Multiple ligands in opioid research

The observation in 1979 that opioid receptors interact, led to the design of bivalent ligands in an attempt to improve selectivity and affinity towards the different subtypes( i.e. mu, delta, and kappa). Dimers of monovalent 'parent' opioid structures have been evaluated and include: (a) endogenous (e.g enkephalins) or exogenous (e.g dermorphin) peptide dimer analogues (b) mixed peptidic -non-peptidic bivalent ligands and (c) dual non-peptidic dimers. Chimeric structures, using an opioid pharmacophore in combination with a a non-opioid pharmacophore, have also been prepared. The common aim in all these studies is to improve the pharmacological profile of potential analgesics to minimize common opioid-induced side effects, such as physical dependence and tolerance. Here we present a brief overview efforts to develop bivalent opioid ligands for use in pain-related research.     

Conformation-activity relationships of opioid peptides with selective activities at opioid receptors

The discovery of endogenous opioid peptides 25 years ago opened up a new chapter in efforts to understand the origins and control of pain, its relationships to other biological functions, including inflammatory and other immune responses, and the relationships of opioid peptides and their receptors to a variety of undesirable or toxic side effects often associated with the nonpeptide opiates such as morphine including addiction, constipation, a variety of neural toxicities, tolerance, and respiratory depression. For these investigations the need for potent and highly receptor selective agonists and antagonists has been crucial since they in principle allow one to distinguish unequivocally the roles of the different opioid receptors (mu, delta, and kappa) in the various biological and pathological roles of the opioid peptides and their receptors. Conformational and topographical constraint of the linear natural endogenous opioid peptides has played a major role in developing peptide ligands with high selectivity for mu, delta, and kappa receptors, and in understanding the conformational, topographical, and stereoelectronic structural requirements of the opioid peptides for their interactions with opioid receptors. In turn, this had led to insights into the three-dimensional pharmacophore for opioid receptors. In this article we review and discuss some of the developments that have led to potent, selective, and stable peptide and peptidomimetic ligands that are highly potent and selective, and that have delta agonist, mu antagonist, and kappa agonist biological activities (other authors in this issue will discuss the development of other types of activities and selectivities). These have led to ligands that provide unique insight into opioid pharmacophores and the critical roles opioid ligands and receptor scan play in pain, addiction, and other human maladies.     

Exploring the structure of opioid receptors with homology modeling based on single and multiple templates and subsequent docking: A comparative study

Opioid receptors are the principal targets for opioids, which have been used as analgesics for centuries. Opioid receptors belong to the rhodopsin family of G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs). In the absence of crystal structures of opioid receptors, 3D homology models have been reported with bovine rhodopsin as a template, though the sequence homology is low. Recently, it has been reported that use of multiple templates results in a better model for a target having low sequence identity with a single template. With the objective of carrying out a comparative study on the structural quality of the 3D models based on single and multiple templates, the homology models for opioid receptors (mu, delta and kappa) were generated using bovine rhodopsin as single template and the recently deposited crystal structures of squid rhodopsin, turkey β-1 and human β-2 adrenoreceptors along with bovine rhodopsin as multiple templates. In this paper we report the results of comparison between the refined 3D models based on multiple sequence alignment (MSA) and models built with bovine rhodopsin as template, using validation programs PROCHECK, PROSA, Verify 3D, Molprobity and docking studies. The results indicate that homology models of mu and kappa with multiple templates are better than those built with only bovine rhodopsin as template, whereas, in many aspects, the homology model of delta opioid receptor with single template is better with respect to the model based on multiple templates. Three nonselective ligands were docked to both the models of mu, delta and kappa opioid receptors using GOLD 3.1. The results of docking complied well with the pharamacophore, reported for nonspecific opioid ligands. The comparison of docking results for models with multiple templates and those with single template have been discussed in detail. Three selective ligands for each receptor were also docked. As the crystallographic structures are not yet known, this comparison will help in choosing better homology models of opioid receptors for studying ligand receptor interactions to design new potent opioid antagonists.     

Novel ligands for the opioid receptors: synthesis and structure-activity relationships among 5'-aryl and 5'-heteroaryl 17-cyclopropylmethyl-4,5 alpha-epoxypyrido[2',3':6,7]morphinans

A series of pyridomorphinans possessing an aryl (10a-s) or heteroaryl (11a-h) substituent at the 5'-position of the pyridine ring of 17-cyclopropylmethyl-4,5 alpha-epoxypyrido[2',3':6,7]morphinan was synthesized and evaluated for binding and functional activity at the opioid delta, mu, and kappa receptors. All of these pyridomorphinans bound with higher affinity at the delta site than at mu or kappa sites. The binding data on isomeric compounds revealed that there exists greater bulk tolerance for substituents placed at the o-position of the phenyl ring than at m- or p-positions. Among the ligands examined, the 2-chlorophenyl (10l), 2-nitrophenyl (10n), 2-pyridyl (11a), and 4-quinolinyl (11g) compounds bound to the delta receptor with subnanomolar affinity. Compound 10c with the p-tolyl substituent displayed the highest mu/delta selectivity (ratio=42) whereas compound 10l with the 2-chlorophenyl substituent displayed the highest kappa/delta selectivity (ratio=23). At 10 microM concentration, the in vitro functional activity determined using [(35)S]GTP-gamma-S binding assays showed that all of the compounds were antagonists devoid of any significant agonist activity at the delta, mu, and kappa receptors. Antagonist potency determinations of three selected ligands revealed that the p-tolyl compound 10c is a potent delta selective antagonist. In the [(35)S]GTP-gamma-S assays this compound had a functional antagonist K(i) value of 0.2, 4.52, and 7.62 nM at the delta, mu, and kappa receptors, respectively. In the smooth muscle assays 10c displayed delta antagonist potency with a K(e) value of 0.88 nM. As an antagonist, it was 70-fold more potent at the delta receptors in the MVD than at the mu receptors in the GPI. The in vitro delta antagonist profile of this pyridomorphinan 10c resembles that of the widely used delta selective antagonist ligand naltrindole.     

Synthesis of [D-Ala2,4'-125I-Phe3,Glu4]deltorphin and characterization of its delta opioid receptor binding properties.

Both [D-Ala2,Glu4]Deltorphin and [D-Ala2,4'-I-Phe3,Glu4]Deltorphin are highly selective ligands for delta, relative to mu, opioid receptors. Radiolabeled [D-Ala2, 4'-125I-Phe3,Glu4]Deltorphin ([125I]Deltorphin) was prepared with a specific activity of 2200 Ci/mmol from [D-Ala2, 4'-NH2-Phe3, Glu4]Deltorphin through a diazonium salt intermediate. The inhibition of [125I]Deltorphin binding to rat brain membranes by ligands selective for mu, delta, and kappa opioid receptors is consistent with binding by the radioligand to a single site having the properties of a delta opioid receptor. The results of these studies are in good agreement with those obtained by structurally different delta opioid receptor ligands. The similarity between the delta receptor site labeled by [125I]Deltorphin and those labeled by other delta receptor agonists, in contrast to differences seen by in vivo studies of their analgesic effects, is discussed.     

Characterization of [3H]naltrindole binding to delta opioid receptors in rat brain.

[3H]Naltrindole binding characteristics were determined using homogenized rat brain tissue. Saturation binding studies at 25 degrees C measured an equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) value of 37.0 +/- 3.0 pM and a receptor density (Bmax) value of 63.4 +/- 2.0 fmol/mg protein. Association binding studies showed that equilibrium was reached within 90 min at a radioligand concentration of 30 pM. Naltrindole, as well as the ligands selective for delta (delta) opioid receptors, such as pCI-DPDPE and Deltorphin II inhibited [3H]naltrindole binding with nanomolar IC50 values. Ligands selective for mu (mu) and kappa (kappa) opioid receptors were only effective in inhibiting [3H]naltrindole binding at micromolar concentrations. From these data, we conclude that [3H]naltrindole is a high affinity, selective radioligand for delta opioid receptors.     

(4-Carboxamido)phenylalanine is a surrogate for tyrosine in opioid receptor peptide ligands

(S)-4-(Carboxamido)phenylalanine (Cpa) is examined as a bioisosteric replacement for the terminal tyrosine (Tyr) residue in a variety of known peptide ligands for the mu, delta and kappa opioid receptors. The Cpa-containing peptides, assayed against cloned human opioid receptors, display comparable binding affinity (Ki), and agonist potency (EC50) to the parent ligands at the three receptors. Cpa analogs of delta selective peptides show an increase in delta selectivity relative to the mu receptor. Cpa is the first example of an amino acid that acts as a surrogate for Tyr in opioid peptide ligands, challenging the long-standing belief that a phenolic residue is required for high affinity binding.     

Prejunctional effects of opioids in the perfused mesentery of the rat and rabbit: interactions with alpha 2-adrenoceptors.

Prejunctional effects of opioids were examined in the perfused mesentery of two species: the rat and rabbit. Use of agonists selective for subtypes of mu, delta, and kappa opioid receptors produced no effect on contractile responses to adrenergic nerve stimulation in the rat perfused mesentery, except for small effects of the kappa agonist EKC, which may be non specific. In contrast, mu, delta and kappa receptors appear to be present in the rabbit. The mu selective agonist, DAMGO, kappa agonist, ethylketocyclazocine, and delta agonists, DPDPE and [Leu5]-enkephalin, all produced significant inhibition of contractile responses to transmural nerve stimulation. The inhibitory effect was greatest for ethylketocyclazocine. To test the possibility that prejunctional activation of alpha 2 adrenoceptors with endogenous norepinephrine might decrease the activity of prejunctional opioid receptors in the rabbit, inhibitory effects of delta and kappa selective agonists were tested in the presence of 10(-7) M yohimbine. Inhibitory responses of the kappa selective agonist ethylketocyclazocine were enhanced, while that of delta selective agonists [Leu5]-enkephalin and DPDPE remained unchanged when yohimbine was present. Thus, the effects of opioids vary and depend on the tissue and receptor subtypes they act upon. Furthermore, the enhanced inhibitory effect of opioid receptor activation in the presence of yohimbine is not found for all opioid receptors.     

Selective activation of opioid receptors differentially affects lordosis behavior in female rats

The effects of opioid peptides that are highly selective ligands for mu receptors (morphiceptin). delta receptors (delta-receptor peptide), kappa receptors (dynorphin 1-9), and the mu/delta complex (beta-endorphin), were tested on lordosis behavior in ovariectomized rats primed with estrogen and progesterone. Intracerebroventricular infusions of beta-endorphin or morphiceptin both inhibited and facilitated lordosis in a dose-dependent fashion whereas all doses of delta-receptor peptide facilitated lordosis. Dynorphin 1-9 had no significant effect at any dose, although a trend toward increased lordosis quotients was observed 30 min after infusion. The effects of beta-endorphin, morphiceptin, and delta-receptor peptide were reversed with naloxone, although naloxone alone had no effect on lordosis behavior. These results indicate that the specific activation of opioid receptor subtypes differentially affects lordosis behavior. It appears that binding to high-affinity mu 1 receptors exerts an inhibitory influence on lordosis, whereas binding to low-affinity mu 2 receptors or delta receptors exerts a facilitatory influence. Binding to kappa receptors does not appear to affect lordosis behavior.     

Development of a 3D pharmacophore for nonspecific ligand recognition of alpha1, alpha2, alpha3, alpha5, and alpha6 containing GABA(A)/benzodiazepine receptors

Transfected cells containing GABA(A) benzodiazepine receptors (BDZRs) have been utilized to systematically determine the affinity of ligands at alpha1, alpha2, alpha3, alpha5 and alpha6 subtypes in combination with beta2 and gamma2. All but a few of the ligands thus far studied have relatively high affinities for each of these alpha subtype receptors. Thus, these ligands must contain common stereochemical properties favorable for recognition by each of the subtype combinations. In the present work, such a common three-dimensional (3D) pharmacophore for recognition of alpha1, alpha2, alpha3, alpha5 and alpha6 containing GABA(A)/BDZRs types of receptors has been developed and assessed, using as a database receptor affinities measured in transfected cells for 27 diverse compounds. The 3D-recognition pharmacophore developed consists of three proton accepting groups, a hydrophobic group, and the centroid of an aromatic ring found in a common geometric arrangement in the 19 nonselective ligands used. Three tests were made to assess this pharmacophore: (i) Four low affinity compounds were used as negative controls, (ii) Four high affinity compounds, excluded from the pharmacophore development, were used as compounds for pharmacophore validation, (iii) The 3D pharmacophore was used to search 3D databases. The results of each of these types of assessments provided robust validation of the 3D pharmacophore. This 3D pharmacophore can now be used to discover novel nonselective ligands that could be activation selective at different behavioral end points. Additionally, it may serve as a guide in the design of more selective ligands, by determining if candidate ligands proposed for synthesis conform to this pharmacophore and selecting those that do not for further experimental assessment.     

In-vitro investigation of oxazol and urea analogues of morphinan at opioid receptors

A series of 2-amino-oxazole (7 and 8) analogs and 2-one-oxazole analogs (9 and 10) were synthesized from cyclorphan (1) or butorphan (2) and evaluated in-vitro by their binding affinity at mu, delta, and kappa opioid receptors and compared with their 2-aminothiozole analogs 5 and 6. Ligands 7-10 showed decreased affinities at kappa and mu receptors. Urea analogs (11-14) were also prepared from 2-aminocyclorphan (3) or 2-aminobutorphan (4) and evaluated in-vitro by their binding affinity at mu, delta, and kappa opioid receptors. The urea derived opioids retained their affinities at mu receptors while showing increased affinities at delta receptors and decreased affinities at kappa receptors. Functional activities of these compounds were measured in the [35S]GTPgammaS binding assay, illustrating that all of these ligands were kappa agonists. At the mu receptor, compounds 11 and 12 were mu agonist/antagonists.     

Use of hydrophilic diamines for bridging of two opioid peptide pharmacophores. Synthesis and receptor binding of two new analogues.

The bivalent ligand approach, which assumes that two pharmacophores are connected by a spacer, was used to design receptor type-selective ligands for opioid receptors. The first two opioid peptide bivalent ligands with different spacer lengths containing different numbers of hydroxyl groups, (Tyr-D-Ala-Gly-Phe-NH-CH2-CHOH-)2 (Tyr-D-Ala-Gly-Phe-NH-CH2-CHOH-CHOH-)2, were synthesized and their binding to mu, delta, and kappa opioid receptors was characterized. Both analogues were found to possess high opioid in vitro activities. The length of the hydrophilic spacer does not affect the affinity for delta receptors, whereas shorter spacer length increases affinity for mu and even more so for kappa receptors. Thus receptor type-selective peptides for opioid receptors can be designed using the bivalent approach.     

Spinal administration of selective opioid antagonists in amphibians: evidence for an opioid unireceptor

In mammals, opioids act by interactions with three distinct types of receptors: mu, delta, or kappa opioid receptors. Using a novel assay of antinociception in the Northern grass frog, Rana pipiens, previous work demonstrated that selective mu, delta, or kappa opioids produced a potent antinociception when administered by the spinal route. The relative potency of this effect was highly correlated to that found in mammals. Present studies employing selective opioid antagonists, beta-FNA, NTI, or nor-BNI demonstrated that, in general, these antagonists were not selective in the amphibian model. These data have implications for the functional evolution of opioid receptors in vertebrates and suggest that the tested mu, delta, and kappa opioids mediate antinociception via a single type of opioid receptor in amphibians, termed the unireceptor.     

Pyrrolo- and pyridomorphinans: Non-selective opioid antagonists and delta opioid agonists/mu opioid partial agonists

Opioid ligands have found use in a number of therapeutic areas, including for the treatment of pain and opiate addiction (using agonists) and alcohol addiction (using antagonists such as naltrexone and nalmefene). The reaction of imines, derived from the opioid ligands oxymorphone and naltrexone, with Michael acceptors leads to pyridomorphinans with structures similar to known pyrrolo- and indolomorphinans. One of the synthesized compounds, 5e, derived from oxymorphone had substantial agonist activity at delta opioid receptors but not at mu and/or kappa opioid receptors and in that sense profiled as a selective delta opioid receptor agonist. The pyridomorphinans derived from naltrexone and naloxone were all found to be non-selective potent antagonists and as such could have utility as treatments for alcohol abuse.     

Inhibition of mu and delta but not kappa opioid binding to membranes by Fab fragments from a monoclonal antibody directed against the opioid receptor

Fab fragments from a monoclonal antibody, OR-689.2.4, directed against the opioid receptor, selectively inhibited opioid binding to rat and guinea pig neural membranes. In a titratable manner, the Fab fragments noncompetitively inhibited the binding of the mu selective peptide [D-Ala2,(Me)Phe4,Gly(OH)5][3H] enkephalin and the delta selective peptide [D-Pen2,D-Pen5] [3H]enkephalin (where Pen represents penicillamine) to neural membranes. In contrast, kappa opioid binding, as measured by the binding of [3H]bremazocine to rat neural membranes and guinea pig cerebellum in the presence of mu and delta blockers, was not significantly altered by the Fab fragments. In addition to blocking the binding of mu and delta ligands, the Fab fragments displaced bound opioids from the membranes. When mu sites were blocked with [D-Ala2,(Me)Phe4,Gly(OH)5]enkephalin, the Fab fragments suppressed the binding of [D-Pen2,D-Pen5][3H]enkephalin to the same degree as when the mu binding site was not blocked. The Fab fragments also inhibited binding to the mu site regardless of whether or not the delta site was blocked with [D-Pen2,D-Pen5]enkephalin. This monoclonal antibody is directed against a 35,000-dalton protein. Since the antibody is able to inhibit mu and delta binding but not kappa opioid binding, it appears that this 35,000-dalton protein is an integral component of mu and delta opioid receptors but not kappa receptors.     

Complementarity of delta opioid ligand pharmacophore and receptor models

The elaboration of a pharmacophore model for the delta opioid receptor selective ligand JOM-13 (Tyr-c[D-Cys-Phe-D-Pen]OH) and the parallel, independent development of a structural model of the delta receptor are summarized. Although the backbone conformation of JOM-13's tripeptide cycle is well defined, considerable conformational lability is evident in the Tyr(1) residue and in the Phe(3) side chain, key pharmacophore elements of the ligand. Replacement of these flexible features of the ligand by more conformationally restricted analogues and subsequent correlation of receptor binding and conformational properties allowed the number of possible binding conformations of JOM-13 to be reduced to two. Of these, one was chosen as more likely, based on its better superposition with other conformationally constrained delta receptor ligands. Our model of the delta opioid receptor, constructed using a general approach that we have developed for all rhodopsin-like G protein-coupled receptors, contains a large cavity within the transmembrane domain that displays excellent complementarity in both shape and polarity to JOM-13 and other delta ligands. This binding pocket, however, cannot accommodate the conformer of JOM-13 preferred from analysis of ligands, alone. Rather, only the "alternate" allowed conformer, identified from analysis of the ligands but "disfavored" because it does not permit simultaneous superposition of all pharmacophore elements of JOM-13 with other delta ligands, fits the binding site. These results argue against a simple view of a single, common fit to a receptor binding site and suggest, instead, that at least some binding site interactions of different ligands may differ.     

A very high affinity opioid binding site in rat brain: demonstration by computer modeling

We present substantial new evidence for at least four distinct types of opioid receptors in rat brain, using quantitative ligand binding studies and mathematical modeling. Three of these binding sites are consistent with the well established "mu", "delta" and "kappa" receptors. The fourth has two distinctive features: 1) extremely high affinity (dissociation constant less than 1 nM); 2) almost complete lack of specificity for the classical "delta" or "mu" selective ligands. These properties are consistent with the putative "mu1" receptor described by Pasternak and coworkers.     

Exploring the unique pharmacology of a novel opioid receptor, ZFOR1, using molecular modeling and the 'message-address' concept.

Previous studies have probed the structural basis of ligand selectivity in the mu, delta and kappa opioid receptors through the application of molecular modeling techniques in concert with the 'message-address' concept. Here, this approach was used in an attempt to rationalize the unique pharmacological profile of a recently cloned novel opioid receptor, ZFOR1 (ZebraFish Opioid Receptor 1). Specifically, a model of the transmembrane domains of ZFOR1 was constructed and used to explore the binding modes of various prototypical opioid ligands. The results show that the 'message' portion of the binding pocket of ZFOR1 is highly conserved; hence, the binding modes of non-selective opioid ligands are well preserved. In contrast, a small number of variant residues at the extracellular end of the binding pocket, particularly Lys288 (VI:26) and Trp304 (VII:03), are shown to create adverse steric interactions with all delta and kappa selective ligands examined, thereby disrupting their binding modes. These results are consistent with, and serve as an explanation for, the observed pharmacology of this receptor, lending support to both the validity of the 'message-address' concept itself and to the use of molecular modeling approaches in its application.     

Opioid receptor-coupled second messenger systems

Although pharmacological data provide strong evidence for different types of opioid receptors (e.g., mu, delta, and kappa), they share many common properties in their ability to couple to second messenger systems. All opioid receptor types are coupled to G-proteins, since agonist binding is diminished by guanine nucleotides and agonist-stimulated GTPase activity has been identified in several preparations. Moreover, all three types inhibit adenylyl cyclase. This second messenger system has been identified for opioid receptors in both isolated brain membranes and in transformed cell culture. Studies with chronic treatment with opioid agonists suggest that the coupling of receptors with G-proteins and second messenger effectors may play important roles in development of opioid tolerance.     

Desipramine modulation of sigma and opioid peptide receptor expression in glial cells.

Exposure of C6 glial cell cultures to desipramine induced the appearance of opioid receptors and up-regulated sigma receptors. Opioid binding was demonstrated with 3H-etorphine and 3H-dihydromorphine (DHM), but was not observed with the mu, delta and kappa ligands 3H-DAMGE, 3H-DADLE or 3H-(-)ethylketocyclazocine in the presence of specific blockers, respectively. Competition experiments with 3H-DHM and either (-)naloxone or (+)naloxone indicated the presence of authentic opioid receptors. In similar studies with beta-endorphin, its truncated form (1-27) or their N-acetyl derivatives, beta-endorphin proved to have the highest affinity. Opioid receptors in glial cell aggregates were primarily kappa, with few mu and delta sites. Desipramine increased Bmax values for kappa but not mu and delta.