Variation in dog-whelk shells in relation to wave action and crab predation

In Nucella lapillus there is usually a progressive gradation in mean shell shape from short squat individuals on exposed headlands to more elongated ones in shelter. This pattern has been attributed to the differential selective effects of wave action and crab predation, although it would almost certainly be an oversimplification to imagine these as the only significant forces involved, especially near the limits of the species' distribution.
However, whilst this pattern of shell-shape variation with exposure is generally true over most of the animal's range in both Europe and North America, there are exceptions. There are occasional enclaves with much more elongated shells than would normally have been expected. Sometimes these are so abundant, as in the Severn Estuary, that all dog-whelk enclaves are unusually elongated, regardless of the exposure of their habitat.
In other areas, such as south-eastern England, the Solway Firth and the area around the mouth of the Conway the shells are not unusually elongated, but the enclaves show very little variation: a normal sheltered-shore form is seen wherever the species occurs. Shetland samples appear to be a combination of this pattern (predominating) with the 'normal' one showing the full range of shellshape variation.
Nucella appears in the Atlantic fossil record at the end of the Pliocene without any antecedent forms. It is assumed to have colonized from the Pacific and exploited the vacant niche before the onset of the Ice Age. Successive advances and retreats of the ice, with attendant changes in sea level, will have served to break up and recombine those dog-whelk populations that were not eliminated. It is postulated that the modern Nucella lapillus is a combination of several genetically distinct populations, some of which show the full range of variation and may respond to the selective effects of crabs and waves, and some of which do not and show little variation.     

Some observations on shell-shape variation in North American populations of Nucella lapillus (L.)

This paper considers shell-shape variation in samples of the dog-whelk/dog-winkle, ucella lapillus , from the southern half of its North American range, between 41 and 46N, and compares it with the pattern seen in Europe. At the extreme southern limit of its American range, to the south of Cape Cod, the species exhibits features to be expected in an animal close to an environmental limit. It is generally rare and has a patchy distribution. There is little variation in the shell: almost all adult individuals have rather large, thick, white, elongated shells. This contrasts sharply with the situation in Portugal, at the southern limit in Europe, where the animals have small thin, coloured shells of intermediate shape.
Away from the marginal situation, north of Nahant (42^CN) in America, the species shows much the same range of variability in shell size, shape and colour on both sides of the Atlantic. Most populations appear to show the same pattern of shape variation in asociation with the exposure of their habitat to wave action. Animals from exposed sites tend to have shorter, squatter shells than their compatriots in shelter. However, in America as in some parts of Europe, there are occasional enclaves which do not fit the usual pattern. It is interesting to note that the form normally associated with extremely exposed shores from Brittany to Faroe in Europe is found in Atlantic Canada but is apparently absent from southern populations in both the U.S.A and the Iberian Peninsula.     

Foraging Decision Rules and Prey Species Preferences of Northwestern Crows (Corvus caurinus)

Categorization of similar prey types and the application of decision rules by dietary generalists can enhance the efficiency of foraging decisions and facilitate the inclusion of novel prey types in the diet. While considerable research attention has been directed toward investigation of these concepts in invertebrates, few have assessed categorization and decision rules used by generalist vertebrate predators. In this study, we experimentally investigated decision rules and prey preferences of northwestern crows (Corvus caurinus) feeding on littleneck clams (Tapes philippinarum) and whelks (Nucella lamellosa). We presented crows with three species‐size combinations: small clams (2.0–2.9 cm length) paired with large whelks (4.0–4.9 cm), small clams paired with medium whelks (3.0–3.9 cm), and large clams (4.0–4.9 cm) with large whelks. Profitability estimates based on observations of crows feeding on these prey species indicated that clams were always the more energetically profitable option; however, in prey choice trials crows consistently selected the heavier prey species, regardless of differences in profitability. These results show that crows apply a general decision rule according to which they select heavier prey items when feeding on hard‐shelled prey requiring similar handling techniques, and that while such decision rules may approximate optimal choices they may not always follow predictions based solely on prey profitability. We discuss these results in the context of behavioural flexibility of generalist predators, and predicting impacts of intertidal avian predators on prey populations.     

Interpopulation and context-related differences in responses of a marine gastropod to predation risk

We conducted laboratory experiments to investigate interpopulation differences in the behavioural responses of the whelk Buccinum undatum to the predatory lobster Homarus americanus and the asteroid Leptasterias polaris, both in the absence and presence of feeding opportunities. Whelks from three populations in the eastern North Atlantic (1) responded to lobsters by displaying avoidance behaviours (burrowing in the sediments or retreating inside their shell), (2) responded to asteroids by displaying escape responses (rapid crawling, shell rocking behaviour or foot contortions), and (3) more often refrained from feeding in the presence of a lobster than in the presence of an asteroid. Although whelks from the three populations responded similarly to lobsters and asteroids, interpopulation differences were evident. Thus, whelks from populations sympatric with a given predator more frequently displayed 'appropriate' antipredator behaviours (i.e. avoidance in the presence of a lobster, and escape in the presence of an asteroid) than did whelks allopatric with that predator. Also, whelks from a population sympatric with both predators fed less readily in the presence of a given predator than did whelks allopatric with that predator. However, the presence of a lobster or an asteroid had the same impact on the feeding response of whelks from two populations with contrasting predator fields, one sympatric with lobsters, but allopatric with asteroids, and one sympatric with asteroids, but allopatric with lobsters. The results of our study indicate that coexistence (over evolutionary or ecological time) with lobsters and asteroids increases the propensity of the whelk to display avoidance and escape behaviours in the presence of lobsters and asteroids, respectively, but has a less predictable effect on how whelks trade off predation risk and food acquisition. Studies are needed to investigate the roles of inheritance and experience on the development of antipredator behaviours and decision making by prey animals when predation risk conflicts with other fitness-related activities such as the acquisition of food or reproductive opportunities. Copyright 1999 The Association for the Study of Animal Behaviour.     

Invasive species cause large-scale loss of native California oyster habitat by disrupting trophic cascades

Although invasive species often resemble their native counterparts, differences in their foraging and anti-predator strategies may disrupt native food webs. In a California estuary, we showed that regions dominated by native crabs and native whelks have low mortality of native oysters (the basal prey), while regions dominated by invasive crabs and invasive whelks have high oyster mortality and are consequently losing a biologically diverse habitat. Using field experiments, we demonstrated that the invasive whelk’s distribution is causally related to a large-scale pattern of oyster mortality. To determine whether predator–prey interactions between crabs (top predators) and whelks (intermediate consumers) indirectly control the pattern of oyster mortality, we manipulated the presence and invasion status of the intermediate and top trophic levels in laboratory mesocosms. Our results show that native crabs indirectly maintain a portion of the estuary’s oyster habitat by both consuming native whelks (density-mediated trophic cascade) and altering their foraging behavior (trait-mediated trophic cascade). In contrast, invasive whelks are naive to crab predators and fail to avoid them, thereby inhibiting trait-mediated cascades and their invasion into areas with native crabs. Similarly, when native crabs are replaced with invasive crabs, the naive foraging strategy and smaller size of invasive crabs prevents them from efficiently consuming adult whelks, thereby inhibiting strong density-mediated cascades. Thus, while trophic cascades allow native crabs, whelks, and oysters to locally co-exist, the replacement of native crabs and whelks by functionally similar invasive species results in severe depletion of native oysters. As coastal systems become increasingly invaded, the mismatch of evolutionarily based strategies among predators and prey may lead to further losses of critical habitat that support marine biodiversity and ecosystem function. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Evaluation of the age of the red whelk Neptunea antiqua using statoliths, opercula and element ratios in the shell

Growth rings present in whole and sectioned statoliths were used to determine the age of red whelks Neptunea antiqua, from the North Sea. Validation of the periodicity of the rings was established in four whelks by comparing the number of statolith rings with the number of seasonal Mg:Ca ratio cycles present in shell calcium carbonate samples drilled sequentially from along the growth axis. There was exact correspondence between the number of growth rings and the number of element ratio cycles in two of the shells and a 1-year difference in the estimated age between the two methods in the other two shells, evidence which is strongly indicative of an annual periodicity of deposition to the statolith rings. The estimated age of the whelks using the statolith rings varied between 4 years (shell length 102 mm) and 17 years (shell length 148 mm). The age of the whelks ascertained from the statoliths was compared with age estimates from the number of adventitious layers in sectioned opercula. The number of adventitious layers in whelks from 51 to 148 mm shell length ranged between 1 and 12 years. No significant difference was observed between the number of strongly defined statolith rings and number of opercula adventitious layers.     

Long‐term stasis and short‐term divergence in the phenotypes of microsnails on oceanic islands

Phenotypic divergence is often unrelated to genotypic divergence. An extreme example is rapid phenotypic differentiation despite genetic similarity. Another extreme is morphological stasis despite substantial genetic divergence. These opposite patterns have been viewed as reflecting opposite properties of the lineages. In this study, phenotypic radiation accompanied by both rapid divergence and long‐term conservatism is documented in the inferred molecular phylogeny of the micro land snails Cavernacmella (Assimineidae) on the Ogasawara Islands. The populations of Cavernacmella on the Sekimon limestone outcrop of Hahajima Island showed marked divergence in shell morphology. Within this area, one lineage diversified into types with elongated turret shells, conical shells and flat disc‐like shells without substantial genetic differentiation. Additionally, a co‐occurring species with these types developed a much larger shell size. Moreover, a lineage adapted to live inside caves in this area. In contrast, populations in the other areas exhibited no morphological differences despite high genetic divergence among populations. Accordingly, the phenotypic evolution of Cavernacmella in Ogasawara is characterized by a pattern of long‐term stasis and periodic bursts of change. This pattern suggests that even lineages with phenotypic conservatism could shift to an alternative state allowing rapid phenotypic divergence.     

Predation by blue crabs, Callinectes sapidus, on rapa whelks, Rapana venosa: possible natural controls for an invasive species?

Blue crabs Callinectes sapidus are voracious predators in Chesapeake Bay and other estuarine habitats. The rapa whelk Rapana venosa is native to Asian waters but was discovered in Chesapeake Bay in 1998. This predatory gastropod grows to large terminal sizes (in excess of 150 mm shell length (SL)) and has a thick shell that may contribute to an ontogenetic predation refuge. However, juvenile rapa whelks in Chesapeake Bay may be vulnerable to predation by the blue crab given probable habitat overlap, relative lack of whelk shell architectural defenses, and the relatively large size of potential crab predators. Feeding experiments using three size classes of blue crab predators in relation to a size range of rapa whelks of two different ages (Age 1 and Age 2) were conducted. Blue crabs of all sizes tested consumed Age 1 rapa whelks; 58% of all Age 1 whelks offered were eaten. Age 2 rapa whelks were consumed by medium (67% of whelks offered were eaten) and large (70% of whelks offered were eaten) blue crabs but not by small crabs. The attack methods of medium and large crabs changed with whelk age and related shell weight. Age 1 whelks were typically crushed by blue crabs while Age 2 whelk shells were chipped or left intact by predators removing prey. Rapa whelks less than approximately 35 mm SL are vulnerable to predation by all sizes of blue crabs tested. Rapa whelk critical size may be greater than 55 mm SL in the presence of large blue crabs indicating that a size refugia from crab predation may not be achieved by rapa whelks in Chesapeake Bay until at least Age 2 or Age 3. Predation by blue crabs on young rapa whelks may offer a natural control strategy for rapa whelks in Chesapeake Bay and other estuarine habitats along the North American Atlantic coast.     

Gene frequencies, genetic background and environment in Pyrenean populations of Cepaea nemoralis (L.)

Microgeographical genetic differentiation of populations of the polymorphic land snail Cepaea nemoralis (L.) has been the subject of intensive investigation. The importance of environmental selection acting at the loci which control the shell polymorphism in determining the distribution of genes in this species remains a matter of considerable controversy. Some populations of C. nemoralis in the central Pyrenees show striking local associations of morph frequency (and particularly of the frequency of unhanded shells) with topography which have been ascribed to the action of natural selection.
In the Ter valley (eastern Spanish Pyrenees) populations described here, however, the pattern of association of the frequencies of the shell morphs with topography is quite different from that found in the central Pyrenees. In particular, the distribution of unhanded shells is almost the inverse of that found in some previously studied populations. The general picture of variation in relation to topography in Pyrenean C. nemoralis populations is now seen to be one of great local consistency within valley systems, but of considerable differences between valley systems. This variation in population structure may be due either to cryptic and undetected environmental differences between valley systems or to evolutionary divergence between their C. nemoralis populations. The difficulty of deciding between these two conflicting hypotheses emphasizes the limitations of the technique of simply examining the distribution of individual genes in natural populations as a method of analysing their evolutionary history.     

Are the opposing selection pressures on exposed and protected shores sufficient to maintain genetic differentiation between gastropod populations with high intermigration rates?

Throughout the world intertidal gastropods living on exposed rocky shores differ strikingly in a number of morphological and life history traits from those on protected shores. Where surf is heavy gastropods tend to be smaller and to have thinner and smoother shells with larger apertures than do those from sheltered areas where crab predation is more intense. These morphological differences can occur within a species and there is evidence that they can be partially genetic and partially environmental. In addition the convergence of shell features in each habitat suggests that there are consistent differences between the selective pressures on exposed shores and the selective pressures on protected shores. I constructed a simulation model for a polygenic trait that experiences different selective pressures on exposed and sheltered shores. The results show that genetic differences can be maintained between the two populations despite high intermigration rates. Replacement of a portion of the random environmental variance with adaptive environmental variance reduces the effect of selection and thus the size of the difference maintained between the two populations. Genetic differentiation between exposed and protected populations can persist for significant periods of time and may have sometimes been the first step in speciation.     

Nonrandom variation of morphological traits across environmental gradients in a land snail

Morphological variation is often attributed to differential adaptations to diverse habitats, but adaptations to a similar environment do not necessarily result in similar phenotypes. Adaptations for water and heat budget are crucial for organisms living in arid habitats, and in snails, variation in shell morphology has been frequently attributed to selection by stressful environmental factors. However, their phenotypic divergence often is not accompanied by a relevant niche differentiation and consistent relationships with environmental correlates are lacking. In the pulmonate genus Albinaria, there is great size and shape variation between and within species, and there are two major shell sculpture morphotypes, ribbed and smooth. We used 62 populations of 28 Albinaria species, taking into account their phylogeny, to examine the variation of shell traits (sculpture, size, shape), their effect on water and heat budget, and their association with geographical and climatic gradients. We found unambiguous size and shape discrimination between the two morphotypes. Ribbed shells are lighter, taller, and slimmer and have a smaller aperture than the smooth ones. Moreover, significant correlations between shell traits and heat/moisture budget and climate/geography were revealed. Ribbed and taller shells retain more water on their shell surface, and on the other hand, smooth shells exhibit lower water permeability. Therefore, two strategies are being used to prevent water loss, active retention or resistance to loss. Consequently, different alternative solutions evolved and were retained as responses to the same stressful factor by the two distinct shell morphotypes. Larger shells occur in southern latitudes, mostly on islands, and at sites where there is a shortage of rainfall. Therefore, the variation of the examined traits is nonrandom with respect to location and to climate and their evolution can be attributed to selection by environmental factors, with water availability being the key driving agent of body-size variation.     

Shell shape variation in dog-whelks (Nucella lapillus (L.)) from the West Coast of Scotland

European populations of the common dog-whelk, Nucella lapillus (L.), usually show a neat and precise pattern of shell shape variation with the exposure of their habitat to wave action. Whilst this is the case along much of the west coast of Scotland, there are a number of instances where unusually elongated shells occur, somewhat reminiscent of the form described for the Severn Estuary. There are no obvious environmental or geographical correlates to explain the occurrence of these forms and a genetical interpretation is sought.     

High genetic differentiation among remnant populations of the endangered Caesalpinia echinata Lam. (Leguminosae–Caesalpinioideae)

Forest fragments along the Atlantic coastland of Brazil have been highly impacted by extensive human activities for the last 400 years. Caesalpinia echinata (Leguminosae– Caesalpinioideae), brazilwood, was overexploited during this period due to its economical importance as a dye. As a result, the species has become endangered and today its total population size is very restricted. We have assessed the distribution of genetic variation between five natural populations of brazilwood by means of RAPD (random amplified polymorphic DNA) markers. Of the total genetic variability, 28.5% was attributable to differences between two geographical groups, 29.6% to population differences within groups and 42.0% to individual differences within populations. The high level of population differentiation observed is in contrast to that expected for a primarily outcrossed woody perennial plant, and suggests that there may be a degree of inbreeding. Our results are in agreement with previous studies which postulated that C. echinata has always occurred in clumps, being common in some places but rare in between. From a conservation point of view, different populations representing different regions should be protected and, yet, plants with different origins should not be synthesized into populations in a recovery process at the risk of loss and dilution of genetic information. This study demonstrates that RAPD markers were effective in establishing a clear correlation between genetic and geographical distance and in identifying areas of maximum diversity, and may be used as an initial approach to assess the partitioning of genetic variation in this endangered species.     

The transfer of cadmium, mercury, methylmercury, and zinc in an intertidal rocky shore food chain

We examined the transfer of cadmium (Cd), inorganic mercury [Hg(II)], methylmercury (MeHg), and zinc (Zn) in an intertidal rocky shore food chain, namely from marine phytoplankton to suspension-feeding rock oysters (Saccostrea cucullata) and finally to predatory whelks Thais clavigera. The uptake of metals from the dissolved phase was also concurrently quantified in the oysters and the whelks. Metal uptake by the oysters was not directly proportional, whereas metal uptake by the whelks was directly proportional to metal concentration in the water. The order of uptake was MeHg>Hg(II)>Zn>Cd, and was much higher in the oysters than in the whelks. The relative uptake of Zn and Cd was comparable between oysters and whelks, whereas MeHg and Hg(II) showed disproportionally higher uptake in oysters than in whelks as compared to Zn and Cd. The assimilation efficiencies (AEs) were in the order of MeHg>Zn>Cd=Hg(II) in oysters, whereas the AEs were highest for MeHg and comparable for Zn, Cd, and Hg(II) in the whelks. Pre-exposure of the oysters to different dissolved concentrations of Cd significantly elevated the AEs of Cd and Hg(II) but not of Zn, in association with the induction of metallothioneins in the oysters. The whelks significantly assimilated Cd and Zn from various prey (barnacles, oysters, mussels, and snails) with contrasting strageties of metal sequestration and storage. There was no significant relationship between the metal AE and the metal partitioning in the soluble fraction (including metallothionein-like proteins, heat stable protein, and organelles). The insoluble fraction of metals was also available for metal assimilation. Our calculations show that the dietary uptake of metals can be dominant in the overall bioaccumulation in the oysters and whelks, and the trophic transfer factor was >1 for all metals. Thus, the four metals have a high potential of being biomagnified in the intertidal rocky shore food chain. MeHg possessed the highest and Hg(II) and Cd the lowest potential of trophic transfer among the four metals considered.     

Would adding scallop shells (Chlamys islandica) to the sea bottom enhance recruitment of commercial species?

We examined the impact of adding scallop shells (byproduct of the fisheries) to sandy and rocky sea bottoms in the northern Gulf of St. Lawrence. The effect of adding shells was greatest on sandy bottoms where species richness increased 3.7-fold and species diversity 1.9-fold. The increase in most species was due to immigration rather than new settlement. Trials examining the effect of different densities of shells in plots of the same size (4 m²) showed that species diversity increased rapidly with shell abundance and levelled off when shells covered half of the bottom, whereas species richness only levelled off when shells almost completely covered the bottom. Trials examining the effect of the size of the shell patches (shell density being kept constant) showed that species diversity was already maximal in 1-m² plots, whereas species richness only attained a plateau at 4 m². Our small-scale trials indicate that the addition of shells would have a positive impact, increasing numerous invertebrates, including commercial species (scallops, whelks and urchins).     

Operationalizing biodiversity for conservation planning

Biodiversity has acquired such a general meaning that people now find it difficult to pin down a precise sense for planning and policy-making aimed at biodiversity conservation. Because biodiversity is rooted in place, the task of conserving biodiversity should target places for conservation action; and because all places contain biodiversity, but not all places can be targeted for action, places have to be prioritized. What is needed for this is a measure of the extent to which biodiversity varies from place to place. We do not need a precise measure of biodiversity to prioritize places. Relative estimates of similarity or difference can be derived using partial measures, or what have come to be called biodiversity surrogates. Biodiversity surrogates are supposed to stand in for general biodiversity in planning applications. We distinguish between true surrogates, those that might truly stand in for general biodiversity, and estimator surrogates, which have true surrogates as their target variable. For example, species richness has traditionally been the estimator surrogate for the true surrogate, species diversity. But species richness does not capture the differences in composition between places; the essence of biodiversity. Another measure, called complementarity, explicitly captures the differences between places as we iterate the process of place prioritization, starting with an initial place. The relative concept of biodiversity built into the definition of complementarity has the level of precision needed to undertake conservation planning.     

The effects of gastropod shell availability and habitat characteristics on shell utilization by the intertidal hermit crab Pagurus longicarpus Say

The shell utilization patterns of two intertidal populations of the hermit crab, Pagurus longicarpus Say, were studied. The populations differed with respect to the physical characteristics of their habitats and the availability of empty gastropod shells. The first population was in an estuary connected to Narragansett Bay. This population had few, if any. empty shells available in the area. The second population was in a rock-cobble area directly on Block Island Sound. There were large numbers of empty gastropod shells available for this population. The consistently high gastropod mortality on this shore appears to be caused by the animals being washed up on the beach, where they die due to desiccation.Data from samples collected from June to November of both 1974 and 1975 showed that there were distinct differences in the shell utilization patterns of the two populations. A greater proportion of the animals collected from the estuary population inhabited damaged shells and/or shells with symbionts compared to the individuals from the population with large numbers of empty shells available.The results of shell selection experiments indicated that individuals from both populations inhabited less than preferred shells. The population with large numbers of empty shells available was qualitatively shell-limited because of the effect of physical factors on the morphology of the gastropod species of that area. In addition, the shell selection experiments showed that individuals from the two areas had significantly different shell preferences. This result may be explained by the effects of the environment on the growth rates of the hermit crabs and/or as an indication that shell preferences may vary in response to the physical factors of a given habitat.     

Shell-shape variation in Faroese dog-whelks (Nucella lapillus (L.))

Nucella lapillus is a common and widely distributed carnivorous gastropod of North Atlantic rocky sea shores. Populations of this animal usually show variation in shell shape according to the exposure of their habitat to wave action, with individuals from exposed sites having a short squat shell and a wide aperture as compared with a more elongated form seen in shelter. The same pattern of variation is seen over most of the species European range, but there are some exceptions. One of these has been described in Sullom Voe (Shetland) and this prompted an investigation of Faroese populations to ascertain whether they behaved in a similar manner. It is shown in this paper that Faroese populations vary in shell shape with exposure in the usual way (and not like those in Shetland) and moreover show such a fine and precise reflection of minor alterations in environmental conditions that measurement of dog-whelk shells may prove to be the best way of 'measuring' exposure in Faroe.     

Character displacement, frequency-dependent selection, and divergence of shell colour in land snails Mandarina (Pulmonata)

Endemic land snails of the genus Mandarina of the oceanic Bonin Islands offer an exceptional example of habitat and character divergence among closely related species. In this study, microhabitat differences between sympatric ground-dwelling species were studied by distinguishing habitats on the basis of vegetation and types of litter. In all sites where two ground species coexisted, segregation occurred with each species showing preference for the microhabitat in which they were found. When they were in sympatry, one species was predominant in relatively wet and sheltered sites and the other in relatively dry and exposed sites. Although most species can live in both types of habitat, occupation by one species is inhibited by occupation by another. This suggests that competitive interaction between sympatric species caused segregation. Except for populations that have undergone interspecific hybridization, no examples were found of sympatric populations of two ground species sharing a similar shell colour. Species that were predominant in relatively wet and sheltered sites possessed shells with dark coloration and their colour patterns were mostly of one type. Species that were predominant in relatively dry and exposed sites possessed shells with bright coloration and their color patterns were polymorphic. Most populations from areas in which single species were distributed had shells with medium coloration. Microhabitat differentiation between sympatric species possibly caused diversification of shell colour, because bright shells are advantageous in sites where snails are largely exposed, and dark shells are advantageous in sites in where they are mostly sheltered from sunlight. In addition, frequency-dependent selection by predators hunting by sight may have operated to maintain colour polymorphism in the populations which are restricted to exposed habitats by competition with other sympatric species. This reveals the importance of interaction among closely related species as a cause of diversification in ecological and morphological traits.