MutS as a tool for mutation detection

MutS, a DNA mismatch-binding protein, seems to be a promising tool for mutation detection. We present three MutS based approaches to the detection of point mutations: DNA retardation, protection of mismatched DNA against exonuclease digestion, and chimeric MutS proteins. DNA retardation in polyacrylamide gels stained with SYBR-Gold allows mutation detection using 1-3 microg of Thermus thermophilus his6-MutS protein and 50-200 ng of a PCR product. The method enables the search for a broad range of mutations: from single up to several nucleotide, as mutations over three nucleotides could be detected in electrophoresis without MutS, due to the mobility shift caused by large insertion/deletion loops in heteroduplex DNA. The binding of DNA mismatches by MutS protects the complexed DNA against exonuclease digestion. The direct addition of the fluorescent dye, SYBR-Gold, allows mutation detection in a single-tube assay. The limited efficiency of T4 DNA polymerase as an exonuclease hampers the application of the method in practice. The assay required 300-400 ng of PCR products in the range of 200-700 bp and 1-3 microg of MutS. MutS binding to mismatched DNA immobilised on a solid phase can be observed thanks to the activity of a reporter domain linked to MutS. We obtained chimeric bifunctional proteins consisting of T. thermophilus MutS and reporter domains, like beta-galactosidase or GFP. Very low detection limits for beta-galactosidase could theoretically enable mutation detection not only by the examination of PCR products, but even of genomic DNA.     

Differential Mismatch Recognition Specificities of Eukaryotic MutS Homologs,MutSα and MutSβ

In eukaryotes, the recognition of the DNA postreplication errors and initiation of the mismatch repair is carried out by two MutS homologs: MutSα and MutSβ. MutSα recognizes base mismatches and 1 to 2 unpaired nucleotides whereas MutSβ recognizes longer insertion-deletion loops (IDLs) with 1 to 15 unpaired nucleotides as well as certain mismatches. Results from molecular dynamics simulations of native MutSβ:IDL-containing DNA and MutSα:mismatch DNA complexes as well as complexes with swapped DNA substrates provide mechanistic insight into how the differential substrate specificities are achieved by MutSα and MutSβ, respectively. Our simulations results suggest more extensive interactions between MutSβ and IDL-DNA and between MutSα and mismatch-containing DNA that suggest corresponding differences in stability. Furthermore, our simulations suggest more expanded mechanistic details involving a different degree of bending when DNA is bound to either MutSα or MutSβ and a more likely opening of the clamp domains when noncognate substrates are bound. The simulation results also provide detailed information on key residues in MutSβ and MutSα that are likely involved in recognizing IDL-DNA and mismatch-containing DNA, respectively.     

MutS recognition: Multiple mismatches and sequence context effects

Escherichia coli MutS is a versatile repair protein that specifically recognizes not only various types of mismatches but also single stranded loops of up to 4 nucleotides in length. Specific binding, followed by the next step of tracking the DNA helix that locates hemi-methylated sites, is regulated by the conformational state of the protein as a function of ATP binding/hydrolysis. Here, we study how various molecular determinants of a heteroduplex regulate mismatch recognition by MutS, the critical first step of mismatch repair. Using classical DNase I footprinting assays, we demonstrate that the hierarchy of MutS binding to various types of mismatches is identical whether the mismatches are present singly or in multiples. Moreover, this unique hierarchy is indifferent both to the differential level of DNA helical flexibility and to the unpaired status of the mismatched bases in a heteroduplex. Surprisingly, multiple mismatches exhibit reduced affinity of binding to MutS, compared to that of a similar single mismatch. Such a reduction in the affinity might be due to sequence context effects, which we established more directly by studying two identical single mismatches in an altered sequence background. A mismatch, upon simply being flipped at the same location, elicits changes in MutS specific contacts, thereby underscoring the importance of sequence context in modulating MutS binding to mismatches.     

A homogeneous resonance energy transfer-based assay to monitor MutS/DNA interactions

Probing the interactions of the DNA mismatch repair protein MutS with altered and damaged DNA is of great interest both for the understanding of the mismatch repair system function and for the development of tools to detect mutations. Here we describe a homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence (HTRF) assay to study the interactions of Escherichia coli MutS protein with various DNA substrates. First, we designed an indirect HTRF assay on a microtiter plate format and demonstrated its general applicability through the analysis of the interactions between MutS and mismatched DNA or DNA containing the most common lesion of the anticancer drug cisplatin. Then we directly labeled MutS with the long-lived fluorescent donor molecule europium tris-bipyridine cryptate ([TBP(Eu³⁺)]) and demonstrated by electrophoretic mobility shift assay that this chemically labeled protein retained DNA mismatch binding property. Consequently, we used [TBP(Eu³⁺)]-MutS to develop a faster and simpler semidirect HTRF assay.     

Mismatch-induced DNA unbending upon duplex opening

A DNA duplex can be torn open at a specific position by introducing a branch or bulge to create an asymmetric three-way junction (TWJ). The opened duplex manifests a bent conformation (bending angle approximately 60 degrees , relative to the unopened form), which leads to a dramatic decrease in gel electrophoretic mobility. In the presence of a basepair mismatch at the opening position, the DNA backbone becomes less bent and assumes a distorted T-shaped structure, resulting in an increase in polyacrylamide gel electrophoretic mobility. Both conformational changes are confirmed using fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments and found to be similar to the signature conformational changes of DNA duplex upon MutS protein binding. Our results imply that some structural rearrangements essential for mismatch recognition are achievable without protein interference. The gel electrophoretic mobility data for DNA TWJs with and without base mismatches correlates well with rotational diffusivity, computed by taking into account the conformational change of TWJ induced by base mismatch.     

A fluorescent multiplex-DGGE screening test for mutations in the BRCA1 gene

Screening for mutations in the BRCA1 gene is challenging because of the wide spectrum of mutations found in this large gene. As the extensive exon 11 is commonly screened by the protein truncation test (PTT), here a fluorescent multiplex denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (FMD) mutation screening technique was developed to test the remaining numerous small exons and splice sites of the gene. The method is based upon the use of an efficient multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of the target regions, followed by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) separation of the amplicon mixture, and the immediate achievement of results by wet gel scanning. The technique was applied to screen 16 samples with different BRCA1 sequence variants distributed over 12 exons. All variants were detected. In addition, 188 DNA samples from ovarian cancer patients were screened, identifying 22 new sequence variants (11.7% of the samples) and 243 common polymorphisms in the BRCA1 locus. Variants included 16 single nucleotide substitutions, 3 deletions of 2 nucleotides, 1 deletion of 4 nucleotides, and 2 insertions of 1 nucleotide. The FMD test provides an accurate, fast, nonradioactive and cost-efficient way to scan the BRCA1 gene with high sensitivity and an ease of result interpretation. This technique may prove to be a useful research tool for the detection of mutations and polymorphisms in the BRCA1 gene and for large-scale epidemiologic studies.     

One tube mutation detection using sensitive fluorescent dyeing of MutS protected DNA

A novel, universal method for mutation detection utilising the ability of MutS protein to recognise DNA incomplementarities is proposed. The examined and reference DNA fragments are PCR amplified. The PCR products are purified, mixed, heated and cooled to form heteroduplexes. In the case of mutation the heteroduplex DNA containing mismatch is protected against exonuclease digestion by MutS, while the DNA without mismatches is degraded. The protection effect is visualised by the direct addition of a highly sensitive fluorescent dye (SYBR-Gold) selectively binding DNA. The Thermus thermophilus recombined His-tagged MutS and 3′–5′ exonuclease activity of T4 DNA polymerase were used in the assay.     

Universal method for single nucleotide substitution identification

A new approach to the identification of point mutations by allele-specific PCR was proposed. The mutation R408W of the human phenylalanine hydroxylase gene was used as a model. A high specificity of the approach was achieved by the use of primers partially complementary to the genomic DNA. Polyethylene glycol covalently attached to one of the allele-specific primers provides for the differential identification of the PCR products due to a change in electrophoretic mobility.     

Chemical cleavage of DNA with single base mismatches for detection of mutations of unknown localization

The most promising approach for detection of random point mutations relies upon the DNA chemical cleavage near associated mismatching base pairs. In our study, the series of heteroduplexes with all types of mismatches and extrahelical nucleotide residues surrounded by both A x T and G x C pairs were performed via hybridization of 50-mer synthetic oligonucleotides differing in only one nucleotide at the central position. The chemical cleavage of DNA duplexes immobilized on magnetic beads by means of biotin-streptavidin interaction was carried out with chemicals, which able to attack only nucleobases flipped out of the base stack: potassium permanganate and hydroxylamine reacting to T and C respectively. The chemical reactivity of different mismatches was shown to correlate clearly with the target local structure in a particular sequence context. This work makes up for a deficiency in systematic study of DNA cleavage near mismatches in dependence on their type, orientation and flanking nucleotides. The model system elaborated may be applied to estimate the sensitivity of the methodology and to control the possibility of false-positive and false-negative result appearance, when different protocols for detection of DNA mutations are used. The modification of heteroduplex mixtures by potassium permanganate and hydroxylamine allows to reveal any non-canonical base pair and suggest its type and neighboring nucleotides from the nature of chemical as well as its localization from the length of cleavage products.     

Mutation detection using a novel plant endonuclease.

We have discovered a useful new reagent for mutation detection, a novel nuclease CEL I from celery. It is specific for DNA distortions and mismatches from pH 6 to 9. Incision is on the 3'-side of the mismatch site in one of the two DNA strands in a heteroduplex. CEL I-like nucleases are found in many plants. We report here that a simple method of enzyme mutation detection using CEL I can efficiently identify mutations and polymorphisms. To illustrate the efficacy of this approach, the exons of the BRCA1 gene were amplified by PCR using primers 5'-labeled with fluorescent dyes of two colors. The PCR products were annealed to form heteroduplexes and subjected to CEL I incision. In GeneScan analyses with a PE Applied Biosystems automated DNA sequencer, two independent incision events, one in each strand, produce truncated fragments of two colors that complement each other to confirm the position of the mismatch. CEL I can detect 100% of the sequence variants present, including deletions, insertions and missense alterations. Our results indicate that CEL I mutation detection is a highly sensitive method for detecting both polymorphisms and disease-causing mutations in DNA fragments as long as 1120 bp in length.     

Mechanism of MutS searching for DNA mismatches and signaling repair

DNA mismatch repair is initiated by the recognition of mismatches by MutS proteins. The mechanism by which MutS searches for and recognizes mismatches and subsequently signals repair remains poorly understood. We used single-molecule analyses of atomic force microscopy images of MutS-DNA complexes, coupled with biochemical assays, to determine the distributions of conformational states, the DNA binding affinities, and the ATPase activities of wild type and two mutants of MutS, with alanine substitutions in the conserved Phe-Xaa-Glu mismatch recognition motif. We find that on homoduplex DNA, the conserved Glu, but not the Phe, facilitates MutS-induced DNA bending, whereas at mismatches, both Phe and Glu promote the formation of an unbent conformation. The data reveal an unusual role for the Phe residue in that it promotes the unbending, not bending, of DNA at mismatch sites. In addition, formation of the specific unbent MutS-DNA conformation at mismatches appears to be required for the inhibition of ATP hydrolysis by MutS that signals initiation of repair. These results provide a structural explanation for the mechanism by which MutS searches for and recognizes mismatches and for the observed phenotypes of mutants with substitutions in the Phe-Xaa-Glu motif.     

Mutation detection using immobilized mismatch binding protein (MutS).

An accurate and highly sensitive mutation detection assay has been developed. The assay is based on the detection of mispaired and unpaired bases by immobilized mismatch binding protein (Escherichia coli MutS). The assay can detect most mismatches and all single base substitution mutations, as well as small addition or deletion mutations. The assay is simple to use and does not require the use of either radioactivity or gel electrophoresis.     

Mutation detection using nucleotide analogs that alter electrophoretic mobility.

A simple primer extension assay has been developed to distinguish homologous DNA segments differing by as little as a single nucleotide. DNA strands are synthesized with one of the four natural nucleotides replaced with an analog that affects electrophoretic mobility. DNAs that are the same length but differ in the number of analog molecules per strand exhibit different mobilities on a sequencing gel. In combination with the polymerase chain reaction (PCR; 1, 2), this method has been used to distinguish mutant and normal alleles of the human insulin receptor gene that differ by a single-base substitution. The method appears to be generally applicable to the detection of any nucleotide polymorphism in any segment of DNA.     

The Phe-X-Glu DNA binding motif of MutS. The role of hydrogen bonding in mismatch recognition

The crystal structures of MutS protein from Thermus aquaticus and Escherichia coli in a complex with a mismatch-containing DNA duplex reveal that the Glu residue in a conserved Phe-X-Glu motif participates in a hydrogen-bonded contact with either an unpaired thymidine or the thymidine of a G-T base-base mismatch. Here, the role of hydrogen bonding in mismatch recognition by MutS is assessed. The relative affinities of MutS for DNA duplexes containing nonpolar shape mimics of A and T, 4-methylbenzimidazole (Z), and difluorotoluene (F), respectively, that lack hydrogen bonding donors and acceptors, are determined in gel mobility shift assays. The results provide support for an induced fit mode of mismatch binding in which duplexes destabilized by mismatches are preferred substrates for kinking by MutS. Hydrogen bonding between the O epsilon 2 group of Glu and the mismatched base contributes only marginally to mismatch recognition and is significantly less important than the aromatic ring stack with the conserved Phe residue. A MutS protein in which Ala is substituted for Glu(38) is shown to be defective for mismatch repair in vivo. DNA binding studies reveal a novel role for the conserved Glu residue in the establishment of mismatch discrimination by MutS.     

Visualization of mismatch repair in bacterial cells.

We determined the localizations of mismatch repair proteins in living Bacillus subtilis cells. MutS-GFP colocalized with the chromosome in all cells and formed foci in a subset of cells. MutL-GFP formed foci in a subset of cells, and its localization was MutS dependent. The introduction of mismatches by growth in 2-aminopurine caused a replication-dependent increase in the number of cells with MutS and MutL foci. Approximately half of the MutS foci colocalized with DNA polymerase foci. We conclude that MutS is associated with the entire chromosome, poised to detect mismatches. After detection, it appears that mismatch repair foci assemble at mismatches as they emerge from the DNA polymerase and are then carried away from the replisome by continuing replication.     

Combinatorial fluorescence energy transfer tags for multiplex biological assays

We report an approach for developing combinatorial fluorescence energy transfer (CFET) tags by tuning the tags' fluorescence emission signatures. The tags can all be excited at a single wavelength and analyzed by a simple optical system. We constructed eight CFET tags with unique fluorescence signatures, detected by a three-color capillary array electrophoresis (CAE) system with 488 nm excitation, using only three fluorescent dyes. A 1',2'-dideoxyribose phosphate spacer was used to separate the donor and acceptor to tune the energy transfer efficiency, generating unique fluorescence signatures. The spacer also served as an electrophoretic mobility tag to tune the mobility of CFET-labeled DNA for multiplex detection of single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). Six nucleotide variations were identified simultaneously using six CFET tags on synthetic DNA templates and on a PCR product from the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor gene.     

Covalently trapping MutS on DNA to study DNA mismatch recognition and signaling

The DNA repair protein MutS forms clamp-like structures on DNA that search for and recognize base mismatches leading to ATP-transformed signaling clamps. In this study, the mobile MutS clamps were trapped on DNA in a functional state using single-cysteine variants of MutS and thiol-modified homoduplex or heteroduplex DNA. This approach allows stabilization of various transient MutS-DNA complexes and will enable their structural and functional analysis.     

Pyrophosphorolysis-activatable oligonucleotides may facilitate detection of rare alleles, mutation scanning and analysis of chromatin structures

Pyrophosphorolysis-activated polymerization (PAP) was initially developed to enhance the specificity of allele-specific PCR for detection of known mutations in the presence of a great excess of wild-type allele. The high specificity of PAP derives from the serial coupling of pyrophosphorolysis-mediated activation of a pyrophosphorolysis-activatable oligonucleotide (P*) followed by extension of the activated oligonucleotide. Herein, we demonstrate that genetically engineered DNA polymerases greatly improve the efficiency of PAP, making it a practical technique for detection of rare mutations. We also show that P* oligonucleotides have the novel and unexpected property of high sensitivity to mismatches throughout at least the 16 3′-terminal nucleotides. Thus, PAP constitutes a technology platform of potential utility whenever high specificity is required along the length of an oligonucleotide.     

The construction of bifunctional fusion proteins consisting of MutS and GFP

MutS as a mismatch binding protein is a promising tool for SNP detection. Green fluorescent protein (GFP) is known as an excellent reporter domain. We constructed chimeric proteins consisting of MutS from Thermus thermophilus and GFPuv from Aequorea victoria by cloning the GFPuv gene into the plasmid vectors carrying the mutS gene. The GFPuv domain fused to the N-terminus of MutS (histag-GFP-MutS) exhibited the same level of green fluorescence as free GFPuv. To obtain the fluorescing histag-GFP-MutS protein the expression at 30 degrees C was required, while free GFPuv fluoresces when expressed both at 30 and 37 degrees C. The chimeric protein where the GFPuv domain was fused to the C-terminus of MutS exhibited much weaker green fluorescence (20-25% compared with those of histag-GFP-MutS or free GFPuv). The insertion of (ProGly)5 peptide linker between the MutS and GFP domains resulted in no significant improvement in GFP fluorescence. No shifts in the excitation and emission spectra have been observed for the GFP domain in the fusion proteins. The fusion proteins with GFP at the N- and C-terminus of MutS recognised DNA mismatches similarly like T. thermophilus MutS. The fluorescent proteins recognising DNA mismatches could be useful for SNP scanning or intracellular DNA analysis. The fusion proteins around 125 kDa were efficiently expressed in E. coli and purified in milligram amounts using metal chellate affinity chromatography.