A single surgeon's experience with the Delaire palatoplasty

The purpose of this review was to evaluate the clinical outcomes regarding velopharyngeal insufficiency and fistulization in patients with cleft palate who underwent primary repair with the one-stage Delaire palatoplasty. All patients who had a primary Delaire-type palatoplasty performed by the senior surgeon over a 10-year period (1988 to 1998) were studied. During this period, each consecutive patient with an open palatal cleft underwent the same type of repair by the same surgeon. Speech quality and velopharyngeal competence as determined by a single speech pathologist were recorded. A total of 95 patients were included in this series. The average length of follow-up was 31 months (range, 1 to 118 months). Average age at time of surgery was 13.3 months (range, 6 to 180 months). Thirty-one patients (32.6 percent) had significant associated anomalies. The average length of hospital stay was 1.9 days (range, 1 to 8 days) with a trend in recent years toward discharge on postoperative day 1. There were no intraoperative complications, either surgical or anesthetic. Three patients (3.2 percent) developed palatal fistula; none of them required repair. Six patients (6.3 percent) had velopharyngeal incompetence. In patients with more than 1 year of follow-up, the incidence of velopharyngeal incompetence was 9.2 percent (6 of 65). The incidence of fistula after the Delaire palatoplasty was lower than usually reported. The incidence of velopharyngeal incompetence requiring pharyngoplasty was equal to or lower than that seen after other types of palatoplasty, suggesting superior soft-palate muscle function attributable to approximation of the musculus uvulae. The Delaire palatoplasty results in a functional palate with low risk for fistula formation and velopharyngeal incompetence.     

Long-term results following the repair of palatal clefts: a comparison of three different techniques

A series of 109 patients was divided according to type of palatal defect, technique of repair (pushback, von Langenbeck, or pushback with island flap), results of standardized multifactorial speech analyses, and effectiveness of primary and secondary operations. Sixty-five patients (60 percent) showed improved speech after the initial repair, with 49 of these rated as "good." Forty-five percent improved after the von Langenbeck operation, 57 percent improved after the pushback procedure, and 53 percent improved after the pushback/island flap repair. Persistent hypernasal speech was treated with superiorly based pharyngeal flaps in 18 patients with uniform success (p less than or equal to 0.001). The worst results (after all three techniques) followed the repair of bilateral complete clefts. This experience has tempered our expectations in dealing with cleft palate patients, especially those having bilateral defects.     

Role of free-tissue transfer in the treatment of recalcitrant palatal fistulae among patients with cleft palates

Recurrent palatal fistulae present a particularly vexing problem for patients with cleft lips and palates and their surgeons. When primary closure fails, conventional wisdom and the standard of care suggest local flap techniques for defect closure. For the large majority of patients, this approach is successful. There is, however, a small subset of patients who undergo multiple surgical procedures in unsuccessful attempts to close recalcitrant fistulae, particularly at the anterior, densely scarred, hard palate. In this setting, repair calls for the introduction of well-vascularized pliable tissue to close the defect and to avoid hampering further palatal growth. Local muscle flaps and oral axial pattern flaps have been advocated and used successfully. However, those approaches have their own drawbacks, such as multiple surgical interventions, patient compliance, and intraoral scarring. In an effort to avoid the problems associated with local flaps, distant microvascular tissue transfers were investigated. During a 6-year period, six free-tissue transfers were performed as a primary means of treating recalcitrant palatal fistulae. Three dorsalis pedis flaps and three osseous angular scapular flaps were used. The conditions of all patients improved, with five patients achieving complete long-term closure of the palatal defect. This experience indicates that modern microvascular techniques have reached a level of success commensurate with that of other flap techniques; therefore, it is concluded that free-tissue transfer should be considered as a primary means of addressing these difficult cleft problems.     

Free forearm flap for closure of difficult oronasal fistulas in cleft palate patients.

There were four patients with palatal clefts who had been operated on many times previously but who still had large oronasal defects due to wound disruption. Moreover, there was considerable scar in the residual palatal tissue, which was contracted in the anteroposterior dimension. These patients were treated with a radial forearm flap transfer. The technical aspects of this reconstruction are emphasized, especially methods to enhance primary healing and to facilitate in setting the flap. Three of the patients were successfully reconstructed with one operation. The fourth had a small area of dehiscence anteriorly that was later closed with advancement of the flap tissue. There were no other complications. With the replacement of healthy tissue, the palate could be pushed further back to achieve better repair of the muscle. This would contribute to better speech function. In every patient, nasal regurgitation was eliminated, and speech quality improved significantly. The radial forearm flap is ideal for intraoral use, providing thin, hairless skin with a long, large-caliber vascular pedicle. It can reconstruct defects in one stage with well-vascularized tissue and minimal dissection of the palate. In a select group of cleft palate patients, this free-tissue transfer should be considered to achieve closure of large oronasal fistulas in patients with dense scar.     

Incidence of cleft palate fistula: an institutional experience with two-stage palatal repair.

The purpose of this study was to determine the incidence of cleft palatal fistula in a series of nonsyndromic children treated at the authors' institution. This retrospective analysis of 103 patients with cleft palate treated by five surgeons between 1982 and 1995 includes 60 boys and 33 girls, whose median age was 18.4 months at the time of surgery. The median length of follow-up was 4.9 years after primary palatoplasty. Cleft palatal fistula was defined as a failure of healing or a breakdown in the primary surgical repair of the palate. Intentionally unrepaired fistulas of the primary and secondary palate were excluded. Extent of clefting was described according to the Veau classification. Statistical examination of multiple variables was performed using contingency table analysis, multivariate logistic regression, and the Wilcoxon rank sum test. The incidence of cleft palatal fistula in this series was 8.7 percent. All of these fistulas were clinically significant. The rate of fistula recurrence was 33 percent. The incidence of cleft palatal fistula when compared by Veau classification was statistically significant, with nine fistulas occurring in patients with Veau 3 and 4 clefts and no fistulas occurring in patients with Veau 1 and 2 clefts (p = 0.0441). No significant differences between patients with and without fistulas were identified with respect to operating surgeon, patient sex, patient age at palatoplasty, type of palatoplasty, and use of presurgical orthopedics or palatal expansion. All three recurrent fistulas occurred in the anterior palate, two in patients with Veau class 3 clefts and one in a patient with a Veau class 4 cleft. The low rate of clinically significant fistula was attributed to early delayed primary closure, with smaller secondary clefts allowing repair with a minimum of dissection and disruption of vascularity.     

The nasopalatine ducts and associated structures in the rhesus monkey (Macaca mulatta): topography, prenatal development, function, and phylogeny

Morphological and developmental characteristics of the rhesus monkey nasopalatine duct system and associated primary palatal structures are described along with functional and phylogenetic considerations. Examination of five adult palates and coronal sections of 13 fetal palates together with dissections of a sixth adult specimen and of a 119-day-old fetal palate reveal that the lateral lobes of the tripartate incisive papilla cover clefts leading into the ducts. The ducts pierce the bony palate to enter the nasal fossae in proximity to the incisive suture. The ontogenetic stability of the duct path reflects the retention of ancient duct and primitive choanae relationships and functionally maintains an optimal oral odorant-to-receptor channel. Sixteen timed pregnancy specimens (35-100 days) provided histological material for documenting rostral nasopalatal development. Duct primordia, identified at 35 days, had by 40 days formed the medial duct walls (conjoined septum-papilla from the primary medial palatal component), the lateral duct walls (maxillary processes), and the rostral walls (fused maxillary-intermaxillary components). The caudal walls derive from the fusion of palatal shelves with the papilla (45 days), thus distinguishing primary and secondary fusion modes. Duct epithelial maturation occurs between 70 and 100 days. The absence of a vomeronasal system is attributed to reduction of olfaction in reproductive behavior, while the presence of the coevolved nasopalatine ducts is linked to the persistence of epiglottal-velar valving. The ducts serve as oral food-odor conduits in otherwise functionally separated respiratory and digestive tracts.     

Glutamine synthetase activity in the developing secondary palate and induction by dexamethasone

Glutamine synthetase (EC 6.3.1.2) (GS) and glutamyltransferase (EC 2.3.2.1) (GT) specific activity were examined in developing A/Jax and C57BL/6J (C57) mouse fetal secondary palates. In addition, the induction of palatal GS was also examined after maternal injection of dexamethasone. Palatal GT activity was uniformly higher in A/J than C57 palates with both strains showing highest activity late on day 13 of gestation and a drop in activity by early day 14. In contrast, A/J palatal GS activity peaked transiently late on day 13, dropped by early day 14 and remained lower throughout the remaining period of palatal development. Palatal GS activity in C57 mouse fetuses, although failing to show a discrete transient peak of activity, remained at a constant elevated level from early day 13 to late day 14 and did not decrease until day 15 of gestation. These elevated levels of palatal GS and GT activity correspond to the gestation period of maximal palatal glycoconjugate biosynthesis. Thus, palatal GS activity may play an important regulatory role in the synthesis of these macromolecules. A/J and C57BL/6J mice exhibit different susceptibilities to glucocorticoid-induced cleft palate. However, maternal administration of a non-teratogenic dose of dexamethasone on either late day 12 or late day 13 resulted in a dramatic stimulation of both A/J and C57 fetal palatal GS but not GT activity when assay 18 h later. A/J palatal tissue responded to dexamethasone with greater induction of palatal GS activity than enzyme activity in C57 palates. Palatal GS, sensitive to glucocorticoid stimulation, may thus be an important link in expressing hormonal control of normal palatal differentiation.     

Roles of collagen and periostin expression by cranial neural crest cells during soft palate development

The tissue in the palatal region can be divided into the hard and the soft palates, each having a specialized function such as occlusion, speech, or swallowing. Therefore, an understanding of the mechanism of palatogenesis in relation to the function of each region is important. However, in comparison with the hard palate, there is still a lack of information about the mechanisms of soft palate development. In this study, the authors investigated the contribution of cranial neural crest (CNC) cells to development of both hard and soft palates. They also demonstrated a unique pattern of periostin expression during soft palate development, which was closely related to that of collagen type I (Col I) in palatine aponeurosis. Furthermore, organ culture analysis showed that exogenous transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) induced the expression of both periostin and Col I. These novel patterns of expression in the extracellular matrix (ECM) induced by CNC cells suggest that these cells may help to determine the character of both the hard and soft palates through ECM induction. TGF-β signaling appears to be one of the mediators of Col I and periostin expression in the formation of functional structures during soft palate development.     

Levator repositioning and palatal lengthening for submucous clefts

Submucous clefts of the palate may present with velopharyngeal incompetence (VPI) or a history of recurrent otitis media. Many surgeons have favored a pharyngeal flap as primary treatment of the velopharyngeal incompetence associated with this disorder. The increasing number of case reports of sleep apnea and airway compromise associated with pharyngeal flaps prompted the use of levator muscle repositioning with palatal lengthening as initial therapy in 15 patients in an attempt to correct the pathologic anatomy while avoiding the postoperative sequelae. Patients were divided into two groups: group A (N = 8) had surgery before age 2 (11.8 +/- 5.7 months), and group B (N = 7) had surgery after 2 years of age (64.3 +/- 24.2 months). No patient in group A required a secondary operative procedure for velopharyngeal incompetence. Normal speech was obtained in 75 percent (N = 6), and slight velopharyngeal incompetence not requiring secondary correction was obtained in 25 percent (N = 2). Group B obtained less dramatic speech results: normal in 14 percent (N = 1), slight velopharyngeal incompetence in 58 percent (N = 4), and no improvement or severe velopharyngeal incompetence requiring a secondary procedure in 28 percent (N = 2). Patients with preoperative otologic disorders (N = 10) obtained significant improvement in 90 percent of cases (p = 0.002). Early surgical intervention in patients with abnormal speech prior to age 2 appears to result in normal speech in the majority of instances. Late repair with levator repositioning and palatal lengthening provided improved speech in 72 percent of patients.     

Predictors of velopharyngeal insufficiency in cleft palate orthognathic surgery

The purpose of this study was to appraise the value of preoperative speech assessments, nasopharyngoscopy, and surgical models as predictors of velopharyngeal deterioration after a Le Fort I maxillary advancement in cleft patients. This retrospective study involved a series of 26 cleft patients (16 unilateral complete and nine bilateral complete cleft lips and palates, and one isolated complete cleft palate) who had Le Fort I maxillary advancements between March 1, 1993, and February 7, 1996. The 13 male patients and 13 female patients ranged in age from 15.3 to 46 years (mean age, 19.5 years). Four of these patients had previously undergone pharyngeal flap surgery. Eleven patients had palatal fistulas and one had a bifid uvula that was repaired at the time of orthognathic surgery. Patients with perceived hypernasal speech preoperatively all had hypernasality after advancement (nine of nine). Velopharyngeal insufficiency was observed in two of the 16 whose resonance preoperatively was within normal limits. Speech assessment, therefore, predicted accurately the postoperative status in 23 of 26 patients. Twelve patients had preoperative nasopharyngoscopy that indicated a high risk for velopharyngeal insufficiency (borderline or inadequate closure). Nine of these patients had postoperative velopharyngeal insufficiency. Two of the 14 patients not judged at risk by nasopharyngoscopy developed velopharyngeal insufficiency. Therefore, 21 of the 26 patients were accurately predicted by nasopharyngoscopy. Scoping detected borderline velopharyngeal insufficiency in one patient who was not detected by speech alone. The combined predictive value of speech and scope identified all but one patient who would develop postoperative velopharyngeal insufficiency. The degree of anteroposterior movement determined from surgical models was not predictive of the outcome. Patients with hypernasal speech preoperatively continue to have hypernasal speech after Le Fort I advancement. Preoperative perceptual speech assessment by specially trained speech-language pathologists is an excellent test for predicting postoperative velopharyngeal insufficiency status. Nasopharyngoscopy is an invasive and resource-dependent test that should be assessed with respect to cost effectiveness. In this series, only one patient's risk was more accurately predicted using nasopharyngoscopy than by speech assessment alone.     

A histochemical study of amines in palatal tissue from normal and glycosuric mice

Synopsis A fluorescence histochemical technique for localizing catecholamines was applied to palatal tissue obtained from laboratory mice and from glycosuric and nonglycosuric Australian hopping mice. Specific catecholamine fluorescence related to blood vessels was demonstrated in all the tissue samples, though there was a tendency for this to be less marked in palates taken from the glycosuric animals.Although the presence of discrete areas of bright yellow fluorescence was noted in the tissue of the laboratory mice, these areas of yellow fluorescence (probably serotonin within mast cells) were virtually absent from the palates of the hopping mice despite the fact that there was little difference in the respective mast cell populations in the palatal tissues of the laboratory and hopping mice as determined by metachromatic staining procedures.     

Evaluation of speech after correction of rhinophonia with pushback palatoplasty combined with pharyngeal flap.

A comparison is made of the preoperative and postoperative speech evaluations of 15 selected subjects who had pharyngeal flap operations combined with palatal pushback. Postoperatively, 13 of the 15 patients (86 percent) showed no abnormal nasal emission and no evidence of significant hypernasality during word production. Gross substitution errors were also corrected by the surgical repair. While the number of patients is small, this study indicates equal effectiveness of the surgical technique described--regardless of the sex, the medical diagnosis, whether the procedure was primary or secondary, or the amount of postoperative time--providing there is good function of the muscles of the soft palate.     

Speech results of the Zürich approach in the treatment of unilateral cleft lip and palate

The purpose of this study was to describe perceptually the speech articulation, voice quality, and velopharyngeal competency of subjects with complete unilateral cleft lip and palate treated by the Zürich approach. The mean age of the 37 subjects was 10.5 years. Although only one subject had had secondary palatal management, no subject was rated as exhibiting a severe articulation or nasality problem. Subjects were rated as exhibiting adequate to marginal velopharyngeal competency 94.5 percent of the time, and the incidence of compensatory articulation errors was low. In comparison with other studies that evaluated the two-stage palatal repair, the Zürich approach appears to give the better results. The type of initial soft palate repair is probably the significant factor which contributes to the better speech of these subjects.     

The Cronin push-back palate repair with nasal mucosal flaps: a speech evaluation

This is a retrospective study of 92 cleft palate patients who had been repaired with the Cronin push-back palate repair with nasal mucosal flaps. The patients were evaluated by a speech pathologist for intelligibility, articulation, and resonance and rated using a 5-point scale devised for this study. Readily intelligible speech was present in 78 percent. Normal articulation was present in 66 percent. Normal resonance was present in 78 percent of the total subject group. Secondary procedures were performed in 14 percent of the group. Repaired clefts of the soft palate achieved a high rate of normal intelligibility, articulation, and resonance. Repaired submucous clefts and short palates achieved the lowest percent of normal articulation and resonance. Educational placement, hearing, and type of structural deformity all appear to influence the ultimate communication outcome.     

Cleft-palate repair by modified Furlow double-opposing Z-plasty: the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia experience

Although the optimal technique of cleft-palate repair remains controversial, several small series have suggested that superior speech results may be obtained with the Furlow double-opposing Z-plasty. To examine speech outcome in a large series of Furlow palatoplasties performed at a single center, we retrospectively reviewed the records of 390 cleft-palate patients who underwent Furlow palatoplasty at The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia from 1979 to 1992. Speech outcome at 5 years of age or greater was available for 181 nonsyndromic patients and was scored using the Pittsburgh Weighted Values for Speech Symptoms Associated with Velopharyngeal Incompetence. No or mild hypernasality was noted in 93.4 percent of patients, with 88.4 percent demonstrating no or inaudible nasal escape and 97.2 percent demonstrating no errors in articulation associated with velopharyngeal incompetence. Secondary pharyngeal flap surgery was required in just 7.2 percent of patients. Age at palatoplasty, cleft type, and experience of the operating surgeon had no significant effect on speech results, although there was a trend toward better outcome in those undergoing palatal repair before 6 months of age and toward poorer outcome in those with Veau class I and II clefts. Overall, Furlow palatoplasty yielded outstanding speech results, with rates of velopharyngeal dysfunction that seem to improve upon those reported for other techniques.     

Amniotic fluid induces rapid epithelialization in the experimentally ruptured fetal mouse palate--implications for fetal wound healing

Cleft of the secondary palate is one of the most common congenital birth defects in humans. The primary cause of cleft palate formation is a failure of fusion of bilateral palatal shelves, but rupture of the once fused palate has also been suggested to take place in utero. The possibility of post-fusion rupture of the palate in humans has hardly been accepted, mainly because in all the cleft palate cases, the cleft palatal edge is always covered with intact epithelium. To verify whether the intrauterine environment of the fetus plays roles in wound healing when the once fused palate is torn apart, we artificially tore apart fetal mouse palates after fusion and cultivated them in culture medium with or without mouse or human amniotic fluid. We thereby found that the wounded palatal edge became completely covered with flattened epithelium after 36 hours in culture with amniotic fluid, but not in culture without amniotic fluid. Using histological and scanning electron microscopic analyses of the healing process, it was revealed that the epithelium covering the wound was almost exclusively derived from the adjacent nasal epithelium, but not from the oral epithelium. Such actions of amniotic fluid on the fetal wound were never simulated by exogenous epidermal growth factor (EGF), albumin, or both. In addition, the rapid epithelialization induced by amniotic fluid was not prevented by either PD168393 (an inhibitor of the EGF receptor-specific tyrosine kinase) or SB431542 (a specific inhibitor of TGFbeta receptor type I/ALK5). The present study provides new insights into the unique biological actions of amniotic fluid in the repair of injured fetal palate.     

Experience with the Furlow double-reversing Z-plasty for cleft palate repair

One-hundred and six cases of soft palate closure using the Furlow double-reversing Z-plasty technique have been reported. Most of these patients have been done in the past 2 years. There seem to be a number of worthwhile advantages to this procedure, with few disadvantages or complications. The operation is adaptable for use in early soft palate closure (3 to 6 months) as well as late closure (12 to 14 months), in submucosal clefts, as well as in secondary palatal repair where lengthening and repositioning of the levator muscle is desired. With this type of palatoplasty, the need for raising or shifting large mucoperiosteal flaps from the hard palate has been completely avoided. The operation can be combined with a primary posterior pharyngeal flap if desired, although this is not advised if early palatal closure (3 to 6 months) is used because of a high incidence of sleep apnea. Preliminary speech results are very encouraging.     

Tissue phosphatase changes following triamcinolone associated with cleft palate in rats.

One theory of the development of cleft palate in rats involves the action of lysosomal enzymes secreted by epithelial cells at the time of fusion of the palatal shelves. To test this theory we studied the biochemistry of the palates of fetal rats daily between days 14 and 19 (from 3 days before to 3 days after palate closure). Triamcinolone was administered once im on gestation day 14 to Wistar rats; 0.5 mg/kg body weight produced approximately 50% cleft palates. Pooled control palatal tissue was compared with pooled experimental tissue; that from fetuses with clefts being pooled separately from those not affected. Acid phosphatase and beta-glucuronidase were assayed. Concentration vs. time curves for both enzymes were very similar. Prior to the time of palate closure both enzymes were present in low concentration. Between days 16 and 17, the normal time of closure, there was an abrupt increased in enzyme concentration, with experimental tissue showing a significant elevation over control tissue on days 17 and 18. Alkaline phosphatase was also present in small amounts before closure and significantly higher in control tissue on day 17. Protein was depressed in palates having clefts on day 17; thus the ratio of enzyme activities to protein synthesis was significantly elevated at a critical time. Unaffected experimental palates had a normal ratio. These results suggest imbalanced acid phosphatase, beta-glucuronidase, and alkaline phosphatase activity compared with protein synthesis at the time of palate closure following triamcinolone in rats.     

Spontaneous complete clefting of the palates in a mouse fetus: a study by scanning electron microscopy and serial section reconstruction

A 15 day mouse fetus having spontaneous complete clefting of the primary and secondary palates was studied in comparison with its normal litter mates and with normal 14 day fetuses. Specimens were studied by scanning electron microscopy at various stages of microdissection, by light microscopy of thin serial sections and by serial section reconstruction of the anterior chondrocranium of the clefted specimen and one of its normal litter mates. Differentiation of tooth and bone tissue was slightly retarded in the clefted fetus but paranasal and oral landmarks, though distorted, were present. The clefted fetus had a smaller angle between cranial base and nasal capsule and a marked discontinuity between the primary and secondary palates. Cell surfaces on the medial edge of the secondary palate in the clefted fetus resembled cell surfaces of oral areas that do not normally fuse, i.e. they are polygonial, flat and bear few surface projections in contrast to the normal 14 day condition where these cells are spindle shaped, convex and have many microvilli. The observations support the concepts that clefting of the secondary palate is consequential to clefting of the primary palate, that maldevelopment of neural crest mesenchyme is not necessarily a contributing factor, that clefting of the primary and secondary palates is associated with a shorter anterior-posterior dimension of the head and that when fusion of palatal shelves fails to occur the cells of the medial edges modulate in the direction of a generalized type of surface epithelium.