The impact of polyadenylation signals on plasmid nuclease-resistance and transgene expression

BACKGROUND: Efficient delivery and expression of plasmids (pDNA) is a major concern in gene therapy and DNA vaccination using non-viral vectors. Besides the use of adjuvants, the pDNA vector itself can be designed to maximize survival in nuclease-rich environments. Homopurine-rich tracts in polyadenylation sequences have been previously shown to be especially important in pDNA resistance. METHODOLOGY: The effect of modifications in the poly A sequence of a model pDNA vector (pVAX1GFP) on nuclease resistance and transgene expression was investigated. Four poly A sequences were studied: bovine growth hormone (BGH), mutant BGH, SV40 and a synthetic poly A. Plasmid resistance (half-life) was assessed through in vitro incubations with mammalian nucleases. The impact in transgene expression was studied by quantifying pDNA, mRNA, and GFP expression in CHO, hybridoma and HeLa cells. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: In vitro and cell culture studies indicate that plasmids containing the SV40 and the synthetic poly A sequences present significant improvements in nuclease resistance (up to two-fold increase in half-life). However, RT-PCR analysis demonstrated that significant reduction in mRNA steady-state levels were responsible for a decrease in transgene expression and detected transfection level of CHO and hybridoma cells when using the more resistant plasmids. Interestingly, transfection of HeLa cells demonstrated that both poly A efficiency and plasmid resistance interfere significantly in transgene expression. The results strongly suggest that the choice of the poly A is important, not only for mRNA maturation/stability, but also for pDNA resistance, and should thus be taken into consideration in the design and evaluation of pDNA vectors.     

Nondisruptive, sequence-specific coupling of fluorochromes to plasmid DNA

A method to attach a fluorochrome sequence-specifically to supercoiled plasmid DNA (pDNA) without perturbing transgene expression would provide an invaluable aid in a variety of applications requiring probes for the intracellular tracking of transfected pDNA. Here we report a method to couple commercially available fluorochromes covalently and sequence-specifically to pDNA using a peptide nucleic acid (PNA) as a linker molecule. The terminal cysteine thiol group on the PNA peptide backbone is reacted with a maleimide moiety on the fluorochrome to produce a fluorescent conjugate which is in turn hybridized to a plasmid expression vector containing an 11-bp target sequence. Spectroscopic evaluation and an electrophoretic mobility shift assay showed that the pDNA hybridized to one PNA-fluorochrome conjugate molecule. The fluorescence signal comigrated with pDNA on acrylamide gels, confirming the stable attachment of the fluorescent conjugate to the pDNA. The utility of one of the conjugates, PNA-Oregon green 488/pCMVbeta-DTS, to probe pDNA transport across the nuclear envelope, a significant barrier to gene transfer, was undertaken using a digitonin-permeabilized HeLa cell assay. The PNA-Oregon green 488/pCMVbeta-DTS conjugate is able to efficiently traverse the nuclear membrane of the permeabilized cells, accumulating in the nuclei within 30 min and reaching maximal levels by 1h. When transfected into HeLa cells, the PNA-Oregon green 488/pCMVbeta-DTS conjugate retained 55% of the native plasmid's biological activity, as determined by a beta-galactosidase assay. Thus, this method allows for the sequence-specific coupling of commercially available fluorochromes to DNA expression vectors while retaining biological function.     

Plasmid DNA purification

The demand for efficient production methods of plasmid DNA (pDNA) has increased vastly in response to rapid advances in the use of pDNA in gene therapy and in vaccines since the advantageous safety concerns associated with non-viral over viral vectors.A prerequisite for the success of plasmid-based therapies is the development of cost-effective and generic production processes of pDNA. However, to satisfy strict regulatory guidelines, the material must be available as highly purified, homogeneous preparations of supercoiled circular covalently closed (ccc) pDNA. Large-scale production of pDNA for therapeutic use is a relatively new field in bioprocessing. The shift from small-scale plasmid production for cell transfection to large-scale production sets new constraints on the bacterial fermentation, processing of bacterial lysate and final purification and formulation of the plasmid DNA. The choice of bacterial strain used for plasmid cultivation affects the plasmid yield, the proportion of different isoforms and the amount of endotoxins in the starting material. The choice of bacterial strain will be greatly influenced by the production and purification procedures of pDNA. Master and working cell banks need to be characterised and established. Alkaline lysis of the bacteria damages the pDNA, resulting in a reduced recovery of ccc pDNA and an increase in partially denaturated ccc pDNA and open circular (oc) forms. Shear stress in these processes needs to be tightly controlled, and buffer composition and pH need to be optimised. To obtain a homogeneous plasmid DNA preparation, different pDNA purification strategies aim at capturing ccc pDNA and eliminating the oc isoform. A highly purified final product corresponding to the stringent recommendations set forth by health and regulatory authorities can be achieved by (i). different chromatography techniques integrated with ultra/diafiltration to achieve optimal purification results; (ii). the formulation of the final pDNA product, that requires a detailed study of the plasmid structure; and (iii). the development of sensitive analytical methods to detect different impurities (proteins, RNA, chromosomal DNA, and endotoxins). We present here a revue of the whole process to obtain such a plasmid DNA, and report an example of RNAse-free purification of ccc pDNA that could be used for gene therapy.     

Specific berenil-DNA interactions: an approach for separation of plasmid isoforms by pseudo-affinity chromatography

Small molecules, like some antibiotics and anticancer agents that bind DNA with high specificity, can represent a relevant alternative as ligands in affinity processes for plasmid DNA (pDNA) purification. In the current study, pDNA binding affinities of berberine, berenil, kanamycin, and neomycin were evaluated by a competitive displacement assay with ethidium bromide using a fluorimetric titration technique. The binding between pDNA and ethidium bromide was tested in different buffer conditions, varying the type and the salt concentration, and was performed in both the absence and presence of the studied compounds. The results showed that the minor groove binder berenil has the higher pDNA binding constant. Chromatographic experiments using a derivatized column with berenil as ligand showed a total retention of pDNA using 1.3 M ammonium sulfate in eluent buffer. A selective separation of supercoiled and open circular isoforms was achieved by further decreasing the salt concentration to 0.6 M and then to 0 M. These results suggest a promising application of berenil as ligand for specific purification of pDNA supercoiled isoform by pseudo-affinity chromatography.     

Specific recognition of supercoiled plasmid DNA in arginine affinity chromatography

Arginine chromatography was used to fully separate supercoiled and open circular plasmid DNA (pDNA) isoforms. The results show that the arginine matrix promotes multiple interactions with pDNA, including not only electrostatic and hydrophobic but also biorecognition of nucleotide bases by the arginine ligand. The strong interactions occurring with DNA backbone provide stability, conducting to high effectiveness of arginine support to bind pDNA at low ionic strength. The specific interaction of arginine with sc pDNA could be due to the ability of arginine matrix to be involved in complex interactions that are partly dependent on the conformation of the DNA molecule.     

Formulation and in vitro transfection efficiency of poly (D, L-lactideco-glycolide) microspheres containing plasmid DNA for gene delivery

The stability, in vitro release, and in vitro cell transfection efficiency of plasmid DNA (pDNA) poly (D,L.-lactide-co-glycolide) (PLGA) microsphere formulations were investigated. PLGA microspheres containing free and polylysine (PLL)-complexed pDNA were prepared by a water-oil-water solvent extraction/evaporation technique. Encapsulation enhanced the retention of the supereoiled structure of pDNA as determined by gel electrophoresis. PLL complexation of pDNA prior to encapsulation increased both the stability of the supercoiled form and the encapsulation efficiency. Free pDNA was completely degraded after exposure to DNase while encapsulation protected the pDNA from enzymatic degradation. Rapid initial in vitro release of pDNA was obtained from microspheres containing free pDNA. while the release from microspheres containing PLL-complexed pDNA was sustained for more than 42 days. Bioactivity of encapsulated pDNA determined by in vitro cell transfection using Chinese hamster ovary cells (CHO) showed that the bioactivity of encapsulated pDNA was retained in both formulations but to a greater extent with PLL-complexed pDNA microspheres. These results demonstrated that PLGA microspheres could be used to formulate a controlledrelease delivery system for pDNA that can protect the pDNA from DNase degradation without loss of functional activity.     

Separation of supercoiled from open circular forms of plasmid DNA,and biological activity detection

To establish a cost-effective purification process for the large-scale production of plasmid DNA for gene therapy and DNA vaccination, a single anion-exchange chromatography (AEC) step was employed to purify supercoiled plasmid DNA (sc pDNA) from other isoforms and Escherichia coli impurities present in a clarified lysate. Two different size and conformation plasmids were used as model targets, and showed similar elution behavior in this chromatographic operation, in which sc pDNA was effectively separated from open circle plasmid DNA (oc pDNA) in a salt gradient. The process delivered high-purity pDNA of homogeneity of 95 ± 1.1% and almost undetectable levels of endotoxins, genomic DNA, RNA and protein, at a yield of 65 ± 8%. Furthermore, the transfection efficiency (29 ± 0.4%) was significantly higher than that (20 ± 0.1%) of a pDNA control. The present study confirms the possibility of using a single AEC step to purify sc pDNA from other isoforms and host contaminants present in a clarified E. coli lysate.     

On the stability of plasmid DNA vectors during cell culture and purification

Gene therapy and DNA vaccination applications have increased the demand for highly purified plasmid DNA (pDNA) in the last years. One of the main problems related to the scale-up of pDNA purification is the degradation of the supercoiled (sc) isoforms during cell culture and multi-stage purification. In this work, a systematic study of the stability of two model plasmids (3,697 and 6,050 bp) during a mid-scale production process, which includes fermentation, alkaline lysis, isopropanol and ammonium sulphate precipitation and hydrophobic interaction chromatography, was performed. Results indicate that by extending cell culture (up to 26 h) and cell lysis (up to 2 h) it is possible to significantly reduce the amounts of RNA, without significantly compromising the yields of the sc pDNA isoform, a feature that could be conveniently exploited for downstream processing purposes. The stability of pDNA upon storage of E. coli pellets at different temperatures indicates that, differently from RNA, pDNA is remarkably stable when stored in cell pellets (>3 weeks at 4°C, >12 weeks at −20°C) prior to processing. With alkaline lysates, however, storage at −20°C is mandatory to avoid sc pDNA degradation within the first 8 weeks. Furthermore, the subsequent purification steps could be carried out at room temperature without significant pDNA degradation. Since the unit operations and process conditions studied in this work are similar to those generally used for plasmid DNA production, the results presented here may contribute to improve the current knowledge on plasmid stability and process optimization. Authors Freitas and Azzoni contributed equally to this work.     

Role of endonuclease G in exogenous DNA stability in HeLa cells

Endonuclease G (EndoG) is a well-conserved mitochondrial-nuclear nuclease with dual lethal and vital roles in the cell. The aim of our study was to examine whether EndoG exerts its nuclease activity on exogenous DNA substrates such as plasmid DNA (pDNA), considering their importance in gene therapy applications. The effects of EndoG knockdown on pDNA stability and levels of encoded reporter gene expression were evaluated in the cervical carcinoma HeLa cells. Transfection of pDNA vectors encoding short-hairpin RNAs (shRNAs) reduced levels of EndoG mRNA in HeLa cells. In physiological circumstances, EndoG knockdown did not have an effect on the stability of pDNA or the levels of encoded transgene expression as measured over a four-day time course. However, when endogenous expression of EndoG was induced by an extrinsic stimulus, targeting of EndoG by shRNA improved the perceived stability and transgene expression of pDNA vectors. Therefore, EndoG is not a mediator of exogenous DNA clearance, but in non-physiological circumstances, it may nonspecifically cleave intracellular DNA regardless of its origin. These findings make it unlikely that targeting of EndoG is a viable strategy for improving the duration and level of transgene expression from nonviral DNA vectors in gene therapy efforts.     

Cloning of bovine growth hormone gene and its expression in bacteria.

A hybrid plasmid was constructed containing beta-lactamase gene of plasmid pBR322 and cloned coding sequences of bovine growth hormone (BGH). The constructed plasmid contains all DNA sequences required to encode BGH, and when used as a hybridization probe it detects one growth hormone gene in the bovine genome. The cloned DNA sequences are inserted into the beta-lactamase gene in the correct reading frame for BGH synthesis. The hybrid gene is expressed in bacteria and the product, a fused beta-lactamase-bovine growth hormone protein, is specifically immunoprecipitated with anti-serum to BGH. Unlike beta-lactamase, very little growth hormone containing sequences can be detected in the periplasmic space.     

Sequence specific cleavage of DNA by micrococcal nuclease.

Micrococcal nuclease is shown to cleave DNA under conditions of partial digestion in a specific manner. Sequences of the type 5'CATA and 5'CTA are attacked preferentially, followed by exonucleolytic degradation at the newly generated DNA termini. GC-rich flanking sequences further increase the probability of initial attack. Unexpectedly, long stretches containing only A and T are spared by the nuclease. These results, which were obtained with spared by the nuclease. These results, which were obtained with mouse satellite DNA and two fragments from the plasmid pBR22, do not support the previous contention that it is the regions of high At-content which are initially cleaved by micrococcal nuclease. This specificity of micrococcal nuclease complicates its use in experiments intended to monitor the nucleoprotein structure of a DNA sequence in chromatin.     

Identification and characterization of a conserved nuclease secreted by strains of the Lactobacillus casei group

AIMS: Nuclease secretion was evaluated for five species of Lactobacillus and the activity was characterized in terms of thermal resistance, molecular weight and mode of action on plasmid DNA. METHODS AND RESULTS: Assays of nuclease from L. rhamnosus ATCC 9595 on DNA of different origins indicates a broad activity spectrum. Secreted nuclease from this strain resists a thermal treatment of 20 min at 100 degrees C, is not sensitive to a treatment for disruption of disulphide bonds nor to EDTA treatment under 10 mM l(-1). Nuclease production is not growth linked and seems to be constitutive. Extracellular nuclease of L. rhamnosus ATCC 9595 introduces a single-stranded nick in supercoiled DNA, thus potentially reducing the transformability of plasmid DNA. In seven of eight tested strains, SDS-PAGE revealed a major protein with a molecular weight of ca 35 kDa. Minor degradation products also showed nuclease activity. CONCLUSIONS: A comparative analysis of the extracellular fractions of 14 different Lactobacillus strains indicate that nuclease secretion seems to be a widely distributed function among species of milk-related lactobacilli. The production of secreted nuclease may contribute to the low ability of Lactobacillus spp. to be transformed and maintain exogenous DNA. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Determination of the characteristics and distribution of nuclease activity contribute to developing strategies to overcome this barrier to efficient transformation of milk lactobacilli.     

Supercoil-stabilized left-handed DNA in the plasmid (dA-dT)16 insert formed in the presence of Ni2+

The (dA-dT)16 insert of the plasmid pAT32 was probed with diethyl pyrocarbonate (DEPC) and nuclease Bal3l in the presence of Ni2+ known to be able to induce transition to left-handed conformation in the synthetic poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-T). It has been shown that this insert in a supercoiled plasmid displays a DEPC modification pattern characteristic of left-handed DNA under conditions not sufficient to induce a left-handed structure in the linear plasmid and poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-T).     

Analysis of Z-DNA in fixed polytene chromosomes with monoclonal antibodies that show base sequence-dependent selectivity in reactions with supercoiled plasmids and polynucleotides

Five monoclonal anti-Z-DNA antibodies were characterized with respect to their binding of synthetic nucleic acid polymers and of supercoiled circular plasmid DNA. All of the antibodies reacted only with DNA in the Z-conformation; however, they fell into two classes on the basis of sequence specificity. One class, with broad specificity, reacted well with all sequences in the Z-form, including poly(dG-dC), poly(dG-dm5C), and poly (dG-dBr5C) in linear polymers and poly(dG-dC)n and poly[(dC-dA)n.(dT-dG)n] sequences in supercoiled plasmids. The other class bound only Z-DNA formed by poly(dG-dC). Binding of the monoclonal antibodies specifically to inserts of Z-DNA-forming sequences in plasmids was mapped directly by cross-linking of antibody to the DNA, digestion with restriction nuclease, and electrophoretic analysis of both the unbound fragments and the bound fragments recovered from immune complexes. The monoclonal antibodies were used for indirect immunofluorescence staining of Drosophila polytene chromosomes fixed by two procedures. One procedure yielded chromosomes with Z-specific antibody binding in many interbands, a few specific bands, and parts of some puffs. On chromosomes fixed by the second procedure, antibody staining appeared to follow the DNA concentration, staining all bands brightly. For each fixation procedure, chromosomes showed the same staining pattern with each of the broad specificity monoclonal antibodies that had been seen with polyclonal antibodies. The antibodies that reacted only with poly(dG-dC) and poly (dG-dC)n plasmid inserts did not stain chromosomes fixed by either protocol. We conclude that stretches of poly(dG-dC)n sequences do not contribute significantly to the presence of Z-DNA in fixed polytene chromosomes of Drosophila melanogaster.     

Enhanced resistance to nuclease degradation of nucleic acids complexed to asialoglycoprotein-polylysine carriers.

We have previously shown targeting of DNA to hepatocytes using an asialoorosomucoid-polylysine (AsOR-PL) carrier system. The AsOR-PL conjugate condenses DNA and facilitates entry via specific receptor-ligand interactions. In these studies, our objective was to determine if AsOR-PL conjugates protect bound DNA from nuclease attack. Double-stranded plasmid or single-stranded oligonucleotide DNA, alone or bound to conjugate, was incubated under conditions mimicking those encountered during in vitro and in vivo transfections. The results showed that complexed DNA was effectively protected from degradation by serum nucleases. Degradation of single-stranded oligonucleotides was inhibited 3- to 6-fold in serum during 5 hours of incubation. For complexed plasmids, greater than 90% remained full-length during 1.5 and 3 hour incubations in serum or culture medium containing 10% serum, respectively. Uncomplexed plasmid was completely degraded after 15 minutes in serum or 60 minutes in medium. In cell lysates, the conjugate was not effective in inhibiting endonuclease activity; plasmids were readily converted from supercoiled to open circular and linear forms. However, the resultant nicked forms were substantially protected from further degradation during one hour of incubation compared to plasmid alone. Under all conditions complexed DNA did not readily dissociate from the conjugate. Overall, for both single and double-stranded DNA, AsOR-PL conjugates conferred substantial protection from nuclease degradation.     

Circular dichroism investigation of the effect of plasmid DNA structure on retention in histidine chromatography

The effect of temperature-induced changes in secondary and tertiary structures of plasmid DNA (pDNA) and on the retention behaviour of open circular (oc) and supercoiled (sc) isoforms in histidine-agarose chromatography was investigated by Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy. Chromatographic experiments performed with three plasmids (2.7, 6.1 and 7.4 kbp) and with a decreasing ammonium sulphate gradient (2.3--2.0 M) showed that the retention of sc pDNA increased as temperature decreased from 24 to 5 °C. Such behaviour was attributed to the temperature-induced removal of negative superhelical turns in sc pDNA which is accompanied by a decrease in the number of dissociated base pairs responsible for interaction with the histidine ligands. CD spectroscopy showed that temperature has an important effect on plasmid secondary structure if adenine-rich inserts are present in the plasmid structure. Chromatographic experiments also suggested that base composition could also be responsible for the induction of specific interactions with histidine ligands.     

Interarm interaction of DNA cruciform forming at a short inverted repeat sequence

A novel interarm interaction of DNA cruciform forming at inverted repeat sequence was characterized using an S1 nuclease digestion, permanganate oxidation, and microscopic imaging. An inverted repeat consisting of 17 bp complementary sequences was isolated from the bluegill sunfish Lepomis macrochirus (Perciformes) and subcloned into the pUC19 plasmid, after which the supercoiled recombinant plasmid was subjected to enzymatic and chemical modification. In high salt conditions (200 mM NaCl, or 100-200 mM KCl), S1 nuclease cut supercoiled DNA at the center of palindromic symmetry, suggesting the formation of DNA cruciform. On the other hand, S1 nuclease in the presence of 150 mM NaCl or less cleaved mainly the 3'-half of the repeat, thereby forming an unusual structure in which the 3'-half of the inverted repeat, but not the 5'-half, was retained as an unpaired strand. Permanganate oxidation profiles also supported the presence of single-stranded part in the 3'-half of the inverted repeat in addition to the center of the symmetry. Both electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy have detected a thick protrusion on the supercoiled DNA harboring the inverted repeat. We hypothesize that the cruciform hairpins at conditions favoring triplex formation adopt a parallel side-by-side orientation of the arms allowing the interaction between them supposedly stabilized by hydrogen bonding of base triads.     

Efficient uptake and rapid degradation of plasmid DNA by murine dendritic cells via a specific mechanism

In spite of the important roles of dendritic cells in DNA-based therapies, the cellular uptake mechanism of plasmid DNA (pDNA) in dendritic cells is poorly understood. The present study was undertaken to investigate the binding and uptake of pDNA in vitro using a murine dendritic cell line, DC2.4 cells. A significant and time-dependent cellular association of [32P]pDNA with DC2.4 cells was observed at 37 degrees C and this fell markedly at 4 degrees C. The binding and uptake of [32P]pDNA were significantly inhibited by cold pDNA, polyinosinic acid (poly[I]), dextran sulfate, or heparin, but not by polycytidylic acid (poly[C]), dextran, or EDTA, suggesting that a specific mechanism mediated by a receptor like the macrophage scavenger receptor may be involved. The TCA precipitation experiments showed that DC2.4 cells rapidly endocytosed and degraded a significant amount of [32P]pDNA at 37 degrees C and released the degradation products into the medium. The pDNA degradation was also significantly inhibited by poly[I], but not poly[C]. The rate of pDNA degradation by DC2.4 cells was significantly higher than that by macrophages. A confocal microscopic study using fluorescein-labeled pDNA confirmed the rapid internalization and degradation of pDNA by the dendritic cells. Taken together, these results indicate that pDNA is efficiently taken up and rapidly digested by the dendritic cells via a specific mechanism. These findings may suggest the important role of the dendritic cells in the innate immune system for host defense.     

Screening of l‐histidine‐based ligands to modify monolithic supports and selectively purify the supercoiled plasmid DNA isoform

The growing demand of pharmaceutical‐grade plasmid DNA (pDNA) suitable for biotherapeutic applications fostered the development of new purification strategies. The surface plasmon resonance technique was employed for a fast binding screening of l ‐histidine and its derivatives, 1‐benzyl‐l ‐histidine and 1‐methyl‐l ‐histidine, as potential ligands for the biorecognition of three plasmids with different sizes (6.05, 8.70, and 14 kbp). The binding analysis was performed with different isoforms of each plasmid (supercoiled, open circular, and linear) separately. The results revealed that the overall affinity of plasmids to l ‐histidine and its derivatives was high (K_D > 10⁻⁸ M), and the highest affinity was found for human papillomavirus 16 E6/E7 (K_D = 1.1 × 10⁻¹⁰ M and K_D = 3.34 × 10⁻¹⁰ M for open circular and linear plasmid isoforms, respectively). l ‐Histidine and 1‐benzyl‐l ‐histidine were immobilized on monolithic matrices. Chromatographic studies of l ‐histidine and 1‐benzyl‐l ‐histidine monoliths were also performed with the aforementioned samples. In general, the supercoiled isoform had strong interactions with both supports. The separation of plasmid isoforms was achieved by decreasing the ammonium sulfate concentration in the eluent, in both supports, but a lower salt concentration was required in the 1‐benzyl‐l ‐histidine monolith because of stronger interactions promoted with pDNA. The efficiency of plasmid isoforms separation remained unchanged with flow rate variations. The binding capacity for pDNA achieved with the l ‐histidine monolith was 29‐fold higher than that obtained with conventional l ‐histidine agarose. Overall, the combination of either l ‐histidine or its derivatives with monolithic supports can be a promising strategy to purify the supercoiled isoform from different plasmids with suitable purity degree for pharmaceutical applications. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.