Acyl carrier protein/SpoT interaction, the switch linking SpoT-dependent stress response to fatty acid metabolism

Bacteria respond to nutritional stresses by producing an intracellular alarmone, guanosine 5'-(tri)diphosphate, 3'-diphosphate [(p)ppGpp], which triggers the stringent response resulting in growth arrest and expression of resistance genes. In Escherichia coli, upon fatty acid or carbon starvation, SpoT enzyme activity switches from (p)ppGpp degradation to (p)ppGpp synthesis, but the signal and mechanism for this response remain totally unknown. Here, we characterize for the first time a physical interaction between SpoT and acyl carrier protein (ACP) using affinity co-purifications and two-hybrid in E. coli. ACP, as a central cofactor in fatty acid synthesis, may be an ideal candidate as a mediator signalling starvation to SpoT. Accordingly, we show that the ACP/SpoT interaction is specific of SpoT and ACP functions because ACP does not interact with the homologous RelA protein and because SpoT does not interact with a non-functional ACP. Using truncated SpoT fusion proteins, we demonstrate further that ACP binds the central TGS domain of SpoT, consistent with a role in regulation. The behaviours of SpoT point mutants that do not interact with ACP reveal modifications of the balance between the two opposite SpoT catalytic activities thereby changing (p)ppGpp levels. More importantly, these mutants fail to trigger (p)ppGpp accumulation in response to fatty acid synthesis inhibition, supporting the hypothesis that the ACP/SpoT interaction may be involved in SpoT-dependent stress response. This leads us to propose a model in which ACP carries information describing the status of cellular fatty acid metabolism, which in turn can trigger the conformational switch in SpoT leading to (p)ppGpp accumulation.     

Bacteria possessing two RelA/SpoT-like proteins have evolved a specific stringent response involving the acyl carrier protein-SpoT interaction

Bacteria respond to nutritional stress by producing (p)ppGpp, which triggers a stringent response resulting in growth arrest and expression of resistance genes. In Escherichia coli, RelA produces (p)ppGpp upon amino acid starvation by detecting stalled ribosomes. The SpoT enzyme responds to various other types of starvation by unknown mechanisms. We previously described an interaction between SpoT and the central cofactor of lipid synthesis, acyl carrier protein (ACP), which is involved in detecting starvation signals in lipid metabolism and triggering SpoT-dependent (p)ppGpp accumulation. However, most bacteria possess a unique protein homologous to RelA/SpoT (Rsh) that is able to synthesize and degrade (p)ppGpp and is therefore more closely related to SpoT function. In this study, we asked if the ACP-SpoT interaction is specific for bacteria containing two RelA and SpoT enzymes or if it is a general feature that is conserved in Rsh enzymes. By testing various combinations of SpoT, RelA, and Rsh enzymes and ACPs of E. coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Bacillus subtilis and Streptococcus pneumoniae, we found that the interaction between (p)ppGpp synthases and ACP seemed to be restricted to SpoT proteins of bacteria containing the two RelA and SpoT proteins and to ACP proteins encoded by genes located in fatty acid synthesis operons. When Rsh enzymes from B. subtilis and S. pneumoniae are produced in E. coli, the behavior of these enzymes is different from the behavior of both RelA and SpoT proteins with respect to (p)ppGpp synthesis. This suggests that bacteria have evolved several different modes of (p)ppGpp regulation in order to respond to nutrient starvation.     

G-protein control of the ribosome-associated stress response protein SpoT

The bacterial response to stress is controlled by two proteins, RelA and SpoT. RelA generates the alarmone (p)ppGpp under amino acid starvation, whereas SpoT is responsible for (p)ppGpp hydrolysis and for synthesis of (p)ppGpp under a variety of cellular stress conditions. It is widely accepted that RelA is associated with translating ribosomes. The cellular location of SpoT, however, has been controversial. SpoT physically interacts with the ribosome-associated GTPase CgtA, and we show here that, under an optimized salt condition, SpoT is also associated with a pre-50S particle. Analysis of spoT and cgtA mutants and strains overexpressing CgtA suggests that the ribosome associations of SpoT and CgtA are mutually independent. The steady-state level of (p)ppGpp is increased in a cgtA mutant, but the accumulation of (p)ppGpp during amino acid starvation is not affected, providing strong evidence that CgtA regulates the (p)ppGpp level during exponential growth but not during the stringent response. We show that CgtA is not associated with pre-50S particles during amino acid starvation, indicating that under these conditions in which (p)ppGpp accumulates, CgtA is not bound either to the pre-50S particle or to SpoT. We propose that, in addition to its role as a 50S assembly factor, CgtA promotes SpoT (p)ppGpp degradation activity on the ribosome and that the loss of CgtA from the ribosome is necessary for maximal (p)ppGpp accumulation under stress conditions. Intriguingly, we found that in the absence of spoT and relA, cgtA is still an essential gene in Escherichia coli.     

Functional analysis of a relA/spoT gene homolog from Streptococcus equisimilis.

We examined the functional attributes of a gene encountered by sequencing the streptokinase gene region of Streptococcus equisimilis H46A. This gene, originally called rel, here termed relS. equisimilis, is homologous to two related Escherichia coli genes, spoT and relA, that function in the metabolism of guanosine 5',3'-polyphosphates [(p)ppGpp]. Studies with a variety of E. coli mutants led us to deduce that the highly expressed rel S. equisimilis gene encodes a strong (p)ppGppase and a weaker (p)ppGpp synthetic activity, much like the spoT gene, with a net effect favoring degradation and no complementation of the absence of the relA gene. We verified that the Rel S. equisimilis protein, purified from an E. coli relA spoT double mutant, catalyzed a manganese-activated (p)ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase reaction similar to that of the SpoT enzyme. This Rel S. equisimilis protein preparation also weakly catalyzed a ribosome-independent synthesis of (p)ppGpp by an ATP to GTP 3'-pyrophosphoryltransferase reaction when degradation was restricted by the absence of manganese ions. An analogous activity has been deduced for the SpoT protein from genetic evidence. In addition, the Rel S. equisimilis protein displays immunological cross-reactivity with polyclonal antibodies specific for SpoT but not for RelA. Despite assignment of rel S. equisimilis gene function in E. coli as being similar to that of the native spoT gene, disruptions of rel S. equisimilis in S. equisimilis abolish the parental (p)ppGpp accumulation response to amino acid starvation in a manner expected for relA mutants rather than spoT mutants.     

(p)ppGpp——“魔斑”核苷酸在细菌中的研究进展

鸟苷四磷酸（guanosine tetraphosphate,ppGpp）/鸟苷五磷酸（guanosine pentaphosphate,pppGpp）是细菌严谨反应的信号分子,其合成和水解由Rel/SpoT同系物（RelA/SpoT homologue,RSH）家族的蛋白质合成和水解活性控制。（p）ppGpp介导的严谨反应能够提高细菌对营养匮乏的适应能力和抗生素抗性。近年来发现（p）ppGpp与细菌生长和细胞分裂、抗生素合成等都密切相关,是细胞内重要的全局调控因子。（p）ppGpp在细菌细胞中有许多靶点,使其可以调节DNA复制、转录、细胞周期、核糖体生物合成以及抗生素合成基因簇的表达。然而,（p）ppGpp如何控制转录和其他代谢过程取决于细菌种类,并在不同的微生物中通过不同的机制调节相同的过程。因此,本文通过综述（p）ppGpp的合成/水解酶的种类和调节机制,（p）ppGpp对微生物代谢调控机制、对细胞周期的影响机制,以及（p）ppGpp对抗生素合成和耐受性的调控机制,为细菌耐药性研究和细胞生理学研究奠定基础。     

Mutational analysis of the Escherichia coli spoT gene identifies distinct but overlapping regions involved in ppGpp synthesis and degradation

The spoT gene of Escherichia coli encodes a guanosine 3′,5′-bis(diphosphate) 3′-pyrophosphohydrolase (ppGppase) as well as an apparent guanosine 3′,5′-bis(diphosphate) synthetase (designated PSII). To determine the regions of the SpoT protein that are required for these two competing activities, we analysed plasmid-borne deletion mutations for their ability to complement chromosomal mutations defective in each activity. We found that a region containing the first 203 amino acids of the 702-amino-acid SpoT protein was sufficient for ppGppase activity while an overlapping region containing residues 67–374 was sufficient for PSII activity. These data indicate that the catalytic sites involved in the two activities are separate but closely linked in the primary sequence of the SpoT protein. A ppGppase-defective Δ1–58 deletion mutant strain failed to synthesize ppGpp in response to nutrient limitation, also supporting the notion that PSII activity from wild-type SpoT does not increase in response to nutrient limitation. Using a strain lacking PSII activity but retaining ppGppase activity, we determined the contribution of the RelA protein (ppGpp synthetase I, PSI) to ppGpp synthesis following glucose starvation. We found that the RelA protein activity accounts for the initial burst of ppGpp synthesis at the onset of glucose starvation but that this source of synthesis is absent when amino acids are present during glucose starvation.     

Fatty acid starvation activates RelA by depleting lysine precursor pyruvate

Bacteria undergoing nutrient starvation induce the ubiquitous stringent response, resulting in gross physiological changes that reprograms cell metabolism from fast to slow growth. The stringent response is mediated by the secondary messengers pppGpp and ppGpp collectively referred to as (p)ppGpp or ‘alarmone’. In Escherichia coli, two paralogs, RelA and SpoT, synthesize (p)ppGpp. RelA is activated by amino acid starvation, whereas SpoT, which can also degrade (p)ppGpp, responds to fatty acid (FA), carbon and phosphate starvation. Here, we discover that FA starvation leads to rapid activation of RelA and reveal the underlying mechanism. We show that FA starvation leads to depletion of lysine that, in turn, leads to the accumulation of uncharged tRNA^Lys and activation of RelA. SpoT was also activated by FA starvation but to a lower level and with a delayed kinetics. Next, we discovered that pyruvate, a precursor of lysine, is depleted by FA starvation. We also propose a mechanism that explains how FA starvation leads to pyruvate depletion. Together our results raise the possibility that RelA may be a major player under many starvation conditions previously thought to depend principally on SpoT. Interestingly, FA starvation provoked a ~100‐fold increase in relA dependent ampicillin tolerance.     

Biochemical studies on Francisella tularensis RelA in (p)ppGpp biosynthesis

The bacterial stringent response is induced by nutrient deprivation and is mediated by enzymes of the RSH (RelA/SpoT homologue; RelA, (p)ppGpp synthetase I; SpoT, (p)ppGpp synthetase II) superfamily that control concentrations of the ‘alarmones’ (p)ppGpp (guanosine penta- or tetra-phosphate). This regulatory pathway is present in the vast majority of pathogens and has been proposed as a potential anti-bacterial target. Current understanding of RelA-mediated responses is based on biochemical studies using Escherichia coli as a model. In comparison, the Francisella tularensis RelA sequence contains a truncated regulatory C-terminal region and an unusual synthetase motif (EXSD). Biochemical analysis of F. tularensis RelA showed the similarities and differences of this enzyme compared with the model RelA from Escherichia coli. Purification of the enzyme yielded a stable dimer capable of reaching concentrations of 10 mg/ml. In contrast with other enzymes from the RelA/SpoT homologue superfamily, activity assays with F. tularensis RelA demonstrate a high degree of specificity for GTP as a pyrophosphate acceptor, with no measurable turnover for GDP. Steady state kinetic analysis of F. tularensis RelA gave saturation activity curves that best fitted a sigmoidal function. This kinetic profile can result from allosteric regulation and further measurements with potential allosteric regulators demonstrated activation by ppGpp (5′,3′-dibisphosphate guanosine) with an EC₅₀ of 60±1.9 μM. Activation of F. tularensis RelA by stalled ribosomal complexes formed with ribosomes purified from E. coli MRE600 was observed, but interestingly, significantly weaker activation with ribosomes isolated from Francisella philomiragia.     

Residual guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate synthetic activity of relA null mutants can be eliminated by spoT null mutations

It was known previously that 1) the relA gene of Escherichia coli encodes an enzyme capable of guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp) synthesis, 2) an uncharacterized source of ppGpp synthesis exists in relA null strains, and 3) cellular degradation of ppGpp is mainly due to a manganese-dependent ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase encoded by the spoT gene. Here, the effects of spoT gene insertions and deletions are compared with analogous alterations in neighboring genes in the spo operon and found to be lethal in relA+ strains as well as slower growing in relAl backgrounds than delta relA hosts. Cells with null alleles in both the relA and spoT genes are found no longer to accumulate ppGpp after glucose exhaustion or after chelation of manganese ions by picolinic acid addition; the inability to form ppGpp is reversed by a minimal spoT gene on a multicopy plasmid. Strains apparently lacking ppGpp show a complex phenotype including auxotrophy for several amino acids and morphological alterations. We propose that the SpoT protein can either catalyze or control the alternative pathway of ppGpp synthesis in addition to its known role as a (p)ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase. We favor the possibility that the SpoT protein is a bifunctional enzyme capable of catalyzing either ppGpp synthesis or degradation.     

The relA/spoT-Homologous Gene in Streptomyces coelicolor Encodes Both Ribosome-Dependent (p)ppGppSynthesizing and -Degrading Activities

Streptomyces coelicolor (p)ppGpp synthetase (Rel protein) belongs to the RelA and SpoT (RelA/SpoT) family, which is involved in (p)ppGpp metabolism and the stringent response. The potential functions of the rel gene have been examined. S. coelicolor Rel has been shown to be ribosome associated, and its activity in vitro is ribosome dependent. Analysis in vivo of the active recombinant protein in well-defined Escherichia coli relA and relA/spoT mutants provides evidence that S. coelicolor Rel, like native E. coli RelA, is functionally ribosome associated, resulting in ribosome-dependent (p)ppGpp accumulation upon amino acid deprivation. Expression of an S. coelicolor C-terminally deleted Rel, comprised of only the first 489 amino acids, catalyzes a ribosome-independent (p)ppGpp formation, in the same manner as the E. coli truncated RelA protein (1 to 455 amino acids). An E. coli relA spoT double deletion mutant transformed with S. coelicolor rel gene suppresses the phenotype associated with (p)ppGpp deficiency. However, in such a strain, a rel-mediated (p)ppGpp response apparently occurs after glucose depletion, but only in the absence of amino acids. Analysis of ppGpp decay in E. coli expressing the S. coelicolor rel gene suggests that it also encodes a (p)ppGpp-degrading activity. By deletion analysis, the catalytic domains of S. coelicolor Rel for (p)ppGpp synthesis and degradation have been located within its N terminus (amino acids 267 to 453 and 93 to 397, respectively). In addition, E. coli relA in an S. coelicolor rel deletion mutant restores actinorhodine production and shows a nearly normal morphological differentiation, as does the wild-type rel gene, which is in agreement with the proposed role of (p)ppGpp nucleotides in antibiotic biosynthesis.     

Accumulation of ppGpp and ppGp in Staphylococcus aureus 8325-4 following nutrient starvation

AIM: To investigate the accumulation of highly phosphorylated guanosine nucleotides in Staphylococcus aureus 8325-4 following nutrient deprivation. METHODS AND RESULTS: Nutrient shiftdown of Staph. aureus, HPLC of nucleotides and Western blotting of cell-free extracts. ppGpp rapidly accumulated when cells were deprived of isoleucine following addition of mupirocin, or after carbon deprivation. In contrast, total amino acid starvation led to delayed production of ppGp, which suggests that Staph. aureus exhibits a unique response to total amino acid deprivation compared with other eubacteria. Intracellular ppGp was observed at high levels under all starvation conditions, which suggests that this nucleotide is linked to nutrient limitation and may therefore be involved in regulating the stringent response in Staph. aureus. pppGpp was not observed under any nutrient-limiting condition. Western blot analysis of whole-cell extracts from Staph. aureus 8325-4, showed that antibodies to RelA and SpoT cross-reacted under conditions that detected these proteins in Escherichia coli. CONCLUSIONS: Staph. aureus produces ppGpp and ppGp following nutrient limitation. Immunological analysis indicates that Staph. aureus contains RelA and SpoT proteins, similar to those produced by E. coli. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study provides a new example of the diversity of metabolic regulations in bacteria.     

Identification of an indispensable amino acid for ppGpp synthesis of Escherichia coli SpoT protein

Amino acid substitutions were introduced into a structurally flexible and highly conserved region of Escherichia coli SpoT protein. SpoT protein changed from Asp to Ala at the 293rd position did not restore cell growth of E. coli CF8295 (delta relA, delta spoT) and did not accumulate ppGpp in the cell, suggesting that the Asp293 is indispensable for ppGpp synthesis of the protein.     

Intramolecular regulation of the opposing (p)ppGpp catalytic activities of Rel(Seq), the Rel/Spo enzyme from Streptococcus equisimilis

Catalytic and regulatory domains of the Rel/Spo homolog of Streptococcus equisimilis affecting (p)ppGpp synthesis and degradation activities have been defined, and opposing activities of the purified protein and its fragments have been compared. Two major domains of the 739-residue Rel(Seq) protein are defined by limited proteolytic digestion. In vitro assays of the purified N-terminal half-protein reveal synthesis of (p)ppGpp by an ATP-GTP 3'-pyrophosphotransferase as well as an ability to degrade (p)ppGpp by a Mn(2+)-dependent 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase. Removal of the C-terminal half-protein has reciprocal regulatory effects on the activities of the N-terminal half-protein. Compared to the full-length protein, deletion activates (p)ppGpp synthesis specific activity about 12-fold and simultaneously inhibits (p)ppGpp degradation specific activity about 150-fold to shift the balance of the two activities in favor of synthesis. Cellular (p)ppGpp accumulation behavior is consistent with these changes. The bifunctional N-terminal half-protein can be further dissected into overlapping monofunctional subdomains, since purified peptides display either degradation activity (residues 1 to 224) or synthetic activity (residues 79 to 385) in vitro. These assignments can also apply to RelA and SpoT. The ability of Rel(Seq) to mediate (p)ppGpp accumulation during amino acid starvation in S. equisimilis is absent when the protein is expressed ectopically in Escherichia coli. Fusing the N-terminal half of Rel(Seq) with the C-terminal domain of RelA creates a chimeric protein that restores the stringent response in E. coli by inhibiting unregulated degradation and restoring regulated synthetic activity. Reciprocal intramolecular regulation of the dual activities may be a general intrinsic feature of Rel/Spo homolog proteins.     

SpoT governs Legionella pneumophila differentiation in host macrophages

During its life cycle, Legionella pneumophila alternates between a replicative and a transmissive state. To determine their contributions to L. pneumophila differentiation, the two ppGpp synthetases, RelA and SpoT, were disrupted. Synthesis of ppGpp was required for transmission, as relA spoT mutants were killed during entry to and exit from macrophages. RelA, which senses amino acid starvation induced by serine hydroxamate, is dispensable in macrophages, as relA mutants spread efficiently. SpoT monitors fatty acid biosynthesis (FAB), since following cerulenin treatment, wild-type and relA strains expressed the flaA transmissive gene, but relA spoT mutants did not. As in Escherichia coli , the SpoT response to FAB perturbation likely required an interaction with acyl-carrier protein (ACP), as judged by the failure of the spoT-A413E allele to rescue transmissive trait expression of relA spoT bacteria. Furthermore, SpoT was essential for transmission between macrophages, since secondary infections by relA spoT mutants were restored by induction of spoT , but not relA . To resume replication, ppGpp must be degraded, as mutants lacking spoT hydrolase activity failed to convert from the transmissive to the replicative phase in either bacteriological medium or macrophages. Thus, L. pneumophila requires SpoT to monitor FAB and to alternate between replication and transmission in macrophages.