K762E) receptor in the pskr null background did not restore root or shoot growth. Instead, the mutant phenotype was enhanced suggesting that the inactive receptor protein exerts growth‐inhibitory activity. Bioinformatic analysis predicted a putative calmodulin (CaM)‐binding site within PSKR1 kinase subdomain VIa. Bimolecular fluorescence complementation analysis demonstrated that PSKR1 binds to all isoforms of CaM, more weakly to the CaM‐like protein CML8 but apparently not to CML9. Mutation of a conserved tryptophan (W831S) within the predicted CaM‐binding site strongly reduced CaM binding. Expression of PSKR1(W831S) in the pskr null background resulted in growth inhibition that was similar to that of the kinase‐inactive receptor. We conclude that PSK signaling requires Ca²⁺/CaM binding and kinase activity of PSKR1 in planta. We further propose that the inactivated kinase interferes with other growth‐promoting signaling pathway(s).     

Genome-wide identification and analyses of the rice calmodulin and related potential calcium sensor proteins

Background  

A wide range of stimuli evoke rapid and transient increases in [Ca²⁺]_cyt in plant cells which are transmitted by protein sensors that contain EF-hand motifs. Here, a group of Oryza sativa L. genes encoding calmodulin (CaM) and CaM-like (CML) proteins that do not possess functional domains other than the Ca²⁺-binding EF-hand motifs was analyzed.     

Principles of Calcium Signal Generation and Transduction in Plant Cells

Calcium ions exhibit unique properties and a universal ability to transmit diverse signals in plant cells under the primary action of hormones, pathogens, light, gravity, and various abiotic stressors. In the last few years, considerable progress has been achieved in deciphering the mechanisms of Ca²⁺ involvement in the regulation of plant responses. Recent studies revealed the genes encoding Ca²⁺-permeable channels that conduct Ca²⁺ currents across the membranes during the transduction of the Ca²⁺ signal. These proteins comprise the ligand-gated Ca²⁺-permeable channels activated by cyclic nucleotides (CNGC) and amino acids (glutamate receptor-like channels, GLR), the voltage-gated tonoplast channel (two-pore channel, TPC1), mechanosensitive channels (MSL, MCA, OSCA1), and annexins. The role of Ca²⁺-ATPase and Ca²⁺/H⁺-exchangers in the active extrusion of excess cytoplasmic Ca²⁺ into the apoplast or cell organelles was examined in detail. The calmodulins (CaM), CaM-like proteins (CML), Ca²⁺-dependent protein kinases (CDPK), and complexes of calcineurin-B-like proteins (CBL) with CBL-interacting protein kinases (CIPK) were found to produce intricate signaling networks that decode Ca²⁺ signals and elicit plant responses to external stimuli. This review analyzes the data accumulated over the past decade on the principles of formation and propagation of the calcium signal in plant cells.     

Modular architecture of Munc13/calmodulin complexes: dual regulation by Ca2+ and possible function in short‐term synaptic plasticity

Ca²⁺ signalling in neurons through calmodulin (CaM) has a prominent function in regulating synaptic vesicle trafficking, transport, and fusion. Importantly, Ca²⁺–CaM binds a conserved region in the priming proteins Munc13‐1 and ubMunc13‐2 and thus regulates synaptic neurotransmitter release in neurons in response to residual Ca²⁺ signals. We solved the structure of Ca²⁺₄–CaM in complex with the CaM‐binding domain of Munc13‐1, which features a novel 1‐5‐8‐26 CaM‐binding motif with two separated mobile structural modules, each involving a CaM domain. Photoaffinity labelling data reveal the same modular architecture in the complex with the ubMunc13‐2 isoform. The N‐module can be dissociated with EGTA to form the half‐loaded Munc13/Ca²⁺₂–CaM complex. The Ca²⁺ regulation of these Munc13 isoforms can therefore be explained by the modular nature of the Munc13/Ca²⁺–CaM interactions, where the C‐module provides a high‐affinity interaction activated at nanomolar [Ca²⁺]_i, whereas the N‐module acts as a sensor at micromolar [Ca²⁺]_i. This Ca²⁺/CaM‐binding mode of Munc13 likely constitutes a key molecular correlate of the characteristic Ca²⁺‐dependent modulation of short‐term synaptic plasticity.     

Differential expression of genes encoding calmodulin-binding proteins in response to bacterial pathogens and inducers of defense responses

Calmodulin (CaM) plays an important role in sensing and transducing changes in cellular Ca²⁺ concentration in response to several biotic and abiotic stresses. Although CaM is implicated in plant-pathogen interactions, its molecular targets and their role in defense signaling pathway(s) are poorly understood. To elucidate the signaling pathways that link CaM to defense responses, we screened a cDNA library constructed from bean leaves undergoing a hypersensitive response (HR) with radiolabeled CaM isoforms. A total of 26 putative CBPs were identified. Sequencing of the cDNAs revealed that they represent 8 different genes. They are homologues of previously identified CaM-binding proteins (CBPs) in other systems. However, some CBPs are novel members of known CBP families. The proteins encoded by these clones bound CaM in a Ca²⁺-dependent manner. To determine if these CBPs are involved in plant defense responses, we analyzed their expression in bean leaves inoculated with compatible, incompatible and nonpathogenic bacterial strains. Expression of three CBPs including an isoform of cyclic nucleotide-gated channels (PvCNGC-A) and two hypothetical proteins (PvCBP60-C and PvCBP60-D) was induced whereas the expression of two other isoforms of CNGCs (PvCNGC-Band PvCNGC-C) was repressed in response to incompatible pathogens. The expression of the rest, a small auxin up RNA (PvSAUR1) and two hypothetical proteins (PvCBP60-Aand PvCBP60-B), was not changed. The expression of most of the pathogen-regulated genes was also affected by salicylic acid, jasmonic acid, hydrogen peroxide and a fungal elicitor, which are known to induce defense responses. Our results strongly suggest that at least five bean CBPs are involved in plant defense responses.     

Metal binding affinity and structural properties of calmodulin‐like protein 14 from Arabidopsis thaliana

In addition to the well‐known Ca²⁺ sensor calmodulin, plants possess many calmodulin‐like proteins (CMLs) that are predicted to have specific roles in the cell. Herein, we described the biochemical and biophysical characterization of recombinant Arabidopsis thaliana CML14. We applied isothermal titration calorimetry to analyze the energetics of Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ binding to CML14, and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, together with intrinsic and ANS‐based fluorescence, to evaluate the structural effects of metal binding and metal‐induced conformational changes. Furthermore, differential scanning calorimetry and limited proteolysis were used to characterize protein thermal and local stability. Our data demonstrate that CML14 binds one Ca²⁺ ion with micromolar affinity (K_d ～ 12 µM) and the presence of 10 mM Mg²⁺ decreases the Ca²⁺ affinity by ～5‐fold. Although binding of Ca²⁺ to CML14 increases protein stability, it does not result in a more hydrophobic protein surface and does not induce the large conformational rearrangement typical of Ca²⁺ sensors, but causes only localized structural changes in the unique functional EF‐hand. Our data, together with a molecular modelling prediction, provide interesting insights into the biochemical properties of Arabidopsis CML14 and may be useful to direct additional studies aimed at understanding its physiological role.     

Early changes in apoplast composition associated with defence and disease in interactions between Phaseolus vulgaris and the halo blight pathogen Pseudomonas syringae Pv. phaseolicola

The apoplast is the arena in which endophytic pathogens such as Pseudomonas syringae grow and interact with plant cells. Using metabolomic and ion analysis techniques, this study shows how the composition of Phaseolus vulgaris leaf apoplastic fluid changes during the first six hours of compatible and incompatible interactions with two strains of P. syringae pv. phaseolicola (Pph) that differ in the presence of the genomic island PPHGI‐1. Leaf inoculation with the avirulent island‐carrying strain Pph 1302A elicited effector‐triggered immunity (ETI) and resulted in specific changes in apoplast composition, including increases in conductivity, pH, citrate, γ‐aminobutyrate (GABA) and K⁺, that are linked to the onset of plant defence responses. Other apoplastic changes, including increases in Ca²⁺, Fe^2/3+ Mg²⁺, sucrose, β‐cyanoalanine and several amino acids, occurred to a relatively similar extent in interactions with both Pph 1302A and the virulent, island‐less strain Pph RJ3. Metabolic footprinting experiments established that Pph preferentially metabolizes malate, glucose and glutamate, but excludes certain other abundant apoplastic metabolites, including citrate and GABA, until preferred metabolites are depleted. These results demonstrate that Pph is well‐adapted to the leaf apoplast metabolic environment and that loss of PPHGI‐1 enables Pph to avoid changes in apoplast composition linked to plant defences.     

Consequences of flagellin export through the type III secretion system of Pseudomonas syringae reveal a major difference in the innate immune systems of mammals and the model plant Nicotiana benthamiana

Bacterial flagellin is perceived as a microbe (or pathogen)‐associated molecular pattern (MAMP or PAMP) by the extracellular pattern recognition receptors, FLS2 and TLR5, of plants and mammals respectively. Flagellin accidently translocated into mammalian cells by pathogen type III secretion systems (T3SSs) is recognized by nucleotide‐binding leucine‐rich repeat receptor NLRC4 as a pattern of pathogenesis and induces a death‐associated immune response. The non‐pathogen Pseudomonas fluorescens Pf0‐1, expressing a Pseudomonas syringae T3SS, and the plant pathogen P. syringae pv. tomato DC3000 were used to seek evidence of an analogous cytoplasmic recognition system for flagellin in the model plant Nicotiana benthamiana. Flagellin (FliC) was secreted in culture and translocated into plant cells by the T3SS expressed in Pf0‐1 and DC3000 and in their ΔflgGHI flagellar pathway mutants. ΔfliC and ΔflgGHI mutants of Pf0‐1 and DC3000 were strongly reduced in elicitation of reactive oxygen species production and in immunity induction as indicated by the ability of challenge bacteria inoculated 6 h later to translocate a type III effector–reporter and to elicit effector‐triggered cell death. Agrobacterium‐mediated transient expression in N. benthamiana of FliC with or without a eukaryotic export signal peptide, coupled with virus‐induced gene silencing of FLS2, revealed no immune response that was not FLS2 dependent. Transiently expressed FliC from DC3000 and Pectobacterium carotovorum did notinduce cell death in N. benthamiana, tobacco or tomato leaves. Flagellin is the major Pseudomonas MAMP perceived by N. benthamiana, and although flagellin secretion through the plant cell wall by the T3SS may partially contribute to FLS2‐dependent immunity, flagellin in the cytosol does not elicit immune‐associated cell death. We postulate that a death response to translocated MAMPs would produce vulnerability to the many necrotrophic pathogens of plants, such as P. carotovorum, which differ from P. syringae and other (hemi)biotrophic pathogens in benefitting from death‐associated immune responses.