Population dynamics of the murine lymphokine activated killer system: precursor frequency and kinetics of maturation and renewal

The proliferation kinetics and population renewal of recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2)-induced murine lymphokine activated killers (LAK) arising from splenic precursors was studied. Extensive proliferation has been shown to accompany the de novo generation of LAK cytotoxicity. In this report, a thymidine 'hot pulse' suicide technique was employed to examine the sensitivity of LAK progenitors during various time periods following culture initiation. Hot pulse during the first 24 hr of culture resulted in a 30-35% reduction in lytic activity when assayed on day 5. Pulse periods between days 1 and 4 resulted in almost complete inhibition (90-95%) of lytic function when assayed on day 5. Proliferation of LAK progenitors was documented by limiting dilution analysis comparison of splenic precursors and functionally mature LAK cultures. These studies showed a 75- to 80-fold enrichment of LAK progenitors after 3 days culture in rIL-2. By flow cytometric cell cycle analysis, we demonstrated that the number of cells in the S/G2/M phase increased with the length of rIL-2 culture and represented approximately 40% of the cells by day 4. Finally, we used the rate of decay of lytic activity following irradiation as a factor to define the mean life span of a cytotoxic effector in the absence of cellular input. An exponential decrease to approximately 50% of controls was observed within 8-9 hr after irradiation. Taken together, these results suggest that the LAK system is highly dynamic and requires continuous cellular proliferation for its maintenance.     

Production and differentiation of NK lineage cells in long-term bone marrow cultures in the absence of exogenous growth factors.

Neither lytic NK cells nor IL-2-responsive NK precursors were produced in myeloid (Dexter) long-term bone marrow cultures (LTBMC). However, when myeloid LTBMC were switched to lymphoid (Whitlock-Witte) conditions and reseeded ("recharged") with fresh bone marrow cells (BMC), nonadherent cells with NK lytic activity and NK 1.1+ phenotype were produced within 1-2 weeks without the addition of exogenous IL-2 to the cultures. NK- and T cell-depleted BMC proliferated extensively in switched cultures and in 2 weeks generated cells that lysed the NK target YAC-1 but not the LAK target P815. The presence of NK precursors in the cultures was confirmed by reculturing nonadherent cells harvested from recharged LTBMC in fresh medium containing 50 U rIL-2/ml. High levels of NK lytic activity were generated. Sequential expression of NK 1.1 and IL-2 responsiveness followed by lytic activity was demonstrated by harvesting cells early after recharge, prior to the appearance of lytic cells. Elimination of NK 1.1+ cells depleted the ability to respond to IL-2 in secondary culture. Our studies demonstrate that myeloid-to-lymphoid switched LTBMC support the proliferation and differentiation of NK lineage cells from their NK 1.1-, nonlytic progenitors in the absence of an exogenous source of growth factors.     

Lymphokine-activated killer cells in rats. IV. Developmental relationships among large agranular lymphocytes, large granular lymphocytes, and lymphokine-activated killer cells

The developmental relationships among large agranular lymphocytes (LAL) large granular lymphocytes (LGL) and the activation of these cells into lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells by rIL-2 was investigated. Highly enriched populations of LAL were isolated from Fischer 344 spleen cells by a combination of nylon-wool filtration (to remove B cells and macrophages), treatment with a pan T cell antibody plus complement (to remove T cells) and incubation in L-leucine methyl ester (to remove LGL). The resultant cells were highly enriched in morphologically identifiable LAL which expressed asialo GM1 and partially expressed the OX8 surface marker. The enriched LAL did not contain detectable NK cytotoxic activity, did not express pan T cell (OX19), Ia, Ig, or laminin surface markers and contained less than 0.2% LGL. Incubation of LAL in a low dose of rIL-2 (100 U/ml) induced the generation of LGL having NK activity within 24 h of culture. Longer culture periods (48 h) resulted in a continued increase in the percentage of LGL and higher levels of NK activity. However, with this low dose of rIL-2, little or no LAK activity (i.e., reactivity against NK-resistant target cells) was generated. With a high dose of rIL-2 (500 U/ml), LAL responded by first generating LGL with NK activity (within 24 h), with subsequent generation of LAK activity by 48 h. Evidence that the development of granular lymphocytes from LAL was responsible first for NK activity and then LAK activity was demonstrated by depletion of the generated granular NK or LAK effector cells by second treatments with L-leucine methyl ester. Concomitant with the induction of LGL with NK or LAK activity, rIL-2 also caused LGL to proliferate and expand four- to five-fold in 48 h. This occurred in the presence of high or low dose rIL-2. These results indicate that LAL are the precursors of LGL/NK cells, that LAL, LGL/NK cells and LAK cells appear to represent sequential developmental or activation stages and that LAL may comprise major source of LAK progenitors in lymphoid populations having few LGL or mature active NK cells.     

Similarities between LAK cells derived from human thymocytes and peripheral blood lymphocytes: expression of the NKH-1 and CD3 antigens

Human thymocytes are devoid of NK cells but develop lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity after culture with recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2). The most active precursor for this activity appears to be a CD3-negative cell. The purpose of these studies was to compare the phenotype and functional activities of thymocyte and peripheral blood lymphocyte (PBL) LAK cells. Following culture, rIL-2-activated thymocytes resemble PBL-generated LAk and PBL NK cells. For each of these populations, lytic activity is highest in NKH-1-positive cells. Two-color fluorescence of each population also indicates that NKH-1+ cells are highly granular, as measured by staining with the lysosomotropic vital dye quinacrine. PBL, PBL-derived LAK cells, and thymus-derived LAK cells have a portion of cells that express both CD3 and NKH-1. However, approximately 60-80% of NKH-1+ cells lack detectable CD3. This suggests that both CD3+ and CD3- cells may be capable of LAK activity. Thymic-derived LAK cells respond to interferon in a manner very similar to NK and PBL-derived LAK cells, but lack the NK-associated CD16 antigen. Thus, despite the absence of NK cells in the thymus, it is possible to generate thymocyte LAK activity which bears a strong resemblance to LAK activity derived from peripheral blood lymphocytes.     

Characteristics of interleukin-6-enhanced lymphokine-activated killer cell function

To study the effect of IL-6 on the development of cytotoxic cells, we examined lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity generated from human nonadherent PBL. Addition of rIL-6 at the initiation of 5-day PBL cultures significantly increases LAK activity in the presence of low concentrations (between 5 and 25 u/ml) of rIL-2. RIL-6 alone induces no PBL LAK activity but at doses as low as 0.8 u/ml rIL-6 enhances LAK activity with optimal enhancement of LAK at 5.0 u/ml of rIL-6. This enhancement is independent of effects on cells growth as rIL-6 did not affect the cell recovery of PBL cultured in rIL-2. RIL-6-enhanced LAK is mediated by the same type of effector cells as those of LAK from rIL-2 alone with effector cells primarily generated from large granular CD3-negative E rosetting lymphocytes. RIL-6 does not change the time course of LAK development and pretreatment of PBL with rIL-6 has no effect on the PBL response to subsequent rIL-2 induction of LAK. Addition of rIL-6 to LAK cultures 2 hr before the cytotoxicity assay shows equal enhancement as addition at the initiation of the culture. However, rIL-6 requires the presence of both rIL-2 and another factor in the supernatant from LAK cultures in order to enhance LAK. Our results indicate that IL-6 can modulate LAK activity at a very late stage of LAK development, and that the enhancement by IL-6 is dependent on the presence of IL-2 and another soluble factor generated during rIL-2 culture.     

Resistance of lymphokine-activated T lymphocytes to cell-mediated cytotoxicity

We observed that lymphokine-activated T lymphocytes, obtained in short- and long-term cultures following stimulation with recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2), are resistant to cell-mediated cytotoxicity. In particular, lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells do not undergo self-lysis or lysis by alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), in line with recent reports concerning CTL clones. Similar findings were further confirmed in a lectin-dependent cell cytotoxicity assay. LAK cell lysis resistance was not due to an inability to recognize itself, since inactivated LAK cells used as cold competitors inhibited tumor cell lysis in a dose-dependent manner. In contrast, the addition on Day 0 of irradiated LAK cells or alloreactive CTL, as well as a CTL clone having LAK-like activity to rIL-2-stimulated cultures abrogated or strongly reduced LAK cell generation. Therefore, LAK cell precursors were most likely susceptible to the lytic activity of differentiated cytotoxic cells, as no inhibition was detected when cell to cell contact was prevented by using a diffusible chamber culture system. These findings, on the whole, suggest that the emergence of the lysis-resistant phenotype is most likely the result of a selective process occurring in vitro that leads to the elimination of lysis-susceptible lymphocytes present in culture.     

NK and LAK activities from human marrow progenitors. I. The effects of interleukin-2 and interleukin-1.

We have investigated the role of interleukin-2 (IL2) as a differentiation factor for human marrow-derived NK cell progenitors and have assessed the effects of interleukin-1 (IL1) on this activity. The effects of these cytokines on early NK cell precursors was determined by testing marrow which had been depleted of mature cells and of CD2+ cells by treatment with soybean agglutinin and sheep erythrocytes (SBA-E-BM). The cytolytic activities of the SBA-E-BM were tested in 51Cr release assays following 7-8 days of liquid culture. K562 targets were used to assess NK activity and NK-resistant Daudi targets were used to measure lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell activity. Neither NK nor LAK activity were measurable in marrow incubated in medium without cytokines, or in medium containing IL1 alone. In contrast, culture in medium containing IL2 resulted in a dose-dependent development of lytic activity. NK and LAK activities could be differentiated by the percentage of cultures in which the activity developed, the dose of IL2 required, the time kinetics of induction, and the effect of depletion of residual cells with NK phenotype prior to culture. The most lytically active effectors of both activities, however, were CD56+. Immunofluorescence analyses before and after culture with IL2 revealed that Leu19+ (CD56) cells increased from less than 2% to as much as 17% of the total marrow cells and showed the appearance of a population of CD56+CD16- cells. The addition of IL1 to the marrow cultures increased NK activity when suboptimal amounts of IL2 were used (less than or equal to 100 U/ml), but did not increase LAK activity at any concentration of IL2. A higher number of NK cells, as well as MY7+(CD13+) myeloid cells were recovered from cultures containing IL1 plus IL2, indicating that NK cells as well as myeloid cells had a growth advantage in the presence of IL1. IL2 receptor (CD25) expression was low in all cultures but was consistently higher in cultures containing IL1 and IL2, however, CD25 was not coexpressed on NK cells. These studies indicate that early NK cell precursors can grow and differentiate in response to IL2 and that NK and LAK lytic activities may be acquired at different developmental stages. IL1 may serve to promote the responsiveness of NK cell progenitors to low concentration of IL2 by a mechanism which may not require expression of CD25.     

Functional heterogeneity of Leu 19"bright"+ and Leu 19"dim"+ lymphokine-activated killer cells

The functional heterogeneity of human lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells was characterized using LAK effector cells generated in vivo during rIL-2 therapy and separated by FACS into Leu 19"bright"+ and Leu 19"dim"+ subsets. The Leu 19"bright"+ subset mediated significantly greater levels of LAK lytic activity against NK-resistant COLO 205 target cells compared to Leu 19"dim"+ effector cells in chromium release assays. Single cell cytotoxicity assays showed that the Leu 19"bright"+ LAK effector cell subset contained a significantly higher percentage of cells capable of binding to and lysing COLO 205 or K562 target cells compared to the Leu 19"dim"+ subset. Furthermore, individual Leu 19"bright"+ LAK effector cells exhibited a more rapid rate of COLO 205 target cell lysis when compared to Leu 19"dim"+ LAK effector cells. In vitro culturing of Leu 19"bright"+ or Leu 19"dim"+ cells from normal donors with 1500 U/ml rIL-2 resulted in significantly greater levels of proliferation and LAK effector activity by Leu 19"bright"+ cells. Furthermore, whereas 86% of normal Leu 19"bright"+ cells maintained a Leu 19"bright"+ phenotype after rIL-2 stimulation, only 24% of Leu 19"dim"+ cells developed a Leu 19"bright"+ phenotype. These data demonstrate that Leu 19"bright"+ LAK cells are significantly more potent effectors than Leu 19"dim"+ cells due to quantitative and qualitative differences in the LAK effector cells contained within these subsets. Furthermore, these data indicate that Leu 19"bright"+ LAK cells that develop during rIL-2 therapy are derived from Leu 19"bright"+ precursor cells.     

Generation of lymphokine-activated killer cell activity from human thymocytes

We have generated lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells from human thymocytes in order to assess the relationship between LAK cells and T cells. Fresh thymocytes lack natural cytotoxic activity, and cytotoxicity cannot be stimulated by short term (1 hr) incubation with interferon or recombinant interleukin 2 (rIL-2). In addition, thymocytes are phenotypically devoid of cells bearing the natural killer (NK)-associated markers cluster designation (CD) 16 and NKH-1. After culture for 5 to 8 days with rIL-2, thymocytes display high levels of cytotoxic activity against both NK-sensitive and NK-resistant targets. Thymocytes require slightly more IL-2 than do peripheral blood lymphocytes to generate LAK activity. We have examined the phenotype of the thymocyte LAK precursor and effector cells. Thymocyte LAK precursors are of low to medium density, CD1-negative, and predominantly CD3-negative. Although CD3-positive cells proliferate in response to rIL-2, they are low in cytolytic capabilities. The effector cells, like the LAK precursors, are low to medium density lymphocytes. The cytotoxic cells are predominantly CD3-negative, and cytotoxic activity cannot be blocked with the use of anti-CD3 monoclonal antibodies. The effector cells also lack most NK-associated markers (HNK-1, and the CD16 markers Leu-11b and B73.1) but possess the NK-associated marker NKH-1 (N901). The responsive cell appears to be at a very early stage of thymic development, and it does not appear to either require or express the CD3-T cell receptor complex.     

Unique murine tumor-associated antigens identified by tumor infiltrating lymphocytes

Tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) were cultured from multiple methylcholanthrene-induced sarcomas under four different conditions: either low-dose (10 U/ml) or high-dose (1000 U/ml) rIL-2 was used with Ag stimulation by irradiated autologous tumor and splenocytes starting either at day 1 or day 10 of culture. TIL grown from four antigenically distinct sarcomas in low-dose rIL-2 were specifically lytic in vitro to their tumor of origin in 13 of 15 (87%) lytic cultures whereas only 8 of 28 (29%) lytic TIL cultures grown in high-dose rIL-2 showed specificity. TIL cultured in low-dose rIL-2 with Ag stimulation on day 1 of culture proliferated at a rate equal to TIL grown in high-dose rIL-2 and maintained their specificity for over 3 mo in culture. Cytolysis by specific TIL was MHC-restricted. TIL with in vitro specificity were therapeutically effective in eliminating established micrometastases in murine models. These investigations demonstrate that CTL derived from tumor-bearing mice can be used to define unique tumor-associated Ag on at least four different sarcomas and may be valuable in studies of the biologic nature of these Ag and in the adoptive immunotherapy of tumors.     

Heterogeneity of long-term cultured activated killer cells induced by anti-T3 antibody

The present study has characterized the short term and long term cultured murine-activated killer (AK) cells that are induced by antibody directed against the epsilon-chain of T3 complex. The conventional lymphokine AK (LAK) cells were generated by culturing normal B6 spleen cells with purified human rIL-2. The alpha T3-induced AK cells (T3AK) were induced by culturing normal B6 spleen cells with alpha T3 and were then maintained in culture medium supplemented with human rIL-2 and/or alpha T3. After initial activation with alpha T3, lymphocyte proliferation and generation of cytotoxic effectors (T3AK) were noted, and these events were related to the endogenous production of IL-2 and IL-4. Addition of alpha IL-2 and/or alpha IL-4 suppressed both the proliferative response and the cytotoxic response induced by alpha T3. In comparing the T3AK cells with the conventional LAK cells, there were many similarities as well as some distinct differences. Both cells displayed a similar cytotoxic spectrum against a variety of tumor targets. The T3AK cells usually gave much higher levels of cytotoxic activity against susceptible targets. However, the susceptibility of different tumor targets to conventional LAK cells and T3AK cells varied. The time course for the generation of lytic activity also differed between the conventional LAK and T3AK cells. One distinct difference was their ability to survive in vitro. The conventional LAK cells survived in culture for only 1 wk. The T3AK cells could survive for at least 4 to 5 wk with active growth. The serologic phenotype of the LAK precursors was asialo GM1 (AsGM1+) cells, but the T3AK precursors could be either AsGM1+ or AsGM1-, depending on the target cell. The LAK effectors were both Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2-, but the short-term T3AK effectors were exclusively Lyt-2+. The long term T3AK cells (cultured for more than 2 wk) were found to consist of Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2- cells, and these subsets of T3AK cells showed different target specificities. These findings demonstrate the heterogeneity of LAK and T3AK cells, and this heterogeneous property may contribute to their diversity in specificity against different tumor targets and thus may affect their effectiveness in the immunotherapy of cancer.     

Human postnatal CD4- CD8- CD3- thymic T cell precursors differentiate in vitro into T cell receptor delta-bearing cells

The signals required for activation and the differentiation of human triple negative postnatal thymocytes were studied in vitro. Highly purified populations of CD4-, CD8-, CD3- (triple negative) thymocytes were isolated by combined panning and preparative cell sorting and the ability of triple negative thymocytes to proliferate in response to various cytokines determined. Maximal triple negative proliferation was obtained using a mitogenic combination of CD2 antibodies and either rIL-2 or the phorbol ester, PMA. Long term growth (2 to 6 wk) of postnatal triple negative thymocytes was best achieved using CD2 antibodies and rIL-2. After in vitro culture with CD2 antibodies and rIL-2, triple negative thymocytes gave rise to TCR-delta+ cells beginning on day 2 of culture (approximately 15% CD3/TCR-delta+) reaching maximum (approximately 60% CD3/TCR-delta+) on day 7 with stable number of TCR-delta+ cells observed in vitro for up to 6 wk. Analysis of 30 clones of human postnatal triple negative thymocytes demonstrated 9 of 30 (30%) were TCR-delta+, beta F1-, essentially ruling out overgrowth of the triple negative population over time by a minor pool of contaminating TCR-delta+ cells. Thus, these studies have defined an in vitro culture system for human postnatal T cell precursors and demonstrated that precursors of human TCR-gamma delta+ T cells reside in the triple negative thymocyte pool.     

Monocyte-dependent,serum-borne suppressor of induction of lymphokine-activated killer cells in lymphocytes from melanoma patients

Summary Both phytohemagglutinin-induced cytotoxicity and recombinant-interleukin-2 (rIL-2)-induced lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity against noncultured melanoma cells were significantly reduced when peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from patients with metastatic melanoma were incubated in RPMI medium 1640 and 10% autologous human serum instead of 10% fetal calf serum, while serum from either healthy donors or patients with primary melanoma did not affect the level of cytotoxicity. The serum-mediated suppression was not restricted by major histocompatibility complex and was time-dependent. Addition of 10% human serum from the patients with metastatic melanoma [HS-Pt(m)] to the culture of PBMC with rIL-2 at the same time or 1 day after incubation significantly inhibited LAK activity. However, addition of 10% HS-Pt(m) 2 or 3 days after incubation did not inhibit LAK activity. Incubation of PBMC for 2 h with a high dose (10⁴ U/ml) of rIL-2 in the presence of 10% HS-Pt(m), followed by incubation in the absence of either rIL-2 or HS-Pt(m), did not affect LAK cell activity. These results suggest that HS-Pt(m) inhibits the early stage of LAK cell differentiation, rather than the binding of rIL-2 to PBMC or a later stage in the differentiation. In contrast to PBMC, monocyte-depleted peripheral blood lymphocytes exhibited comparable levels of LAK activity when cultured with rIL-2 either in 10% fetal calf serum, 10% human serum from healthy donors or 10% HS-Pt(m). Addition of purified autologous monocytes to the culture of monocyte-depleted peripheral blood lymphocytes with rIL-2 suppressed LAK cell induction when 10% HS-Pt(m) was present. Thus serum-mediated suppression of LAK cell induction is largely dependent on the presence of monocytes, which may produce a secondary inhibitor that acts on lymphocytes. Addition of indomethacin to the culture did not reverse this monocyte-dependent serum-mediated suppression in a majority of cases, suggesting that prostaglandin E₂ does not have a major role in the suppression.This work was supported in part by NIH grant RR5511-25 and grants from The Council for Tobacco Research USA Inc., The Meadows Foundation, the Erwin Zaban Melanoma Research Foundation, and the Gillson-Longenbaugh Foundation     

Heterogeneous lymphokine-activated killer cell precursor populations

Summary We developed a monoclonal antibody (mAb) 211, which recognizes the precursors in peripheral blood of lymphokine-activated killer cells (LAK) induced by recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2). In conjunction with complement mAb 211 also eliminates natural killer cells (NK) and a majority of the cytotoxic T lymphocytes. B cells and monocytes do not express the 211 antigen. Since mAb 211 recognized such a large percentage of peripheral blood lymphocytes we examined which 211⁺ subpopulation was the predominant precursor of rIL-2-induced LAK cells using two-color fluoresence-activated cell sorting (fluorescein-conjugated 211 mAb plus phycoerythrin-CD11b). This method identified the 211⁺/ CD11b⁺ population as the predominant phenotype of the rIL-2-induced LAK precursor. In addition, we directly compared the phenotype of the LAK precursor induced by delectinated T-cell growth factor (TCGF) to that induced by rIL-2. The 211-depleted population, which was devoid of NK cells and LAK precursors (inducible by rIL-2), was capable of generating LAK activity when TCGF was used as the source of lymphokine. LAK cells induced by TCGF from the 211-depleted population lysed a fresh sarcoma and an NK-resistant cultured melanoma tumor target but not the Daudi cell line, which was lysed by rIL-2-induced LAK cells. Lymphoid subpopulations, depleted using NKH1a mAb, behaved similarly, generating high levels of lysis against the two solid tumor targets when cultured with TCGF but not with rIL-2. CD 3-depleted populations showed enrichment for LAK precursors using either rIL-2 or TCGF. These results indicate that while rIL-2-induced LAK precursors cannot be separated from cells with NK activity, TCGF-induced LAK cells can be generated from populations of peripheral blood mononuclear cells without NK activity.     

Transforming growth factor-beta 1 (TGF-beta 1) and recombinant human tumor necrosis factor-alpha reciprocally regulate the generation of lymphokine-activated killer cell activity. Comparison between natural porcine platelet-derived TGF-beta 1 and TGF-beta 2, and recombinant human TGF-beta 1

We have investigated the ability of porcine-platelet-derived transforming growth factor-beta 1 (TGF-beta 1) to inhibit the generation of lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells by human rIL-2. The results demonstrate that TGF-beta 1, in a dose-related manner, significantly inhibits rIL-2-induced LAK cell activity against Daudi and COLO target cells and, to a lesser degree, against K-562 cells. Maximal inhibition was obtained by the addition of TGF-beta 1 at the time of culture initiation and, to a lesser degree, on day 1. Only minimal inhibition was obtained when TGF-beta 1 addition was delayed until day 2 of culture or when added directly into the LAK cell assay. Additional studies demonstrated that porcine platelet-derived TGF-beta 2 and human rTGF-beta 1 inhibited LAK cell generation similar to that obtained with TGF-beta 1. The inhibition of LAK cell activity by TGF-beta 1 was reversed by the addition of human rTNF-alpha at the initiation of culture. In addition, rTNF-alpha synergized with suboptimal levels of rIL-2 in the generation of LAK activity. After stimulation with rIL-2, LAK cells produced significant levels of IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha, and TNF-beta. TGF-beta 1 inhibited the production of these cytokines in a dose-related manner. The results extend the previous known activities for human rTNF-alpha and TGF-beta 1 and further demonstrate the reciprocal relationship between these two molecules in the regulation of certain immune functions.     

In vivo effects of recombinant IL-2. I. Isolation of circulating Leu-19+ lymphokine-activated killer effector cells from cancer patients receiving recombinant IL-2

This study was designed to isolate and phenotypically characterize lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells generated in vivo during administration of high dose rIL-2 to cancer patients. The development of circulating LAK effector cells in these patients was demonstrated by the ability of fresh PBL to exhibit lytic activity against the NK-resistant Daudi cell line and fresh tumor cells without prior in vitro culture with rIL-2. Kinetic studies demonstrated that circulating LAK effector cells are detectable 4 to 6 wk after the initiation of rIL-2 therapy. Cells isolated by FACS revealed that circulating LAK cells are Leu-19+, Leu-17+ but CD5-. We have previously reported that circulating Leu-19+ cells are heterogeneous with regard to the expression of CD16 and CD8. Since sorting of cells expressing Leu-19 and either low quantities of CD8 or CD16 resulted in cytolytic activity in both the positive and negative fractions, these latter two markers do not identify subpopulations of Leu-19+ cells with or without LAK cytolytic activity. Although all LAK cells generated in vivo were Leu-19+, we generated LAK cells from the Leu-19- subpopulation after in vitro culture with rIL-2, suggesting that at least some of in vitro generated LAK cells are derived from Leu-19- precursor cells. These LAK cells did not, however, express the Leu-19 surface marker. Based on the functional data reported in this paper, we conclude that circulating LAK effector cells are a phenotypically heterogeneous population that express surface Ag in association with NK cells and not T lymphocytes.     

IL-4 regulation of murine lymphokine-activated killer activity in vitro. Effects on the IL-2-induced expansion, cytotoxicity, and phenotype of lymphokine-activated killer effectors

The in vitro incubation of B6 splenocytes with purified, mouse rIL-4 for 4 to 5 days was sufficient to generate lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity. In addition, rIL-4 augmented LAK cytotoxic activity when combined with rIL-2, as measured in a 4 h 51Cr-release assay against fresh, syngeneic MCA-sarcoma (MCA-102 and MCA-105) cells. Interestingly, this augmentation was not observed against the cultured YAC-1 target. LAK generation and augmentation of cytotoxicity by rIL-4 was species-specific, because human rIL-4 (up to 20,000 U/ml) failed to elicit these effects in the mouse splenocyte cultures. When 5-day B6 LAK cells (splenocytes incubated in rIL-2 at 1000 U/ml for 5 days) were split and recultured in the combination of rIL-2 plus rIL-4 for 4 additional days at least a twofold greater expansion in cell number resulted compared to similar cells cultured in either rIL-2 or rIL-4 alone. Moreover, LAK cells expanded in rIL-2 plus rIL-4 exhibited substantial increases in in vitro cytolytic activity (on a per cell basis) against MCA-102 and MCA-105 sarcoma cells, but not against YAC-1 targets. FACS analysis or negative selection using Lyt-2 or NK-1.1 mAb plus C revealed no differences in effector phenotype(s) of LAK cells expanded in rIL-2 alone compared to rIL-2 plus rIL-4 to account for the differences observed in both expansion and cytolytic activity by rIL-4. The majority of cells was Thy-1+, Lyt-2+, T3+, and ASGM-1+. However, a marked increase in the granule-associated serine esterase, BLT-E, was found only in LAK cells expanded in the combination of both lymphokines. Collectively, these studies show that rIL-4 has potent regulatory activities on splenic LAK generation, expansion, and cytotoxic function in the mouse.     

“Differentiation Induction” culture of human leukemic myeloid cells stimulates high production of macrophage differentiation inducing factor

We recently developed a new culture system based on dialysis perfusion (designated JCC-device) for the generation and expansion of human lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells (Murata et al., 1990). More recently we have scaled up the volume of the culture vessel of the JCC-device from 100 ml to 400 ml for clinical use. In the present study, using this new 400 ml JCC-device, we cultured human lymph node lymphocytes (LNL) obtained from 8 surgical patients with primary lung cancer, and investigated the cellular characteristics in comparison with a conventional batchwise culture system using tissue culture dishes. With the JCC-device, the cell density reached a maximum 2.7×10⁷ cells/ml with greater than 90% viability by the appropriate exchange of perfusion medium and by making additions at the appropriate intervals for recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2). The expansion fold of LNL with the JCC-device, ranging 6.6- to 19.2-fold (mean 13.8-fold), was not significantly different from that in dish cultures. There was no marked difference in cell surface phenotypes between the two culture systems in 7 out of 8 cases. As for LAK activity of LNL, the JCC culture was either superior or equal in 4 out of 8 cases, but inferior in the other 4 cases to the conventional dish cultures. In the latter cases, the usage of serum for the JCC culture was limited, which might have resulted in the low LAK activity. The JCC-device was able to reduce the consumption of basal medium, rIL-2 and serum by 20%, 84% and 96%, respectively compared to the conventional tissue culture systems. The JCC-device improved the routine performance of adoptive immunotherapy with LAK cells and rIL-2.Abbreviations LAK lymphokine-activated killer - rIL-2 recombinant interleukin-2 - LNL lymph node lymphocytes - BM basal medium - CM complete medium - HBSS Hanks balanced salt solution - JRU Japan reference unit     

IL-4-induced lymphokine-activated killer cells. Lytic activity is mediated by phenotypically distinct natural killer-like and T cell-like large granular lymphocytes

The purpose of the current study was to characterize lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity induced with IL-4/B cell stimulatory factor-1 and to compare IL-4-induced LAK activity with IL-2-induced LAK activity. Culture of murine lymphocytes with high concentrations of IL-4 induced nonspecific lytic activity against a wide variety of tumors. Lytic activity induced by IL-4 increased with increasing concentrations of IL-4 over the range of 1.0 to 25 ng/ml. The kinetics of LAK induction by IL-4 and IL-2 were similar; however, IL-4 was less effective than IL-2 in maintaining lytic activity for longer culture periods and provided lower viable cell yields than did IL-2. Similar to IL-2, IL-4 induced blastogenesis and the generation of large granular lymphocytes, all LAK activity observed was exclusively associated with the large granular lymphocyte fraction, and the cytolytic effector cells were heterogeneous in regards to cell surface phenotype. The majority of IL-4-induced lytic activity was associated with mutually exclusive NK-like (i.e., NK-1.1+ Lyt-2-) and T cell-like (i.e., NK-1.1- Lyt-2+) LAK cells. The precursors for each subset were distinct and expressed the asialo-GM1+ Lyt-2- and the asialo-GM1+ Lyt-2+ phenotypes, respectively. Although IL-4-induced LAK effector cells were morphologically and phenotypically similar to IL-2-induced LAK cells, IL-2 generated equivalent numbers of T cell-like and NK-like LAK cells, whereas IL-4 generated 3.5-fold more T cell-like LAK cells than NK-like LAK cells. It might eventually be possible to exploit the preferential activation of T cell-like LAK by IL-4 for therapeutic advantage.     

Adoptive immunotherapy of a mouse colon carcinoma with recombinant interleukin-2 alone or combined with lymphokine-activated killer cells or tumor-immune lymphocytes

Summary We have used a BALB/c colonic adenocarcinoma (C-26) to evaluate the therapeutic potential of recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2) at high and low dosages in combination with or without lymphokine-activated killers (LAK) or tumor-specific, immune lymphocytes in either an adjuvant spontaneous or an artificial metastasis system. Most (80%) of the mice that underwent s.c. C-26 tumor excision were shown to die of spontaneous metastasis with lung involvement by 1–4 months after excision. Postsurgical systemic treatment with low-dose rIL-2 (3 × 10⁴ U/day, i.p.) increased the survival rate to 31% as compared to 21% (not significant) in excised controls while administration of high-dose rIL-2 (8 × 10⁴ U/day) led to 53% survival (P <0.01). Both LAK cells and C-26-tumor-immune lymphocytes given during rIL-2 treatment significantly increased the effects of rIL-2 at the low but not at the high-dose, with tumor-immune effectors resulting in the highest percentage (63%) of cures. When mice bearing 3-day artificial lung metastases of C-26 cells were treated with low- or high-dose rIL-2, in combination with or without LAK or tumor-immune lymphocytes, a highly significant reduction or abrogation of the number of lung foci was observed with all treatments, including those involving or tumor-immune lymphocytes alone. Assessment of survival benefit in these mice, however, showed survival prolongation, with 20% cures achieved by low-dose rIL-2 alone and up to 65% cures by LAK in combination with low-dose rIL-2. In this system of artificial metastasis high-dose rIL-2 alone increased the survival time but failed to cure the animals, and the addition of LAK was ineffective whereas that of tumor-immune lymphocytes led to 80% cure. These results suggest that tumorimmune lymphocytes are more effective than LAK when combined with rIL-2 and that caution is necessary in extrapolating findings obtained in artificial metastasis models.