Variants of DNA polymerase Beta extend mispaired DNA due to increased affinity for nucleotide substrate

DNA polymerase beta offers an attractive system to study the biochemical mechanism of polymerase-dependent mutagenesis. Variants of DNA polymerase beta, Y265F and Y265W, were analyzed for misincorporation efficiency and mispair extension ability, relative to wild-type DNA polymerase beta. Our data show that the fidelity of the mutant polymerases is similar to wild-type enzyme on a one-nucleotide gapped DNA substrate. In contrast, with a six-nucleotide gapped DNA, the mutant proteins are slightly more accurate than the wild-type enzyme. The mutagenic potential of Y265F and Y265W is more pronounced when encountering a mispaired DNA substrate. Here, both variants can extend a G:G mispair quite efficiently, and Y265F can also extend a T:G mispair. The kinetic basis of the increased mispair extension efficiency is due to an improved ability to bind to the incoming nucleotide. Y265W extends the G:G mispair even with an incorrect nucleotide substrate. Overall, our results demonstrate that the Y265 hinge residue is important for stabilizing the architecture of the nucleotide binding pocket of DNA polymerase beta, and that alterations of this residue can have significant impacts upon the fidelity of DNA synthesis.     

Mismatched base-pair simulations for ASFV Pol X/DNA complexes help interpret frequent G*G misincorporation

DNA polymerase X (pol X) from the African swine fever virus is a 174-amino-acid repair polymerase that likely participates in a viral base excision repair mechanism, characterized by low fidelity. Surprisingly, pol X's insertion rate of the G*G mispair is comparable to that of the four Watson-Crick base pairs. This behavior is in contrast with another X-family polymerase, DNA polymerase beta (pol beta), which inserts G*G mismatches poorly, and has higher DNA repair fidelity. Using molecular dynamics simulations, we previously provided support for an induced-fit mechanism for pol X in the presence of the correct incoming nucleotide. Here, we perform molecular dynamics simulations of pol X/DNA complexes with different incoming incorrect nucleotides in various orientations [C*C, A*G, and G*G (anti) and A*G and G*G (syn)] and compare the results to available kinetic data and prior modeling. Intriguingly, the simulations reveal that the G*G mispair with the incoming nucleotide in the syn configuration undergoes large-scale conformational changes similar to that observed in the presence of correct base pair (G*C). The base pairing in the G*G mispair is achieved via Hoogsteen hydrogen bonding with an overall geometry that is well poised for catalysis. Simulations for other mismatched base pairs show that an intermediate closed state is achieved for the A*G and G*G mispair with the incoming dGTP in anti conformation, while the protein remains near the open conformation for the C*C and the A*G syn mismatches. In addition, catalytic site geometry and base pairing at the nascent template-incoming nucleotide interaction reveal distortions and misalignments that range from moderate for A*G anti to worst for the C*C complex. These results agree well with kinetic data for pol X and provide a structural/dynamic basis to explain, at atomic level, the fidelity of this polymerase compared with other members of the X family. In particular, the more open and pliant active site of pol X, compared to pol beta, allows pol X to accommodate bulkier mismatches such as guanine opposite guanine, while the more structured and organized pol beta active site imposes higher discrimination, which results in higher fidelity. The possibility of syn conformers resonates with other low-fidelity enzymes such as Dpo4 (from the Y family), which readily accommodate oxidative lesions.     

Nucleotide-induced DNA polymerase active site motions accommodating a mutagenic DNA intermediate

DNA polymerases occasionally insert the wrong nucleotide. For this error to become a mutation, the mispair must be extended. We report a structure of DNA polymerase beta (pol beta) with a DNA mismatch at the boundary of the polymerase active site. The structure of this complex indicates that the templating adenine of the mispair stacks with the primer terminus adenine while the templating (coding) cytosine is flipped out of the DNA helix. Soaking the crystals of the binary complex with dGTP resulted in crystals of a ternary substrate complex. In this case, the templating cytosine is observed within the DNA helix and forms Watson-Crick hydrogen bonds with the incoming dGTP. The adenine at the primer terminus has rotated into a syn-conformation to interact with the opposite adenine in a planar configuration. Yet, the 3'-hydroxyl on the primer terminus is out of position for efficient nucleotide insertion.     

Rapid segmental and subdomain motions of DNA polymerase beta

DNA polymerase (pol) beta is a two-domain DNA repair enzyme that undergoes structural transitions upon binding substrates. Crystallographic structures indicate that these transitions include movement of the amino-terminal 8-kDa lyase domain relative to the 31-kDa polymerase domain. Additionally, a polymerase subdomain moves toward the nucleotide-binding pocket after nucleotide binding, resulting in critical contacts between alpha-helix N and the nascent base pair. Kinetic and structural characterization of pol beta has suggested that these conformational changes participate in stabilizing the ternary enzyme-substrate complex facilitating chemistry. To probe the microenvironment and dynamics of both the lyase domain and alpha-helix N in the polymerase domain, the single native tryptophan (Trp-325) of wild-type enzyme was replaced with alanine, and tryptophan was strategically substituted for residues in the lyase domain (F25W/W325A) or near the end of alpha-helix N (L287W/W325A). Influences of substrate on the fluorescence anisotropy decay of these single tryptophan forms of pol beta were determined. The results revealed that the segmental motion of alpha-helix N was rapid ( approximately 1 ns) and far more rapid than the step that limits chemistry. Binding of Mg(2+) and/or gapped DNA did not cause a noticeable change in the rotational correlation time or angular amplitude of tryptophan in alpha-helix N. More important, binding of a correct nucleotide significantly limited the angular range of the nanosecond motion within alpha-helix N. In contrast, the segmental motion of the 8-kDa domain was "frozen" upon DNA binding alone, and this restriction did not increase further upon nucleotide binding. The dynamics of alpha-helix N are discussed from the perspective of the "open" to "closed" conformational change of pol beta deduced from crystallography, and the results are more generally discussed in the context of reaction cycle-regulated flexibility for proteins acting as molecular motors.     

The E288K Colon Tumor Variant of DNA Polymerase β Is a Sequence Specific Mutator

DNA polymerase β (pol β) is the main polymerase involved in base excision repair (BER), which is a pathway responsible for the repair of tens of thousands of DNA lesions per cell per day. Our recent efforts in sequencing colon tumors showed that 40% of the tumors sequenced possessed a variant in the coding region of the POLB gene; one of these variants is E288K. Expression of the E288K variant in cells leads to an increase in the frequency of mutations at AT base pairs. In vitro, the E288K variant is as active as and binds one-base-gapped DNA with the same affinity as wild-type pol β. Single-turnover kinetic data for the E288K variant show that its mutator phenotype is specific for misincorporating opposite template A up to 6-fold more than the wild-type enzyme and that this is due to a decrease in the degree of discrimination in nucleotide binding. Molecular modeling suggests that the substitution of Lys at position 288 causes the polymerase to adopt a more open conformation, which may be disrupting the nucleotide binding pocket. This may explain the reduced degree of discrimination at the level of nucleotide binding. The enhanced mutagenesis of the E288K variant could lead to genomic instability and ultimately a malignant tumor phenotype.     

Mismatch-induced conformational distortions in polymerase beta support an induced-fit mechanism for fidelity

Molecular dynamics simulations of DNA polymerase (pol) beta complexed with different incorrect incoming nucleotides (G x G, G x T, and T x T template base x incoming nucleotide combinations) at the template-primer terminus are analyzed to delineate structure-function relationships for aberrant base pairs in a polymerase active site. Comparisons, made to pol beta structure and motions in the presence of a correct base pair, are designed to gain atomically detailed insights into the process of nucleotide selection and discrimination. In the presence of an incorrect incoming nucleotide, alpha-helix N of the thumb subdomain believed to be required for pol beta's catalytic cycling moves toward the open conformation rather than the closed conformation as observed for the correct base pair (G x C) before the chemical reaction. Correspondingly, active-site residues in the microenvironment of the incoming base are in intermediate conformations for non-Watson-Crick pairs. The incorrect incoming nucleotide and the corresponding template residue assume distorted conformations and do not form Watson-Crick bonds. Furthermore, the coordination number and the arrangement of ligands observed around the catalytic and nucleotide binding magnesium ions are mismatch specific. Significantly, the crucial nucleotidyl transferase reaction distance (P(alpha)-O3') for the mismatches between the incoming nucleotide and the primer terminus is not ideally compatible with the chemical reaction of primer extension that follows these conformational changes. Moreover, the extent of active-site distortion can be related to experimentally determined rates of nucleotide misincorporation and to the overall energy barrier associated with polymerase activity. Together, our studies provide structure-function insights into the DNA polymerase-induced constraints (i.e., alpha-helix N conformation, DNA base pair bonding, conformation of protein residues in the vicinity of dNTP, and magnesium ions coordination) during nucleotide discrimination and pol beta-nucleotide interactions specific to each mispair and how they may regulate fidelity. They also lend further support to our recent hypothesis that additional conformational energy barriers are involved following nucleotide binding but prior to the chemical reaction.     

Influence of DNA structure on DNA polymerase beta active site function: extension of mutagenic DNA intermediates

In the ternary substrate complex of DNA polymerase (pol) beta, the nascent base pair (templating and incoming nucleotides) is sandwiched between the duplex DNA terminus and polymerase. To probe molecular interactions in the dNTP-binding pocket, we analyzed the kinetic behavior of wild-type pol beta on modified DNA substrates that alter the structure of the DNA terminus and represent mutagenic intermediates. The DNA substrates were modified to 1) alter the sequence of the duplex terminus (matched and mismatched), 2) introduce abasic sites near the nascent base pair, and 3) insert extra bases in the primer or template strands to mimic frameshift intermediates. The results indicate that the nucleotide insertion efficiency (k(cat)/K(m), dGTP-dC) is highly dependent on the sequence identity of the matched (i.e. Watson-Crick base pair) DNA terminus (template/primer, G/C approximately A/T > T/A approximately C/G). Mismatches at the primer terminus strongly diminish correct nucleotide insertion efficiency but do not affect DNA binding affinity. Transition intermediates are generally extended more easily than transversions. Most mismatched primer termini decrease the rate of insertion and binding affinity of the incoming nucleotide. In contrast, the loss of catalytic efficiency with homopurine mismatches at the duplex DNA terminus is entirely due to the inability to insert the incoming nucleotide, since K(d)((dGTP)) is not affected. Abasic sites and extra nucleotides in and around the duplex terminus decrease catalytic efficiency and are more detrimental to the nascent base pair binding pocket when situated in the primer strand than the equivalent position in the template strand.     

Loop II of DNA polymerase beta is important for discrimination during substrate binding

Loop II of DNA polymerase beta (pol β) consists of 14 amino acid residues and is highly flexible and solvent exposed. Previous research from our laboratory has shown that this loop is important for polymerase activity and fidelity. In the study presented here, we demonstrate that a shortened five amino acid residue loop compromises the fidelity of pol β. This five-residue loop, termed ENEYP, induces one base frameshift errors and A–C transversions within a specific sequence context. We demonstrate that ENEYP misincorporates dGTP opposite template A at higher efficiencies than wild-type pol β. The kinetic basis for misincorporation is a defect in discrimination of the correct from incorrect dNTP substrate at the level of ground-state binding. Our results are consistent with the idea that loop II of pol β functions to maintain accurate DNA synthesis by a direct or indirect influence on the nucleotide binding pocket.     

The E249K mutator mutant of DNA polymerase beta extends mispaired termini

The DNA polymerase beta mutant enzyme, which is altered from glutamic acid to lysine at position 249, exhibits a mutator phenotype in primer extension assays and in the herpes simplex virus-thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) forward mutation assay. The basis for this loss of accuracy was investigated by measurement of misincorporation fidelity in single turnover conditions. For the four misincorporation reactions investigated, the fidelity of the E249K mutant was not significantly different from wild type, implying that the mutator phenotype was not caused by a general inability to distinguish between correct and incorrect bases during the incorporation reaction. However, the discrimination between correct and incorrect substrates by the E249K enzyme occurred less during the conformational change and chemical steps and more during the initial binding step, compared with pol beta wild type. This implies that the E249K mutation alters the kinetic mechanism of nucleotide discrimination without reducing misincorporation fidelity. In a missing base primer extension assay, we observed that the mutant enzyme produced mispairs and extended them. This indicates that the altered fidelity of E249K could be due to loss of discrimination against mispaired primer termini. This was supported by the finding that the E249K enzyme extended a G:A mispair 8-fold more efficiently than wild type and a C:T mispair 4-fold more efficiently. These results demonstrate that an enhanced ability to extend mispairs can produce a mutator phenotype and that the Glu-249 side chain of DNA polymerase beta is critical for mispair extension fidelity.     

Structural insights into DNA polymerase beta deterrents for misincorporation support an induced-fit mechanism for fidelity

DNA polymerases generally select the correct nucleotide from a pool of structurally similar molecules to preserve Watson-Crick base-pairing rules. We report the structure of DNA polymerase beta with DNA mismatches situated in the polymerase active site. This was achieved by using nicked product DNA that traps the mispair (template-primer, A-C or T-C) in the nascent base pair binding pocket. The structure of each mispair complex indicates that the bases do not form hydrogen bonds with one another, but form a staggered arrangement where the bases of the mispair partially overlap. This prevents closure/opening of the N subdomain that is believed to be required for catalytic cycling. The partially open conformation of the N subdomain results in distinct hydrogen bonding networks that are unique for each mispair. These structures define diverse molecular aspects of misinsertion that are consistent with the induced-fit model for substrate specificity.     

Functional interactions of mitochondrial DNA polymerase and single-stranded DNA-binding protein. Template-primer DNA binding and initiation and elongation of DNA strand synthesis.

Functional interactions between mitochondrial DNA polymerase (pol gamma) and mitochondrial single-stranded DNA-binding protein (mtSSB) from Drosophila embryos have been evaluated with regard to the overall activity of pol gamma and in partial reactions involving template-primer binding and initiation and idling in DNA strand synthesis. Both the 5' --> 3' DNA polymerase and 3' --> 5' exonuclease in pol gamma are stimulated 15-20-fold on oligonucleotide-primed single-stranded DNA by native and recombinant forms of mtSSB. That the extent of stimulation is similar for both enzyme activities over a broad range of KCl concentrations suggests their functional coordination and a similar mechanism of stimulation by mtSSB. At the same time, the high mispair specificity of pol gamma in exonucleolytic hydrolysis is maintained, indicating that enhancement of pol gamma catalytic efficiency is likely not accompanied by increased nucleotide turnover. DNase I footprinting of pol gamma.DNA complexes and initial rate measurements show that mtSSB enhances primer recognition and binding and stimulates 30-fold the rate of initiation of DNA strands. Dissociation studies show that productive complexes of the native pol gamma heterodimer with template-primer DNA are formed and remain stable in the absence of replication accessory proteins.     

Minor groove interactions at the DNA polymerase beta active site modulate single-base deletion error rates

The structures of open and closed conformations of DNA polymerase beta (pol beta) suggests that the rate of single-nucleotide deletions during synthesis may be modulated by interactions in the DNA minor groove that align the templating base with the incoming dNTP. To test this hypothesis, we measured the single-base deletion error rates of wild-type pol beta and lysine and alanine mutants of Arg(283), whose side chain interacts with the minor groove edge of the templating nucleotide at the active site. The error rates of both mutant enzymes are increased >100-fold relative to wild-type pol beta. Template engineering experiments performed to distinguish among three possible models for deletion formation suggest that most deletions in repetitive sequences by pol beta initiate by strand slippage. However, pol beta also generates deletions by a different mechanism that is strongly enhanced by the substitutions at Arg(283). Analysis of error specificity suggests that this mechanism involves nucleotide misinsertion followed by primer relocation, creating a misaligned intermediate. The structure of pol beta bound to non-gapped DNA also indicates that the templating nucleotide and its downstream neighbor are out of register in the open conformation and this could facilitate misalignment (dNTP or primer terminus) with the next template base.     

DNA structure and aspartate 276 influence nucleotide binding to human DNA polymerase beta. Implication for the identity of the rate-limiting conformational change

Structures of DNA polymerase (pol) beta bound to single-nucleotide gapped DNA had revealed that the lyase and pol domains form a "doughnut-shaped" structure altering the dNTP binding pocket in a fashion that is not observed when bound to non-gapped DNA. We have investigated dNTP binding to pol beta-DNA complexes employing steady-state and pre-steady-state kinetics. Although pol beta has a kinetic scheme similar to other DNA polymerases, polymerization by pol beta is limited by at least two partially rate-limiting steps: a conformational change after dNTP ground-state binding and product release. The equilibrium binding constant, K(d)((dNTP)), decreased and the insertion efficiency increased with a one-nucleotide gapped DNA substrate, as compared with non-gapped DNA. Valine substitution for Asp(276), which interacts with the base of the incoming nucleotide, increased the binding affinity for the incoming nucleotide indicating that the negative charge contributed by Asp(276) weakens binding and that an interaction between residue 276 with the incoming nucleotide occurs during ground-state binding. Since the interaction between Asp(276) and the nascent base pair is observed only in the "closed" conformation of pol beta, the increased free energy in ground-state binding for the mutant suggests that the subsequent rate-limiting conformational change is not the "open" to "closed" structural transition, but instead is triggered in the closed pol conformation.     

Local deformations revealed by dynamics simulations of DNA polymerase Beta with DNA mismatches at the primer terminus

Nanosecond dynamics simulations for DNA polymerase beta (pol beta)/DNA complexes with three mismatched base-pairs, namely GG, CA, or CC (primer/template) at the DNA polymerase active site, are performed to investigate the mechanism of polymerase opening and how the mispairs may affect the DNA extension step; these trajectories are compared to the behavior of a pol beta/DNA complex with the correct GC base-pair, and assessed with the aid of targeted molecular dynamics (TMD) simulations of all systems from the closed to the open enzyme state. DNA polymerase conformational changes (subdomain closing and opening) have been suggested to play a critical role in DNA synthesis fidelity, since these changes are associated with the formation of the substrate-binding pocket for the nascent base-pair. Here we observe different large C-terminal subdomain (thumb) opening motions in the simulations of pol beta with GC versus GG base-pairs. Whereas the conformation of pol beta in the former approaches the observed open state in the crystal structures, the enzyme in the latter does not. Analyses of the motions of active-site protein/DNA residues help explain these differences. Interestingly, rotation of Arg258 toward Asp192, which coordinates both active-site metal ions in the closed "active" complex, occurs rapidly in the GG simulation. We have previously suggested that this rotation is a key slow step in the closed to open transition. TMD simulations also point to a unique pathway for Arg258 rotation in the GG mispair complex. Simulations of the mismatched systems also reveal distorted geometries in the active site of all the mispair complexes examined. The hierarchy of the distortions (GG>CC>CA) parallels the experimentally deduced inability of pol beta to extend these mispairs. Such local distortions would be expected to cause inefficient DNA extension and polymerase dissociation and thereby might lead to proofreading by an extrinsic exonuclease. Thus, our studies on the dynamics of pol beta opening in mismatch systems provide structural and dynamic insights to explain experimental results regarding inefficient DNA extension following misincorporation; these details shed light on how proofreading may be invoked by the abnormal active-site geometry.     

Structure-function defects of human mitochondrial DNA polymerase in autosomal dominant progressive external ophthalmoplegia

Progressive external ophthalmoplegia (PEO) is a mitochondrial disorder associated with mutations in the POLG gene encoding the mitochondrial DNA polymerase (pol gamma). Four autosomal dominant mutations that cause PEO encode the amino acid substitutions G923D, R943H, Y955C and A957S in the polymerase domain of pol gamma. A homology model of the pol gamma catalytic domain in complex with DNA was developed to investigate the effects of these mutations. Two mutations causing the most severe disease phenotype, Y955C and R943H, change residues that directly interact with the incoming dNTP. Polymerase mutants exhibit 0.03-30% wild-type polymerase activity and a 2- to 35-fold decrease in nucleotide selectivity in vitro. The reduced selectivity and catalytic efficiency of the autosomal dominant PEO mutants predict in vivo dysfunction, and the extent of biochemical defects correlates with the clinical severity of the disease.     

Variant forms of DNA polymerase beta in primary lung carcinomas.

DNA polymerase beta (pol beta) provides most of the gap-filling synthesis at apurinic/apyrimidine sites of damaged DNA in the base excision repair pathway. A truncated form of the pol beta protein is expressed in colon and breast cancers. However, the role of the pol beta gene in lung cancer is not known. Thus, we investigated a possible occurrence of pol beta variants in primary lung tumors. The entire cDNA of pol beta obtained by RT-PCR amplification was analyzed for nucleotide sequencing in lung tumor and matched normal lung tissue of the same patient. Three types of variants were detected in squamous, non-small, or large cell carcinomas. The most common variant was a deletion of 87 bp from pol beta cDNA at a site corresponding to exon 11. In addition, a variant exhibiting deletions of 87 and 140 bp together with an insertion of 105 bp was identified in three lung tumors. This is the first report of the occurrence of pol beta variants, possibly splicing variants, in lung cancer. A truncated pol beta protein resulting from variant forms of the gene may impact the function of the enzyme and increase susceptibility to carcinogenesis.     

The L561A substitution in the nascent base-pair binding pocket of RB69 DNA polymerase reduces base discrimination

Several variants of RB69 DNA polymerase (RB69 pol) with single-site replacements in the nascent base-pair binding pocket are less discriminating with respect to noncomplementary dNMP incorporation than the wild-type enzyme. To quantify the loss in base selectivity, we determined the transient-state kinetic parameters for incorporation of correct and all combinations of incorrect dNMPs by the exonuclease-deficient form of one of these RB69 pol variants, L561A, using rapid chemical quench assays. The L561A variant did not significantly alter the k(pol) and K(D) values for incorporation of correct dNMPs, but it showed increased incorporation efficiency (k(pol)/K(D)) for mispaired bases relative to the wild-type enzyme. The incorporation efficiency for mispaired bases by the L561A variant ranged from 1.5 x 10(-)(5) microM(-)(1) s(-)(1) for dCMP opposite templating C to 2 x 10(-)(3) microM(-)(1) s(-)(1) for dAMP opposite templating C. These k(pol)/K(D) values are 3-60-fold greater than those observed with the wild-type enzyme. The effect of the L561A replacement on the mutation frequency in vivo was determined by infecting Escherichia coli harboring a plasmid encoding the L561A variant of RB69 pol with T4 phage bearing a mutant rII locus, and the rates of reversions to rII(+) were scored. The exonuclease-proficient RB69 pol L561A displayed a weak mutator phenotype. In contrast, no progeny phage were produced after infection of E. coli, expressing an exonuclease-deficient RB69 pol L561A, with either mutant or wild-type T4 phage. This dominant-lethal phenotype was attributed to error catastrophe caused by the high rate of mutation expected from combining the pol L561A and exo(-) mutator activities.     

Active site mutation in DNA polymerase gamma associated with progressive external ophthalmoplegia causes error-prone DNA synthesis

Progressive external ophthalmoplegia (PEO) is a heritable mitochondrial disorder characterized by the accumulation of multiple point mutations and large deletions in mtDNA. Autosomal dominant PEO was recently shown to co-segregate with a heterozygous Y955C mutation in the human gene encoding the sole mitochondrial DNA polymerase, DNA polymerase gamma (pol gamma). Since Tyr-955 is a highly conserved residue critical for nucleotide recognition among family A DNA polymerases, we analyzed the effects of the Y955C mutation on the kinetics and fidelity of DNA synthesis by the purified human mutant polymerase in complex with its accessory subunit. The Y955C enzyme retains a wild-type catalytic rate (k(cat)) but suffers a 45-fold decrease in apparent binding affinity for the incoming nucleoside triphosphate (K(m)). The Y955C derivative is 2-fold less accurate for base pair substitutions than wild-type pol gamma despite the action of intrinsic exonucleolytic proofreading. The full mutator effect of the Y955C substitution was revealed by genetic inactivation of the exonuclease, and error rates for certain mismatches were elevated by 10-100-fold. The error-prone DNA synthesis observed for the Y955C pol gamma is consistent with the accumulation of mtDNA mutations in patients with PEO.