Improving coiled-coil stability by optimizing ionic interactions

Alpha-helical coiled coils are a common protein oligomerization motif stabilized mainly by hydrophobic interactions occurring along the coiled-coil interface. We have recently designed and solved the structure of a two-heptad repeat coiled-coil peptide that is stabilized further by a complex network of inter- and intrahelical salt-bridges in addition to the hydrophobic interactions. Here, we extend and improve the de novo design of this two heptad-repeat peptide by four newly designed peptides characterized by different types of ionic interactions. The contribution of these different types of ionic interactions to coiled-coil stability are analyzed by CD spectroscopy and analytical ultracentrifugation. We show that all peptides are highly alpha-helical and two of them are 100% dimeric under physiological conditions. Furthermore, we have solved the X-ray structure of the most stable of these peptides and the rational design principles are verified by comparing this structure to the structure of the parent peptide. We show that by combining the most favorable inter- and intrahelical salt-bridge arrangements it is possible to design coiled-coil oligomerization domains with improved stability properties.     

NMR solution structure of a highly stable de novo heterodimeric coiled-coil

The NMR solution structure of a highly stable coiled-coil IAAL-E3/K3 has been solved. The E3/K3 coiled-coil is a 42-residue de novo designed coiled-coil comprising three heptad repeats per subunit, stabilized by hydrophobic contacts within the core and electrostatic interactions at the interface crossing the hydrophobic core which direct heterodimer formation. This E3/K3 domain has previously been shown to have high alpha-helical content as well as possessing a low dissociation constant (70 nM). The E3/K3 structure is completely alpha-helical and is an archetypical coiled-coil in solution, as determined using a combination of (1)H-NOE and homology based structural restraints. This structure provides a structural framework for visualizing the important interactions for stability and specificity, which are key to protein engineering applications such as affinity purification and de novo design.     

Effect of chain length on coiled-coil stability: decreasing stability with increasing chain length

The de novo design and biophysical characterization of three series of two-stranded alpha-helical coiled coils with different chain lengths are described. Our goal was to examine how increasing chain length would affect protein folding and stability when one or more heptad repeat(s) of K-A-E-A-L-E-G (gabcdef) was inserted into the central region of different coiled-coil host proteins. This heptad was designed to maintain the continuous 3-4 hydrophobic repeat of the coiled-coil host and introduce an Ala and Leu residue in the hydrophobic core at the a and d position, respectively, and a pair of stabilizing interchain ionic i to i' + 5 (g to e') interactions per heptad inserted. The secondary structures of the three series of disulfide-bridged polypeptides were studied by CD spectroscopy and their stabilities determined by chemical and thermal denaturation. The results showed that successive insertions of this heptad systematically decreased the stability of all the coiled coils studied regardless of the overall initial stability of the host coiled coil. These observations are in contrast to the generally accepted implication that the folding and stability of coiled coils are enhanced with increasing chain length. Our results imply that, in these examples where an Ala and Leu hydrophobic residue were introduced into the coiled-coil core per inserted heptad, there was still insufficient stability to overcome unfavorable entropy associated with chain length extension, even though the inserted heptad contained the most stabilizing hydrophobic residue (Leu) at position d and stabilizing ionic attractions.     

Structure-function analysis of the heat shock factor-binding protein reveals a protein composed solely of a highly conserved and dynamic coiled-coil trimerization domain.

Heat shock factor-binding protein (HSBP) 1 is a small, evolutionarily conserved protein originally identified in a yeast two-hybrid screen using the trimerization domain of heat shock factor (HSF) 1 as the bait. Similar in size to HSF1 trimerization domain, human HSBP1 contains two arrays of hydrophobic heptad repeats (designated HR-N and HR-C) characteristic of coiled-coil proteins. Proteins of the HSBP family are relatively small (<100 residues), comprising solely a putative coiled-coil oligomerization domain without any other readily recognizable structural or functional motif. Our biophysical and biochemical characterization of human HSBP1 reveals a cooperatively folded protein with high alpha-helical content and moderate stability. NMR analyses reveal a single continuous helix encompassing both HR-N and HR-C in the highly conserved central region, whereas the less conserved carboxyl terminus is unstructured and accessible to proteases. Unlike previously characterized coiled-coils, backbone 15N relaxation measurements implicate motional processes on the millisecond time scale in the coiled-coil region. Analytical ultracentrifugation and native PAGE studies indicate that HSBP1 is predominantly trimeric over a wide concentration range. NMR analyses suggest a rotationally symmetric trimer. Because the highly conserved hydrophobic heptad repeats extend over 60% of HSBP1, we propose that HSBP most likely regulates the function of other proteins through coiled-coil interactions.     

The fusion core complex of the peste des petits ruminants virus is a six-helix bundle assembly

We describe the properties of the two heptad repeats (HR1 and HR2) of the Peste des petits ruminants virus (PPRV) fusion protein (F) to obtain insights into the mechanism by which these repeats influence PPRV-mediated cell fusion. Both HR1 and HR2 inhibit PPRV-mediated syncytia formation in Vero cells in vitro. Of these, HR2 was found to be more effective than HR1. We studied the mechanism of fusion inhibition by these two repeats by using various biophysical and biochemical methods either separately or together. CD spectral analysis of these repeats revealed that the alpha-helical content of HR1 and HR2 when used together is higher than that of their simulated spectrum in the mixture, suggesting the formation of a highly structured complex by these repeats. Protease protection assays confirmed that such a complex is highly stable. Electrospray mass spectrometry of protease-digested products of the HR1-HR2 complex showed protection of fragments corresponding to both HR1 and HR2 sequences involved in complex formation. By employing size-exclusion chromatography and chemical cross-linking experiments, we show that three units each of HR1 and HR2 form a complex in which HR1 is a trimer and HR2 is a monomer. Homology-based three-dimensional modeling of this complex showed that HR1 and HR2 together form a six-helix and trimeric coiled-coil bundle. In this model, the HR1 trimer forms the core whereas HR2, while interacting with HR1 in an antiparallel orientation, forms a two-stranded coiled-coil structure and lies at the periphery of the structure. These results are discussed in the context of a common fusion mechanism among paramyxoviruses.     

Removing an interhelical salt bridge abolishes coiled-coil formation in a de novo designed peptide

Alpha-helical coiled coils represent a common protein oligomerization motif that are mainly stabilized by hydrophobic interactions occurring along their coiled-coil interface, the so-called hydrophobic seam. We have recently de novo designed and optimized a series of two-heptad repeat long coiled-coil peptides which are further stabilized by a complex network of inter- and intrahelical salt bridges. Here we have extended the de novo design of such two heptad-repeat long peptides by removing the central and most important g-e' Arg to Glu (g-e'RE) ionic interhelical interaction and replacing these residues by alanine residues. The effect of the missing interhelical ionic interaction on coiled-coil formation and stability has been analyzed by CD spectroscopy, analytical ultracentrifugation, and X-ray crystallography. We show that the peptide, while being highly alpha-helical, is no longer able to form a parallel coiled-coil structure but rather assumes an octameric globular helical assembly devoid of any coiled-coil interactions.     

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) gp41 escape mutants: cross-resistance to peptide inhibitors of HIV fusion and altered receptor activation of gp120

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infects cells by fusing with cellular membranes. Fusion occurs when the envelope glycoprotein (Env) undergoes conformational changes while binding to cellular receptors. Fusogenic changes involve assembly of two heptad repeats in the ectodomain of the gp41 transmembrane subunit to form a six-helix bundle (6HB), consisting of a trimeric N heptad repeat (N-HR) coiled-coil core with three antiparallel C heptad repeats (C-HRs) that pack in the coiled-coil grooves. Peptides corresponding to the N-and C-HRs (N and C peptides, respectively) interfere with formation of the 6HB in a dominant-negative manner and are emerging as a new class of antiretroviral therapeutics for treating HIV infection. We generated an escape mutant virus with resistance to an N peptide and show that early resistance involved two mutations, one each in the N- and C-HRs. The mutations conferred resistance not only to the selecting N peptide but also to C peptides, as well as other types of N-peptide inhibitors. Moreover, the N-HR mutation altered sensitivity to soluble CD4. Biophysical studies suggest that the 6HB with the resistance mutations is more stable than the wild-type 6HB and the 6HB formed by inhibitor binding to either wild-type or mutant C-HR. These findings provide new insights into potential mechanisms of resistance to HIV peptide fusion inhibitors and dominant-negative inhibitors in general. The results are discussed in the context of current models of Env-mediated membrane fusion.     

Coiled-coil domains in glycoproteins B and H are involved in human cytomegalovirus membrane fusion

Human cytomegalovirus (CMV) utilizes a complex route of entry into cells that involves multiple interactions between viral envelope proteins and cellular receptors. Three conserved viral glycoproteins, gB, gH, and gL, are required for CMV-mediated membrane fusion, but little is known of how these proteins cooperate during entry (E. R. Kinzler and T. Compton, submitted for publication). The goal of this study was to begin defining the molecular mechanisms that underlie membrane fusion mediated by herpesviruses. We identified heptad repeat sequences predicted to form alpha-helical coiled coils in two glycoproteins required for fusion, gB and gH. Peptides derived from gB and gH containing the heptad repeat sequences inhibited virus entry when introduced coincident with virus inoculation onto cells or when mixed with virus prior to inoculation. Neither peptide affected binding of CMV to fibroblasts, suggesting that the peptides inhibit membrane fusion. Both gB and gH coiled-coil peptides blocked entry of several laboratory-adapted and clinical strains of human CMV, but neither peptide affected entry of murine CMV or herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1). Although murine CMV and HSV-1 gB and gH have heptad repeat regions, the ability of human CMV gB and gH peptides to inhibit virus entry correlates with the specific residues that comprise the heptad repeat region. The ability of gB and gH coiled-coil peptides to inhibit virus entry independently of cell contact suggests that the coiled-coil regions of gB and gH function differently from those of class I, single-component fusion proteins. Taken together, these data support a critical role for alpha-helical coiled coils in gB and gH in the entry pathway of CMV.     

The two-stranded alpha-helical coiled-coil is an ideal model for studying protein stability and subunit interactions.

We have designed de novo a two-stranded alpha-helical coiled-coil which consists of two identical 35-residue polypeptide chains arranged in a parallel and in-register alignment. Their structure is stabilized by interchain hydrophobic interactions from hydrophobes at positions "a" and "d" of a repeating heptad sequence. The formation and stability of the coiled-coil is dependent on peptide concentration due to the monomer-dimer equilibrium. In contrast, that coiled-coil containing an inter-helical disulfide bond does not show any concentration dependence in the guanidine hydrochloride denaturation experiments as expected. Replacement of one large hydrophobic Leu residue in each chain with Ala significantly decreases coiled-coil stability in both the reduced and oxidized coiled-coils [decreases in transition midpoint of 1.6M (2.3-0.7) and 2.4M (5.3-2.9), respectively]. A large pH dependence on coiled-coil stability is observed over the pH range 4 to 7 (transition midpoints at pH 4, 5, 5.5, 6 and 7 were 3.8, 3.2, 2.0, 1.2 and 0.7M, respectively). The increasing stability with decreasing pH correlates with the protonation of the Glu acid side-chains and reduction of intrachain repulsions between Glu-Glu side-chains in positions i, i + 3 or i, i + 4 along each alpha-helix of the coiled-coil. In addition, coiled-coil stability increases with increasing ionic strength.     

Clustering of large hydrophobes in the hydrophobic core of two-stranded alpha-helical coiled-coils controls protein folding and stability

The de novo design and biophysical characterization of two 60-residue peptides that dimerize to fold as parallel coiled-coils with different hydrophobic core clustering is described. Our goal was to investigate whether designing coiled-coils with identical hydrophobicity but with different hydrophobic clustering of non-polar core residues (each contained 6 Leu, 3 Ile, and 7 Ala residues in the hydrophobic core) would affect helical content and protein stability. The disulfide-bridged P3 and P2 differed dramatically in alpha-helical structure in benign conditions. P3 with three hydrophobic clusters was 98% alpha-helical, whereas P2 was only 65% alpha-helical. The stability profiles of these two analogs were compared, and the enthalpy and heat capacity changes upon denaturation were determined by measuring the temperature dependence by circular dichroism spectroscopy and confirmed by differential scanning calorimetry. The results showed that P3 assembled into a stable alpha-helical two-stranded coiled-coil and exhibited a native protein-like cooperative two-state transition in thermal melting, chemical denaturation, and calorimetry experiments. Although both peptides have identical inherent hydrophobicity (the hydrophobic burial of identical non-polar residues in equivalent heptad coiled-coil positions), we found that the context dependence of an additional hydrophobic cluster dramatically increased stability of P3 (Delta Tm approximately equal to 18 degrees C and Delta[urea](1/2) approximately equal to 1.5 M) as compared with P2. These results suggested that hydrophobic clustering significantly stabilized the coiled-coil structure and may explain how long fibrous proteins like tropomyosin maintain chain integrity while accommodating polar or charged residues in regions of the protein hydrophobic core.     

Solution structure of the C-terminal antiparallel coiled-coil domain from Escherichia coli osmosensor ProP

Bacteria respond to increasing medium osmolality by accumulating organic solutes that are compatible with cellular functions. Transporter ProP of Escherichia coli, a proton symporter and a member of the major facilitator superfamily, senses osmotic shifts and responds by importing osmolytes such as glycine betaine. ProP contains a cytoplasmic, C-terminal extension that is essential for its activity. A peptide corresponding to the C-terminal extension of ProP forms a homodimeric alpha-helical coiled-coil even though some of its heptad a positions are not occupied by hydrophobic amino acid residues. Unexpectedly, amino acid replacement R488I, occurring at a heptad a position, destabilized the coiled-coil formed by the ProP peptide and attenuated the response of the intact transporter to osmotic upshifts in vivo. Thus, ProP was proposed to dimerize via an antiparallel coiled-coil. We used nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to determine the structure of the synthetic peptide corresponding to residues 468-497 of ProP. This region did form an antiparallel coil-coil in which critical residue R488 specifies the antiparallel coiled-coil orientation by forming stabilizing salt-bridges. Charged residues (both acidic and basic) are clustered on the c/g surface of the coiled-coil whereas polar residues are distributed on the b/e surface. This causes the structure to be bent, in contrast to other known antiparallel coiled-coils (those from the hepatitis delta antigen (PDB ID code 1A92) and the bovine F(1) ATPase inhibitor protein (PDB ID code 1HF9)). The coiled-coil and its possible importance for osmosensing are discussed.     

Structural characterization of the SARS-coronavirus spike S fusion protein core

The spike (S) glycoprotein of coronaviruses mediates viral entry into host cells. It is a type 1 viral fusion protein that characteristically contains two heptad repeat regions, denoted HR-N and HR-C, that form coiled-coil structures within the ectodomain of the protein. Previous studies have shown that the two heptad repeat regions can undergo a conformational change from their native state to a 6-helix bundle (trimer of dimers), which mediates fusion of viral and host cell membranes. Here we describe the biophysical analysis of the two predicted heptad repeat regions within the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus S protein. Our results show that in isolation the HR-N region forms a stable alpha-helical coiled coil that associates in a tetrameric state. The HR-C region in isolation formed a weakly stable trimeric coiled coil. When mixed together, the two peptide regions (HR-N and HR-C) associated to form a very stable alpha-helical 6-stranded structure (trimer of heterodimers). Systematic peptide mapping showed that the site of interaction between the HR-N and HR-C regions is between residues 916-950 of HR-N and residues 1151-1185 of HR-C. Additionally, interchain disulfide bridge experiments showed that the relative orientation of the HR-N and HR-C helices in the complex was antiparallel. Overall, the structure of the hetero-stranded complex is consistent with the structures observed for other type 1 viral fusion proteins in their fusion-competent state.     

The effect of a side chain-backbone swap on protein stability.

To assess the relative importance of backbone hydrogen bonding (H-bonding) vs. side chain hydrophobicity in protein structural formation, a method called side chain-backbone swap is proposed. Such a method swaps the side chain and backbone portions of certain amino acid residues, such as Asp, Glu, Asn, Gln, Lys, and Arg. Such a swap retains the sequence of a polypeptide and preserves the identity of the backbone linkage. On the other hand, the swap disrupts backbone H-bonding geometry because of the introduction of extra methylene groups into the peptide backbone. In this project, we chose the two-stranded alpha-helical coiled-coil to implement side chain-backbone swap. A pair of 36-residue peptides was designed. The two peptides have identical sequence with four residues in each heptad repeat occupied by glutamyl residues. Each glutamic acid was incorporated either as alpha-glutamyl residue (the peptide is denoted as alpha-Glu-36) or as gamma-glutamyl residue (the peptide is denoted as gamma-Glu-36). The inter-conversion between the two peptides constitutes a side chain-backbone swap. Residues constituting the hydrophobic core of the coiled-coil, however, are left unchanged. The peptide pair was characterized by circular dichroism spectroscopy, reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC), and two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). The results indicate that alpha-Glu-36 is a two-stranded alpha-helical coiled-coil while gamma-Glu-36 lacks stable structural elements. It is concluded that, at least for coiled-coils where hydrophobic interactions are predominantly long-range, local backbone H-bonding is a required for structural formation, consistent with a hierarchic folding mechanism. The methodological implication of side chain-backbone swap is also discussed.     

NMR and CD studies on the conformation of a synthetic peptide containing epitopes of the human immunodeficiency virus 1 transmembrane protein gp41

CD and nmr characterizations are reported for the 23-mer peptide CMC3, corresponding to residues 577–599 of gp41, the transmembrane glycoprotein of the human immunodeficiency virus 1. Concentration, temperature, and pH dependencies of CD and nmr spectra are indicative of self-association with a consequent stabilization of secondary structural elements in water. The addition to the water solution of small amounts of trifluoroethanol induces a secondary structure, mostly due to the presence of helical elements. The amphipathic character of the helix and the presence of three hydrophobic 4/3 heptad repeats suggest that the peptide could be structured in a symmetric association of helices, such as in a coiled-coil structure. This behavior is discussed in terms of a possible role of this segment in the gp41 envelope oligomerization. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Requirement of the coiled-coil domain of PML-RARalpha oncoprotein for localization, sumoylation, and inhibition of monocyte differentiation

Homo-oligomerization via a coiled-coil (C-C) domain has been shown to be necessary for the promyelocytic leukemia (PML)-retinoic acid receptor-alpha (RARalpha) fusion protein to acquire oncogenic potential in acute promyelocytic leukemia. We show here that PML(DeltaC-C)-RARalpha, which contains a deletion in its C-C domain, is neither localized as characteristic microspeckles nor modified by small ubiquitin-like modifiers (SUMO). The absence of sumoylation of the DeltaC-C mutant was due to the lack of binding to Ubc9, a SUMO conjugation enzyme. The integrity of RING finger domain was also needed for both sumoylation and microspeckle formation. In GAL4-DNA tethering assays, the DeltaC-C mutant completely lost the inhibitory effect on retinoic acid (RA)-mediated transactivation. Furthermore, the expression of CD14 in U937 cells expressing the DeltaC-C mutant in response to vitamin D3 was markedly higher than in cells expressing PML-RARalpha. However, the RA-mediated induction of C/EBPbeta in cells expressing the DeltaC-C mutant was comparable to that of control cells. Thus, our results suggest that the C-C domain-associated functions of sumoylation, localization as microspeckles, and the inhibition of monocyte differentiation all contribute to the oncogenic activity of PML-RARalpha.     

Engineering of the hydrophobic core of an alpha-helical coiled coil

The amino acid sequence that forms the alpha-helical coiled coil structure has a representative heptad repeat denoted by defgabc, according to their positions. Although the a and d positions are usually occupied by hydrophobic residues, hydrophilic residues at these positions sometimes play important roles in natural proteins. We have manipulated a few amino acids at the a and d positions of a de novo designed trimeric coiled coil to confer new functions to the peptides. The IZ peptide, which has four heptad repeats and forms a parallel triple-stranded coiled coil, has Ile at all of the a and d positions. We show three examples: (1) the substitution of one Ile at either the a or d position with Glu caused the peptide to become pH sensitive; (2) the metal ion induced alpha-helical bundles were formed by substitutions with two His residues at the d and a positions for a medium metal ion, and with one Cys residue at the a position for a soft metal ion; and (3) the AAB-type heterotrimeric alpha-helical bundle formation was accomplished by a combination of Ala and Trp residues at the a positions of different peptide chains. Furthermore, we applied these procedures to prepare an ABC-type heterotrimeric alpha-helical bundle and a metal ion-induced heterotrimeric alpha-helical bundle.     

pH-induced conformational change in an alpha-helical coiled-coil is controlled by His residues in the hydrophobic core

An alpha-helical coiled-coil structure is one of the basic structural units in proteins. Hydrophilic residues at the hydrophobic positions in the coiled-coil structure play important roles in structures and functions of natural proteins. We reported here a peptide that formed a triple stranded alpha-helical coiled-coil showing the pH-dependent structural change. The peptide was designed to have two His residues at the hydrophobic positions of the center of the coiled-coil structure. The peptide folded into a triple stranded coiled-coil at neutral pH, while it unfolded at acidic pH. This construct is useful to create a protein that the structure or function is controlled by pH.     

Resistance to Virus Infection Conferred by the Interferon-Induced Promyelocytic Leukemia Protein

The interferon (IFN)-induced promyelocytic leukemia (PML) protein is specifically associated with nuclear bodies (NBs) whose functions are yet unknown. Two of the NB-associated proteins, PML and Sp100, are induced by IFN. Here we show that overexpression of PML and not Sp100 induces resistance to infections by vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) (a rhabdovirus) and influenza A virus (an orthomyxovirus) but not by encephalomyocarditis virus (a picornavirus). Inhibition of viral multiplication was dependent on both the level of PML expression and the multiplicity of infection and reached 100-fold. PML was shown to interfere with VSV mRNA and protein synthesis. Compared to the IFN mediator MxA protein, PML had less powerful antiviral activity. While nuclear body localization of PML did not seem to be required for the antiviral effect, deletion of the PML coiled-coil domain completely abolished it. Taken together, these results suggest that PML can contribute to the antiviral state induced in IFN-treated cells.