Geographical and Temporal FA Variation in Threespine Stickleback Populations from Galicia (NW Spain)

Subtle departures from bilateral symmetry (FA) in morphological traits has been used as a measure of developmental stability in populations subjected to genetic and environmental processes as inbreeding, pollution or parasitic infection. Geographic variation of FA was assessed in 19 threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) populations from Miño and Limia rivers, from Galicia (NW Spain). This variation was evaluated using four FA indices on five meristic and one morphometric traits. Temporal variation of FA was also assessed using several samples through time in only one population. Significant geographical variation was detected for pectoral fin rays, lateral forks, lateral plates and spine length. Lateral plates, upper gillrakers, pectoral fin rays and spine length showed significant variation through the time. The variation of FA through the time showed a common performance for all characters during the period considered: a slight increase in the intermediate months with a decrease at the end of the period. Symmetric and asymmetric sticklebacks exhibited similar infection, with one exception: symmetric sticklebacks for lower gillrakers of Antela populations exhibited increased parasite infection relative to asymmetric ones. Sticklebacks with extreme phenotypes exhibited much higher levels of asymmetry than modal ones in all samples for all traits.     

Ecological opportunity and levels of morphological variance within freshwater stickleback populations

The 'ecological opportunity' hypothesis predicts that when interspecific competition or predation is reduced, populations will exhibit increases in phenotypic variance as a result of colonization and adaptation to vacant or underutilized ecological niches (i.e. character release). We assessed this hypothesis by examining morphological diversity within stickleback populations in 40 undisturbed lakes from six islands off the mid-coast of British Columbia, Canada. Because larger lakes with well-developed littoral and limnetic zones will have greater trophic niche diversity than smaller lakes with only littoral zones, we predicted a positive association between lake size and variation in trophic morphology. Conversely, reduced vertebrate predation in small bog lakes allows increased variance in defensive structures without costs to fitness. Consistent with both predictions, we observed that phenotypic variance in two traits that are involved in feeding (gape width and pectoral fin length) increased with lake size while variability in defence structures (lateral plate number and dorsal spine length) was inversely related to lake size. Moreover, increased variance in defence morphology was accentuated in populations with severe armour reduction (spine loss, decreased plate overlap), another strong indicator of reduced vertebrate predation. In the majority of cases, these patterns were repeatable among islands, independent from the geographical distance between lakes, and arose from a combination of high variance within each of the sexes and increases in sexual dimorphism. These findings suggest that character release can be trait-specific and reflect the combined effects of competition, predation and habitat heterogeneity.  © 2005 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2005, 86 , 297–308.     

Heritability of asymmetry and lateral plate number in the threespine stickleback

The estimation of individual fitness and quality are important elements of evolutionary ecological research. Over the past six decades, there has been great interest in using fluctuating asymmetry (FA) to represent individual quality, yet, serious technical problems have hampered efforts to estimate the heritability of FA, which, in turn, has limited progress in the investigation of FA from an evolutionary perspective. Here we estimate the heritability of number of lateral plates, their FA and directional asymmetry (DA) in threespine stickleback, Gasterosteus aculeatus. By (i) using a meristic trait and (ii) basing our calculations on a large half-sib design experiment involving 2,079 offspring from 84 families, we overcame many of the difficulties faced by earlier FA studies. Both lateral plate number and FA in lateral plates were heritable (h² = 0.46 and 0.21, respectively), even after controlling for marker genotypes linked to EDA (the major locus influencing plate number). Likewise, DA in lateral plates was heritable h² = 0.23). The additive genetic component of FA in lateral plates makes it a prime candidate for further investigation into the evolutionary implications of FA and the genetic underpinnings of developmental instability. This discovery in an evolutionary model species holds the possibility to invigorate the study of FA from an evolutionary perspective.     

Asymmetry in structural defenses: insights into selective predation in the wild

Assessment of geographical patterns in fluctuating asymmetry (small, random differences between sides of bilateral characters) among populations shows promise as a tool to resolve the relative biomechanical importance of traits, in addition to being a possible indicator of habitat quality. We used 115 endemic freshwater populations of threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) from Haida Gwaii (Queen Charlotte Islands), British Columbia, Canada, to explore the degree of concordance between geographical variation of asymmetry in a predator defense structure (bony lateral plates) and geographical variation in several indirect measures of predation regime as well as several abiotic habitat variables. We found a geographical cline in the population frequency of lateral plate asymmetries, with reduced asymmetry in the southern clear-water regions of the archipelago characterized by long reaction distances and greater chance of capture by predators, and elevated asymmetry in the northern stained-water regions with poor visibility and low chances of capture. Lateral plate asymmetry was strongly correlated with expression of several defensive armor traits, including total plate numbers among populations, mean cross-sectional diameter of stickleback with the dorsal and pelvic spines erect, and mean degree of overlap between the plates and spine supports. There were no significant correlations between frequency of asymmetric fish and any of our abiotic habitat variables. Stickleback with structural plate asymmetries had fewer trout-induced scars than symmetric fish in the significant majority of populations, and there was a decrease in structural plate asymmetry with age in stained-water habitats, suggesting that trout predators may be selectively removing asymmetric fish in some lakes. This study provides evidence that geographical variation in developmental stability of threespine stickleback, as seen in the frequencies of asymmetry, reflects differences among populations in the importance of structural defenses to fitness rather than differences in habitat quality, and that asymmetry may be a target of selection by predators in wild populations.     

Experimentally Manipulated Growth Rate in Threespine Sticklebacks: Assessing Trade Offs with Developmental Stability

The evolution of adaptive growth rate and its influence on how other life history traits evolve is a neglected topic in biology. Growth rate influences life history because size strongly influences age-specific survival and fecundity, and because growth rate defines the relationship between age and size. Improved predictions about the evolution of life history traits may be possible with a greater understanding of the factors that influence the evolution of growth rate. We experimentally tested the hypothesis that a trade off may exist between growth rate and developmental stability in freshwater threespine sticklebacks, Gasterosteus aculeatus. We compared the degree of developmental instability (measured as fluctuating asymmetry = FA) in four lateral plate and two fin traits of fish reared under a high vs. low growth regime in response to food ration and temperature. We found evidence that symmetry was reduced (FA increased) in fast growing compared to slow growing fish, suggesting that a trade off between developmental stability and growth is possible. FA plausibly reflected developmental instability because of significant associations between rank FA levels across traits in individuals. These results are preliminary because of the possible confounding effects of temperature and food ration on asymmetry, and because we do not know if this trade off has fitness or other life history consequences. Our results also do not support the hypothesis of honest signaling sometimes invoked in studies of sexual selection because greater symmetry was found under poorer rather than better resource levels.     

Sensory trait variation contributes to biased dispersal of threespine stickleback in flowing water

Gene flow is widely thought to homogenize spatially separate populations, eroding effects of divergent selection. The resulting theory of ‘migration–selection balance’ is predicated on a common assumption that all genotypes are equally prone to dispersal. If instead certain genotypes are disproportionately likely to disperse, then migration can actually promote population divergence. For example, previous work has shown that threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) differ in their propensity to move up‐ or downstream (‘rheotactic response’), which may facilitate genetic divergence between adjoining lake and stream populations of stickleback. Here, we demonstrate that intraspecific variation in a sensory system (superficial neuromast lines) contributes to this variation in swimming behaviour in stickleback. First, we show that intact neuromasts are necessary for a typical rheotactic response. Next, we showed that there is heritable variation in the number of neuromasts and that stickleback with more neuromasts are more likely to move downstream. Variation in pectoral fin shape contributes to additional variation in rheotactic response. These results illustrate how within‐population quantitative variation in sensory and locomotor traits can influence dispersal behaviour, thereby biasing dispersal between habitats and favouring population divergence.     

Evolutionary history shapes the association between developmental instability and population‐level genetic variation in three‐spined sticklebacks

Developmental instability (DI) is the sensitivity of a developing trait to random noise and can be measured by degrees of directionally random asymmetry [fluctuating asymmetry (FA)]. FA has been shown to increase with loss of genetic variation and inbreeding as measures of genetic stress, but associations vary among studies. Directional selection and evolutionary change of traits have been hypothesized to increase the average levels of FA of these traits and to increase the association strength between FA and population‐level genetic variation. We test these two hypotheses in three‐spined stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus L.) populations that recently colonized the freshwater habitat. Some traits, like lateral bone plates, length of the pelvic spine, frontal gill rakers and eye size, evolved in response to selection regimes during colonization. Other traits, like distal gill rakers and number of pelvic fin rays, did not show such phenotypic shifts. Contrary to a priori predictions, average FA did not systematically increase in traits that were under presumed directional selection, and the increases observed in a few traits were likely to be attributable to other factors. However, traits under directional selection did show a weak but significantly stronger negative association between FA and selectively neutral genetic variation at the population level compared with the traits that did not show an evolutionary change during colonization. These results support our second prediction, providing evidence that selection history can shape associations between DI and population‐level genetic variation at neutral markers, which potentially reflect genetic stress. We argue that this might explain at least some of the observed heterogeneities in the patterns of asymmetry.     

Geographical variation in asymmetry in Gasterosteus aculeatus

We tested whether fluctuating asymmetry (FA) in undisturbed populations is associated with several natural environmental factors and whether FA is negatively correlated with fitness in the wild. We compared the FA of multiple bony structural defences among 87 endemic populations of threespine stickleback ( Gasterosteus aculeatus L.) inhabiting pristine freshwater habitats on the islands of Haida Gwaii, British Columbia, Canada. Multi-trait FA for adults and juvenile fish varied extensively among populations, but only in adults did it correlate with geography and two habitat characteristics (pH and water colour). Mean FA among individual traits varied concordantly among populations but was not correlated within individuals. While asymmetrical fish showed slightly higher levels of parasitism as predicted, selection differentials based on age class comparisons suggested that asymmetrical fish had the same or marginally higher survival than symmetrical fish. Selection differentials of FA varied significantly among traits and may reflect variability in their functional importance and in the strength of selection on their developmental stability. The data imply that FA/fitness associations are heterogeneous and character-specific.  © 2002 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2002, 77 , 9–22.     

Reductions in prolonged swimming capacity following freshwater colonization in multiple threespine stickleback populations

We compared ancestral anadromous-marine and nonmigratory, stream-resident threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) populations to examine the outcome of relaxed selection on prolonged swimming performance. We reared marine and stream-resident fish from two locations in a common environment and found that both stream-resident populations had lower critical swimming speeds (U(crits) ) than marine populations. F1 hybrids from the two locations displayed significant differences in dominance, suggesting that the genetic basis for variation in U(crit) differs between locations. To determine which traits evolved in conjunction with, and may underlie, differences in performance capacity we measured a suite of traits known to affect prolonged swimming performance in fish. Although some candidate traits did not evolve (standard metabolic rate and two body shape traits), multiple morphological (pectoral fin size, shape, and four body shape measures) and physiological (maximum metabolic rate; MMR) traits evolved in the predicted direction in both stream-resident populations. However, data from F1 hybrids suggested that only one of these traits (MMR) had dominance effects similar to those of U(crit) in both locations. Overall, our data suggest that reductions in prolonged swimming performance were selected for in nonmigratory populations of threespine stickleback, and that decreases in MMR may mediate these reductions in performance.     

Isolation between sympatric anadromous and resident threespine stickleback species in Mud Lake,Alaska

A sympatric pair of anadromous and resident freshwater threespine stickleback species (Gasterosteus aculeatus species complex) occurs in Mud Lake in the Matanuska-Susitna Valley, Alaska. The two forms differ in an array of morphological traits, including traits associated with predator defense (e.g., spine lengths) and trophic ecology (e.g., number of gill rakers). Mud Lake is only the third lake reported to have anadromous stickleback (which have a complete row of lateral plates) coexisting with low-plated resident stickleback in the absence of intermediate partially plated fish. Microhabitat and seasonal isolation appear to contribute to reproductive isolation between the two forms.     

Adaptation and constraint in a stickleback radiation

The evolution of threespine sticklebacks in freshwater lakes constitutes a well‐studied example of a phenotypic radiation that has produced numerous instances of parallel evolution, but the exact selective agents that drive these changes are not yet fully understood. We present a comparative study across 74 freshwater populations of threespine stickleback in Norway to test whether evolutionary changes in stickleback morphology are consistent with adaptations to physical parameters such as lake depth, lake area, lake perimeter and shoreline complexity, variables thought to reflect different habitats and feeding niches. Only weak indications of adaptation were found. Instead, populations seem to have diversified in phenotypic directions consistent with allometric scaling relationships. This indicates that evolutionary constraints may have played a role in structuring phenotypic variation across freshwater populations of stickleback. We also tested whether the number of lateral plates evolved in response to lake calcium levels, but found no evidence for this hypothesis.     

Evolutionary diversification of opercle shape in Cook Inlet threespine stickleback

We investigated the evolution of a large facial bone, the opercle (OP), in lake populations of the threespine stickleback that were founded by anadromous ancestors, in Cook Inlet, Alaska. Recent studies characterized OP variation among marine and lake populations and mapped a quantitative trait locus with a large influence on OP shape. Using populations from diverse environments and independent evolutionary histories, we examined divergence of OP shape from that of the anadromous ancestor. We report preliminary evidence for divergence between benthic and generalist lake ecotypes, necessitating further investigation. Furthermore, rapid divergence of OP shape has occurred in a lake population that was founded by anadromous stickleback in the 1980s, which is consistent with divergence of other phenotypic traits and with OP diversification in other lake populations. By contrast, there has been limited evolution of OP shape in a second lake population that may have experienced a genetic bottleneck early in its history and lacks genetic variation for OP divergence. Taken together, the results obtained from these two populations are consistent with studies of other stickleback phenotypic traits that implicate ancestral variation in postglacial adaptive radiation of threespine stickleback in fresh water.  © 2009 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2009, 97 , 832–844.     

Stable isotope niche differentiation in sticklebacks with symmetric and asymmetric pectoral fins

Fluctuating asymmetry (FA) is often, but controversially, viewed as an indicator of fitness and a target of selection. In the brook stickleback, Culaea inconstans (Kirtland), FA of the pectoral fins, which are the main source of propulsion, is inversely correlated with fecundity. We examined the hypothesis that asymmetry of the pectoral fins could affect locomotion in such a way as to influence foraging and niche use in prereproductive brook stickleback. Nitrogen and carbon stable isotope analysis showed the diet of symmetric and asymmetric males diverged with increasing body size. Larger symmetric males fed at higher trophic levels and had a diet based on carbon emanating from a more pelagic source than their asymmetric counterparts. Such effects were not observed in females or smaller males. The number of chironomid larvae found in the gut was greater on average in asymmetric than symmetric fish. The results from this study strongly suggest FA of pectoral fins affects the foraging behaviour of C. inconstans and that stable isotope analyses of individual phenotypes provides a useful tool for assessing the ecological consequences of FA.  © 2007 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2007, 92 , 617–623.     

Habitat dependent associations between parasitism and fluctuating asymmetry among endemic stickleback populations

Inconsistencies in the relationship between fluctuating asymmetry (FA) and fitness may be due to selection acting on the degree of trait asymmetry that differs among populations or among traits. We assessed relationships between parasite susceptibility and fluctuating asymmetry in the number of bony lateral plates among 83 populations of freshwater Gasterosteus aculeatus (three spined stickleback) and among lateral plate positions that vary in the selection they experience for symmetry. The correlation between FA and parasite infection was highly variable among samples. Excess of infected asymmetric G. aculeatus increased significantly as the robustness of structural predator defences decreased. This effect was found for one parasite species only (Eustrongylides sp.) and was slightly stronger in females. In addition, there was a trend for there to be an excess of infected females asymmetric in those lateral plates positions that did not experience selection for their symmetry, although the trend only approached significance. These results suggest that selection for trait symmetry can obscure relationships between fitness and individual-wide developmental stability, providing one possible explanation for some of the heterogeneity in FA/fitness relationships seen in the literature. These results are also consistent with previous reports showing that ecological segregation between symmetric and asymmetric G. aculeatus and between sexes can alter the FA/fitness relationship.     

Strong nonlinear selection against fluctuating asymmetry in wild populations of a marine fish

Theoretical links between fluctuating asymmetry (FA) and fitness have led many to use FA as a proxy for average fitness. However, studies examining whether asymmetry actually correlates with individual fitness in wild populations are relatively rare and often use simple measures of association (e.g., correlation coefficients). Consequently, the pattern of selection on asymmetry in the wild is seldom clear. We examined selection on FA of pectoral fin morphology in two wild populations of a marine fish (the kelp perch; Brachyistius frenatus). As expected, variance in signed FA in each initial sample was significantly greater than that found in the surviving population, indicating selection against FA. Our estimate of the fitness surface confirmed perfect symmetry as the phenotypic optimum and indicated strong, nonlinear selection against asymmetry. No difference in the form of selection was detected between populations. However, the level of FA in the initial samples varied among populations, leading to an overall difference in the level of selective mortality. Our results suggest that selection on asymmetry in wild populations may be strongly nonlinear, and indicate that the demographic costs of asymmetry may play a substantial role in the dynamics of populations.     

Predation-imposed selection on threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) morphology: a test of the refuge use hypothesis

The transition from marine to freshwater life in the threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) is accompanied by complex morphological changes-including reduction in bony armor and change in body shape-but experimental evidence for the selective agents behind these evolutionary transitions is sparse. We investigated whether selection by predatory fish affects threespine stickleback morphology differentially when refuge is absent (pelagic lifestyle-ancestral condition) or present (benthic lifestyle-derived condition). Our results show that selection favors low numbers of lateral plates in habitats with refuge, whereas fully plated individuals have a selective advantage in habitats without refuge. We also found that a decrease in the length of the caudal peduncle increased survival probability, irrespective of habitat. The effect of spine lengths on survival was evident only in a multivariate analysis of selection, implying that it is essential to account for phenotypic and genetic correlations between traits before drawing conclusions about the effects of selection on single traits. Apart from uncovering targets and patterns of predator-induced selection on threespine stickleback morphology, our results provide direct evidence to support the hypothesis that differences in antipredator strategies in pelagic versus benthic sticklebacks could play a role in the repeated, independent cases of plate number reduction following freshwater colonization in this species.     

Abrupt changes in defence and trophic morphology of the giant threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus sp.) following colonization of a vacant habitat

To evaluate the first stages of adaptation and differentiation following colonization into a vacant and ecologically divergent habitat, 100 melanistic and low‐plated adult threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) exhibiting gigantism in body size and robust spines were transferred in 1993 from a large dystrophic lake (Mayer Lake, Haida Gwaii, British Columbia, Canada) with a diverse vertebrate predator regime, into an adjacent fishless eutrophic pond with macroinvertebrate piscivores. Eight generations were examined as a test of multiple functional hypotheses on the morphological traits that differentiate lake and pond stickleback throughout their distribution. Measurements of 20 defence and trophic traits were made on 275 wild‐caught fish collected from the source and transplant populations over multiple years. There have been significant reductions (males: females) in plate count (8%: 0.5%), lateral plate 2 frequency (46%: 17%), lateral plate 3 height (17%: 18%), pelvic spine length (12%: 6%), dorsal spine length (21%: 16%), gill raker number (5%: 1%), and gill raker length (37%: 43%), and an increase in gill raker spacing (+5%: 0%), jaw length (+5%: +4%), and eye diameter (+8%: +7%). These changes within eight generations represent one‐third of the morphological differences observed between naturally established large lake and pond populations in these archipelago and are all in the direction predicted from the change in habitat. Field samples indicate strong selection in the colonists although lab‐reared individuals implicate an additional role of plasticity for dorsal spine and gill raker lengths, which may contribute to the rapid adaptation into novel and highly divergent selective landscapes. © 2012 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 2012, 107 , 494–509.     

Unusual number of pectoral fin rays in an Icelandic population of threespine stickleback (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Gasterosteus aculeatus</Emphasis>) recently isolated in freshwater

Threespine stickleback most often have 10 pectoral fin rays, and it seems to be a highly canalized trait. We observed an unusually high frequency of stickleback with 11 pectoral fin rays in a population recently isolated from the marine environment in a freshwater lagoon in Iceland. These new morphologies may be beneficial for the fish in the new habitat but may disappear because of strong canalizing selection for the typical 10 pectoral fin rays.Co-ordinating editor: Kaitala     

Analyzing nested variation in the body form of Lepomid sunfishes

Phylogenetic hierarchies are often composed of younger diverging lineages nested within older diverging lineages. Comparing phenotypic variation among several hierarchical levels can be used to test hypotheses about selection, phenotypic evolution and speciation. Such hierarchical comparisons have only been performed in threespine stickleback, and so here we use a hierarchical pattern of divergences between near-shore littoral and off-shore pelagic habitats to test for selection on the evolution of body form in Lepomis sunfish in lakes. We compare variation in external body form between fish from littoral and pelagic habitats at three levels: among ecomorphs within individual lake populations (intrapopulation), among populations of the same species in different lakes (interpopulation), and between bluegill and pumpkinseed sunfish species (interspecifically). Using geometric morphometric methods, we first demonstrate that interpopulation variation in mean body form of pumpkinseed sunfish varies with the presence of pelagic habitat. We then incorporate these results with existing data in order to test the similarity of phenotypic divergence between littoral and pelagic habitats at different hierarchical levels. Parallel relationships between certain body form traits (head length, caudal length and pectoral length) and habitat occur at all three levels suggesting that selection persistently acts at all levels to diversify these traits and so may contribute to species formation. For other traits (caudal depth and pectoral altitude), divergence between habitats is inconsistent at different hierarchical levels. Thus, nested biological variation in Lepomid body form reflects a history of deterministic selection and historical contingency, and also identifies traits that likely have likely influenced fitness and so serve important functions.     

近期引入三刺鱼种群的骨板和体型的现时进化

近期引入到新环境中的种群给我们提供了一个推论种群过去微进化变化的难得的机会,而这些变化曾导致了种群在历史上对新栖息地拓殖的适应。自从1967年三刺鱼(GasterosteusaculeatusL.)被有意引入到不列颠哥伦比亚的Heisholt湖后,就隔离的淡水对其完全骨板化(CP)变体的相对适合度的影响已经做过多种多样的测定。CP变体的个体在早期的样本中比较常见(占20.3%-31.7%),而在现代的样本中比较稀少(占0%-5.0%)。后者样本中骨板弱化的变体占优势,这是绝大多数淡水种群的典型情形。我估测Heisholt湖的一个流域中三刺鱼体侧骨板数目从1974年到1997年的进化速率是-0.029海尔登,这比大多数对近期引入的或隔离的三刺鱼种群的现时进化的估测要低。最后,来自于Heisholt湖的CP个体比那些作为引入源溪流中的个体明显要小。总之,对应于已建群的自然淡水种群的文献资料,在引入种群中所观察到的个体大小和体侧骨板数目的变化,意味着三刺鱼对与淡水环境中生活相关的多种挑战的适应可以快速发生。