Interactions between Marek's Disease Herpesvirus and Avian Leucosis Virus in Tissue Culture

A GROUP B herpesvirus is important in the aetiology of Marek's disease, a highly contagious lymphoproliferative disease of chickens^1,2. Chicks inoculated with enveloped Marek's disease herpesvirus (MDHV), extracted from feather follicle epithelium of chickens with the disease, developed tumour-like aggregates of lymphoid cells in the viscera and frequently in the peripheral nerves^3,4. Cultures of chicken embryo fibroblast (CEF) cells infected with MDHV develop discrete foci of altered cells⁵. Our data show that MDHV infection of cultures of CEF cells, previously infected with an avian leucosis virus (RAV-2), results in both a reduction in the number of MDHV foci and an increase in the complement fixing avian leucosis antigen (COFAL)⁶ titre.     

Embryonic infection with the endogenous avian leukosis virus Rous-associated virus-0 alters responses to exogenous avian leukosis virus infection.

We inoculated susceptible chicken embryos with the endogenous avian leukosis virus Rous-associated virus-0 (RAV-0) on day 6 of incubation. At 1 week after hatching, RAV-0-infected and control chickens were inoculated with either RAV-1 or RAV-2, exogenous viruses belonging to subgroups A and B, respectively. The chickens injected with RAV-0 as embryos remained viremic with exogenous virus longer and either failed to develop type-specific humoral immunity to exogenous virus or developed it later than the control chickens not inoculated with RAV-0. The RAV-0-injected chickens also developed neoplasms at a much higher frequency than did the control chickens. We suggest that the lower immune responses of the RAV-0-injected chickens were due to an immunological tolerance to envelope group-specific glycoproteins shared among endogenous and exogenous viruses.     

Isolation and Characterization of an Isolate (HN) of Marek's Disease Virus with Low Pathogenicity

A cytopathic agent was isolated and characterized as an isolate of Marek''s disease herpesvirus (MDHV) with low pathogenicity, and referred to as the HN isolate. This isolate of MDHV did not cause clinical Marek''s disease (MD) or death in a highly susceptible line of chickens within 5 weeks after exposure. Gross lesions of limited extent were noted in a few of the inoculated birds. Microscopic nerve lesions in the inoculated and contact-infected birds were invariably minimal, closely resembling C-type MD lesions.     

Isolation and Characterization of an Isolate (HN) of Marek''s Disease Virus with Low Pathogenicity

A cytopathic agent was isolated and characterized as an isolate of Marek's disease herpesvirus (MDHV) with low pathogenicity, and referred to as the HN isolate. This isolate of MDHV did not cause clinical Marek's disease (MD) or death in a highly susceptible line of chickens within 5 weeks after exposure. Gross lesions of limited extent were noted in a few of the inoculated birds. Microscopic nerve lesions in the inoculated and contact-infected birds were invariably minimal, closely resembling C-type MD lesions.     

Susceptibility to erbB-induced erythroblastosis is a dominant trait of 151 chickens.

Rous-associated virus-1 (RAV-1)-induced erythroblastosis results from proviral insertions into or viral transductions of the c-erbB region of the epidermal growth factor gene. Most chickens develop low incidences (less than 5%) of RAV-1-induced erythroblastosis. However, an inbred line of chickens (151) suffers high incidences (approximately 80%) of RAV-1-induced erythroblastosis. Analysis of 151, K28, and (K28 X 151) X K28 chickens for susceptibility to RAV-1-induced erythroblastosis revealed that susceptibility to RAV-1-induced erythroblastosis is a dominant trait of line 151 chickens. Analysis of 151 X K28 and K28 chicks for susceptibility to the induction of erythroblastosis by two new c-erbB-transducing viruses (avian erythroblastosis virus strains AEV-5005 and AEV-5009) revealed that susceptibility to transformation by new c-erbB-transducing viruses is also a dominant trait of 151 chickens. We think it is likely that both of these dominant traits are encoded by the same gene or genes. Our hypothesis is that this gene (or genes) potentiates the ability of the transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains of the epidermal growth factor receptor to transform cells.     

Sequence of the Long Terminal Repeat and Adjacent Segments of the Endogenous Avian Virus Rous-Associated Virus 0

Rous-associated virus 0 (RAV-0), an endogenous chicken virus, does not cause disease when inoculated into susceptible domestic chickens. An infectious unintegrated circular RAV-0 DNA was molecularly cloned, and the sequence of the long terminal repeat (LTR) and adjacent segments was determined. The sequence of the LTR was found to be very similar to that of replication-defective endogenous virus EV-1. Like the EV-1 LTR, the RAV-0 LTR is smaller (278 base pairs instead of 330) than the LTRs of the oncogenic members of the avian sarcoma virus-avian leukosis virus group. There is, however, significant homology. The most striking differences are in the U(3) region of the LTR, and in this region there are a series of small segments present in the oncogenic viruses which are absent in RAV-0. These differences in the U(3) region of the LTR could account for the differences in the oncogenic potential of RAV-0 and the avian leukosis viruses. I also compared the regions adjacent to the RAV-0 LTR with the available avian sarcoma virus sequences. A segment of approximately 200 bases to the right of the LTR (toward gag) is almost identical in RAV-0 and the Prague C strain of Rous sarcoma virus. The segment of RAV-0 which lies between the end of the env gene and U(3) is approximately 190 bases in length. Essentially this entire segment is present between env and src in the Schmidt-Ruppin A strain of Rous sarcoma virus. Most of this segment is also present between env and src in Prague C; however, in Prague C there is an apparent deletion of 40 bases in the region adjacent to env. In Schmidt-Ruppin A, but not in Prague C, about half of this segment is also present between src and the LTR. This arrangement has implications for the mechanism by which src was acquired. The region which encoded the gp37 portion of env appears to be very similar in RAV-0 and the Rous sarcoma viruses. However, differences at the very end of env imply that the carboxy termini of RAV-0, Schmidt-Ruppin A, and Prague C gp37s are significantly different. The implications of these observations are considered.     

Homology between avian oncornavirus RNAs and DNA from several avian species.

3H-labeled 35S RNA from avian myeloblastosis virus (AMV), Rous associated virus (RAV)-0, RAV-60, RAV-61, RAV-2, or B-77(w) was hybridized with an excess of cellular DNA from different avian species, i.e., normal or leukemic chickens, normal pheasants, turkeys, Japanese quails, or ducks. Approximately two to three copies of endogenous viral DNA were estimated to be present per diploid of normal chicken cell genome. In leukemic chicken myeloblasts induced by AMV, the number of viral sequences appeared to have doubled. The hybrids formed between viral RNA and DNA from leukemic chicken cells melted with a Tm 1 to 6 C higher than that of hybrids formed between viral RNA and normal chicken cell DNA. All of the viral RNAs tested, except RAV-61, hybridized the most with DNA from AMV-infected chicken cells, followed by DNA from normal chicken cells, and then pheasant DNA. RAV-61 RNA hybridized maximally (39%) with pheasant DNA, followed by DNA from leukemic (34%), and then normal (29%) chicken cells. All viral RNAs tested hybridized little with Japanese quail DNA (2 to 5%), turkey DNA (2 to 4%), or duck DNA (1%). DNA from normal chicken cells contained only 60 to 70% of the RAV-60 genetic information, and normal pheasant cells lacked some RAV-61 DNA sequences. RAV-60 and RAV-61 genomes were more homologous to the RAV-0 genome than to the genome of RAV-2, AMV, or B-77(s). RAV-60 and RAV-61 appear to be recombinants between endogenous and exogenous viruses.     

Enhancer activity correlates with the oncogenic potential of avian retroviruses.

Avian retroviruses lacking an oncogene, such as Rous-associated virus 1 (RAV-1), RAV-2, and td mutants of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), can nevertheless cause leukemias and other neoplastic diseases. During this process, viral DNA integrates near a cellular proto-oncogene, such as c-myc, and thus de-regulates its expression. The virus RAV-0, on the other hand, is known to be non-oncogenic even in long-term in vivo infections of domestic chickens. The major difference between oncogenic and non-oncogenic viruses is found within the U3 region of the long terminal repeat (LTR) which is known to harbor the promoter and enhancer elements. We therefore wanted to see whether viral oncogenicity was correlated with enhancer activity. Using a variety of techniques (including the SV40 'enhancer trap' from which we obtained RSV-SV40 recombinant viruses), we demonstrate that a strong enhancer exists within the LTRs of both RSV and RAV-1. In contrast, no enhancer is present in RAV-0, although RAV-0 has functional promoter elements. Our data therefore strongly support a concept of oncogenesis by enhancer insertion.     

In vivo cooperation of two nuclear oncogenic proteins, P135gag-myb-ets and p61/63myc, leads to transformation and immortalization of chicken myelomonocytic cells.

To investigate a possible in vivo cooperation between the p61/63myc and P135gag-myb-ets proteins, we used a previously constructed retrovirus, named MHE226, which contains the fused v-myb and v-ets oncogenes of the E26 retrovirus and the v-myc oncogene of MH2. For that purpose, chicken neuroretina cells producing MHE226 and pseudotyped with the Rous associated virus-1 (RAV-1) helper virus were injected in 1-day-old chickens. In control experiments, we also injected chicken neuroretina cells producing E26 (RAV-1), RAV-1 alone, or constructs lacking one of the oncogenes of MHE226. The average life span of MHE226-infected chickens is half that of E26-infected chickens. MHE226-infected chickens harbor tumors scattered in many organs, but compared with E26, MHE226 induced a weak leukemia. Study of integration sites suggests that the majority of the tumors results from clonal or oligoclonal events. Cell cultures were derived from the tumors of MHE226-infected chickens and grown in standard medium without addition of exogenous chicken myelomonocytic growth factor. These cells still divide at high rate after more than 100 passages and can thus be considered immortalized. By using several criteria, these cells were characterized as precursors of the myelomonocytic lineages.     

Induction of neoplasms by subgroup E recombinants of exogenous and endogenous avian retroviruses (Rous-associated virus type 60).

Chickens susceptible to infection with subgroup E viruses were inoculated with four independent isolates of Rous-associated virus type 60 (RAV-60) that are subgroup e recombinants of endogenous and exogenous virus. Neoplasms developed in each inoculated group. Therefore, nontransforming viruses of subgroup E can induce lymphoid leukosis at a moderate rate compared with RAV-0, a subgroup E endogenous virus, suggesting that oncogenicity is not a viral envelope (env)-related characteristic. Since the common (c) regions of the RAV-60s examined were of exogenous origin, we suggest that the c region rather than env is important for a high rate of induction of lymphoid leukosis and related neoplasms.     

Long terminal repeat (LTR) sequences, env, and a region near the 5'' LTR influence the pathogenic potential of recombinants between Rous-associated virus types 0 and 1.

A series of recombinants between Rous-associated virus type 0 (RAV-0), RAV-1, and a replication-competent avian leukosis virus vector (RCAN) have been tested for disease potential in day-old inoculated K28 chicks. RAV-0 is a benign virus, whereas RAV-1 and RCAN induce lymphoma and a low incidence of a variety of other neoplasms. The results of the oncogenicity tests indicate that (i) the long terminal repeat regions of RAV-1 and RCAN play a major role in disease potential, (ii) subgroup A envelope glycoproteins are associated with a two- to fourfold higher incidence of lymphoma than subgroup E glycoproteins, and (iii) certain combinations of 5' viral and env sequences cause osteopetrosis in a highly context-dependent manner. Long terminal repeat and env sequences appeared to influence lymphomogenic potential by determining the extent of bursal infection within the first 2 to 3 weeks of life. This would suggest that bursal but not postbursal stem cells are targets for avian leukosis virus-induced lymphomogenesis. The induction of neutralizing antibody had no obvious influence on the incidence of lymphoma.     

Integration of Rous-associated virus type O provirus in susceptible chicken cells.

The number of viral genome equivalents per haploid cell genome was determined in normal chicken embryos from three selected chicken lines and in cultured fibroblasts (CEF) from these embryos. The cellular concentration of endogenous proviral DNA is similar in embryos from chickens of lines SPAFAS, 7, 15, 7 x 15, and 100. The concentration of proviral DNA is not affected by in vitro cultivation in CEF from lines that do not spontaneously produce virus, nor in CEF from line 7, which lacks receptors for Rous-associated virus type 0 (RAV-0). There is, however, a restricted increase in the number of integrated proviral genome equivalents in CEF from line 7 x 15, which produces RAV-0 and can support replication of this virus, and in CEF from line 15 experimentally infected with RAV-0.     

Ev 2, a genetic locus containing structural genes for endogenous virus, codes for Rous-associated virus type 0 produced by line 72 chickens.

ev 2 is one of seven recently described genetic loci of chickens which contain structural genes for endogenous virus. ev 2 is present exclusively in line 72 chickens, an inbred strain of white Leghorns which is homozygous for the capacity to produce Rous-associated virus type 0 (RAV-0), a subgroup E virus. This phenotype is known as V+ and has been assigned a genetic allele designated V-E7. The segregation of ev 2 was followed in a genetic cross in which the V-E7+ phenotype was also segregating. The progeny of the cross were analyzed for endogenous viral loci by cleavage of embryo DNA with restriction endonuclease SstI, electrophoretic separation of the resulting fragments, and identification of bands containing viral sequences by hybridization of the DNA to radiolabeled viral RNA. Four endogenous viral loci, ev 1, ev 2, ev 4, and ev 5, were identified in the progeny of the cross. One of the progeny contained no detectable endogenous viral sequences. ev 1, ev 4, and ev 5 were present in progeny of both the V-E7+ and V-E7- phenotypes. ev 2 was present exclusively in progeny of the V-E7+ phenotype, and all V-E7+ progeny contained ev 2. In addition, one of the V-E7+ progeny contained only ev 2. FRom these data, we conclude that ev 2 codes for RAV-0 virus produced by the cells of line 72 chickens.     

Recombinants between endogenous and exogenous avian tumor viruses: role of the C region and other portions of the genome in the control of replication and transformation.

Endogenous retroviruses of chickens are closely related to exogenous viruses isolated from spontaneous tumors in the same species, yet differ in a number of important characteristics, including the ability to transform cells in culture, ability to cause sarcomas or leukemias, host range, and growth rate in cell culture. To correlate these differences with specific sequence differences between the two viral genomes, the genome RNA of transforming subgroup E recombinants between the Prague strain of Rous sarcoma virus, subgroup B (Pr-RSV-B), and the endogenous Rous-associated virus-0 (RAV-0), Subgroup E, and seven nontransforming subgroup E recombinants between the transformation-defective mutant of Pr-RSV-B and RAV-0 was examined by oligonucleotide fingerprinting. The pattern of inheritance among the recombinant viruses of regions of the genome in which Pr-RSV-B and RAV-0 differ allowed us to draw the following conclusions. (i) Nonselected parts of the genome were, with a few exceptions, inherited by the recombinant virus progeny randomly from either parent, with no obvious linkage between neighboring sequences. (ii) A small region in the Pr-RSV-B genome which maps in the 5' region was found in all transforming but only some of the nontransforming recombinants, suggesting that it plays a role in the control of the expression of transformation. (iii) A region of the Pr-RSV-B genome which maps between env and src was similarly linked to the src gene and may be either part of the structural gene for src or a control sequence regulating the expression of src. (iv) The C region at the extreme 3' end of the virus genome which is closely related in all the exogenous avian retroviruses but distinctly different in the endogenous viruses is the major determinant responsible for the differences in growth rate between RAV-0 and Pr-RSV-B. This latter observation allowed us to redefine the C region as a genetic locus, c, with two alleles cn (in RAV-0) and cx (in exogenous viruses).     

Intracellular restriction on the growth of induced subgroup E avian type C viruses in chicken cells.

Subgroup E avian type C viruses produced by bromodeoxyuridine-treated 100 X 7, line 7, or line C chicken cells were restricted in their intracellular growth on K28 chicken cells but not on line 15 chicken cells. Cells from embryos of line 15 chickens bred with K28 chickens did not restrict the growth of the subgroup E induced leukosis viruses (ILVs). This result indicates that the phenotype for the intracellular restriction of the growth of subgroup E ILVs found in K28 cells is recessive. Long-term growth of the subgroup E ILVs in K28 cells resulted in the appearance of subgroup E virus that grew well on K28 cells. No change in growth characteristics was observed for subgroup E ILVs grown in line 15 cells indicating that appearance of nonrestricted virus occurred only during growth of the subgrouo E ILVs on a restrictive host. RAV-0, a subgroup E virus closely related to the ilvs, had the same growth characteristics as the subgroup E ILVs. RAV-60, a subgroup E virus formed by recombination of exogenous avian leukosis virus with endogenous subgroup E virus coat information, grew well on both line 15 and K28 cells.     

Systematic pathogenesis and replication of avian hepatitis E virus in specific-pathogen-free adult chickens

Hepatitis E virus (HEV) is an important human pathogen. Due to the lack of a cell culture system and a practical animal model for HEV, little is known about its pathogenesis and replication. The discovery of a strain of HEV in chickens, designated avian HEV, prompted us to evaluate chickens as a model for the study of HEV. Eighty-five 60-week-old specific-pathogen-free chickens were randomly divided into three groups. Group 1 chickens (n=28) were each inoculated with 5 x 10(4.5) 50% chicken infectious doses of avian HEV by the oronasal route, group 2 chickens (n=29) were each inoculated with the same dose by the intravenous (i.v.) route, and group 3 chickens (n=28) were not inoculated and were used as controls. Two chickens from each group were necropsied at 1, 3, 5, 7, 10, 13, 16, 20, 24, 28, 35, and 42 days postinoculation (dpi), and the remaining chickens were necropsied at 56 dpi. Serum, fecal, and various tissue samples, including liver and spleen samples, were collected at each necropsy for pathological and virological testing. By 21 dpi, all oronasally and i.v. inoculated chickens had seroconverted. Fecal virus shedding was detected variably from 1 to 20 dpi for the i.v. group and from 10 to 56 dpi for the oronasal group. Avian HEV RNA was detected in serum, bile, and liver samples from both i.v. and oronasally inoculated chickens. Gross liver lesions, characterized by subcapsular hemorrhages or enlargement of the right intermediate lobe, were observed in 7 of 28 oronasally and 7 of 29 i.v. inoculated chickens. Microscopic liver lesions were mainly lymphocytic periphlebitis and phlebitis. The lesion scores were higher for oronasal (P=0.0008) and i.v. (P=0.0029) group birds than for control birds. Slight elevations of the plasma liver enzyme lactate dehydrogenase were observed in infected chickens. The results indicated that chickens are a useful model for studying HEV replication and pathogenesis. This is the first report of HEV transmission via its natural route in a homologous animal model.     

Marke''s disease herpesviruses. III. Purification and characterization of Marek''s disease herpesvirus B antigen.

Sera from chickens naturally infected with Marek's disease herpesvirus (MDHV) form preciptin lines with at least two immunologically distinct soluble antigens designated MDHV-A and MDHV-B. Partial purification and characterization of the glycoprotein MDHV-A antigen was previously reported. MDHV-B was found predominantly in the sonically treated extracts of infected cells, in contrast to the predominantly extracellular MDHV-A. Analysis of these extracts from [14C]glucosamine-labeled cells by immunodiffusion with chicken anti MDHV-B serum negative for MDHV-A followed by autoradiography confirmed that MDHV-B was a common antigen between MDHV and herpesvirus of turkeys and revealed that it was also a glycoprotein. Because of their glycoprotein nature, both MDHV-A and MDHV-B bound to concanavalin A affinity chromatography columns and could then be eluted by alpha-methyl-D-mannoside and recovered for further analysis. Concanavalin A affinity chromatography was an excellent technique for initial purification of MDHV-A and MDHV-B, since approximately 5- and 15- fold purification, respectively, was achieved in a single simple step. MDHV-B was resistant to trypsin under conditions where MDHV-A was sensitive, but was similar to MDHV-A in resistance to pH 2.0 and to 1.0 or 2.0 M urea and 0.05% Brij 35. Partially purified MDHV-B was analyzed by sucrose gradient sedimentation, isoelectric focusing, and gel filtration on Sephadex G-200 in the presence of 1.0 or 2.0 M urea and 0.05% Brij 35 to purify the antigen and to determine its physical and chemical properties in comparison with those already reported for MDHV-A. MDHV-B had a much lower isoelectric point in pH 4,54, a higher sedimentation coefficient of 4.4S, and a greater molecular weight of 58,250. These data indicate that MDHV-B is physically distinct from MDHV-A antigen, although the size difference is not sufficient to allow for effective separation. In contrast, the isoelectric point difference of greater than 2 pH units makes isoelectric focusing an effective means of purifying the antigens free of one another. The four-step purification procedure achieved greater than 200-fold purification of MDHV-B. Immunization of rabbits with this highly purified antigen results in the preparation of antisera that appeared monospecific for MDHV-B in immunodiffusion.     

Pathogenicity for Chickens of a Paramyxovirus Type 1, Isolated from Racing Pigeons in Sweden

Strains of paramyxovirus type 1 (PMV-1) have been isolated from diseased racing pigeons in Sweden. One of these isolates was selected for studies of the pathogenicity and contagiousness in chickens. The same isolate was previously found to have a high intravenous pathogenicity index (IVPI) in 6 weeks old chickens. In three experiments it was found that the PMV-1 isolate was very pathogenic for 1 week old chickens but not pathogenic for 120 day old pullets inoculated intranasally and ocularly. Symptoms in the young chickens were similar to those seen in the neurotropic form of Newcastle disease. The mortality was high and the incubation period 5–11 days. The disease easily spread to young chickens kept in contact with diseased birds. The microscopic examination revealed an interstitial nonpurulent pneumonia and a nonpurulent encephalitis in the young chickens. In the pullets the only finding was a mild encephalitis. PMV-1 was recovered from all young chickens but not from the pullets. Both the chickens and the inoculated pullets developed antibodies to PMV-1.