Molecular fate of heterologous bacterial DNA in competent Bacillus subtilis: further characterization of unstable association between donor and recipient DNA and the involvement of the cellular membrane

Summary Although heterospecific transformation is extremely inefficient and very little heterologous donor DNA integrates into the recipient chromosome in a stable way, we have previously shown that B. pumilus DNA entering competent B. subtilis efficiently associates with the recipient chromosome in an unstable way. This association can be stabilized by photocrosslinking in the presence of 4,5,8-trimethylpsoralen; it depends on the recombination proficiency of the recipient strain and on strand-separation of the recipient chromosome (te Riele and Venema 1982b). The present study provides further evidence that the heterologous donor DNA and the recipient DNA are associated by regions of base-pairing. Based on the high sensitivity of the donor moiety in the complex to nuclease S1 (90%) and the high sensitivity of the complex to moderate denaturing conditions (Tm=48°C), we presume that donor and recipient DNA are associated either by several short sequences of 15–25 fairly well matched base pairs or by a region of base-pairing of about 200 bases, which contains 25% of mismatches. During incubation, the unstable complex disappears, probably due to nucleolytic degradation.The unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex (DRC) was found to be membrane-bound. However, in contrast to homologous DRC, the unstable heterologous DRC remains membrane bound during incubation. Apparently, the predominantly single-stranded character of the heterologous DRC prevents release of the complex from the membrane.Abbreviations DRC donor-recipient complex - TMP 4,5,8-trimethyl-psoralen - DNAase I deoxyribonuclease 1 - TCA trichloroacetic acid     

An unstable donor-recipient DNA complex in transformation of Bacillus subtilis.

Summary In re-extracted DNA obtained shortly after uptake of transforming DNA by Bacillus subtilis, increased amounts of donor DNA radioactivity banding at the position of donor-recipient DNA complex (DRC) are observed in CsCl gradients, if the cells are irradiated with high doses of UV prior to reextraction of the DNA. Qualitatively, the same phenomenon is observed if lysates of transforming cells are irradiated. UV-irradiation of lysates of competent cells to which single-stranded DNA is added after lysis, does not result in linkage of this DNA to the chromosomal DNA. Two observations argue in favour of the formation of a specific labile complex between donor and resident DNA during transformation. Firstly, heterologous donor DNA from Escherichia coli, although being processed to single-stranded DNA in competent B. subtilis, does not seem to be linked to the recipient chromosome upon UV-irradiation, and secondly, the labile complex of donor and recipient DNA can be stabilized by means of treatment of the lysates of transforming cells with 4, 5¹, 8-trimethylpsoralen in conjuction with long-wave ultra violet light irradiation. This indicates that base-pairing is involved in the formation of the complex. On the basis of these results we assume that the unstable complex of donor and recipient DNA is an early intermediate in genetic recombination during transformation.     

Molecular Fate of Heterologous Bacterial DNA in Competent BACILLUS SUBTILIS. I. Processing of B. PUMILUS and B. LICHENIFORMIS DNA in B. SUBTILIS

Competent Bacillus subtilis cells were exposed to radioactive and density labeled donor DNA extracted from B. pumilus and B. licheniformis. The DNA from these strains hybridized with B. subtilis DNA in vitro at a rate of 24% and 11%, respectively. After entry the vast majority of heterologous DNA was found at the single-strand DNA position in CsCl gradients, and was gradually degraded during incubation. Much less donor DNA than expected from the hybridization values participated in the formation of the donorrecipient complex (DRC). By subjecting the heterologous DRC to sonication and alkaline CsCl gradient centrifugation, it was established that the DRC consisted of three components: (1) recipient DNA in which breakdown products of donor DNA were incorporated through DNA synthesis, (2) recipient DNA in which donor DNA was covalently integrated and (3) recipient DNA in which the donor moiety was not covalently integrated.     

Single-stranded regions in transforming deoxyribonucleic acid after uptake by competent Haemophilus influenzae.

About 15% of donor deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) is single stranded immediately after uptake into competent Haemophilus influenzae wild-type cells, as judged by its sensitivity to S1 endonuclease. This amount decreases to 4 to 5% by 30 min after uptake. Mutants which are defective in the covalent association of recipient and donor DNA form little or no S1 endonuclease-sensitive donor. At 17 C donor DNA taken up by the wild type contains single-stranded regions although there is no observable association, either covalent or noncovalent. The single-stranded regions are at the ends of donor DNA molecules, as judged by the unchanged sedimentation velocity after S1 endonuclease digestion. The amount of single-stranded donor remains constant at 17 C for more than 60 min after uptake, suggesting that the decrease observed at 37 C is the result of association of single-stranded ends with single-stranded regions of recipient cell DNA. Three sequential steps necessary for the integration of donor DNA into recipient DNA are proposed: the synthesis of single-stranded regions in recipient DNA, the interaction of donor DNA with recipient DNA resulting in the production of single-stranded ends on donor DNA, and the stable pairing of homologous single-stranded regions.     

Fate of heterologous deoxyribonucleic acid in Bacillus subtilis.

CsCl density gradient fractionation of cell lysates was employed to follow the fate of Escherichia coli, phage T6, and non-glucosylated phage T6 deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) after uptake by competent cells of Bacillus subtilis 168 thy minus trp minus. Shortly after uptake, most of the radioactive Escherichia coli or non-glucosylated T6 DNA was found in the denatured form; the remainder of the label was associated with recipient DNA. Incubation of the cells after DNA uptake led to the disappearance of denatured donor DNA and to an increase in the amount of donor label associated with recipient DNA. These findings are analogous to those previously reported with homologous DNA. By contrast, T6 DNA, which is poorly taken up, appeared in the native form shortly after uptake and was degraded on subsequent incubation. The nature of the heterologous DNA fragments associated with recipient DNA was investigated with Escherichia coli 2-H and 3-H-labeled DNA. Association of radioactivity with recipient DNA decreased to one-fourth in the presence of excess thymidine; residual radioactivity could not be separated from recipient DNA by shearing (sonic oscillation) and/or denaturation, but was reduced by one-half in the presence of a DNA replication inhibitor. Residual radioactivity associated with donor DNA under these conditions was about 5% of that originally taken up. Excess thymidine, but not the DNA replication inhibitor, also decreased association of homologous DNA label with recipient DNA; but, even in the presence of both of these, the decrease amounted to only 60%. It is concluded that most, or all, of the Escherichia coli DNA label taken up is associated with recipient DNA in the form of mononucleotides via DNA replication.     

Fate of homospecific transforming DNA bound to Streptococcus sanguis.

The fate of [3H]DNA from Streptococcus sanguis str-r43 fus-s donors in [14C]S. sanguis str-s fus-r1 recipients was studied by examining the lysates prepared from such recipients at various times after 1 min of exposure to DNA. The lysates were analyzed in CsCl and 10 to 30% sucrose gradients; fractions from the gradients were tested for biological activity and sensitivity to nucleases, subjected to various treatments and retested for nuclease sensitivity, and run on 5 to 20% neutral and alkaline sucrose gradients. The results demonstrate that donor DNA bound to S. sanguis cells in a form resistant to exogenous deoxyribonuclease is initially single stranded and complexed to recipient material. Donor DNA can be removed from the complex upon treatment of the complex with Pronase, phenol, or isoamyl alcohol-chloroform. Within the complex, donor DNA is relatively insensitive to S1 endonuclease but can regain its sensitivity by treatment with phenol. With time the complex moves as a whole to associate physically with the recipient chromosome. After a noncovalent stage of synapsis, donor material is covalently bonded to and acquires the nuclease sensitivity of recipient DNA, while donor markers regain transforming activity and become linked to resident markers.     

Heterospecific transformation in Bacillus subtilis: protein composition of a membrane-DNA complex containing unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex

Summary Previously it was demonstrated that, in contrast to the homologous donor-recipient complex, the unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex remains bound to the cellular membrane. To examine whether proteins known to be involved in the processing of transforming DNA in Bacillus subtilis are associated with membrane fragments which carry chromosomal DNA, a crude membrane-DNA complex was subjected to electrophoresis through a sucrose gradient. This resulted in the separation of membrane fragments associated with DNA and free membrane fragments. By means of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis several proteins, either uniquely present or considerably enriched in the purified membrane-DNA complex, were detected. Among these proteins we identified the 45 kD recE gene product, required for recombination, the 18 kD binding protein involved in the binding of transforming DNA and a 17 kD nuclease involved in the entry of transforming DNA.These results suggest that the membrane sites at which donor DNA integrates into the recipient chromosome are in the vicinity of the sites of entry of donor DNA through the membrane.Abbreviations DNAase I deoxyribonuclease I - DRC donor-recipient DNA complex - PEG polyethyleneglycol - PMSF phenylmethylsulphonylfluoride - SSC standard saline citrate - TCA trichloroacetic acid     

Assimilation of single-stranded donor deoxyribonucleic acid fragments by nucleoids of competent cultures of Bacillus subtilis.

Lysates containing folded chromosomes of competent Bacillus subtilis were prepared. The chromosomes were supercoiled, as indicated by the biphasic response of their sedimentation rates to increasing concentrations of ethidium bromide. Limited incubation of the lysates with increasing concentrations of ribonucleases resulted in a gradual decrease in the sedimentation velocity of the deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) until finally a constant S value was reached. Incubation with sonicated, 4,5',8-trimethylpsoralen-monoadducted, denatured, homologous donor DNA molecules at 37 degrees C and concomitant irradiation with long-wave ultraviolet light of the nucleoid-containing lysates resulted in the formation of complexes of the donor DNA molecules and the recipient chromosomes. This complex formation was stimulated when nucleoids were previously (i) unfolded by ribonuclease incubation, (ii) (partially) relaxed by X irradiation, or (iii) subjected to both treatments. Monoadducts were not essential. On the other hand, the complex-forming capacity of recipient chromosomes previously cross-linked by 4,5',8-trimethylpsoralen diadducts was greatly reduced, suggesting that strand separation of the recipient molecule was involved in the formation of the complex. None of these effects has been observed when heterologous (Escherichia coli) donor DNA has been used. When the same kind of experiments were carried out at 70 degrees C, donor-recipient DNA complexes were also formed and required strand separation and homology similar to donor-recipient complex formation at 37 degrees C. However, in contrast to what was found at 37 degrees C, unfolding plus relaxation of the nucleoids, as well as the absence of monoadducts in the donor DNA fragments, resulted in a decrease in complex formation. On the basis of these results, we assume that superhelicity can promote the in vitro assimilation of single-stranded donor DNA fragments by nucleoids of competents B. subtilis cells at 70 degrees C, but that at 37 degrees C a different mechanism is involved.     

Uptake and fate of bacteriophage phi W-14 DNA in competent Bacillus subtilis.

Phage phi W-14 DNA (in which one-half of the thymine residues are replaced by alpha-putrescinyl thymine) was taken up by competent Bacillus subtilis cells at a rate threefold higher than the rate of homologous DNA uptake. In contrast to other types of heterologous DNA, the amount of phi W-14 DNA taken up in 15 min exceeded the amount of homologous DNA taken up by a factor of two to three, as measured in terms of acid-precipitable material. The amount of phi W-14 DNA taken up was even greater than this analysis indicated if allowance was made for the fact that phi W-14 DNA was degraded more rapidly after uptake than homologous DNA. Competition experiments showed that the affinity of phi W-14 DNA for homologous DNA receptors was lower than the affinity of homologous DNA and was similar to the affinities of other types of heterologous DNA. The more rapid and more extensive uptake of phi W-14 DNA appeared to occur via receptors other than the receptors for homologous DNA, and these receptors (like those for homologous DNA) were an intrinsic property of competent cells. Uptake of phi W-14 DNA was affected by temperature, azide, EDTA, and chloramphenicol, as was uptake of homologous DNA. This was consistent with entry of both DNAs by means of active transport. After uptake, undegraded phi W-14 [3H]DNA was found in the cells in a single-stranded form, whereas a portion of the label was associated with recipient DNA, presumably as a result of incorporation of monomers resulting from degradation. Acetylation of the amino groups of the putrescine side chains in phi W-14 DNA decreased the affinity of this DNA for its receptors without affecting its ability to compete with homologous DNA.     

Intrachromosomal recombination between well-separated, homologous sequences in mammalian cells.

In the present study, we investigated intrachromosomal homologous recombination in a murine hybridoma in which the recipient for recombination, the haploid, endogenous chromosomal immunoglobulin mu-gene bearing a mutation in the constant (Cmu) region, was separated from the integrated single copy wild-type donor Cmu region by approximately 1 Mb along the hybridoma chromosome. Homologous recombination between the donor and recipient Cmu region occurred with high frequency, correcting the mutant chromosomal mu-gene in the hybridoma. This enabled recombinant hybridomas to synthesize normal IgM and to be detected as plaque-forming cells (PFC). Characterization of the recombinants revealed that they could be placed into three distinct classes. The generation of the class I recombinants was consistent with a simple unequal sister chromatid exchange (USCE) between the donor and recipient Cmu region, as they contained the three Cmu-bearing fragments expected from this recombination, the original donor Cmu region along with both products of the single reciprocal crossover. However, a simple mechanism of homologous recombination was not sufficient in explaining the more complex Cmu region structures characterizing the class II and class III recombinants. To explain these recombinants, a model is proposed in which unequal pairing between the donor and recipient Cmu regions located on sister chromatids resulted in two crossover events. One crossover resulted in the deletion of sequences from one chromatid forming a DNA circle, which then integrated into the sister chromatid by a second reciprocal crossover.     

Differential behavior of plasmids containing chromosomal DNA insertions of various sizes during transformation and conjugation in Haemophilus influenzae.

Plasmids with chromosomal insertions were constructed by removal of a 1.1-kilobase-pair piece from the 9.8-kilobase-pair vector plasmid pDM2 by EcoRI digestion and inserting in its place various lengths of chromosomal DNA (1.7, 3.4, and 9.0 kilobase pairs) coding for resistance to novobiocin. A fourth plasmid was constructed by insertion of the largest piece of chromosomal DNA into the SmaI site of pDM2. The plasmids without inserts were taken up poorly by competent cells and thus were considered not to contain specific DNA uptake sites. The presence of even the smallest insert of chromosomal DNA caused a large increase in transformation of Rec+ and Rec- strains. The frequency of plasmid establishment in Rec+ cells by transformation increased exponentially with increasing insert size, but in Rec- cells there was less transformation by the larger plasmids. Conjugal transfer of these plasmids was carried out with the 35-kilobase-pair mobilizing plasmid pHD147. The frequency of establishment of plasmids by this method not only was not markedly affected by the presence of the insertions, but also decreased somewhat with increase in insert size and was independent of rec-1 and rec-2 genes. Recombination between plasmid and chromosome was readily detected after transformation, but could not be detected after transconjugation even when the recipient cells were Rec+ and made competent. These data suggested that there is a special processing of plasmid DNA that enters the competent cells in transformation that makes possible recombination of homologous regions of the plasmid with the chromosome and pairing with the chromosome that aids plasmid establishment.     

Fate of transforming DNA following uptake by competent Bacillus subtilis. I. Formation and properties of the donor-recipient complex

Following uptake by competent Bacillus subtilis, transforming DNA is converted to two distinct slowly sedimenting molecular forms which possess little transforming activity (eclipse). A few minutes after uptake is initiated, a physical complex of donor and recipient DNA begins to form. The recovery of donor transforming activity following eclipse, and the appearance of recombinant activity, previously reported by Venema, Pritchard &; Venema-Schröder (1965), is shown to be due to changes occurring in the donor—recipient complex. This complex exists transiently in a form with low recombinant-type transforming activity. This transient form may be one in which the donor and recipient components are joined non-covalently. The donor-recipient complex is shown to be a heteroduplex structure in which the donor moiety has an approximate molecular weight of 750,000.     

Transformation in Bacillus subtilis: characterization of an intermediate in recombination observed during transformation.

Summary From recombination-proficient competent cells of Bacillus subtilis in which the donor DNA entered at 17°, and which were kept at the same temperature, a complex of donor DNA and the recipient chromosome can be obtained which has a relatively high buoyant density in CsCl gradients. Exposure of the isolated complex to nuclease S1 liberates donor radioactivity. The limited biological activity of DNA re-extracted from cells attempting to recombine at 17° is decreased upon incubation with nuclease S1. If recombination is allowed to proceed at 30°, the high buoyant density of the donor-recipient complex decreases to normal values and less radioactivity can be liberated from the complex by nuclease S1. Concomitantly the biological activity of re-extracted DNA becomes less vulnerable to nuclease S1 under these conditions. On the basis of these observations we assume that the intermediate complex partly consists of unpaired single-stranded donor DNA.Support for the correctness of this assumption is derived from experiments with a mutant, which is delayed in the processing of high buoyant density donor-recipient complex to normal buoyant density donor-recipient complex. This delay is reflected in the time of acquisition of resistance to nuclease S1 digestion of the isolated complex.     

Optimal conditions for uptake of exogenous DNA by Chinese hamster lung cells deficient in hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase.

Conditions were characterized for maximizing the uptake of exogenous mammalian cell DNA by hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase-deficient Chinese hamster lung cells. Recipient cell cultures in an exponential growth phase were found to be more competent in taking up DNA than stationary cultures. Polyornithine enhanced the uptake of exogenous DNA more reproducibly and to a greater extent than did any of the other facilitators tested (DEAE-dextran, CaCl2, latex spheres, spermine, polylysine and polyarginine). Maximal DNA incorporation occurred when polyornithine and DNA were mixed together prior to inoculation. About 25-30% of the DNA inoculum became deoxyribonuclease-resistant in a typical experiment utilizing polyornithine as the facilitator. Both homologous and heterologous exogenous DNAs rapidly became associated with recipient cell nuclei: approximately 95% of the deoxyribonuclease-resistant donor DNA was nuclear-associated 15 min after inoculation.     

Reexamination of phenotypic defects in rec-1 and rec-2 mutants of Haemophilus influenzae Rd.

Radiolabeled donor DNA is efficiently taken up into competent H. influenzae Rd rec-2 mutant cells but does not undergo the rapid degradation observed in wild-type cells. Furthermore, donor label is not recovered in the chromosome even after 1 h. The donor DNA appears to remain in a protected state in a compartment that can be separated from the rest of the cell. We interpret this as a failure of the donor DNA to be translocated out of the transformasome. In contrast, rec-1 cells translocate labeled donor DNA normally. The donor label accumulates in the recipient chromosome, but, as expected for cells with a recombination defect, there is no preferential localization of the label in sites homologous to the donor DNA. In addition, we have observed two enzymatic activities that act on transformasome-associated DNA of rec-2 cells, an endonuclease which may play a role in the translocation of closed circular DNA and a phosphatase.     

Restriction and modification in Bacillus subtilis: effects on transfection under marker rescue conditions

The role of homology between donor and recipient DNAs in the protection of transfecting DNA against restriction by competent Bacillus subtilis R cells was studied under marker rescue conditions with modified helper phage. By comparing restriction under conditions of preinfection marker rescue and superinfection marker rescue, the significance of DNA homology during the initial stages of DNA processing by competent cells could be studied. The results showed that both in preinfection and in superinfection, complete protection against restriction of transfectants produced via rescue by the modified homologous helper chromosome occurred. Even up to 90 min after entry, DNA entering the helper-mediated pathway of transfection was not affected by restriction. The significance of these findings is discussed in the general context of the role of DNA homology between donor and recipient on the fate of donor DNA in competent B. subtilis, in particular in relation to the effects on restriction.     

DNA hybrids stabilized by heterologies.

The double D-loop DNA hybrid contains four DNA strands following hybridization of two RecA protein coated complementary single-stranded DNA probes with a homologous region of a double-stranded DNA target. A remarkable feature of the double D-loop DNA hybrids is their kinetic stabilities at internal sites within linear DNA targets after removal of RecA protein from hybrids. We report here that heterologous DNA inserts in one or both probe strands affect the kinetic stability of protein-free double D-loop hybrids. DNA heterologies normally distort DNA-DNA hybrids and consequently accelerate hybrid dissociation. In contrast, heterologous DNA inserts impede dissociation of double D-loops, especially when the insert sequences interact with each other by DNA base pairing. We propose a mechanism for this kinetic stabilization by heterologous DNA inserts based on the hypothesis that the main pathway of dissociation of double D-loop DNA hybrids is a DNA branch migration process involving the rotation of both probe-target duplexes in the hybrids. Heterologous DNA inserts constrain rotation of probe-target duplexes and consequently impede hybrid dissociation. Potential applications of the stabilized double D-loops for gene targeting are discussed.     

Chromosomal gene capture mediated by the Pseudomonas putida TOL catabolic plasmid.

The Pseudomonas putida TOL plasmid pWW0 is able to mediate chromosomal mobilization in the canonical unidirectional way, i.e., from donor to recipient cells, and bidirectionally, i.e., donor-->recipient-->donor (retrotransfer). Transconjugants are recipient cells that have received DNA from donor cells, whereas retrotransconjugants are donor bacteria that have received DNA from a recipient. The TOL plasmid pWW0 is able to directly mobilize and retromobilize a kanamycin resistance marker integrated into the chromosome of other P. putida strains, a process that appears to involve a single conjugational event. The rate of retrotransfer (as well as of direct transfer) of the chromosomal marker is influenced by the location of the kanamycin marker on the chromosome and ranges from 10(-3) to less than 10(-8) retrotransconjugants per donor (transconjugants per recipient). The mobilized DNA is incorporated into the chromosome of the retrotransconjugants (transconjugants) in a process that seems to occur through recombination of highly homologous flanking regions. No interspecific mobilization of the chromosomal marker in matings involving P. putida and the closely related Pseudomonas fluorescens, which belongs to rRNA group I, was observed.     

DNA repair and the evolution of transformation IV. DNA damage increases transformation

Natural genetic transformation in the bacterium Bacillus subtilis provides a model system to explore the evolutionary function of sexual recombination. In the present work, we study the response of transformation to UV irradiation using donor DNAs that differ in sequence homology to the recipient's chromosome and in the mechanism of transformation. The four donor DNAs used include homologous-chromosomal-DNA, two plasmids containing a fragment of B. subtilis trp⁺ operon DNA and a plasmid with no sequence homology to the recipient cell's DNA. Transformation frequencies for these DNA molecules increase with increasing levels of DNA damage (UV radiation) to recipient cells, only if their transformation requires homologous recombination (i.e. is recA⁺-dependent). Transformation with non-homologous DNA is independent of the recipient's recombination system and transformation frequencies for it do not respond to increases in UV radiation. The transformation frequency for a selectable marker increases in response to DNA damage more dramatically when the locus is present on small, plasmid-borne, homologous fragments than if it is carried on high molecular weight chromosomal fragments. We also study the kinetics of transformation for the different donor DNAs. Different kinetics are observed for homologous transformation depending on whether the homologous locus is carried on a plasmid or on chromosomal fragments. Chromosomal DNA- and non-homologous-plasmid-DNA-mediated transformation is complete (maximal) within several minutes, while transformation with a plasmid containing homologous DNA is still occurring after an hour. The results indicate that DNA damage directly increases rates of homologous recombination and transformation in B. subtilis. The relevance of these results and recent results of other labs to the evolution of transformation are discussed.     

Single-stranded regions in Streptococcus pneumoniae chromosomal deoxyribonucleic acid and their relation to transformation.

Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) in lysates of both completent and noncompetent streptococcus pneumoniae cells was characterized by chromatography on benzoylated, naphthoylated diethylaminoethyl-cellulose columns, by sensitivity to Aspergillus oryzae S1 endonuclease, and by sucrose gradient analysis. The DNAs from both competent and noncompetent cells were found to contain similar extents of single-stranded regions. These single-stranded regions appeared to be intact, unpaired regions in double-stranded DNA rather than gaps, nicks, or unpaired ends in the DNA. Inhibition of cells with rifampin prior to lysis increased the amount of such single strandedness in the DNA. Lysates made at various times after [14C]thymidine-labeled cells had bound [3H]thymidine-labeled transforming DNA were also characterized by benzoylated, naphthoylated diethylaminoethyl-cellulose chromatography. Changes in the elution profiles of DNA from cells exposed to homospecific (S. pneumoniae) donor DNA were indicative of the formation of complexes between donor DNA and the single-stranded regions of recipient DNA. In contrast, profiles of DNA from cells exposed to heterospecific (S. sanguis) DNA did not show significant changes, indicating that few such donor-recipient complexes were formed during heterospecific transformation.